ラフマニノフ／ピアノ協奏曲Op.18 No.1,2007コンペティション特級

[vedaralove]

6:04 OMG!

[arika002]

The video title is incorrect. It's no. 2 in C minor, op. 18, not no. 1.

Rachmaninoff piano concerto no. 1 (F-sharp minor, op. 1) is not a well known piece, most people don't know about it but it's so beautiful, truly a little gem. I love Rach-1 so much more than Rach-2. Oh, btw, I played it in 2009. please see my channel.

I also played Rach-2 1st mov. when I was in high school - here is a link for you.

How old was Erika-san when she played Rach-2 ?

[mioko923]

素晴らしいですね♪

[ungava100]

What a rush! Sergeii Rachmaninoff would be proud of you. Please don't stop performing.

[ikimono1126tom0]

この曲でピアノ弾くのが(オーケストラと共演)夢ｗｗ

[syukuya00]

鳥肌総立ちです。



[ishi916ngc1]

これに、アジアを感じる人がどのくらいいるのでしょうか。背景も­知らず、テクニークを誇る馬鹿馬鹿しさをのみ理解して、悦に入っ­ている方が若干見受けられるようです。奏者のお名前は存じ上げま­せんけれども。すみません、聞き流してください。

[bachmana2008]

＞若い演奏家はお金を払ってくれる聴衆を求め­ているのです

楽しく聞きに来たのに…なんか不愉快だね…

本当の音楽って？

あなたが一番わかってないんじゃん？

[ReiReiRachel]

Amazing! I would faint after 5 minutes of such intense playing

[nevulatube]

＞若い演奏家はお金を払ってくれる聴衆を求め­ているのです

そうなんだ

行ってみたいけど敷居高いな

[princessyaegakihime]

@nevulatube そういわずに　誰にも初めてがある　是非　是非

[utauneko0801e]

こんな風に弾けたらいいな～憧れます♪

[princessyaegakihime]

@utauneko0801e そうねぇーーーー　出だしだけでも嬉しいな　出来たら

[piano8o8]

はじめまして、こんにちは。

初心者の私でもわずか２８日で好きな曲を

弾けるようになった簡単練習法教えます。

詳細は下のＩＤクリックして私のプロフィール画面に

↓ウェブサイトのリンクがありますのでそこをクリックしてくださ­い。

[keikoforkeikofor]

ド～レ　ド～レ　ド～シラソ♪

いいですね・・・この波がいってはまたきて・・・

あの手の大きさだからなのでしょうか？

最後のクライマックスをためてためて・・・期待感を引っ張り出す­。

なんというか引き込まれます。

[WTBbboyNAME]

heh is it just me or does this sound EXACTLY like Ashkenazy's performance/interpretation?

[ChristianFiel]

@WTBbboyNAME

that's what I thought first, too, but Ashkenazy plays it "softer" and more accurately (speaking of the LSO/Previn version) if this isn't a fake (looks as if people watched the perfomance in a cinema), compliments! better than Lang Lang!

[shige292]

やっぱ最初の和音は1回で弾く方が良いな～(^_^;)

でも1回で弾ける人余りいないよな～…～てかﾗﾌﾏﾆﾉﾌ相当 手でかい。

[arika002]

@shige292

I did play the chords together - see my channel or my video response above.

[sockmonkeyzruleXD]

i didn't look at her face the whole time, because i like to think that she's me in the future, and someone taped it and went back in time to post it...

[KUDODO2007]

棒棒~~~

[Energyin]

楽譜みたよ。

何この楽譜!?

左手の列にオタマジャクシがいっぱい．．．

[zeriitte]

噛み合ってない

[nkymx4a]

ホルンピッチｗｗｗ

[ystme]

WiMAXとiPod touchの組み合わせで、どこにいても好きな音楽を聴ける。改­めてすごいことだ

(Posted by Youtube Stream for iPhone (yst.me) on behalf of clarinet1031 at twitter)

[keithewisdom]

I listened to this concerto at Kyoto Concert Hall just before Valentine Day. I love this concerto!

[euch27]

I'm a violinist, but where are the cellos? Just sayin...

[Zombiezar]

Китайцы молодцы! А Рахманинов круто сочинил. Это каким музыкальным талантом надо обладать. У меня идеальный слух, но сочинить не могу что-то новое. Respect!

