"killing of 15 U.S prisoners of war who were captured out of uniform on a mission to blow up a railroad tunnel behind enemy lines."- have no combatant status !
@wsimpson86 Anton Dostler was accused of having ordered the shooting of fifteen American prisoners of war in violation of the Regulations attached to the Hague Convention Number IV of 1907, and of long-established laws and customs of war.
@Stehnz that's not right ... the most German of today shame for her past .... in Germany you will be punished with five years in prison, if you make the Hitler salute
@LuizViciado He was not even a member of the NSDAP and were engaged in military duties since 1911 for his fatherland (at that time for the Kaiserreich). Please, refrain from spewing out uneducated ramblinhs and enlighten yourself by informing you more detailed on the notorious "Dostler Case"; then you will see which side committed the REAL war crime in this trial (to begin with your "enlightment" please. read the two "thumped up" comments above.....).
@Stehnz Coming from your mouth, I take that as an compliment for sure.
To be quite frankly, I am not but even if I were a "nazi" that might still be better than being an ultrazionist bolchevistic bastard who should be the very last to open up their big flapping mouthes about Germany and Nazis and so on and so forth, right ?!?
@kernerschreiber13 I'm not sionist, not a jew, but you still are a nazi. You should be executed for that. All germans should be exexuted because they still are nazis.
@Stehnz Tendancy of having the last word so that you "won" the debate ?!?
BTW, I did not know that in such a short lunatic sentence you just did spew out there could be so much idiocy....congrats for that "accomplishment", dude....
"germans lost all the wars" ?!? Well.......the debate ust ended here I guess
Secondly, I am not into that "aryan race" ideology.......
Thirdly, better let your doctor take care of you.....well, better not you are an hopeless simplistic lunatic to say the least !!
Ladies and Gentleman, witness here a war crime being documented by it's very perpetrators. The General was guilty of nothing more than carrying out what is standard US policy in Iraq or Afghanistan today. His execution is the only warcrime attributable to him.
In March 1944, 15 U.S. Soldiers landed on the Italian coast to demolish a railroad tunnel. The group was captured and confined under the command of German Col.Almers. The immediate, superior command was that of the 75th Army Corps, commanded by Dostler. Dostler ordered them executed. German Officers contacted Dostler in an attempt to achieve a stay but Dostler refused. Two more unsuccessful attempts were made by the officers and the fifteen Americans were then executed on Dostler's orders.
@sunny71169 You did forget to mention the most crucial point about the sabotage mission and the 15 saboteurs and the namely "Dostler Case": The 15 saboteurs were OUT OF UNIFORM.....
@davemccarthy707 yes, sure, because it is completely reasonable to do something to people who, possibly didnt even want to fight.
sure, the generals, yes, as they orchestrated the mass killings, but the privates? the corporals who were just following orders, wanting to live to see their family? you believe that THEY too deserved to die? jesus man.
@StalkingSpartan Don't expect to try to take over the world then expect pity when you fail. The Germans alone killed 27million Russians (not including what Stalin killed himself). I think the Germans should consider themselves lucky. It would have been right just to let the whole country starve to death like they did with the Jews. Civilians and all, as there were no civilians in Germany.
Everyone needs to remember that this took place when the fog of war was at it's thickest. I think the Americans would've been of the attitude "live and let live" at the conclusion of the war. Then they saw the concentration camps and what had been going on. Then it all became about reprisals. Everyone was mad. Dostler was guilty. Of a crime? I can't say. Just another casualaty. Still, it's amazing to see what a 30.06 can do.
for some odd resion i respect the nazi army but i hate how they used it!only if they used it for good not for total war! fuck hitler! he should have ben hanged wait no he should have ben burned alive!
who should have died for the bombing of dresden hamburg, hiroshima and nagasaki? comunists executed, raped, and destroyed 5 times more then germans. u dont see them banning comunism in theire country or being ashamed for it. u all know why no1 payed for this? coz they won the war. easy to pass all the guilt to the germans when they lost. but hey american justice have been done, you killed a guy who passed an order. 200 k ppl died in hiroshima in 2 sec and usa is a hero country. pathetic.
@ScotjeRPAS well im not screamin im saying my opinion and facts. got any arguments against?. im sorry i speak to difficult for you to understand but i cant go down to your level of understanding. hope u make sense of what i wrote now. auf wiedersehen
@ScotjeRPAS regarding my english, if EVEN YOU can understand me then its much better then i thought or NEEDS to be and by bringing it up just puts you in a very ridiculous light. if ppl agree or not is a choice and can bring arguments against.
@ScotjeRPAS you just prooved u have no ideea over anything that happened, but ofc, typical for ppl who lack the intelectual, you are big mouth. anyway i will explain so you understand:
nazi- very bad; stalin- worse; allies-bad but not as bad as other 2. and just for your info, allies didnt won anything. russians defeated the nazis, by june 1944 everyone knew germany would loose the war, only question was when. Auf Wiedersehen! <<< and thats not swearing at you. im done wasting time with you
@ScotjeRPAS ' anyway i will explain so you understand:
nazi- very bad ' thats what i said in my previous post. at what point have i said nazis werent bad? i am most amazed u manage to turn on a computer and log to youtube. and as i noticed, u dont understand english, or ur intelect doesnt help you
@ScotjeRPAS choose sides? i hate nazis, i hate stalin, and dislike the way allies pretended are virgins when in fact they were whores. truth is i am on the peace side and there is no good side in war, NOT EVEN the allies
@ScotjeRPAS where in any of my posts have i taken any side and said thats the good side? i will explain again so that you understand the sense of my inial post. i will not make sentences coz i noticed it gets to complicated for you: nazis---very bad; stalin-----worse; allies - bad but not as bad as other 2. war in general very bad; again, im amazed over your capability to turn on a computer
Que hace un sopilote de la iglesia en un fusilamiento? como si dios les diera el poder de perdonar, ademas dios no existe es una leyenda urbana y tambien pueblerina
This was unjustified killing, probably some dumb-as-$h*t US officer trying to cover his screw-up in getting his sabotage team caught and executed as spies.
