He sucks how did he get the job is he maybe a seacret relation this kid can barely ake it through a hack version of the song.,., watch the reissue concerts .,,., just doesnt make sense i would guess he is playingfree but wow spend a few bucks
I gotta admit the kid is good as hell but he doesn't have the feel that Jimmy Chamberlin had guess it's a good fill in but in my opinion u can't replace Jimmy
guys vake up! just look at jimmy and at this new guy. look at his expression on the face while he drums. and look at chamberlin. chamberlin is RELAXED. he is in this magic bubble while he plays, and this new guy is almost wasted in the end of this video after this song. he doesnt have my respects, in my opinion, he sucks compared to jimmy chamberlin...
@neverAskMeWhy07 How can you judge a drummer when you most likely have ZERO experience on a kit? Drum this song behind Corgan and a couple of hundred people then let's see who sucks at drumming.
guys vaken up! just look at jimmy and at this new guy. look at his expression on the face while he drums. and look at chamberlin. chamberlin is RELAXED. he is in this magic bubble while he plays, and this new guy is almost wasted in the end of this video after this song. he doesnt have my respects, in my opinion, he sucks compared to jimmy chamberlin...
but, like i said in earlir post, how good can Mike become because if this time w/ billy? how old is he agian? think Billy hasnt told him of Jimmy's young shortcomings to be just as good? i like him, and the influence Billy mite be having on him. won't be in SP forever, but will check him out in whatever band he winds up in!
The problem with Byrne is that he'll never get close to the massive, concrete solidness of Jimmy when it comes to writing material. It was Chamberlin who always signalled Corgan when the arrangement worked and when it didn't. I can just imagine Billy walking into the studio with the demo of a new song with a drum machine in it. And go like, "okay Mickey, there you go. Now we just have to record this". Jimmy would just trash that, put in drums the way he wanted, and it will always be great.
@popoyt well keep in mind he's not the one who writes the songs. While I enjoy the TBK songs thus far, they're not the type of songs in which he can shine drumming wise. Give it time, this kid will be one of the greats in a few years.
@pawnsacrifice1 I saw them in Seoul with the no drummer. Yes, he's no Jimmy, but they put on one hell of a show. I would still go see them for a 5th time.
smashing pumpkins are my all time favorite band. needless to say, they were an abysmal, gothy embarrassment during the machina period as well as zeitgeist. but this feels like a comeback. they sound absolutely phenomenal here and just as good as their '93-ish peak. welcome back!
Jimmy remains one of the greatest ever.......but maybe M ike one day can claim a title as being great............years to go but he sounds good.................
And it is great to see Billy in black again like he is ... maybe he will write some sad music for Teargarden....I'm not saying by wearing all black he is depressed, but he looks it...full of joy for the music but inside he's torn......Great music has come from his pain!!!!
Con Jimmy esta cancion hubiera sonado mas brutal, pero en fin no esta mal...a la hora que se pone a tocar esos temas! recupera el tiempo perdido Billy!
The Pumpkins, just sounding like a kick-ass rock band? SWEEEEEEEEET! Billy tries a bit too hard with the theatrics and stuff at times.
By the way, who was actually in the band here? I see Billy and Mike Byrne (who did a fantastic job, not easy when you're replacing Jimmy Chamberlin), but no one else seems to be visible. I know Ginger's left the band, so who was on bass? Was Jeff Schroeder playing here?
After how shitty tghe 20th ann tour was i refused to go stand in line for free tix to go to this. Now seeing he didn't bore people with Tear garden bullshit i really feel like a fuck'n idiot. Touche corgan touche
Fuck man, anyone who says SP died back in 2000 needs to check this shit out! Fuuuuuck! This is why I'm proud to be a Smashing Pumpkins fan! Just listen to this, this song was written back in like 1989, and check out how well they perform it! Amazing! His voice is definitely back in more than one way!
He sucks how did he get the job is he maybe a seacret relation this kid can barely ake it through a hack version of the song.,., watch the reissue concerts .,,., just doesnt make sense i would guess he is playingfree but wow spend a few bucks
inpictures 2 months ago
I gotta admit the kid is good as hell but he doesn't have the feel that Jimmy Chamberlin had guess it's a good fill in but in my opinion u can't replace Jimmy
motoredskull 6 months ago
@YourImaginaryEnd Eww are you kidding me? Clearly far inferior to Chamberlain.
hardmous 10 months ago
nice cover...
