Ghost Hunters Live! 10/31/08 a spirit tugs collar?

[harukadeimos85]

I'd imagine that after doing this type of stuff for years doesn't really frighten them very easily. They expect the worst but don't let it get to them, even the little things and that what i call professional. I'm sorry not everybody is chicken shit with the little things that happen.

[mrshutter45]

no matter what he will not move his right arm lmao

[FunkyMotherfucker]

such bad actors

[marlboro1ization]

fake

[Kimbelle10]

I love wandering around in the cells during the summer! LoL! It's hot as hell and it's nice to get a breeze. I don't do it by myself though--but I do think that F.D. is haunted--Stood in a cell for a good 5 minutes by myself and I thought someone was watching me by the door. I laughed and sped-walked the crap OUT! Lol! My friend Lindsay saw a ghost too...She says it was some little blonde boy...

Anyway; going back next summer!! LoL! Down the secret spot we found too--It wasn't roped off either..

[mortimer2100]

I find it odd that grant stays pretty calm during the tug's. If my collar got pulled, I doubt that I would keep calm about it.

[valpro99]

During the 2nd tug you can see the skin of his right hand just hanging off his pant pocket. I'm sorry but his right hand isn't doing anything. He's not faking anything. Everyone has to just get over it and move on. This is what real paranormal activity looks like.

[CatViper]

@valpro99 Thank you lol I totally believe that they wouldn't fake evidence. What reason would they have too?

[shawnaMatrious1]

@CatViper they have the reason fake things for popularity and entertainment...

[mrshutter45]

@CatViper MONEY AND RAITING!!!sorry but you ghost buddies have sold you out!

[CatViper]

I've watched the clip and to be perfectly honest i don't see any evidence of this being faked. Yes his hand stays by his side but in different positions.

[MoQuake]

yeah wtf was this live or something cuz why would they want to fake this shit. its so obvious.

[FranklinPatriot]

@MoQuake because ghosts aren't real...dipshit

[MoQuake]

@FranklinPatriot one question- why are you so hostile toward me?

[CatViper]

@FranklinPatriot Prove ghosts aren't real. I have no reason to believe they don't exist when i have seen them myself.

[jsnmllr1981]

if you look at the thermal evedence there is a heat signiture that looks like a thumb. I think when he was tugged, he was not tugged has hard as you think, I think it was just enough to make him jump back a little.

[slipsk8er456]

Guys listen at 1:42 you here a breahting noise its pretty kewl.

[ladyamerias]

listen to all the whining haters. amazing. i believe it is real.

[nibornna]

if people can't tell that grant is acting in this, then i don't know what to tell them! they are such LIARS, and not to mention very bad actors!

[SERGEda3RD]

this looks incredibly fake, if you notice right b4 his collar gets tugged his hand is in his pocket or above it leading me to believe hes pulling on something from the inside of his jacket, then immediately afterwards he doesnt freak out but adjusts it back to a more comfortable position he does it with a slight lean to his right as if to reach further down with his hand, good try but not the greatest acting

[StargateSG1Rules]

the evidence that you guys say about how he has one hand in his pocket and that since he only has one hand then its fake well i walk with 1 hand in my pocket all the time.

[mechwolf2003]

@StargateSG1Rules Do you walk around with one hand in your pocket because you're playing pocket pool? LOL

[valpro99]

@mechwolf2003 I don't normally but Grant has a habit of doing it. Not only the night in question but on a lot of his shows he does. I've met him in person and investigated with the entire group along with Grant and he had the tendency to put his hands in his pockets. Im sorry if some don't agree with me but I'm entitled to my opinion.

[mechwolf2003]

@valpro99 Wow! That would be cool to investigate with them. I realize that there will always be sceptics in everything. I really want to believe that Ghost Hunters is the one real show, but like them, I do try to de-bunk things. I doubt tho, that they would fake stuff.

[ForensicThermal]

flir is in auto mode which makes the camera constantly adjust every time someone moves.

[para03sarah]

dude i live in delaware. been to fort delaware lots of times. its creepy man. i believe its haunted.

and the camera man was probably wondering where grant was going because the other guys might have been standing still.

love the show anyway because they actually try to debunk things unlike most haunted.

it was real. grant and the whole taps team would never fake something because they are skeptics themselves when entering a new place. and they are desensitized to the paranormal (experience)

[kimleechang]

Totally bad acting. If something would have pulled on him, he would have more of a reaction than that.

[ccee3000]

@kimleechang dude you are a RETARD for saying that. yeah so that sorta thing happens all the time to them so they're kinda used to it. you stupid piece of crap!

