With all due respect to the poster, the only reason India even *has the boundaries it has* is because of the British Colonials. And why annex Pakistan and Bangladesh? Wouldn't that just be more headaches and problems for India?
inspite of all the boundaries muslims are one..and every muslim will be united for the well being of human beings because muslim is meant for peace.. dont abuse each other because you are not ALLAH who is superior.. at the end your identity other than muslim will be shamefull for you..
Whats with the Hostility, you should realize one very important thing, In India, in West Bengal, being Indian and Bengali is the samething, there is no difference, only you see a difference, Let Bangladesh be, and let India be, but Bangladesh is not the only country for Bengalis, India is also the home for Bengalis.
There is no hostility but I am pointing out the obvious. If you are a citizen of India then you are Indian. That is your nationality and identity. I am Bengali. Bangladesh refers to Bengali's. The identity, language, culture is all Bengali.
West Bengal is being taken over by north indian hindi culture, half the young population can't even speak Bengali but it doesn't matter bengali culture won't die because BD is still here and Bengali will remain the identity and language
If Bangladesh drowned tommorow then I would rather drown in Bangladesh under my sea then go to India. If Bangladesh never became rich then I would rather be poor and hungry in Bangladesh sitting under my flag with my family with the pride that we are free. If Bangladesh would turn into a military dictatorship then I would remain to take my country back to democracy or die trying. If Bangladesh faced a terrible disease then at least I get to die in my motherland.
I dont usually comment on youtube, but here i Must. I am a Bengali, a Muslim and a Proud Indian. So, you being a Bangladeshi, might have a lot in common with me. But you talk about freedom, let me tell you we in India are free, we are on the set of becoming a recognized superpower of the region, and we the Bengali Muslims of India are very Proud and uphold Indian Democracy. You are willing to die for Bangladesh, yet you forget where your history comes from.
I will never ever be part of another country. Not after what happened. Only bengali's can be trusted by Bengali's. I will for my Bangladesh and all my Bengali's hindu. muslim, atheist, buddhist whatever. I don't care if India is a superpower as long as BD rises out of poverty which it is doing cutting it by 2% a year and will have cut it in half by 2015 and met all of our MDG's.
Whether you agree with me or not, realize one facet of India and Bengal. There is a Bengal in India, and it is called West Bengal, out of respect for East Bengal aka Bangladesh. Another truth, that you will not agree with, is that when you say your Bengali, we associate that with being Indian. When you say you are Bangladeshi, we associate you with being Bangladeshi. Being Bengali to you has a different meaning than to us Bengali Indians. Just respect that. Joy Bengal, and Joy Hind!
I'm from Bangladesh and no way in hell will I ever join with India and lose my Bengali culture and language. Anyway I don't think any Indians want Bangladesh to join. I wish India all the best of luck but Bangladesh and India are on separate paths. Bangladesh' to survive and rise out of poverty then find our soul and find what kind of country we are, hopefully a centre of knowledge, peace and calm. One where we are insulated from the horrors of the world and may live in peace.
The number of Bengali speakers has dropped to about half in West Bengal amongst its young people replaced with Hindi and English. The street sighs are in Hindi and English, the institutions are British. The culture of North India and bollywood are replacing Bengali culture. They are Indians not Bengali. I'm proud of being part of the only country in south asia to win its independence in revolution not be handed it like Porkistan and India. Blood was spilled for it and will never be forgotten
Like you said Bangladesh might burn tommorow and you will care, so will India, because Bangladesh was once a part of India, surrounded 95 percent by India, so what happens to you, whether you burn or flourish..we Indians will care for Bangladesh, even if Bangladeshis dont care about India. By the way Ashoka..is an Indian Emperor..what does it have to do with Bangladesh?
The anthem of Bangladesh..Amar Shonar Bangla was written by Tagore, not for an independent Bangladesh, but for the unity of Bengal, India, when the state was partioned first in 1905. Be Proud to be a Bangladeshi, you are grew up across the border so you feel that way, but there are many many Bengali in India, Muslim and Hindu alike who are Proud Bengali Indians and know what freedom is really about.
You were given your freedom by Britain, my grandfather died fighting the Porkistani's for mine. Believe me i know the price of freedom and I will not betray his sacrifice for anyone. Tagore was around before Bengal was seperated but what's done is done. You are an Indian now and I am not. I wish you luck but our paths are separate now and will never join again.
India must get larger. Nations that stop growing, start shrinking. India must rescue its irredenta in Bangladesh and Pakistan occupied Punjab, Kashmir, and Sindh. The rest of Pakistan will go to Afghanistan, so that NATO and Afghanistan can cleanse Pakistan occupied Afghan irredenta from Pakistan's hypocritical anti-Islamic ideology of hatred and terrorism. India will become a super-power, with its historical lands, including the irredenta of Sri Lanka, Maldives, and Nepal.
I am so glad i found u on youtube, this is soo true ive been trying to get indians to join me in the fight for all of the real india including pakistan and bangladesh to be ours again. but alll ive found are people defending hinduism. how lame. i hae a propostion for pakistan if ur interested in hearing it please message me.
@User100606: I'm a Bangladeshi Muslim and I see that the way you talk you want aggressive anexation of Bangladesh. India may invade Bangladesh since it may be beneficial, since Dhaka, Sylhet, and Chittagong are becoming megacities as the years progress. POverty is going down 2% every year thanks to Grameen Bank, so I know India has her eye in East Bengal, because we're certainly doing better than West Bengal as a state.
Xajcrunkx, if Bangla Desh is doing so well, then why are Bangla Deshis flooding Assam and other Indian states bordering Bangla Desh? Why are Bangla Deshi women being desperately exported to Pakistan's financial capital Karachi's streets for prostitution? Bangla Desh has had many military coups like Pakistan. Only Mother India has remained a stable democracy with judicial integrity, the people of East Bengal, West Punjab, Pak. occ. Kashmir, and Sindh dream of being a part of Mother India again.
xajcrunkx , come out of illusion. How do you expect to do better than West Bengal??? Already West Bengal has double per capita income than you and it is growing far faster than you and it has a far better infra than you. Wake up dear friend, stop writing useless blogs and start doing work. (I am from West Bengal and I have stayed a long time in Sylhet, Pabna and Chitagong due to my job.)
foronecause,I am in favour of South Asian Union bcoz that can bring South Asia at the centre-stage of the world and ofcourse unitedly we will become the biggest superpower as we were before.
