@hsl1993 The original russian term could be translated as "obsession", which is more accurate than "suggestion". "Suggestion Diabolique" is the most common translation of the title for this piece. Some users stated it before, by the way.
i watched this ar 12 30 at night and the turned the speakers way up without realizing so i could hear the low register opening notes... i nearly jumped off the couch
Grandes pastores evangélicos y sacerdotes católicos gustan de escuchar estas sinfonías y tonos musicales para deleite del oído. Su nombre: obsessión diabolique. De la opera #4 de Prokofiev.
@pieguyfry22 1) soft self portrait with bacon 1941 2) the vertebrate grotto transfer series 1936 3) study of colloque sentimental 1948 4) part od the red orchestra series, sorry, can't name it. 1944 5) face of war 1940-41 6) portrait of picasso 1947 7) bird 1928 8) the temptation of saint anthony 1946 9) portrait of jaun de pareja 1960 10) followers of simon 1951 11) partial hallucination-six apparitions 1931 12) self portrait with neck of raphael 1920
Hmmm... I like some of Prokofiev's work, own a "Freddy Kempff Plays Prokofiev" CD... but this is a very light and happy song, whether he meant it to be or not... Also, I mean, its also not terribly entertaining or cerebral.
If I want piano music of a "diabolique" nature I'll stay with Ligeti Etudes for now =)
Still listening. I'm sorry, I just don't find anything about this song to be... well what we would consider "heavy" and dark now.
A couple tone clusters, a few fff, sure its chromatic, but it all sounds based around a major key (keys) to me. I don't have or feel like analyzing the sheet, is just how it sounds to me.
Again, I find it jovial and light-hearted. Musically there just isn't anything that makes it "dark or heavy" to me.
@EuphoricDan It could be argued that different pieces mean different things to people. But i certainly wouldn't call this piece lighthearted just as i wouldn't call Chopin's Funeral March happy.
Cheerfulness (for me) is in pieces like Schumann's Piano Concerto (3rd mvmt), Not this. I can, however, see an evil being smiling when i hear this. It is satirical, maybe...
Look, I don't want to get into downing this piece of music or what it should mean to other people (seriously). I'll concede that even to me there are some big mischievous themes. To me they are more like kids running around on Halloween. I can very easily see how someone else would think this to be very, well "Diabolical" in nature, lol.
...Wondering what I consider the most cheerful piece... Maybe Ode to Joy (yeah, cop-out). Oh well, I tend towards the heavier stuff.
@EuphoricDan Could you clarify what you mean by "heavy"? You've used it twice & its purpose is vague to me at this point.
"...Maybe Ode to Joy" you see, i'd have never thought of that because (i'll readily admit that) i don't understand a lot of Beethoven's music. Had it not been called "ode to JOY", i probably might have not made the connection. When i listen to it, it looks like a serene tea party set in the 1800s with wigs etc... (Probably because that's the way it's used in movies:D)
Hammered right now. Would love to oblige, will do so when soberness overcomes me tomorrow. Wonderful question though. Is amazing to explore music.
As for Ode to Joy... As I said... Cheery music is generally not my genre. Though I do have some "As My Guitar Gently Weeps (Love version)" running through my speakers as I type.
@EuphoricDan The light nature of the piece only enhances the satirical, caustic delirium of the speaker. The dark feeling, in my opinion, comes from this destruction of mind painted so accurately through Prokofiev's genius.
This is..one of the most fierce, most perfect and cynic piano pieces I have ever enjoyed. Thank you for posting; it really is appriciated. Wonderful artwork, too.
so many of the painting's have a moment where all of a sudden, they click, you realise what is actually there and coupled by Prokofiev i found that quite profound.
This really does capture the anguish one feels when in the rapture of the forbidden, and the frustration of chasing a mystery that is always, always out of reach. This pieace is all tension and no release, because there is no respite from desire.
One of the all-time best piano pieces. This is music that Franz Liszt would have gobbled up! It reminds me very much of Late Liszt, just more percussive.
Fine performance! I wonder who Valentin Bogolubov is. There was a Ukrainian chess player by the name of Yefim Bogolubov many years ago, and I wonder if the pianist is related to him. Anyway, a fine video, though I would prefer to see the performance instead of the Dali paintings.
