Added: 3 years ago
From: hopexza101
Views: 291,515
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,023)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She was born to be a star. She can sing. She still looks hot. Her career is smoking. She was a child in high school. Her career blew up. She is rich. Haters to hell.

  • @Buckeyecat2002 What Do You Mean Haters.?

    She Couldn't Sing, She's Way Talented Now Because She Had Couching.

  • @khalid305786 She was naturally talented at an early age. Most people cannot stand on a stage, open their mouths and have melodic words come out, in front of an audiance. She had help from Jay Z, who is worh 1/2 a BILLION dollars and can afford anything his client needed. Anybody who is anybody had some coaching and mentoring. Success begets success. Professional singers professionally record, market and sell music. Rihanna is no exception. I hope this helps.

  • terrible!!!!

  • this bitch can't sing or dance

  • bad bad bad bad ! bitch has no voice

  • Lol, what the hell?

  • she sounds amazing, bet you cant sing like that.. love you baby.. @rihanna:****

  • Yeah but they purposely take the piss out of the fact she cant sing on TheLonelyIslands making her sound even more electronic lol

  • Even the autotuned stuff she sings nowadays has a nasally quality that leaves me cold.

  • that shows you that the industry dosent want real talent anymore. Rihanna's successful and famous and can't sing one bit.

  • it can't be true

  • y'all go watch the whole video. The cunt who made this video is being a scum showing her mess up. She's famous, successful, and makes a lot of money. What exactly are you doing? Goodbye you unsuccessful, hateful DUMBASS.

  • @yesimcool101 No need to use such hateful language.

    Listen to Marlena Shaw and Gloria Jones and Aretha Franklin if you'd like to hear some genuinely nice female vocal talent with depth and soul.

  • @tactictoe and and and, crikey I just wrote like Willow spoke in American pie. I should have used a comma after Marlena Shaw eh? :)

  • for a 15 year old with no vocal training WHATSOEVER I think she did pretty damn well with a challenging song like this. Plus you have to remember, she was young, and performing at school. She was probably really nervous, or she might have had an off day. I don't think she got up their without practicing the song first intentionally trying to embarrass herself. So instead of looking at the bad why not give credit where it's needed. She's HUGE, very talented, and beautiful. Stop hating cunts.

  • @yesimcool101 -Amen. There seem to be a bunch of bathroom shower singers/Rihanna haters offering their critques. Broke people cannot teach millionaires how to make money, only how to be broke. SINGER Rihanna is worth @ $ 75 MILLION dollars, 2012. Somebody likes her singing.

  • cant the guy just shut up ?! :D

  • lol, that was rather horrific

  • *best

  • i went to her loud tour concert and she really isnt a bad singer live. She gives a great show, and considering she's running around singing, she can't be perfect. She's not the bet singer out there, but back then her voice wasnt matured yet, and she had no training to work on her vocal range. Basically if she hadnt tried to kill the song she wouldnt have been so sucky.

  • Man lets face it, this is bad, bery bad. She didnt have the voice to sing it then, and she still hasn't. She is not a good singer, she is a commercial singer...Well, pop music dont really requires good singing anyway...

  • LMAOO!!

    And people have made this talent-less HO a hit??? People need to get their ears checked...xD

  • serious i like all her songs.. but she can't sing... you only have to listen to this video.. 

  • i like rihanna music but i tell everybody all the time i would never see her in concert or buy her cds, because her live performances suck and to know that her voice is probably embellished to the max is a turn off

  • Well, now I know... I still have hope xD

  • She Cnt Sing she never culd nd she jus get she vice autunee i frum barbados proud ass bajin butt wenn i 2 wa she does do 2 'promote de country' nt tink it need promoteinn

  • she cant sing here :/

  • wait .....has something meant to have changed?

  • and she has 10 number ones, wow , she sucks,

  • SHE SOUNDS LIKE BEYONCE HERE!!!

    BEYONCE AND RIHANNA ARE ON THE SAME LEVEL VOCALLY...

  • @QueenSitiNurhaliza Haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa....Hilari­ous....Rihanna Will NEVER Be VOCALLY On The Same Level As Beyonce'.....NEVER.....YouTube Beyonce' At 15 (No,No,No) Or Even DC's First Album, Many Songs On The Album She Was 13-14 Singing....I.E., "Second Nature", "Bridges," "Tell Me" Amongst Many Others & She Doesn't Sound Like This Goat....

  • @BeyonceSoloStar NOPE - STILL SOUNDS LIKE BEYONDGAY KNOWLES

  • omg,she was really very nervous,totally out of tune

  • ALL CREDS TO JAY Z, HE FOUND HER AND COACHED HER, and she did wonders for def jam records. who wouldhave thought then, someone sitting amongst the audience, what a great singer she will be.

