One Piece censoring comparison

[UnNuclear]

One Piece is not for little kids just like Bleach. Wtf is up with that last censor at the end!?!

[GamestLink]

That's it! I'm looking for the originals. I knew when I was first watching it a lot was censored. Probably the reason why I fell out of it.

[theL0SINGteam]

im not gonna lie... i never new it was censored that bad O.O think thats why i never watched onepiece after it was off cartoon network..... never really thought about the marines with water guns thing :/ feel kinda stupid now....

[bob55566]

Why does 4kids even bother making dubbed anime if they are going to censor any anime to disgusting levels? I don't remember anyone censoring looney toons or Tom and Jerry and those are sometimes nearly if not more violent than most animes. I can only reach one conclusion... 4Kids is an organization of evil.

[WhitedevilEE]

Hey look, Cap. SMOKER can breath smoke! :D

[warekoala]

also against the sand guy luffy could just randomly put liquid in him i guess

[warekoala]

according to 4kids ppl r invincible and dont bleed no matter how much u cut them so y trying to help they may end up making kids think they r invincible nd they will cut them selfs and be like WTF

[SanRukia]

SMOKEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEER XDXXXXXDDDDDDD

[DBZUTFAN01]

Why... the... LAUGH?! what are they afraid of kids seeing? a tongue?! jeez, 4kids sucks

[ThePloteron]

WOW THEY EVEN CENCORED RICE BALLS WHICH ARE JUST FOOD

[Dokubo1]

dont trust 4kids

[TheLittlePanther]

1:52 they censored ace???!!! OMFG!!!

[aghostshell]

God forbid children see guns, blood, cuts, explosives, Rice balls? and cleavage. They'll figure it out someday in the end. not like Internet is up here already telling them it's here.

[Galentw]

4kids: "We've got something new from Japan, called anime.

 Oh, It's cartoon, then I guess it's for babies.'

[Fandubridge]

My favorite is @ 0:44

[Incathelizard]

1:28 wouldnt that mean he would put the wrong end in his mouth because the lit end is the actual lolly

[pirategirl102]

Hate to be THAT person, but what is the name of this song? I love it!!

[termites21]

@pirategirl102 it's BRAND NEW WORLD by D-51 .

One piece opening 6.

[animemaster9500]

WHY DOES 4KIDS HATE RICE BALLS!!!!?

[gravitywheel]

Wow. 1:28.What the hell.

[gravitywheel]

We don't have cable. My son and I watch SUBTITLED, UNCUT anime together. I decide what is and isn't appropriate. :)

[HEVIPOINT]

Thank God i watch the original in Japanese, i hate it how America waters down this awesome Anime into a shitty kids film COME ON!!!!!!

[darkevilapie]

how are boobs not natural.(i like cookies tho) bunch of whiners

[Fire004Burn]

totaly fake!

[ScarFan93]

Thank god we didn't get the 4kids version in my country...

[Th3DarkPheon1x]

He doesn't laugh.

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAH!

[Th3DarkPheon1x]

How are riceballs evil?

[Th3DarkPheon1x]

Screw you 4kids. I'm watching Funimation's version!

[huntdog11]

4:08, oh hell no, you cant cencor luffy's grin

[TheCrazyBeaniez]

1:56 WTF

[ThunderCavalier]

0:42

Behold, the reason why the Navy does fuck all in One Piece.

[FnD4212]

What the heck?! Green gun!!

[kratos9312]

4:06 srsly?

[MikipatamBR]

Stop fucking animes, stupid 4kids!

[NYClolita]

we have proof 4kids is the anti-christ!!!! THEY TURNED WINE INTO WATER!!! XDDDDD hate you 4kids

[XFreeStyleZX]

Marines with water guns? Srsly?

[bobpie7]

@XFreeStyleZX

I know it's stupid for the marines to have water guns, but if you think about it water makes devil fruit users weak so other marines with swords can finish them off. Or the water can be extremely high pressure and cut through their enemies..............I don't know, it might work.

