The compliment to Reznor is that Cash covered it. Wouldn't worry too much about people mistaking the authorship. Reznor's fans (and I'm one) will make sure that no one forgets where the song came from.
There are examples of covers being better than the original, after all. Consider "cold missouri waters" by James Keelaughan, but covered by Cry Cry Cry. Or (perhaps more famously) "Blinded by the light" by Springsteen, and covered by Manfred Mann.
Solomon's ECCLESIASTES in The Bible is all about these feelings, and how they come from the hopeless state of all people. It's the dark poetical book of The Bible. It's depressing but cool. I think that God is so much more poetic than we can ever imagine. I think that He even understands our plight of immortality and confusion better than we do..... somehow.
To clear up all your arguements.....Johnny Cash sang this song as his last song and gave all credits to Nine Inch Nails, who originated this song!!!!!! Johnny rocks!! Awesome version of this song....
tbh I think JC used it as a euology for himself, and possibly an epitaph, he recognised the poignancy in Trents lyrics and fitted them into his own past,,, so Trent has been recognised and acknowledged by JC,,,can't be all that bad can it! :)
trent reznor made, wrote the song, put all his feelings out into, and worked very hard on this song. this video is from 1995, and cash didnt cover it until 2002. seriosly?
One time some guy tried to tell me it was Johnny Cash who wrote this song and not Trent Reznor, which is ppular opinion. And I said that was bullocks. Bullshit. NIN wrote Hurt plain and simple. But then I did some research and turns out that crazy guy was right about it the whole time. I posted all the evidence up on my channel so you guys can learn the truth too. Turns out Johnny Cash really did write the song, and a lot of people collaborated to and make it seem otherwise.
wow, to many idiots think cash wrote this masterpiece.... no Mr.Trent Reznor did. so.... shut the fuck up bout cash writin it, dont get me wrong, cash's version, is bad ass as well. but 2 completely diff things they r singing bout.
@MrChevelless1972 indeed, although it is Trent's song Cash made it his own when he did it which is a beautiful thing, both versions wonderful and both meanings completely different from the other.
@IAmIronMant...you are right about Bowie...he was really sick on this tour. There was an announcement about it, IIRC. We had also seen him in Hartford on an earlier tour (Glass Spider, with Peter Frampton) and it was night and day.
First I comment that NIN sucks and can't play, then I wait for two weeks and comment that Johnny looks like a fidgeting carcass. Just to "stir up" the conversation :)
First I comment that NIN sucks and can't play, then I wait for two weeks and comment that Johnny looks like a fidgeting carcass, just to "stir up" the conversation :)
First I comment that NIN sucks and can't play, then I wait for two weeks and comment that Johnny looks like a fidgeting carcass just to "stir up" the conversation :)
I saw this concert back in 95... NIN was fantastic, but Bowie was complete shite. Bowie couldn't hold a tune, his voice was terrible, and it only took a few songs after NIN had left the stage for almost everyone in the arena to leave as well. As a Bowie fan... it was the most disappointing concert I'd ever been to. I really felt sorry for him, by the time we left... there were maybe a thousand people left in the arena that was sold out at 17,000 some capacity.
@IAmIronMant that's weird,.I'm a big fan of both,have seen most of his concerts, never seen or heard DB out of tune or singing badlyl,but as far as I know the tour with NIN was a succes,a pity. at the time I saw him in Holland his first Europian concert of the outside tour,he was ab fab ,but no NIN they continued touring in the states!!The free NIN-David Bowie live d.load sounds really cool both r great ! Am glad I didn't have to see that, DB being shite !
Does anyone here understand what I am saying? I'm saying that Trent Reznor lied to all of us. He and his vampire lawyers have fabricated a giant story where Trent Reznor is honored and grateful that Johnny Cash covered "his" song. But in fact, it was Johnny Cash that was deeply wounded when he heard that his special song Hurt had been covered by Trent Reznor. There is plenty of evidence on my channel if you do not believe me. Trent Reznor stole Hurt from JC, and that is a disgrace to the M.I.B.
do people real ly think that Cash wrote this fab song???
The same story with Nirvana,''the man who sold the world''a classic of DB,people saying ''I saw Bowie he did a cover of Nirvana,some people live under a rock!!!