But the situation now is not suitable for that.We r fighting war last sixty years(blame British).There is massive amount of religious hatred against India everywhere.Moreover in Pakistan & B'desh fundamentalists r becomming powerful day by day and it can b a serious threat to India's security and economy.
If there are any muslim indians, I would be interested in hearing your views, about the relationship between pakistan and India. Is there any hope for peace, and maybe an South Asian Union? Would you support it, or be against it. And more generally what are the problems for pakistan and india ahead, and what can be the possible solutions to those problems.
Yes ALL Kashmiri's should have been given a vote in 1948, but they didn't. Tough bloodly luck. Any vote now wouldn't be fair becuase of the Hindu Kashmiri's forced out of their homes, by the blood sucking muslims.
If U don't like indian kashmiri then fuck off 2 paki kashmiri, where I'm sure U will live much better life, one of milk and honey.
And if U guys go, takes some other muslims from the rest of india, pakistan was the home of muslims so why live in India
You ass hole drink my piss. whole kashmir is our kere maan day koosay manji daa kay tere bhen choodan kooosi maaan day bachiaa. Tere dharti maan de bund which baan paa kay kud lavan gay kashmir
Really whole of kashmir is yours, then why don't you have it?
Maybe becacause you are gay, and can't deal with real MEN.
And asking me to drink your piss, is certain gay. If YOU are an example of a Kashmir man, then they are all gay pussy's, that like getting fucked by the Indian army.
If you want your comments understood by a wider audience, you should try using english. Unless Kashmir are so stupid that you can't use english, in which case, use whatever fucking language you want.
It (democracy) suits India much better than it suit either the Isamic World, or that lovely country next door to us (pakistan).
But you shouldn't worry, the Western world including those lovely Americans will help ALL of the Islamic world see the wonderful light of democracy.
It might mean short term pain, like the terrible things that happened in places Abu ghraib and Guantanamo bay. Although you maybe muslim, I don't support any bad things done to the koran or muslim people.
How many years of democracy has paki enjoyed, since it's independence in 1947?
Pakistan is a basket case, it tries hard to compete with India,it looks west towards Afganistan, and has tried it's best 2 make it into a basket case as well.
I'm sure Muhammad Ali Jinnah will be proud of the basket case that is pakistan.
But I don't blame Pakistan, muslims seem 2like living under dictorships. That's why most of the Islamic world is so governed.
most muslims countries are democracies, where people elect their leaders Iran, Egypt, Lebanon, Turkey.
Democracy is rule of the majority and is bad for 3rd world nations. It leads to radicals and corrupt people being elected. (ie. BJP, or Benazir Bhutto)
India is a democracy, and when the BJP lost those radicals as you stated excepted the fact they had lost the election.
Bhutto, was the BEST hope for pakistan. And the crazies killed the best hope for pakistan. If democracy is so bad why do most people in pakistan want to live in a democratic country. Why did Mohammad Ali Jinnah want a democracy for both EAST and WEST pakistan.
FACE it pakistan has failed the democracy test, what a real shame.
nonsense. Benazir was a crook and an american puppet. If india was a democracy they would let kahlistan and kashmir go along with waster bengal, goa, utter pradesh. No secular country allows relgious parties to enter elections. As for Bengal, it was a mistake to make them east Pakistan. Bangladesh along with india, Pakistan should have been an indepdent country in 1947
Beanair maybe was a crook, and YES an American puppet but she was the best hope for Pakistan, that was the real shame. I know muslims don't like Americans, but if YOU willing to follow them they will help you, as they did for Pakistan during the cold war.
Democracy doesn't mean that you let small groups do whatever they want to do. ALL of India supports indian kashmir in India. I know you might not like it, but this view is shared by a majority of Indian Muslims.
Gohlan5,New cities & industries r comming up in India.These people can b employed in these labour intensive industries alongwith Indians.Already places like Punjab, Kerala and Gujrat facing shortage of unskilled labour and it is going to increase.
Unless we start thinking on it right now,it is going to become a massive human disaster and atleast 40 mmillion people r going to b affected.And this 40 million hungry people will become new talibans and effect the peace and security of whole world.
Pakistan is the direct result of British divide and rule policy.
My friend today Greater India, would have been a stronger place and better place.
Can you not see the fact that 125 million our brothers and sisters of Pakistan, joined to 104 million brothers and sisters of Bangladesh, and 133 million muslims in India. That is 362 million muslims, which would of been better for the people of Pakistan, Bangladesh, and India.
Gohlan5,we can solve the problems of Bangladesh if we work unitedly-
firstly, Bangladesh can get neccessary food item from India to stop hunger in short run, secondly,India is planning to have second phase of green revolution and it will b done in Eastern India and we can include B'desh in such plan which will help B'desh to share technology,capital and fresh and rain water with India.
Thirdly,we need to train new skills and urbanize peope staying in costal areas.
For one thing NO wars between all of us. And I hope you do remember that East and West Pakistan went to war against each other.
These and other resources could have been spent on improving the lives of people.
I hope you don't think the money spent by these poor countries on their amries couldn't be better spent on their people.
The problems India and other countries face are just going to get much worse, like global warming. Some type of Union, may help put their veiws to the world
Gohlan5,situation in Bangladesh is really grave.There a massive part of land is going under sea in next few yrs and salty water is increasing in rivers due to influx of sea water so more and more land is becomming infertile,so food production is going down and population is exploding.So,just think what is going to happen there after 10/15years(food inflation is already 20%).Bangladesh is going to b like time bomb for India unless India intervene and solve the problem with long term goal.
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
The main problem of Asian EU is,India have to take sacrifice it's economic gain for lot of enemy and failed states like Pakistan, Bangladesh etc.Moreover they will soon start destructive activities in our soil.Muslim mindset will never change- marry 4 wives, produce atleast 10 children,then send them to madrasa(noone can afford quality education for so many kids), without proper education remain poor forever and according to Koran for all ur miseries blame infidels and start jihad.
Global - I'm not muslim, but I don't think the Koran blames all infidels for their problems.
An Asian EU, would not hold back India. Plus India would be able to held it's partners.
Pakistan and Bangladesh I wouldn't go as far as calling them failed states. Pakistan needs some help which it should be able to get within this Union.
A greater Union would also mean that both Pak and India, could spend less on defence and more on helping the poor
Gohlan5,I am not calling them failed states. Transperency International(TI) is a famous international organization and they publish list of failed staes every year and in their list they have included- Pakistan, bangladesh, Nepal and Srilanka as failed states bcoz they have failed to provide basic amenities to their citizens.Bangladesh has become the most corrupt country in the world for 5 consecutive yrs in TI list.Even CIA has predicted that by 2015,Pakistan will completely fail and collapse.
