Added: 4 years ago
From: khelmut
Views: 773,902
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (601)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • please check out my cousins piano cover!!

  • BRAVO !!!! Well done !!! How did you do to learn this piece ? It is difficult because it is speedy and also fingers must be very far from each other. I am French (excuse my poor English please (i hope you understand what i mean...) Thanks anyway you play very well. I would like to be able to do it like you...

  • I love it <3

  • Left hand sucks. But sounds epic if u compare with skill u nedd :I

  • 9gagers everywhere :D whatever, i wanted to say that i can't move my fingers like that o.O yours are like worms, katharina, du bist einfach fantastisch ;xx

  • That guy sure loves his maturity...

  • Ladies please, you're both beautiful.

    But I think this song is prettier. ;)

  • you are genius.

  • I remember this piece from about 3 years ago, which was around the time that I started the piano. Now that I came back to this piece, it feels musically immature. I mean it's a nice simple piece of music but the way it develops along with the constant repetition feels very childish, musically speaking.

  • @4hm3dimr4n simplicity can be beautiful :) obviously

  • @TheJeneye

    Yea I know but the beauty here seems superficial.

  • @4hm3dimr4n if you see this as childish you must listen to justin bieber

  • @wecandoitmeandyou

    1.) You're assumptions make you seem stupid.

    2.) I'm actually a musician (particularly fond of JS Bach, Chopin, Rachmaninoff to the extent that I've studied some of their works (not so much Rachmaninoff though) to the extent that I have an idea of what musical maturity is) so I have an idea of what I'm talking about. Look at my response to NicLou23's comment because I'm not repeating myself or carrying this conversation too far.

    3.) That name you refer to doesn't belong here.

  • @4hm3dimr4n im not sure why your telling what music your into. i could care less about your personal life bro. take the stick out of your ass.

  • @wecandoitmeandyou

    The point was to show that I have experience with some forms of mature music and of course you care. Because you misunderstood my comment for a piece of music, that is apparently very dear to you, as a negative comment, you're hurt to the extent that you had to make a stupid comment in an attempt to insult/dismiss me as the listener of stupid pop music (thus rendering my opinion mote). You need to stop being rude, condescendingly and assumptive. I hope you can find maturity.

  • @4hm3dimr4n your crazy man stop messaging me i dont know what your trying to prove. your the one who started this by insulting the song. you can insult it when you create a better piece of music

  • @wecandoitmeandyou

    Oh fuck you I give up.

  • @4hm3dimr4n haha arite im sorry i give up to. theres no reason to argue. i agree the song is slightly repetitive.

  • @4hm3dimr4n

    How is this at all childish? Regardless of however it's put together it has to do with the overall sound of the song. Some of the most famous pieces are the most basic. This song is beautiful in my opinion. I would learn this over something ridiculously difficult because it's more 'mature', musically speaking, any day.

  • @NicLou23

    When I started composing, I had the bad habit of repeating things twice. I say this is not mature because he is doing what I did when I was musically immature (also note the lack of harmonic development). Keep in mind, this topic has NOTHING to do with technical difficulty. It's more about the depth of the relationship between the quality of the music and the theory rather than virtuosity or depth of emotional attachment.

  • @NicLou23

    Personally I agree with you about famous/basic pieces. One example is JS Bach's famous prelude in C (the maturity becomes evident when you analyze the harmony). If it makes you feel any better, notice that I never did insulted this piece. I merely labeled it as I saw fit. I think that you made the mistake in assuming that immature music is bad music.

  • @4hm3dimr4n I feel as if it's more developed towards Amelie. I mean, the whole film basically shows her own immaturity and lot of the other characters' immaturities.

  • @icepirouette

    Yea I know that it works well as background music to that video but by itself it's not that great.

  • @4hm3dimr4n

    It sounds to me like you're expecting some grand amount of development and progression is what is essentially a minimalist piece. I'm guessing you're also not a fan of Glass? These composers set out to be repetitive intentionally. I see them as representing a single mood. You're supposed to be left feeling the same as you did when the piece began as it did when it ends, yet you're using this as grounds for criticism. It's like complaining that a nocturne is too tranquil.

  • @opmike343

    I didn't know it was minimalist but you do make a fine point in your last sentence. Regardless, I still wouldn't find myself coming back to this video to listen to the music (nor can I tip my hat to the ongoing repetition the composer used).