[sish85]

weird opening

[mailtaiji]

ラフマニノフは20代前半で、初めての交響曲である第1番を作曲­しましたが、初演時に、こんな曲はダメと悪評され、ショックでノ­イローゼになり約3年間何もしない生活を送ります。その後、ある­精神科医に出会い、「あなたは、傑作の作品を作る」と、自己暗示­をかけさせます。病から立ち直り、その時に作曲したのがこの曲で­す。この曲は、立ち直らせてくれた精神科医に捧げられています。­作品は、やはり人生を反映していますね。交響曲第1番はどちらか­というと明るい感じですが、パート譜はすべて処分され、指揮者が­見るスコアだけが残っていて、それを復元するという状態だったら­しいです。ラフマニノフの死後に発見されています。私自身では、­この交響曲第1番がとても気に入っていて、これを聴いてから、ピ­アノ協奏曲第2番を聴けば感じ方が変わるかも知れません。作曲者­は独身が多く、ラフマニノフはノイローゼになりましたが、20代­で結婚し、2児の父親でした。精神科医のおかげですね。



[a308m]

@mailtaiji さん

つい先日、Ning An氏の演奏を舞台上で聴いたのですが（ちょっと自慢です・・・­）、ラマニノフの様々な苦悩とともに生まれた、『コレルリの主題­による変奏曲』を聴きました。素晴らしかったです。人間の苦悩か­ら生まれる芸術作品は、ものすごいエネルギーを数百年、数千年に­渡って人々の心に訴えかける力があると感じました。この協奏曲も­そうですね。

[norio54531]

氏がどんな人生を送ってきて、どのような道をたどったのか、それ­は音楽から聞こえてくる気がしました。クラシックはあまり知らな­いのですが、鬱屈とした気持ち、晴れ晴れとした気持ち、転げ落ち­る様な気持ち、他の音楽には無い豊かさと怖さを感じました。全部­をyoutubeで聞く前にコンサートに行きたいです。そして、­もっと勉強していきます。時間がなく時間がかかるかと思いますが­。。。

[prahavltava]

Arigatou gozaimasu

[nhkosaka]

ラフマニノフって生きてるのツラかったのかな...

[LeoP2218]

私も何かそんな気がする

[LeoP2218]

私も何かそんな気がする



[xxxruka]

@nhkosaka

ラフマニノフが精神を病んでいたのは有名。映画もありますしね。­観てみるといいですよ。

[diiiva2010]

she does really take my breath away... her playing give this piece of music to another level and imagination... different yet beautiful and amazing than Rachmaninoff... really great job I LOVE IT^^... now when going to sleep.. this concerto will be ringing in my ears, memories the whole night :D... specially her Piano.. Yay!! and oh! thanks for the upploading

[ruper29]

L'interpretazione di Erika di questo concerto è, a mio avviso, il migliore di tutti gli altri concertisti che conosco aver interpretato questo. L'unico che, ma con diverso modo interpretativo, raggiunge lo stesso livello è, sempre a mio modestissimo giudizio, Arcadi Volodos-.

[Stoptapingme]

@ruper29 Erika's interpretation of this concert is, in my opinion, better than all the other musicians I know have taken that. The only one, but with a different way of interpretation, reaches the same level is always in my modest opinion, Arcadi Volodos. "

[MultiRenzokuken]

det var en gång en snorpelle.... Nice!

[chai9tea7latte]

確かに死ぬまで弾けるようになりたい！ピアノ習い続けてればよか­ったなぁ。

[choi0909]

와우 최고... 키신이나 안스네스 같은 유명한 사람 연주보다 좋다...진짜.

짐머만의 포스까지는 아니지만...

진짜 깨끗하게 잘치넹...

근데 이름이 뭔지 모르겠네...

[prahavltava]

Very impressed...

THANKS.

[Linta1983]

人それぞれ好みあるかと思いますが、ラフマニノフは壮厳ですね。­最高っ！

[uhartchristian]

this young lady has already 400.000 people looking at her video. This is very much for classical music, even pavarotti did not make it much more on youtube.....

[aputiify]

中学校の部活でこの曲やってます。コントラバスです。顧問の先生­が、こんな曲はふつう中学生のやる曲じゃないって言ってました。­（やるって決めたのは先生ですが）

[scookie14]

Fantastic. Her expression is amazing, the tempo is at the right pace. I believe this is probably the best verson of this song. Rachminoff is an incredible player.

[upatoia]

@scookie14 Sergei Rachmaninoff ( 1873 - 1943 ) is the composer.

Erika Hanada is the pianist here but there are old versions played by Rachmaninoff himself in youtube as well.

[natirodri2000]

me encanta esta musica y la forma bellisima en que toca.

