Added: 3 years ago
From: bryant313
Views: 64,140
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (267)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The beauty of RUSH...One of their most beautiful songs...

  • The band needs to re-master this one next, into a nice 5.1 suuround dvd CD.

  • flourishes and accents ? Really?

  • Well I won the Guitar center drum off in 1995 in So Cal...I can play "Natural Science" to a T which is harder than this song. I did not say I could not play it. It's seeing other drummers try to play it...That say they can. They get the Hi Hat part right. But the right foot 5/4 then 6/4 is where they cant hang-You got the 6/4 & 5/4 backwords..Listen to the kick drum. 12345-123456

  • @JCAUPS1 i never said you couldn't play it lol, i'm just saying that if you've never seen another drummer do it, its probably because they couldn't get the 11/8 time signature with all the flourishes and accents correctly, my point was to just get time signature down and be able to play it correctly, then work on actual syncopation

  • thought prevoking song awsome

  • OK from 3:13 on to be specific

  • I been playing drums for over 20 years and I have never seen a drummer play the pattern at @2:50 correctly...Drummers say they can play this song until they get to 2:50 and fall on thier ass. I would like to see a video of drummer that can play this to a T

  • @JCAUPS1 the song starts in 5/4 time signature and the part you're talking about doesn't sound particularly difficult, maybe the syncopation is hard to get down, but during the part that starts at 2:50 the beat altenates between 6/4 and 5/4 every other time, so its like 11/8... and after that at 3:56 it goes to 6/4 ... and the rest of the song is in 5/4 and 4/4, hard to play, yes, but count it out and then practice and it shouldn't be too hard to learn it, or at least it worked for me

  • @21Rushisaband12 Nope your'e right it is 6/4 than 5/4 had to go play it.

  • I love a song with not one but multiple stories to tell ,I love the line "sadder still to watch die than ever to have known it"we all go through growing older and wishing we had been somewhere or done that something special and just never having the time or means to do it and by the time you do you're physically unable.I've always wanted to hang glide at Jackson hole but with 4 children and life tasks,you get the drift.Rush is a one of a kind.

  • Some are born to move the world

    To live their fantasies

    But most of just dream about

    The things we'd like to be

    wow

  • One of Rush's best songs

  • Beutifull, this song is awesome and always will be!!!

  • This song reminds me so much of my Father, he was a teacher and spent his whole life shining light into the lives of others, he was the smartest man I ever knew and his knowledge was amazing. Now he has alzheimer's and only rarely is he the way he once was.

  • @karlmoles65 respect to you and your dad , thank god for music which gets into your soul .

  • @Jazzawray Thank you, and amen to that.

  • @karlmoles65 your welcome, have a listen to a song called long, long , long, by the beatles, not a well known one but one of their best , a beautiful number .

  • @Jazzawray Not a bad song at all that, thanks.

  • It's not my favorite but Signals just might be Rush's most perfect album.

  • it is a fact that Rush got me through the 70's , The Beatles have got me through the noughtys i love them both more than i can say .i especially love this song .

  • @Jazzawray Rush has helped get me through three decades now.

  • this tune made me learn electric violin....its still one of the best EV soloes ever....even after 30 yrs

  • Comment removed

  • This is an amazing well written tune....Awesome!!

  • 2 people have lost it, or really never had it!

  • That song motivates me to do things while im young and can..

  • Ive been thinking of the most perfect words to describe this song,,,, I give up!!

  • @NickMialzzo688 wierd. I'm feeling sad and lonely and I'm just getting sadder

  • This song always makes me feel better when I'm sad. I don't know why. It's just a beautiful song.

  • this still gives me goose bumps even after all these yrs and i thank my perents

    for having me in the 60s so i could grow up in the best music era and in a time when tracks like this were writen and produced to last forever

  • Is there any RUSH song that sucks?... ONE? ... RUSH is one of the greatest bands of my lifetime. They belong up there with U2 for this generation... An amazing band!!!

