omg so hes doing shows at the 40 watt club, theyre sold out but im still thinking about driving down to georgia anyways just to sit outside and listen with my eyes closed
i sometimes think that jeff is some sort of musical alien. i cant think of anyone who makes music like his, its otherworldly but deeply human. i dont fucking understand, but then again, im not sure im supposed to.
There is no other band in the world that can create a sound as rich and pure and honest as the music they create. This, in it's most unadulterated form, clean and fresh, is what gives music its true name.
I love this song, too bad it was never released on their studio albums, so many lost gems I never discovered until recently because I had stuck only to their 2 studio albums and didnt explore any of their EPs, Demos, or live stuff which featured songs not on Aeroplane or Avery Island.
Good sir, you have just paired two of my favorite things: Neutral Milk Hotel and silent films. I salute you! (By the way, the clip fits perfectly with the song! Good job!)
Well, if you've ever been depressed, you know that there are pockets where you manage to make yourself feel content, but it's all a facade until the true issue is resolved.
@crappybassist96 It sort of reminds me of the last chapter of The Cathcer in the Rye when the main character, who's been depressed the entire book, is overwhelmed by this unexplained melancholy happiness and starts to cry. That's how I feel about his song. I think you're emotions are more vulnerable when you're depressed so a feeling of joy is so sublime and euphoric that nothing can compare to it.
one of the most under rated voices, i like how he re-uses alot of phrases in songs like " milking".. neutral milk is a big influence for my own music creation, when one of my best friends died i listened to alot of them and it mimiced my sadness
while this song reminds me of where I came from, I come to terms that where i grew up, molded me to become who I have becomem for the rest of my life.
I can't tell by the sound, but Jeff has been known for playing his Gibson ES-125 most often, as you can see in many of Neutral Milk Hotel's live performances. I assume that is the guitar he is using here.
bankspappas, I had no intention of plagiarizing someone else's material. It seems that you did not press "more info" to see my full description of this video. I quote from the description: "The movie is a 1924 silent film part of the Tribune-American Dream Picture serial. It is part of the Prelinger Archives so it is licensed under the Creative Commons No Rights Reserved."
yeahh. it was the B-side to Holland, 1945, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't released on a CD or anything. you can download it...paying for it or not.. :D
it's live on the jittery joes album, which is just jeff mangum alone, and the version I prefer, but it's also on the album everything is, which is their earliest release. Both are on itunes.
Seeing him tomorrow in New Haven. First show of tour.
goodless 2 weeks ago
This is good stuff
kakoreo 4 weeks ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Neutral Milk Hotel
omg so hes doing shows at the 40 watt club, theyre sold out but im still thinking about driving down to georgia anyways just to sit outside and listen with my eyes closed
deatheater459 1 month ago
I haven't heard this version before, I really like it :)
SomethinRofl 1 month ago
100,000 views....now lets add a few more 0s to this masterpiece.
TreyMMA 1 month ago
That was adorable.
Brudda2daman 1 month ago
I'm seeing him in January......If he plays this.....oh lord.
ZRN959 2 months ago
We must get back to Oakland at once!
mysteriorockanova 2 months ago
shit holy fuck! neutral milk hotel is a real band? my day is made :D
TheElectricfish1001 2 months ago
@PollyPetron >mfw i dont have a fayce for how surprised i am
anbuubnaanbuubna 2 months ago
inb4 /mu/tants
anbuubnaanbuubna 2 months ago
Seeing him in Dublin ...... hes like a fairytale character
Adam23Smiths 3 months ago
You didnt make this. You just put music over it. Dick.
tysonsteven 3 months ago
Is it just me or did it speed up as it went along?
IonsAgo 3 months ago
Awesome video editing! Congrats!