GlobalRecruiter............The Next Eleven or N-11 are world's , potentially, next biggest economies. Pakistan and Bangladesh are both part of N-11.
Besides if Pakistan and Bangladesh still fall, India will suffer as well. i.e Afghanistan got ruined, Pakistan suffered big time. The same will happen to India if what you are saying is correct. Hopefully not though.
And you're bragging about India. 320 million people live on less than a dollar a day and 600 million don't have adequate health care.
foronecause,I am not racist.I have worked in Bangladesh for 2 years as IT teacher, I can say that Bangladeshis(hope Pakistanis too)are very good people.I have many very good friends and students there. And even after leaving Bangladesh 4 years back,I have a very good contact with them.
The love and respect that I got there was really great.All the Indian teachers working there were very happy.Some have stayed there till now and others who came back still have a nice relationship with students.
Global...........Why are you being racist? or religiously discriminative?
Next to no one gets married 4 times in Pakistan. And not a lot of people have ten children. So, in no way is that the Muslim mindset. There aren't too many sending kids to madrasas. Only some radicals in the West, near Afghanistan.
Go read the Quran before you say anything about it.
But sad fact is that the condition there is very bad compared to India.Everything is 3 to 5 times more expensive than India(official exchange rate is 100INR=170BDT),law and order condition is too bad(u can b robbed and murdered anytime anywhere),rampant corruption and there is no hope of country's future.I really feel sorry for my dear and nice students there.I know that my students r not anyway less than anyone, but they r victim of corrupt politicians and policy of hatred.
foronecause,both Pakistan and Bangladesh has huge potential.But to harness that u need right policy,right leadership and good relationship with neighbours.Sadly the leadership in both countries r very corrupt and fundamentalist.They r making their people fool in the name of religion and exploiting them.India ofcourse wants Pakistan and Bangladesh to developd.But u need to take first step- stop hatred,feel we all south asians r brothers and united south asia is only way to prosperity.
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
I know that partition was wrong and that Pakistan, India and Bangladesh should never have been separated.
Now it has been over 60 years since partition. And I believe that Pakistan and India have developed some different characteristics. Pakistan was supposed to be given the name "Islamic Republic of India" because that's what it is and we are Indian Muslims.
We are the same and yet different. But Punjab is still totally the same.
I think South Asia should make some thing like EU.
foronecause , u r absolutely right. Pakistanis were part of India for last 10000 years. But in last 60 years Indians and Pakistanis became completely different. Now it is very hard to unite. I think Indians will not be ready to unite as they think unification will bring Jehadis directly on their soil without any resistance.
Pakistan were not part of India for 10000 years. Look at map of Persian Sassanid Empire from 100AD - 700AD (Pakistan was part of Persia). Before that, look at map of Alexander's Empire, Pakistan is in it. It was also part of Afghan rulers for many years. Before that at 500BC, it was part of 1st Persian Achaemenid Empire. After 700AD it was part of Arab Empire, then it remained part of Islamic Persia for 100's of years until Mughals conquered rest of India and ruled together.
ancient HINDU maps show all of present day paki punjab and sindh as being part of BHARAT. ONE DAY India will get its territory back..all we have to do is fight another war and this time show no mercy by capturing a large chunk of paki territory.
The word 'Hindu' is derived from 'Sindh'. Words like 'Hindu' and 'Hindustan' were the names given by Persians/Mid-Easterns. The word 'Hinduism' is infact a western term given to the religion that was followed by the people living south of Sindh. The actual name of religion is 'Sanatan Dharma'. The word 'Hindu' cannot be found in early scripts of India.
Therefore its ridiculous to claim there was any ancient 'Hindu' map.
Secondly, south of Indus River i.e present day India was never ruled by one single kingdom before the Mughals arrived. It was a colony of several Kingdoms ruling different regions. North-Western regions of India i.e Pakistan were always separate than India from atleast 500BC (just look at map of 1st Persian Empire). Same can be said about Bengal which had been a separate Dynasty.
If you want to claim that I am wrong, please provide me evidence.
alifbah I don't think you know much about Indian history going buy your comments. Yes at times India was fragmented so was China as well as Arabia. So does this mean we all go back to our fuedal states? Offcourse not. The greatness of some of the civilisations has been their ability to group together. There are nunerous instances in Indias history the Maghadas, then the Maurayas ruled by Asia's first buddhist monarch king Asoka, Kushans who ruled much of central asia Guptas, Cholas & Mughals.
Pakistanis don;t feel partition was wrong because they don;t but into the myth of India in the first place. For example I am from Sialkot-we were part of many Empires: Greek,Afghan,Persian, Mughal and annexed to British India for only 100 years. We don;t identify with India-you are right that Indian Muslims who migrated to Pakistan soemtimes think differently about partition since they left their homes but native Pakistanis know their history and don't see the British Indian colony as a homeland
Gohlan5,I completely agree with u that without Pakistan(and muslims)we can do much better.I was reading in an article that in 1000 AD,India and all Europe had same amount of GDP and almost same per capita.After that India went under muslim rule due to our infighting and we can see the result.Now Europe has fifteen times more GDP than India and 50 times more per capita income than us.Since Hindus rule in India again,India is again prospering.And in the world all muslims countries r backward.
Gohlan5,in 2007 India was 12th economy in the world - after US(13.8 trillion dollars), Japan(4.3 td),Germany(3.3 td),China(3.2td), UK(2.7td),France(2.5td),Italy(2.1td),Spain(1.4td),Canada(1.4td),Brazil(1.3td) and Russia(1.1td).But India(1.1td) is growing much faster.And it is expected that by 2020, India's GDP will be 3 td and by 2030,it will be around 6 td and India will be the fourth biggest economy after EU,US and China. But in 1000 AD,our GDP was equal to EU which is now 16.8 td.
I see that you don;t want to hear the views of real Pakistanis. Just to remind you, we don;t buy into the myth of a British created colony called India. Our people and land mass have been part of many a civilisation. We can be friends with India but never one. India would do better to unite with Sri Lanka and Bangladesh who share the same culture and history as India. Cheers from a native Pakistani!
Actually, the unification of Indian and Pakistan were made by the Mughals before British. Before the Mughals, regions of Pakistan were part of Islamic Empire, and before that it was part of Persian or Alexander's Empire, and before that all the way to IVC it was completely different than India. Pakistan is very different than India.
