@85Aheadstix Stupid, do U really see Peart playing a Necrophagist song??? U just can't see. Peart did what he could which has BEEN great but... he is just history, a legend. His time has passed.I'm pretty sure that if he would have gone to the Dream Theatre auditions, he would have been left on the same place with Aquiles Priester and Derek Roddy.
@morganix007 Hahahaha!, man you obviously dont know shit about drumming!, Peart on the same level as priester and Roddy?, wow thats the funniest thing ive ever heard!, Peart invented what portnoy played, hell, Rush invented prog rock pretty much.
There aint nothing they could play that he cannot.
@morganix007 Dude you must be an old Peart fan! I like yes you have to give Peart credit, but man he isn't the greatest drummer if you could be honest. Music today is much different than what he used or continue to play man. And yeah I'm a drummer and I've seen what these drummers has been doing. To be honest, peart doesn't impress me at all...mate but this guy Marco Minneman...awesome although that drum solo is kind of a bit boring.
Ahora veo por qué no se decidían entre este cuate y Mike Mangini a la hora de decidirse para reemplazar a Pornoy en Dream Theater. Sorprendentemente Brutalll...
better then over rated portnoy! Marco is one of the best drummers out there, I am glad he didn't get into dream theater cuz he can do better then that! he is too expresive for that band
I'm here to talk about the existence of a brand new musical experience called Idaea. The influence ranges from Planet X, Meshuggah, Dream Theater, Chick Corea to Contemporany and Experimental music. It would be really cool if you visited our myspace and added coments, thoughts and opinions!:
yeah the DT audtion was funny wasnt it....i mean a player of his fucking incredible caliber didnt get the gig...makes you wonder whether it was set up to spike interest in Dream Theater after protnoy,...I mean Virgill Donati , Thomas Lang and Marco auditioned and didnt get it , i smell a rat! hahaha I think they were payed to do the audition and be part of the DVD that was produced ...
Could you please wait till after 30. april, because i really want to see him play with Steven Wilson. :) After that you can do what you want with him. :D
Did your parents drop your on your ears when you were little? Saying the Rev is better than Marco is like saying that Kerry King is a better guitarist than John Petrucci.
I think him playing with Jordan later this month is a sine he is next in line.... which is a good thing! Oh and can any of us make a PDP sound that good?
Chemistry 101 - Mix the most fantastic pieces of every awesome drummer on the planet together, and you have a vial of nastiness that can only be named Marco Minnemann. I salute you...
@slash17rockz 100%. He has creativity AND chops down pat, with a very fitting style for DT to boot: a combination of musical elements that virgil, lang or any other I can think of do not have that would be suitable for the band. the guys from DT would be crazy not to pick him.
yes one of the best alternatives i think. but i don't know if he can sing and play like mike... otherwise, why shouldn't he, his coordination is incredible, singing at the same time should be no problem
@slash17rockz funny thing he now is going to fill portnoy's shoe's ;) I discussed it with other fans aswell before something was said about he being the next Dream Theater drummer, he is just the right guy
its the chops of buddy rich with the technicality of dennis chambers or virgil donati, mixed with the metal of george kollias or roddy. he is definitely on of the greatest drummers top three no doubt.
Did this guy play for paul gilbert?
amazingfantasy66 4 hours ago
Damn! Marcos got like a trillion rhythms floating around in his head to access. One of my favorite drummers.
pedimatt60 2 days ago
OVERRATED!, atleast ten other drummer can do twice that!, Peart is the master, this guy is just a copycat!.
85Aheadstix 1 week ago
@85Aheadstix If Peart is the master, the student surpass him...
morganix007 3 days ago
@morganix007 Hahahahaha!, thats a good one, Minneman surpass Peart?, yeah whatever mate, maybe in your mind, nobody is gonna surpass peart.
Peart is the grand master, the student is never as good as the master.
Your clearly have no i dea about drums or drumming.
85Aheadstix 3 days ago
@85Aheadstix Stupid, do U really see Peart playing a Necrophagist song??? U just can't see. Peart did what he could which has BEEN great but... he is just history, a legend. His time has passed.I'm pretty sure that if he would have gone to the Dream Theatre auditions, he would have been left on the same place with Aquiles Priester and Derek Roddy.
morganix007 2 days ago
@morganix007 Hahahaha!, man you obviously dont know shit about drumming!, Peart on the same level as priester and Roddy?, wow thats the funniest thing ive ever heard!, Peart invented what portnoy played, hell, Rush invented prog rock pretty much.
