Funny she talks about cultures. In Tagalog salamat po is thank you. It stems from the Persians, who said salem (originally meaning "regards"). Later it would mean peace; Indians integrated their culture into the Philippines. Spain would come and integrate the idea of you meaning elder, I think. Po means elder. History repeats itself. Integration means respect. When in rome, you say thank you rome.
Did everyone know that this woman makes the most amazing cookies to ever grace this little planet? Go get her cookies there insane!!! AND THANK YOU LAURA!
The reason you don't ask for praise is because you want it to be SINCERE, and if you ask, people will say it simply because you have asked, not because they appreciate what you've done.
That doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out. <_<
yeah but that doesn't seem to be enough for most people. the raw appeal of christianity [before it's symbology was sucked dry by anyone with ulterior motives and a printing press] was/is that it seems to offer a mechanism by which to synthesize a route to closure of whatever they feel is holding them from simply being.
the sun doesn't shine on every being; some are still too afraid to come out of the trees.
Nope but the moon and stars do, it just that these repent dudes splash a load of guilt around that is just cultural taboos from a by-gone age, that are needless if God requires anything of man its to have a good laugh, and if you've ever had a individual experience of Universal Love You will know that all the littleness you send it all your shames and guilts it just Loves totally unconditionally and that is one thing that finally brings you to your knees in tears of gratitude.
you haven't answered my question, which god are you talking about? zeus, apollo, thor?
Want to experience "universal love" (whatever that means), just take heroin. Are you saying people should take heroin and other drugs? seriously, where are your morals?
You sure are one agressive person rationalcrash. I am not saying peple should or should not do be have anything. What I am saying is that those who spread guilt around are just deluded. As for Morals its who you choose to be in the moment that counts. the god I talk about is that All that is both seen and unseen ever present now. Personally I call that Chief cos I am a irreverant child, and the Chief kinda likes irreverance beats the crap outta those pious bastards who preach repentance.
discussing morals and ethics is good, but why bring in any talk about (almost certainly) non-existent deities? It isn't just the religious guilt spreaders who are deluded; it is anyone who is dogmatic and has faith. Ignoring reality (that is what faith and dogma do through ignoring evidence) is one of the biggest problems.
i disagree, my rugby coach used to ride me if i didn't do something right, pointing out every flaw till i got it right. very rarely did he actually praise someone. he pushed me hard but it helped.
and also by thanking people rarely it added far more when he actually did praise you. a quiet nod or a pat on the back for a good piece of play would mean far more than if he thanked me for every time i didnt trip over my own feet or drop the ball.
by over using it, praise would loose its importance.
But you do not have to over use it. And you do not have to say only "thank you" and add nothing else. It has to be meaningful; you have to say "thank you for doing this or being this way", and you have to actually feel that you are grateful. Because if you fake it, trust me, it will be detected.
you are right, I did misunderstood your comment and I appreciate that you helped me understand you. and the "pat on the back" or the "nod" thing sure is meaningful. non verbal communication is in most of the cases better and truthful.
I find this sort of strained new-age namby-pamby twisted logic to be another symptom of a lack of acceptance of the limits of human freedoms and powers.
One must wait for praise, and not be in such a rush, lest he knock the value out of the generousity of others.
Agreed homerthompsonman, the kind of approval and acknowledgment we naturally seek as people is not what we're going to get if we follow this woman's advice.
Once you ask for a certain kind of praise or attention, it's no longer an unprecipitated, genuine act on the part of the other person. This may be temporarily cathartic but will only reveal itself to be unfulfilling in the long run.
I think you're missing the point; it is not to ask for some kind of recognition that the person asked wouldn't feel is justified. Instead it is to ask for some kind of recognition that the person wouldn't give on his/her own accord but still feel was warranted. Perhaps because the person felt it wasn't imported enough to mention or to be appreciated. To express the fact that it would be appreciated or that it is important is -I think- a good thing to do.