Plus, I think Bengal and East Indian region should be liberated from India. Bangladesh, West Bengal, Manipuri has completely different culture than rest of India.
Thanks for your clarification. Like you, I belive that native Pakistanis hould point out the historical uniqueness of our Pakistani land mass and how distinct it is from India. I think that people go on and on about the partition and British India not understanding that real Pakistanis don't give a damn about the artificial British colony. Our need is to highlight our own history and thrown away the British inspired crap about the Raj and rediscover our own roots. Cheers from another Pakistani.
alifbah0 , firstly u need a lot more knowledge about history and geography. Bengalis are not separate than rest of India. I am from West Bengal and I can tell you that all Bengalis of West Bengal treat themselves as proud Indian.
I am not saying that West Bengalis are separate than India. Ofcourse, WB is inside India and hence part of India. Both India's national anthem was written in Bengali. I am aware of that. All I have stated is that Bengali culture, customs is very different than rest of India. And, the reason I talked about liberation is because, Bengali culture is being demolished/replaced with Bollywood culture over the years.
Daska66 even if u kneel down and ask for unifciation..India will not accept..we are a forward looking, progressive nation with a rich heritage culture and history..we were not born 50 years back...and we do not like to keep our own women under burqas while salivating at other women..we are not a frustrated copy cat nation..all the best..may Allah bless Paksitan.
We do wish all the best for India but try to understand patritotic Pakistanis want nothing of it. We are proud of our own history and traditions.You may fun of our culture and but I don't have to make fun of your culture to love my own. We are just proud to be Pakistanis and we will achieve our own destiny. Don't worry about what we do and to each his own.May Bhagwan give Shakti to India and to Indians. Cheers!
daska66, I wish Pakistan to develop but I think Pakistan cannot grow without help of India. Because India has huge resources, manpower and market. But the differences of mentality between people of two countries are too huge. So, I do not think it is possible atleast now.
GlobalRecruiter - pakistan can develop by itself and do petty well as a result. It like India needs to sort out corruption, and get some type of stable democratic government.
Where Inida will do really well, is the range of resources and manpower. India will sooner or later be one of the largest and powerful countries in the world, along with China.
Paskistan can't hope to compete, with the likes of India and China, as long as it know that it can do OK for itself, as a third rate power.
i reality i think only sindh, punjab and parts of NWFP, not to mention kashmir, can be reincorporated back into hind. balochistan and Waziristan FATA, r not integral parts of our land. essentially we need the indus valley back in its entirity.
AKHAND BHARAT AMAR RAHE!!! Im glad to see theres ppl that wat to see the reunification of the motherland. if u r as committed to the cause than me, u will see our goal achieved in ur lifetime.
no reunification please. india is doing quite well and we don't need instability of pakistan nor the poor bangladeshis being a burden on social programs
r u jokin bangaldesh ppl have all come over anyway...the only thing we havent got is the land. lol. pakistan ppl used to be tolerant b4 1947, its time to take back wat is rightfully ours, let them embrace secularism and democracy. jai hind brother!
Fuck porquistan!!!
INDIA WONS 3 WARS (AGAINST POUKISTAN) & FUCKS UP THIS MOTHERFUCKER STATE!!!
HINDUSTAN ZINDABAD!!!
Kenzo0190 4 months ago
पाकिस्तान जिन्दाबाद इंडिया मुर्दाबाद
syedumairnaqvi 5 months ago
With all due respect to the poster, the only reason India even *has the boundaries it has* is because of the British Colonials. And why annex Pakistan and Bangladesh? Wouldn't that just be more headaches and problems for India?
NickB1967 1 year ago
daeth of india just pakistan gona be fuck india be caer full hindustan murda bad pakistan zinda bad
khalidislam100 1 year ago
daeth of india just pakistan gona be fuck india be caer full
khalidislam100 1 year ago
daeth of india just pakistan
khalidislam100 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
KALISTAN ZINDABAD ASSAM ZINDABAD NAGALAND ZINDABAD TARIMPUR ZINDABAD ARCHUNPARDESH ZINDABAD KANNADU ZINDABAD HYDERABAD DECCAN ZINDABAD TAMIL NADU ZINDABAD
gay hind
DIVIDEINDIA1 1 year ago
inspite of all the boundaries muslims are one..and every muslim will be united for the well being of human beings because muslim is meant for peace.. dont abuse each other because you are not ALLAH who is superior.. at the end your identity other than muslim will be shamefull for you..
auiman20 1 year ago
Whats with the Hostility, you should realize one very important thing, In India, in West Bengal, being Indian and Bengali is the samething, there is no difference, only you see a difference, Let Bangladesh be, and let India be, but Bangladesh is not the only country for Bengalis, India is also the home for Bengalis.
RajahHindustani 2 years ago
There is no hostility but I am pointing out the obvious. If you are a citizen of India then you are Indian. That is your nationality and identity. I am Bengali. Bangladesh refers to Bengali's. The identity, language, culture is all Bengali.
West Bengal is being taken over by north indian hindi culture, half the young population can't even speak Bengali but it doesn't matter bengali culture won't die because BD is still here and Bengali will remain the identity and language
BengaliAshoka 2 years ago
If Bangladesh drowned tommorow then I would rather drown in Bangladesh under my sea then go to India. If Bangladesh never became rich then I would rather be poor and hungry in Bangladesh sitting under my flag with my family with the pride that we are free. If Bangladesh would turn into a military dictatorship then I would remain to take my country back to democracy or die trying. If Bangladesh faced a terrible disease then at least I get to die in my motherland.
BengaliAshoka 2 years ago
I dont usually comment on youtube, but here i Must. I am a Bengali, a Muslim and a Proud Indian. So, you being a Bangladeshi, might have a lot in common with me. But you talk about freedom, let me tell you we in India are free, we are on the set of becoming a recognized superpower of the region, and we the Bengali Muslims of India are very Proud and uphold Indian Democracy. You are willing to die for Bangladesh, yet you forget where your history comes from.
IndianMuslim007 2 years ago
I will never ever be part of another country. Not after what happened. Only bengali's can be trusted by Bengali's. I will for my Bangladesh and all my Bengali's hindu. muslim, atheist, buddhist whatever. I don't care if India is a superpower as long as BD rises out of poverty which it is doing cutting it by 2% a year and will have cut it in half by 2015 and met all of our MDG's.
