This version has much better tone, I think, than the others. Also, it's the version I recall hearing back on an oldies station about a decade and a half ago (so of course none of the others feel quite the same).
There were actually three versions. The other "lost" version is on "The Complete Motown Singles, Vol. 1" and that version is also stated as the original Detroit version. So which version is the original Detroit recording? Maybe no one remembers. Nevertheless, this particular version is now available on the "Depend On Me" box set on Hip-O Select. Nice guitar work!
@tas6010 Agree. This is a different version to the 'Original Detroit version' that was issued on the Miracles 35th Anniversary box set. That is much slower and doesn't have the funky guitar and prominent saxophone as this version does. According to the 'Don't Forget T|he Motorcity' site, there were two regional versions, with the second version being the one that is on the 35th Anniversary box set. The other regional version (maybe this one) is on the 'Depend On Me: The Early Albums' CD set.
Mama's give some damned good advise sometimes..I wish i had listened to my mama, but i had to get hit over the head with a brick every time before i paid attention.
What is the difference between a Detroit Black and a Louisiana Black? a In Louisiana they eat Chicken witha side order of greens: detroit they eat their chicken with a .45 or .38 by their side
b In Detroit they dig Motown: In la., they dig ditches
c in La. blacks and white try to co-exist together,in detroit blacks and whites co-exist together in DIFFERENT NEIGHBORHOODS
d In Detroit, young black men worked in the auto industry: in La. ,young black men too-stealing cars
Thanks for posting this!!! I've always wanted to hear it after hearing Smoke speak about Berry calling him in the wee hours to get the group back into the studio to re-record it with various changes that BG made. If I recall, Berry is on the piano on the remake. Although I like this, I must admit that I do like the remake much better!
My oldest sister had promotional copy of this record she got from a friend at Motown back in 1960. I have heard other copies of this recording and THEY DID NOT SOUND LIKE THIS ONE.
How can it be- this is the recording that I fell in love with in late '60/early '61at home in Manhattan and in school in Connecticut. I've always assumed that the other version was the LP version. I'm also sure, but I couldn't swear it, that the single that I bought at the time was this version. Anyway, it's one of my favorite records of those golden years and a record that I associate with another favorite which came out at the exact same time, "Will You Love Me Tomorrow" by The Shirelles.
One of the Motown autobiographies stated this was released in Detroit, Berry wasn't happy, had all copies retrieved, and they worked on it real quick and reissued the big selling version.
My oldest sister had this version (her boyfriend got it for her). The words; Bills voice inflections, and some of the musical arrangement were different. But the national release was much more consistent with the pop times of that day. This was the song that put Motown on the map (1st Hit!) and alerted Detroiters of Motown. On the national release, the flip-side also became a hit (whos lovin you). We would slow-drag to this song.
I had this version since I was from the Detroit area. When I heard the national version, I couldn't understand why they were different. Thanks for posting.
Yes I had never heard this version before,while I love that one better,this one is really great also.But I prefer the other one.This song is from 1960,49 years ago!
The difference between the 2 versions is that whilst this one is guitar led, the hit version is piano led, which for me was the right way to go with the song. Probably one of the finest pop songs ever recorded in my humble opinion and a superb vocal by Smokey Robinson.
This version has that raw feel to it. Not as polished and more spontanious. More soul in the vocals, sounds like the band is just jamming and having a great time!
Not sure which version I prefer. To me, Smokey sings this one a bit better, and I prefer the tempo, but the guitar obbligato near the end of the bridge sounds out of place and the change to the break is too abrupt. The second, "national hit" version is tighter, but overall not quite as interesting. Thanks for uncovering this hidden gem.
Maybe a platitude but they really don't make songs like that anymore, and it's a damn shame too. This song rocks. Can't decide which version I like better, though, so I'll play them both.
Thank you for the music history! It is sad that most of the music made before I was even born is better than my contemporary music. I like this version also, I never knew it existed.
Wasn't this version in one of those Motown-music inspired movies? I swear I heard this version before--Cooley High, Good Morning Vietnam, that ensemble movie with Glenn Close, Hurt and Kevin Kline, et al? I just can't remember the name of the movie....
In 1960, I was a sophomore in high school ... At a high school dance (record hop) when this record was put on all of us would STREAM onto the dance floor. Is now and always has been one of the best dance songs ever put out!!! Go Smokey and the Miracles!!!!
This version is pretty rare. The hit version can be found on all of the albums including "Greatest Hits from the Beginning", "Anthology" and a number of CD's and album compilations. The Detroit version of "Shop Around" is rare, but I've never heard this version before, but I prefer a better hit version. Thanks for putting that up.