  • that was not that bad x) It may be a little false, the sound was just not developed and professional, she still had a great sing voice. I mean, I would be happy if I could sing like that lol :D

  • that was not that bad x) It may be a little false, the sound was just not developed and professional, she still had a great sing voice. I mean, I would be happy if I could sing like that lol :D

  • What was she doing at the end CTFU! who ever made this video is just mean tho because in the beginning of the song she sounds really nice she just had major issues with the higher notes. People wonder why Rihanna is famous? Well because she has IT she is the IT girl the industry doesnt give a damn about Talent all they care about is Looks and Rihanna is pretty girl and she has something different and that is what got her to the top so people stop hating! Talent doesnt matter anymore! 

  • dayum even i can sing that better than her she sounds like she is sick

  • America, these are the people you consistently make your superstars! People with mediocre to absolutely no talent whatsoever! You are buying into their fashion and looks, not talent! The music business is the only business in the world where you can be number one or on top of your game for NOT being superior at music or singing and that's a really sad commentary about how far our expectation and taste has fallen, when it comes to music!

  • weeee.....todo el mundo quiere cantar esa cancion hauhahu nadie como mariah nadie...!!!

  • @MrTulio20045 POR LO MENOS DEMOSTRO QUE CANTA BIEN IGUAL NO??? MEJOR QUE BRITNEY POR LO MENOS JJJJ

  • Ohh boyy

  • hahahahahahahahahahah!!!

  • This is sad. People say she sounds better now and blah blah blah. Even though I believe that is NOT true. Shouldn't she have enterned the buisness with talent instead of getting her vocals trained. It's like they put random people in the studio now in days. -.- It's sad when you see much better people not get what they deserve and shits like this get to live it up.

  • The only artist that can really sing now is Beyonce. And probably Christina Aguilera. Other than that everyone else needs the studio. Whoever said looks don't matter was a damn lie because if Rihanna was ugly no one on this earth would pay to hear that girl live.

  • Wow u guy's are Really fucked up ....

  • Omg Whoever Made This Video Is Terrible. Because When They Showed The Ond Rihanna Singing First Of All Thats A Very Long Song And people Mess Up Nobodys perfect not Even Rihanna, Okay, So You All Need To STFU Because I Highly Freaking Doubt Any Of You Can sing Like That. And If You Watch The Whole Video Of Robyn Singing Hero She's Really Good Until She Gets To The End. Then Her Voice Wears Out.. Face It That Happens. So All Im Saying Is Respect her Because Look Where The hell She is Now!!!!

  • @SiennaSimz There are many non famous people who have covered the song and sound amazing. Rihanna sounds HORRIBLE. She sounded horrible through out the whole song. Just because you like her you should see the obvious. People who are younger than she was when she sing this can carry out the hold song wonderfully. Rihanna just sucks and thats that. She sounds the same now. Her live performences always suck.

  • @ScarleteBabe Look, I Wasn't Saying Anything Bad, Like Most Of TheseJack Wagons.. And Im Happy With What I Said. And That That. So As I Was Saying She's Famous Now And You Aren't So Its Not Your Place To Judge.

  • @SiennaSimz I don't care if I'm not famous. Being famous doesn't mean your life is better. And I know you weren't saying anything bad. Just like you spoke your mind. I did the same thing.

    I'm not judging I speaking the obvious. If she can't sing she shouldnt be in the business.

  • i think my ears just vomited o.O

  • she sounds horrible lol

  • PLEASE CHECK MY COVER PLEASE  youtube.com/watch?v=m_yxUXIknT­g.

  • That juss TOOO BADDD. No hero there!?

  • america.... where you could be the worst singer and make millions of dollars

  • uh wtf just happened here

  • God I was just listening to her performance on Bilboard awards, it was the same bad as this. horrible,she shouldn`t sing

  • this isn't the real video she didnt sound like that for real...like damn i saw the real episode, if u gone bash someone be real bout yo shot

  • WOW dat was terrible thank god she sounds A LOT better now

  • @Controversy102 lmao WHAT?

  • Me: *finishes watching video* It wasn't that bad.

    My mom: Hun, what did I tell you about lying?

  • the difference now is that she has a better voice and she makes part of the fucking Illuminati , the conclusions are that she's a fucking bitch

  • the ending...like i was begging her to stop

  • Waw she still sounds the same

  • LMAOOOOOOOOOO

    SHE SUCKED! xDD

    She is so much better now xD

    she probably had some vocal lessons.

