Huge and awesome scientific discoveries made by Muslims !

[cp007ify]

Leaders shud spread peace and inspire people to achieve somthing in their lives, to live with good principles & VALUES and to love and respect everyone. I am calling him an extremist for not respecting/accepting anything other than islamism.So called passion or spirit he fills in muslim individuals by these kind of speeches is 90-100% negative

[Andytheantiathiest]

Racist lies

[1GodOnlyOne]

@Andytheantiathiest The only mention of race in this lecture is when he stated that the Arabic numeral system is so-called because it was invented by Arabs.

That is neither racist, nor a lie. It is simply a historical fact.

This man is by no means a racist.

[mca3258]

at world war 3,,the rise of Islamic world,,

[abkritz]

he is such a fool.....does he listens to himself?

[BatmanbinSuperman12]

@abkritz he is well respected by many Muslims christians and so on he is aspiring in knowledge. Thats a part of Islam.

[flywithmeamerica]

This guy is so wrong... Muslims destructed and stiffed Ideas and innovation, many of the things he claims where made by Indians

[BatmanbinSuperman12]

@flywithmeamerica Actually search the stuff he is talikng about its true. My science teacher is christian even he respects Zakir naik

[narlzp]

@BatmanbinSuperman12

How do you explain the number system? To me and my mathematics knowledge this whole idea that Muslims invented the number system is the biggest rort of the Indians who created it dont you agree?

[BatmanbinSuperman12]

@narlzp Dude Assyrians, Sumerians, The Egyptians, the Myans, The Aztec, Inca, Chinese, Persian, Akkadian, Hitites all hade a number sysytem. BTW Arabs came before Indians. But no one said the muslims invented the number system. But Muslims made many contribution to math and science. 

[narlzp]

@BatmanbinSuperman12 What exactly do you mean that the Arabs came before the Indians? The number system I am talking about is the one that we use currently to do our mathematics called Hindu-Arabic numerals. So called because they were developed in India and then transmitted by the Arabs to the Europeans later on. To think so otherwise is historical nonsense its like saying you were born before your parents.

[narlzp]

Both mathematicians Al Khwarizmi and Al-Biruni mention India's importance including the translated works of Aryabhata Al-nanf and bhaskara Ta'rikh al-Hind. I leave it from here btw have you the chance to see his other videos? I have just browsed through something is wrong with this guy when he starts saying buddhism prophezised the coming of Muhammed and hence making Islam the greater of the two. He later states that Buddhism is illusionary and untrue in his comparisons.

[narlzp]

I am not a hardcore buddhist but many devotee's will find this offensive. If I start to translate Islam in the light of buddhism how might muslims feel? In my opinion if this so called scholar cannot respect or appreciate other faiths how can he be taken for face value? This guy is very questionable at and at best a nut job for making these comparisons and untrue claims.The fact he speaks of Arabic numerals here is testament to his lack of knowledge anyways i leave it from here all the best

[BatmanbinSuperman12]

@narlzp He has respect for Buddhism and other faiths. He is just saying maybe Buddha was a prophet of god but instead of worshiping god it was him who they worshiped. A Muslim isn't allowed to do debates and things like comparison and giving a lecture without knowledge. Peace be with you br./sr.

[BatmanbinSuperman12]

@flywithmeamerica Actually search the stuff he is talikng about its true. My science teacher is christian even he respects Zakir naik and wich Indians are you talking about?

[jack10133]

Muslims stole what they could when the great western civilizations fell (Rome and Greece) sat on it for 1000 years (basically contributed nothing over that period) then when the renaissance began, Europeans started from where they left off and haven't looked back.

[nightowl8936]

Muslims are also claiming on YouTube they invented the decimal number system too ... yet we see no great advancements in mathematics from Muslim countries ... no calculus or tensors or transforms ... nothing.

So given that Muslims are not above stealing others work and claiming it for their own ... how can anyone trust the claims in this video?

[warriorofpeace786]

@nightowl8936 That's why you go and research about these claims yourself and make up your own decision

[tahirbannu]

very well Zakir sir.its a light for those who thinks Muslim are from Dark age

[zecle]

everything in this video is true. but it's not the case anymore. muslims doesn't honorthe scientific enlightenment of their ancestors ! those who were there when europe entered thousand years of stupidity. those who saved knowledge about astonomy, chemistry, mathematics and so much more. those who exchanged with several cultures of the rest of the world to make their one richer and bigger.

[kynismos]

@iloveafg123 hahahahaha you sound like the kind of guy who believes... Well, start thinking!