Dear friend,thank you for your comments!Valentin Bogolubov works actually a lot by the synthesis of the arts (like A.Scriabin's "Music-Light-Image-Dance etc." project).Hi's not related to Yefim Bogolubov.
Awesome *_*
dafTpunKEctriCKmx 1 week ago
It's "suggestion diabolique" =_=
hsl1993 1 month ago
@hsl1993 The original russian term could be translated as "obsession", which is more accurate than "suggestion". "Suggestion Diabolique" is the most common translation of the title for this piece. Some users stated it before, by the way.
QsarShuffler 1 month ago
Do you know the name of one of this pictures?
I´m only know "la piedad"
G1GAR0 1 month ago
The skeleton looks like "One Missed Call"
christiaanmeyer 1 month ago
I love Russian composers. You always get something completely mental from them.
Nakata995 1 month ago
Dali´s surrealism and Prokofiev energy... a great combination
Misducky03 2 months ago 6
@Misducky03
Thank you for your comment.
ValentinAmadeus 2 months ago
realist music and surrealist paints, haha, IT'S PERFECT!!
PabloDelRococo 2 months ago
Remarkable.
carmen71280 2 months ago
Great playing, keep up the good work! You are amazing
ravenpt 2 months ago
Seriously mister Valentine, bloody great job.
SkaalSokrates 2 months ago
:-)
malit1234 3 months ago
@ValentinAmadeus You're so polite
malit1234 3 months ago
AWESOME!!!!
malit1234 3 months ago
@malit1234
Thank you for comment.
Valentin
ValentinAmadeus 3 months ago
This music scares me to death. And I love it.
matheuspa42 3 months ago 9
@matheuspa42
God bless you!
ValentinAmadeus 3 months ago
@matheuspa42 Try alkan's mad woman on the sea shore :)
Vesivian 3 months ago
Bizarre & beautiful
miasmesia 4 months ago 2
@miasmesia
Thank you!
Valentin
ValentinAmadeus 4 months ago
the word genius is too small to describe salvador dali
LohengrinT 4 months ago 4
@LohengrinT
You're right!
Valentin
ValentinAmadeus 4 months ago
@LohengrinT Well, he did proclaim himself exactly that! He also made Alka-Seltzer commercials, so go figure...
shandelear 4 months ago
i watched this ar 12 30 at night and the turned the speakers way up without realizing so i could hear the low register opening notes... i nearly jumped off the couch
shadowmalik009 4 months ago 3
@shadowmalik009
It's what this music's supposed to do!
Thanks!
Valentin
ValentinAmadeus 4 months ago 2
@shadowmalik009 pussy
Goregunzoleuh 4 months ago
Grotesque
theOfficialTrooth 4 months ago
Is the artwork by Salvador Dali? This video is exquisite anyway.
zombieconverse4 4 months ago
@zombieconverse4
Paintings by Salvador Dali, music by Russian composer Sergei Prokofiev.
V.B.
ValentinAmadeus 4 months ago
...Creepy, yet oddly captivating...
redhootie123 5 months ago
you are not right naming this piece obsession. "suggestion diabolique".
odinglaz 5 months ago
@odinglaz
Suggestion diabolique - is a wrong translation of russian word "Наваждение"(Navazdenie).
Obsession - more accurate!
All the best - V.B.
ValentinAmadeus 5 months ago 9
@ValentinAmadeus its pronounced "Navajhdenie"
timsons7777 3 months ago
Great video man! These two enhance the hell out of each other. Particularly the music to the paintings.
Chakiejan 5 months ago 5
@Chakiejan
I'm happy we're on same page!
ValentinAmadeus 5 months ago
It's actually diabolic SUGGESTION, not obsesion
goncalocurto 6 months ago
This is a bad ass combination!
Automathan5388MR 6 months ago
I've heard a lot of pianists tackle this piece but few play it as nicely as this. The visuals are wonderful and fitting, as well.
20somethingstories 6 months ago
@20somethingstories
Thank you, dear friend!
ValentinAmadeus 6 months ago
This piece effin rules
heyaidkwhut 6 months ago
Developed. You should be please. :)
t3tsuyaguy1 6 months ago
fue perturbador y hermoso, gracias por esa interpretación.
rakatanttttt 6 months ago
I hereby proclaim this song to be the official music of one Dr. Victor Frankenstein.