BengaliAshoka 2 years ago 2
Whether you agree with me or not, realize one facet of India and Bengal. There is a Bengal in India, and it is called West Bengal, out of respect for East Bengal aka Bangladesh. Another truth, that you will not agree with, is that when you say your Bengali, we associate that with being Indian. When you say you are Bangladeshi, we associate you with being Bangladeshi. Being Bengali to you has a different meaning than to us Bengali Indians. Just respect that. Joy Bengal, and Joy Hind!
RajahHindustani 2 years ago
@RajahHindustani पाकिस्तान जिन्दाबाद इंडिया मुर्दाबाद
syedumairnaqvi 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@RajahHindustani पाकिस्तान जिन्दाबाद इंडिया मुर्दाबाद
syedumairnaqvi 5 months ago
I'm from Bangladesh and no way in hell will I ever join with India and lose my Bengali culture and language. Anyway I don't think any Indians want Bangladesh to join. I wish India all the best of luck but Bangladesh and India are on separate paths. Bangladesh' to survive and rise out of poverty then find our soul and find what kind of country we are, hopefully a centre of knowledge, peace and calm. One where we are insulated from the horrors of the world and may live in peace.
BengaliAshoka 2 years ago
Bengali is an official language of India, incase you didnt know, there are also Bengalis in India.
RajahHindustani 2 years ago
The number of Bengali speakers has dropped to about half in West Bengal amongst its young people replaced with Hindi and English. The street sighs are in Hindi and English, the institutions are British. The culture of North India and bollywood are replacing Bengali culture. They are Indians not Bengali. I'm proud of being part of the only country in south asia to win its independence in revolution not be handed it like Porkistan and India. Blood was spilled for it and will never be forgotten
BengaliAshoka 2 years ago
Like you said Bangladesh might burn tommorow and you will care, so will India, because Bangladesh was once a part of India, surrounded 95 percent by India, so what happens to you, whether you burn or flourish..we Indians will care for Bangladesh, even if Bangladeshis dont care about India. By the way Ashoka..is an Indian Emperor..what does it have to do with Bangladesh?
IndianMuslim007 2 years ago
The anthem of Bangladesh..Amar Shonar Bangla was written by Tagore, not for an independent Bangladesh, but for the unity of Bengal, India, when the state was partioned first in 1905. Be Proud to be a Bangladeshi, you are grew up across the border so you feel that way, but there are many many Bengali in India, Muslim and Hindu alike who are Proud Bengali Indians and know what freedom is really about.
IndianMuslim007 2 years ago
You were given your freedom by Britain, my grandfather died fighting the Porkistani's for mine. Believe me i know the price of freedom and I will not betray his sacrifice for anyone. Tagore was around before Bengal was seperated but what's done is done. You are an Indian now and I am not. I wish you luck but our paths are separate now and will never join again.
BengaliAshoka 2 years ago
jai hind sade punjab jaaro aik hoiya ga
jerrindersingh99 3 years ago 3
looks nice .....!
youterror 3 years ago 2
India must get larger. Nations that stop growing, start shrinking. India must rescue its irredenta in Bangladesh and Pakistan occupied Punjab, Kashmir, and Sindh. The rest of Pakistan will go to Afghanistan, so that NATO and Afghanistan can cleanse Pakistan occupied Afghan irredenta from Pakistan's hypocritical anti-Islamic ideology of hatred and terrorism. India will become a super-power, with its historical lands, including the irredenta of Sri Lanka, Maldives, and Nepal.
User100606 3 years ago 2
I am so glad i found u on youtube, this is soo true ive been trying to get indians to join me in the fight for all of the real india including pakistan and bangladesh to be ours again. but alll ive found are people defending hinduism. how lame. i hae a propostion for pakistan if ur interested in hearing it please message me.
dominator120397 3 years ago
@User100606: I'm a Bangladeshi Muslim and I see that the way you talk you want aggressive anexation of Bangladesh. India may invade Bangladesh since it may be beneficial, since Dhaka, Sylhet, and Chittagong are becoming megacities as the years progress. POverty is going down 2% every year thanks to Grameen Bank, so I know India has her eye in East Bengal, because we're certainly doing better than West Bengal as a state.
xajcrunkx 3 years ago
Xajcrunkx, if Bangla Desh is doing so well, then why are Bangla Deshis flooding Assam and other Indian states bordering Bangla Desh? Why are Bangla Deshi women being desperately exported to Pakistan's financial capital Karachi's streets for prostitution? Bangla Desh has had many military coups like Pakistan. Only Mother India has remained a stable democracy with judicial integrity, the people of East Bengal, West Punjab, Pak. occ. Kashmir, and Sindh dream of being a part of Mother India again.
User100606 3 years ago
lol i know no politic but I know bangla tumi kuram acho? I from west bengal anyway have a nice day
chalo takeo
Rohan4basu 3 years ago
xajcrunkx , come out of illusion. How do you expect to do better than West Bengal??? Already West Bengal has double per capita income than you and it is growing far faster than you and it has a far better infra than you. Wake up dear friend, stop writing useless blogs and start doing work. (I am from West Bengal and I have stayed a long time in Sylhet, Pabna and Chitagong due to my job.)
GlobalRecruiter 2 years ago
HINDUSTAN ZINDABAD FROM AN AFGHAN
ala4akbar 3 years ago 14
Thnks. Afganistan zindabad too.
GlobalRecruiter 2 years ago
Pathan zindabad from an Indian
bhartha2007 2 years ago 6
HINDUSTAN ZINDABAD!
RebelLeaderX45 3 years ago 2
GlobalRecruiter, before you were saying that a South Asian Union would be bad and now you're supporting it?
I don't get it, are you pro or anti united South Asia?
Could you clarify.
foronecause 3 years ago
foronecause,I am in favour of South Asian Union bcoz that can bring South Asia at the centre-stage of the world and ofcourse unitedly we will become the biggest superpower as we were before.
But the situation now is not suitable for that.We r fighting war last sixty years(blame British).There is massive amount of religious hatred against India everywhere.Moreover in Pakistan & B'desh fundamentalists r becomming powerful day by day and it can b a serious threat to India's security and economy.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
If there are any muslim indians, I would be interested in hearing your views, about the relationship between pakistan and India. Is there any hope for peace, and maybe an South Asian Union? Would you support it, or be against it. And more generally what are the problems for pakistan and india ahead, and what can be the possible solutions to those problems.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Democracy is wonderful
Yes ALL Kashmiri's should have been given a vote in 1948, but they didn't. Tough bloodly luck. Any vote now wouldn't be fair becuase of the Hindu Kashmiri's forced out of their homes, by the blood sucking muslims.