[iloveafg123]

@chitrakuut give him 24 hours to talk bout this on stop n he'll say everything id like u to read read and give a leture of one hour and only allowing a few minutes for each question, ignorant.

[iloveafg123]

@kynismos hahahhahhahahhahahaah funny u say that. u sound like the type of guy who believes his grand father was a fish

[iloveafg123]

@kynismos omgggggggggggggggg u sound more ignorant than some dude who thinks his grnadfatehr was fish

[Islam4way]

@chitrakuut he is talking about the current so called English numerals they are actually arabic

[bellrockyin]

He talks faster than I can read!....

[amico99999]

This video is spreading false info. making futile attempt to prove the superiority of one culture over the other.Bring this person to debate with scientists,we will see.

[amico99999]

Ibn Nafis was first to describe pulmonary circulation,yes.Hahaha mediterranean map was clearly drawn by Hecataeus in 500BC itself.Arabic numerals????,It is actually known as HINDU-ARABIC numerals.Read History Please. All the other things said by zakir naik are false.What about thousands of discoveries and inventions made by ancientEgyptians,Indians,chine­se,Romans?oh have you heard of Ancient Greeks?

[Islam4way]

@amico99999 HA HA yes 1 2 3 etc are Arabic numerals learn more

[0bama12]

He speaks indian in english...can someone do a subtitle...jzk

[qwerty0019]

@0bama12

Full transcript, word by word, is just below in the description of the video.

Regards.

[alfatourist]

I think if there is anybody to be blamed it is the muslims themselves, because God gave them mony even when the west was developing the Science & technology.

Muslims are not sincere to each other.

They have become victims of political interests of the rulers.

Facts of historyare not to disputed, only checked..

refer to brittanica encyclopaedia to verify what he said about pythogras

Dispute is on opionons only.

Muslims lose as Muslims when they become hypocrites, this is what happened

[alfatourist]

Muslims made so many contribution in the medieval ages.

Then God gave oil to Muslims, and made them the richest people, and they did not use the money sufficeintly to influence the world.

The depended on the west for science & technology instead of becoming part of it in development.

They hired the people of the poor countries, their countries depended on the middle east for their foreigh reservers, who later became stronger, and now some of them don't even apprciate that.

[ethandrood]

He Quoted Pythagoras wrong.

[torykpandeglang]

allahu akbar

[saintpine]

"But the media is in the hand of the western world "

And what is this supposed to mean, create your own media, if you don't know your own great scientists, teach them in your schools, do you expect the western world to praise and follow "science" books written thousands of years ago ?

The world goes on, we don't worship the people that make discoveries, we learn and move on.

[rbairos1]

Reminds me of the dad in 'My Big Fat Greek Wedding'

[CommanderUTube]

The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources.

( Albert Einstein)

That's why the great libraries of Alexandria were burnt. And that was not the first and last such.

When the British Empire extended itself to the Far East, the navy went about systemetically destroying the records and artifacts of anything reminding locals & future generations of the previous powers. Even the monument of Dragon's Teeth at Singapore harbor left by Admiral Cheng Ho of China were bombarded to pieces.

[chodaboy51500]

Agreed! Pride in your race is empty pride. You achieved it by being born. Do something truly worthy of pride.

[aref9494]

thats right ppl do the research about the names of he said and compare and contrast. i agree with zakir naik..

[3yearappentice]

i agree 100% with what u say

[runeguldberg]

Wrong. Not muslims. Arabs and Persians. They learned it from the Indians.

[madzyzome]

Musims USED to be scientifically advance until they started their own dark ages which they are still in right now. Scientific advances no longer come from the muslim world.

To say Al-Khindi basically gave the theory of relativity to Einstein is a load of shit. The theory of relativity is much more than the idea that physical laws are relative. Einstein actually DESCRIBED mathematically how they are relative. What Al-Khindi did was make a guess that it was relative, nothing more.

[FahadKhan1988]

Actually, making such Ideas are more difficult than the mathematics. If you know how the system works, its just a matter of time when you get the correct equations. See "Islamic Golden Age" on google. It was indeed the Muslims who made the total basic of Science. Today not, because they are all getting bombarded by the peacefull country`s.

[madzyzome]

Really? An idea is more difficult then the mathematics? Einstein arrived to the idea with math. His math proved everything is relative. Al-Khindi just guessed. You cannot compare the two.

