the last 55 seconds were without a breath... as it was saktah before that is arguable but this shaikh has many many years of years and practice and to say it is impossible is nonesense.
الله الله الله الله الله الله اللهوكمايقول له احد المعجبين بقوة وحلاوة صوته يابطل الجمهورية وهويقصد انه الاول فى التلاوة بين اقرانه وكلهم فيهم الخير ولكنه المنشاوى
even raffat hussein .. i listen to his reciting .. it's clear that they took some tiny breaths .. i asked expert in sounds about this .. ( في مواضع السكت في الكلمات يأخذ نفس قصير كي يعطي الحنجرة طاقة )
@mhidmi , listen to him reading fatiha he never takes any short breaks like minshawi , listen to him then u can belive that breath can reach more than a minute , god bless you , even if he does take a breath , thats not the thing , the thing is what have you learned from this reciting , he wanted to represent quran in a better way to us and so he did, forgive me but he deserves more than you have given him.
maybe not, because he read according to riwayah of khalaf from hamzah (the quran that we usually read, the popular one, is according to riwayah of hafs). Therefore, the break between the sencentes were "saktah": that you cannot take a breath during the pause
yes i'm well aware of the different riwayahs of the quran. But he doesn't do sakt, because he stops on fatha tanweens. Besides, even if he doesn't take a breath during the pauses, the melody is not very complicated or breathtaking to pull off.
correct abdussamad used to do it , but not as much as minshawi did
there are seven readings of quran and this is one of them , and it requires long breath , and it is not always gifted to them , they train for that for years
maaşallah barekallah
tuncaydilmac 1 year ago
mashallah very good!!!!!!!!
truly is a very long breath and i belive there is no breathing takeing place in the recitation:)
huzaifadahmed 2 years ago
the last 55 seconds were without a breath... as it was saktah before that is arguable but this shaikh has many many years of years and practice and to say it is impossible is nonesense.
qarishahg 2 years ago
الله الله الله الله الله الله اللهوكمايقول له احد المعجبين بقوة وحلاوة صوته يابطل الجمهورية وهويقصد انه الاول فى التلاوة بين اقرانه وكلهم فيهم الخير ولكنه المنشاوى
ايمن خليصى قطر
aymanalansary 3 years ago
no breaths i was there
12345kab12345 3 years ago
no .. it is impossible , he is breathing, he cant , and it is clear that he takes small breaths
mhidmi 3 years ago
@mhidmi , ok i suggest u listen to sheikh rafat hussien
MohamadZabin 2 years ago
even raffat hussein .. i listen to his reciting .. it's clear that they took some tiny breaths .. i asked expert in sounds about this .. ( في مواضع السكت في الكلمات يأخذ نفس قصير كي يعطي الحنجرة طاقة )
mhidmi 2 years ago
@mhidmi , listen to him reading fatiha he never takes any short breaks like minshawi , listen to him then u can belive that breath can reach more than a minute , god bless you , even if he does take a breath , thats not the thing , the thing is what have you learned from this reciting , he wanted to represent quran in a better way to us and so he did, forgive me but he deserves more than you have given him.
MohamadZabin 2 years ago
allahu ekber sallu alen nebiy maşaallahu barek allahu le havle vela kuvvete illa billah kesiyran ya allah allah ya allah maşaallah allahu ırza aleyk allaaaaaaaaahu ekber kebiyran vahiyden ehaden sameden lem yetthiz sahibeten vela veleden allahu ekber huuuuuuuuuuuu mesut
insantusem 4 years ago
he breathes, it's impossible to go that long without taking a few breaths.
m03ez 4 years ago
may be reight... thanks my brother
muhibbumustaid 4 years ago
maybe not, because he read according to riwayah of khalaf from hamzah (the quran that we usually read, the popular one, is according to riwayah of hafs). Therefore, the break between the sencentes were "saktah": that you cannot take a breath during the pause
alfatihawordpress 4 years ago
yes i'm well aware of the different riwayahs of the quran. But he doesn't do sakt, because he stops on fatha tanweens. Besides, even if he doesn't take a breath during the pauses, the melody is not very complicated or breathtaking to pull off.
m03ez 3 years ago
the first two were not, but after that it is saktah.
alfatihawordpress 3 years ago
correct abdussamad used to do it , but not as much as minshawi did
there are seven readings of quran and this is one of them , and it requires long breath , and it is not always gifted to them , they train for that for years
MohamadZabin 2 years ago