  • @Jaxboxing they blow away u2 and every band thats ever played...lyrically and musically there has never been a band like RUSH

  • in my opinion their best song, simply perfect . 

  • 1 person is losing it

  • I've sat here for an hour already, playing this song over and over again.

  • Losing it is so profound

    

  • I think either you get this song or you don't. Listen to the lyrics.

  • Completely-Honestly: I walk around believing I'm "The One" often, yet Neil Peart is like a sleeping fox, he writes the lyrics and drums as if he has 2 minds and 8 limbs. Chris Martin of Coldplay may just be a distraction...I'm thoroughly intimidated by Neil. Please don't "usurp" my candy Neil.

  • This song reminds me of homework...

  • Man, how I love this song. You didn't hear it played alongside their hits, but the lyrics, music, and sentiment is priceless. Nothing like an epic band with brains and bottomless heart.

  • RUSH plays the music of my life, the rhythm of my heart. This song in particular is so moving...! I love you guys!!

  • LIke bands like Roxy, Talk Talk, Joe Jackson & their fans, Rush & we fans don't give a shit what self-absorbed pretentious criticts think. We're not snobs, we simply recognize something-a bit more so to speak. More important we feel what they're playing & what they're trying to convey. As a young aspiring artist I could "feel" exactly the emotion they were creating my 1st listen. If anything, now I only feel it more deeply, especially where the frantic race against time starts about 2:40 in.

  • @redfishradical I couldn't have said it better myself. What a beautiful comment.

  • @TenderCrusade Thank you very much, I appreciate the compliment!

  • Rush consist of the best musicians of our lives,,,Rolling stone also rated Steve Perry the lead singer for Journey #76 best rock vocalist. ????? Rolling Stone should only line bird cages....

  • @ghostman758 Yeah and they probably voted Bob Dylan #1. They don't appreciate the great progressive rock and AOR bands of the 70's / 80's

  • bell tolls for thee

  • rolling stone named neil peart one of the WORST lyricists of all time (#2}

    that really makes me wonder whats up with them?

    its like their trying to talk people out of listening to it

    WHY?

  • LOL, consider the source! Do you think anyone puts any stock (at all) in what the knowledgeless queerbaits @ Rolling Stoned magazine say? Listen to how deep and meaningful Peart's lyrics are, and then listen to just about ANYONE elses' and when you're done laughing.....

  • @roman14032 That wasn't Rolling Stone, that was Blender Magazine, which has absolutely no musical authority whatsoever...

  • Not your typical Rush song, for sure! Second part inspired by the last days of Ernest Hemingway's life. Note the 2 literary references to him.

  • i might as well say it. i miss my youth.i miss all the good times and music.no cell phones or computers.no fuckin nothing .i miss that.

  • This song is just breathtaking. The solo makes my soul feel like it's screaming, trying to escape my body.. It's shame there's so many people in the world who don't appreciate such beautiful music..

  • I know every chord change and lyric to every Rush song. I've probably heard each one over 50 times, and my most enjoyed travks over 100 times.

    This and La Villa Strangiato are my favorite songs of all time.

  • I wasn't a big Rush fan until I met my husband whose a drummer and idolized Neal Peart. I gained a whole new respect for the band of 3 that produces the amazing music that they do. This song is amazing!

  • The truth to this song is amazing. Hemmingway would be honored...

  • I played this for my dad today, and he said, "son, i never imagined i would listen to this with my son." I am 18, My dad is 42.. nuff said....

  • @Wingfieldr i'm 12 and my dad's 46. we both love rush. :)

  • @FuyuAkiWorld this is the great thig about rush...my dad, mom, and uncle loves rush. me and my brother love rush. my children (hopefully) will love rush. their greatness spans generations.

  • @Wingfieldr my dad always the retrospective tapes in our car, and as a kid, all i knew where those rush songs, me and him were always huge fans, then i drifted away from rush for a few years, but then i re-listed to those tapes and got hooked again, then i got their entire discography and actually introduced him to this song, now he loves it, along with many other hidden gems we've found... i'm 18, my dad is 58... so, likewise, nuff said....