@weightfeather1 Miracle Marv Tarplin's guitar is heard more prominently on this version than on the national hit version.
williamg2552 3 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for The Miracles
This version has much better tone, I think, than the others. Also, it's the version I recall hearing back on an oldies station about a decade and a half ago (so of course none of the others feel quite the same).
bohemianhare 4 months ago
that Tamla lable was named after Smokey's daughter, thats how he made money, he had a couple lables too
kabooki09 8 months ago
There were actually three versions. The other "lost" version is on "The Complete Motown Singles, Vol. 1" and that version is also stated as the original Detroit version. So which version is the original Detroit recording? Maybe no one remembers. Nevertheless, this particular version is now available on the "Depend On Me" box set on Hip-O Select. Nice guitar work!
tas6010 10 months ago
@tas6010 Agree. This is a different version to the 'Original Detroit version' that was issued on the Miracles 35th Anniversary box set. That is much slower and doesn't have the funky guitar and prominent saxophone as this version does. According to the 'Don't Forget T|he Motorcity' site, there were two regional versions, with the second version being the one that is on the 35th Anniversary box set. The other regional version (maybe this one) is on the 'Depend On Me: The Early Albums' CD set.
Bradburger 1 week ago
@Bradburger Here is the version that's on the 35th anniversary set: -
youtube.com/watch?v=O3aPe3Qid98&feature=fvst
Bradburger 1 week ago
Mama's give some damned good advise sometimes..I wish i had listened to my mama, but i had to get hit over the head with a brick every time before i paid attention.
DrFeelRotten 11 months ago
what a great find,theirs history behind the record
jac5562 11 months ago
Absolutely love this - but can't make up my mind which version I like best !! x Love 'em both !!!
soulhoney56 1 year ago
@weightfeather1 For me that guitar is hella bliss. Kickin in @ 1:02 it grabs the nuts. It's not out of tune, it's micro-pitching into the gutter.
strandwolf 1 year ago
Loooord A'mighty. This RUUUULES.
jasonpfinch 1 year ago
Loooord Almighty. This RUUUULES.
jasonpfinch 1 year ago
What is the difference between a Detroit Black and a Louisiana Black? a In Louisiana they eat Chicken witha side order of greens: detroit they eat their chicken with a .45 or .38 by their side
b In Detroit they dig Motown: In la., they dig ditches
c in La. blacks and white try to co-exist together,in detroit blacks and whites co-exist together in DIFFERENT NEIGHBORHOODS
d In Detroit, young black men worked in the auto industry: in La. ,young black men too-stealing cars
teehonky 1 year ago
@teehonky very funny. Not.
jasonpfinch 1 year ago
@jasonpfinch Jason...go FINCH urself
teehonky 1 year ago
@teehonky OK, OK, calm down
jasonpfinch 1 year ago
Is it just me or does this version have a very garage band type feel to it?
bat115 1 year ago
Thanks for posting this!!! I've always wanted to hear it after hearing Smoke speak about Berry calling him in the wee hours to get the group back into the studio to re-record it with various changes that BG made. If I recall, Berry is on the piano on the remake. Although I like this, I must admit that I do like the remake much better!
false7sab 1 year ago
I like Helen Shapiro s version a lot, too ))
this one is cool
moscowandy 1 year ago
My oldest sister had promotional copy of this record she got from a friend at Motown back in 1960. I have heard other copies of this recording and THEY DID NOT SOUND LIKE THIS ONE.
xunclexx 1 year ago
How can it be- this is the recording that I fell in love with in late '60/early '61at home in Manhattan and in school in Connecticut. I've always assumed that the other version was the LP version. I'm also sure, but I couldn't swear it, that the single that I bought at the time was this version. Anyway, it's one of my favorite records of those golden years and a record that I associate with another favorite which came out at the exact same time, "Will You Love Me Tomorrow" by The Shirelles.
SandViolet 1 year ago
I like this. Has more of a funky feel than the national version.
canonet17 1 year ago
60's ! COME BACK PLZ :(
felipebrasil5 1 year ago
This is the version I grew up with. Love it!
yonnie1947 2 years ago
this is better, it does not have the 60's goin' to a go-go sound, but has a 50's sound to it AKA motown sound .that's right ...
markantonymcwhorter 2 years ago
start it at 0:50 if you want to hear the record rather than some egotist talking about it
jasonpfinch 2 years ago
I just found a 45 reissue of this version on the later TAMLA brown and yellow label
RockinEd 2 years ago
One of the Motown autobiographies stated this was released in Detroit, Berry wasn't happy, had all copies retrieved, and they worked on it real quick and reissued the big selling version.
srercrcr 2 years ago
save the vinyl's
palmrockbermuda 2 years ago
Thank you! I actually prefer this to the Billboard version. Nice and easy.
asubant 2 years ago
Comment removed
alotfallend364 2 years ago
My oldest sister had this version (her boyfriend got it for her). The words; Bills voice inflections, and some of the musical arrangement were different. But the national release was much more consistent with the pop times of that day. This was the song that put Motown on the map (1st Hit!) and alerted Detroiters of Motown. On the national release, the flip-side also became a hit (whos lovin you). We would slow-drag to this song.
xunclexx 2 years ago
I had this version since I was from the Detroit area. When I heard the national version, I couldn't understand why they were different. Thanks for posting.
