Added: 1 year ago
From: MiDiVP
Views: 27,147
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (110)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I LOVE HER!! SHE IS ABSOULUTELY AMAZING!! REAL VOCAL ARTIST!!

  • 2:36 is that Usher???

  • i don't like..

  • A real singer shouldn't have to belt their face off like a cat to be recognized as a good singer.

  • @jayckubwoyeek How funny.......... on another video of Siobhan, someone said "she sings too soft" Well.................... The truth is, she can sing it all, and. awesomely. Check out her video of Somehow, Someday. In this song, you will hear her do quite a range of expressions that'll just blow you away

  • @VioletFlameMusic I just checked the video out, not really my bread and butter. I'm currently getting my Bachelor of Arts in Musical Theatre, so this isn't just coming from some random person. Then again it is just my opinion so it's subjective, I enjoy watching her performance in this video much more than her acting. Some of her vocal habits just bug me.

  • Comment removed

  • just because you CAN hit the high notes doesn't mean you should.....

  • When she belts really high it sounds really annoying

  • WOW! She has an incredible mixed voice!

  • Umm did she win!!! She is amazing!!! ??

  • how is it really even possible to belt out notes like that?

  • @maddog8757 afaik: it's with the help of abs. :)

  • @Fl4dd3rm0uz and 10 years of practice :P

  • She's fuckin beautiful! If she had wiast length hair, I would love to have her as mine, but even with short hair, she's pretty gorgeous!

  • @michaeldriggers123 Paint it Black by the Rolling Stones.

  • She sounds like Erykha Badu when belting those incredible high belts!

  • Comment removed

  • song at 1:28?

  • HOLYY SH*T !!!! ADAM'S SOULMATE AROUND THE TOWN !!!!!!

  • 0:53 WOOOAAA!!!!

  • my favorite notes in one video awesome XD

  • LOL I thought the title meant she was going to sing an A 19.... :D

  • ADAM IN A FEMALE VERSION?

  • I love this so much! when I showed this to my man, he said "wow. the person that put this together knew what they were doing." I definitely agree with him. I love the end, where you can hear her beautiful singing and there's so many pics of her smiles. it's sooo touching!

  • Well, it doesn't matter to me if people doesn't enjoy her performances cos thats none of my business really and neither do I want to know that you don't like her performance cos for me, I enjoy her performances the most especially in the seasons of guitar singers where the sound of guitars bored the whole show after sometime. She's the unique and fun I found during that season. I hope I can hear more of her materials!

  • A year later....Yep! Got me too and I'm almost 70. Thought I'd seen all her UTUBE stuff but somehow missed that one.

    The creator of that piece should be very proud. Technically it was very good. More importantly, it did what most videos only try to do, it captured the person, the free spirit who won our admiration, our awe and our respect, Siobhan Magnus.

  • i really really really missed HER!!!!

  • i'm usually not THAT emotional, but near the end where you hear her singing "through the fire" and it shows all of the pics of her smiling, and the caption says to keep the smile on her face, we should keep voting....it totally made my eyeballs wet lol. and then to make it even more special it showed Ellen with the "more please" lol

    

  • Siobhan Magnus is The best. . ! ! !

    No Doubt!

  • Cyndi Loper type of soprano. She is a super soprano very very high soprano!

  • Voice wise, it was an absolute no brainer. Could you really see yourself paying money too see/hear any of the other contestants? I mean really, I am going to see her band if/when the next time they are in Atlanta.

  • she should try out now cuz steven tyler and her could hav a scream duet

  • @Bella23rd  lol totally.

  • i luv her but after a while the screams got old

  • she's yelling and full of sharps

  • I agree in saying that Lee Dewyze shouldn't have won. Many women just thought he was attractive and, therefore, voted for him. Also, I thought it was so stupid when the judges saved Mike because he clearly was not the best. Is it just me or did his wife give birth every week?

  • @bhubba01 yea cause i dont see lee out with any music he peopbley did but i think nobody really knows about idk y he enter if he dont got songs out really i agree with u

  • She could get a new award...Best AI has ever seen...whether she won or not! Keep Rockin Sweety!

  • She has a annoying voice. She is not a Star. If you can hit the biggest high notes ever, It doesn't mean that you have what it takes to be a recording artist. Face IT

  • @sdogar1000 U R clueless! who do U like, Beyonce?

  • @generationaluv NO, I Like The Most Talented Singer In The Whole World, The Best Performer, ADAM LAMBERT!!

  • @sdogar1000 I dont know what American Idol you were watching. Last yrs was the saddest AI has ever been. Siobhan was the only thing interesting ab the whole season. Look @ Lee Dewyze and tell me you see star quality there? I didnt think so.. Even w/o the high notes Siobhan was awesome and most def shld have won!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Like the Female Adam Lambert!

  • I wanted her to win!

    And im from mexico!!!!

    After she left the show,i didnt watch it...She was different,witth a huuuge voice,we dindt see since patti labelle,AND U KNOW WHAT I MEAN...I just hope somebody can help her and make a career

  • I love Christina AGuilera and Siobhan Magnus, BOTH EQUALLY AMAZING SINGERS! that's talent!

  • I fucking love her! MY GOD!

  • goosebumps.

  • she is legit amazing. scream Siobhan, scream!!!!!!!!! :D

  • Comment removed

  • nice ending.. cuz studio version of TTF is awesome.