If U don't like indian kashmiri then fuck off 2 paki kashmiri, where I'm sure U will live much better life, one of milk and honey.
And if U guys go, takes some other muslims from the rest of india, pakistan was the home of muslims so why live in India
Gohlan5 3 years ago
You ass hole drink my piss. whole kashmir is our kere maan day koosay manji daa kay tere bhen choodan kooosi maaan day bachiaa. Tere dharti maan de bund which baan paa kay kud lavan gay kashmir
Raj karay ga Khalsa
zaheerkk82 3 years ago
Really whole of kashmir is yours, then why don't you have it?
Maybe becacause you are gay, and can't deal with real MEN.
And asking me to drink your piss, is certain gay. If YOU are an example of a Kashmir man, then they are all gay pussy's, that like getting fucked by the Indian army.
If you want your comments understood by a wider audience, you should try using english. Unless Kashmir are so stupid that you can't use english, in which case, use whatever fucking language you want.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
and thats why democracy doesnt suit you now so stop preaching something U arent willing to practice
PakistanKnight 3 years ago
It (democracy) suits India much better than it suit either the Isamic World, or that lovely country next door to us (pakistan).
But you shouldn't worry, the Western world including those lovely Americans will help ALL of the Islamic world see the wonderful light of democracy.
It might mean short term pain, like the terrible things that happened in places Abu ghraib and Guantanamo bay. Although you maybe muslim, I don't support any bad things done to the koran or muslim people.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
How many years of democracy has paki enjoyed, since it's independence in 1947?
Pakistan is a basket case, it tries hard to compete with India,it looks west towards Afganistan, and has tried it's best 2 make it into a basket case as well.
I'm sure Muhammad Ali Jinnah will be proud of the basket case that is pakistan.
But I don't blame Pakistan, muslims seem 2like living under dictorships. That's why most of the Islamic world is so governed.
Mr P Knight democracy in paki a goodthing?
Gohlan5 3 years ago
most muslims countries are democracies, where people elect their leaders Iran, Egypt, Lebanon, Turkey.
Democracy is rule of the majority and is bad for 3rd world nations. It leads to radicals and corrupt people being elected. (ie. BJP, or Benazir Bhutto)
PakistanKnight 3 years ago
Most countries like Saudi, U.A.E, Omen, Yemen, Jordan, Syria, Morocco, Algeria, Libya, Chad, Sudan, Eritrea, Somalia, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Kyrgystan, Kazakhstan.
Turkey and Lebanon, OK democratic.
Iran and Egypt are far from perfect democratic countries. And if you wish we can go into that later.
And those lovely Americans are helping bring democracy in Iraq, Afganistan, and Pakistan.
So the question is MOST, are you joking?
Gohlan5 3 years ago
So 3rd world can't deal with democracy.
India is a democracy, and when the BJP lost those radicals as you stated excepted the fact they had lost the election.
Bhutto, was the BEST hope for pakistan. And the crazies killed the best hope for pakistan. If democracy is so bad why do most people in pakistan want to live in a democratic country. Why did Mohammad Ali Jinnah want a democracy for both EAST and WEST pakistan.
FACE it pakistan has failed the democracy test, what a real shame.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
nonsense. Benazir was a crook and an american puppet. If india was a democracy they would let kahlistan and kashmir go along with waster bengal, goa, utter pradesh. No secular country allows relgious parties to enter elections. As for Bengal, it was a mistake to make them east Pakistan. Bangladesh along with india, Pakistan should have been an indepdent country in 1947
PakistanKnight 3 years ago
Beanair maybe was a crook, and YES an American puppet but she was the best hope for Pakistan, that was the real shame. I know muslims don't like Americans, but if YOU willing to follow them they will help you, as they did for Pakistan during the cold war.
Democracy doesn't mean that you let small groups do whatever they want to do. ALL of India supports indian kashmir in India. I know you might not like it, but this view is shared by a majority of Indian Muslims.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Gohlan5,New cities & industries r comming up in India.These people can b employed in these labour intensive industries alongwith Indians.Already places like Punjab, Kerala and Gujrat facing shortage of unskilled labour and it is going to increase.
Unless we start thinking on it right now,it is going to become a massive human disaster and atleast 40 mmillion people r going to b affected.And this 40 million hungry people will become new talibans and effect the peace and security of whole world.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
Pakistan is the direct result of British divide and rule policy.
My friend today Greater India, would have been a stronger place and better place.
Can you not see the fact that 125 million our brothers and sisters of Pakistan, joined to 104 million brothers and sisters of Bangladesh, and 133 million muslims in India. That is 362 million muslims, which would of been better for the people of Pakistan, Bangladesh, and India.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Gohlan5,we can solve the problems of Bangladesh if we work unitedly-
firstly, Bangladesh can get neccessary food item from India to stop hunger in short run, secondly,India is planning to have second phase of green revolution and it will b done in Eastern India and we can include B'desh in such plan which will help B'desh to share technology,capital and fresh and rain water with India.
Thirdly,we need to train new skills and urbanize peope staying in costal areas.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
we have better tech and water then bdesh
VIVEK0123456789 3 years ago 3
Yes u r completely true.
GlobalRecruiter 2 years ago 2
For one thing NO wars between all of us. And I hope you do remember that East and West Pakistan went to war against each other.
These and other resources could have been spent on improving the lives of people.
I hope you don't think the money spent by these poor countries on their amries couldn't be better spent on their people.
The problems India and other countries face are just going to get much worse, like global warming. Some type of Union, may help put their veiws to the world
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Gohlan5,situation in Bangladesh is really grave.There a massive part of land is going under sea in next few yrs and salty water is increasing in rivers due to influx of sea water so more and more land is becomming infertile,so food production is going down and population is exploding.So,just think what is going to happen there after 10/15years(food inflation is already 20%).Bangladesh is going to b like time bomb for India unless India intervene and solve the problem with long term goal.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
I know of some of these problems for Bangladesh.
The problem is solutions, I think an South Asian EU could hold an answer.
What do you think we could do to solve the problems that we hit the India and other countries in the area?
Time bombs can be defused, with the right answers. As India is completely surrounds Bangladesh, it's our problem as much as it is Bangladesh.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
foronecause 3 years ago
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
foronecause 3 years ago
Foronecause - I'm not from Pakistan, but I agree with you.
And there are many indian muslims who would fully agree with you.