This dude (DeliveryManBoy) is posting on a bunch of NIN videos. He's trolling you guys... I don't have to watch his videos on his channel because I know he's laughing his ass off at people getting up in arms about Mr. Cash writing "Hurt". Those who already know, don't waste your time arguing with him. Enjoy NIN, enjoy the weather, enjoy life and don't sweat the small shit.
@TrentsReznor wrong. check your facts before you go making wild statements. it was johnny cash who originally wrote this song. he just never had it recorded or copyrighted because he thought it was too special. Trent Reznor heard the song at a private engagement and recorded it as his own the following year. While johnny Cash never made a big deal about it, he was deeply offended to have his song covered by a necropheliac. There is a bit of evidence to this fact on my channel I have provided.
@DeliveryManBoy Actually, you, sir, are incorrect. And before you go around spreading lies, here is the truth. Rick Rubin (famous producer, part owner of Columbia Records - VERY well known in the music business) introduced "Hurt" to Johnny Cash in the final years that Cash was alive. "Hurt" as part of a series of songs and albums that Rubin felt Cash could put a very strange and unusual twist to. Other songs include Sting's "I hung my Head" and Depeche Mode's "Personal Jesus".
@DeliveryManBoy Incase you still didn't believe me, go to Google and search for "NPR Rick Rubin Cash", click on the first link. Actually, it's even listed in the "Editorial Review" section on Amazon when you search for Cash's album: "American IV: The Man Comes Around". I was going to post the links for you, but YouTube doesn't allow links to be posted in comments. Reznor himself was even quoted saying that "Hurt" was no longer his song because of how well Cash remade it as a compliment to Cash.
@DeliveryManBoy Just out of curiousity, who told you your facts? Your buddies? Don't believe everything you hear, even though it sounds like it could be true. I've never heard your theory before, and really, you should always site your sources when you make an assertion, let alone win an argument. I'm not trying to be rude, but you are telling other people to "check their facts" and then immediately make an unverified assertion. Citing your "YouTube Channel" doesn't count.
@bopptb Those of you who would say that Cash's song is nothing compared to the Nine INch Nails version? How can you support a man who blatantly rips off a legendary country stars work and then trys to make himself look like the original composer? Further, how can you support a cross dresser who often plays with parts of dead animals? It turns my stomach. And I know your going to go cut and paste the wiki article, or tell me you have the album. It's a conspiracy. Proof on my channel.
@DeliveryManBoy Stop it. I even remember when Cash's version was released. I had been listening to the NIN version for years. This is a nice one with Bowie, another favourite of mine.
@ipakski THEY will try and tell you Trent Reznor wrote this song. THEY will tell you, RIck Rubin suggested Johnny Cash "cover" the song, and after some apprehension, Trent Reznor eventually decided that he was "honored" to have Cash cover "his" song. Both men's albums give the writer's credit to Trent. And Wikipedia says the same. but... IT'S ALL BULLSHIT! JOHNNY CASH WROTE THIS SONG. I have proof to this fact on my channel. TRENT REZNOR STOLE HURT FROM JC!!! I have sources.
@DeliveryManBoy Really? well then Cash took his sweet time releasing it seeing that NIN's version was written 8 YEARS before Johnny Cash covered it, besides songs like that arent Cash's style, so i doubt he wrote it, I love both versions though.
@DeliveryManBoy What the hell dude? I've seen you trolling around like every cover video of this song. Your obviously wrong. Go ride your bike and do something worthwhile.
@DeliveryManBoy no way,written by Trent Reznor,got the anbum since '94.Cash probably didn't have a clue at that time,remind you his own son tells in a special about Cash that he had to change the lyrics a bit,and it was his son he told him to cover Trent's ''Hurt'',and you can see him listening to Trent's ""hurt'' of the ''Downward spiral'' album!!Cash listening btw.He covered many songs esp. the last 2 albums have many!!You better check your facts!!
@TrentsReznor I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
Johnny Cash wrote and recorded a lot of music in his lifetime. He recorded a lot of serious songs, but he also recorded a lot of funny ones like “A Boy Named Sue.” There are a lot of Johnny Cash songs that I like. Some of my favorites are "Ring of Fire", "I Walk the Line", "Folsom Prison Blues", "Get Rhythm" and "Man in Black" just to name a few. But my favorite Johnny Cash song of all has got to be the song “Hurt.” Johnny Cash wrote the song in 1974 while serving time in Folsom prison.