There aint nothing they could play that he cannot.
And there are better drummers than Marcos.
85Aheadstix 1 day ago
@morganix007 Dude you must be an old Peart fan! I like yes you have to give Peart credit, but man he isn't the greatest drummer if you could be honest. Music today is much different than what he used or continue to play man. And yeah I'm a drummer and I've seen what these drummers has been doing. To be honest, peart doesn't impress me at all...mate but this guy Marco Minneman...awesome although that drum solo is kind of a bit boring.
morganix007 1 day ago
@85Aheadstix
"the student is never as good as the master"
So each new generation of drummers is worse than the generation before them, and the first ever drummer is the best of all time?
Do you really think that?
redefn199 23 hours ago
penisphagist
LHondrums 1 week ago
paul gilberts brother?
09052010boo 1 week ago
@09052010boo not brother but interesting that they look similar and he played for gilbert...
daviddaimary7734 1 week ago
happiest drummer in the world
PimpMasterT 1 week ago
Marco is such a musical monster! The guy at the very bottom of the screen, right at the end of the video is HILARIOUS!
jp60476 1 month ago
AS Jordan Rudess says: "Pure musical joy"
toastedhippo 1 month ago 2
the dislike its from joy jordinson...
xnukexsxe10 1 month ago 3
This drum set is not perfect for his solos, but he's rocking the hell out.
metalwizard32 2 months ago
his cross are not good enough. but hands are gifted.
TheCrusify 4 months ago
Ahora veo por qué no se decidían entre este cuate y Mike Mangini a la hora de decidirse para reemplazar a Pornoy en Dream Theater. Sorprendentemente Brutalll...
valthern 4 months ago
death by drum solo!
drummerchris22 4 months ago
That dislike comes from a frustrated drummer who can't play even 60 bpm..........
slmc777 4 months ago
@slmc777 it must be from mangina..
visious123 4 months ago
I met and talked with this guy at an Aristocrats clinic/show in Vermont at Higher Ground!
thetryingmusician 4 months ago
wow, half bar changes, very ingenious......
BigRooster747 4 months ago
i think if i attempt this ill be seriously injured...
drums4metal 5 months ago
HE LOOKS LIKE TOM GREEN
superrobotmunkyman 5 months ago
I met marco yesterday at a drum clinic. An I saw his new band the aristocrats, he kicks ass and he's super nice.
Techdeath96 5 months ago
I trust this guy more than I trust my metronome.
viasevenvai 5 months ago 54
that shit is impossible. this guy is not from this planet.
phizzo11 5 months ago 2
I shat bricks. Marco is definitely in my top drummers list
GiviPieFace 5 months ago
Just look at him smile!
Naaga88 5 months ago
First DW signs this guy..Then they sign Cobus...What a down grade..cmon DW..talents or cocky pretyboy celebs??
OfivetwoekVeeDee 6 months ago
Doesn't he remind you of Keith Moon???
fireice113 6 months ago
the best part of this is the mini hi hat solo @ 3:12 the second best part is that he plays promark
MrBlarghmaster 6 months ago
better then over rated portnoy! Marco is one of the best drummers out there, I am glad he didn't get into dream theater cuz he can do better then that! he is too expresive for that band
pinkpussy2007 6 months ago
haaaaaaaaaaaaluuuuuucinant !!!
mkknot 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello everyone.
I'm here to talk about the existence of a brand new musical experience called Idaea. The influence ranges from Planet X, Meshuggah, Dream Theater, Chick Corea to Contemporany and Experimental music. It would be really cool if you visited our myspace and added coments, thoughts and opinions!:
/idaeaband
Thanks for the time! Stay tuned for more!