Esteparia8 4 months ago
the sound of sadness makes me happy somethimes (thank you nmh)
Unundead 5 months ago 7
seeing him play this live is something i won't soon forget.
saccredtwin 5 months ago 2
Neutral milk hotel will forever be incredible.
nuggetmush 5 months ago
what album is this on?
junskey 5 months ago
@junskey It's the b-side of a single
TheDude4077 3 months ago
And if there's a taste in this life more inviting... it's the taste of Neutral Milk Hotel..
Dee dee dee, dee dee, dee deee deeeee!
MoshHead1989 6 months ago
the riff is Sgt. Pepper.........
:D
ApparitionOfficial 6 months ago
I swear I account for about half of the views. I absolutely love this song.
adamckillip 6 months ago
My Band covers this song and a couple others at shows...But We listened to neutral and others Back in the day...before digital transfer...
Anyone here around when cassettes were the norm?
MrManboobie 6 months ago
Bastard in a basket! Bastard in a basket!
zimzum5000 6 months ago
I'm trying to click your link to the aquarium drunkard page and it sends me back to youtube. :(
GrapefruitP 7 months ago
Sounds kinda like Gravity Car by Olivia Tremor Control.
Lazy0Waffle 7 months ago
I have the version with the singing saw.
TurkeyJones91 8 months ago
@TurkeyJones91 it sounds so much better with the saw
toobsockproductions 7 months ago
i sometimes think that jeff is some sort of musical alien. i cant think of anyone who makes music like his, its otherworldly but deeply human. i dont fucking understand, but then again, im not sure im supposed to.
greatgooglymoogly12 8 months ago
Thank you so much for uploading this. Thank you.
imgaston 9 months ago
I absolutely loved the video you put with this.
L0veSings 9 months ago
so this is what mu sucks dicks for?
sh1tpickle 10 months ago
I thought he said "i am an injun" the first time i heard this lol
Meatychunks1 11 months ago
@Meatychunks1 I thought he said ninja the first time. Kinda funny.
Mynamesbob8 10 months ago
like this comment if you like neutral milk hotel please seriously i need some moral support guys!!!!
LetMyInspirationFlow 11 months ago 2
@LetMyInspirationFlow If you need moral support from youtube "likes" then you need to seriously sort out your priorities in life.
seansuperman 10 months ago
@seansuperman I think LetMyInspirationFlow was kidding....
alall94 9 months ago
Excellent video! Beautiful song. Love NMH
22sarahnealy 11 months ago
this video is so adorable. i smiled so hard at the end.
irascib1e 11 months ago
This might be the best pearl jam cover i have ever heard!
officerfriday 1 year ago
Jeff Mangum cures depression. Fuck medication.
mussman717word 1 year ago 22
I'm going out on a limb, but don't mind the fall...NMH (Jeff) might be the greatest lyricist along with B. Dylan that ever graced a mic.
jamesoshea4444 1 year ago
I really want to download this set but I cant figure out how to. Can anyone figure out how to get the mp3's from the link in the video description.
shoot me a message if so
iHeartCoolStuff 1 year ago
@iHeartCoolStuff figured it out... right click the sound and save link as.
iHeartCoolStuff 1 year ago
i couldn't imagine a NMH video that didn't have footage from like at least 60 years ago. there's something timeless about it!
AndyTabelz 1 year ago 2
The couple lives in Oakland? Doesn't look like it.
conradssel 1 year ago
NMH=GOD
pimpinthewhole9 1 year ago
@carlasnudel >>An live
go 'an hero'
lozgibbs243 1 year ago
fuck yeah, just. fuck. yeah.
austinarto1 1 year ago
You guys are high. This is so fucking boring and he has a lisp.
despoticwalnut 1 year ago
Aw lawdy, this is amazing.
Also, 69th comment.
AngryRantingNerd 1 year ago
that's cause he's fucking baby, mr. dumbfuck cop of the planet
MustLovePoop 1 year ago
Comment removed
Nurple 1 year ago
Herp derp. The info told me.
arlinkingmartin 1 year ago
Where is this version from? I know it from Beauty and Jittery Joe's, but I've never heard this one.
arlinkingmartin 1 year ago
lil wayne has so much more talent
MrKannibis 1 year ago
@MrKannibis Dude. That's just messed up
Lukeinator64 1 year ago
2 people have no soul
artistsandbox 1 year ago
@artistsandbox 69
garetthunt 1 year ago
I absolutely adore 20's films. The women's fashion I think is my favorite of the 20th century.
