All great questions & concerns. I presume your are referring to this video. Perhaps like me you are too bored to listen to me speak. The lesson here is what the student will want to do in response to incoming contact. I don't see anywhere he is being taught to collapse. If you watch my striking elbows vids I am not a proponent of elbow use for strikes as it violates the physics of WC. Also hand replacement ability is essential to WC. The focus here is on what HE should do. Thanks.
Quick question I thought that forward energy would lead the guy to punch if you collapse? I get the adjustment to the reach around attack but still if some run hands we punch right? Maybe that just for beginners and this video covers a situation that requires higher level kung fu. I'm not sure.
That's the thing, to play at that level of mastery where you can lead what appears to be a collapse and still retain total control of all potential movements. Chances are they can't even run if you have that type of control but if they do, they have to earn it buy positing an explosive energy that you must respond to and while you do they dissapear and run. Not likely though. So yes, they run you crush. Hulk crush. Hulk kill. LOL
Why do you teach your student to Chuk Kiu (collapse)?
Why do you use a Fei Jang (flying elbow) in Chi Sao?
Why are you not in a position to apply Fan Sau (hand replacement) after your initial attack?
ariellewong1 5 months ago
@ariellewong1
All great questions & concerns. I presume your are referring to this video. Perhaps like me you are too bored to listen to me speak. The lesson here is what the student will want to do in response to incoming contact. I don't see anywhere he is being taught to collapse. If you watch my striking elbows vids I am not a proponent of elbow use for strikes as it violates the physics of WC. Also hand replacement ability is essential to WC. The focus here is on what HE should do. Thanks.
heartslord 5 months ago
Whats your opinion on using Ngoi Jut Sao vs. your outside advancing hand.
WingChunNinja7 6 months ago
@WingChunNinja7
Please make a short video of that jut as I am unfamiliar with the Ngoi terms. ;-)
heartslord 6 months ago
Quick question I thought that forward energy would lead the guy to punch if you collapse? I get the adjustment to the reach around attack but still if some run hands we punch right? Maybe that just for beginners and this video covers a situation that requires higher level kung fu. I'm not sure.
mosdef2000 7 months ago
@mosdef2000
That's the thing, to play at that level of mastery where you can lead what appears to be a collapse and still retain total control of all potential movements. Chances are they can't even run if you have that type of control but if they do, they have to earn it buy positing an explosive energy that you must respond to and while you do they dissapear and run. Not likely though. So yes, they run you crush. Hulk crush. Hulk kill. LOL
heartslord 7 months ago
great clip, like the application of elbow at 2:26. Thanks.
MYVTKungFu 8 months ago