i understand; will work on it and see; some pieces sound better in a higher fret; i play Couperin's Barricades in the 2nd, also Mudarra's Fantasia 10. The prelude seems a lot to work out; did it take you long?
@MrReinhardj well, i learned a lot with this piece (the suite actually) so, i think its good to take some time with this piece... i think it has for sure more tricky parts than prelude bwv 998 for example, but maybe this is individual...
Beautiful, very nice playing..i couldn't resist to download it and the notes from Classical Guitar Forum and start right away. It seems you prefer B minor to A, any reason? Now i read those commentaries below..
I think it is actually being played in C-minor. The original suite was composed in C-minor for the lute, but is usually transcribed into A minor for guitar. Ronny is probably performing in C-minor to keep some originality of key.
that was one reason behind it.. i play capo 2nd fret . which my guitar tuned to 443 so it sounds to a "low" c-minor... besides thta i can play different (more musical) fingerings with stretchs because the frets are closer....
thx! just bought a baroque lute... so check in some time...i hope it´s gonna be even "closer" to the original sound! if you need any help for 997 let me know... :)
I love this piece. It's very difficult to play.I know because I've tried to get through it. In A minor though. In a year or so, I'll be able to make it sound like actual music. You've played it wonderfully. Hats off to you,sir.
Yes, I play bach a lot (tends to take too much place in my concerts program, but I don't care!), and if I had to choose only 1 piece in all his luth works it would be 997 prelude... I have a spruce from Sato (1996) that sounds a bit like yours, that's why I asked ! Seems that the difference between materials sometime grow blurred...
Great moving, good thinking! I usely do not like the option of multiple strings fingerings, as the notes are confusing between themselves, but I have to say the result is very interesting here.The only thing for me is the 1st note, as I do not believe it's possible to make sound harmonic notes as part of the melody like normal notes : the sound is too different (the octave between the two 1st notes of the bass is not disturbing, I think). Anyway thanks a lot! Is the guitar in cedar or in spruce?
Very nice! Keep them coming. Though, you seem to be overcompensating because of the comments in a previous video about not wearing a shirt. Come on! Go au natural! If it was good enough for Lara St. John, it's good enough for you! :-)
Great job! I play this too. It is full of tong twister fingerings. Keep up the great playing
ericmusicable 6 months ago
i understand; will work on it and see; some pieces sound better in a higher fret; i play Couperin's Barricades in the 2nd, also Mudarra's Fantasia 10. The prelude seems a lot to work out; did it take you long?
MrReinhardj 6 months ago
@MrReinhardj well, i learned a lot with this piece (the suite actually) so, i think its good to take some time with this piece... i think it has for sure more tricky parts than prelude bwv 998 for example, but maybe this is individual...
LittleBigManGuitar 6 months ago
Beautiful, very nice playing..i couldn't resist to download it and the notes from Classical Guitar Forum and start right away. It seems you prefer B minor to A, any reason? Now i read those commentaries below..
MrReinhardj 6 months ago
@MrReinhardj
a 443 b is almost a "early music" c ... this and the fingerings-reasons why i put a capo on 2nd fret...
greets anf thx for the comment!!!
LittleBigManGuitar 6 months ago
I like your playing. But why do you pump up your tags with all the big names? Are you suggesting you are in the same row? Hmm ...
TheMusicalEvents 7 months ago
Very nice work .Thumb up.J.C.
glaoud 8 months ago
BRAVO!!!!!!
IDBChops 10 months ago
You're really great.
jmspeters 1 year ago
I'm normaly a rock guitar player but i just enjoy to listen to this great music.
hunzl3 1 year ago
isn`t it faster? anyway... great job =)
tks for share
maurorock445 2 years ago
well played!
problembox 2 years ago
you play it in a swing... It changes the whole mellody
Roukangas 2 years ago
Umm... This isn't a swing... It's got a fair amount of rubato but there's no swinging in there
Ponchothewise 2 years ago
In D-minor ? Most seem to play it in A-minor, but it's nice to hear it in onather key...
hrowloph 2 years ago
I think it is actually being played in C-minor. The original suite was composed in C-minor for the lute, but is usually transcribed into A minor for guitar. Ronny is probably performing in C-minor to keep some originality of key.
dracula126 2 years ago
@dracula126
that was one reason behind it.. i play capo 2nd fret . which my guitar tuned to 443 so it sounds to a "low" c-minor... besides thta i can play different (more musical) fingerings with stretchs because the frets are closer....
