My guess is that most people grew up knowing the version from PCL, but I was the opposite. I had this Peel Session on Cassette back in the 90s when I was in high school. I didn't buy PCL until I was nearly thirty. I like both versions, but this will always be my favorite. Like others have said, this version sounds like it is its own song versus the Blue Monday-like version found on PCL. Great, great stuff!
Indeed. But I was going PCL, what the f*ck is he on about ? Then the lighbulb in my head: "Power, Corruption and Lies". Well it was a long, long time ago...
Wow. Never heard this version. Opening synths are KILLER. I'm a life long NO fan, and Youtube allows me to discover new stuff by them. And this is by far the best that I had never heard before....
This is off PCAL and not Movement, so doubt Peel effected the sale of Movement with his comments. Great track though, Blue Monday precursor, NO in full Moroder rip-off :)
Just noticed this ! JP was slagging some of the production of some of the songs on Movement, saying how bad they were compared to how good they were done on the session versions.
Well I remember JP himself saying he preferred their session versions to the album versions. In fact he positively put the boot into the versions on "Movement". I remember listening to him saying it on that particular show, and with his droll manner he just cracked me up completely !
There were 2 New Order Peel Sessions CDs released many years back. Each had 4 tracks. One was from their Movement period including Dreams Never End and ICBM. The second was from the Power, Corruption & Lies period and included this excellent version of 586.
I think it's from "Top Of The Pops", when they actually played "Blue Monday" live - a "privilege" allowed to very few groups, although I remember Sham 69 being allowed to play live so that Jimmy Pursey could shout to his Mum "Who's on Top Of The Pops then, eh?!"
But I'm probably totally wrong! It's perhaps a photo taken in the Hacienda Club.
Sorry I can't be more specific, as I just nicked it from Google.
I love this picture (and tune lol).... It is from the top of the pops performance but I think it might be from the soundcheck or something 'cos Barney is wearing a different shirt!
I always preferred this to 'Blue Monday'. I bought the Peel Sessions on vinyl around the same time that I got PCL on cassette and loved them both.
repose1983 2 weeks ago
@repose1983
Blue Monday, which I initially thought was great, has been so overplayed I can't stand the song now.
roddy76to86 1 week ago
I never heard this version until today and I can't stop listening to it. A new favourite of mine for sure, thanks a million for uploading it.
mravka9 4 weeks ago
YES COOL SONG AND WELCOME EVERYBODY ON YOUTUBE ZIRGLE AND THE WAVES
christophezirgle 1 month ago
This version's the Daddy.
Daveloves586 1 month ago 2
COOL TRACK , WELCOME ON YOUTUBE ZIRGLE ANDTHE WAVES ELECTRO SYNTH MUSIC
christophezirgle 2 months ago
love the synthetic 'whip' snare in this...great sound and awesome start to the song too
cresshead 5 months ago 2
My guess is that most people grew up knowing the version from PCL, but I was the opposite. I had this Peel Session on Cassette back in the 90s when I was in high school. I didn't buy PCL until I was nearly thirty. I like both versions, but this will always be my favorite. Like others have said, this version sounds like it is its own song versus the Blue Monday-like version found on PCL. Great, great stuff!
Procopius1980 8 months ago in playlist My Music
@Procopius1980
Indeed. But I was going PCL, what the f*ck is he on about ? Then the lighbulb in my head: "Power, Corruption and Lies". Well it was a long, long time ago...
roddy76to86 8 months ago
@roddy76to86
It probably would have helped if I had put PC&L, which is a way I have seen it abbreviated in the past. Let me contribute my thanks for posting!
Procopius1980 8 months ago in playlist My Music
@Procopius1980
My pleasure.
No problem, it was quite funny. My brain ticking over in bafflement, and then suddenly the answer was there !
roddy76to86 8 months ago
@Procopius1980 we will talk later I hear you calling
\
ralphrocksoff 8 months ago
all-time top ten New Order tune - IMHO
Eisonhawk 10 months ago
@Eisonhawk
I'd say top three.
mravka9 4 weeks ago
C(K)urtis, where are you, my friend?
invitriol123 11 months ago
Sounds less like Blue Monday than the album version. More of its own song.
AdobeGillis 11 months ago
Wow. Never heard this version. Opening synths are KILLER. I'm a life long NO fan, and Youtube allows me to discover new stuff by them. And this is by far the best that I had never heard before....