  • @Wingfieldr Freaking beautiful man. I'm proud of you and i don't even know you.

  • I love how this song has a semi-Pink Floyd feel with the saxophone sounding part. Overall great song by my favorite band.

  • @RoCk4LiFe90 It's an electric violin. The musician is Ben Mink ;-)

  • @SuperLobwedge Oh I never knew that, thanks

  • @SuperLobwedge Electric violins are interesting...I believe Kansas used them too.

  • LOVE THIS SONG

  • Que musicos de otro nivel mi banda favorita sin lugar a dudas ARRIBA RUSH!!!

  • its good, considering its the second-to-last good album(grace under pressure) before the disaster of the 80's.

  • While this song is not a great example of what Rush sounds like, it is prob my favorite song by them. Although what is Rushs' sound? Also, the waltz after the solo is uber rush!!!

  • a very beautiful song but very scary too, i think its about alzheimers

  • @lunasea71

    Not necessary, My father in law lives with us now, he is 77 and he used to be able to lots of things that he can no longer do. I see it in his eyes when he gets mad. He wants to help, but just can't. But I respect your view as well.

  • non possum oblivisci hujus carminis, quod cantat tristiam inevitabilem.

  • Algunos nacen para mover el mundo para vivir sus fantasías

    Pero la mayoría de nosotros sueña con las cosas que nos gustaría ser

  • 0 dislikes

    RUSH IS AMAZING

  • One of my high school yearbook quotes was from this song.

  • how the hell is rush NOT in the rock and roll hall of fame!!!!!!!!!

  • @mikesweet69 - It's an absolute travesty is what it is!!!

  • how the hell is rush NOT in the rock and roll hall of fame!!!!!!!!!

  • I used to think Alex was playing a guitar synth on this song.lol

    Signals just gets better with age. Underrated but excellent album.

  • Absolutely beautiful! :'D

  • One of my Rush's fav...songs...absolutely great !!!

  • what did ben mink do?

  • @bassist1100 Ben Mink is a producer, and also an avid violin player. All the electric violin on this song is Mink's work, and it makes me want to get an electric violin so badly.

  • I've always loved this song since the first hearing of it. Beautiful!

  • Ben Mink is incredible!

  • "Some are born to move the world

    To live their fantasies

    But most of us just dream about

    The things we'd like to be

    Sadder still to watch it die

    Than never to have known it"

    - how true, especially the last two lines

  • Signals is Rush in the greatest part of their synthesizer experimentation phase... and this song is a prime example of the fruits of that period.... great, and very under rated.... I would drop to MY KNEES if they ever played this in concert ....

  • one of the most underated songs i've ever seen

  • The violin was played by a guy from the band FM, which opened for them on the Signals tour. Can't remember his last name, but his first name was Corneilius. Very good band.

  • After seeing them at the o2 in london on wednesday  brilliant as always but i wish they would play this live :(

  • Best Rush song in my opinion. Overall just phenomenal, and I agree with you Twinkiepoodle lol

  • I have loved Rush for many years and did see them live in the 90's. What a great show.

  • I love how the guitar part in the chorus mimics, but doesn't overshadow the vibe of this song! And then...FUCK! Electric violins!? Mozart couldn't have farted a better progression! PURE GENIUS.

  • Damn, this is depressing...

    Great song.... but...holy crap...

  • My second favorite Rush song after "Red Barchetta"

  • can totally relate. slowly going deaf..

  • Electric violin FTW!

  • Love a lot of Rush songs, something about this one makes me love it most.

  • neil peart is a master with lyrics , what a song this is . ive loved them since i was 16 which is many years ago now .

  • @Jazzawray

    Me too 43 now, first heard "Moving Pictures" and was hooked. Peace

  • best song ever

  • I'm analyzing and writing a presentation for these lyrics for a poetry project I'm doing for a lit course. Listening to them over and over makes me wonder if i really want to do what I'm going to school for, or if i should pursue my real passion no matter how unlikely it is that I'd be successful.