Facundo Negri - Idaea´s drummer
DonatiStudent 6 months ago
lol @ 9:10 this guy is possessed.
chrisgr00ver 6 months ago
yeah the DT audtion was funny wasnt it....i mean a player of his fucking incredible caliber didnt get the gig...makes you wonder whether it was set up to spike interest in Dream Theater after protnoy,...I mean Virgill Donati , Thomas Lang and Marco auditioned and didnt get it , i smell a rat! hahaha I think they were payed to do the audition and be part of the DVD that was produced ...
candidcomment 7 months ago
How can he move two high hats and two kick pedals at the same time???
danielalien 7 months ago
@danielalien Marco has actually 4 legs (and 4 arms) but you can't see them cause he's too fast
sexypoulpe 7 months ago
@danielalien if you watch this /watch?v=ANxVWgBELZA you can see he has mad hi-hat to kick pedal transition skillz
vidfreek 7 months ago
@danielalien he tilts his feet at a funny angle so the heel is on one pedal and the toe on another.
Look for his solos with the footcam.
gnsumas 1 month ago
They should do this with the guitars!
HandofMisery 8 months ago
Fuck. Yes.
MrShtsweak 9 months ago
I want to kill and eat Marco Minnemann, just so I can attempt to gain his power.
DraytonAJohn 9 months ago 30
@DraytonAJohn You're a weird person you know that?
ImLo0u 3 months ago 3
@DraytonAJohn
Could you please wait till after 30. april, because i really want to see him play with Steven Wilson. :) After that you can do what you want with him. :D
Odinsgade 1 month ago
@DraytonAJohn Pft!, all you will get is a bad cae of overratedness, eat some Kollias, true power lies in his legs.
85Aheadstix 1 week ago
He's even better than Chuck Norris!
Nightcrawler874 9 months ago in playlist Drum solos,interviews and drum covers
does he imitate mangini's solo style or am i too mean about him? double basses with crashes and the ending tune!
emptytrashcan 9 months ago
@emptytrashcan Yeah the thought occurred to me too :P
CelestialTina 9 months ago
i think that this guy is one of the most versatile drummers ou there and thats what makes him so special !!!! thumbs up marco minneman !!! lmL
infirmusisdrums 9 months ago
Why the hell is there only one green thumbs
Factoriellepi 9 months ago
Hannes Grossman and Romain Goulon are good drummers who played for Necrophagist but Marco shits on them 100 times over.
KHfan4ever23 9 months ago
this guy is paul gilbert on drum Lol
:P
norranun 10 months ago 3
@norranun hah i think he plays in the same band as paul gilbert, racer x
Morain42 9 months ago
the guy at the end is great
mattderose 10 months ago
Marco and Mangini..i can't decide!!
deathscythekim729 10 months ago
Buddy looks like Napoleon Dynamite, but damn he can drum.
PoeticJustice05 10 months ago
1000 steps up to mr portboy!
alexyellow 1 year ago
Amazing! I like how they did the camera work similar to Ginger Baker's drum solo in Cream's farewell concert video. Good stuff.
adi93das 1 year ago
I am a huge fan of Dream Theater, but i have to admit Minnemann eats Portnoy on breakfast, lunch and dinner!!!!
Malikuniversotomb 1 year ago
I love the groove at the 5:00 mark.
ajmckillop 1 year ago
ppl saying things about dream theatre and portnoy. i don't get it, marco is way better than portnoy :/
MAYLO777 1 year ago
absolute perfect choice for dream theatre!!!
blowmyroot 1 year ago
I feel like his feet aren't fast enough to do what Portnoy does.
YourDailyLaughz 1 year ago
Sick, and I thought the only guy who could replace Mike was Steve Smith. How wrong can I be? lol
valermos08 1 year ago
is tom green on the drums!
crazygring 1 year ago 2
Ah, and at 9:14 is THE metal face of 2011! (Although this is older footage :p)
iCe1984zz 1 year ago
Unusual tom setup, very interesting. Looks very weird though. But he has a weird style ;)
Typical Marco solo, but very different from the other solo's of him I've seen. I like it!
iCe1984zz 1 year ago
Agreed Slash! This guy would be (will be) great
guyetcj 1 year ago
use Octoban x MTPOLIS PT1 6 OO ETC
betobareto 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Rev > this guy
PanasonicYouth1349 1 year ago
@PanasonicYouth1349
Did your parents drop your on your ears when you were little? Saying the Rev is better than Marco is like saying that Kerry King is a better guitarist than John Petrucci.
doooomination 1 year ago 2
@PanasonicYouth1349 good one bro! haha good one!
