@WinterLamp . @tdzheng .. Why is Hakka frowned upon from then till now? Dr Sun family mentioned in a book that they are Cantonese. I can't understand why Hakka claimed that Dr Sun YS is Hakka. It is such a shameful claim without fact and proof. Why don't Hakka be proud of remarkable Hakka leaders such as former Thai Prime Minister (Thaksin), former Taiwan president (Chen Shui Bian, Lee Teng Hui) and many others....for their corruption charges.
Hakka is always barbaric. That is why many Hakka had assimilated into Cantonese (HK, Guangzhou), Hokkien (M'sia, S'pore) and Mandarin Chinese (China & Taiwan) and forget their barbaric dialect. Even language u use is so vulgar. Who told U Dr Sun Yat Sen is Hakka? His family is Cantonese.
@limyangyang hakkas were often associated to the taiping rebellion at the time which for your info almost toppled the qing dynasty if not for western help, so even if sun yat sen was a hakka, he wouldn't admit it as it was frowned upon at that time. heck we're all chinese so why bother?
Some hakka people also speak vietnamese as well as cantonese, even though they are not born in China nor never been there. Only because it was their mother tongue. Of course, they often don't know any chinese character.
JCCO123 you must keep attacking limyangyang ,the son of a whore.He is trying to instigate the Hakka to hate Cantonese!he is a subversive element .If he is in Sigapore he will be thrown into jail without a trial.He is a classic empty vessel ,self proclaimed historian barking like a mad dog ,disturbing the peace! Don't be nice to him ,use the roughest language you can.He is talking like someone of high authority but in fact a small worm crawling in a pool of shit!Too much shit in his brain!
You are just jealous. The Hakkas were the officer (guan) class in China. Just look at the number of famous political and military leaders of China and other Chinese societies who are Hakkas.
The powerful position in army, government & PLA will always be in the hands of Northerners Mandarin & Shanghainese in the next 50 yrs. Hakka only given some minor positions. As known source of revolutionary, Chinese govwill always be wary of Hakka. Look at Kuomintang, they rather appoint a Minnan VP Candidate. DPP both candidates of President-VP is Minnan. Hakka? They fight 4 independence n slow down Taiwan economy (Chen Shui-bian & Lee Tang-hui)
limyangyang, A Stupid Malay like you shud stop crapping about Hakkas, Chu De, Deng Xiao Ping and ye Jianyin were all Hakkas. Stupid fuck that you are. LOL!
Cantonese and English Language combined make Hong Kong Number One Economic Powerhouse. Hong Language had no place in China, Taiwan or anywhere else. That is low class barbaric language spoken by poor n old Hakka living in seclusion in hilly/jungle area. Cantonese is prestige language that many Mandarin speakers in all over China younth is learning. It is so popular. Hakka is shit dialects.
Hong Kong Cantonese will suffer in short term due to control fromBeijing in preference to Shanghai & Beijing. The economy of HK now rely so much from China only. Slowdown started since 1997 handover. But in long term Cantonese power will rise again in Guangdong & HK.
limyangyang, do you honestly think Hakka people only speak Hakka? Most Hakkas are polyglots: They speak Hakka, Guangzhouhua, Taishanhua, Hokkien, Putonghua, English, Dutch, French, and if you name a language, there are probably Hakka people who can speak it.
@WinterLamp . @tdzheng .. Why is Hakka frowned upon from then till now? Dr Sun family mentioned in a book that they are Cantonese. I can't understand why Hakka claimed that Dr Sun YS is Hakka. It is such a shameful claim without fact and proof. Why don't Hakka be proud of remarkable Hakka leaders such as former Thai Prime Minister (Thaksin), former Taiwan president (Chen Shui Bian, Lee Teng Hui) and many others....for their corruption charges.
limyangyang 4 months ago
@limyangyang
you should bring your argument to one hakka individual -- Lee Kuan Yew of Singapore.
if you can win an argument against him.... nah, you cant
tekknesss 3 months ago
Hakka is always barbaric. That is why many Hakka had assimilated into Cantonese (HK, Guangzhou), Hokkien (M'sia, S'pore) and Mandarin Chinese (China & Taiwan) and forget their barbaric dialect. Even language u use is so vulgar. Who told U Dr Sun Yat Sen is Hakka? His family is Cantonese.
limyangyang 9 months ago
@limyangyang hakkas were often associated to the taiping rebellion at the time which for your info almost toppled the qing dynasty if not for western help, so even if sun yat sen was a hakka, he wouldn't admit it as it was frowned upon at that time. heck we're all chinese so why bother?
tdzheng 6 months ago
Some hakka people also speak vietnamese as well as cantonese, even though they are not born in China nor never been there. Only because it was their mother tongue. Of course, they often don't know any chinese character.
pat1170 3 years ago
hongkongyan2 (KRATOYlim / limPANTAT) is SUSPENDED!