@bcfsl I am crying of river of tears for poor Nazi swine General Anton Dostler who was executed and In the first Allied war trial, Dostler was accused of carrying out an illegal order, while Dostler maintained that he did not issue the order, but only passed along an order to Colonel Almers from supreme command. The trial found General Dostler guilty of war crimes. He was sentenced to death and shot by a firing squad on December 1, 1945 in Aversa. Oh the poor Naiz oink, oink bit the dust
I would like tto give my opinion to this - but due to political correctness and some laws in Germany I am afraid I am not allowed to. I only can say, that I agree with noiyt. Isn't it significant, that more and more videos are banned to view by German youtube viewers?
@planetrockford I doublechecked on that. I can only say that in every war there is kind of a spiral of injustice that, once started spinning, leaves no one unharmed.
Os americanos executavam qualquer alemão que se econtrassem na mesma situação. Se um soldado alemão fosse pego com uma arma, bota ou qualquer coisa americana era fuzilado. Isso não passou de vingança, justiça do vencedor.
@maxflipper27 In a traditional Firing Squad, 1 maybe 2 soldiers would have a bullet and the rest will have blanks. No one knows which soldier has the real bullet. This is to protect the identity of the soldier who gave the killing shot, so that even he doesn’t know that he was the executioner.
Dont see what every one is so worked up about. Given the amount of innocent men, women, and children who were murdered by the nazis, they are lucky thst every last one of them wasnt lined up against a wall and shot. Or even better, use their own gas chambers to rid the world of anyone stupid enough to listen to some crazy little austrian and his nazi buddies.
It was rather interesting to see the moist, warm air of his lungs escaping out the bullet holes in his back. Too bad we can't do that to all the Illuminati today...but alas...they will get their's in due time.
Wikipedia says the U.S. soldiers were, "duly in uniform". Also that the German officers in charge of the prisioners contacted General Dostler several times to have the order for execution rescinded, and he refused. Lastly that Alexander zu Duhna-Schlobitten, the officer in charge of 135 Fortress Brigade where the prisoners were held, refused to sign the execution order leading to his dimissal from the Wehrmacht. Seems to indicate that even the German officers felt Dostler's order was illegal.
were Italian partisans. Sabotage activities in CIVILIAN clothing behind ennemy lines automatically excluded you from the protection of the Geneva Convention.
The "Führerbefehl" was "pretty clear", though........agreed.......
Like the Russians of a certain era were responsible for the horrendous atrocities the bolchevists did carry out against other nations like the Ukranians but mainly against their own people like the North Americans of a certain era who indeed did track, pursuit or hunt down the Native Indians in a genocidial manner with hundreds of thousands of deaths amongst the Native population.
ALL Russians / Americans "should share this guilt" ?!? Were those nations adequately punished for their dirty
Lets face it all germans of that era were guilty of war crimes in the fact that they did not try to stop Hitler and the SS at that time. All germans of that age should share this guilt. At the end of the war they were not adequately punished for their crimes of mass genocide and yet they dropped the atom bomb on Japan.
Out of uniform, fair game. Cue the execution video of German soldiers who were out of uniform and caught behind enemy lines during the Normandy invasion.
The German soldiers was not only out of their own uniform (unlike the Rangers). They could have got away with just that. But they was also in a fake flag operation, IN their enemy uniform, with enemy ID papers, carrying their weapons and gear, driving their vehicles, faking to be enemy soldiers and caused a number of death of said enemy soldiers in the process. A sure way to end up in front of a firing squad. At lest they got a trial before they was lined up at the wall.
@MrConradMurray The "Rangers" as you did put it according to several testimonies were OUT of uniform which automatically turned those "Rangers" inot spies without the pritection of the Geneva Convention; General Dostler did adhere to the regulations of war by giving the order to shoot those "Rangers".
In the last recent years even American sources admitted that those "trials" used torture, repression etc. to get the "right" testimony in front of the court.
Not even” spies” can be lawfully summarily executed. Define out of uniform: being in a uniform but lacking the “fixed distinctive signs recognizable at a distance"? In a replay of the case , Dostler’s defense would probably choose to dig deep into the Geneva Convention’s rather rigid and outdated definition of a uniform. At the time however it appears to be seen as a long shot not found worthwhile to going after. The Führerbefehl was pretty clear……………….
@MrConradMurray Well, that seemed to be the crucial point about this case whether the members of the commando were in uniform or not; according to several testomonies they were not only lacking the insignias but were completelly in CIVILIAN clothing. The descent of these sabotage commando with the aim of blowing up a relevant tunnel was Italian in combination with the civilian clothing in the first place made made the Wehrmacht soldiers who captured the sabotage commando think that those were
@MrConradMurray Actually spies can be summarily executed, it is lawfull under the rules of war. One does not have to have a trial, just confirmation that they are spies is enough to seek execution.
…..………….at this point - immediate death was to be inflicted on enemy personnel (uniformed or not) captured behind German lines. Understandably enough, the defense was more interested in pursuing the yet un-tested *superior orders* defense, and did so with gusto - hoping to strike a major chord with the tribunal's military officers in impressing upon them the danger to military order of establishing a precedent that subordinates was held accountable for the illegal orders from above.
Load of bullshit all of it..victors did'nt have any judges..how many industrialists and scientists were spared(equaly guilty of war crimes)and snapped up by the yanks and soviets..Werner von Braun for one..and Allies rubbish..stalin keeping everyone else busy in europe while he laid claim to the Balkens and kept everything.
If it's a fact that General Dostler executed 15 POW's who were in civilian clothes working behind German lines, then under the laws of war, he was entitled too. It's illegal for combatants to fight in civilian clothing or enemy uniform, as three German soldiers found out, when the American army executed them in Belgium in 1944.
@newspapers Under the accepted customs and laws of WW2, killing fighters out of uniform was definitely permitted (you were considered a spy if you were out of uniform). Both sides did so repeatedly. So this execution is just "victor's justice".
@nojyt Err, get your facts straight those Allied commandos were in uniform, you were informed of that in the Info.
He was the willing agent of the spiteful Nazi tactic of culling commandos simply because they were the most brave, daring and unconventional. Pure spite. Not tactical nor legal basis.