LittleBigManGuitar 2 years ago
yes this suite is a testicle cruncher ;)
Well played, very nicely done!
Matt
mattsuzo 2 years ago
how can i learn to play this?? please help me out so i can!!
guitarzshredz626 2 years ago
Comment removed
murtsworld666 2 years ago
Beautiful transcription and playing.
raulcalderonbird 2 years ago
great music and one of the best 997 preludes on youtube. thanks! :)
kedonsiemen 2 years ago
i love this so much! Bach is genius!
ziboooka 2 years ago
Man.. Extremely clean and well played. I just started learning this piece... it's not easy:) but, after some months I hope I will master it!
JSB rules!!
Reference21 2 years ago
thx! just bought a baroque lute... so check in some time...i hope it´s gonna be even "closer" to the original sound! if you need any help for 997 let me know... :)
LittleBigManGuitar 2 years ago
im working on this... it's a long ride xd...
koporcic 3 years ago
hi! yes definitly one of the most difficult pieces i played (the whole suite is amazing beautiful, but amazing hard to play...)
LittleBigManGuitar 3 years ago
nice job
simpson1901 3 years ago
Lovely...lots of expression and all the right fingerings..so the bass notes staying on nicely x
louwhatling 3 years ago
hello Ronny, lovel sound and a very good interpratation, i liked it, bravo, jarods
yarods 3 years ago
I love this piece and you do it nicely. Clean and consistent. Thanks for posting.
lucassalazar 3 years ago
The passagens on 1:31 are very bold, well done. I just dont like the fast beggining, the entrance, I rather play it as and symphony, more slowly.
fl4vio 4 years ago
You have made my day !!
kwatube08 4 years ago 2
Sehr schön gespielt, Gratulation! JSB ist der Größte von Allen!
alvaro444 4 years ago
Super gespielt, schönes Video!
Danke für's posten! :)
BbMinor 4 years ago 2
I love this piece. It's very difficult to play.I know because I've tried to get through it. In A minor though. In a year or so, I'll be able to make it sound like actual music. You've played it wonderfully. Hats off to you,sir.
ProtoCosmos 4 years ago
nnnnnnnice!!! that must have taken a lot of effort, i liked it very much.
i want to learn that tune now :-)
insaneguitarfreak 4 years ago
YES!!! Beautifully done. I love this piece so much and you are definitely doing it justice. Thanks.
lucassalazar 4 years ago
Yes, I play bach a lot (tends to take too much place in my concerts program, but I don't care!), and if I had to choose only 1 piece in all his luth works it would be 997 prelude... I have a spruce from Sato (1996) that sounds a bit like yours, that's why I asked ! Seems that the difference between materials sometime grow blurred...
dadalaidou 4 years ago
Great moving, good thinking! I usely do not like the option of multiple strings fingerings, as the notes are confusing between themselves, but I have to say the result is very interesting here.The only thing for me is the 1st note, as I do not believe it's possible to make sound harmonic notes as part of the melody like normal notes : the sound is too different (the octave between the two 1st notes of the bass is not disturbing, I think). Anyway thanks a lot! Is the guitar in cedar or in spruce?
dadalaidou 4 years ago
hi!
its made by boguslaw teryks
he is an amazing guy, living in germany (close to frankfurt)
amazing good guitars:-)
cheers ronny
LittleBigManGuitar 4 years ago
Is this a double top or just standard?
ImaGuitaristDawg 4 years ago
it´s a double top ....
LittleBigManGuitar 4 years ago
What kind of guitar is this?
Abs0lutGuitar 4 years ago
Exzellentes Video, vielen Dank Ronny!! Grüße
wolllfang 4 years ago
Very nice! Keep them coming. Though, you seem to be overcompensating because of the comments in a previous video about not wearing a shirt. Come on! Go au natural! If it was good enough for Lara St. John, it's good enough for you! :-)
DaveGrossmanSoloBass 4 years ago