The American Historical Review, among the oldest and most prestigious academic journals in the United States, has condemned Service’s biography of Trotsky, saying that it "fails to meet the basic standards of historical scholarship". The review has explicitly endorsed the critique of Service's book by David North, the chairman of both the Socialist Equality Party in the United States and the international editorial board of the World Socialist Web Site.
Robert Service and other leading British academics have launched a campaign of historical falsification, slandering Trotsky, and denying his historical significance. The purpose of the campaign is to prevent young people coming into political struggle from learning about Trotsky's political legacy. David North of the World Socialist Website has written a number of essays in defence of Trotsky - see "Political biography and the historical lie: An examination of Robert Service’s Trotsky" on wsws
Trotsky thought it correct to attack Mexico's President Lazaro Cardenas after Cardenas gave him asylum in Mexico. Cardenas who was the only Mexican President that implemented a real socialist agenda, was generous enough to allow Trotsky into Mexico. But Trotsky, who made secret alliances with the CIA. Rockefeller, Mussolini and Hitler, was far from graceful and attacked Cardenas socialist policies as burgeois acts. Trotsky was nothing more than a small and petty mouse in the house of lions.
What lies. Trotsky was no bourgeoisie spy and never made alliances with the fascists. Lazaro Cardenas was no Marxist. He never founded a socialist republic and Mexico did not become socialist. Beside his political party was in alliance with the progressive bourgeoisie.
@xoloboy Absolutely stupid, read Trotsky's analysis, he's a true marxist, not like Stalin who executed or put in the gulag every true marxist in Russia, and made so many stupid mistakes, because he didn't understand anything to Marxism, and in fact because he didn't care! That he made an alliance with Hitler... Moreover, you're so stupid that you ignore that the CIA was created AFTER the second world war.
I don't need COMMUNISM$PERVS If smb would like to built such "communism " I'll fight against it. I am always against perverts, against faggots, against dykes, bowcats etc. scum!
Alexander Rabinowitschs Book "The Sowjetpower the first year" are now published in German and will present by himself in Berlin in the Humboldt University on the 14. of October 2010. More: world socialist web site
FIVE.......
Rise up.
northerbrewer 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The American Historical Review, among the oldest and most prestigious academic journals in the United States, has condemned Service’s biography of Trotsky, saying that it "fails to meet the basic standards of historical scholarship". The review has explicitly endorsed the critique of Service's book by David North, the chairman of both the Socialist Equality Party in the United States and the international editorial board of the World Socialist Web Site.
robharris38 8 months ago
Comrade! Good man!
JordanMargetts 10 months ago 2
A true, true comrade and martyr.
rabkebab28 11 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Thank god this Jewish plague had his head bashed in. Fuck the Communist Jews and the filth and lies they spew.
shareyourvideosworld 1 year ago
Long Live the IV International!
smolny1917 1 year ago 2
¡Viva la IV Internacional!
Trotten84 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Robert Service and other leading British academics have launched a campaign of historical falsification, slandering Trotsky, and denying his historical significance. The purpose of the campaign is to prevent young people coming into political struggle from learning about Trotsky's political legacy. David North of the World Socialist Website has written a number of essays in defence of Trotsky - see "Political biography and the historical lie: An examination of Robert Service’s Trotsky" on wsws
OliverCroft 1 year ago
LOL, gotta love the old Stalinist lies. They still do damage to class consciousness. How sad.
TheMarzpro 1 year ago
This is really great. Please keep this up. Thank you!
Redsociology 1 year ago
Trotsky thought it correct to attack Mexico's President Lazaro Cardenas after Cardenas gave him asylum in Mexico. Cardenas who was the only Mexican President that implemented a real socialist agenda, was generous enough to allow Trotsky into Mexico. But Trotsky, who made secret alliances with the CIA. Rockefeller, Mussolini and Hitler, was far from graceful and attacked Cardenas socialist policies as burgeois acts. Trotsky was nothing more than a small and petty mouse in the house of lions.
xoloboy 1 year ago
What lies. Trotsky was no bourgeoisie spy and never made alliances with the fascists. Lazaro Cardenas was no Marxist. He never founded a socialist republic and Mexico did not become socialist. Beside his political party was in alliance with the progressive bourgeoisie.
Your lies are worth nothing.
UDSS 1 year ago
@UDSS Read a little my friend maybe then you will learn the history of the little man that never was.
xoloboy 1 year ago
@xoloboy Absolutely stupid, read Trotsky's analysis, he's a true marxist, not like Stalin who executed or put in the gulag every true marxist in Russia, and made so many stupid mistakes, because he didn't understand anything to Marxism, and in fact because he didn't care! That he made an alliance with Hitler... Moreover, you're so stupid that you ignore that the CIA was created AFTER the second world war.
maischlma 1 year ago
@maischlma
Trotsky was a bowcat and Stalin hated fag, dykes, bowcats etc scum.
Stalin USSR - strong moral instead of free sex. No bowcats allowed!
Motaro76 11 months ago
@Motaro76
In your comment, a perfect summary of the degree of political culture of a stalinist...
Well, not so perfect: you maybe forgot: "gay", "jew", etc...
"Stalin USSR" just lost the right to have the words "socialist" and "sovietic"in it, but if you think moral has been saved...
maischlma 11 months ago
@maischlma
I don't need COMMUNISM$PERVS If smb would like to built such "communism " I'll fight against it. I am always against perverts, against faggots, against dykes, bowcats etc. scum!
LONG LIVE STALIN, ENVER, KIM JONG IL, GADDAFI!
DEATH2BOWCATS!
Motaro76 11 months ago
@Motaro76 you mean "long live mental cases"?
nietzscheprime 11 months ago
@nietzscheprime
I mean- DOWN THE PUSSY-EATERS!!!
Motaro76 11 months ago
@Motaro76 retard
nietzscheprime 11 months ago
@nietzscheprime PUSSY-EATER
Motaro76 11 months ago
@nietzscheprime PUSSY-EATER and BOWCAT
Motaro76 11 months ago
Comment removed
maischlma 11 months ago
@xoloboy Treat yourself to a history book
Drac39 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Alexander Rabinowitschs Book "The Sowjetpower the first year" are now published in German and will present by himself in Berlin in the Humboldt University on the 14. of October 2010. More: world socialist web site
FranzSchobert00 1 year ago
communist that is truly Marxist.
travisg336 1 year ago 14
Comment removed
travisg336 1 year ago
Trotsky - true marxist
eliwoood1 1 year ago 25
@eliwoood1 he is internetionalman. he is destroeyr and murder
makulaturoman 1 year ago
@eliwoood1
fuck jew trotzkij
long life GREAT STALIN
ololoshenkilolo 11 months ago
@ololoshenkilolo
Totally agree
LONG LIVE STALIN!
DOWN THE BOWCAT TROTSKY!!!
Долой пиздолиза Троцкого!
Motaro76 11 months ago
@eliwoood1
Trotsky - true BOWCAT. Like you.
Motaro76 11 months ago