G0D666 1 year ago
Jeff magnum in this song. witch is by far my favorite song by them!
but it reminds me of a more melancholy bob dylan.
easily number one on the playlist that im makeing for my funeral;)
askwhy93 1 year ago
what album is one from the one i downloaded has another sound to it..
is it the live version?
askwhy93 1 year ago
Listening to NMH is like being reborn.
Amazing,
Like you figure things out about yourself from one song, that most people can't in a life time,
I think listening NMH is Love.
shhmellshlikeasshhhh 1 year ago
There is no other band in the world that can create a sound as rich and pure and honest as the music they create. This, in it's most unadulterated form, clean and fresh, is what gives music its true name.
suppage99 1 year ago
absolutely love this song and this video creation.
lotusintheraw 1 year ago
I love this song, too bad it was never released on their studio albums, so many lost gems I never discovered until recently because I had stuck only to their 2 studio albums and didnt explore any of their EPs, Demos, or live stuff which featured songs not on Aeroplane or Avery Island.
badskroy71 1 year ago
i met him in the metro station some days ago····
overban888 1 year ago
@overban888 U MET JEFF? TELL ME ABOUT HIM, WHAT WAS HE LIKE? TELL ME TELL ME TELL ME TELL ME
TommyTomato93 1 year ago
What album is this off of?! I keep finding these NMH songs on youtube I've never heard and want to buy them!
vansrok1 1 year ago
incredibly soothing
AtmaRising 1 year ago
what album is this on?
chunkymilk 1 year ago
THANK YOU.
jamesoshea4444 1 year ago
Good sir, you have just paired two of my favorite things: Neutral Milk Hotel and silent films. I salute you! (By the way, the clip fits perfectly with the song! Good job!)
ZoeSquared21 1 year ago 5
Excellent work!
PlaceboMode 1 year ago
so happy :)
spp41 1 year ago
POOP.
Amandabearish 1 year ago
Well, if you've ever been depressed, you know that there are pockets where you manage to make yourself feel content, but it's all a facade until the true issue is resolved.
crappybassist96 1 year ago 6
@crappybassist96 It sort of reminds me of the last chapter of The Cathcer in the Rye when the main character, who's been depressed the entire book, is overwhelmed by this unexplained melancholy happiness and starts to cry. That's how I feel about his song. I think you're emotions are more vulnerable when you're depressed so a feeling of joy is so sublime and euphoric that nothing can compare to it.
sMC193 1 year ago 7
Chord progression is indeed G, A, C. Sounds best with the barre chords IMO
go30tigers7 1 year ago
amazing band completely unique
captmcswashbuckle 2 years ago
Jeff says this is a happy song, but it always depresses me. Mmmm.
crappybassist96 2 years ago
???? this song is so happy
sMC193 1 year ago
On "Live at Jittery Joe's" he goes on a rant about how it was written in the midst of depression because his life was "in the shitter".
That's what it sounds like to me - a thin veil of contentment over depression.
crappybassist96 1 year ago
yeah but he said he wrote it while he was feeling good.
sMC193 1 year ago
Great video :)
nugget0022 2 years ago
ya you can use G A C G or bar chords or power chords either way its a simple but great song
bdl6 2 years ago
SO wonderful
maggiedarko 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't get them.. at all.