OrionoftheStar 7 months ago
I'll probably never realize if they miss-touched...
CryingBird000 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
es mi interpretacion favorita
jiririji 9 months ago
es mi interpretacion favorita
jiririji 9 months ago
It's only 2:57, long, but it can last an eternity
udistritalextrema 10 months ago 5
@udistritalextrema
Thank you very much! Sincerely - Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 10 months ago
@ValentinAmadeus Since yesterday I have played this video like 20 times at least.
Thanks to you Actually!
udistritalextrema 10 months ago
merveilleux!
csillagasz 11 months ago
Musical Intersect!
MetGriller 1 year ago
Grandes pastores evangélicos y sacerdotes católicos gustan de escuchar estas sinfonías y tonos musicales para deleite del oído. Su nombre: obsessión diabolique. De la opera #4 de Prokofiev.
KAZADORDEKORRUPTOS 1 year ago
@KAZADORDEKORRUPTOS
Muchas Gracias!
ValentinAmadeus 1 year ago
Prokofiev and Dali are a match made in hell
chammasp 1 year ago 4
Excellent mix!!
hotplate85 1 year ago
Isn't this piece called Suggestion Diabolique?
Pianistrocker101 1 year ago
It's Suggestion Diabolique not Obsession Diabolique LOL
aizendarwin 1 year ago 3
@aizendarwin actually it is "obsession diabolique" but it's roughly translated to "diabolical suggestion" , or something o:
MetroidMilkMan 11 months ago
i would love to see a list of all the paintings in this slideshow :)
pieguyfry22 1 year ago 12
1rockcut 2 months ago
suggestion is not an obsession.
Volodyasd 1 year ago
Gracias, Amigo!
ValentinAmadeus 1 year ago
exelente, buena mezcla de la musica y el video
ThePoserMan 1 year ago
No doubt music to my ears.
KAZADORDEKORRUPTOS 1 year ago
thanks! for the video!
malbuono 1 year ago
I love 2:00 for some reason..
Reubunderfull 1 year ago
Merci pour ce clip !
medal8 1 year ago
@medal8
Je suis ravi si vous l'avez aime!
ValentinAmadeus 1 year ago
Anyone else reminded of the original music for Super Mario Bros. when listening to this? Specifically, the underground theme and Bowser's Castle?
TheouAegis 1 year ago
This music is very much in vein like the diabolical pieces of Franz Liszt: mephisto waltzer, Scherzo und Marsh and of course TotenTanz. I like it
dajohnthomas69 1 year ago
Hmmm... I like some of Prokofiev's work, own a "Freddy Kempff Plays Prokofiev" CD... but this is a very light and happy song, whether he meant it to be or not... Also, I mean, its also not terribly entertaining or cerebral.
If I want piano music of a "diabolique" nature I'll stay with Ligeti Etudes for now =)
EuphoricDan 1 year ago
@EuphoricDan "this is a very light and happy song..." Someone needs to listen more carefully :D
th3wing3dpaint3r 1 year ago
@th3wing3dpaint3r
Still listening. I'm sorry, I just don't find anything about this song to be... well what we would consider "heavy" and dark now.
A couple tone clusters, a few fff, sure its chromatic, but it all sounds based around a major key (keys) to me. I don't have or feel like analyzing the sheet, is just how it sounds to me.
Again, I find it jovial and light-hearted. Musically there just isn't anything that makes it "dark or heavy" to me.
EuphoricDan 1 year ago
@EuphoricDan It could be argued that different pieces mean different things to people. But i certainly wouldn't call this piece lighthearted just as i wouldn't call Chopin's Funeral March happy.
Cheerfulness (for me) is in pieces like Schumann's Piano Concerto (3rd mvmt), Not this. I can, however, see an evil being smiling when i hear this. It is satirical, maybe...
th3wing3dpaint3r 1 year ago
@th3wing3dpaint3r
Look, I don't want to get into downing this piece of music or what it should mean to other people (seriously). I'll concede that even to me there are some big mischievous themes. To me they are more like kids running around on Halloween. I can very easily see how someone else would think this to be very, well "Diabolical" in nature, lol.
...Wondering what I consider the most cheerful piece... Maybe Ode to Joy (yeah, cop-out). Oh well, I tend towards the heavier stuff.