Bombarded by peaceful countries? WTF? The Muslim countries are in their own dark ages, things like evolution or anything that disagrees with the Koran are banned in many muslim countries. They are holding themselves back just like the europeans did in the middle ages

[FahadKhan1988]

Why don`t you google: "Quran and evoltution", I hope that will shut your big mouth. Not a single human on earth, first plays with mathematics and then forms Idea`s. The chance you will find something is 0. Like in physics or chemical engineering, first the balance, then the differential equations, then solve it. If you dont know the picture, forget about it with the mathematics.

[madzyzome]

You want to know what Einstein's ideas were? He used to imagine he was riding a beam of light, he pondered what the world would look like to him. THATS his idea. It was a daydream. Not exactly influenced by some muslim philosopher that has been mostly lost to the ages.

WTF does the Quran have to do with biological evolution? The only thing I found was very vague interpretations that might mean something along the lines of evolution but thats grasping at straws.

[FahadKhan1988]

Good, that could be his dream. But the basic of his Idea was not from himself, like it or not. Glad you agree now that mathematics is not the cause of his nobel prizes.

I said: "Google it". There are many sites dealing with it, it is you who is denying it. Quran supports facts rather than theory`s. Many parts in the evolution theory is a lie or outdated, simply to promote Atheïsm.

Now there is not such ting as intrepetation, you dont even use the energy to read the tafseer...

[Chuckschinfist]

Well looks like MadZyzome is forbidden from posting here so I will answer you.

You don't get Nobel prizes for "ideas". You need something to back them up like, I don't know.. facts! Einstein didn't even get the Nobel prize for general relativity, her got it for discovering the photoelectric effect. Which muslim philosopher gets that one? Was there one I don't know of that was keenly aware of the existence of photons and electrons?

[FahadKhan1988]

It`s not about nobel prices. Its about the scientific discovery`s. Afcours you wont hear many Muslims winning a nobel price, the media keep labeling them as terrorists. Have you seen Islamic Golden Age right now?

[Chuckschinfist]

Nobel prizes are give to monumental discoveries something muslims do not do anymore because theocracies do not promote good science.

"Afcours you wont hear many Muslims winning a nobel price, the media keep labeling them as terrorists."

HAHAHAHA and aliens control our minds with microwaves!

"Have you seen Islamic Golden Age right now?"

Nope. And you never will.

[FahadKhan1988]

So you dont even use the energy to find out where science came from (islamic golden age). And you call yourself a freethinker, another ignorant atheist.

[Chuckschinfist]

"Many parts in the evolution theory is a lie or outdated, simply to promote Atheïsm."

Which parts? Do you even know what Evolution is? DO you know the definition? It has nothing to do with Atheism.

"Quran supports facts rather than theory`s"

That doesn't even make sense. There are no facts in the quran.

"Now there is not such ting as intrepetation, you dont even use the energy to read the tafseer."

Yes there is, that's all you can do when you read the quran/bible/torah, it's too ambiguous.

[FahadKhan1988]

I didnt said that it deals with Atheïsm, I said it PROMOTES Atheïsm. Simply trying to debunk creationism with hypothises and theory`s with no support at all.

If there are no facts in the Quran, it explained the ignorance in your heart.

There is no exact translations of the Quran. These are all aproximations. Tafseer is the 100% translation, you need a whole libary.

[Chuckschinfist]

Once again you clearly show a lack of understanding of what biological evolution is. You make these insane claims up with no support except what other idiots tell you. Have a open mind and find out for yourself, you might learn something.

"If there are no facts in the Quran, it explained the ignorance in your heart.There is no exact translations of the Quran. These are all aproximations. Tafseer is the 100% translation, you need a whole libary."

Once again this is what they tell you.

[FahadKhan1988]

Alright, I dont know biology. Then why dont YOU TEACH me, and show me a SINGLE proof.

Tafseer is not a fantasy story, google the word "tafseer" if you have an open mind. Making a conclusion without any check is not freethinking, but dogma ;)

[emuholic]

lol muslims making scientific discoveries .. hilarious hahahaha

[8704822]

JazakAllah bro for uploading.

[CattleBruiser2008]

Arabic numeral are actually Indian... look it up

[strongside200]

no man your wrong Indian man discover zero with the Arabic numeral 1 threw 9 but if you look at the in Arabic numbers they have the same zero as the Arabic numeral

[CattleBruiser2008]

The number system is only called "Arabic" by the western world because it reached Europe through the Arabs. To this day, however, Arabs still call them "Indian numerals".