Is it just me or does deliverymanboy sound like the mom from water boy. Calling Trent the devil. And he doesn't even listen to what you say. He keeps posting the same fucking comments on every video. He is a fucking moron, who can't except shit. So do us all a favor and just GO!
@Deliverymanboy. I'd love to see these documents that defy the laws of time and space. I think you simply can't accept that a musician you hate wrote a song you love so you've built up this complex delusion around the whole subject. After seeing how many people have discounted you, it's pretty clear that it's not really about the song. You know, therapy might not be a bad route for you, and I actually mean this sincerely. God can be strong guidance but sometimes we all need a little extra help.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@Fordyshoor Do not get me started on that disgraceful cover that Nine Inch Nails did of this song. I don't want to argue about it on my channel. Flame me if you like It doesn't bother me. I know that all of the proof on my page vindicates the name of johnny Cash, and prooves beyond a shadow of a doubt who actually wrote this song. It surely wasn't Trent Reznor. He's a devil worshiper.
if u actually bought the single u would know the credits clearly state the song was written by Trent Reznor.
doesn't get more official than that.
and no offense for your great johnny cash...but he could have never come up with such melody and songwriting....not even if he lived another million years.
@animativ Cash damn well could and has. And yes Trent wrote it but even Trent thinks Cash's version is gold. Why be a jackass and argue over which is better? They're DIFFERENT. Just live and let live without being a douchnozzle.
@Deliverymanboy. They're both great versions but before you blindly assert, I'd suggest looking at history. Unless you assume MR. Reznor built himself a time machine and stole Cash's song 7 years later, the likelihood of you being right is slim. Also, wouldn't you say Johnny Cash insinuating he's Jesus is equally sacreligious? Or maybe him covering a song by the satanic tinged Danzig years earlier? I'd suggest removing your holy head from out of your ass before you suffocate yourself.
@Fordyshoor I have supplied plenty of proof on my channel that johnny Cash wrote this song in 1974 and that Trent Reznor stole the song and covered it on the downward spiral in 1994. There are documents where Juaqine Pheonix attempts to alert the major news outlets of the Nine Inch Nails conspiracy. Interview Notation of his daughters making similar claims. Copyrighted paperwork and legal documents from Trent Reznor's lawyers that show contempt. I have made a solid case Trent stole the song.
@DeliveryManBoy Really now, well then you'll have no trouble believing that I am Ghandi's mum, even though I'm fifteen. oh yeah, and Abraham Lincoln is Jesus' gardner.
@7PsycoMantis7 As Abraham Lincoln, I can verify that statement. I'm also an Alien from the Same plane tthat the Hindu Gods are from, I founded Shintoism, was Cleopatra when I founded ancient Greece and I use my Sixth eye to hypnotize Lawn Gnomes into coming to life and worshiping me as God.
@Wolfysama Oddly enough, Trent himself would disagree with you, he said that he was so blown away by cash's verson of the song that it was no longer his.
In the fankierocks1 Johnny Cash hurt video comments, Frankierocks1 blocked me from posting on his page because I was arguing so good. Go on that comments section and accuse frankierocks1 of being a nazi tyrant for deleting me. Explain to him how NIN stole the song Hurt from Johnny cash, since I can't defend him there anymore. With a little help from the resistance, I think we can eventually coerce Trent Resnor to admit to what he has done, and then get his version of Hurt banned for all time.
@SparkedTiger Look, you are becoming more of a problem than I can handle here. Your kind of getting in the way of my crusade here making me argue with you over grammar, when I have conspiracies to uncover here. I've already got enough problems what with all the people going on my youtube channel and posting all this ignorant hate speech and disliking all my videos. What do I have to say to get you to go away and stop posting all this crap on my Johnny Cash evidence videos? Stay off my channel!
@Everyone responding to the rantings of an illogical Internet Kid nitwit that is DeliveryManBoy, please continue to feed the fire to the obvious Troll. There is further enjoyment to be had out of this.
@Grictonis Your not making any sense. Of course I think that Johnny Cash's version is better. I love Johnny Cash. It is MR. Trent Reznor I am upset with for covering this beautiful song and using computers and synthisizers. It just does not work. Not to mention he changed the line Crown of Thorns which was a reference Cash made to Jesus, to Crown of Shit, which is just anti-christian. It makes me sick. I despise Mr. Trent Reznor's cover. And I have tried to see the bright side in this.
