Y'all do realize that many people that watch and listen to them on here are Chinese right? Including me, so would y'all shut the freak up about our government?! Plus, if you haven't noticed, many people in Japan and all over the world don't accept Visual Kei either because many people think "they look like girls and are stupid gay cross-dressers" or something, it's not just China. Also, Visual Kei wasn't popular at first in Japan either, but after some time, look at them now. Give it some time.
Mandarin has taken some time to get used to...but these guys are wonderful! A lot better than some of the more popular Japanese VK bands, in my opinion. :)
@everstarshanghai At least in 40 short years the Chinese government managed to better the lives of most of the Chinese people by dropping the poverty rate from 48% when Mao was alive to 8% today, made it the second largest economy, be the third to go to space, host olympics, pulling China back on its feet after ~200 years of perpetual and continuous civil war and foreign occupation.
Do not bad mouth the government just because they prevent this one band from being "Visual Kei."
it sounds like 90's vk, can someone recommend me some chinese vk or rock band which sounds like the third vk wave? (well, not just the same... ^^). I like pretty heavy stuff, but not just that.
It is not cause of the chinese government,they are still a visual band.It is because visual kei is not so accepted in china.They are not successful in commercial.
@maxqiang being commerical is overrated and once you reach that level that's where the brainwashing begins. most commercial bands aren't even good, the best lie in the underground
@MNProductionx Unfortunately you have to get permissions to move from your hometown in China, otherwise you are like an illegal immigrant, moreover this permissions only last for 2 years -.- Something like that :S
Aaaah I love this song so much! I remember when my friends and I got into them back in the days~ It's such a shame they can't be visual :( is it really only because of the government? Visual is banned?? So they would actually want to stay visual? <3 oh dear..
China is still in the "industrialization" stade actyally... so they make great sacrifice for their nation and human rights is at is lowest level ever...:S (Mondialization and all export stuff *buh Buh*!)
China is capitalism under a communist party. The current Chinese government doesn't like the whole rock genre. Hopefully it will change because China has a lot of metalheads.
It would have been alright if the bird flu hadnt stopped them then they would have made an international debut brought in money and tourism then china could have been full of v-kei
In this video, Lucy (guitarist), Liang (Vocalist), Zhen (drummer), and Hong (bassist) are in this video. Liang and Zhen are the only ones still active I believe.
if only lucy is back with silver silver ash & silver ash be visual again : (
femboygothicwolf 1 month ago
我很喜欢这支乐队 期待更多的作品!
DARKsoul860807 2 months ago
Y'all do realize that many people that watch and listen to them on here are Chinese right? Including me, so would y'all shut the freak up about our government?! Plus, if you haven't noticed, many people in Japan and all over the world don't accept Visual Kei either because many people think "they look like girls and are stupid gay cross-dressers" or something, it's not just China. Also, Visual Kei wasn't popular at first in Japan either, but after some time, look at them now. Give it some time.
MoonStar0519 3 months ago 5
@MoonStar0519 yea but the chinese government was censoring them at the beginning, atleast the japanese government let them be visual (im chinese)
Vampiric59 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Stupid Chinese Communist!Why ban the band?
mertentwotwo 4 months ago
Comment removed
mertentwotwo 4 months ago
Cool band. Despite not being a huge visual kei fan
Mefistau 4 months ago
Comment removed
msjulicious 4 months ago
Hi This is Silver Ash official Channel
We have the latest Silver Ash video and their news.
They has restarted activities now!
silverashofficial 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Awesome Song!
EverythingOtaku 4 months ago
cool ) nice voice
LittleAngelFan 7 months ago
Mandarin has taken some time to get used to...but these guys are wonderful! A lot better than some of the more popular Japanese VK bands, in my opinion. :)
eyamora 7 months ago 2
fucking chinese government, because of them, china lacks modern culture...
everstarshanghai 9 months ago
@everstarshanghai At least in 40 short years the Chinese government managed to better the lives of most of the Chinese people by dropping the poverty rate from 48% when Mao was alive to 8% today, made it the second largest economy, be the third to go to space, host olympics, pulling China back on its feet after ~200 years of perpetual and continuous civil war and foreign occupation.