  • @opmike343

    I will tell you that the only reason I've said what I've said from the start was because this piece of music used to be as dear to me as it is to the very people that have replied to my comments (or maybe even more dear), but now it feels like child's play. I'm just surprised at how much my taste has changed over the past three years.

  • Ouaaww

  • do u use the pedal?

  • i wish to play this one perfectly..!!!!!!

  • The best cover on youtube, IMHO.

    Other videos are, for sure, parodies.

  • esta wea me hace llorar por la xuxa ....

  • 76 people dont know what is music 

  • People who know piano, i have only a little experience playing but i REALLY want to play this, do you think id be able to learn it if i just kept at it and did it little by litte? or would i have to become better at playing before i could even try first?

  • @iRsemple i just started learning this song, know only one other song a little, if you really want to learn this you will be able to, it only might take you longer than a pro to learn

  • @mastorroel lol a tip, start with your left hand, its the same the entire song, then build your right hand parts around it bit by bit

  • Should I try to learn this song? Challenge accepted.

  • now, there are 76 people who don't only recognize talent, but are probably also ugly and nasty

  • I´m missing a lot of heart and soul in that version !

  • i wish for the 2012 i could play piano .... just to play this song !!!!!!!!!! thnx for this video

  • bravissimo/a

    

  • crasy o.O

  • Cool! Did u played it wrong??

  • amazinggg...

  • I love is so much *__* i sometimes cry if i heard this pianosong

  • Rhyme of another summer's after noon. =)

  • amazing..........love it............

  • I love it

  • hi there

    can you teach me how to play this song ???

    because this is my favourite piano song i, i listen more than 200 times :)

  • great job ! :)

  • we are using this in a dance on our balletschool.

    it is great dance music!

  • what piano is it?

  • awesome!

  • BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    

  • nicely done..!

  • Well done man!

  • i heard some faults so it's not realy great but it is a good try

  • j'adore!

  • ouaa ses triste j adore stp je veux les partition

  • no feeling..

  • Magnifique!

  • Magnifique, magique, mélodieux, ...

  • j'adore, qu'est ce que c'est beau, yann tiersen c'est magique

  • Perfeita...

    

  • I think that it's the best execution I've ever heard!! The other executions are not professional.

  • Thumbs up if people always ask you "can you play Amelie?" when you just played a very difficult Liszt piece

  • @jeangodecoster So true my friend. Well actually, it was even worse. In my case, I played a few really tough songs, and then this, and all of a sudden my friend was like "OH MY GOD, IS THAT WHAT I THINK IT IS? THAT'S AMAZING!!!!". Then he was inspired enough to learn piano, and found out this shit is easy, it was the first song he learned. Them Asians.

  • well done , but you change the speed to much and get to fast at 0:51 . if you play it a bit slower it sounds more beautyful :)

  • juste amazing nice job ;)

  • az egy dolog, hogy le tudja játszani, mert nem nehéz, de azt ahogy játsza, az nekem túl darabos, és néha egy kicsit ütemtelen.

  • Godlike...

  • awesome! :D

  • whaouahh :)

  • Harika :)

  • @laylaylom760 Bazinga! :)

  • when i look at ur fingers it reminds me of a spider xD

    but i love it *-*

  • Very fast)

  • Superrr

  • My hands are so small i can't really do this :(

  • je l'adore mais j'arrive pas a la jouer...!

  • AMAZING

  • 60 people dont know what is music

  • @AmazingChanelGirls Wrong.60 (now 76) know what is REAL music

  • Fantastic! I play piano every day and i feel so many things when you play =)

    Amazing <3

  • Just the best song for me. Amazing, it's so amazing.

  • einfach nur geil,beautiful :-)

  • que dire apart magnifique ?

  • snif

  • true pianists fingers

  • Where can I get the notes?

  • просто невероятно

  • Very Beautiful.

    Now Play Death Waltz (:

  • Tu ne te sers pas de tout tes doigts c'est dommage! (pour la partie ou sa fait si mi si si mi si si mi si.... il faut rajouter le 3 eme comme cela tu peux prendre plus de vitesse!)

  • Thank you, it helps me a lot by learning to play it myself!

  • gracias!!!!! me sirvio para sacarlo en violin !!!!!! muchas gracias!!!!!

  • Очень красиво! молодец!

  • @702235fernando SHUT THE FUCK UP!

  • Beautiful!! :D

  • I learned half this song in 1 hour, and I just had 2 piano lessons. It ain't that hard.

  • @TheKonbur But it aint so easy too dude!