RainPoetry 1 year ago
@RainPoetry
Yes, it is rather good, isn't it ? I've just listened to it myself, which I don't think I've done since I uploaded it over 2 years ago !
roddy76to86 1 year ago
@roddy76to86 Forgot to mention: thanks SO much for uploading.
RainPoetry 1 year ago
@RainPoetry
My pleasure !
roddy76to86 1 year ago
Comment removed
makuus12 1 year ago
really surprised - never heard it. GREAT VERSION !!! thanks very much.
mk2007al 1 year ago
TRUST NO ONE, NOT EVEN YOUR FRIENDS. THE WORLD IS YOUR ENEMY!!!!
movementsofhumanbody 1 year ago
@movementsofhumanbody Thank you Mulder. X-Files finished some time ago.
Tokyoesque 1 year ago
far far better than the album version.
jupste66 1 year ago
Much darker than the album version. I like it!
Gorette66 1 year ago
I like the PCL version, but this is New Order as they should have been!
Procopius1980 1 year ago
fuck i had this on a tape yrs ago great song
joydivision808 2 years ago 2
This is off PCAL and not Movement, so doubt Peel effected the sale of Movement with his comments. Great track though, Blue Monday precursor, NO in full Moroder rip-off :)
bestyleeds 2 years ago
Just noticed this ! JP was slagging some of the production of some of the songs on Movement, saying how bad they were compared to how good they were done on the session versions.
And yes, this song wasn't one of them.
roddy76to86 2 years ago
i had the original taped off the radio for years ho ho much better than the album version imho
pagglejamia 2 years ago
Some of New Orders 'Peel Session' work is fantastic. This is pretty cool stuff. Never heard this before. Many thanks :)
ghosttroop 2 years ago 2
Well I remember JP himself saying he preferred their session versions to the album versions. In fact he positively put the boot into the versions on "Movement". I remember listening to him saying it on that particular show, and with his droll manner he just cracked me up completely !
roddy76to86 2 years ago
@roddy76to86 who cares what he thought, he's just another person, i love the versions on movement
chrisnoaro1 1 year ago
Is there anywhere one can buy this?
ftheGOP 2 years ago
Try Amazon, that's where I got it, but a couple of years ago. It's part of a "Peel Sessions" CD, with some other great New order tracks.
roddy76to86 2 years ago
There were 2 New Order Peel Sessions CDs released many years back. Each had 4 tracks. One was from their Movement period including Dreams Never End and ICBM. The second was from the Power, Corruption & Lies period and included this excellent version of 586.
sinfanti 2 years ago
Did Stephen Morris sing on one of the versions?
NYYMGMG 3 years ago
I'm afraid that I've got no idea.
roddy76to86 3 years ago
no he didn't
ady10001 2 years ago
Does he sing anywhere though? And do you know if it was him who was responsible for writing the musical arrangements for this song? Thanks.
NYYMGMG 2 years ago
I'm afraid I've still no idea !
roddy76to86 2 years ago
from what performance is that still image?
seeeiii 3 years ago
I think it's from "Top Of The Pops", when they actually played "Blue Monday" live - a "privilege" allowed to very few groups, although I remember Sham 69 being allowed to play live so that Jimmy Pursey could shout to his Mum "Who's on Top Of The Pops then, eh?!"
But I'm probably totally wrong! It's perhaps a photo taken in the Hacienda Club.
Sorry I can't be more specific, as I just nicked it from Google.
roddy76to86 3 years ago
You're spot on... it's taken from the appearence on Top Of The Pops when they performed a shorter version of Blue Monday live
lioii 3 years ago 2
Thank you. Always nice to get a bit of confirmation !
roddy76to86 3 years ago
I love this picture (and tune lol).... It is from the top of the pops performance but I think it might be from the soundcheck or something 'cos Barney is wearing a different shirt!
Can you send me a copy ?
:)
themanamp 3 years ago
As far as I know there's no way of forwarding photos on YouTube.
But if you just Google "New Order", there it is, fourth from the left !
roddy76to86 3 years ago
Ohh this is damn good! One of my fav New Order songs
Chod1977 3 years ago 2
its really good;D
wot2wot2 3 years ago 2
its really nice! :D
bobimpotent 3 years ago 2