[kimleechang]

oh I'm sorry. Didn't know you were sensitive and believed all this shit. I'm not saying it's not haunted. I'm saying that's fake. so take the stick out of your ass.

[isaatt53]

I spent the night in Fort Delaware...trust me... it's haunted

[utubin67]

right before he says " I DON'T KNOW WHAT I COULD BE CAUGHT ON" he whips out the wire or whatever evidence there was and chucks it away, then Jay goes over to show everyone "LOOK THERE'S NOTHING THERE".. too bad the camera caught Grant removing it.. too bad for them, that is.. but for us to see it is to me 100% proof these guys are frauds. "Ghost Frauds" Season 1 starring the shamed "Jay & Grant" coming next Fall on Channel 0.

[nibornna]

@utubin67 your right you can see it clearly!!! as many time's as ive watched this ive never noticed that. i knew it was fake anyway's, but this put's the icing on the cake!! thank's for pointing that out !!!

[utubin67]

@nibornna well this is a blast from the past.. lol haha I forgot all about these comments I made back then.. but I do remember really slowing this video down and being able to see Grant rip that cord/wire out of his hood area and well I just dropped my head in dissapointment b/c I'd much rather have honest guys with no ghosts that fraud liars to insult us.. the fans? uh uh.. no way I haven't watched these guys since this.. I just walked away and I'm not happy either b/c I liked them alot. LIKED

[utubin67]

thanks tho nibornna for your reply.

[utubin67]

If I was a ghost, trust me, I wouldn't be just tuggin on 1 guy's coat. Why would I do that if I could do something to all 3 of thise idiots.

[kiloshinobi]

THEY HAVE NO FEAR SHIT HEAD

[jaelynrae08]

There were two other people in the room, why was the camera only following Grant? Plus this would have been their biggest experience, they would have been freaking out if it was real. I have seen them almost hyperventilate with excitement over a slight bump on other shows. You would think with an actual caught on film contact, they would be shouting in excitement.

[jaelynrae08]

I love how every time Jason goes to check he first conveniently moves right in front of the camera before checking.

[jaelynrae08]

I am sorry instinctively you would put up both hands not just the one facing the camera. I have watched this show tons of times and I have never seen him walk around with his hands in his pockets, usually he is blowing on his hands to warm them up.

[jaelynrae08]

If you look at the thermal cam at 3:06 you can actually see the string whip across the screen as he pulls it out, don't blink it is quick. So sad! I loved this show.

[utubin67]

Dude GREAT CATCH!!!!!!!!

[LINTON1985]

there reactions seem abit dodgy to me my opinion is they just done this hoax to give the live thing some entertainment cus in the normal shows i believe thats true

[trag5150]

this is just sad for me as I have been a fan of ghost hunters for a long time,does anyone know if GH has made in comments on this crap?

[funkykid]

i seen it earlygates u can hear him yanking the string out of his jacket good catch.

[arson2112]

"Goodness me. Some thing has pulled my collar. What ever could it have been? Perhaps the ghost of my acting coach?"

[earlygates]

3:05 - 3:08 you can see him disconnect the string and throw the anchor away. Check it out.

[cazqab]

well if it isnt real they could of found something more believable after 4 years ( why only his hood , always the same place ?)

[ripping76]

Why didnt he take the jacket off to prove it? That is what they usually would have done! Grank never uses a hooded sweat shirt and walks around with his hands in his pocket! I have done my own investigating for years...This is just so disapointing!

[phuckfacemoron]

Infinitely dissapointing. I will never watch that show again. Shame on the network for airing that. Poor Jason - he totally doesn't seem to be involved with the destroying of his show.

[satyr72]

To form our own opinion unlike sheep like you mike.

[screamfreak79]

I trust the TAPS gang..This is the real deal people...

Mike S

[fingersticks74]

this is very poor acting

[FaceOnMars99]

Obvious Fraud. These guys need to be taken off the air.

[dontknow4whyiwatch]

Check out the video at 1:03. You can see a fog moving next to that guy. I thought at first it might be his breath, but I don't see it any other time.

[roryboryalice]

I have TiVo & used the slo-mo...it's NOT a hoax. Plus to debunk for myself I tugged on a friend's coat collar & she had the same reaction. Very little effort/same reaction. Challenge to try it...then youtube it. Neither uses personal experience to PROVE paranormal activity, which is probably why Jason initially disregards it & searches for a reasonable cause.

[fallingstareye]

Does anyone think maybe Grant rigged this on his own and Jason is suspicious? Jason seems to not want to be a part of it and right before Jason checks Grant's collar out (at 3:06) Grant seems to pull something from his collar and throw it down. Jason is more interested in talking about the big bat blocking out the light than the jacket tug. It will be interesting to see if in the near future Grant steps down and Steve steps up into Grant's spot.