Suprematista 11 months ago
guys vake up! just look at jimmy and at this new guy. look at his expression on the face while he drums. and look at chamberlin. chamberlin is RELAXED. he is in this magic bubble while he plays, and this new guy is almost wasted in the end of this video after this song. he doesnt have my respects, in my opinion, he sucks compared to jimmy chamberlin...
neverAskMeWhy07 1 year ago
@neverAskMeWhy07 Thank you!
hardmous 10 months ago
@neverAskMeWhy07 How can you judge a drummer when you most likely have ZERO experience on a kit? Drum this song behind Corgan and a couple of hundred people then let's see who sucks at drumming.
kanookle 7 months ago
@kanookle dude, i HAVE, otherwise i wouldnt been saying what i said =)
neverAskMeWhy07 6 months ago
@kanookle i was talking from my own experience
neverAskMeWhy07 6 months ago
guys vaken up! just look at jimmy and at this new guy. look at his expression on the face while he drums. and look at chamberlin. chamberlin is RELAXED. he is in this magic bubble while he plays, and this new guy is almost wasted in the end of this video after this song. he doesnt have my respects, in my opinion, he sucks compared to jimmy chamberlin...
neverAskMeWhy07 1 year ago
but, like i said in earlir post, how good can Mike become because if this time w/ billy? how old is he agian? think Billy hasnt told him of Jimmy's young shortcomings to be just as good? i like him, and the influence Billy mite be having on him. won't be in SP forever, but will check him out in whatever band he winds up in!
stevecato 1 year ago
The problem with Byrne is that he'll never get close to the massive, concrete solidness of Jimmy when it comes to writing material. It was Chamberlin who always signalled Corgan when the arrangement worked and when it didn't. I can just imagine Billy walking into the studio with the demo of a new song with a drum machine in it. And go like, "okay Mickey, there you go. Now we just have to record this". Jimmy would just trash that, put in drums the way he wanted, and it will always be great.
soberek 1 year ago 2
GET THE ORIGINAL PUMPKINS BACK TOGETHER, FOR GOD'S SAKE!!!
BabyWetsAllNight 1 year ago
so cool that it took a 19 year old phenom to resurrect the energy lost 19 years ago! we welcome you, mike, and we bow down!
jjames05 1 year ago
1:06 gives me a huge chill. billy is rocking out with such irresistible glee here. the magic of smashing pumpkins is back.
morganenosfilms 1 year ago
Mike's good at playing Jimmy's parts, that's for sure... But when it comes to creation he's definitely not interesting.
popoyt 1 year ago 6
@popoyt well keep in mind he's not the one who writes the songs. While I enjoy the TBK songs thus far, they're not the type of songs in which he can shine drumming wise. Give it time, this kid will be one of the greats in a few years.
Spookster 1 year ago
@popoyt Exactly...
Suprematista 11 months ago
@YourImaginaryEnd or cash car star ;)
skylar44 1 year ago
Welll done Mike on drums...you are no Jimmy Chamberlain but then very few are!
pawnsacrifice1 1 year ago
@pawnsacrifice1 I saw them in Seoul with the no drummer. Yes, he's no Jimmy, but they put on one hell of a show. I would still go see them for a 5th time.
fatcatbuzz 1 year ago
smashing pumpkins are my all time favorite band. needless to say, they were an abysmal, gothy embarrassment during the machina period as well as zeitgeist. but this feels like a comeback. they sound absolutely phenomenal here and just as good as their '93-ish peak. welcome back!
morganenosfilms 1 year ago
Comment removed
morganenosfilms 1 year ago
He's pretty damn amazing.
solidtenpin 1 year ago
Tristessa !! Yeah !! And Byrne is the man !!!
Ozzalin 1 year ago
Byrne Byrne Byrne !!! AWESOME Drums !!!
Ozzalin 1 year ago
Yea Mike is killer..............
Jimmy remains one of the greatest ever.......but maybe M ike one day can claim a title as being great............years to go but he sounds good.................
And it is great to see Billy in black again like he is ... maybe he will write some sad music for Teargarden....I'm not saying by wearing all black he is depressed, but he looks it...full of joy for the music but inside he's torn......Great music has come from his pain!!!!
jmInDreams 1 year ago
Kick ass song. Powerful drumming. Hope to see more Gish era songs
onkel44lekno 1 year ago
@YourImaginaryEnd don't forget Cash Car Star!