Well, I think you might have missed the sublty of my comment.
When someone asks for flowers, they are not asking for something the giver feels is arrented in getting. But the mere fact that ACT first (ask for flowers) takes something important away from the act of giving flowers. After all, the giver might have had it in mind to give flowers or something else, and now the potential future act is tainted the by IMPATIENCE demonstrated by the potential receiver.
It's selfish to make someone wait for something they require so you can feel like you gave it for the correct reason. In that instance, you are not giving so they can feel something. you are giving so you can feel something. And that is probably why they need to ask in the first place.
A gift of flowers is not a requirement. Gifts can be things that are needed, but that is charity. I am OK with people asking for things they need. What I am NOT Ok with is people who want to muddy the waters and try to make all desires into needs. That is marketing 101: turn the desired object into a NEED and there will be social leverage.
Flowers, and other mementos, must come from the giver as a surprise. That is part of their charm.
IMHO It's more important to voice our appreciation and gratitude for the small things, than to ask others to do it for us. If we don't do, we have no right to ask for it. If we do it first, nine times out of tent people will reciprocate.
[Part II] All you're doing is trying to artificially increase your self-esteem by soliciting a positive value judgement from someone else. And because most people are pushovers, they'll probably apologize for not properly showing their appreciation, and from then on will "thank you" constantly for even the smallest favour you do for them. So you'll just be getting false/forced gratitude.
[Part I] Why should I have to -ask- another grown adult to thank me for something I've done? If I've done something for someone that truly deserves his praise, either he'll show his gratitude in some way - even if it's not by directly saying "thank you" - or he won't show any gratitude, and I'll know not to do favours for him anymore. But asking someone to thank you is emotionally immature.
thank you in advance for the great job you're going to do in fixing the audio video sync that all the viewers and subscribers are looking forward to and commenting about. testing the power of thank you....thank you, thank you, 1,2,3
dont you think that if you ask someone to praise you in one or another way, when they do you will feel like it is not a genuine praise? wont you feel like they are just saying it to make you feel better? i would! it wouldnt work for me and i think it wouldnt work for most people so thats the reason why people dont ask for what they want to hear, because they want to hear it coming from that person not as an echo bouncing back from a wall in front of them.
Yes, I agree with you to a point. But like the person you commented just before you, some people don't know how to be appreciative and letting them know that it would be nice to have some feedback or even gratitude for one's work for that person, well that could be a great life learning experience for that unaware and unappreciative person.
Good question. Idk. I guess its for ppl who don't realize they aren't being appreciative. But even then doesn't make it it genuine, but it could if the person is that clueless.
is this meant to be an unfiltered presentation, as is the TED of my experience, or a thinly veiled NOKIA corporate message... there is no distinct line between sponsor and presenter.. and it is hard to say how one is meant to relate to the other. JTU
This seems so unlike TED --the audio is substantially out of sync with the video. I would encourage the user account managers to take down this and upload a corrected version. It is a great message and deserves a good presentation.
I'm afraid that if I ask for what I need or would like to hear the person I'm asking won't really mean "Thank you" or "Well done" but they will simply be saying by rote what I told them to say.
Great stuff...will give it a try asap!!!
thethirdq 6 months ago
Funny she talks about cultures. In Tagalog salamat po is thank you. It stems from the Persians, who said salem (originally meaning "regards"). Later it would mean peace; Indians integrated their culture into the Philippines. Spain would come and integrate the idea of you meaning elder, I think. Po means elder. History repeats itself. Integration means respect. When in rome, you say thank you rome.
amazeblaze 11 months ago
she was expecting a standing ovation
stickybelvedere 1 year ago
Thank you, Dr Laura. Simple but inspiring talk. Resonated within me. I knew i needed to hear this and practice it!
drdollars77 1 year ago
Did everyone know that this woman makes the most amazing cookies to ever grace this little planet? Go get her cookies there insane!!! AND THANK YOU LAURA!
inspiredmoda 1 year ago
Thank you , that does feel good ;)
derman077 1 year ago
Fix the audio on this video kthnx.
digitalheir 2 years ago 5
"if you have to ask, you'll never know." -louis armstrong.
nerdyharry 2 years ago
(additional verse) "funky mother fuckers will not be told to go" - anthony kiedis
if u have to ask, u'll never know! :)
HuckleberrySlim 2 years ago
This is ridiculous!
