Added: 4 years ago
From: ruriel2
Views: 203,370
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (284)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What a CLASS ACT she is! One more season of Idol where the BEST SINGER didn't win.

  • Who won that season? Because she should have.

  • @MrVision76 Me too, that's why she's my all time favorite idol contestant ever because if you can come back after all these years after rooting for new favorites on the show & still come back still remember these great performances I think that says something about a persons talent & nobody has topped her for me yet but scotty is a close second right now!!

  • amazing even after all the years since she was on i watch these video clips and get CHILLS!!!

  • Melinda do some MJ songs.

  • @pscanyc3 yοս ϲаn wаtcհ tv from all over tհе world on yoսr рϲ just by dοԝnloading some prοցram, іt's got thoսѕаnds of сհaոոels οn іt. just ցο to linevid com (рսt а . befοrе the ϲοm, іt ԝοո't let me рοѕt lіnks fοr ѕome reаѕon) іt's а bit priсеy but it'ѕ јust oոе tіmе аnd it ԝorkѕ really wеll

  • Agree with others, she should have won season 6. This was a great performance. Performs and sounds like a seasoned pro.

  • KILLED IT!!! she was waaaaay tooooo goooood to be on American Idol! I mean really, she honestly deserved a better platform to showcase her talents! A.I did not at all do her any justice. not cuz she shouldh've won, but becuz the maturity of her voice is so beyond a singing competition, she shouldn't have to compete, she got the chops to go out and get it on her own.

  • unbelievable voice. U-N-B-E-L-I-E-V-A-B-L-E.

  • Melinda was a "miracle". She looks so sweet and humble off stage, but when she was up there she's like a whole different person. She knows how to rock the audience while still looking at the camera.

    Idol nowadays sell "inspiring stories" but the performances are boring. The contestants barely move (depending on guitar/piano much?) and it's like they are "forced to find the camera". Very stiff!

    Love you Melinda!

  • she should be on broadway

  • Best singer ever on Idol! Just sensational. Seriously, she could compete with the best of the Motown singers. Wow.

  • this was the first show of season 6-and this performance is better than anything from season 9. This is how you work the stage,the judges and the audience!

  • @rekabs season 9 contestants suck!

  • @jjamj3

    OMG, I agree with you!!!

    Every year I usually record seasons performance to VHS, but this season I practically stop recording and just watch YT instead.

    They brought MILEY C as a mentor, and later they brought Adam Lambert too. Ooh, I wish Melinda could mentor one episode! I miss her much!

  • @Nyanyinyah Iv just heard about adam lambert mentoring the contestants... grrr.... melinda is way way much better than adam.

  • great voice and talent!

  • i totally agree.. but i also love jordin sparks that season.. =)

  • The best of all time1

  • PERFECTO!

  • melinda is very pretty and talent....... XD

  • malinda is very pretty....now Taylor swift that's ugly

  • Melinda Transforms

    Sounds great

    Earl

  • Write-in vote Melinda for PCA's!!! =D You can write her in for Favorite Breakout artist, favorite female singer, favorite R & B artist! ;-)

    Go to the People's Choice website =)

  • you will never ever get to hear something great like this on a german casting show. I hate those german copied casting shows. bad singers and well....i miss watching american idol, with much better performers and talents.

    I watched this season in 2007 (during my stay in the US) and yes I loved Melinda, she was and is a very very good singer!

  • she is something special :)

  • love this girl and bless her talent!!

  • Yeah I agree with u guys on this one...

  • she just rips it up on this song.........as good as anybody in the business, if not better. i hope she gets somebody to handle her career that knows what to do with her special talent.............

  • She is an extremely talented girl but unfortunately record companies only want the young and beautiful because they think thats what the young people want.

  • thats what i think too i totally agree!!! : )

  • Yeah, but who says she's not beautiful? What's the criteria? Anyway, Melinda rocks anything she does.