[ffOSTnerd217]

what song is this? =D

[myimaginaryfriend01]

@ffOSTnerd217 hashiridase, opening 6

[ffOSTnerd217]

@myimaginaryfriend01 ohhhhhh right. thank you! knew it was familiar... >.<

[myimaginaryfriend01]

@ffOSTnerd217 no problem :D

[madmcmurdockXIII]

@Someguy226X Hate to say this but, no shit sherlock xD. Fansubs > Corporations.

[Elhvir]

I still can't realize they actually got trough with removing the blood from final fight with crocodile. HOW they explain Luffy can suddenly punch him?!

[NebulousSquirrel]

...so i know they have stopped dubbing one piece now (THANK FUCK!) but i just gotta imagine how Hancock would be handled by 4kids...

She would have to be both less sexy, and not have been a slave... who therefore wasn't branded with a gigantic hot iron...

Maybe she was umm (this is hard) left with a umm mean stepfather who drew a errr hoof thing on her back in umm special paint that never comes off? (no tattoo's allowed remember)... hell maybe he painted a smiley face knowing 4kids

[Incathelizard]

@ToyoKadiyaMikayla I have never watched one piece in my life but yeah it might be, I just wanted to see because it looks creepy

[noisejunky1414]

lol they cencored rice balls

[pokeOneko]

i watch the subbed version so i didn't even know censoring was happening! fucking parental stuffyasses that can't tell their kids not to watch something and instead get angry over a cupple cigaretes and some wine. THEY'RE PIRATES FOR BINKS SAKE! let 'em have their way of life!

[DarkBlitzkrieg46]

For every anime is you want to see it original you have to buy it on dvd or blu-ray

[geckodragon]

@DarkBlitzkrieg46 or you could just go on an anime site..

[TheRainbowBunni]

What's wrong with Luffy having his mouth wide open? o_e *twitch*

[2992007bkts]

Geez this is ridiculous....Pffaahahaha... Even germany doesn't censor that damn much....hahaha .... Well maybe they thought Vivi's or Nami's drawn titts could harm someone?... O.o Errr... this is just exaggerated!

[Incathelizard]

What episode was the girl being stabbed by the long black fingers? It looked really creepy but awesome!

[ToyoKadiyaMikayla]

@Incathelizard Well, if by "the girl" you mean Nami (orange hair), it's episode 117.

[ToyoKadiyaMikayla]

@Incathelizard Oh, and you're right, btw, that scene is creepy...

[aevis1111]

... And in the end they share the treasure with everyone in the world, make friends with all enemies, have a huge party, and live happily ever after ...

[BlackMilker]

LOL the lollipop one mocked it!

[Garrund]

What the fuck with the green weapons? Does colour them green mke them less lethal? I'll take note of that: green guns with real bullets next birthday..ñ who knows? Maeby my parents buy me them that way....

[MrChamber69]

cigar to mainstream put lollipop

[ThePirateKEE]

wtf. haha. luffy's huge smile at the last. what happened

[pappaolof]

I hate childrens food

[BahamutZero777]

-_- this is why i always watch anime in Japanese they dont take out the stuff that would make the anime good

[DragonXKeeper92]

0:28 wtf is the guy in the purple holding over cobys head?! i mean serusly if only tht were hovering over cobys head luffy wouldnt have bother to punch him or coby woulda been all like*cowerdly doge then run away over to luffy* cencoring makes no sense

[Xfluffymonkeyx]

anime people's blood is imperative to the plot.

[TheOriginalKingD]

Did you know 4kids edited out black pirates because they thought they were to dark and would offend people... I'm black and I can tell you thats complete bullshit because if it was true nobody would watch wesley snipes movies

[Trojianmaru]

This is making me want to watch Dubbed one piece just to see how different it truly is, but my jaw hurts from this small video alone (epic Jaw drop :O) I don't think I could survive 4kids

[KidDerp]

NOOO!!! THE BASTARDS TOOK HIS CIGAR!!!

[ThePirateKEE]

@KidDerp and changed it to lollipop/ :D

[SoulTheHedgehog1]

2:02 How do you fall down like that when you don't even get hit.

1:27 That's just funny how a ciggarete can turn into a lollypop like that.

[SuperSaiyanLink093]

They edited Miss Merry Christmas' boobs because she was too sexy.