@DeliveryManBoy Well I'm glad to see you ignorant Christians blindly believing what you want to without bothering to do any research. Keep up the good work, at least I get a good laugh.
@SparkedTiger You've left six or seven offensive posts on my channel in the last two days, and thats not even counting the ones you made on my videos. This is getting out of hand mstrk and I want it to stop NOW!!!! It's one thing to disagree with me thats all well and fine, but you stay off of my profile man. All the language you use and your anti-christian messages end NOW! Leave me alone. Enough is enough. Were not in highschool anymore. Johnny Cash wrote the song. Get over it Ninny fan!
I would like to take this opportunity to appologize to anyone in the youtube community that I may have offended with my comments. If you visit my channel, you will see that a great many threats have been communicated against me because of my beliefs. This is no excuse for me to be negative. While I remain adamant that it was wrong and disreputable for Nine Inch Nails to have covered this song which Johnny Cash wrote back in the 70's, If I lower myself to the level of my opponents, then they win.
Don't feed the trolls people, and they will go away (ie, DeliveryManBoy). Even the fish know that this song is a Trent Reznor original. He's just baiting y'all because he loves any kind of feedback, even the negative kind. And unfortunately many of you are falling for it.
@voodooseed72 And I see him on almost every video of this song as I have been looking for the best version.Obviously he has made this into a crusade and nobody will get it through to him.All the articles, facts ect. won't stop him.Seems funny that Cash said in the " Rolling Stone" how much he admired Trent's lyrics.Funny coming from the man Trent "stole" the song from him.Hey, it keeps him off the streets, he's safer taking his venom to comment threads.......Peace!
@trippinvic there is plenty of evidence to support the claim that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. There are multitude's of evidence on my channel which speaks to the matter at hand and proves, in my opinion, beyond a shadow of a doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. Trent Reznor did not write it, he just made a horrendous and obnoxious cover. If you don't believe all the evidence on my channel, just do a simple google search and you will find plenty of evidence.
@trippinvic The dude is a troll, plain and simple. He knows the truth, everyone knows Trent wrote it, even a moron like him, but people responding to him, even in a negative manner, is what he lives for. That's just how sad and pathetic his life is. Unfortunately there are many just like him no matter where you look on the internets. Just check any given music video here or any imdb board and you'll see what I mean. He's not even worthy of a direct response. He's a troll-baiting piece of poo.
@voodooseed72 I have seen alot of it on many comment threads, it seems to be a major hobby to some people.Yes, it is pretty sad.What bothers me is seeing all the negativity it creates. Johnny Cash and Trent Reznor both are ground breaking and gifted musicians and I hate to see either of their names being bashed over this foolishness.Ah well, what can you do but try to ignore it and not get baited into responding to them.Like arguing with a rock.No one wins and it's a waste of effort.
@voodooseed72 LOL-"poo"? Love it! Missed the irony the first time.Nice to see someone expressing anger without resorting to cursing.Very well done.No troll food from you! Kudos!
@trippinvic Have you seen any of DeliveryManBoy's videos? He even attempts 'singing' this, it's really funny, but kinda sad too. The dude obviously has a few screws loose, to say the least. I kinda feel sorry for him, but even more-so, I pity his parents who brought such a waste of space into the world. He's the greatest excuse for pro-choice I've ever seen. Besides, no pregnancy that's a result of in-breeding should go full term.
@voodooseed72 I checked his page to see his "proof" and as I am significantly older and read alot I would have heard of this while it was happening.I did,however, read how much JC loved the song and was pleased to get permission from Trent to cover it.JC was a strong man of great character and would not have just let it go if his beloved song was stolen.He not only insults Trent but Johnny as well.Some way to respect his idol,potraying him as a spineless wuss.Incredibly disrespectful and sad.
@voodooseed72 Damn, someone else is making an abortion joke? thats like the 3rd different one this morning. I guess you were the first to put the inbreeding twist on it, but damn, I thought you were better than that voodooseed. I had come to expect great things from you. You were the first to put a whole different spin on the resistance. Now your just like raputin67rr or eXXXaJackXXX from the Nine INch Nails - Hurt With Lyrics page.