The reason you don't ask for praise is because you want it to be SINCERE, and if you ask, people will say it simply because you have asked, not because they appreciate what you've done.
That doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out. <_<
molewizard 2 years ago
the audio is a little off from the video, but.....thank you
lol
HuckleberrySlim 2 years ago
haha, I finished the video and was like "what is wrong with my computer..." then I saw this comment, haha.
Glad it's not just me!
Thank you! (haha)
CPeyser08 2 years ago
Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins. Acts 2.38.
Jedidiah960 2 years ago
God doesn't care what you do God's love is unconditional, like the sun shining on every being.
iamcrazydave 2 years ago
yeah but that doesn't seem to be enough for most people. the raw appeal of christianity [before it's symbology was sucked dry by anyone with ulterior motives and a printing press] was/is that it seems to offer a mechanism by which to synthesize a route to closure of whatever they feel is holding them from simply being.
the sun doesn't shine on every being; some are still too afraid to come out of the trees.
nerdyharry 2 years ago
which god? zeus? apollo? shiva? (isn't shiva the destroyer?).
P.S. the sun doesn't shine on gophers and worms or on people at night.
rationalCrash 2 years ago
Nope but the moon and stars do, it just that these repent dudes splash a load of guilt around that is just cultural taboos from a by-gone age, that are needless if God requires anything of man its to have a good laugh, and if you've ever had a individual experience of Universal Love You will know that all the littleness you send it all your shames and guilts it just Loves totally unconditionally and that is one thing that finally brings you to your knees in tears of gratitude.
iamcrazydave 2 years ago
you haven't answered my question, which god are you talking about? zeus, apollo, thor?
Want to experience "universal love" (whatever that means), just take heroin. Are you saying people should take heroin and other drugs? seriously, where are your morals?
rationalCrash 2 years ago
You sure are one agressive person rationalcrash. I am not saying peple should or should not do be have anything. What I am saying is that those who spread guilt around are just deluded. As for Morals its who you choose to be in the moment that counts. the god I talk about is that All that is both seen and unseen ever present now. Personally I call that Chief cos I am a irreverant child, and the Chief kinda likes irreverance beats the crap outta those pious bastards who preach repentance.
iamcrazydave 2 years ago
discussing morals and ethics is good, but why bring in any talk about (almost certainly) non-existent deities? It isn't just the religious guilt spreaders who are deluded; it is anyone who is dogmatic and has faith. Ignoring reality (that is what faith and dogma do through ignoring evidence) is one of the biggest problems.
rationalCrash 2 years ago
praise won't turn you into a pussy...
bajawind 3 years ago
i disagree, my rugby coach used to ride me if i didn't do something right, pointing out every flaw till i got it right. very rarely did he actually praise someone. he pushed me hard but it helped.
and also by thanking people rarely it added far more when he actually did praise you. a quiet nod or a pat on the back for a good piece of play would mean far more than if he thanked me for every time i didnt trip over my own feet or drop the ball.
by over using it, praise would loose its importance.
punkslashhippy 3 years ago
Dont tell me, you trained for the texas cowboys or the buffalo bills, otherwise why would he ride you?. ROFL I am so innocents
kubikmaster 3 years ago
But you do not have to over use it. And you do not have to say only "thank you" and add nothing else. It has to be meaningful; you have to say "thank you for doing this or being this way", and you have to actually feel that you are grateful. Because if you fake it, trust me, it will be detected.