  • shes mad cute

  • her best performance

  • god she was a powerhouse every week i was so said when she was gone i started watch on season 5 but i think season 2 was the time it started when all the good ones went out the top 3 cuz S2 Kimberley S3 Jasmine S4 Vonzell S5 Elliot S6 Melinda S7 Syesha and now S8 Danny i wonder whose next

  • the difference between season 6 and all the others you mentioned is that in season six, melinda was better than BOTH of the people in the final. Kimberly and Clay would have been the final in season two for example, syesha and archie in 7 lambert and gokey in 8. but all the people you mentioned still wouldn't have won.

  • she's good. I hope she wins.

  • Uhm..... This was 2 season ago.

  • Uhm....it was a joke...

  • Uhm..... Okay then.

  • Amen to Melinda.

    Jorden Sparks wasnt even on her level.

  • Oh My Gosh! I forget how great Melinda is. I'm going to buy her CD.

  • lol it i think this was melinda doolittle singing since u been gone by kelly clarkson anyway this was good to

  • It can't be. None of the lyrics she's singing matches besides the chorus.

  • It's actually Aretha Franklin's "Since You Been Gone"

  • Wow, is she ever the professional!!

  • Sooo good. Buy her new CD "Coming Back To You". I listen to all kinds of music, but I can honestly say it is one of the best I have ever listened to. Buy it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • Have already done so and totally agree with you on that.

  • she should've been in season 7 or 8, she would've won without a doubt...

  • TOTALLY !!!!!

  • So... good...

  • Melinda Doolittle really should have won that season of American Idol. She was absolutely excellent. Every single performance she blew it out of the box. Not once did she get a bad comment from the judges, not even Simon. Outstanding love her.

  • definitely, i think she is better and more experienced then jordin sparks

  • With her talent (no, talent is too weak a word for what she has) it doesn't matter that she didn't win. She is not a star in the making - she seems to have just dropped from heaven - a singer in all perfection. I feel so lucky to have witnessed her coming to fame because one day she will be remembered along with the greatest performers of humankind :-)

  • Man...just....wow....she just leaves me speechless.

  • damn :)

  • The fact that she didn't win still makes me completely angry. It was a travesty. She was the best. I was totally shocked when she was voted off.

  • Justice4ev - the fact is, it's a popularity contest. Melinda is way too talented to appeal to most tweeners and teens. They look for someone thinner, hipper, more trendy. Yes, it's superficial, but they don't know any better.

    What American Idol needs to do is limit the calls to 5 per phone line. This unlimited calling is totally wrong and slants the results.

  • I completely agree. That show needs to make some serious changes to the voting system so that the best singers have a better chance of winning.

  • Justice4ev - it'll never happen. They won't be able to rave that they had 60,000,000 votes. Do the math, is 1 in 5 Americans watching American Idol? The numbers are so inflated because of the unlimited voting. They have to know that it's unfair and it slants the results. You have people having phone parties where they have multiple phones - landlines and cell phones calling for 4 hours straight - call, redial, call, redial, call, redial - ad nauseum. It should stop.

  • You weren't alone.

  • She's amazing and I think she should have won!

  • she may have sounded the same durring her run on A.I.but this woman could sing,she was consistent through-out season 6 this cover of A. F. hit,made her an American idol in my eyes. she was the best i believe!!! #1.

  • Im confused by (natyboops) one comment down!........

  • What??????!!!!!!??????

  • She is one of the few people that can cover an Aretha Franklin song and not be afraid of not measuring up!

  • The reason besides her amazing voice why I like her so much is her sweet personality. You can see she is real and not a fake. She is so nice!

  • she makes me happy and i think there will; never be a person as good as melinda on AI

    i love her

  • she's just amazing!

  • There will NEVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER be another sing on AI as good as Melinda

  • i totally agree .. she makes me so happy and i thihk that there will never ever be a better person than her

  • i couldn't agree more!

  • AMAZING

  • .....her charming aura brings her on top

  • Oh my! I haven't heard this one, and...Wow! Nothing else to add.