EuphoricDan 1 year ago
@EuphoricDan Could you clarify what you mean by "heavy"? You've used it twice & its purpose is vague to me at this point.
"...Maybe Ode to Joy" you see, i'd have never thought of that because (i'll readily admit that) i don't understand a lot of Beethoven's music. Had it not been called "ode to JOY", i probably might have not made the connection. When i listen to it, it looks like a serene tea party set in the 1800s with wigs etc... (Probably because that's the way it's used in movies:D)
th3wing3dpaint3r 1 year ago
@th3wing3dpaint3r
Hammered right now. Would love to oblige, will do so when soberness overcomes me tomorrow. Wonderful question though. Is amazing to explore music.
As for Ode to Joy... As I said... Cheery music is generally not my genre. Though I do have some "As My Guitar Gently Weeps (Love version)" running through my speakers as I type.
Love to people!
EuphoricDan 1 year ago
@EuphoricDan Damn you! now everytime i hear this i see kids playing around at night on Halloween :S
th3wing3dpaint3r 1 year ago
@th3wing3dpaint3r
lmao, I'm sorry
EuphoricDan 1 year ago
@EuphoricDan The light nature of the piece only enhances the satirical, caustic delirium of the speaker. The dark feeling, in my opinion, comes from this destruction of mind painted so accurately through Prokofiev's genius.
eomcello 9 months ago
to the marriage of true minds, let me not admit impediments ... thank you for uploading :-)
spheere1 1 year ago
This is..one of the most fierce, most perfect and cynic piano pieces I have ever enjoyed. Thank you for posting; it really is appriciated. Wonderful artwork, too.
MIICHEMI 1 year ago
I like it very much..
pianotalent 1 year ago
What is the name of the picture at 2:26?
Thanks
FranzLisztian 1 year ago
"suggestion diabolique"
karakuliambro89 1 year ago
Keith Whiteduck would be proud! :)
KeithStreet007 1 year ago
so many of the painting's have a moment where all of a sudden, they click, you realise what is actually there and coupled by Prokofiev i found that quite profound.
coolfool64 1 year ago
Perfect!
MarilynMacron 1 year ago
what's the title of the painting in 0:50?
8Maik 1 year ago
This really does capture the anguish one feels when in the rapture of the forbidden, and the frustration of chasing a mystery that is always, always out of reach. This pieace is all tension and no release, because there is no respite from desire.
Rhademanthus 1 year ago
Amazing use of the tritone! Cerebral and magical.
Amputecht1 1 year ago
Nice video !
Well done indeed.
valeriealmamarie 1 year ago
Devestating.
exlibrismarilyn 1 year ago
a little scary paintings
BNM321zxy 1 year ago
try some pictures of basquiat and bacon.. :D
filopaa1990 1 year ago
Fabulous combination, well done!
mindpastah 2 years ago 2
Great combination, Salvador fits this music really well, colour me impressed;)
nissa2525 2 years ago 4
This is what youtube is all about, Well done!
malibu64 2 years ago 5
The music, the artwork, the editing. They all fit together so well... Brilliant!
Spareknikov 2 years ago 16
Y faltaron los sueños liquidos! buenisimo!
Arthud2 2 years ago 3
This video is fantastic....
One of the best i've ever seen in Utube!
1978christos 2 years ago 2
Wonderful
yaotzin216 2 years ago 2
Great idea putting this to the work of Dali.
mahler151 2 years ago 5
Agreed; wonderful pairing!
manlyman80345 2 years ago 2
Thank you !
24Hermes 2 years ago
This is from another realm, far from this plane.
Remoxx 2 years ago
Yuck.
7855waldo 2 years ago
Splendide musique !! Dali est superbe !!!
AinsiSoitJeLoli 2 years ago
Anyone know the painting at 1:14??????
ibanezmannn 2 years ago
any one how knows that crazy painting at 2:19?
rapeking 2 years ago
That's Dali's "The Temptation of St. Anthony"
Aerovistae 2 years ago
'The Temptation of Saint Anthony' by Salvador Dali. :-)
codeman2008 2 years ago 5
what is the correct name of this piece? obsession or suggestion diabolique?
interceptor6 2 years ago
suggestion diabolique
JoshDuJour 2 years ago 2
Huh... that was pretty freakin cool! It's been said a dozen times, but I'll say it again. Awesome combo!