Do not bad mouth the government just because they prevent this one band from being "Visual Kei."
Ravensteinzh 8 months ago 6
that's a batman costume that vocalist wearing?
Frosty609544790 9 months ago
ppl stand up for freedom!
Born2Rock1987 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ah stupid chinese government
---
Ah stupid americans
TervelBG 10 months ago
かっこいい!!美しい!
melancholy1210 10 months ago
it sounds like 90's vk, can someone recommend me some chinese vk or rock band which sounds like the third vk wave? (well, not just the same... ^^). I like pretty heavy stuff, but not just that.
bestiaonthedrum 10 months ago
These guys are awesome!
Jonnyeth 11 months ago
this is better then most of the japanese visual kei bands!))
ivan200591 1 year ago 5
It is not cause of the chinese government,they are still a visual band.It is because visual kei is not so accepted in china.They are not successful in commercial.
maxqiang 1 year ago
@maxqiang being commerical is overrated and once you reach that level that's where the brainwashing begins. most commercial bands aren't even good, the best lie in the underground
BODOMmETALwolF 1 year ago
This is amazing. .... Beautiful, in everyway shape and form... Perfect mix
TheNauticalKraken 1 year ago
Dude they're back to their visual kei sound.
Mefistau 1 year ago
<3 8D
Eliza0445 1 year ago
T.T I want this!!! where can I download???? ;(
suzierox2 1 year ago
Beautiful band!
MurasakiFuyu 1 year ago
they should move to hong kong. there're more musical freedom there
MNProductionx 1 year ago
@MNProductionx Unfortunately you have to get permissions to move from your hometown in China, otherwise you are like an illegal immigrant, moreover this permissions only last for 2 years -.- Something like that :S
silakotonaru 1 year ago
I love their sound, can anyone tell me what is their best song?
blingadingading 1 year ago
Their music is beautiful!
The Chinese government should let them be VK again!
AkatsukiDarkRose21 1 year ago 4
So unfair & wrong how their government is... this band is very talented & the vocalist's voice is beautiful.
AutumnMystry 1 year ago 3
brilliant :)
Kyo1Uroboros 1 year ago
it really was a shame that such an amazing band was discontinued from publishing or exhibiting their talents. it's rough even finding their old cds.
schaotic 1 year ago
beautiful song...
BloodOfForgottenRose 1 year ago
but on wikipedia they say that they didn't stop... they're still playing shows in China...
?
monique6661 2 years ago 11
@monique6661 well.... I think that it's not banned in China, more it's like no one really know about them and thier CD's are not selling.
wytapirowana 9 months ago
awesomeness XDD
luckily i moved out frm china was i was small and hk is more free than china x.x
dude they even banned death note D;
oh well, tks for the uploads ;D
mizuxkagami 2 years ago 9
Lol banned death note. Jeez they are scared.
Daedoichi 2 years ago 7
lol well.. murders copying death note has happened in other countries ;s
but oh well, ppl re-uploaded death note with a diff name, kinda 1337 XD
mizuxkagami 2 years ago
@Daedoichi i dont think death note is still banned, there are death note videos on chinese websites and even a death note forum on baidu tieba
Vampiric59 1 month ago
hahahahahahahahahahahaha people murdering in "death-note" style :O
omg you made my day :p
Daedoichi 2 years ago
haha lol XDD
i read it all on wiki x,x
apprently some kid gt expelled for owning a fake death note
anyways, im going off topic of the orignal vid XDD
VISUAL ROCK FTW XDD
mizuxkagami 2 years ago 4
rofl great come back VK ruLeZ XD
Daedoichi 2 years ago 3
LOVE!!!!!! Ling's voice is incredibly ! Amazing <3
Hideko12012 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
Hideko12012 2 years ago
Argh. The Chinese Government! Silver Ash is the bomb! I love them!!! XD
ruunapandanerd 2 years ago
So true ^^ ty for comment!