  • that proves she wasn't chosen for her voice ...

  • ....who was that?????????

  • @oritesane1 yeah but when i here rihanna sing live she sounds good still

  • what????????????? no smh

  • Man she killed that song literally

  • Comment removed

  • Skinny!

  • lmfao!!!

  • how did she get so good now ?????

  • @Samuel115s she didn't...

  • lol.. this is pitiful.. the real video is titled "Miss Combermere 2004 Hero RIHANNA ( by Mariah Carey)"

  • her names not rihanna!!!!!!!!!

  • i was there, she did it amazing her last falsetto note wasn´t in this video but live was amazing, now she can´t sing but there she could

  • *Robyn Fenty

  • SMH MOST OF THESE SINGERS CANT SING FOR SHIT TODAY ..kesha , lady gaga , rihanna , katy perry ,justin bieber ......nameless ..

    all the great singing in the 80's and 90's , 70's and so on are LONG GONE .. i feel bad for some kids today , that dont know their music ... soon they would think singing is image and singing badly... thats why i think there is sumthin evil behind the music industry tody .

    put rihanna next to mj , aretha franklin , and all those GREAT SINGERS . they would #BLOW ..

  • @andrej1195 Who the hell would hate on her with a voice like that? She sounds no different today. It's so bad no one has to alter it.

  • i jus listened to the original...it did not sound like this...it wasnt perfect but this vid was edited..........

  • @aha00002 pish u must be a 'ri ri' fan the stupid wee girl cant sing for shit, she just gets her fanny out to sell songs music died 20 years ago and the crap thats out today is all sweeked in studio's to sound good!!!! dont get me started on 'live shows' when they dont have the mike up in to the crowed saying you all know the words its all eeeehhh yeeeehh yeeeeh!!!!!!

  • @CapitalCityScumbag hey you can have your negative opinion about her as an artist or whatever but i was commenting on THIS video...they altered it

  • "murdering a Mariah Carey song" - yup she's murdering the song ALRIGHT hahahaha

  • ---and she still can't sing today! XDDD

  • Very Pitchy

  • She can take SOME notes!

  • practise... when you have nothing else to do

  • 0:11 i sing better then her in the shower!! 0_o

  • still way better than me.. 0.0

  • ohhaaaa, take the paint hahahhahhahahahhahah

  • HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HAHAHAHAHAAH

  • Kill it with fire!

    

  • ok wow ! if u look the actual video up ---> (rihanna singing hero at age 15) she sounded incredible at the begining ! but at the very end her voice gave out it happens to everyone ! all yall hattin ass people like really get a damn life! rihanna is a talented and amazing singer i mean like damn i kno she not a nigga but but why yall all up on her dick !

  • Omg, this can´t be rihanna!?!?!? D8

  • y were dhey clappinqq??? nd she still has dha same voice itz just dhey edit her voice.its some sad stuff dhat she dont ghot no talent

  • @imani457 Your writing skills is the same as her singings skills.

  • @lunar112 itz called slang luk it up

  • Not much has changed

  • @KenElizabethFilms Exactly!!

  • i have to admit, she was pitchy. but she can sing NOW... she obviously trained her voice to get more control because i have seen her live a few weeks ago and her voice is phenomenal.

    at least she had a dream and followed it... what are you guys doing to pass your time? oh yeah, bagging on other people who are successful. sad.

  • @Faceb00kAddict

    Yeah' that's right.. and you guys.,..You are so. sad.. -.-'

  • I HOPE THIS BITCH ROTS IN HELL

  • bwahahaha people on here are ruthless with their comments.she is hot but she is way overrated if not for the booty poppin and skimpy clothes she wouldn't be half as famous.

  • well, you must admit, a lot of singing today comes from being able to entertain and keep consumers' attention. take, for example, britney spears, i doubt she can realllyy sing without her moan-reliant stuff, or katy perry, she i just facisnating and fun, and other, i would name more but i think it's time i stop putting in soo much effort into a youtube comment

  • ugh she can't sing for nuttin

  • Errybody is all like "She can't sing" ect,

    I'm just thinking, WTF HER REAL NAME IS ROBIN FENTY?

  • @Rachfothermucker lmaooooo

  • @Rachfothermucker Rihanna is her middle name.

  • @Rachfothermucker

    LOLL SAME HERE BUDDY....

    

  • wow . that was bad . shit hasn't changed

  • maybe it was just nerves:)

  • You have to start from some point.

  • rhianna was NOT 24 in this video. 