  • Melinda was a total master. Her voice has such prescence.

  • SHE IS THE BESS!! awesome singer...love her voice...so POWERFUL!!

  • Great voice.

  • Awesome! 0:21 she is killing it, just getting started. Another great performance from the best sing on all AI series

  • OMG! Just look at her. She seems so much more confident than she was during the auditions. Whoa! Way to go girl! I LOVE YA! And, just for your info, you look like Kelly Rowland here. And you are the obvious winner to me, even if you didnt win Idol. You are my AI. Go girl! You rock!

  • i love her she should have won BELIEVE ME SHE GONE BE HOW JENNIFER HUDSON WAS after she left idol a few years went by then she blow up WATCH

  • 1,9,09 album in stores

  • Yeah well actually its 2/9/09 but anyway its still good!!!

  • thats some tina turner shit right there , all she needs is a ginger afro

  • It's an outrage that she isn't the biggest star on the planet

  • idol just started to suck after the fifth season. there were a couple of good ones...like melinda, but i really didn't find anything special special with the past 3 seasons. i am not an AI fan anymore. and david cook wouldn't have even made the top 5 if he was in this batch.....he was lucky last season was a total failure and that nobody didn't have a talent melinda possessed last season...

    he wouldn't have made the top 10 if he was in elliot yamin's season. lol.

  • vidmaster22 david cook is better than anyone from season 6 except melinda...season 6 had only ONE great singer and a few good ones....it was the weakest season overall....i'm thinking cook will come out with some good material...to compare season 7 to melinda is a bit unfair since she's arguably the best singer the show has ever had....i thought season 7 rocked

  • Melinda Doolittle such an amazing performer, One of the best in the history of Idol

  • Luv the *double-dutch pump before she takes the stage *(that's a jump-rope game we city-girlz play)! Randy was sooo right (did I say that?) "When ya got it, prove it! You sung...blew it out the box!" After this performance there would be no doubt: Melinda Doolittle is an 'out-the-box' lead performer! At her Street Team, we call this an example of Melinda-mite! Boom, baby! ;-)

  • She got me with that "it was Pride on my lips" part..wooooo!!

  • hello there.... i don't know what's wrong with you... but if you say Blake is better than Melinda, you gotta be kidding me... Melinda is a lot better singer than Blake... Blake has his skill but like Simon says: "It's a singing competition"... Whoever has the best vocal techniques and best attitude should win....

  • Hello! well not trying to be rude, but my opinoin was that blake should have won, because his beat boxing made it funner to listen too, but simon WAS right, it IS a singing comp.

  • It's ok... I'm not trying to be rude to you too.. :).. I truly agree that Blake has his own skill especially in beat boxing... and to be honest i picked 4 contestant to be in the Semis and one of them is Blake... But i am afraid his not the best singer here... I do think that his album could be a big hit... just like Clay Aiken... Number 2 in competition but no 1 in record album selling...

    BTW : I LOVE HAYDEN PANETTIERE... :)

  • i wonde what happened eto clay.....hmmmm do u know? i haven't heard ANYTHING from him,he wasn't successful, like kelly clarkson, i know.

    oh great! i'm glad u like hayden :)

    :)

  • Clay Aiken's album is quite successful... Especially in Asia... I do liked his voice when he's singing "Proud of your boy"... You could find it in Youtube...

    So you're a fan of Hayden, huh?... I have to tell you... She's hot... ;)

  • the only song i heard from him was "Invisible"

    yeah, i'm a fan of hayden, she is really nice,and + a hero to animals, haha... yeah she is pretty, lol

  • funner?

  • She's awesome!!

  • AMAZING!!! What more can I saw? Melinda, you are INCREDIBLE in every way shaep and form! I love you!♥

  • i think she def. shouldve won... !

  • LaKIsha was the best that night. Maybe the best performance ever on Idol.