@Treblaine You tell me to read the info blurb because it says they were in uniform. No it doesn't. It says they were out of uniform. Read it again. My original comment stands - rightly or wrongly, many WW2 soldiers were executed by both sides for operating out of uniform.
(PS. Please don't reply to 7-month old comments. I had no idea what the conversation was about).
@nojyt Wow, I can see why I read it as "in uniform" BECAUSE THEY WERE!
The Geneva Conventions are clear, uniform need be any obviously identifying articles, including the open carrying of the arms of their relevant side.
Dostler was merely facilitating Hitler's notorious Commando Order, to kill all "commandos" regardless of uniform, only the fact that they were daring and effective.
Effectively, Geneva-Conventions are only void when one disguise as a neutral or opposing force.
@newspapers The reason why he was executed is because yes, under the laws of war he had every right to kill POW's. However, POW's are protected under International Law and carries the death penalty if tried and convicted. International Law over-rides Justices of war itself.
@rowbo88 The 15 captured Americans were OUT OF UNIFORM operating behind German lines as saboteurs; therefore, they were NOT considered as POW´s and ergo, definitely NOT protected under the Geneva Convention as you want us to make believe.
By executing the 15 captured Americans in civilian clothes, General Dostler absolutely did adhere to the regualtions of war.
Your reasoning or conclusions don´t hold the water at all.......
This footage shows victor´s "justice" at its worst for sure.....
The Germans started it! If someone punched you in the face and told you that you were scum and that they were gonna gas all your family would smile back? There were a lot of Jews in the Allied forces, and anger presided on both sides, but none of this would have happened without Hitler making the first move. Do you think if Germany had won - the American generals would have been treated any differently?
Big tough Germans killed how many Jews? Nothing but a bunch of coward Germans during WWII. Once America joined the war Germany had no chance. He got what he deserved.
@jcatcatcatcat26 , it's not the only post war Kangaroo set up, maybe the west thought that surviving German officers would interfere with how history was written / made up.
@jcatcatcatcat26 Be civil... How would you call it when presented with the proof that the one on trial commited war crimes? If the story about U.S. servicemen dropping in plain clothes is true (which I think it is. INFILTRATION) Then yeah, spies in plain clothes, not much you can do about that. But, if you are the guy in charge of a death camp or a bonified guard (SS/Gestapo), you do not desreve to share the air I breathe. You and I were not there. He probably did more than what was said.
One further note. Dostler unlike Keitel and Jodl was allowed to wear his General's insignia at the time of his execution and was shot rather than hung. The only insignia removed were those containing the swastika. All other high ranking German officers be they Wehrmacht or SS were stripped of all insignia when put on trial.
I am going on information from trial transcripts. For further research Google:
The Dostler Case: Trial of General Anton Dostler. UN War Crimes Commission.
After much thinking I was at first baffled as to why Dostler would disobey Hitler's Commando Order and have these commandos shot instead of handing them over to the SD as required. Maybe in his Teutonic way of thinking he thought he was sparing these men torture at the hands of the SD. His subordinates protested his order too.
From what I am able to subsume from all of the given sources is they were out of uniform.In this special case, the allies were out fro revenge and blood no matter what because their boys were executed.Even in pro-American sources it is mentioned that the verdict was highly controversial. Go figure or scutinize more on this case etc. !!
LottoWinner999, dude you're preaching to the choir, did you read my posts? Where on Earth do you get the idea that I'm an Axis sympathizer? My screen name? I use that for it's literal meaning "watch dog" not the slang term used during WW2.I agree Dostler got what was coming to him. His subordinates tried to dissuade him from issuing that order.but he did anyway. I think you need to address your comments to kernerschreiber13, not me.
To clear the record, Dostler was executed because he ordered 15 US Army commandos who were in American uniforms and behind enemy lines shot in obedience to Hitler's criminal Commando Order. Dostler violated the Geneva Convention. In 1944 the US Army shot several members of Otto Skorzeny's SS teams who were dressed in AMERICAN uniforms and thus treated as spies.
Big difference here folks, the US commandos were shot in the uniform of their own country while the SS men were treated as spies.
@robinhood48 it is true the americans are scum and this man this german did his job he was right but the history now shows that the jews took over america and they run america and the americans are so fucking stupid they do not know it but if they were german the jews would not own america
No no I don't have any problem with that, I just wonder what made that man a hero as opposed to anyone else. Are you saying there are many men who didn't do their duty at all odds? I am not saying he isn't a hero, but there can be many reasons for for that.
Thirdly, you are just making a very valid point for my case by saying that "makes him a spy and violates the Geneva Rules of War and spies can be shot where they stand". Yeah, indeed, dude, General Dostler did excatly what you were supposing to do.He completelly did adhere to the regulations of war of that era and let those American saboteurs or spies shoot "where they stand" !!
in one rifle there is empty fake bullet and this has been told to the squad before so no one is 100 percent sure who did the execution, emotionally no one gets responsibility,
@spareaxe General Anton Dostler can be hardly portrayed as a "fucking bastard".
He started his military duties in 1914 in Prussia under the command of Kaiser Wilhelm II. He was an honourable veteran militarty man from the sources I did read.
Maybe US generals are all "fucking bastards", too ?!?
smokin hawt
pogo14022002 1 week ago
Ві все пидорасы и жиды.Хайль Гитлер
KurtAdolfMeyer 1 week ago
mi-e sila de rasa mea!de tot ce a facut de 8000 de ani incoace!!!
TheBloc27 2 weeks ago
"killing of 15 U.S prisoners of war who were captured out of uniform on a mission to blow up a railroad tunnel behind enemy lines."- have no combatant status !
ad220588 3 weeks ago
I don't get it, we fight murder with murder? Killing someone isn't the answer to problems people. Think of how barbaric that is.
wsimpson86 1 month ago
@wsimpson86 Anton Dostler was accused of having ordered the shooting of fifteen American prisoners of war in violation of the Regulations attached to the Hague Convention Number IV of 1907, and of long-established laws and customs of war.
ad220588 3 weeks ago
all germans are nazi, even today
Stehnz 1 month ago
@Stehnz that's not right ... the most German of today shame for her past .... in Germany you will be punished with five years in prison, if you make the Hitler salute
metaldrumsmurph 1 month ago
Funny how war crimes are only committed by the losers of a war...It's true what they say: The victors always write history.