[lololololol821]

Rules Of 4K!DS:

-No Smoking

-No Tatoos

-No Rice Balls

-No Purple Drinks

[charizardoreo]

@lololololol821 -no huge smiles

[runescapedude47]

What is so bad about riceballs?

[narutosonicxfan]

1:52 Ace is a ghost!!!!

[narutosonicxfan]

0:33 cause a sword is better than a chain of explosives. :D

[MachSpeedMaster]

I wonder if Pokemon was ever like this.....

[Someguy226X]

EVERYTHING I KNOW IS A LIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[sAvViTo19]

xaxaxaxaxaxaxaxaxaxaxaxaxaxaxx­axa they completely deleted Ace!!!!!!!!!!!

[HeavenIsALie88]

So apparently, kids don't know what wine, cigarettes, blood and tits are. They must be from Nameck.

[onelessninjapirate]

Im glad they changed the colour of that guys suit from black to purple. i found the original too scary (!) ¬¬

[Yosher21]

Just imagine what they're going to do to Boa Hancock.

[19Stickman94]

Is there anyone out there waching the censored version?

[coolcattie1]

@19Stickman94 sometimes I do it with my friend and laugh of how screwed up it is ;D

[19Stickman94]

@coolcattie1 lol yes i think i will watch some episodes of it now just to laugh my ass off :DD

[MixMasterNightShayd]

and where are all my blood and bombs.

[MixMasterNightShayd]

I understand that the green rods are suppose to replace the guns; but seriously what child friendly object are they suppose to be.

[tomboypanda]

ACE IS GONE

[tomboypanda]

now i no why i hated it as a kid

[Anathar88]

They should have just shown like it originally is, and if the parents get mad, just tell 'em "Well, here's a thought: DON'T LET YOUR KIDS WATCH IT!"

Fuck a parent.....

[matheusbr20]

0:43 A water gun?!

You gotta be kidding me!

[jetmaster16]

Bullshit at 4:03 .....Why the pointless censoring of a smile?!

[101playmakers]

@jetmaster16 Maybe 4kids thought it was too close to a rapeface for the kiddies -_-'

[jetmaster16]

@101playmakers lol

[Gerbil360000]

I prefer the left side a lot more than the right. It brings more to the show.

[ShaftplayN]

i don't get what seeing clevage would do to children, seriusly there are more sexual shows on TV that kids can watch yet the PTC and FCC are so stupid they don't realize that.

[AXELisSMEXY]

lol all the girls have no clevage

[Mini96Mew]

Why do they have to change riceballs into cookies??

[KaiokenLuffy]

Doing this to a masterpiece like one piece, is like killing art itself

[g0h4nl0v3r]

REALLY? U HAVE 2 GO AS FAR AS 2 EDIT A SMILE? WTF? SOME OF THE SIGS AND BLOOD...meebee explainable... BUT A SNILE OF ALL THINGS? WHAT IS THIS WORLD COMING 2? hopefully 2 a beautiful time were NO1 WILL EDIT THE HELL OUT OF STUFF!!!!!

[Athnar93]

Wow, suddenly I want to chew 4Kids the fuck out over this crap... seriously super soakers? Well at least they're not invisible guns like in Yugioh -_-

[shadowhedgehogfan22]

what is this song

[FluqioxoDresults]

@shadowhedgehogfan22 One Piece opening 6.

[Narutofan345565]

in the 4kids world they use super soakers to kill people

[PsychicEmeraldSpirit]

Why would they even attempt this?

[bryan4490]

cookies really?

[kztar621]

Why do they erase the cigarettes but not the smoke?

[UtoPiKal]

WTF is with luffys smile s:p it looks retared in CN

[giserson2]

...and thats why i read the translated manga

[samtemdo8]

4kids= making one piece......for kids.

funimation= making one piece for 14 and above by keeping all the action, blood, sexyness, guns, and naughty langauge from the japanese version for "FUN"!

Ironic eh?

[Suppenschuh]

One thing ive found somehow rediculous. Ruffy killed Sir Crocodile at 2:40 cause he cant stand water, but he bled and blood is also wet. in german version he killed crocodile but his arms were cmpletely dry. The blood was censored so it was like "WTF? Wich blood?"