Maybe some type of Sub-continent Union modelled of the European Union, might be possible some time in the future
Gohlan5 3 years ago
The main problem of Asian EU is,India have to take sacrifice it's economic gain for lot of enemy and failed states like Pakistan, Bangladesh etc.Moreover they will soon start destructive activities in our soil.Muslim mindset will never change- marry 4 wives, produce atleast 10 children,then send them to madrasa(noone can afford quality education for so many kids), without proper education remain poor forever and according to Koran for all ur miseries blame infidels and start jihad.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
Global - I'm not muslim, but I don't think the Koran blames all infidels for their problems.
An Asian EU, would not hold back India. Plus India would be able to held it's partners.
Pakistan and Bangladesh I wouldn't go as far as calling them failed states. Pakistan needs some help which it should be able to get within this Union.
A greater Union would also mean that both Pak and India, could spend less on defence and more on helping the poor
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Gohlan5,I am not calling them failed states. Transperency International(TI) is a famous international organization and they publish list of failed staes every year and in their list they have included- Pakistan, bangladesh, Nepal and Srilanka as failed states bcoz they have failed to provide basic amenities to their citizens.Bangladesh has become the most corrupt country in the world for 5 consecutive yrs in TI list.Even CIA has predicted that by 2015,Pakistan will completely fail and collapse.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
GlobalRecruiter............The Next Eleven or N-11 are world's , potentially, next biggest economies. Pakistan and Bangladesh are both part of N-11.
Besides if Pakistan and Bangladesh still fall, India will suffer as well. i.e Afghanistan got ruined, Pakistan suffered big time. The same will happen to India if what you are saying is correct. Hopefully not though.
And you're bragging about India. 320 million people live on less than a dollar a day and 600 million don't have adequate health care.
foronecause 3 years ago
foronecause - I've got to agree with you and what you said about the countires around India failing.
My nightmare is that Pakistan REALLY and truly fails, it will be terrible for the people of Pakistan, but a nightmare for india.
India needs peace not war, a democractic and successful pakistan is in the interest of India.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
foronecause,I am not racist.I have worked in Bangladesh for 2 years as IT teacher, I can say that Bangladeshis(hope Pakistanis too)are very good people.I have many very good friends and students there. And even after leaving Bangladesh 4 years back,I have a very good contact with them.
The love and respect that I got there was really great.All the Indian teachers working there were very happy.Some have stayed there till now and others who came back still have a nice relationship with students.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
When I think of failed states I think of Afganistan and Burma.
Pakistan I hope and pray doesn't become a failed state. As it will badly effect India.
Global - Even in India corruption is bad.
If all the countires round India are in trouble, India is trouble.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Global...........Why are you being racist? or religiously discriminative?
Next to no one gets married 4 times in Pakistan. And not a lot of people have ten children. So, in no way is that the Muslim mindset. There aren't too many sending kids to madrasas. Only some radicals in the West, near Afghanistan.
Go read the Quran before you say anything about it.
foronecause 3 years ago
But sad fact is that the condition there is very bad compared to India.Everything is 3 to 5 times more expensive than India(official exchange rate is 100INR=170BDT),law and order condition is too bad(u can b robbed and murdered anytime anywhere),rampant corruption and there is no hope of country's future.I really feel sorry for my dear and nice students there.I know that my students r not anyway less than anyone, but they r victim of corrupt politicians and policy of hatred.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
foronecause,both Pakistan and Bangladesh has huge potential.But to harness that u need right policy,right leadership and good relationship with neighbours.Sadly the leadership in both countries r very corrupt and fundamentalist.They r making their people fool in the name of religion and exploiting them.India ofcourse wants Pakistan and Bangladesh to developd.But u need to take first step- stop hatred,feel we all south asians r brothers and united south asia is only way to prosperity.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
foronecause 3 years ago
daska66, how many Indians have you talked to? We are almost the same.
I am from Rawalpindi, so I am a native Pakistani. My family didn't leave anything behind and I still think that partition is something to be regretted, and not rejoiced upon.
In case you are wondering, I am a very patriotic Pakistani who wishes to fight and die for his country.
I just think that the Indian sub-continent should make a strong union and have much stronger ties with each other.
foronecause 3 years ago
INDIA can do better, without the useless country that is Pakistan.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
I know that partition was wrong and that Pakistan, India and Bangladesh should never have been separated.
Now it has been over 60 years since partition. And I believe that Pakistan and India have developed some different characteristics. Pakistan was supposed to be given the name "Islamic Republic of India" because that's what it is and we are Indian Muslims.
We are the same and yet different. But Punjab is still totally the same.
I think South Asia should make some thing like EU.
foronecause 3 years ago
foronecause , u r absolutely right. Pakistanis were part of India for last 10000 years. But in last 60 years Indians and Pakistanis became completely different. Now it is very hard to unite. I think Indians will not be ready to unite as they think unification will bring Jehadis directly on their soil without any resistance.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
Pakistan were not part of India for 10000 years. Look at map of Persian Sassanid Empire from 100AD - 700AD (Pakistan was part of Persia). Before that, look at map of Alexander's Empire, Pakistan is in it. It was also part of Afghan rulers for many years. Before that at 500BC, it was part of 1st Persian Achaemenid Empire. After 700AD it was part of Arab Empire, then it remained part of Islamic Persia for 100's of years until Mughals conquered rest of India and ruled together.
alifbah0 3 years ago
I am not supporting anyone here. I have nothing against Pakistan or India. I am just stating what I know so far.
alifbah0 3 years ago
ancient HINDU maps show all of present day paki punjab and sindh as being part of BHARAT. ONE DAY India will get its territory back..all we have to do is fight another war and this time show no mercy by capturing a large chunk of paki territory.
scoobysaurus 3 years ago
The word 'Hindu' is derived from 'Sindh'. Words like 'Hindu' and 'Hindustan' were the names given by Persians/Mid-Easterns. The word 'Hinduism' is infact a western term given to the religion that was followed by the people living south of Sindh. The actual name of religion is 'Sanatan Dharma'. The word 'Hindu' cannot be found in early scripts of India.
Therefore its ridiculous to claim there was any ancient 'Hindu' map.
alifbah0 3 years ago
Secondly, south of Indus River i.e present day India was never ruled by one single kingdom before the Mughals arrived. It was a colony of several Kingdoms ruling different regions. North-Western regions of India i.e Pakistan were always separate than India from atleast 500BC (just look at map of 1st Persian Empire). Same can be said about Bengal which had been a separate Dynasty.