Brk40 1 month ago 2
damn i love to set nazis get executed if u like two thumps up for this
LuizViciado 1 month ago
@LuizViciado He was not even a member of the NSDAP and were engaged in military duties since 1911 for his fatherland (at that time for the Kaiserreich). Please, refrain from spewing out uneducated ramblinhs and enlighten yourself by informing you more detailed on the notorious "Dostler Case"; then you will see which side committed the REAL war crime in this trial (to begin with your "enlightment" please. read the two "thumped up" comments above.....).
kernerschreiber13 1 month ago
@kernerschreiber13 shut up, nazi
Stehnz 1 month ago
@Stehnz Coming from your mouth, I take that as an compliment for sure.
To be quite frankly, I am not but even if I were a "nazi" that might still be better than being an ultrazionist bolchevistic bastard who should be the very last to open up their big flapping mouthes about Germany and Nazis and so on and so forth, right ?!?
kernerschreiber13 1 month ago
@kernerschreiber13 I'm not sionist, not a jew, but you still are a nazi. You should be executed for that. All germans should be exexuted because they still are nazis.
Stehnz 1 month ago
@Stehnz You are welcome )........Always a pleasure, little simpleton.
kernerschreiber13 3 weeks ago
@kernerschreiber13 germans lost all their wars, lol so much for the aryan race. fucking nazi shut the fuck up
Stehnz 3 weeks ago
@Stehnz if they would ve wanted only usa or the soviet union,they would've won,so stfu. just sayan
branza27 2 weeks ago
@branza27 lol you are a nazi
Stehnz 2 weeks ago
@Stehnz Tendancy of having the last word so that you "won" the debate ?!?
BTW, I did not know that in such a short lunatic sentence you just did spew out there could be so much idiocy....congrats for that "accomplishment", dude....
"germans lost all the wars" ?!? Well.......the debate ust ended here I guess
Secondly, I am not into that "aryan race" ideology.......
Thirdly, better let your doctor take care of you.....well, better not you are an hopeless simplistic lunatic to say the least !!
kernerschreiber13 1 week ago
@Stehnz You may not be a Zionist or Jew, but you'll always be an imbecile.
TheCitizenfitz 2 weeks ago
@TheCitizenfitz and you'll always be a nazi. Yes, that's worse.
Stehnz 1 week ago
Jew Bolsheviks killed how many?
supralex1 2 months ago
How many people did Stalin kill?
supralex1 2 months ago
Ladies and Gentleman, witness here a war crime being documented by it's very perpetrators. The General was guilty of nothing more than carrying out what is standard US policy in Iraq or Afghanistan today. His execution is the only warcrime attributable to him.
CE750 2 months ago 9
In March 1944, 15 U.S. Soldiers landed on the Italian coast to demolish a railroad tunnel. The group was captured and confined under the command of German Col.Almers. The immediate, superior command was that of the 75th Army Corps, commanded by Dostler. Dostler ordered them executed. German Officers contacted Dostler in an attempt to achieve a stay but Dostler refused. Two more unsuccessful attempts were made by the officers and the fifteen Americans were then executed on Dostler's orders.
sunny71169 3 months ago
@sunny71169 You did forget to mention the most crucial point about the sabotage mission and the 15 saboteurs and the namely "Dostler Case": The 15 saboteurs were OUT OF UNIFORM.....
kernerschreiber13 3 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
They should have booted in his skull to save ammo. Piece of Nazi trash.
davemccarthy707 3 months ago
Comment removed
StalkingSpartan 3 months ago
@StalkingSpartan I am not American. All Nazi's deserved to die like dogs. Chained to a post.
davemccarthy707 3 months ago
@davemccarthy707 yes, sure, because it is completely reasonable to do something to people who, possibly didnt even want to fight.
sure, the generals, yes, as they orchestrated the mass killings, but the privates? the corporals who were just following orders, wanting to live to see their family? you believe that THEY too deserved to die? jesus man.
StalkingSpartan 3 months ago
@StalkingSpartan Don't expect to try to take over the world then expect pity when you fail. The Germans alone killed 27million Russians (not including what Stalin killed himself). I think the Germans should consider themselves lucky. It would have been right just to let the whole country starve to death like they did with the Jews. Civilians and all, as there were no civilians in Germany.
davemccarthy707 3 months ago
@davemccarthy707 believe your propaganda, idiota
StalkingSpartan 3 months ago 4
7 soldiers shooting at 1 man .. what a waste of ammo
drummerbf 4 months ago
@drummerbf yes they should have hanged him .. slowly pull up
metaldrumsmurph 1 month ago
Everyone needs to remember that this took place when the fog of war was at it's thickest. I think the Americans would've been of the attitude "live and let live" at the conclusion of the war. Then they saw the concentration camps and what had been going on. Then it all became about reprisals. Everyone was mad. Dostler was guilty. Of a crime? I can't say. Just another casualaty. Still, it's amazing to see what a 30.06 can do.
mindeloman 4 months ago
shit... that's sb's son
fuck the war :(
DarkDiDi 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
he got what he deserved
keperkeikkari 6 months ago
USA USA!!!
sswwaann1 6 months ago
the allies executed soldiers out of uniform!
peiper1231 7 months ago
TWITTER TheMrPangloss Living Nazi Guard at Auschwitz
OurBomberHarris 8 months ago
Comment removed
bloodsling 9 months ago
for some odd resion i respect the nazi army but i hate how they used it!only if they used it for good not for total war! fuck hitler! he should have ben hanged wait no he should have ben burned alive!
epicduck123 9 months ago
who should have died for the bombing of dresden hamburg, hiroshima and nagasaki? comunists executed, raped, and destroyed 5 times more then germans. u dont see them banning comunism in theire country or being ashamed for it. u all know why no1 payed for this? coz they won the war. easy to pass all the guilt to the germans when they lost. but hey american justice have been done, you killed a guy who passed an order. 200 k ppl died in hiroshima in 2 sec and usa is a hero country. pathetic.