[LtStarkiller]

I've been interested in paranormal investigation for years. Tons of reading, case studies, videos, interviews. This is 100% guaranteed a hoax.

[justgvnmyopinion]

With that said... I did a COLLAR TUG TEST at home and did get these same results. I just used a needle and thread but I put it down through the inside of the collar and ran it down the coat through a belt loop in my pants and had the string at my side, just like Grants hand. I got the same results.. But dont have a camera to post it.. Maybe someone else can try it and post for us to compare.

[justgvnmyopinion]

I am a true beleiver of paranormal. I love TAPS and have been a fan for years. BUT I do NOT beleive this collar tug to be real. I think SCIFI wanted something to "talk" about and this is what they came up with. You can totally tell (watching the live show) that Jason was NOT impressed and seemed to leave the area when something was going to happen. His actions alone tell the truth. I am very sad.

[aelias55]

I did not mean that he picked up his arm and pulled on his hood. What I am saying is that at the exact moment of the tug on Grants hood,you clearly see that Jason arms does a downward pulling motion. Seriously, LOOK AT IT AT 1:15! IT IS NOT FAR FETCHED TO BELIEVE THAT JASON PULLED THE HOOD WITH A FISHING WIRE. A REAL THIN FISHING WIRE COULD BE totally INVISIBLE IN THE DARK! I loved the show and watched but they totally screwed up here and I am starting to doubt all their work.

[dustbunnieboo]

Good video! Thanks!

You might also enjoy "TAPS LIES - Ghost Hunters Live - 2008 - Fraud-O-Rama" by moviedan and "Jacket Pull Debunk" by FORMERGHFAN for some solid evidence. Remember evidence? That's what TAPS *used* to be about. :-/

[davematthewsfan24]

what's that noise at 1:41?

[aelias55]

You know, I actually defending these guys but at 1:15, my opinion of them changed. Just look at Grants hood and Jasons arm. There is a clear pull by Jasons arm. I am shocked by this. They praise proof and evidence. 1:15 proves that there is evidence of contamination!

[Kayiko]

I think you are reading WAY to into that. I watched it 20 times and Grants collar comes down before Jason's arm goes down. The pull happens before the arm movement. It would have to be the other way around for your claims to be believable.

[satyr72]

FAKE,

[stme2008]

fake lost these fans

[SithHound]

I don't believe in ghosts or the "supernatural", but I don't see what you guys are talking about. If his collar was rigged, he would be controling it with his hand in his pocket, I don't see any mechanism. I don't understand the "opposite day" physics comment 'cause i don't see what you guys are seeing. At 2:35 the jacket comes down, and that part looks real. Isn't the infrared camera supposed to pick up ghosts by reading heat or lack there of. There is no change on the jacket.

[TacoTown241]

So your saying you do believe something supernatural pulled on his jacket you just don't think its a ghost? Little bit of a conflicting comment their. You can clearly see that the collar is getting tugged downward. Probably by wire, probably by someone out of view, who knows. But it appears to me that he is controlling it with something in his pocket. If you notice,his arm never moves during the entire shot.Only till after the commercial break do we see him with his right arm out of his pocket.

[SithHound]

My comments are conflicting because I am not ready to rule anything out right away. I am looking at all possibilities, not just jumping to the conclusion that it's fake because there is "probably a wire, probably being pulled down by someone out of view" I'm not saying I believe it's real either.

[TacoTown241]

And no one has yet mentioned that the "tug" on Grant's jacket looks more like its making an impression in his jacket than a pulling look. Was the ghost inside Grants collar when the tug happend. Now unless physics in ghost world works likes its opposite day, that just doesn't fly. Now the question is why would they risk losing their entire fan base for a poorly set up trick like that.

[TacoTown241]

LAWl! This is so obviously fake. You can see something in the hood of his jacket the whole time. Bears is right, after the jacket gets checked you see the mechanism in his jacket move again. It also seems strange that Grant was always in the shot when it happend. If you look at 1:12 Grant looks like he really wanted to make sure he was in full view of the camera when the so called "tug" occurred. At least they could have done a better job of setting that up.

[findlaybears]

Grant's coat actually gets tugged 4x. Watch Grant's collar after Jason pats him on the back. The collar moves yet again but Grant says nothing about feeling any tug. If you can do a closeup of the back of the coat, it looks like something is sticking out the back of the collar. It looks like a hole. Did Grant rig his coat to move and then disposed of some of the evidence (but unforunately for Grant not all of it) before Jason checked it out?

My vote? FAKE!!!