Added: 3 years ago
From: fingal61
Views: 41,643
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (59)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Amanda is great she has a brilliant talent and she fits perfect for mamma Mia and plus why didn't they put this song in the film?! Amanda fits for all these songs and she is great!!!

  • @TheDannimay28 they didnt put this song in the movie because then they would have to come up with more songs for her othr 'fathers' and then the movi would have been too long. i agree the song is good but in a movie the way they made it wasnt the best

  • i love it soo mutch!! <3 she's the best!!

  • I love Amanda Voice!!! <3 She's Awsome, she can sing, act, is beautiful, extremely gorgeous and sweet!

  • this was so awesome!!

  • I love Amanda's voice, is so sweet!

  • they really shouldve kept this in the movie!! its so cute between them!!

  • Oh My!! The scene is too important to be deleted!!

  • brillent :) shouda put it in the film really

  • I love this scene. I agree, they really should have kept it in the final version of the film! Thank god for the bonus material on the dvd! Thank you for uploading this in a brighter version!

  • I started singing this one day, I too don't know who my dad is :|

    xx

  • i am so glad i had the chance to watch this in the movie theatre,, my god how time flies it's almost two years since i saw this in cinema.

  • cant belive they cut it out!!!!!!!!!!!! it would have been sooo good

  • love this scene! i think it's good that we don't know who the father is, she got three really good fathers instead (;

  • Donna loved Sam and thought of him more often - she wants him to be the father.... Bill was the only one who OUT RIGHT said "YES"... so instead of the question being answered completely- we are left to assume Sam because that's who Donna wanted it to be

  • this would've been so much better for the movie instead of the actual scene. love it!

  • i checked it out and i think that this song was more towards bill and no one else and would give the viewers a different point of view from sam to bill but why they would even do this scene in the movie and know that it wasnt gonna go in the actual movie.

  • i think they didnt put this song in the movie is because that sam is the father instead of bill but then again this was based on the play

  • this has got to be the best song in the movie though i waish Bill was the father

  • why they deleted this escene? OMG it was perfect.

    I think is Bill her father too, cuz for some reason they have like a special connection, u know what now I realized that´s maybe the reason why they didnt put this escene, to stop us to think he is her father. And Bill didnt say anything to Sam when he proposed to Donna cuz he is not inlove with her, she was just an adventure.

  • i think if i were bill i would feel extremely awkward with her singing to me like that although she is a GREAT singer i just wouldnt be able to stand there while someone sang to me lol

  • this is a musicale movie, it wont happen in real life

  • Of course it will :) just not to you!

  • Ok I wanna know who you think is the father

    1. Bill

    1.Sam

    3.Harry

    I think its Bill for some reason O_o

  • I think it's Bill.....she looks more like him....and the whole Aunt Sofia thing....just my opinion.

  • i also think it's bill. but what I don't understand is that sam proposed to donna at the end and bill didn't say anything.

  • dude watch the movie i wish it was Bill but no its Sam in the end.

  • he had 2 fall in love with rosie

  • they never answer that question, duh.

    Sam said they'd all share instead of taking a DNA test.

  • whats stupid is they put this song on the sound track, even though it wasnt actually in the movie, but they didnt put "chicatita" (yeah I dont know how to spell it off the top of my head) or "say I do"

  • no offense to people who love this song including me but its funny when she says smile its like shmile lol

  • well i dont think it is deleted though

  • Oh my goodness! Why would they delete this scene!! AHHHH I <3 THIS SONG!

  • This is the best song ever!!!!!!!

    I love this song!!!

  • *1:34

  • Mamma mia came out just before i went on holiday, loved this song and listenend to it the whole time i was away.

    now when i listen to it, it brings it all back exactly where i was in France and everything, love it :))

    best part is at- 1:24 :D

    she has a great voiceeee

  • She has a wonderful Voise!!!!

  • well if you asked me its nice it could even be nicer if sam was the one she was singing to it would really be great but its nice really nice

  • great song and beautyfull singer :)

  • yeah she has a wonderful voice

  • Comment removed

  • Reply to goldenfilly...You have no idea what you're talking about. Did you even see the movie?

  • they should of left it in the movie its a good song it goes with it

  • grr why did they take this scene outta the movie?! =/

  • they shouldnt have takin this scene from the movie...grr

  • @graywolf27 ikr

  • @graywolf27 i think it is because at the end of the movie Donna says she doenst know who the father is.

  • @1991CK25 All fathers say they are her father.

  • Why did they delete this song from the movie???? It sounds great !!!!

  • when they deleted this song they pieced little clips from the scene together for the movie. but at one point they screwed it up, cause in the deleted scene Bill said "I don't know, i should really talk to donna about this" and thats when sophie says "no, our secret until the wedding" but in the actual movie they cut out him saying "i should really talk to donna about this" but then they didn't cut out sophie saying "no" so it sounds weird:

    "I don't know" "no, our secret until the wedding"

  • You have to listen carefully!

    Bill said: "I have to talk to Donna!"

    &Sophie "No, no our secret until the wedding."

    Nothing is weird!!

  • great song n great singer!!

    but i think this song is more suitable to a boyfriend nor father...

    why donna didn't sing this,to sam maybe...

    i like this song!!

  • i love amanda's voice! i cant get enough of it! im going to buy the soundtrack!

  • This is my favorite song from the broadway show but when it wasn't in the movie i was sad!!!

  • yeah its a good song and it KINDA fits in with it all but the lyricist designed the song as though the girl is singing it to her lover not her father...

  • it rock

  • i lov dis part dey def should hav kept it in the movie!! i hav the extended edition and it def fits in!! lovvve it!!!

  • Tnx for that...too bad it isnt in the movie!

  • i love this song and scene :)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more