  • Alex's desperate sounding guitar solo....crying out with tears of rage is the perfect compliment to Neil's lyrics. I was a boy of 15 when this was released and thanks to their masterful work even I with my whole life in front of me felt what it was like to lose it.

  • Niel incorporates so much into his lyric. He speaks to the lonely, the frustrated. The trodden. But he also gives hope. Direction and Grace to the listener. And the mastery of what Gary and Alex do to bring that feel out in music, makes this a MUST not miss band. We're going this month!

  • One of RUSH BEST SONGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • One of RUSH BEST SONGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This is one of those rare, absolutely perfect songs. The interplay of the guitar & electric violin at the end and their building crescendo, the increasing urgency of the drums, and among the best lyrics one of rock music's all time greatest lyracists has offered; all add up to a true & ageless masterpiece. I'm usualy one of those who rips the rampant hyperbole in world pop-culture now. But honeslty, I find this even more brilliant than the 1st time I heard it years ago. Rock as high art...

  • @redfishradical Well said my brother

  • @redfishradical - Couldn't have said it better!

  • I turn 50 this November...I share this video with my teen high school students...

    Make your lives memorable...

    Do something!!!

  • So am I the only Rush fan that has this on their favorite Rush playlist?? With a really high spot to boot!

  • @TheGuitarman355 Naw I love this saw it's up there me as well

  • ben mink inspired me to play electric violin...

  • I read in Neil Pearts book, Ghost Rider, that the lyrics " sadder still to watch it die, than never to have  known it" Are from Ernest Hemmingway!

  • @jblan131 - sure, the bell tolls for thee... absolutely. Huge thanks to my high school English teacher who had me spend the bulk of my junior year dissecting Rush lyrics.

  • @j1simple so lucky you got to dissect Rush lyrics in high school in this day and age we don't get to experience that level of intelligence in high-school

  • Oh, my...! How many times in my life have I quoted this, "sadder still to watch it die, than never to have known it..." ! - I die for this song, truly.

  • 135 likes, 0 dislikes. Yes!!!!

  • When this album came out, New World Man, Subdivisions, and Analog Kid got all the radio play; I bought the album and discovered all the other tracks, like Chemistry, Digital Man, the Weapon. This track is definitely different from all the rest. This brings me back to when I was a teenager. I think none stirred me as intensely nor emotionally as this way under appreciated piece. I chose to come on youtube to hear it, but also to see what others think. It's great that others feel the same way.

  • may 19 th got ticket my super brother bought me for crimbo been listening to rush since (shit) 1977 and if i listen to this tune after not listening to it for a while i am a jibbering wreck

  • this song is sad, yet hauntingly beautiful..........

  • The guitar solo at the end is my favorite guitar work of all time...

    Even more than Pink Floyd's "Shine on you crazy diamond"

    Signals is their best album in my opinion, coming close with Farewell to Kings

  • just wanted to inform the guitar at the end is mostly an electric violin played by Ben Mink

  • EU PROPRIAMENTE FALANDO E PENSANDO COMO UMA BANDA CHEGA A ESTA QUALIDADE SONORA DE GRANDE QUALIDADE E COM PRAZER QUE ESCUTAMOS UMA HARMONIA DIVINA QUASE CELESTIAL ,marcus vinicius - portugal - lourosa

  • one of the best Rush songs ever!!!!!!!!!Bri Guy the Drummer Guy....

  • I saw diz tour @ da gardenz MLG in YYZ, 1zt row floor centre wen I wuz 15yrz old n I still put er az me FAVOURITE concert.

  • perfectly said, twinkiepoodle

  • Sign into your facebook and type Juno Awards and

    Vote for Rush New World Man from the Signals album as favorite song

  • Any of Rush's albums are arguably their best album! 