[mvolkov11]

Andrea, you misunderstood my comment - I meant that Lisitsa, not Erika. played it way too fast - Erika's tempo is PERFECT. This is a dream-like performance that wonderfully balances surging passion with lyrical intimacy. She displays the same qualities in the magnificent Scriabin Fantasy Op. 28, one of Scriabin's best pieces. I hope Erika can sustain a major career - she clearly deserves to.

[nicolas090909]

@mvolkov11

I agree with your opinion. Her tempo is perfect.

Nicolas

[gsc1ugs]

perfect

[andreaoyole]

It's wonderful to see a woman playing this concert, and it's not way too fast as mentioned by the other coment.

Rachmaninov otself played this way.

Bravo Bravo Bravo!!!!!!

[Vije4ka]

Bravo,Erika! Wonderful sound and technic!!!!!

[goomasutaa]

評価に対して失意に堕ちたラフマニノフがセラピーを受けて　～精神開眼した証に手がけたコンチェルトの謂れ　‐はチャイコやグリークのよりも癒し効果は極！

！　まだロシア大地の偉大さ完璧性を世界誇示出来た時代のジャンル

[goomasutaa]

　終始右サイドアングルからのソロアクションでブルー衣装とヘアー­の釣り合いが

[PapaPosadskiy]

Класс!

[Japanese1970]

Is she playing not too fast ahead of the orchestra?

[MISHA1119]

Mints, Lisitsa does have a marvelous flow over the keyboard, but she plays this movement way too fast, not luxuriating in the beautiful details while keeping the

large-scale structure intact, which this girl does. Lisitsa does not feel the passionate surging emotional power of this piece, nor any other piece

I've heard her play. It's always the same story - no nuance, just a breakneck tempo. Even unsophisticated audiences can sense this, and she will never sustain a significant career.

[jamkablam]

it must have been hard for Erika to get in-sync with the orchestra! they don't play well

[007strauss]

Sorry, but that orchstra was playing awfully. Poor Erika!

[synterlu]

すばらしい・・・

[sexysadiesays]

I watch this video every single day at least once a day. I can't get over how much it moves me...even now. Thank you so much for posting this.

[hakucantabile]

何と言えぬ美しさが心臓の底に響くほどで、そんな繊細な弾き方、­うっとりしている。どう人間は木造の楽器でこんな美麗な音色を描­くかよく分からないから、この協奏曲は天使に作られたに違いない­。

[ai0101koi]

私も高校で弾きました^^

懐かしいです^^

[SaintJimmyxxx]

It's so amazing !

[kusunokinomasatoki]

感動!

これって、彼がスランプになった時に霊謀の所に行って作曲したら­しいですね

[chiharh]

@kusunokinomasatoki ほんとですか。。。。　おもしろいこと聞きました。

[kusunokinomasatoki]

@chiharh　霊謀というより、催眠療法ですねw

ピアノ協奏曲第一番を批判され、精神衰弱に陥っていたところを

友人のすすめでダーリ博士の催眠療法を受けます。

すると症状は快方へ向かい、この名曲を完成させた訳です

催眠療法は、ホントに効くんでしょうか。。。

[chiharh]

@kusunokinomasatoki　わざわざお返事、ご説明いただいてありがとうございます＾＾*　そうだったのですね。　トラウマのような症状には効きそうですね。　そんな昔から催眠療法があったことにも若干おどろきです。当時だ­ったら、実際 霊媒と言われても仕方なかったような。。。

[yappari29]

tears fullfill my face

[Piper12056]

Technique is nearly flawless. I didn't read her name but I hope she matures into a star and that we can look forward to her future recordings and concerts. Interpretation was very good but, i think she held back somewhat for the sake of technique as many young performers do. Exciting, nonetheless...

[petie32]

She ROCKs.. Like a young Argerich; you expect a femine interpretation and she blows you away. She will be heard from.

[kakokakoism]

この曲だいすきです。

ラフマニノフの思いが伝わってくる感じで・・・

[PPQ12F567]

Very clean articulation and a somewhat methodical approach. She and the orchestra took their time, but alas the passion in interpretation has eluded the young pianist.

[mintsauce82]

@PPQ12F567 And who are you exactly? This was awesome.

[PPQ12F567]

@mintsauce82 Look and listen to Valentina Lisitsa playing Rachmaninoff Piano Concert 2. You will hear better pace and tempo and an all around more authoritative and commanding perfornance. Notice how Valentina's hands flow over the keyboard. By the way, the piano Valentina is playing is a Bosendorfer 97 keys 12 feet Imperial Grand.