[Broski527]

all of these censoring can suck it cause seriously..CENSORING A DAMN CIGARETTE!! IT'S A CIGARETTE, GOSH

[GrimmjowJaegerjaque1]

@megamanboy Whats the music?

[Barbaryotaku]

Lol how is translating the logo into English considered censoring? Before besmirching their good work you should perhaps learn the definition of the word.

[DoomGuyFifi]

...........  that is all

[lakysay]

wait. if Luffy didn't had any blood in his fists when fighting crocodile, then how the hell did he managed to win against him? in the japanese version he won because of the blood, then with what logic did he win?

[Rexaura888]

@lakysay Somehow he managed to learn Busoshoku Haki during their fight...and then immediately forgot it.

[GreggMays64]

@lakysay Well actually Luffy used his sweat. It was so hot down there that he was sweating a lot.

[4787716a]

SO THIS WHAT IT COME TO 4KIDS ERASING BOOBS U CAN ERASE THEIR BOOBS YOU KEEP LADY TSUNADE BOOBS THOSE THINGS ARE BIGGER THAN GIANT RASEGAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[shadow101010100]

@4787716a lol

[mkoba24]

I think Smoker look cooler with da smoke just comein out his mouth

[DrTaconinja]

It's funny because the lollipop stick looks like a cigarette.

[aevis1111]

They censored rice balls into cookies! This is hilarious. Also Ace is so dangerous he had to be removed ... :D

Btw to react @RogueWarrior869's comment:

It is not good if children find violence normal or cool. They simply can't understand the dangers and this is exactly what might lead them hurting themselves or others. Of course too much censoring can happen. I think the reason is this: the target audience of One Piece is ~16 and the audience of 4kids is <10. This show is simply not for kids.

[GrimmjowJaegerjaque1]

Whats the soundtrack?

[Avenexx]

omg he have dirty hairs lets censore that because kids stop showering

[DBinitiate]

I can understand censorings, but you have to stay rational. Some twenty years ago (or somewhat more), these censorships would make sense. Nowadays this is just unnecessary. Most of the movies that are produced now contain worse things than the things that are censored here.

[Konogn]

WHAT TEH FRICK IS DIS CRAP????

[AliceSonicGundamFan]

1:57 Mysteriously Appearing Powered ChopperMan.

[captainblackjack123]

ive never seen four kids version but im guessing instead of using blood againts crocodile he used sweat?

[Stereotypeblackguy]

I am Insulted they censored the Blood and the Boobs!!!!

[almunia99]

his name is SMOKER...and he doesn't smoke...ver smart 4kids

[MajorGravity]

Luffy cant win against Crocodile without his blood. DUH, 4kids. :-(

[shadow101010100]

@MajorGravity they said he used his sweat

[ShaggyTheOnly]

For reasons like this I am thankful that I do not life in America, I hate fucking censors, when I think of any I always think GFY tenfold and there after gdiad.

[xENxFitz]

NOT THE CLEAVAGE!!!

[samverwimp]

wich is thing song :p what opening of one piece is this ?

[SkillTriger]

1:54 WTF is Ace a bad example for kids??? Fuck

[halak4141]

I hate 4kids version.

[TheSkesh]

Man, no wonder america is so fat and pathetic, remember when we weren't pussies?!

[dogbone2121]

So.. In Arabasta they used water guns.... While the country was in the middle of a drought.... :|

[GamersForever100]

Whats next, swearing in future shows like YuGiOh being censored......oh wait, thats already happening

-_-

[TheFantasticTom]

censoring ruins everything

[shadow101010100]

wait if in the croc fight if toonami didn't have blood how did luffy beat him?

[coolcattie1]

@shadow101010100 he said he used his sweat...

[SteampunkScorpion]

Wow I just started watching one piece but I guess I'm watching the uncensored. Wow the one where Helmeppo is holding a hammer thing instead of a gun...wow just wow

[egoexitosus]

@SteampunkScorpion When it was first dubbed it was done by 4kids, and they had to censor it alot . It is now being done by funimation the way it was originally intended which is probably what you are watching.

[war42]

I always wondered why there was smoke coming out of his mouth....