SpidersUnderSkin 2 years ago
alot of their songs are about anne frank..
andyjcostello 2 years ago
@SpidersUnderSkin not really something to "get". just listen to the music :)
wootyeah222 2 years ago
one of the most under rated voices, i like how he re-uses alot of phrases in songs like " milking".. neutral milk is a big influence for my own music creation, when one of my best friends died i listened to alot of them and it mimiced my sadness
shadyreefer69 2 years ago 42
@shadyreefer69
If your own lyrics are inspired by Neutral Milk Hotel, then you must be whiting some damn good songs sir.
joshuaWEC 1 year ago
while this song reminds me of where I came from, I come to terms that where i grew up, molded me to become who I have becomem for the rest of my life.
jsolonzano 2 years ago 5
awesome video.
xxscarlettrigger 2 years ago
Does anyone know what chrds Jeff is ising? It sounds like there's only three.
runningWITHscisors 2 years ago
yah, it's G A C G
but he plays it the bar chord way rather than the formal way
chasethevdevil 2 years ago 3
G, A, C
Barred.
shakezulathemicrulah 2 years ago
Chords are G A C, and back to G, I believe.
kidcopernicus 2 years ago
@kidcopernicus he played it live G# A# C#, but yeah, sooo good.
devonsokay 1 year ago
I'm sure this is a long shot, but does anyone know what type of guitar Jeff has from the sound?
stickman106 2 years ago
I can't tell by the sound, but Jeff has been known for playing his Gibson ES-125 most often, as you can see in many of Neutral Milk Hotel's live performances. I assume that is the guitar he is using here.
Ukanflyy 2 years ago 5
He's played it on a couple of different guitars in live performances, so I dunno lol.
pre3per 2 years ago
@stickman106 hes got himself a martins acoustic mate
apresmatch101 1 year ago
@stickman106 Just use any acoustic guitar with dulled strings
zimzum5000 6 months ago
i dont get why people are fighting on this
Go fight about something else
alotofcheese76 2 years ago 11
Is this envy?? or just the illusion of your superiority??; why don't you criticise war, or rape or abortion?? Not interesting enough?
arjunel 2 years ago
Comment removed
bankspappas 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck the UN
virgin4lyfe 2 years ago
Hello, everybody!
bankspappas, I had no intention of plagiarizing someone else's material. It seems that you did not press "more info" to see my full description of this video. I quote from the description: "The movie is a 1924 silent film part of the Tribune-American Dream Picture serial. It is part of the Prelinger Archives so it is licensed under the Creative Commons No Rights Reserved."
Ukanflyy 2 years ago
Comment removed
bankspappas 2 years ago 2
@Ukanflyy it's all good brother. you dun good. realgood.
happygoessmokey 9 months ago
Yes but he had the thought to do it.
fleebenworth 2 years ago
The clips were very fitting. I quite enjoyed it.:]
camrenishot1 3 years ago 6
where can i get this song -cant find it on ther albums... I love the song
MountainGoatt 3 years ago 2
a lot of Jeff's best songs never came out on an official album.
z0mz0m 3 years ago 10
Oh man, thats to bad! Sombody have to release this song on a EP! Or something else. Thanks for the answer :)
MountainGoatt 3 years ago
yeahh. it was the B-side to Holland, 1945, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't released on a CD or anything. you can download it...paying for it or not.. :D
z0mz0m 3 years ago
it's live on the jittery joes album, which is just jeff mangum alone, and the version I prefer, but it's also on the album everything is, which is their earliest release. Both are on itunes.
nivelnadd 3 years ago 4
It's not on Everything Is, it's on the Holland, 1945 single.
Everything Is playlist:
1. Everything Is
2. Snow Song, Part 1
3. Aunt Eggma Blowtorch
4. Tuesday Moon
I agree that the Live at Jittery Joes version is the best
wanderofys 2 years ago
I enjoy Jittery Joe version of many songs.. your video is cool though.. very simple.
sbeaulieu07 2 years ago 2
You can also find it on the awesome Oh, Merge! compilation.
joeydrake1 3 years ago
Wow, this is really bizarrely fitting. Good job!
Feralnerd 3 years ago 6
I like how they keep the baby in an actual basket. That's classy right there.
The ending gave me chills, I don't know why.
larsofthebourgeoise 3 years ago 25