Another BOGUS ACCOUNT of insane SPAMMER & China-HATER_Hakka-HATER limyangyang aka limPANTAT / limBUTOH / KRATOYlim -- hongkongyan2 is SUSPENDED!
type hongkongyan2 and you will get: "This account is suspended."
ultrableu777 3 years ago
JCCO123 you must keep attacking limyangyang ,the son of a whore.He is trying to instigate the Hakka to hate Cantonese!he is a subversive element .If he is in Sigapore he will be thrown into jail without a trial.He is a classic empty vessel ,self proclaimed historian barking like a mad dog ,disturbing the peace! Don't be nice to him ,use the roughest language you can.He is talking like someone of high authority but in fact a small worm crawling in a pool of shit!Too much shit in his brain!
hakkalow 4 years ago
You are just jealous. The Hakkas were the officer (guan) class in China. Just look at the number of famous political and military leaders of China and other Chinese societies who are Hakkas.
JCCO123 4 years ago
The powerful position in army, government & PLA will always be in the hands of Northerners Mandarin & Shanghainese in the next 50 yrs. Hakka only given some minor positions. As known source of revolutionary, Chinese govwill always be wary of Hakka. Look at Kuomintang, they rather appoint a Minnan VP Candidate. DPP both candidates of President-VP is Minnan. Hakka? They fight 4 independence n slow down Taiwan economy (Chen Shui-bian & Lee Tang-hui)
limyangyang 4 years ago
hakkalow (1 day ago) : "... limyangyang ,the son of a whore ..."
Is it TRUE, limPANTAT?
888DeepBlue 4 years ago
limyangyang, A Stupid Malay like you shud stop crapping about Hakkas, Chu De, Deng Xiao Ping and ye Jianyin were all Hakkas. Stupid fuck that you are. LOL!
Maohammet 2 years ago
Cantonese and English Language combined make Hong Kong Number One Economic Powerhouse. Hong Language had no place in China, Taiwan or anywhere else. That is low class barbaric language spoken by poor n old Hakka living in seclusion in hilly/jungle area. Cantonese is prestige language that many Mandarin speakers in all over China younth is learning. It is so popular. Hakka is shit dialects.
limyangyang 4 years ago
limyangyang, have you actually been to HK? HK is not a no1 Economic Powerhouse. It is very stagnant and relies on outside money to keep it running.
JCCO123 4 years ago
Hong Kong Cantonese will suffer in short term due to control fromBeijing in preference to Shanghai & Beijing. The economy of HK now rely so much from China only. Slowdown started since 1997 handover. But in long term Cantonese power will rise again in Guangdong & HK.
limyangyang 4 years ago
hakkalow (1 day ago) : "... limyangyang ,the son of a whore ..."
Is it TRUE, limPANTAT?
888DeepBlue 4 years ago
Accept this fact
Cantonese is Great Modern Language, with Great Songs; whereas
Hakka is LOW-CLASS language with UGLY songs that sounds like SHIT!!
No wonder Cantonese Language become MAINSTREAM int'l Chinese language like Mandarin & Taiwanese.
Hakka language will FOREVER be sidelined even by Hakkas; as a language of uneducated peasants or hill-tribes peoples call "Guests or Kejia"
SINCE MAJORITY OF HAKKA CAME FROM GUANGDONG, THEY SHOULD ASSIMILATE & SPEAK CANTONESE INSTEAD.
limyangyang 4 years ago
Stupid thought!
You knew nothing about Hakka
So shut up!
uilktj 4 years ago
This world is shitty because there are so many shitty racist people like you.
JCCO123 4 years ago
limyangyang, do you honestly think Hakka people only speak Hakka? Most Hakkas are polyglots: They speak Hakka, Guangzhouhua, Taishanhua, Hokkien, Putonghua, English, Dutch, French, and if you name a language, there are probably Hakka people who can speak it.
JCCO123 4 years ago
if you choose the audiocontrol to right, you will only hear putonghua
zhonghua2006 4 years ago
Interesting video. Could the audio in English be improved, please?
normalie 4 years ago