Wamuigi 2 years ago
i think you misunderstood my comment, the power words/actions have comes from how and when you use them.
if i told every girlfriend i ever had that i loved them, it wouldn't mean as much when i said it to my future wife.
if you use a word/phrase sparingly it has more impact when you eventually do use it.
punkslashhippy 2 years ago
you are right, I did misunderstood your comment and I appreciate that you helped me understand you. and the "pat on the back" or the "nod" thing sure is meaningful. non verbal communication is in most of the cases better and truthful.
Wamuigi 2 years ago
its alright mate, have a good life :D
punkslashhippy 2 years ago
I find this sort of strained new-age namby-pamby twisted logic to be another symptom of a lack of acceptance of the limits of human freedoms and powers.
One must wait for praise, and not be in such a rush, lest he knock the value out of the generousity of others.
homerthompsonman 3 years ago
No: the reason people don't ask for praise is the same reason girls don't ask for flowers, If you have to ask then it wasn't a genuine expression.
We want praise, we crave it, sure, but deep down we know if we only get it after asking then it just not quite as valuable.
You wanna "true" your fucking wheels stop listening to namby pamby pap like this.
I am sorry TED, but this one is not worthy of praise.
homerthompsonman 3 years ago 2
maybe another way of saying this is that you may thank people, instead of waiting to be the one receiving praise;
so that, instead of waiting for something, you are the first to give it away.
And when you give it, you often somehow don't care that much of getting it anymore.
tutubi49 3 years ago 3
Agreed homerthompsonman, the kind of approval and acknowledgment we naturally seek as people is not what we're going to get if we follow this woman's advice.
Once you ask for a certain kind of praise or attention, it's no longer an unprecipitated, genuine act on the part of the other person. This may be temporarily cathartic but will only reveal itself to be unfulfilling in the long run.
ezmorningrebel 3 years ago
I like it when people agree with me! And I find I am even more pleased to find friends of philosophy out there.
Cheers ezmorningrebel! Here is to the examined life!
homerthompsonman 3 years ago
I think you're missing the point; it is not to ask for some kind of recognition that the person asked wouldn't feel is justified. Instead it is to ask for some kind of recognition that the person wouldn't give on his/her own accord but still feel was warranted. Perhaps because the person felt it wasn't imported enough to mention or to be appreciated. To express the fact that it would be appreciated or that it is important is -I think- a good thing to do.
a87fhj 3 years ago
Well, I think you might have missed the sublty of my comment.
When someone asks for flowers, they are not asking for something the giver feels is arrented in getting. But the mere fact that ACT first (ask for flowers) takes something important away from the act of giving flowers. After all, the giver might have had it in mind to give flowers or something else, and now the potential future act is tainted the by IMPATIENCE demonstrated by the potential receiver.
homerthompsonman 3 years ago
It's selfish to make someone wait for something they require so you can feel like you gave it for the correct reason. In that instance, you are not giving so they can feel something. you are giving so you can feel something. And that is probably why they need to ask in the first place.
funkyandfree 2 years ago
A gift of flowers is not a requirement. Gifts can be things that are needed, but that is charity. I am OK with people asking for things they need. What I am NOT Ok with is people who want to muddy the waters and try to make all desires into needs. That is marketing 101: turn the desired object into a NEED and there will be social leverage.
Flowers, and other mementos, must come from the giver as a surprise. That is part of their charm.
homerthompsonman 2 years ago
If you fixed up the audio everyone will thank you.
declan3906 3 years ago 21
how come the voice doesnt match the vid..
popitypop 3 years ago 3
thank u
danielslzhou 3 years ago
Thank you!
jaymas2 3 years ago
thank you
Punniabi 3 years ago
What the hell is up with the A/V lineup? Dang, I was really looking forward to hearing this.
elreysincorona 3 years ago
go to ted . com for all tedtalks in high quality.
georgemargaris 3 years ago
testing the power of thank you to fix the audio. testing: thank you, thank you, one, two, three......testing...
