Thank you Thelerot, for this upload. We have waited a long time for the complete performance. And I, for one. am thrilled with it. I'm only sorry there is no more video, but i understand security was tight that evening. Like the extended cello solo, but feel the old choir part was better than the new. An indispensible chapter of Floyd history, and I am very grateful for your contribution.
Drummer critics: shut the fuck up and appreciate your blessings.
Sem palavras... Desde os meus 12 anos que ouço Pink Floyd, tenho 37 e não descubro nada mais completo e superior! Esta faixa faixa que é muito desprezada no "mainstream", é considerada para nós "pinkfloydianos" uma obra intemporal e épica.
@MrBlasga Você está certo meu amigo e que os anos passam, mas os mesmos acordes e arranjos ainda como o original, porque nós dois sabemos que David improvisa em sua própria e que o torna único, porque ele está fora do cotidiano e sempre improvisando. além do bem que você gostou = D
I absolutely LOVE this performance, but the drummer, could have been replaced, by a jar of old hot dogs, dung, and fly vomit !!! That is one UN-INSPIRED, UN-MUSICIAN !!!! Way to shit on a MASTERPIECE, you poor excuse for a drummer. I know that Nick Mason, is FAR from great, but I actually CRAVE his drumming, on this song, and that is sad, because, Nick Mason SUCKS, but he sometimes, gets it right. At least he is better than Charlie Watts, but so is my cat.
I love this album, and I love to compare it to, Sgt. Pepper, but for a different reason. Both, are AMAZING albums (obviously), but with two different perspectives. Sgt. Pepper, has the orchestra, as part of the band, and Atom Heart Mother, has the band, as part of the orchestra. I am biased, so i prefer Pink Floyd's perspective, but BOTH, are pure Genius !!! :) Thank you for sharing this. Atom Heart Mother, was ALWAYS, one of my favorite albums, that is ALWAYS, overlooked. :)
@1013301 Thank you very much you agree with the comparisons and indeed you are right and in my opinion although the band did not want it with an orchestra, the final product is amazing right??? I'm glad you liked beyond hope you see this and my other videos Greetings from Mexico =)
Truly, one of THE MOST, overlooked, epic albums, in rock history. Awesome performance!!! Too bad, this drummer, sounds EXACTLY like the chart he is reading. I know that Nick Mason was a technically HORRIBLE drummer, but I crave his playing, in this song. HELL.., even Charlie Watts, could have done a better job, than THIS guy, and Charlie Watts, is THE WORST DRUMMER, EVER!!!!! (Nick Mason, is right behind him though) lol
@1013301 I agree with you on the subject of the battery but I still like David Gilmour in his solos that madefrom slide guitar to normal. This is a video that is hard to find but thanks for commenting full hope you liked Beyond Greetings from mexico !!!!!
Aaaarggg!!! Windows f*cked me up again! the video froze into a darn picture!!...I´m glad David is recovering this album.
Sam7my1ed 22 hours ago
SOBERBIO, ME MANDA A RECORRER TODO UN MUNDO DE EMOCIONES
baritogo 2 weeks ago
Cool,Thanks
vinylray 3 weeks ago
EXPECTACULAR!
naotemnenhumnomedipo 4 weeks ago
BU NE BEAA EŞŞEK ANIRTISI DİNLETİYOLAR ADAMA BEAAAAAAAAA
burningtoavange 1 month ago
Cool!
nearvana2003 1 month ago
Thank you Thelerot, for this upload. We have waited a long time for the complete performance. And I, for one. am thrilled with it. I'm only sorry there is no more video, but i understand security was tight that evening. Like the extended cello solo, but feel the old choir part was better than the new. An indispensible chapter of Floyd history, and I am very grateful for your contribution.
Drummer critics: shut the fuck up and appreciate your blessings.
wordofgord
thewordofgord 1 month ago
Sem palavras... Desde os meus 12 anos que ouço Pink Floyd, tenho 37 e não descubro nada mais completo e superior! Esta faixa faixa que é muito desprezada no "mainstream", é considerada para nós "pinkfloydianos" uma obra intemporal e épica.
MrBlasga 1 month ago 2
@MrBlasga Você está certo meu amigo e que os anos passam, mas os mesmos acordes e arranjos ainda como o original, porque nós dois sabemos que David improvisa em sua própria e que o torna único, porque ele está fora do cotidiano e sempre improvisando. além do bem que você gostou = D
TheIerot 1 month ago
Thanks a lot for this video ! i was looking for month the complete performance
Beaujolois 1 month ago
essa é a melhor versao ao vivo que ja ouvi!!!!! essa suite é estrambólica
naotemnenhumnomedipo 1 month ago
Cada vez que eu escuto esta música eu sinto uma sensação diferente.... cada vez ela se torna melhor... é uma das trilhas sonoras da minha vida.
hevertonbol 1 month ago
Vielen Vielen Dank,ich liebe es und hätte sogern eine Zeitmachiene!
Whitetrashjuni1963 1 month ago
I absolutely LOVE this performance, but the drummer, could have been replaced, by a jar of old hot dogs, dung, and fly vomit !!! That is one UN-INSPIRED, UN-MUSICIAN !!!! Way to shit on a MASTERPIECE, you poor excuse for a drummer. I know that Nick Mason, is FAR from great, but I actually CRAVE his drumming, on this song, and that is sad, because, Nick Mason SUCKS, but he sometimes, gets it right. At least he is better than Charlie Watts, but so is my cat.
1013301 1 month ago
i listen to atom heart mother 3 times a day..
jsphbrv 2 months ago
I love this album, and I love to compare it to, Sgt. Pepper, but for a different reason. Both, are AMAZING albums (obviously), but with two different perspectives. Sgt. Pepper, has the orchestra, as part of the band, and Atom Heart Mother, has the band, as part of the orchestra. I am biased, so i prefer Pink Floyd's perspective, but BOTH, are pure Genius !!! :) Thank you for sharing this. Atom Heart Mother, was ALWAYS, one of my favorite albums, that is ALWAYS, overlooked. :)
1013301 3 months ago 4
@1013301 Thank you very much you agree with the comparisons and indeed you are right and in my opinion although the band did not want it with an orchestra, the final product is amazing right??? I'm glad you liked beyond hope you see this and my other videos Greetings from Mexico =)
TheIerot 3 months ago
Truly, one of THE MOST, overlooked, epic albums, in rock history. Awesome performance!!! Too bad, this drummer, sounds EXACTLY like the chart he is reading. I know that Nick Mason was a technically HORRIBLE drummer, but I crave his playing, in this song. HELL.., even Charlie Watts, could have done a better job, than THIS guy, and Charlie Watts, is THE WORST DRUMMER, EVER!!!!! (Nick Mason, is right behind him though) lol
1013301 3 months ago 2
@1013301 I agree with you on the subject of the battery but I still like David Gilmour in his solos that madefrom slide guitar to normal. This is a video that is hard to find but thanks for commenting full hope you liked Beyond Greetings from mexico !!!!!
TheIerot 3 months ago
@1013301
And Ringo star ? don't forget him lol !
Beaujolois 1 month ago
Sweet!...what year is this?
knot4u11 3 months ago
@knot4u11 It was in 2008 at the Cadogan Hall can say it was a tribute It's good that you liked Beyond Greetings from Mexico
TheIerot 3 months ago