Example is the book "On the Use of Indian Numerals" (R. fi Isti'malal'Hisab al'Hindi)

[strongside200]

no they don't, don't tell me Arabs call it Indian numerals,look at the Arabic regional numbers it almost the same as the Arabic numeral, you even have one of the best scholar on that video said it Arabic numerals

[CattleBruiser2008]

I have read somewhere that Arabs call them Indian numerals - regardless, they were developed IN INDIA, including the number zero. Why would Arabs write books about the use of "INDIAN NUMERALS" if they were not from India?

On the Use of Indian Numerals" (R. fi Isti'malal'Hisab al'Hindi) كتاب في استعمال العداد الهندي by Al-Khwarizmi? Simple answer: They are from India. End of story.

[strongside200]

i dont know where did you read saying Arab say it Indian numeral, i am Arab and we never say it Indian numeral, and again look at the the regional Arabic numbers it almost the same as Arabic numeral and far as goes for zero i dont know if Indian discover it or not but it look the same as the regional zero in Arabic numbers, Al-khwarizimi was born and died in Baghdad go to mathsisgoodforyou . net algber is an arab and that an arabic name it will tell you right there and many other site's

[narlzp]

This is for strongside200 all historic evidence points to India this should be so hard to visualise perhaps you ahould visit the temple of gwalia in Northern India where zero is invented. Watch this watch?v=Na0xc1SiFJk

[PalestinianV]

initially they were indians but the arabs developed them and make them a much better numerical system !

[narlzp]

HOw much better PalestinianV? Was it astheticaly pleasing perhaps a different way of writing 8 in arabic as opposed to the Indian 8. The numerical system used now is and was the same as used in India in ancient times. The treaty that CattleBruiser2008 mentions is called Aryabhatia in honour of the scholar Aryabhat.

[PalestinianV]

watch this video '' Muslim contribution to Mathematics ''

[narlzp]

"The other ones are called as Roman numerical it is called as Arabic numerals. Why it is called Arabic numerals?" In the English speaking tongue its known as Hindu-Arabic numerals giving credit to the Indians who first discovered it and started using it. There is no mention in info of the many mathematical treaties handed over by the Indians to the Arabs.

[narlzp]

I forgot to mention its they use Arabic because it was the Arabs who passed it onto the Europeans. I might mention this Muslim scholar is a nut job I have seen his lectures before he claims the greatness of Buddhism is because of Islam and that Buddhism prophecized the coming of a greater prophet his full name Dr Zakir Naik. He is neither an archaelogist, historian or religiously learned in other faiths like Buddhism. He merely uses them to say Islam is better.

[AestheticAsatu]

Being a muslim woman, im slightly offended to the fact that most of the men are sitting down while a few women are standing up, what happen to common courtesy of givng up your chair? Which is the proper thing to do.

[kallikusta]

I think they are there to ask questions :S

[mobasel]

ok indian gave the numbers who did the hardwork .. if u gave a clay to a person n he makes a craft out of it .. who work is it the person gicing the clay or the person making the craft out of it .. ....

[Cnidarious]

This man says, Muslim scientists..

Why is it important that scientists be Muslim?

certainly there is no problem with one being a Muslim but i fail to understand why it is so important to Indicate this.

[JRBendixen]

Oi!

[gulmalik]

Zakir Naik

[DSSNTC]

Everybody is claiming Arabs took it from Indians...you guys are missing the point...yes the Arabs got the numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, etc...but they actually invented algebra and developed the modern math's and added the number 0, which without you wouldn't have any equation solved, Arabs and Muslims also has great contribution to chemistry, physics, medicine, astronomy, if you go to UK and Europe universities,in astronomy they still teach them the book 'mnaakh' which means 'the weather' in Arabic.

[narlzp]

I disagree on that point that Arabs soley invented algebra how about the first detailed works of Panini, Aryabhatta, Brahmagupta this is well before the numerical system was passed onto the arabs. Many arab mathematicians have this to say about Indian mathmaticians Al-Gaheth wrote: " India is the source of knowledge, thought and insight many Arab scholars like Al Maoudi comment on the greatness of India and the treaties translated from them. No they did not add the zero again it was India.

[narlzp]

Zero, decimation, Fibonnaci sequence and binary system worked on by Pingala, the cubic, calculas and logarithmic scale works by Aryabhatta. By the way this are Indian scholars not Arabic.