Lymphaticnessicity 2 years ago
woooooooow fantastic glissando!!!!
dsyglym 2 years ago
Dear god, I love too much Dali and this obsession diabolique, a-m-a-z-i-n-g
PhilosopheClassique 2 years ago 8
Thank you so much, dear Philosophe!
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago 2
Wow, these two really match together.
A great, fantastic work. Excellent!
pyskute 2 years ago 14
Thank you very much , dear friend! Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
im your pain when you cant feel...
xdarkfalcox 2 years ago 2
Bravo!
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
It's Suggestion diabolique not Obsession =)
dsyglym 2 years ago 5
what the name of the painting at 0:43
suicideclub 2 years ago
The name is "Sentimental Colloquy". All the best - Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
i mean the one right before that
suicideclub 2 years ago
"Two Figures"
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
Those images.. Oh god!
Gilgamoosh 2 years ago 2
Is that surrealism in your video?
turokcalde 2 years ago
No,dear friend it's the true life! Sincerely - Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
Haha, life is surreal!
turokcalde 2 years ago 2
Thanks!
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
1:45 great! Just discovered it!!
Aikobako 2 years ago
this piece is played awesomely,it contains such a morbid atmosphere,sounds really like satan suggested the notes to this masterpiece
strangehands89 2 years ago 2
Yes, so is it! But this kind of interpretation demands a lot of inner transparency from the pianist! Best regards - Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
One of the all-time best piano pieces. This is music that Franz Liszt would have gobbled up! It reminds me very much of Late Liszt, just more percussive.
shortestgiant 2 years ago
You're so right, dear friend! It's an absolute master-piece full of inspiration. All the best - Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shit pictures but good music EEK
LeAzEMOval 2 years ago
Artistically orgasmic....
azharoslan 2 years ago 2
Well chosen paintings. Many of them reflect that mysterious, bizarre and naughtly dark accent from this magnifical piece.
nKLsblahvlahblah 2 years ago 2
Not many pieces of music can surpass Suggestion Diabolique.
pikachun00b7 2 years ago 3
The title is "suggestion", not "obsession"
tigrankalevian 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Ahhh.. I must subscribe to you haha
iluvS2music 2 years ago
Ah.. I must subscribe to you haha
iluvS2music 2 years ago
This performance is unbelievable. I have learned from you. Thank you.
tranceoxide 3 years ago
Thank you, dear friend!
ValentinAmadeus 3 years ago
You have a nice taste in art.
Kalen1457 3 years ago 2
Suggestion not Obsession... :(
WojciechPiotrowicz 3 years ago 5
The paintings conflate so well with this music. Great collage!
Kneenibble 3 years ago
Prokofiev is amazing. Such energy and musicality!
auresius88 3 years ago 3
Man is strange, or as Strindberg said:"I pity mankind"
Faxe90Swe 3 years ago 2
scuse me but this song is call..SUGGESTION IN DIABOLIQUE
Polorf 3 years ago 3
Dear friend,this is bad translation from russian "Navajdenie". Obsession diabolique(in french) sounds more correctly. All the best-Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 3 years ago
this is beautiful ! do you have any recommendations for a beginner to classical music ?
thank you
acortez48 3 years ago
what do you mean?
StrmUndDrng 2 years ago
are you asking for recommendations for composers? i'd stick with the russians, hehe, rachmaninoff, shostakovich, tchaikovsky :)
phiastardust 2 years ago
For beginners?
Pollther 2 years ago
the music alone never appealed to me...but with the paintings it's extraordinarily demented.
i love it!
Atropos911 3 years ago
Fine performance! I wonder who Valentin Bogolubov is. There was a Ukrainian chess player by the name of Yefim Bogolubov many years ago, and I wonder if the pianist is related to him. Anyway, a fine video, though I would prefer to see the performance instead of the Dali paintings.
ssprokofiev 3 years ago
Dear friend,thank you for your comments!Valentin Bogolubov works actually a lot by the synthesis of the arts (like A.Scriabin's "Music-Light-Image-Dance etc." project).Hi's not related to Yefim Bogolubov.
ValentinAmadeus 3 years ago
tHANK yOU VERY MUSIC fOR Dali's paintings!!!
fatherwkd 3 years ago
I'm happy you like it.Best regards-Valentin.
ValentinAmadeus 3 years ago