rotatingwah 3 years ago
This is such a great TED talk. I wish they would fix the audio.
stephenetienne 3 years ago
IMHO It's more important to voice our appreciation and gratitude for the small things, than to ask others to do it for us. If we don't do, we have no right to ask for it. If we do it first, nine times out of tent people will reciprocate.
akylae101 3 years ago
I completely agree. Except for the 9 out of tent. Haha. :P
sighuponsigh 3 years ago
[Part II] All you're doing is trying to artificially increase your self-esteem by soliciting a positive value judgement from someone else. And because most people are pushovers, they'll probably apologize for not properly showing their appreciation, and from then on will "thank you" constantly for even the smallest favour you do for them. So you'll just be getting false/forced gratitude.
UzbekUkuleleist 3 years ago
"thanking" you is overated
i'm just fine with seeing someones face light up on gratitude... im more than enough payed with that
Organell 3 years ago 2
[Part I] Why should I have to -ask- another grown adult to thank me for something I've done? If I've done something for someone that truly deserves his praise, either he'll show his gratitude in some way - even if it's not by directly saying "thank you" - or he won't show any gratitude, and I'll know not to do favours for him anymore. But asking someone to thank you is emotionally immature.
UzbekUkuleleist 3 years ago
another great TED speech thank you
reivilo 3 years ago
thank you in advance for the great job you're going to do in fixing the audio video sync that all the viewers and subscribers are looking forward to and commenting about. testing the power of thank you....thank you, thank you, 1,2,3
rotatingwah 3 years ago
^^^lulziest comment of the day.
BoozyBeggar 3 years ago
dont you think that if you ask someone to praise you in one or another way, when they do you will feel like it is not a genuine praise? wont you feel like they are just saying it to make you feel better? i would! it wouldnt work for me and i think it wouldnt work for most people so thats the reason why people dont ask for what they want to hear, because they want to hear it coming from that person not as an echo bouncing back from a wall in front of them.
iosuVakerizzo 3 years ago
Yes, I agree with you to a point. But like the person you commented just before you, some people don't know how to be appreciative and letting them know that it would be nice to have some feedback or even gratitude for one's work for that person, well that could be a great life learning experience for that unaware and unappreciative person.
stephenetienne 3 years ago
Asking someone for thanks is like asking someone for love. Unrequired if you know the answer and unresolvable if you don't.
Please fix the sync. Thank you.
namlhots 3 years ago 2
If you have to ask for a thank you, then what makes it genuine?
guitarguy93 3 years ago
Good question. Idk. I guess its for ppl who don't realize they aren't being appreciative. But even then doesn't make it it genuine, but it could if the person is that clueless.
sighuponsigh 3 years ago
Great message/talk. Horribly out of synch audio. Not what I have come to expect from TED.
norfboi757 3 years ago
is this meant to be an unfiltered presentation, as is the TED of my experience, or a thinly veiled NOKIA corporate message... there is no distinct line between sponsor and presenter.. and it is hard to say how one is meant to relate to the other. JTU
usonianUHF 3 years ago
thanks!
matshroom 3 years ago
fix...
pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeee
swyft187 3 years ago
Love it.
Justen 3 years ago
This seems so unlike TED --the audio is substantially out of sync with the video. I would encourage the user account managers to take down this and upload a corrected version. It is a great message and deserves a good presentation.
Thank you. :)
Ch2Diacorda 3 years ago 24
Here here.
blath 3 years ago
I'm afraid that if I ask for what I need or would like to hear the person I'm asking won't really mean "Thank you" or "Well done" but they will simply be saying by rote what I told them to say.
Elaina43 3 years ago
way out of sync
abigor315 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I wonder what she'd say about FUCK YOU.
Treknologist 3 years ago
Waaaaaay out of sync
Matty14388 3 years ago
Out of sync.
wolverine005 3 years ago