We put this question to Shaykh ‘Abd-Allaah ibn Jibreen (may Allaah preserve him) who answered as follows:
In our opinion it is haraam because it sounds like, and could be taking the place of, musical instruments, which are forbidden and which distract people from remembering Allaah. So whatever takes their place is also haraam. And Allaah knows best.
@OnyxArrow I know, I'm a stranger, a "extremist" for following the sunnah by forbidding the evil and enjoining the truth. I'm a extremist just like Muhammad (pbuh) who told his people to stop worshipping idols. Don't follow Islam according to your desires. May Allah guide u whoever u are.
@razor1995guls Just because something is against ur desires it becomes extreme? Look at the evidence I gave from one of the known scholars among Ahlus Sunnah wal Jama'ah, where is your evidence? Is that all u can shame ''extremist'', u disgust me and u are one of those coca cola democratic muslims Abdur Rahim Green was talking about in his ''Coca Cola generation of Muslims''. The believers are those who say 'we hear and we obey' they don't appose something because it goes against their desire.
@OnyxArrow It doesnt matter if its children or olders. And I even quoted u a fatwa from a great scholar Shaykh Ibn Jibreen may Allah have mercy on him. My aim is not to cause hate or to make u sin by calling me names, I wish u were sincere and really researched what I am saying from reliable sources and not the ''moderate democratic muslims''. Remember Islam is a complete religion, no democracy. Let me know if u want proof that music is haram,period. Doesnt matter whether its children or not.
@john1136 yeah ur a wrong extremist. have u evar read the hadith? do you know what rasulallah SAW said about the children?
I don't follow islam of my own desires. and rasulallah SAW said... if anyone adds something in islam, which was not revealed. he will get a shameful doom. Mohammed SAW was/is/ will be the greatest person in the world and no1 can be like him, but we try our best. He was extremist kind, mercy. but not extremist like you. You forbid' music to children, but he didn't.
@OnyxArrow LOL astaghfirullah, show me the evidence where Muhammad peace be upon him allowed music ''for children''. Show me the evidence where Muhammad peace be upon him allowed music. And Pashto Nasheeds do not contain music, they are only voices and the lyrics are all about martyrdom and sacrificing in the way of Allah. What can be more beautiful than dying in the way of my Creator. Look forgive me for not conveying the dawah to properly but my aim was to correct u,music is haram in islam...
Although I have a lot of respect for dr zakir naik, can someone please explain to me how this can be allowed in Islam, kids dancing, singing to this type of modern day music??? Surely this is haraam, and then to make it worse, it's kids that are involved in this.
Also why dr zakir n the kids dress in western clothing is another concern?
@wajray well this songs are islamic songs and not considered as music but nasheeds alright! there is nothing haram involved here...in ISlam music which involves instrument is not allowed but islamic nasheed is allowed...these are small kids they are not exposing their figure just showing movement with the songs its not called 'dancing' and they are not adults but kids of std 1-5
Love the way that boy recites at the beginning.... also love the song heard it in chipmunck version!! <3_<3
angelria88 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This song sounds so nice i love god even more :D GO MUSLIMS !!!!
MrPurpleleather 2 months ago
This song sounds so nice i love god even more :D GO MUSLIMS !!!!
MrPurpleleather 2 months ago
Praise be to Allaah.
We put this question to Shaykh ‘Abd-Allaah ibn Jibreen (may Allaah preserve him) who answered as follows:
In our opinion it is haraam because it sounds like, and could be taking the place of, musical instruments, which are forbidden and which distract people from remembering Allaah. So whatever takes their place is also haraam. And Allaah knows best.
Shaykh ‘Abd-Allaah ibn Jibreen
IslamQA(dot)com question number: 1867
john1136 6 months ago
@john1136 omg... what an extremist
OnyxArrow 5 months ago
@OnyxArrow I know, I'm a stranger, a "extremist" for following the sunnah by forbidding the evil and enjoining the truth. I'm a extremist just like Muhammad (pbuh) who told his people to stop worshipping idols. Don't follow Islam according to your desires. May Allah guide u whoever u are.
john1136 5 months ago
@john1136 aahhh THE HOLY PROPHET WAS NOT AN EXTREMIST.....
razor1995guls 4 months ago
@razor1995guls Just because something is against ur desires it becomes extreme? Look at the evidence I gave from one of the known scholars among Ahlus Sunnah wal Jama'ah, where is your evidence? Is that all u can shame ''extremist'', u disgust me and u are one of those coca cola democratic muslims Abdur Rahim Green was talking about in his ''Coca Cola generation of Muslims''. The believers are those who say 'we hear and we obey' they don't appose something because it goes against their desire.
john1136 4 months ago
@john1136 Why do you not guide those drug dealers, the pimps, the dancing women, singing women or men. the gangsters. the party dancer. etc.
if you think singing is my interest, then forget it. because i never listen to music. and i never guide other muslims from my own opinion.
OnyxArrow 4 months ago
@OnyxArrow It doesnt matter if its children or olders. And I even quoted u a fatwa from a great scholar Shaykh Ibn Jibreen may Allah have mercy on him. My aim is not to cause hate or to make u sin by calling me names, I wish u were sincere and really researched what I am saying from reliable sources and not the ''moderate democratic muslims''. Remember Islam is a complete religion, no democracy. Let me know if u want proof that music is haram,period. Doesnt matter whether its children or not.
john1136 4 months ago
@john1136 Btw why do you listen to pashto nasheeds? and u hate when people are singing nasheeds on english etc. Why so egoist?
OnyxArrow 4 months ago
@john1136 yeah ur a wrong extremist. have u evar read the hadith? do you know what rasulallah SAW said about the children?
I don't follow islam of my own desires. and rasulallah SAW said... if anyone adds something in islam, which was not revealed. he will get a shameful doom. Mohammed SAW was/is/ will be the greatest person in the world and no1 can be like him, but we try our best. He was extremist kind, mercy. but not extremist like you. You forbid' music to children, but he didn't.
OnyxArrow 4 months ago
@OnyxArrow LOL astaghfirullah, show me the evidence where Muhammad peace be upon him allowed music ''for children''. Show me the evidence where Muhammad peace be upon him allowed music. And Pashto Nasheeds do not contain music, they are only voices and the lyrics are all about martyrdom and sacrificing in the way of Allah. What can be more beautiful than dying in the way of my Creator. Look forgive me for not conveying the dawah to properly but my aim was to correct u,music is haram in islam...
john1136 4 months ago
Although I have a lot of respect for dr zakir naik, can someone please explain to me how this can be allowed in Islam, kids dancing, singing to this type of modern day music??? Surely this is haraam, and then to make it worse, it's kids that are involved in this.
Also why dr zakir n the kids dress in western clothing is another concern?
Please someone help answer these few questions?
wajray 11 months ago
@wajray its not allowed, its like mixing zamzam and alcohol, ends dont justify the means
lamecatcook 9 months ago
@wajray well this songs are islamic songs and not considered as music but nasheeds alright! there is nothing haram involved here...in ISlam music which involves instrument is not allowed but islamic nasheed is allowed...these are small kids they are not exposing their figure just showing movement with the songs its not called 'dancing' and they are not adults but kids of std 1-5
ThePeacefulmuslimah 7 months ago
chand lamhon mein islam ka jamea pegha dena in bchon ki achi kawish hy,allah inki hifazat kry.
TheIslamians 1 year ago
i think i islam is the best
sajidaflower 1 year ago