VonKungbak 9 months ago 2
@VonKungbak You are just screaming nonsense..
ScotjeRPAS 9 months ago
@ScotjeRPAS well im not screamin im saying my opinion and facts. got any arguments against?. im sorry i speak to difficult for you to understand but i cant go down to your level of understanding. hope u make sense of what i wrote now. auf wiedersehen
VonKungbak 9 months ago
@VonKungbak You obviously can't write in proper English...
Just noticed, so I figured I would say it.
But I don't think ANYBODY is going to agree with your first comment.
ScotjeRPAS 9 months ago
@ScotjeRPAS regarding my english, if EVEN YOU can understand me then its much better then i thought or NEEDS to be and by bringing it up just puts you in a very ridiculous light. if ppl agree or not is a choice and can bring arguments against.
VonKungbak 9 months ago
@VonKungbak Ah, you are learning quick. You ain't saying ''Auf Wiedersehen'' anymore,
And the Germans brought way more damage to the humans then the Allied forces.
And they are killing thousands of people without a legit reason. Does that seem fair to you?
Allied forces killed a lot of people too, indeed. But look where we are now, and where we would have been if there were no Allies.
You think about that, mister.
ScotjeRPAS 9 months ago
@ScotjeRPAS you just prooved u have no ideea over anything that happened, but ofc, typical for ppl who lack the intelectual, you are big mouth. anyway i will explain so you understand:
nazi- very bad; stalin- worse; allies-bad but not as bad as other 2. and just for your info, allies didnt won anything. russians defeated the nazis, by june 1944 everyone knew germany would loose the war, only question was when. Auf Wiedersehen! <<< and thats not swearing at you. im done wasting time with you
VonKungbak 9 months ago
@VonKungbak It is quite ironic that a German says that the Nazi's weren't so bad.
ScotjeRPAS 9 months ago
@ScotjeRPAS ' anyway i will explain so you understand:
nazi- very bad ' thats what i said in my previous post. at what point have i said nazis werent bad? i am most amazed u manage to turn on a computer and log to youtube. and as i noticed, u dont understand english, or ur intelect doesnt help you
VonKungbak 9 months ago
@VonKungbak I ain't understanding English?
You really need to read what I say, that is in English, and they are on a comment of yours where you speak English.
And you are ''against'' the Allies.
You HAVE to choose sides.
You can't be neutral, you just can't.
So you have Allies and Germans.
You are saying things against Allies.
So you are ''on'' the side of the Germans, as I see it.
ScotjeRPAS 9 months ago
@ScotjeRPAS choose sides? i hate nazis, i hate stalin, and dislike the way allies pretended are virgins when in fact they were whores. truth is i am on the peace side and there is no good side in war, NOT EVEN the allies
VonKungbak 9 months ago
@VonKungbak Ah, now we are talking peacefully!
ScotjeRPAS 9 months ago
@ScotjeRPAS where in any of my posts have i taken any side and said thats the good side? i will explain again so that you understand the sense of my inial post. i will not make sentences coz i noticed it gets to complicated for you: nazis---very bad; stalin-----worse; allies - bad but not as bad as other 2. war in general very bad; again, im amazed over your capability to turn on a computer
VonKungbak 9 months ago
@ScotjeRPAS ''Auf wiedersehen'' means ''Goodbye, or farewell''...
caporalchef4 7 months ago
@caporalchef4 I know, but I see it like something, I don know rofl.
But I find it offending, I don say everytime I comment on something Tot Ziens.
ScotjeRPAS 7 months ago
Que hace un sopilote de la iglesia en un fusilamiento? como si dios les diera el poder de perdonar, ademas dios no existe es una leyenda urbana y tambien pueblerina
100yayala 9 months ago
This was unjustified killing, probably some dumb-as-$h*t US officer trying to cover his screw-up in getting his sabotage team caught and executed as spies.
bcfsl 10 months ago
@bcfsl I am crying of river of tears for poor Nazi swine General Anton Dostler who was executed and In the first Allied war trial, Dostler was accused of carrying out an illegal order, while Dostler maintained that he did not issue the order, but only passed along an order to Colonel Almers from supreme command. The trial found General Dostler guilty of war crimes. He was sentenced to death and shot by a firing squad on December 1, 1945 in Aversa. Oh the poor Naiz oink, oink bit the dust
LottoWinner999 9 months ago
Bastards!
deranwald 10 months ago
I would like tto give my opinion to this - but due to political correctness and some laws in Germany I am afraid I am not allowed to. I only can say, that I agree with noiyt. Isn't it significant, that more and more videos are banned to view by German youtube viewers?
wasgaujaeger 10 months ago
@wasgaujaeger Sounds vaguely familiar, time to check your ethnic background.
planetrockford 9 months ago
@planetrockford I doublechecked on that. I can only say that in every war there is kind of a spiral of injustice that, once started spinning, leaves no one unharmed.
... literally spoken.
wasgaujaeger 9 months ago
@wasgaujaeger German ashamed of their past .. make the Hitler salute in Germany and you're five years in prison
metaldrumsmurph 1 month ago
The later episodes of Bilko were definately funnier.
planetrockford 10 months ago
Os americanos executavam qualquer alemão que se econtrassem na mesma situação. Se um soldado alemão fosse pego com uma arma, bota ou qualquer coisa americana era fuzilado. Isso não passou de vingança, justiça do vencedor.
kratan21 10 months ago
did they really need that many guys to kill him.
maxflipper27 11 months ago
@maxflipper27 In a traditional Firing Squad, 1 maybe 2 soldiers would have a bullet and the rest will have blanks. No one knows which soldier has the real bullet. This is to protect the identity of the soldier who gave the killing shot, so that even he doesn’t know that he was the executioner.
Jmbk7278 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
burn in Hell fucked german nazi pig !