@ZetsubouMFZB Let me tell you something buddy.This is the greatest song that Johnny Cash ever wrote. On the 6th of January, my rebel uncle Bobby killed himself by chopping off his arm with an ax. I never was aloud to hang out with him because my mom said he was crazy. They used to always tell story's about him and how he would run from the Sheriff every other weekend in his dodge charger for all of the town to see. We listened to this song at his funeral. Every man there drank a 24 pack himself.
Trent Reznor wrote the song and Johnny Cash covered it. There are plenty of interviews and other sources to confirm that fact. Also your little story about your uncle does nothing to change the fact that you were wrong about the write of the song. You may just be another internet troll since no sane being can possibly be that oblivious.
@ZetsubouMFZB there is plenty of evidence to support the claim that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. There are multitude's of evidence on my channel which speaks to the matter at hand and proves, in my opinion, beyond a shadow of a doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. Trent Reznor did not write it, he just made a horrendous and obnoxious cover. If you don't believe all the evidence on my channel, just do a simple google search and you will find plenty of evidence.
I doubt your homemade videos could trump over interviews by both Trent Reznor and Johnny Cash and the fact that Reznor wrote the song in 1994 while Cash's version was released in 2002. Cash even admitted that it was a cover. Any Google search would lead to undeniable evidence that Reznor wrote the song and Cash covered it. For a guy who practically worships Johnny Cash, you sure know nothing about one of his biggest hits/covers.
@ZetsubouMFZB Now while most of these statements are at the very least half truths, if you look a little closer you will see a web of deceit. At the very heart of the matter, is one big ugly lie, and that is to say, that Trent Reznor wrote the song “Hurt” He did not. It was Johnny Cash. And once you see how easily they have manipulated the truth about Cash's death and his music, you will be very disturbed just as i was. Please join me in boycotting Nine inch nails altogether.
You're just trying to get channel views. You are the only person in the world who seems to think Cash wrote it. Also, I can't imagine Cash talking about drug addiction. "The needle tears a hole, the old familiar sting, try to kill it all away, but I remember everything." You just WISH Cash wrote it, and its strange because its probably the biggest cover of all time and everyone in the music industry knows it. And finally, those lyrics are very fitting to NIN's style, not Cash's.
@JamesCmuse You've left six or seven offensive posts on my channel in the last two days, and thats not even counting the ones you made on my videos. This is getting out of hand mstrk and I want it to stop NOW!!!! It's one thing to disagree with me thats all well and fine, but you stay off of my profile man. All the language you use and your anti-christian messages end NOW! Leave me alone. Enough is enough. Were not in highschool anymore. Johnny Cash wrote the song. Get over it Ninny fan!
@DeliveryManBoy How about you crawling back into that black hole from which you came from? That would stop all the negative comments you're complaining about in an instant. Also, like I told you in the comment on your 'version' which you deleted, mental illness is hereditary. Yes, your uncle was obviously a nutcase, but all the signs point to you being one too. Sad, but true. Seek help, take your meds, get lost.
PS, 'aloud' and 'allowed' are two entirely different words, you illiterate troll.
LOL, the 90s....
ToiletBomberAlpha 5 days ago
what have I become my sweetest friend everyone I know goes away in the end..
aleiss28 5 days ago
So, I can't help but wonder why these twits can't appreciate the beautifully amazing song instead of worrying about drugs.
QueenLabyrinthine 2 weeks ago
36 people forgot to hurt themselves today
GentlemanofWolves 2 weeks ago
@GentlemanofWolves 37 should have
Sheepish1991 1 week ago
i like the original more
BlueOnionGroup 3 weeks ago
@BlueOnionGroup This is the original
SkitsNdip 3 days ago
@SkitsNdip without bowie.....
BlueOnionGroup 2 days ago
@BlueOnionGroup Oh lol!