  • great video! can you please extend this video, including the rest of her AI performances, "suspicious minds", "house of the rising sun," "across the universe," "any man of mine," etc. ?? then it would be the perfect siobhan tribute vid.

  • shes soo good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • As soon as she was kicked off we swore to never watch Idol again...and we didn't! Siobhan was by far the best all year!

  • She is going to be HUGE. Don't you worry. She just needs the right cultivating with some great song writers and producers. She's going to be a legend. =) God willing. I love her mind, her sound, and her heart. She's a really deep, compassionate, unique girl...

  • Did she really have to belt up into the 5th octave during every performance? Not necessary. I love her voice though

  • @l0os3nup Not necessary of course, she just loves to do it and that's who she is as an artist. She's a high belter and loves all styles. Judges couldn't figure that out but that's who she is.

  • SCREAM ON!

  • OMG! i thought! she was still on ai and no w that i see the comments i realized that she got kicked out!...i mean...she was clearly the best singer out of them all u know!...she was my favorite since the beginning i thought she was going to win the whole thing...but i guess americans are all about looks and carisma, so they didnt saw all her potencial focusing on her vocals u know...not so many white girls can belt that high.!

  • @oo0o0opss i think she was cheated...... thousandsssss of her votes went to Arron.....finally i got kicked off AI insteadof Arron........cheeezeeee

    noone believes that a idol with over 35.000.000 votes can be droped out of top 6 easily......hates Simon and Kara.......

  • @chibimaruco too bad u know...i really think she is unique!...whos that arron guy anywasy?...the guy with the famous smile?...i hate him anyways!

  • @oo0o0opss and she has charisma, and looks good... silly americans..

  • @osahju914 well, I am AMerican, but I think Siobhan is stunningly beautiful, sexy, lovely, sweet, and the best singer this show has ever had...even better than Carrie Underwood!

  • @generationaluv me too, I was referring to the americans who voted her out.

  • @osahju914 I knew what U meant...it's cool! anyone who recognizes Siobhan is the coolest in my book! Keep rockin with Sexy Siobhan!

  • @oo0o0opss She doesn't have what it takes to be an Idol. She is not what American needs. Do you find a star in her? I don't think so. She came every time on stage as a singer who wants to become "American Idol" instead of an Artist wants to entertain the World.

  • she sends chills down my spine:)

    i miss her soo much. she was amazing.

    and simon lovedd her. thats amazing! lol i wish they could have saved her.

  • what happened to the american population ?!

    (cant wait for your album siobhan ! ! !)~~~~

    ~~~~~~siobhan obsessed

    ~~~~~~addicted to high notes

  • If Fat Mike had gone home in 9th place like he should have, the judges would have saved Siobhan...this girl is one of the best to ever grace the idol stage hands down.

  • @joshholt87 exactly what i thought.

  • @joshholt87 Exactly! 12. Lacey Brown 11. Paige Miles 10. Didi Benami 09. Michael Lynche 08. Andrew Garcia 07. Tim Urban 06. Siobhan Magnus (Saved) 06. Aaron Kelly and Katie Stevens 04. Casey James 03. Lee DeWyze 02. Crystal Bowersox 01. Siobhan Magnus!
  • @dslite804  Wow, that's exactly how I had it pictured too!

  • @joshholt87 Fat Mike LOL.

  • @joshholt87 ahahahahahahahahha "Fat Mike" Its "Big Mike" But i totally agree ;DDDDD

  • @joshholt87 No, she's not. only hitting the high notes doesn't show what you can do. I comepeltly agree with America, they made the right choice by sending her home.

  • @MrAD123AD Haha! How did you know? Sorry, I actually prefer musicians with talent. Not someone who rides on the fact that can attempt notes like that. Sure it's ok the first time. Maybe the second. But not in every fucking song they perform. It's old and sounds terrible.

  • I am so mad that Siobhan Magnus went home she was the best idol i think to ever that grace that stage in a while but it is what it is i guess because she is going to make it vocally for sure and artist wise she is okay I think

  • Too bad she couldnt talk or think...or do anything thats reflective of what an "idol" should be. She was ok at singing, but horrid at being a performer / interviewer.

  • she's amazing! shame she got voted off=[

  • LOVE U SIOBHAN!

  • @MrAD123AD Obviously. But they are just stating how they feel. And rightly so... She's terrible.

  • just not always good. I mean....not in every song girl lol

  • i like her screamXD

  • god damn i'm absolutely amazed by this girl, not only she's beautiful, she has MAD VOCALS. she's an absolute powerhouse WOW !

    Keep screaming Siobhan!! Love you !

  • She is amazing i keep getting goose bumps wheneber she sings

  • Great! I hope she wins!

  • I THINK SHE SHOULD SING "FANTASY" by EARTH WIND AND FIRE....THOSE NOTES IN THE END SHOULD FIT HER WELL!!

  • nice vid :)

  • shes NEEEDS to start picking better songs, she picks really randoms ones that dont suit ever since paint it black, shes peaked too soon prob luv her though

  • I haven't stopped voting for her, and i won't until she wins.

  • i love siOBHAN

  • she doesnt only scream, she hits the notes!

  • I LOVE THIS VIDEO!!! It expressed the exactly same feeling with me who are not American, BUT CRAZY WITH HER!!! She really really have to win. Indeed.

  • American needs to vote for her to win !

    She is the only saving grace for this season !

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i think she sucks

  • She has the potential... but she also has to learn when to scream - be more creative! (Like adam ..? lol )

    Simon said it himself, those screams always at the end are getting boring...

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more