  • I disagree, Lakisha may have went for the most long notes and vocal gymnastics but her pitch wasn't always spot on. Melinda's performance for me was the best of the night.

  • Different opinions but I totally respect yours!

  • im kind of confused as to why they didn't put any singers like this in season 7? i mean we had syesha and carly, both of which i loved, but we didn't have any lakisha's or mandisa's or melinda's... you know what i mean?

  • That's what I say..Lakisha may of struck 1st,but MELINDA pounded her into the ground afterwards

  • i agree. this was the best song that night and STILL the best singer the show's ever had. when she says "pride" it was all over. lol. waiting for that cd girl. waiting just to hear you sing again Melinda.

  • Did Simon forget about this performance when he told the other 23 contestants they might as well pack their bags after Lakisha Jones' performance (And I'm Telling You)? Lakisha was awesome that night....but come on Simon....Melinda never took a backseat to anyone on AI season 6. She's perhaps the best contestant ever. But I would have liked to have seen more of Frenchy Davis too though. I can't think of anyone who's shown Melinda's range as yet.

  • I agree with you on the pack your bags comment Simon made. I thought Melinda tore this song up! I find he often cheapens things with his overboard comments.

  • Does anyone know if she is any closer to an album. So strange that she/record producers did not strike while the iron was hot(so crucial for Idol stars since a short 7 months later, everyone tuning in to the next season). She absolutely was the best vocalist of of AI Season 6, next came Paris Bennet(so amazing), Phil Stacey tied with Blake Lewis. Jordin is adorable and talented but she didn't strike me as the best performer/vocalist. Wish them all the very best for sure.

  • Her album will be out this summer! She signed with a small label,so she could do exactly what she wanted. She's also working on a x-mas album that will be out this year! :)

  • so sad sad sad that she did not win... she's still for me the best on AI ever.

  • she shouldve won!!! is this kelly clarkson song??

  • No, it's Aretha Franklin's. I didn't see this performance the night that she sang it, but I looked on another site which listed the contestants' song choices. And when I saw "Since You've Been Gone" for Melinda I was like...WHAT!?! :D She tore this song up

    (especially the last note!!!)

  • so true- she worked the audience (as always) and everybody can't sing Aretha. that last note was indeed the cherry on top. Melinda delivered EVERY week, and she was genuine.

  • I'm kinda glad she didn't win. She would have been overexposed and under the yoke of AI management, singing what they wanted her to sing. Now, everyone knows her as the singer who SHOULD have won. From what I understand she signed with a small label so she could do exactly the kind of music she wants to. Smart woman...she'll have a lengthy career if she wants one. So looking forward to her CD and would love to see our next "Soul Diva" on tour. Hope she does some throwback classic soul too.

  • dairywoman2001 and craziedancer17, Melinda has said during an AI7 finale red carpet interview that her debut CD will come out end of summer this year and she has a holiday CD coming out winter this year, too! Yay, Melinda!

  • MELINDA SHOULD HAVE WON!

  • She is amazing. Every time she sings I never want the song to stop!

  • This woman is goddess.

  • I agree.

    when is she coming out with her cd?

  • Her CD should be out at the beginning of June actually.

  • Melinda Doolittle is the BEST singer ever to grace the American Idol stage!!!!!!!!!!! Outstanding!!!!!!!

  • OMG!!!!!! she blew me away.

  • This woman is byfar one of the best american idol contestant!

  • we <3 you melinda!!!

  • OH MY GOD WONDERFUL

  • rafael35ala is wrong.....kelly clarkson is the stronger american idol

  • I have to believe that the AI band and backup singers gave that little "extra" for Melinda during AI6. Watching this video and her "I've Got Rhythm" performance, the band tore the house down for her! Great performances!

  • And for me, that made her great!

  • Well, I'd say that for others, Melinda may not be the best American Idol, but for me, She is the most humble American Idol of all time.