MiscVideos7 2 years ago
I 've been wanting to hear this. Thanks bankman58!
shnen2 2 years ago
Wow! Haven't heard this one. Nice variation of the more familiar version. Actually, that one is really a variation of THIS :) Thanks!
McSurly 2 years ago
wow, I use to have the "45" probably still do. This is the original as far as I know. Brings back memories.....cool....
betsoutdoors 2 years ago
thanks for posting this one , i never heard this version before . i like this one better.. i played this song for my youing son.
carolyrrh 2 years ago
Still good advice to young people everywhere. :-)
Smokey, SO COOL! Great Detroit music!
justmusicandme 2 years ago
This is good,there will never be great music like this anymore
margaret30575 2 years ago
Thanks....what a great recording!
lowsparksister 2 years ago
this is the best of the 2 recordings
joehancock01 2 years ago
Yes I had never heard this version before,while I love that one better,this one is really great also.But I prefer the other one.This song is from 1960,49 years ago!
nema1218 2 years ago
This version is funkier than the national version. I guess Berry Gordy was looking for a more commercial sound
cbjrcher 2 years ago
The difference between the 2 versions is that whilst this one is guitar led, the hit version is piano led, which for me was the right way to go with the song. Probably one of the finest pop songs ever recorded in my humble opinion and a superb vocal by Smokey Robinson.
flimbambo 2 years ago
this one is a lil slower than the more popular one
kyle41894 2 years ago
This version has that raw feel to it. Not as polished and more spontanious. More soul in the vocals, sounds like the band is just jamming and having a great time!
lgwelsh1 2 years ago 6
Dayum I didnt no they had 2 version to this song (Who is this)??
tryyoluck 2 years ago
Not sure which version I prefer. To me, Smokey sings this one a bit better, and I prefer the tempo, but the guitar obbligato near the end of the bridge sounds out of place and the change to the break is too abrupt. The second, "national hit" version is tighter, but overall not quite as interesting. Thanks for uncovering this hidden gem.
BFF1 3 years ago
Okay, I've heard both versions and don't know which one I like the best...let's face it, both are great!!
Lovelymiz 3 years ago 6
Yes! I remember it! Oh, to be in Detroit in 1960!! The radio was attached to my ear. Thank You.
justmusicandme 3 years ago
I prefer this version =)
Individuell83 3 years ago 2
incredible!!!! tuffest
strictlyfabio 3 years ago
Has anyone seen a copy of a two-record set album titled,"Miracles, In the Beggining?"
chezvous68 3 years ago
Dare all good who gives a f*** some salesman from the record company iving it
dogsbreath101 3 years ago
i had no idea this version was reissued on 45. wow.
losttouchwithreality 3 years ago
Maybe a platitude but they really don't make songs like that anymore, and it's a damn shame too. This song rocks. Can't decide which version I like better, though, so I'll play them both.
youvexme 3 years ago
Thank you for the music history! It is sad that most of the music made before I was even born is better than my contemporary music. I like this version also, I never knew it existed.
kooljuice93 3 years ago 2
Wow! Never heard this version before seeing this post. Quite a find!
57Will 3 years ago
Wow......First time I heard this...where do you all find these gems?
ioxxd90 3 years ago 3
I found them in various record auctions and in Oldies record shops in the N.Y. area.
bankman58 3 years ago
Thanks man. I am a record collector. That's priceless.
ioxxd90 3 years ago
is that bubble wrap you're using as a slipmat? i've got to try that.
soln4suh 3 years ago
Wasn't this version in one of those Motown-music inspired movies? I swear I heard this version before--Cooley High, Good Morning Vietnam, that ensemble movie with Glenn Close, Hurt and Kevin Kline, et al? I just can't remember the name of the movie....
bornwithaBA 3 years ago
In 1960, I was a sophomore in high school ... At a high school dance (record hop) when this record was put on all of us would STREAM onto the dance floor. Is now and always has been one of the best dance songs ever put out!!! Go Smokey and the Miracles!!!!
kookoocachoo29 3 years ago 3
The single was first released on the "striped" Tamla label, but it was reissued with the globes, and then the "bar" design.
BrooklynMouse 3 years ago
This version is pretty rare. The hit version can be found on all of the albums including "Greatest Hits from the Beginning", "Anthology" and a number of CD's and album compilations. The Detroit version of "Shop Around" is rare, but I've never heard this version before, but I prefer a better hit version. Thanks for putting that up.
BrooklynMouse 4 years ago
Cool version. Might be better than the faster version.
farfo61 4 years ago 2
David Archuleta's version is way better! But man, this song's got power ;)
linrocksyou 4 years ago
wow this is awsome, i never knew this version came out on the globes, i posted a vid on the Detroit version of Way Over There
MotownMaster 4 years ago