FUCK HIM
dawidjoseph05 11 months ago
1:15 and boom goes the dynamite
purekain555 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is unjust is innocent
heber78 1 year ago
Comment removed
heber78 1 year ago
Comment removed
heber78 1 year ago
Jews dominate U.S.
heber78 1 year ago
Faced death like General,allied justice??have you courage to face like this man for what you done in iraq,Afghanistan????
shamidfdg 1 year ago
In war, everybody is a f"""ng asshole.
VeniVidiVici45 1 year ago
1:15
IknowMYwwii 1 year ago
Dont see what every one is so worked up about. Given the amount of innocent men, women, and children who were murdered by the nazis, they are lucky thst every last one of them wasnt lined up against a wall and shot. Or even better, use their own gas chambers to rid the world of anyone stupid enough to listen to some crazy little austrian and his nazi buddies.
thehamish 1 year ago
@thehamish
This man was a not a Nazi. He was a military general.
dajord 11 months ago
@dajord he was a millitary general and a fanatic nazi
metaldrumsmurph 1 month ago
It was rather interesting to see the moist, warm air of his lungs escaping out the bullet holes in his back. Too bad we can't do that to all the Illuminati today...but alas...they will get their's in due time.
usedbrain 1 year ago
An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
fifafreak310258 1 year ago 24
@fifafreak310258 unless you're killing the evil & wicked...He got the easy way out, that was to soft.
corymajor1 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@fifafreak310258 "An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind."
Empty platitudes to the families of Dostler's murder victims. It's clear you can't make the distinction between Justice and Revenge.
Treblaine 9 months ago
@fifafreak310258 ok Ghandi. You can continue your yoga now and STFU.
bbasher79 9 months ago
@fifafreak310258 Oh shut it this is real GEEK !!!
GameSpotterz 9 months ago
@fifafreak310258 Oh shut it this is real GEEK !!!
GameSpotterz 9 months ago
@fifafreak310258 And a world without justice turns into chaos.
OnYouGlenn 2 months ago
Wikipedia says the U.S. soldiers were, "duly in uniform". Also that the German officers in charge of the prisioners contacted General Dostler several times to have the order for execution rescinded, and he refused. Lastly that Alexander zu Duhna-Schlobitten, the officer in charge of 135 Fortress Brigade where the prisoners were held, refused to sign the execution order leading to his dimissal from the Wehrmacht. Seems to indicate that even the German officers felt Dostler's order was illegal.
JDSFLA 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kid at 2:25 : "That's all, folks!" ;)
bag3lmonst3r 1 year ago
Comment removed
bag3lmonst3r 1 year ago
were Italian partisans. Sabotage activities in CIVILIAN clothing behind ennemy lines automatically excluded you from the protection of the Geneva Convention.
The "Führerbefehl" was "pretty clear", though........agreed.......
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
blood because their boys did get executed by General Dostler >>>>
Victor´s Justice at its worst.......
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WHAT GOES AROUND COMES AROUND!
"The fear of the Lord is to hate evil...." (Proverbs 8:13)
bernardrichards 1 year ago
A war and expeirience no man should have saw
synysterguitar63 1 year ago
he took it as a man
SweStuff94 1 year ago
kill the german bastard
nite187 1 year ago
@nite187 thats not right... kill the NAZI bastard... when you say German bastard, are you also racist
metaldrumsmurph 1 month ago
deeds errrr or maybe not ?!?
They have been endless mass genocides in history during all those centuries you know, dude.
Don´ t pretend to stand on the moral high ground.
Your nation has enough blood on its own hands to care about.....
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
Like the Russians of a certain era were responsible for the horrendous atrocities the bolchevists did carry out against other nations like the Ukranians but mainly against their own people like the North Americans of a certain era who indeed did track, pursuit or hunt down the Native Indians in a genocidial manner with hundreds of thousands of deaths amongst the Native population.
ALL Russians / Americans "should share this guilt" ?!? Were those nations adequately punished for their dirty
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
Lets face it all germans of that era were guilty of war crimes in the fact that they did not try to stop Hitler and the SS at that time. All germans of that age should share this guilt. At the end of the war they were not adequately punished for their crimes of mass genocide and yet they dropped the atom bomb on Japan.
rocking983 1 year ago
Out of uniform, fair game. Cue the execution video of German soldiers who were out of uniform and caught behind enemy lines during the Normandy invasion.
firstclassbulkheader 1 year ago
@firstclassbulkheader
The German soldiers was not only out of their own uniform (unlike the Rangers). They could have got away with just that. But they was also in a fake flag operation, IN their enemy uniform, with enemy ID papers, carrying their weapons and gear, driving their vehicles, faking to be enemy soldiers and caused a number of death of said enemy soldiers in the process. A sure way to end up in front of a firing squad. At lest they got a trial before they was lined up at the wall.
MrConradMurray 1 year ago
@MrConradMurray The "Rangers" as you did put it according to several testimonies were OUT of uniform which automatically turned those "Rangers" inot spies without the pritection of the Geneva Convention; General Dostler did adhere to the regulations of war by giving the order to shoot those "Rangers".
In the last recent years even American sources admitted that those "trials" used torture, repression etc. to get the "right" testimony in front of the court.
The Americans simply were out for
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
@kernerschreiber13
Not even” spies” can be lawfully summarily executed. Define out of uniform: being in a uniform but lacking the “fixed distinctive signs recognizable at a distance"? In a replay of the case , Dostler’s defense would probably choose to dig deep into the Geneva Convention’s rather rigid and outdated definition of a uniform. At the time however it appears to be seen as a long shot not found worthwhile to going after. The Führerbefehl was pretty clear……………….
MrConradMurray 1 year ago
@MrConradMurray Well, that seemed to be the crucial point about this case whether the members of the commando were in uniform or not; according to several testomonies they were not only lacking the insignias but were completelly in CIVILIAN clothing. The descent of these sabotage commando with the aim of blowing up a relevant tunnel was Italian in combination with the civilian clothing in the first place made made the Wehrmacht soldiers who captured the sabotage commando think that those were
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
@MrConradMurray Actually spies can be summarily executed, it is lawfull under the rules of war. One does not have to have a trial, just confirmation that they are spies is enough to seek execution.
confederatecharlie 7 months ago 7
…..………….at this point - immediate death was to be inflicted on enemy personnel (uniformed or not) captured behind German lines. Understandably enough, the defense was more interested in pursuing the yet un-tested *superior orders* defense, and did so with gusto - hoping to strike a major chord with the tribunal's military officers in impressing upon them the danger to military order of establishing a precedent that subordinates was held accountable for the illegal orders from above.