  • Melinda, where are you? I sure hope that you are reading the comments that people are leaving. If so, know that you are awesome and that your singing is truly a gift from God. I wish you well1

  • From this performance onward, until she was voted off that is - I knew none of them could aproach her vocally - she is the best AI has EVER had - ever. Kelly C is good and Fantasia is good but Melinda is great.

  • Kelly Clarkson has a bigger range. It's difficult to compare the different styles of the two of them.

    Honestly, I think Clarkson's Grammies speak for themselves. One of the highest selling female artists ever. She's the original, and in my opinion, best American Idol ever.

  • I understand that Clarkson has AMAZING vocals, and is DEFINITELY one of the best AI winners. However, she's not QUITE the best vocalist ever. I think it would be REALLY close between Melinda and Jennifer Hudson. Jennifer Hudson OBVIOUSLY has the more powerful voice, but I think Melinda's control is much better. It's a toss up.

  • HAHAHAHA yeah right

  • hahahahaahahah You definitely don't know what we are referring to. "Strength." Not record sales, make up, or die hard fans.

  • How could she not win ... damn hear her go... xxx

  • Melinda's take on an Aretha Franklin song, flawless delivery ! Every word is understandable, very controlled vocals, Performance value is awesome, It's still weird to me that Jordin won over her! Still bitter here!

  • i love Jordin but i do think Melinda should have stayed in there!!!...

  • Why didn't she win? She should have gotten paid for every performance she did on that show!

  • fucking amazing voice

  • She should have won this, I dont know what happened here. All of her performances were effortless and professional.

  • She should have gotten PAID for this performance

  • Still can't believe she didn't win- she was better than Jordin...and the other guy who came second.

  • The David(s) maybe good but melinda is very consistent and one of a kind.Personally, I think she is way better than the all the Davids combined.

  • LOL!! RIGHT ON!!

  • haha that must be a joke. melinda is a pro.

  • lol. there is one david used to strip. and how can you compare a songstress to male singers?

    imlance, your comment is spot on!

  • The DAVIDS??!?! Why are we comparing her to the Davids? They are not even on the same season.

  • EVERYONE "MY FUNNY VALENTINE" IS AVAILABLE ON iTUNES! 99 CENTS. ITS CHEAP AND ITS A GREAT. SUPPORT OUR MELINDA DOOLITTLE!!!

  • imagine if american idol was based on singing rather than popularity =/

  • Despite the shallow competition last year, i believe Melinda would still be the best of this season is she competed this year. Yes, even better than David A.

  • I second that. The girls this year have NOTHING on Melinda, it's not even funny.

  • You took the words right out of my mouth... they have NOTHING on Melinda... she was a one time thing... mark my words... its going to be a while before we see anyone with that kind of talent again on any idol program.

  • Melinda Would blow all of these guys out the water this year

    But David A. and her would be the final two :)

    LOL

  • You guys are right!! Melinda is truly someone who stands out among the crowd. Even the word 'incredible' doesn't do justice to her voice!!!! :D

  • Best ever on Idol - bar none - there have been other good ones but none are better than Melinda - oh but little Blakey came in second because the little girls thought he was "cute".

  • Any hearing person can tell that this lady has "IT".... and she will have a very long and wonderful career.

  • WTF? did u even watch last season??? She outshined EVERYONE and should have one. She was the most consisten Contestant yet. U know nothing.

  • You must be tone deaf, it you think she did this song badly. To each their own. I think she is wonderful, the best female ever on the show.

  • Firstly, if you were looking for Kelly Clarkson you should have kept it moving and found her. Secondly, I see you know nothing about soul music since you dont even know that Aretha Franklin is the original singer and this is a fairly popular soul song. Finally, why would you even say you're glad someone didn't win?

  • Man it's like every note she sings is flawless and effortless.

    She so should have won.

  • Melinda should have won.

  • She sings with incredible passion.

  • Amazing! Brillant, sensasionnal, P.E.R.F.E.C.T!

    Melinda is the absolute female vocalist!

  • this season needs a MELINDA!