If you want to claim that I am wrong, please provide me evidence.
alifbah0 3 years ago
alifbah I don't think you know much about Indian history going buy your comments. Yes at times India was fragmented so was China as well as Arabia. So does this mean we all go back to our fuedal states? Offcourse not. The greatness of some of the civilisations has been their ability to group together. There are nunerous instances in Indias history the Maghadas, then the Maurayas ruled by Asia's first buddhist monarch king Asoka, Kushans who ruled much of central asia Guptas, Cholas & Mughals.
narlzp 3 years ago
The Persians and Greeks both made it into what is now present day India, not just present day Pakistan.
And the Ancient Romans(Western and Eastern Empire) even had substantial trade with South India.
madmaxninja08 3 years ago
Pakistanis don;t feel partition was wrong because they don;t but into the myth of India in the first place. For example I am from Sialkot-we were part of many Empires: Greek,Afghan,Persian, Mughal and annexed to British India for only 100 years. We don;t identify with India-you are right that Indian Muslims who migrated to Pakistan soemtimes think differently about partition since they left their homes but native Pakistanis know their history and don't see the British Indian colony as a homeland
daska66 3 years ago
Agree with you on an south Asian EU
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Gohlan5,I completely agree with u that without Pakistan(and muslims)we can do much better.I was reading in an article that in 1000 AD,India and all Europe had same amount of GDP and almost same per capita.After that India went under muslim rule due to our infighting and we can see the result.Now Europe has fifteen times more GDP than India and 50 times more per capita income than us.Since Hindus rule in India again,India is again prospering.And in the world all muslims countries r backward.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
Gloabl do you know where India is in terms of it's GDP?
As far as I know it's in top 10, and China become 4th.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Gohlan5,in 2007 India was 12th economy in the world - after US(13.8 trillion dollars), Japan(4.3 td),Germany(3.3 td),China(3.2td), UK(2.7td),France(2.5td),Italy(2.1td),Spain(1.4td),Canada(1.4td),Brazil(1.3td) and Russia(1.1td).But India(1.1td) is growing much faster.And it is expected that by 2020, India's GDP will be 3 td and by 2030,it will be around 6 td and India will be the fourth biggest economy after EU,US and China. But in 1000 AD,our GDP was equal to EU which is now 16.8 td.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
thank you for that answer
Gohlan5 3 years ago
I see that you don;t want to hear the views of real Pakistanis. Just to remind you, we don;t buy into the myth of a British created colony called India. Our people and land mass have been part of many a civilisation. We can be friends with India but never one. India would do better to unite with Sri Lanka and Bangladesh who share the same culture and history as India. Cheers from a native Pakistani!
daska66 3 years ago
Actually, the unification of Indian and Pakistan were made by the Mughals before British. Before the Mughals, regions of Pakistan were part of Islamic Empire, and before that it was part of Persian or Alexander's Empire, and before that all the way to IVC it was completely different than India. Pakistan is very different than India.
Plus, I think Bengal and East Indian region should be liberated from India. Bangladesh, West Bengal, Manipuri has completely different culture than rest of India.
alifbah0 3 years ago
Thanks for your clarification. Like you, I belive that native Pakistanis hould point out the historical uniqueness of our Pakistani land mass and how distinct it is from India. I think that people go on and on about the partition and British India not understanding that real Pakistanis don't give a damn about the artificial British colony. Our need is to highlight our own history and thrown away the British inspired crap about the Raj and rediscover our own roots. Cheers from another Pakistani.
daska66 3 years ago
alifbah0 , firstly u need a lot more knowledge about history and geography. Bengalis are not separate than rest of India. I am from West Bengal and I can tell you that all Bengalis of West Bengal treat themselves as proud Indian.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
I am not saying that West Bengalis are separate than India. Ofcourse, WB is inside India and hence part of India. Both India's national anthem was written in Bengali. I am aware of that. All I have stated is that Bengali culture, customs is very different than rest of India. And, the reason I talked about liberation is because, Bengali culture is being demolished/replaced with Bollywood culture over the years.
alifbah0 3 years ago
Daska66 even if u kneel down and ask for unifciation..India will not accept..we are a forward looking, progressive nation with a rich heritage culture and history..we were not born 50 years back...and we do not like to keep our own women under burqas while salivating at other women..we are not a frustrated copy cat nation..all the best..may Allah bless Paksitan.
jaihindkisena 3 years ago
We do wish all the best for India but try to understand patritotic Pakistanis want nothing of it. We are proud of our own history and traditions.You may fun of our culture and but I don't have to make fun of your culture to love my own. We are just proud to be Pakistanis and we will achieve our own destiny. Don't worry about what we do and to each his own.May Bhagwan give Shakti to India and to Indians. Cheers!
daska66 3 years ago
daska66, I wish Pakistan to develop but I think Pakistan cannot grow without help of India. Because India has huge resources, manpower and market. But the differences of mentality between people of two countries are too huge. So, I do not think it is possible atleast now.
GlobalRecruiter 3 years ago
GlobalRecruiter - pakistan can develop by itself and do petty well as a result. It like India needs to sort out corruption, and get some type of stable democratic government.
Where Inida will do really well, is the range of resources and manpower. India will sooner or later be one of the largest and powerful countries in the world, along with China.
Paskistan can't hope to compete, with the likes of India and China, as long as it know that it can do OK for itself, as a third rate power.
Gohlan5 3 years ago
Silly, Sindhis, Punjabis and the Kashmiris, it is 100% Hindu civilization in the past.
kashmirishakta 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is not Akhand Bharat, this is regular India, that was divided by the British. Akhand Bharat includes more territory.
RajahHindustani 4 years ago
i reality i think only sindh, punjab and parts of NWFP, not to mention kashmir, can be reincorporated back into hind. balochistan and Waziristan FATA, r not integral parts of our land. essentially we need the indus valley back in its entirity.
thekatarexpress 3 years ago
we never desecrate the idea of akhand bharat
Jai hind!
shaansmsm 4 years ago
AKHAND BHARAT AMAR RAHE!!! Im glad to see theres ppl that wat to see the reunification of the motherland. if u r as committed to the cause than me, u will see our goal achieved in ur lifetime.
thekatarexpress 4 years ago
no reunification please. india is doing quite well and we don't need instability of pakistan nor the poor bangladeshis being a burden on social programs
expectopatrono 4 years ago
r u jokin bangaldesh ppl have all come over anyway...the only thing we havent got is the land. lol. pakistan ppl used to be tolerant b4 1947, its time to take back wat is rightfully ours, let them embrace secularism and democracy. jai hind brother!
thekatarexpress 4 years ago