[balshehriaa]

Alkwarsmi - who the algebra and lograthim is called after...learned the useless Roman numeracles and inefficient hindu mathmatics...he invented the DICIMAL POINT which maths would worth nothing today without it ..and then he came up with a usefull quadratic equations to solve problems...watch this BBC report on youtube

[narlzp]

balshehriaa lol and yet it was the inefficient mathmatics as you call it of the Indian's that Arabs began to prosper many Indian mathmaticians were welcomed to Arabic treatises. I think this is a more accurate statement the Arabs rehashed what the Indians had done and inturn the Europeans rehashed what Arabs had added on and learned form the Indians. Decimal point again is not Arabic, Arabs back then were counting from their fingertips and using counters.

[balshehriaa]

Cont: "SCIENCE & ISLAM 6/6 | The language of science "

also watch the other episods to learn what other contributions have arabs and muslims provided.

[narlzp]

I really like to know where in the Quran can I learn calculas?

Or what Mohammed really thought of the universe

[DSSNTC]

lol. al Khawarsmi invented the dicimal point and the modern "Al-gebra"..i can talk about about Islamic schoolars contributions to science forever...not only in maths but physics, astronomy, medical science, etc.....you just dragged the Quran into this!! im talking about muslims not Islam!! watch the BBC report on youtube ( Science and Islam BBC) you might learn something!..no body denied the indians contribution..but the muslim schoolars inventions was extrodnary and made today Science possible.

[narlzp]

"you just dragged the Quran into this" So then why do you attempt to link Islam and science together I think my querie is quite legitimate given the fact many Muslims seem to parrot that Islam is science. I think perhaps you are best to laugh at this so called Dr who hasn't a clue about Indian history or its faiths I gave my reasons earlier. I could do the sam after all I do engineering & maths almost all my searches ended up with ancient India.

[narlzp]

I too can go on about the list of Indian scholars as well who made contributions in all those fields some dating 5 centuries before Arabs & Persians were studying and adding onto them. You may learn something too don't be shocked but the persian scholar Al Khawarsmi translated the works Aryabhatiya close to 800 to 900 AD. Shall I name a few more treaties translated from Sanskrit to central Persian & Arabic.

[movieguy7589]

This is all false the indians gave the indian numerals to arabs who then transferred it into the western world. Aryabhata mathematics and calculation of the earth's sphere goes back years before arabs knew it. And by the Pythogras own biography and history says that he went to the ganges to study math after which he developed his theorem from the satapatha brahmana. It bears the name Phytogras because he introduced the theorem to the west.

[NUKDEL]

Hindus and Muslims are stuck up in these trash claims of self glorifications.

Ancient civilizations worked independent of Religion.

Whether Arabs,Egyptions,Indians,Chines­e,Greeks.

Ideas could have overlapped during different ages.

Hindus and Muslims leaders have been fooling the masses with these self glorified rantings.

Layman is devoid imagination for better understanding

[DSSNTC]

Everybody is claiming Arabs took it from Indians...you guys are missing the point...yes the Arabs got the numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, etc...but they actually invented algebra and developed the modern math's and added the number 0, which without you wouldn't have any equation solved, Arabs and Muslims also has great contribution to chemistry, physics, medicine, astronomy, if you go to UK and Europe universities the still teach them the book 'mnaakh' which means 'the weather' in Arabic.

[movieguy7589]

Yes... I know they did invent algebra, etc. I am just saying the arabic numerals are actually indian that's all....by the way zero did exist in the indian numerals as well, just to let you know....

[CattleBruiser2008]

Wrong. The zero was invented in India by Aryabhatta. Look it up.

I am not trying to downplay the contribution Arabs made to the world - but it is only fair that I defend the contributions that Indians made to the world.

[Eating003]

wow, so wrong.......

Pythagoras was a greek who hypothesized that the sum of both legs of the triangle squared will give you the hypotenuse squared. so the assumption that the hypotenuse squared is the sum of the two sides, is blatantly false....

'a' and 'b' are the legs of the triangle and 'c' is the hypotenuse

a^2+b^2=c^2 Pythagorean theorem

c^2=a+b wrong theorem the Dr. has postulated.

[NUKDEL]

Keen observation and listening skills leading to error detection.

Good

[rajivunome]

Muslims took the work from great indian mathematics like aryabhata. Look up Abu Rayhan Biruni, he is considered too be the greatest muslims scientist ever in which he went too india too study Brahminical tradition! Look how much he acomplish from India!!

[rjdaredevil]

so where r all those muslim genius people !?

why muslims r dump now a days !?

why muslims r not inventing anything anymore !?

its just so sad....

[dgames]

what a stupid question...

just because they don't have enough money to reserch that doesn't mean we shouldn't appreciate the discovers they made in the past...

[spiritlite]

SalaamAlaikum, MASHALLAH, JAZAKALLAH KHAIR.