MrLosfuegos 1 year ago
@PanasonicYouth1349 Flame War Attempt FAIL lol
shred440 1 year ago
drops his left stick at 3.05. i honestly believe roman guolon smokes this guy
viralbheda 1 year ago
so is he the drummer for necrophagist or was he just doing a solo? i only knew about hannes who left for obscura.
Jrim615 1 year ago
@Jrim615 Taken from Wiki; ".. Marco toured with death metalists Necrophagist on the Summer Slaughter tour 2007 .."
MikePostDrums 1 year ago
I agree, the perfect drummer for DT!!
matslundq 1 year ago
I think him playing with Jordan later this month is a sine he is next in line.... which is a good thing! Oh and can any of us make a PDP sound that good?
olisofsunhillow 1 year ago
Comment removed
olisofsunhillow 1 year ago
Chemistry 101 - Mix the most fantastic pieces of every awesome drummer on the planet together, and you have a vial of nastiness that can only be named Marco Minnemann. I salute you...
IceShadow333 1 year ago
All I can say is Woooooooooooooooooow!
KanuomleStudios 1 year ago
perfect drummer to fill the shoes of mike portnoy!
slash17rockz 1 year ago 46
@slash17rockz 100%. He has creativity AND chops down pat, with a very fitting style for DT to boot: a combination of musical elements that virgil, lang or any other I can think of do not have that would be suitable for the band. the guys from DT would be crazy not to pick him.
tmayne220 1 year ago
@slash17rockz
yes one of the best alternatives i think. but i don't know if he can sing and play like mike... otherwise, why shouldn't he, his coordination is incredible, singing at the same time should be no problem
MetalJaska 1 year ago
@slash17rockz ohhh, that would be awesome
artha5 1 year ago
@slash17rockz never :(
45pantera 1 year ago
@slash17rockz I agree totally! I would love to see what he could do to their music! They need this kind of man for a refresher!!
bazzman666 1 year ago
@slash17rockz I totally agree! I would love to see what he could do to their music! They need this kind of man for a refresher!!
bazzman666 1 year ago
@slash17rockz funny thing he now is going to fill portnoy's shoe's ;) I discussed it with other fans aswell before something was said about he being the next Dream Theater drummer, he is just the right guy
hellsing1983 1 year ago
@slash17rockz I think so too! One of the best prog. drummers, i've ever seen.
MoercelK 1 year ago
@slash17rockz Portnoy's shoes are too small for this guy.
rockslavesoft 10 months ago
@slash17rockz
Absolutely!
Nightcrawler874 9 months ago in playlist Drum solos,interviews and drum covers
@slash17rockz well apparently not lol... they chose mangini... but seriously a crazy drummer
bodomtopps 5 months ago
its the chops of buddy rich with the technicality of dennis chambers or virgil donati, mixed with the metal of george kollias or roddy. he is definitely on of the greatest drummers top three no doubt.
dallyson 1 year ago
@dallyson you forgot the independence of Terry Bozzio!
artha5 1 year ago
Comment removed
IceShadow333 1 year ago
Polyrhythms, swing, lightning speed, hair-splitting timing - what CAN'T he play! And a nine minute drum solo that never gets boring...
jcopen 1 year ago 2
He is the man.
depoistedigo 1 year ago
wow
blister1324 2 years ago
One of the greatest drum solos I've ever seen.
Love the stick thing @ 8:45
zeroskater133 2 years ago
yeah i saw it in concert and it blew my mind hes the best drummer in the world in my opinion, and NECROPHAGIST FUCKING OWNS!
psycroptic66 2 years ago
Why am I the first to comment on this!!, This is one of the best drum solos I've seen. Jesus Fucksacks!! Minnemann you are incredible.
GrooveThumper 2 years ago 32
@GrooveThumper cos the people doesnt understan this and prefer the drumming of lars, joey, or travis and thats sad
Kudan26 1 year ago
@GrooveThumper
No need to to use Jesus' name with jerk trashtalk like this. Elevate yourself to something better.
beyondonethousand 7 months ago
@beyondonethousand Go fuck yourself christfag.
Psycho888999 6 months ago
@Psycho888999
I will laugh when you rot in hell. Have a nice day for now.
beyondonethousand 6 months ago
@beyondonethousand I'm currently laughing at you sucking jesus' tiny jew cock.
Psycho888999 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Psycho888999
May the Lord avenge His Name against you.
beyondonethousand 6 months ago