  • mi nombre es jenna. tengo 7 años de edad, cabello rubio y ojos aterradores. no tengo nariz ni orejas, estoy muerta, si no pones esto en los siguientes 3 paginas en los proximos 40 minutos aparecere esta noche junto a tu cama con un cuchillo y te matare... esto no es una broma algo bueno te sucedera a ti esta noche a las 9:50 te lo vuelvo a decir esto no es una broma alguien especial te llamara por telefono o hablara contigo y te dira cuanto te quiere

  • i've never had lessons yet i'm soooo close to finishing this song

  • @thesimplyuniquelife me too dude! practice is our key!

  • heeyyy where´s the feeling...?

  • heeyyy where´s the feeling...?

  • your little finger on your left hand moves like a snake ur so good haha

  • Maravilhosa!!

  • you have perfect hands for playing the piano and in fact you are absolutely perfect and awsome!

  • I love this melodie:) Also I can play this on the piano:) playing thihs makes me happy!!:D

  • Põe-me triste mas é linda a música!!!

  • VERY WELL PLAYED!!! BRAVO!!!

  • ew

    

  • i wish i could play this...

  • @chuy192 its very easy, its just putting both the hands together thats tricky. practice and youll have it in no time!

  • @chuy192 I'm actually practicing this piece. You can do it too! :D

  • I've seen many "comptine" performances on youtube. This is the best one.

    Intonation and accents are incredibelly right, like you composed the song by yourself. Bravo

  • Comment removed

  • without a mistake ):=

  • espetacular

    

  • thanx for share ur feelin

  • there are no grasshoppers, these are spiders from minecraft xD

  • i need maybe 500 years to play this

    it's a gift only

  • Ich bringe mir das Stück gerade selber bei. :D

    Ich hoffe das klingt dann auch so wie das hier. *.*

  • er streichelt die tasten *-*

  • Essa composição é belíssima,de cunho dramático...Estou tentando aprender a tocá-la..Um dia conseguirei!!!

  • calmar )) nice thx

  • you're lucky you have such long fingers. i can barely reach an octave -.-

  • Someone's drawing behind you !

  • está música é muito mais muito linda eu adoro ela toca no morde e assopra eu adoro eu consigo tocar está música... Toco piano

  • Man your hands are freaking spiders

  • Awesome.

    

  • i instantly knew something was wrong. not to be mean but lets take some time to implement some constructive criticism. your notes were too precise. i did not have the same feeling i would if i heard someone else play the song. it almost sounded rushed. try playing it, not slower, but play your notes more defined, not rushed

  • é a musicaa LINDAAA so perde para a cançao de ninar de crepusculo S2

  • im learning this at the moment and watching this feels a little bit daunting haha! i hope ill be able to play this as well as you <3

    

  • your timing is off on some notes bud

  • Te felicito, muy buena interpretacion!!

  • Love it!!

  • i wish i could play the piano as wonderful as you :C eeppp im jealouse but still i like it so much ^___^

  • I tought i was listening to the original ;o

  • ohgott *-* ich will auf klavier spielen

  • <3 OMFGGGG!!!

  • ...amazing...very good..

  • Vas-y, Jean-Charles !

  • 52 people have carpal tunnel. 

  • i like that 'retro' style of video

  • did you videotape it with a cam on your head?? ;)

    Great playing, keep it up!

  • świetnie grasz ;) Great!

  • Amazing but was anyone else distracted by how skinny their fingers were???

  • @Gonzo6994 you have fat fingers cuz mine are way thinner

  • @tyrannoboy123 i may have fat fingers, but i can still play it as fast as this person

  • @Gonzo6994 grats, you just learned what a female's hand looks like

  • @Gonzo6994 true but talented pianist all have the same fingers dude just try too play piano with ur fat fingers and u ll c.

  • @Gonzo6994 its a woman because hands from men´s are bigger , or i think he is an golum

  • Gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­d'

  • AMAZING !!!! Wonderful .... i doesn´t find words for this =DDDD SUper

  • Really great

  • Great!

  • очень красиво,, молодец

  • verdammt gut :O

  • c'est tres bon!

    

  • Ignore the people who don't like this, screw them, U keep on playing & enjoy yourself wish you luck learning other song, need a lot of patience♥

  • my girlfriend taught me tis song before she left :( i miss her

  • Your left hand, you're harming yourself. You need to relax it.. Despite of that, nice performance..! :)

  • too fast

  • it's unbelivabel, i thought this musice made by big team no one can do it alone, but after i see it i bealive it now .

  • Je t'aime Katharina, i love you Katharina