MrConradMurray 1 year ago
Victors justice.
beninmelb 1 year ago
Load of bullshit all of it..victors did'nt have any judges..how many industrialists and scientists were spared(equaly guilty of war crimes)and snapped up by the yanks and soviets..Werner von Braun for one..and Allies rubbish..stalin keeping everyone else busy in europe while he laid claim to the Balkens and kept everything.
bikebandit48 1 year ago
Why is a priest there ?
What an arsehole - the priest, to make that clear..
MucusFelidae 1 year ago
If it's a fact that General Dostler executed 15 POW's who were in civilian clothes working behind German lines, then under the laws of war, he was entitled too. It's illegal for combatants to fight in civilian clothing or enemy uniform, as three German soldiers found out, when the American army executed them in Belgium in 1944.
newspapers 1 year ago
@newspapers Under the accepted customs and laws of WW2, killing fighters out of uniform was definitely permitted (you were considered a spy if you were out of uniform). Both sides did so repeatedly. So this execution is just "victor's justice".
nojyt 1 year ago 18
@nojyt Err, get your facts straight those Allied commandos were in uniform, you were informed of that in the Info.
He was the willing agent of the spiteful Nazi tactic of culling commandos simply because they were the most brave, daring and unconventional. Pure spite. Not tactical nor legal basis.
Treblaine 9 months ago
@Treblaine You tell me to read the info blurb because it says they were in uniform. No it doesn't. It says they were out of uniform. Read it again. My original comment stands - rightly or wrongly, many WW2 soldiers were executed by both sides for operating out of uniform.
(PS. Please don't reply to 7-month old comments. I had no idea what the conversation was about).
nojyt 9 months ago
@nojyt Wow, I can see why I read it as "in uniform" BECAUSE THEY WERE!
The Geneva Conventions are clear, uniform need be any obviously identifying articles, including the open carrying of the arms of their relevant side.
Dostler was merely facilitating Hitler's notorious Commando Order, to kill all "commandos" regardless of uniform, only the fact that they were daring and effective.
Effectively, Geneva-Conventions are only void when one disguise as a neutral or opposing force.
Treblaine 9 months ago
@newspapers The reason why he was executed is because yes, under the laws of war he had every right to kill POW's. However, POW's are protected under International Law and carries the death penalty if tried and convicted. International Law over-rides Justices of war itself.
rowbo88 1 year ago
@rowbo88 The 15 captured Americans were OUT OF UNIFORM operating behind German lines as saboteurs; therefore, they were NOT considered as POW´s and ergo, definitely NOT protected under the Geneva Convention as you want us to make believe.
By executing the 15 captured Americans in civilian clothes, General Dostler absolutely did adhere to the regualtions of war.
Your reasoning or conclusions don´t hold the water at all.......
This footage shows victor´s "justice" at its worst for sure.....
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
another jew hater being killed, not surprised
Warlord795 1 year ago
wow that was like 20 shots into his cheast
20130807 1 year ago
Comment removed
hashem37927 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the real criminals of war by Robert S. McNamara:
LeMay said, "If we'd lost the war, we'd all have been prosecuted as war criminals". And I think he's right.
/watch?v=S21tC-JxWXA
hashem37927 1 year ago
Comment removed
hashem37927 1 year ago
Comment removed
hashem37927 1 year ago
@FreiNemmersdorf its true the american is so fucking stupid he does not ever know the jews run america
zzzippo55 1 year ago
& what happened to the Amerikanisch generals who killed any captured German soldier in "Operation Greif"?!
hashem37927 1 year ago
@hashem37927 The Germans started it!
samgmalpass 1 year ago
The Germans started it! If someone punched you in the face and told you that you were scum and that they were gonna gas all your family would smile back? There were a lot of Jews in the Allied forces, and anger presided on both sides, but none of this would have happened without Hitler making the first move. Do you think if Germany had won - the American generals would have been treated any differently?
samgmalpass 1 year ago
@samgmalpass Your rambling "Germans started it" has zero relevance for this specific case and kangaroo trial.
General Dostler did absolutely adhere to the regulations of war of that era but still got executed !!
Victor´s justice at its worst.....
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
Comment removed
hashem37927 1 year ago
Comment removed
hashem37927 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@samgmalpass - I was talking to another "Ally" (Amerikaner) on another unrelated video (about Iraq) & he gave the same ignorant argument.
you all think that everyone is like you, a dishonorable "do-you-before-you-do-me" nation!
beside, Hitler didn't start this war, he was dragged to it!
listen how a true leader knows what is the cause of going to war unlike your puppets who can't speak 2 words without a cue-card!
/watch?v=gqTx6DKbzrA
hashem37927 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@samgmalpass - I was talking to another "Ally" (Amerikaner) on another unrelated video (about Iraq) & he gave the same ignorant argument.
you all think that everyone is like you, a dishonorable "do-you-before-you-do-me" nation!
beside, Hitler didn't start this war, he was dragged to it!
listen how a true leader knows what is the cause of going to war unlike your puppets who can't speak 2 words without a cue-card!
/watch?v=gqTx6DKbzrA
hashem37927 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@samgmalpass
I was talking to another "Ally" (Amerikaner) on another unrelated video (about Iraq) & he gave the same ignorant argument.
you all think that everyone is like you, a dishonorable "do-you-before-you-do-me" nation!
beside, Hitler didn't start this war, he was dragged to it!
listen how a true leader knows what is the cause of going to war unlike your puppets who can't speak 2 words without a cue-card!