Daedoichi 2 years ago
Is there a way i could contact them??
write to them??
Ive always thought that to pursue what you want to accomplish you musnt quit if its your passion...where theres a will theres a way~
kizume8 3 years ago
ah stupid chinese government
RoseMilord 3 years ago 23
so sad that they had to change style, such a good band.
hopefully one day China will have less strict rules.
i'm glad that i'm chinese, german and american and live in California sometimes. it would be so different for me to be living in China.
kowaipasaro 3 years ago 2
Chinese, German and American O_o
Quite a nice mixing pot :p
hehe
China doesn't look like a nice place if you want to be different XD
Daedoichi 3 years ago
what a beautiful tune...
shame they don't do visual kei anymore...
6haku 3 years ago 2
Aaaah I love this song so much! I remember when my friends and I got into them back in the days~ It's such a shame they can't be visual :( is it really only because of the government? Visual is banned?? So they would actually want to stay visual? <3 oh dear..
Amejou 3 years ago
Yep... Yep...
Actually, they are still doing music with NO visual style -___-'
I'm Nyappy You like em' anyway =^^='
ThX comment!
Daedoichi 3 years ago
well, the style isnt wuts important, its the music!
yearof07 3 years ago
You are pretty right but their musical style changed also:/ The ambiance and all :/
Daedoichi 3 years ago
The melody is kind of hypnotic.
SoulZero 3 years ago
Great song! Someone know where I can find their songs ? Or can send me them?
Thank you
P.S. A shame to banned music! Visual or not!
Don't make me laught when we told that Chine is a new nation of human right!
Sorry if I offense somebody, don't take it bad
keiralexiel 3 years ago 2
*hug*So lovely comment you wrote! ^^'
Mah! Mah! That is right! *about P.S*
China is still in the "industrialization" stade actyally... so they make great sacrifice for their nation and human rights is at is lowest level ever...:S (Mondialization and all export stuff *buh Buh*!)
So So... Luv SA anyway ^^'
Daedoichi 3 years ago
This is cool.
lol Ive never heard a chinese vk band before, or chinese metal band for that matter.
opticon91 3 years ago
ameze songgg
"..stopped from doing visual kei because of the chinese governmenт"
thy is that? =__=
Yorikowa 3 years ago
Everything that someone does publicly in China has to be okay'ed by the government (to my current knowledge China is communist).
So, if the government isn't okay with something they have the power to stop them, and apparently they aren't okay with visual kei themed bands.
KanaKozuKandyApple 3 years ago
Everything that someone does publicly in China has to be okay'ed by the government (to my current knowledge China is communist).
So, if the government isn't okay with something they have the power to stop them, and apparently they aren't okay with visual kei themed bands.
KanaKozuKandyApple 3 years ago
China is capitalism under a communist party. The current Chinese government doesn't like the whole rock genre. Hopefully it will change because China has a lot of metalheads.
Ravensteina 3 years ago
isn't it more or less the visual then the rock?
Troyjr 3 years ago
It would have been alright if the bird flu hadnt stopped them then they would have made an international debut brought in money and tourism then china could have been full of v-kei
odorobujohn 3 years ago
China needs some rock music! The current mainstream music Ok'd by the CCP is so lame and boring.
conneda 3 years ago
well, there r SUM gems(JAY CHOU!!), but rock is mostly underground...and underground is RLLY hard 2 find in china...u need 2 have connections
=(
yearof07 3 years ago 2
Can someone tell me which members are in this mv? & If they're still active?
UkNoWkNoWsU 3 years ago
In this video, Lucy (guitarist), Liang (Vocalist), Zhen (drummer), and Hong (bassist) are in this video. Liang and Zhen are the only ones still active I believe.
ruunapandanerd 2 years ago 2
I think you are quite right ^^ ty for precision ^___^
Daedoichi 2 years ago
just 2 commets o.o
louisezero31 4 years ago
Yeh comets! ^^
Mah ya 2 comments ! lol
Daedoichi 4 years ago
XD haha
louisezero31 4 years ago
i realy love silver ash
sunny729 4 years ago