[iSewil]

@war42 Because he is a smoke logia? ._.

[the55898]

no cigars no tattoo wtf? are cigars evil?

[09064678272]

I guess they edited the rice ball cus it looked like.....breast or just cuz its dirty?

[09064678272]

I guess you guys watch One Piece on tv....pfft

[Greystripe55]

._. W..... T...... F.......

[silverbomb46]

the hulu version is uncencered

[BlaqkJackal]

WHY DOES 4KIDS HATE RICEBALLS?! WHY!!!

[Tataru5117]

that last one can be real ._. but it must

[cutepigs1234]

And taking into account that the anime is less blood filled than the manga...

[FlashFire40]

3:05

Lol covering up breasts

[owenuzumaki]

omg good thing i saw the japanese bersian

[stelkin656]

Kid.1 Hey, Eric can i try throwing these knives at you?

Kid.2 Um, no thanks

Kid.1 Aww, come on, you'll be fine, they always do it in One piece and Naruto, and they never get hurt.

Kid.2 How can you tell?

Kid.1 THEY NEVER BLEED!!!

Someday 4kids will get sued for their overprotective BS editing!

[RogueWarrior869]

I may be wrong(grasping at straws, really) but, aren't they censoring this more for the parents sake and less for the children?

Children normally find this stuff, violence and blood, normal and or cool. Parents do not. They usually see it as mindless violence that could warp their child's mind and possibly make them act out as if they are trying to mimic the show/character.

In short

Censored show = parents not on their backs.

Again, possibly grasping at straws.=x

[zeran147]

@RogueWarrior869 its true, you know that about 95% of young people who have re-inacted violent things from different media, games, movies and anime or cartoons for example, have infact had a history of mental illness before ever coming into contact with said media. In some cases they have been blamed when never having had contact with them. im not taking a stab at parents but personally i think the whole violent games are bad scenario is them looking to place blame in case something goes wrong.

[MrOisean]

@zeran147 95% of young people? If you're gonna say something you better be able to back that shit up with evidence.

[zeran147]

@MrOisean what evidence would satisfy you and from what, country, region, gender, age group and ethnicity?

can i also ask you to more carefully analyse the wording before quoting people. as i wasn't quoting from the text released and the subject, and as i didn't have it on hnd i could give the exact figures hence the "about". please also take into account that children with mental illnesses who have committed violent acts from shows like this number inthe dozens ina particular country per year.

[TheMagicalBlossom]

wait was Ace just cencored ind that one scene okey WTF

[ffOSTnerd217]

i understand them cutting out like, spurting and shooting blood, stuff like that. i mean, i'm much older than i would be if i were to watch 4kids dubs, and i still sort of cringe when stuff like that happens. but to completely cut it out... LOOK IF YOU DON'T THINK ITS APPROPRIATE FOR KIDS THAN JUST LEAVE IT TO JAPAN OR FUNIMATION!!!

[AmeliaOak]

@ffOSTnerd217 Someone from 4kids came forward and said that they never should have touched One Piece because it was a show that was never meant for kids in the first place.

[eyaw3008]

I really wonder how is franky's naked scene,,, =.=///

[drizztken]

all this sensoring crap i still have yet 2 see the animation make cheif zeph eat his leg that would b wicked

[LifeOrbPlusle]

In america....Blood, Cuts, Guns, and Boobs do not exist. According to 4kids.

[FutureUSMC12]

Why cut all the blood? It's not like kids have never seen blood before.

[UltraAnimaniac101]

Dear God...I always thought people were just hating on the 4kids version of One Piece but now... How could I not notice this when I watched the show?! I mean I didn't even know the guns were water guns as a child. I all this time I thought they were just mad at the dubbing which I thought was alright (better the funimation one which was the reason I stopped watching it on Toonami) but now....god...

[GrimmjowJaegerjaque1]

4Kids builds themselves a lot of plot holes, like how Luffy was bloody when her beat crocodile.. he needed to be bloody and what the hell was with censoring luffy's open mouth... kids know what open mouth looks like.

[AmeliaOak]

@GrimmjowJaegerjaque1 that one got me too. How in the world does that make sense? How do they justify censoring that? What in the world?