I might be wrong but when a zen master hits a student with the stick on the shoulder (which is a common practice in retreats in Japan) it's not because of keeping the student alert but it's a way to eventually frustrate the mind of the "seeker" so that eventually the mind just gets fed up with not finding anything and gives up (so to speak).
I'd say the function of talking about reaching some goal is to lure the seeker in a trap and eventually build up the frustration of not finding that which is thought tobe findable. That's how this particular, seeming unfolding goes between the so-called masters and the disciples.
@ReefFrog And yes, there is no seeker or a trap. Or rather this "thing" within which the seeker, the luring and the trap seem to happen can't be said to exist or not exist. And all this is "this" when it is this and it's "that" when it's that. And all this is only words, everything is only as it is.
@youbloodybetcha don't take him that literally - arguing within spiritual terms WILL end up contradictous anyhow... there's this complete impossibility of grasping truth, accept that... lol what a grasp again (see?! ;))
So, if you have a message you're a teacher and if you're a teacher then you're not talking about non duality. I do agree we have no say about when we are liberated, so it is a waste of energy looking for it.
Hi Tony, I've enjoyed your many videos on nonduality. But I find your criticism of Eckerd Tolle odd.
You both take pains to explain that words are merely pointers at best and shouldn't be taken too literally. Yet you take issue with his use of the word: "presence". How is that any different than your "aliveness"? As someone who's spent a good deal of time listening to you both, may I make so bold as to suggest that you are insufficiently familiar with his teachings?
I love TP, but I think he's contradicting himself here, on ET's teachings.
At 2:22 (referring to ET's teachings) he says "one is comforting and helping people" and the other (his own teachings) "point to something beyond that" - but isn't "pointing to something beyond that" suggesting that there is something "else" to be pointed at?
I don't think there is a difference between the teachings. I understood ET's work to be about accepting what is, not about looking for something else.
JamesThomas said, "Tony's message doesn't give us anything to hold on to. It's more about "killing" the "me","... Not quite, because he sees there is no "me" to kill. You can't kill what doesn't exist. On the surface, ET's teaching gives the impression there is a "me", and that "me" needs to find the "now". But the deeper teaching is also there. I feel Tony fails to see the deeper teaching. ET dances around it too much, while Tony obviously doesn't
Finally I heard a fair opinion about the teaching that makes people think that it is possible to live right and wrong and that there is a way of how to be right. Many people bought into this nonsense.
Interesting comments about EckhartTolle, but it's true. We're not likely to see Tony write a book called: Finding Your Life's Purpose.
Perhaps I have enjoyed Tolle's work so much because it does give one a sense of finding something. Whereas Tony's message doesn't give us anything to hold on to. It's more about "killing" the "me", than supporting "me" in any way whatsoever.
Tony's message is frightening, yet can draw one like a moth to a flame.
Comment removed
bohdeesvaha 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
bohdeesvaha 2 weeks ago
I might be wrong but when a zen master hits a student with the stick on the shoulder (which is a common practice in retreats in Japan) it's not because of keeping the student alert but it's a way to eventually frustrate the mind of the "seeker" so that eventually the mind just gets fed up with not finding anything and gives up (so to speak).
ReefFrog 2 months ago
I'd say the function of talking about reaching some goal is to lure the seeker in a trap and eventually build up the frustration of not finding that which is thought tobe findable. That's how this particular, seeming unfolding goes between the so-called masters and the disciples.
ReefFrog 2 months ago
@ReefFrog And yes, there is no seeker or a trap. Or rather this "thing" within which the seeker, the luring and the trap seem to happen can't be said to exist or not exist. And all this is "this" when it is this and it's "that" when it's that. And all this is only words, everything is only as it is.
ReefFrog 2 months ago
fantastic!
Mikaire2 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@youbloodybetcha don't take him that literally - arguing within spiritual terms WILL end up contradictous anyhow... there's this complete impossibility of grasping truth, accept that... lol what a grasp again (see?! ;))
fossegrim91 4 months ago
He did not criticize eckhart....he just said eckhart teaches a person, or to a " you " there is no YOU...
oxen1957 6 months ago
I don't think Tony had the right to criticize eckhart. If it wasn't for eckhart I wouldn't be watching this right now. Or so it appears anyway.
kiwikieran18 8 months ago
existence cannot be conceptulized and conceptualization has no author = POWERLESS
swingtrade2 9 months ago
this guy givea me bad vibes.
mickehill 9 months ago
@mickehill
thats a pretty good sign
darthvaderabraham 8 months ago
So, if you have a message you're a teacher and if you're a teacher then you're not talking about non duality. I do agree we have no say about when we are liberated, so it is a waste of energy looking for it.
JanIroth 10 months ago
Hi Tony, I've enjoyed your many videos on nonduality. But I find your criticism of Eckerd Tolle odd.
You both take pains to explain that words are merely pointers at best and shouldn't be taken too literally. Yet you take issue with his use of the word: "presence". How is that any different than your "aliveness"? As someone who's spent a good deal of time listening to you both, may I make so bold as to suggest that you are insufficiently familiar with his teachings?
youbloodybetcha 10 months ago
Comment removed
fossegrim91 4 months ago
I love TP, but I think he's contradicting himself here, on ET's teachings.
At 2:22 (referring to ET's teachings) he says "one is comforting and helping people" and the other (his own teachings) "point to something beyond that" - but isn't "pointing to something beyond that" suggesting that there is something "else" to be pointed at?
I don't think there is a difference between the teachings. I understood ET's work to be about accepting what is, not about looking for something else.
Frinkle233 1 year ago
@Frinkle233 There is no sucn thin as accepting or resistance what is. There is just what is/
9fatman 1 year ago
Comment removed
darthvaderabraham 8 months ago
I LOVE YOU TONY, BRO! thank you soooo much, you b*stard!!! :-))))
GeorgeGogle 1 year ago
JamesThomas said, "Tony's message doesn't give us anything to hold on to. It's more about "killing" the "me","... Not quite, because he sees there is no "me" to kill. You can't kill what doesn't exist. On the surface, ET's teaching gives the impression there is a "me", and that "me" needs to find the "now". But the deeper teaching is also there. I feel Tony fails to see the deeper teaching. ET dances around it too much, while Tony obviously doesn't
19justme51 1 year ago
Finally I heard a fair opinion about the teaching that makes people think that it is possible to live right and wrong and that there is a way of how to be right. Many people bought into this nonsense.
9fatman 1 year ago
Comment removed
9fatman 1 year ago
Comment removed
MasterJonze 1 year ago
Interesting comments about EckhartTolle, but it's true. We're not likely to see Tony write a book called: Finding Your Life's Purpose.
Perhaps I have enjoyed Tolle's work so much because it does give one a sense of finding something. Whereas Tony's message doesn't give us anything to hold on to. It's more about "killing" the "me", than supporting "me" in any way whatsoever.
Tony's message is frightening, yet can draw one like a moth to a flame.
JamesThomas 1 year ago
Nothing can be done vs. hearing the message and something happens.
Can't have it both ways.
rovingdesertfox 1 year ago
@rovingdesertfox Nothing can be done about hearing the message and something happening.
snowypetrel 1 year ago
Tony says it as it is. Other teachers tell stories.
okydokysmoky 1 year ago
thanks a lot for this video!!
GeorgeGogle 1 year ago
Comment removed
MsRedjay 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thank you !!!!!!!!!!1
vikohad 1 year ago
great again, thanks.
Ponferrada22 1 year ago
Thank you,more of coffee!:-))
nizigar 1 year ago