Sharpster7 1 year ago
I had my reservations about the new incarnation of the Pumpkins, but I have to say this sounds freakin' awesome!
tristessa56079 1 year ago
myke fucking rocks!! so ass the hole smashing pumpkins baby
infinitycero 1 year ago
Fucking great drum vibes!! Jimmy can be proud of Mike.
RobinB84 1 year ago
yesssssss. first time live in 16 years :)
dukkookim7 1 year ago
up until seeing this video, I was calling bullsh*t.
Mike's got some internalizin' to do....
Tribute2JohnnyB 1 year ago
Listened to it a second time in a row, just to savor the awesomeness.
mom2faithnjames 1 year ago
this song has almost 20 years, so great. good vibes coming from the pumpkinland
joao1988pedro 1 year ago
lawl mike
fengrr 1 year ago
Con Jimmy esta cancion hubiera sonado mas brutal, pero en fin no esta mal...a la hora que se pone a tocar esos temas! recupera el tiempo perdido Billy!
carlosalas 1 year ago
Wow, Mike really fucking nailed this! I was wondering how he would perform on the old songs and wow, he was amazing!
silverfuck77jpm 1 year ago
The Pumpkins, just sounding like a kick-ass rock band? SWEEEEEEEEET! Billy tries a bit too hard with the theatrics and stuff at times.
By the way, who was actually in the band here? I see Billy and Mike Byrne (who did a fantastic job, not easy when you're replacing Jimmy Chamberlin), but no one else seems to be visible. I know Ginger's left the band, so who was on bass? Was Jeff Schroeder playing here?
PantheonLincoln 1 year ago
@PantheonLincoln Billy, Mike, Jeff, Mark Tulin and also Kerry Brown for a some bits
TheSPumpkin100 1 year ago
... I saw the title of this video, and all I had to say to myself was, "No Fucking Way."
...but they did. They played Tristessa.
Jesus Christ this is the definition of all things awesome.
Thank you Billy! Thank you!
IncliningPizza 1 year ago 2
WOW !
JTristesse 1 year ago
fuckin... 1:30 with the tongue. Awesome
msevrens 1 year ago
@Floskeknosk yeah that's sp right there!!! +1000000000000000000 rok on points!!
rugasyano 1 year ago
THIS right here is The Smashing Pumpkins!!
Floskeknosk 1 year ago 2
After how shitty tghe 20th ann tour was i refused to go stand in line for free tix to go to this. Now seeing he didn't bore people with Tear garden bullshit i really feel like a fuck'n idiot. Touche corgan touche
whitetrashshayno 1 year ago
Comment removed
lisam805 1 year ago
Fuck yes!
Jazzed about Byrne aint even close, he is fucking awesome.
Was cool to see Billy a-smiling and a-ripping it up indeed!!!!!!!!!!
pizzed 1 year ago
Kudos Billy!
Chris197980CH 1 year ago
Fuck man, anyone who says SP died back in 2000 needs to check this shit out! Fuuuuuck! This is why I'm proud to be a Smashing Pumpkins fan! Just listen to this, this song was written back in like 1989, and check out how well they perform it! Amazing! His voice is definitely back in more than one way!
easternmind 1 year ago 3
YES!!
halfawhole1 1 year ago
0:58-1:05 I wish the frame rate of this video was higher so I could even see Mike go!
starcrux 1 year ago
Omg!I wish I was there!<3
WhiteLotusFlower 1 year ago
Wow, Mike. Wow. The Byrne era is here.
Soonago2 1 year ago 7
I was so curious how Mike would sound when it came to the Classic Pumpkin songs, and he sounds really great! He rocked Tristessa!
Metalpug79 1 year ago
@YourImaginaryEnd YES MIKE RULES
TheMercuryTree 1 year ago
That first part of the solo is so sick.
weezer521 1 year ago 4
asimo! Thank you!
Sounds great!
murmurson 1 year ago
Sounds great!!
reggaeluv2000 1 year ago
WOW. SP history was made today!
lisam805 1 year ago
I have to say... even without Jimmy Chamberlin, both Billy Corgan AND the smashing pumpkins are in top form...
sj73 1 year ago