/watch?v=gqTx6DKbzrA
hashem37927 1 year ago
@FreiNemmersdorf
Big tough Germans killed how many Jews? Nothing but a bunch of coward Germans during WWII. Once America joined the war Germany had no chance. He got what he deserved.
docdeedoo 1 year ago
@docdeedoo it was russia, not america, that destroyed the reich
nederwiet1 1 year ago
@FreiNemmersdorf
Don't you mean victorious allies metting out the appropriate punishment for war criminal Nazis? I thought this was an excellent video :)
AccountReporter 1 year ago
I like how every allied tribunal just assumes every member of the german armed services is guilty of war crimes
jcatcatcatcat26 1 year ago
@jcatcatcatcat26 , it's not the only post war Kangaroo set up, maybe the west thought that surviving German officers would interfere with how history was written / made up.
DeadOriginal 1 year ago 2
@jcatcatcatcat26 I don't....I always think about the man who is not willing to die for his country.
stevedude92 1 year ago
@jcatcatcatcat26 Be civil... How would you call it when presented with the proof that the one on trial commited war crimes? If the story about U.S. servicemen dropping in plain clothes is true (which I think it is. INFILTRATION) Then yeah, spies in plain clothes, not much you can do about that. But, if you are the guy in charge of a death camp or a bonified guard (SS/Gestapo), you do not desreve to share the air I breathe. You and I were not there. He probably did more than what was said.
radargod1977 1 year ago
Drop the dead donkey
blockthehood 1 year ago
One further note. Dostler unlike Keitel and Jodl was allowed to wear his General's insignia at the time of his execution and was shot rather than hung. The only insignia removed were those containing the swastika. All other high ranking German officers be they Wehrmacht or SS were stripped of all insignia when put on trial.
kettenhund54 1 year ago
I am going on information from trial transcripts. For further research Google:
The Dostler Case: Trial of General Anton Dostler. UN War Crimes Commission.
After much thinking I was at first baffled as to why Dostler would disobey Hitler's Commando Order and have these commandos shot instead of handing them over to the SD as required. Maybe in his Teutonic way of thinking he thought he was sparing these men torture at the hands of the SD. His subordinates protested his order too.
kettenhund54 1 year ago
From what I am able to subsume from all of the given sources is they were out of uniform.In this special case, the allies were out fro revenge and blood no matter what because their boys were executed.Even in pro-American sources it is mentioned that the verdict was highly controversial. Go figure or scutinize more on this case etc. !!
I am out of here.
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
LottoWinner999, dude you're preaching to the choir, did you read my posts? Where on Earth do you get the idea that I'm an Axis sympathizer? My screen name? I use that for it's literal meaning "watch dog" not the slang term used during WW2.I agree Dostler got what was coming to him. His subordinates tried to dissuade him from issuing that order.but he did anyway. I think you need to address your comments to kernerschreiber13, not me.
kettenhund54 1 year ago
To clear the record, Dostler was executed because he ordered 15 US Army commandos who were in American uniforms and behind enemy lines shot in obedience to Hitler's criminal Commando Order. Dostler violated the Geneva Convention. In 1944 the US Army shot several members of Otto Skorzeny's SS teams who were dressed in AMERICAN uniforms and thus treated as spies.
Big difference here folks, the US commandos were shot in the uniform of their own country while the SS men were treated as spies.
kettenhund54 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dig him up and shoot him again
cobyt78 1 year ago
Here you can see a German hero dying like a real man. May he rest in Peace.
I take pride in the knowledge that this man gave an example to the US criminals how a man has to die.
robinhood48 1 year ago 2
@robinhood48 - I totally agree.
for the first time in history, one side treats the other as a common criminal.
this is may be the only Amerikanisch invention of modern warfare.
that's because they know nothing of honor & respect between enemies.
R.I.P. General Anton Dostler
hashem37927 1 year ago
@robinhood48 it is true the americans are scum and this man this german did his job he was right but the history now shows that the jews took over america and they run america and the americans are so fucking stupid they do not know it but if they were german the jews would not own america
zzzippo55 1 year ago 2
@zzzippo55
Can you prove that Jews took over America?
StopFear 1 year ago
@robinhood48
I feel bad for a soldier of any army who dies in any circumstances. But how is this man more heroic than any other?
StopFear 1 year ago
@StopFear
Did I say he was more heroic than others?
robinhood48 1 year ago
@robinhood48
If I misunderstood, then can you explain what he did that made him a hero who died like a real man? I just wonder.
StopFear 1 year ago
@StopFear
This man did his duty against all odds and when he was supposed to die he showed his enemies how a German soldier preserved his dignity.
This is the death of an hero.
I did not compare him with other soldiers of today I just said my opinion.
Any problems with that?
robinhood48 1 year ago
@robinhood48
No no I don't have any problem with that, I just wonder what made that man a hero as opposed to anyone else. Are you saying there are many men who didn't do their duty at all odds? I am not saying he isn't a hero, but there can be many reasons for for that.
StopFear 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@robinhood48 Loves Little Boys Bums
blockthehood 9 months ago
@robinhood48 Has your chocolate starfish recovered ? Nazi freak
OurBomberHarris 8 months ago
Thirdly, you are just making a very valid point for my case by saying that "makes him a spy and violates the Geneva Rules of War and spies can be shot where they stand". Yeah, indeed, dude, General Dostler did excatly what you were supposing to do.He completelly did adhere to the regulations of war of that era and let those American saboteurs or spies shoot "where they stand" !!
Thank you for backing me up.......
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago
Tapfer german general was going his last gang tapfer and aufrecht!
nachtschattenuser 1 year ago
I think he was pretty nerves
mussefele 1 year ago
in one rifle there is empty fake bullet and this has been told to the squad before so no one is 100 percent sure who did the execution, emotionally no one gets responsibility,
BLOODYCLQ 1 year ago
@BLOODYCLQ Bullshit, they hardened combat soldiers. They aim and shoot the fucking bastard.
spareaxe 1 year ago
@spareaxe why don't you google search instead of writing bullshit. this way you dont have to apologize from people all your life young boy.
BLOODYCLQ 1 year ago
@spareaxe General Anton Dostler can be hardly portrayed as a "fucking bastard".
He started his military duties in 1914 in Prussia under the command of Kaiser Wilhelm II. He was an honourable veteran militarty man from the sources I did read.
Maybe US generals are all "fucking bastards", too ?!?
kernerschreiber13 1 year ago