[chenierchenier]

she is so beautiful...

[JayKania4]

This should be titled "ROCK" Maninoff!

[studiobianconi]

???????? are you crazy ??

[daichan33]

Alexis Weissenberg has a better version, in my opinion

[XXmichelleS2]

AMAZING. I think she needs more strength to play this even better, though

[skullchukka]

Best version ever..

[kato0202]

ドキドキしてたまらない♪

作曲者のこの時の状況が知りたいですね。

[goldengriffin]

this is beyond wonderful. No words.

[ObliviousIkuto]

Wonderfully played.. How a trust Rakhmaniov should be played fantastic :P The orchestra is perfect too in perfect sync with the piano... Just fantastic

[gorillapenguin]

holy crap she is amazing

[himapan]

のだめ

[Bissen]

@himapan lol!

[stradivarius001]

テンポが少し速めで、なんか吸い込まれる感じがものすごくいい！­！

[hendriktoch]

My compliments to Erika; She has stolen my heart !

I hope we'll be hearing much of her in the future !

[redtails]

Oh wow..

[yokohamasogyo]

Ｉｔ　is beautiful and it it is solemn !

[skelterboi21]

本当に吸い込まれますね

[KuroiNekoh]

Wow, She's very young !

[MrAsungot]

not passionate enough

[UranumPlanet]

это япония или китай? Я русский,и преклоняю колено перед ними.

[sergepolo]

судя по ссылке справа - Япония

[civillaser]

She is Japanese. Could Russian play marvelously like this?

[sayeu]

I don't know but seem like russian compose the score

[DoninWhiting]

So you graduated MSM and you gotta insert your four letter initials here to make for idiot reading idiot language. Are you lost for intelligent words with respect for others reading it? As Toscanini would say, " stupido"

[arykk]

THis is one of the few interpretations on youtube that I love!

Beautiful

[ruper29]

Una esecuzione perfetta e una interpretazione stupenda!

[Ashe287]

How old are she ?

[alexusstukov]

At least she can play the piano not everyone else can play it

[PatrickBlak]

Very good keyboard artistry, But a little too tame for me to enjoy it fully. Though moderato, I think could have some more presence and gusto.

[TheJgutierrez]

the song is also very good

when she plays it SHE'S SEXY

[darnott44]

you are scum Jgutierrez

[darnott44]

She is fucking fabulous. Are you people OUT OF YOUR MINDS???? look at her arms. From the first note she had every note under her control. I graduated (Masters) from MSM and this girl represents why I quit playing! She is EVERYTHING and I don't even know her name. Mine is Deborah Arnott. I'd love to meet her.

[sexysadiesays]

This is one of my very favorite interpretations of this piece. Stunning. I have watched this video at least a few dozen times and I still feel moved every single time.

[crs75012]

Nice!

[meditatedhammapada]

Elegantly played, thoroughly enjoyed it!

Altho it seems a bit too soft for my taste.

Listen to Rachmaninov play the Rach 2

and you'll see what I mean.

[nikitema]

It is beautiful!

[negishi45]

いろんな演奏聞いたけど、わたしは花田さんのが好きー(*・∀・­)

[yushi0614]

7:00～のところ

鳥肌が立ちます・・

[biblereader1611]

are you saved

[Phersephoie]

very beautifull playing.. really well done... wonderfull sound!

[mamoru1213]

メッチャかんどーなんですけど。

[mspianowitch]

This is one of my favourite concertos! It's played well here.

The pieces from Nodame have become really popular! ...not that they weren't before

Some people don't have a choice on whether or not they can break chords! I can't play a clean 10th...need like half a cm more :(

[chimera15]

Is this version different from the normal concerto? I listened to some other versions and they didn't seem the same. Is this a special composition for the Nodame Cantabile?] series or something?

[Phersephoie]

tell me about it :( not to mention that Rach 3 is destined remain on the "dream list"

[ShereKhanTiger]

Starting at 7:00, I get all giggly like a school girl and just melt at the same time.

This is my most favorite piano piece of all time. I LOVE Rachmaninov.

[ShereKhanTiger]

And the beginning chords are just... how do you describe that? Do I use the cliche of "epic", or is there some better adjective that fails me?

[weetbx]

"Epic" is overused these days, but it is definitely apt in this case.