  • @golfdom1987 I agree. I can honestly say I LOVE them all. There was a time when I thought a particular album might not have been what I though it should have been. I know now that it was ME that wasn't ready to get it. I look back at ALL of them and I see them as important chapters in Rush history book as well as my own. I can't wait for the next chapter!! LONG LIVE RUSH!!

  • @Lydirius I know exactly where your coming from, been a fan and listening to Rush for a long, long time, couldn't or didn't get Test for Echo or Vapour Trails at first, now I can't stop listening to them, aswell of course to the unparalelled back catalogue of their music/albums, 2011 should be great year for all Rush fans with the release of Clockwork Angels, simply cannot wait!

  • RUSH is far away the best Canadian band ever

  • I love the outro of this song ,It hits me hard but the downside is that the producer thought it would be a good idea to do a volume fade out right when the Outro Synths hit at 4:37 . That's when I need it the most too hear those Synths which conclude the Mood of the song. I wish it was extended and didn't fade out. A similar Outro Fade when I need it the most happens on Beauty School off of Deftones Diamond Eyes Album.It fades the guitar outro right when I need it the most

  • This solo is amazing Alex Lifeson underrated guitar god

  • Rush does two things that other bands don't: create masterpieces, and put meaning to their masterpieces.

  • Luckily with the science of hormone replacement therapy, this song will never have any meaning in our future lol. Just ask Stallone

  • love this .... even though a more rather 70's rush fun, have to say, this is sublime

  • Rush is that band that makes me feel like there's something more mysterious, mystical out there. And that you go searching for it.

  • OH my God. My whole life existance has been Rush. No other band can make me feel the way they do or change signatures like they can. This is my favorite record cover of all time. I'm such a private person but the truth of me has come out, anyone who really knew me or sees my face at their shows can see the love and how much they move me.

  • This song has never been played live. I wish it were.

  • Hemingway and other great writers lost to suicide...age takes us all

  • i was diagnosed with MS in 2004, since then i sold all my googys vette, z/28, bike but it took me years to sel l my Tamas. since i can"t play my beloved rush i figured why frustrate m yself. i will listen to rush for all the time i have left. the song "losing it" has a special meaning for me.God bless all you guys out there who "get it" long liverush and all you guys Ric/Gazoo

  • @exdrummercauseofMS Be strong my brother. I willl pray for you. Go see Rush 2nd row Apr 12 in Chicago and be cured.

  • @exdrummercauseofMS Be strong my brother. I willl pray for you. Go see Rush 2nd row Apr 12 in Chicago and be cured.

  • I feel this song ....

  • Wow i havent listened to this album in forever. Reminds me why i love it. Long live rush

    

  • how do u make videos like this im new to youtube

  • this is one of their best songs on one of their best albums

  • classic by the band who inspire me everyday of my life

  • I can't even believe how hauntingly incredible this song is.

  • @Crust218 And I cant belive that the last time Ive hear was like in 2005 or 06, no clue exactly. Breathtaking.

  • saddest thing. ever.

  • Lyrically, the "writer" is supposed to be based on Ernest Hemingway.

  • i gotta figure out how to play this song

  • Love this song :) Always have!

  • Rush is musically, the best band ever. Peiod.

  • @undertakerfreak1127 - I couldn't agree more!

  • Alex Lifeson is the most under rated guitarist ever

  • @zachgcarvalho - You are 100% right about that!

  • I've been listening to Rush for almost 30 years. I love'em. I've seen them live on every tour since Hold Your Fire. But to say they're bigger than the Beatles is absurd. I can think of dozens of bands influenced by Rush. But what band was NOT influenced by the Beatles? What music lover does not have a favorite Beatles songs. What human doesn't know a Beatles song. The only people who'd say Rush is bigger than the Beatles are children and adults with their hands on their ears.

  • @kellermoon Dude, the Beatles are overrated to the max. Deal with it.

  • Very good!

    One of the only songs that captures Geddy's voice perfectly along with heart full of soul(album) and others.

  • I've always wondered-is the solo guitar or keyboards?

  • @12guitdown Electric Violin. I know, very strange for Rush