  • @xKRiiTiiKaLx Lol even today she still can't sing that whats her octave range 2

  • I'd give her a record deal. :|

  • It's clear that at 15 her voice needed a lot of work when switching to the upper ranges, but she had a good basic tone to start with and she sings live 90% of the time, so we can all hear she has good vocals now! As far as tallent goes, well..... There's a lot worse out there!!

  • ahw money can make fame. heres some proof! look what they did to rihanna.. Some ridiculous expensive singing lessons, harmonizer, an image (or alter ego) and a personal trainer. put jays face near the person and voila. star is made.

  • lmao

  • like a nightmare

    poff

  • she isnt as bad as he is making her out to be

  • @XxAnnaCx were you listening? lol

  • @benherne01 yh XD ok i listened to it a couple of times it is quite bad but she sounds rly nervous give her a break xDDDD 

  • She started good.. She was not bad at all. she just got tired. 

  • rihanna is a hack...like most pop stars today shes a pretty face in a package with a big mouth. no talent. 0 talent.

  • she sounds horrible singing that mariah carey song

  • Yeah, u said everything...she was 15...she is so much hot now, i dnt care about her voice, Mariah sounds bad for me too...and she is a toothpic

  • @kalariosmeufilho lol..how could mariah sound bad for u? lol yeah u r more interested in singers getting hot n slutty n stuff rt? so u dont know real music

  • On behalf of the rest of the world who can hear we apologize Mariah that ur song was butchered in such a cruel way.

  • hahahha

  • Lest just say She Improved :]]

  • swear she's worse now.......

  • thank you?rrmmm.... Rihanna, you wanted to say " I'm sorry"? :/

  • What happened to this Rihanna?

  • I think 0:59 - 1:03 is awsom

  • she is better now still not the best voice but she is a great performer... makes good songs as well, but this goes to show u dont have to be able to sing like mariah to become famous..def who u know and how u get noticed!

  • omg this is so awful.. make old chezza sound good :)

  • wow :|

  • lmaoooooooooooooooooooo!!! ok this IS hilarious .................

  • This is what happens when she tries to belt. This is why she doesn't sing ballads, just fun sounding or regular pop songs.

  • Her voice still takes amazing it has that amazing sound about it

  • woah seriously?

  • Idiots it has NOTHING to do with age!!!! so many singers had a beautiful voice when they were 8 and even younger!!! its called naturally good at singing she is NOT a good singer not even a good entertainer she sucks!!

  • i think people are giving her too much credit for being 15 you can blame it on puberty all you want but you know the truth

  • Loooooool. Thank God for auto-tune.

  • @cutietboo lmaooo!! AMEN lmaooo

  • No as in wth? lmao this is just O.o

  • No as what the hell lmao no stylz this is just ).0

  • oh dear god 0:45 :O

  • Yeah, not good- at all. Then again, she was still in the ages of puberty.

    Anyway, I'm not too experienced myself, but check out my channel. I doubt my voice sounds anything like that..not to be conceited. Haha.

  • she has TREMENDOUS potential. it's until after she got signed that she learned how to control her powerful and wonderful voice.

  • lol! "We are terribly sorry for what we are about to show you"

  • Her producer basically said she looked like a hot piece, so he signed her despite the lack of vocal ability. Sorry to be crude, but that was the deal. She's still no songbird. She's a pretty girl who looks great in makeup and clothes, but she's studio magic. And if you can stay awake through one of her live performances, you're better than me. But they say she's a nice person.

  • She was 15 at that time and her vocals were weak. But her vocals are stronger now

  • lol, this gives me hope :')

  • wow this is funny

  • "ahh take the paiin."

    i love this shit! how could 75 ppl not like this? if this was anyone but her singing it would have a million views and been all over tv clip down shows.

  • @Batiste369 and simon would say: " it sounds like a cat jumping from the empire state building".

  • it say she was 15.

    and she really can sing.

    maybe she was nervous.

    search rihanna sings acapella

    and shes great!

  • lol yall wrong 4 tht

  • KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

  • she doesnt sing in any of her songs, she just says shit obviously and hits like one note thats fkn ez

  • Obviously she picked a song thats not meant for her voice and vocal range. all this proves is that shes got nothing on mariah carey's vocal skills, which makes no sense to compare the two in the first paly. snow if she murdered a britney spears song, then you got something! So yeah she needed plenty of practice and training now shes a great singer

  • even it sounds awfull, you can feel that she really has potential. she just needed more practice and confidence! and look at her now :)

  • i did not expect she can whistle. She needs more practice

  • @stanbalo she cannot do the whistle! what you talking about? that was screaming!

  • Oh NO .this is AWFUL ...damn she messed that song up ...