[gnimez]

@ShereKhanTiger hyperepic

[Marklar3]

@ShereKhanTiger

I think Nodame Cantabile described them as "blinding"

[Alastor255]

I completely agree with you it's my favorite piano piece and the 7:00 part is EPIC.

[bae215]

almost everyone who playes this breaks the chords! There is nothing wrong with that. I break the chords myself... (some of them)

[WcSpecter]

yeah but breaking the chords just doesn't have the same effect. i tried it when i played this piece and preferred not breaking them...

[pjkilmer]

This was an excellent performance.

Lots of comments here on breaking chords. Can you or someone tell me what exactly this is? Breaking chords as in arpeggiating the last note that you can't reach, right? Not breaking a legato transition into staccato, right?

Can you point out for me where she does this here?

[TheJgutierrez]

who cares just look at the girl she's hot

[wataame1238wataame]

This song is very very good!!

[no666death]

一生のうちに一度でも良いから

生演奏で聴きたい・・・

[omatsu123]

@no666death そういうことを言う前に、どんな演奏家でもいいからチケットを買­って観るべきですよ。いつ最高の演奏に会えるかなんて誰にも分か­らないし、ウジウジ言ってるうちに歳を取って外出もままならなく­なります。ましてや、若い演奏家はお金を払ってくれる聴衆を求め­ているのです。だから、さっさとコンサートに行きなさい。でない­と、一生本当の音楽に出会えませんよ・・・

[AnnMarry19]

wonderfull!! :)

[AnnMarry19]

Many people break this chords. For example: Helene Grimaud

Ann :)

[mcynthi16]

wow! (I..I)

[animalmother1065]

Rachmaninov had banana hands. This pianist doesn't. Therefore, no. She can't reach them.

[Gioacchino4]

3.40 in myy heart forever... thanks.

[ElNath645]

Rakhmaninov has such amazing pieces <3

btw, the pianist wiping and cleaning the keyboard just goes to show how prepared she is for anything, which is good :D

[barret73]

7:02 :P

[hashirimedes]

この出足を見ると何故か涙が出る。

すごい曲だ。

[tlovesnnlovest]

私もまさに、そうでした。

[RonnieSkittles]

Amazing :o

[9OH4loridaChico]

5:10 i've never seen a pianist clean the piano during a tacet haha.

She plays excellent and well deserves the silver medal.

One of my favourite parts of music, is competition.

[ankhaton]

The sound mixing >>> she is way to soft when the orchestra is at hand

[eudolph]

the hissing sound from the mic is annoying. or is that part of the orchestra?

[garunise]

心が落ち着き、凄く感動しました。

特に自分の中では7:00の所が良いと思いました。

[ColtonBrook]

that section felt a bit laggy to me...she seems to want to go a bit faster but had to contain herself. maybe i am just used to hearing other interpretations play it a bit faster

[NapoleonLee]

Russian Orchestra`s performance is.. better.

[Pitchaxistheorem]

yeah we know that already -.-

[ma21ify]

ブラボ～！！！

[brokenXwords]

beautiful.

[nhav12345]

I think this is not according to the piece. But i think it's good. I don't know your interpretation of the piece.

[LversusKira]

This recording is hit and miss for me. Don't like the opening chords, let down by the climax theme, but really liked some of the soft parts.

[Nataliena]

strength is leaving her arms even before she hits the keyboard, I feel like there is no firmness in her hands, and the excessive wrist motion and hand lifting at the beginning of the movement - which is so trendy right now among new-coming pianists - completely takes the immediacy and force out of the sound. I'd say stay away from Rachmaninoff until you're really ready. The pretty princess dress won't help you much either.

[thunder1909]

only hear part of it's voice. In Rachmaninoff's standards, and in the standards of all great pianists, this performance rates good, or great at the most.

[brokenXwords]

excessive hand motion was considered etiquette in the time period of the music. Look at the fingerings written by the original composers, it reflects it. Your focus is mostly on appearance, but its not about looks, its about quality of the music. That's why most music competitions now-a-days are screened. Piano is one of the few exceptions.

[Nataliena]

If you read my comments more carefully, you will see that I am speaking about how the the physical posture and motion affects the sound. I was observing how the excessive lifting of the hand and the swinging motion takes out the spontaneous force and immediacy out of the music that I would like to hear especially in Rachmaninoff. Her technique may be more fitting for Chopin etc...but if etiquette gets in the way of music then I see a problem there.

[sexysadiesays]

Her performance was breath taking and for those who found her wiping her hands and the keys distracting I think you are easily distracted. I found the action in no way detracted from her performace and barely noticed.