SkitsNdip 1 day ago
I wonder if trent did coke with bowie
StickyInADarkBlueCut 3 weeks ago
As much as I like this song and David Bowie.. I have to say, this version is absolutely terrible. :(
TheChohr 1 month ago 2
Wonder if they did concaine together too...
sulphites01 1 month ago
@sulphites01 no, concaine didnt come out till 2011
demninjaeyes20 1 month ago
Lol this isn't about drugs at all
gamerfan81 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hellchild65 he went into detox for heroin in 96 guy. This song is about girl not cocaine
mrdigz198 1 month ago
@hellchild he went into detox in 96 for heroin guy. This song is about girl not cocaine.
mrdigz198 1 month ago
@mrdigz198 and he talks about needles because... its about heroin
TomOliver93 1 month ago
Wow, a cover by Johnny Cash, and a live performance with David Bowie, what a fucking accomplishment this song was.
frootloopwarriors 1 month ago
@WOODY9879 Trent wrote this song when he was getting clean.
mrdigz198 1 month ago
@mrdigz198 he didnt start to get clean till early 2000's guy, thru the 90's he was still a huge cocaine addict
hellchild65 1 month ago
Special meaning to all heroin addicts that got clean. Always be a special song for me
mrdigz198 1 month ago
I was at this show, the memories still give me goose bumps
hydrogin111 1 month ago
Yeah, Reznor stole a song from Johnny Cash and Bowie stole songs from Nirvana and Vanilla Ice. Waddayanow.
AntonKuzmin 2 months ago
@AntonKuzmin are you actually that stupid?
excelisinsane 1 month ago
@excelisinsane Sarcasm.
AntonKuzmin 1 month ago
The compliment to Reznor is that Cash covered it. Wouldn't worry too much about people mistaking the authorship. Reznor's fans (and I'm one) will make sure that no one forgets where the song came from.
There are examples of covers being better than the original, after all. Consider "cold missouri waters" by James Keelaughan, but covered by Cry Cry Cry. Or (perhaps more famously) "Blinded by the light" by Springsteen, and covered by Manfred Mann.
jdsahr 2 months ago
I get to be the 667th Comment :)
Solomon's ECCLESIASTES in The Bible is all about these feelings, and how they come from the hopeless state of all people. It's the dark poetical book of The Bible. It's depressing but cool. I think that God is so much more poetic than we can ever imagine. I think that He even understands our plight of immortality and confusion better than we do..... somehow.
CoachLanceSmith 2 months ago
Shut the fuck up and listen
jimmiow 2 months ago
Love how Trent is emotional thru the entire song like bringing back the devil inside. Hey that's a good lyric.
khanikki1 3 months ago
beautiful...its trent song...95
denthegun 3 months ago
the first song that plays, right before hurt, what's the name of it??!?!? Sounds so good but i can't find the name of it :S
urso93 3 months ago
@urso93 It is a remix of THE PERFECT DRUG. I'm not sure which one though.
MutleeIsTheAntiGod 3 months ago
To clear up all your arguements.....Johnny Cash sang this song as his last song and gave all credits to Nine Inch Nails, who originated this song!!!!!! Johnny rocks!! Awesome version of this song....
WOODY9879 3 months ago
Comment removed
elocrellim 3 months ago
I thought Johnny Cash wrote The Man Who Smells Like Hurt.
'I am still right here' says David, and David is correct.
drawlbag 4 months ago 3
Yes,yes, Barack is his first name.....
strudel60 4 months ago
No you guys got it all wrong, Obama wrote it! I also heard he is working on his own version maybe even with the killers
strudel60 4 months ago
@strudel60 who? barack obama lol
devilhunter123100 4 months ago
seven dust does a remake on this also check it out
polomartinez1 4 months ago
what have a i become my sweetest friend
aleiss28 4 months ago
Comment removed
aleiss28 4 months ago
Heroin is one hell of a drug!
rickyray101 4 months ago
For all those bitching about who wrote what--seriously? Both versions are amazing, so stfu and enjoy the music!!!
angelnic007 4 months ago
maybe they wrote it, but Johnny Cashs version is waaaaaaaay better.
Matriculon 4 months ago
@Matriculon Johnny Cash can hit all of like three notes.
kwaal 2 months ago
What a perfect combination. This is amazing, so much better than all the shit in the charts these days, i was born at the wrong time haha.
JakeLeeProductions 5 months ago
Wow. Wow. Wow. Love the two together. Great duet! The song was already beautiful, this just made it beautiful in a different way. :D
AngelGhostchild 5 months ago
everyone who thinks this is a j cash song is a full on retard.great version btw.
TotalFuckingHate 5 months ago
Eerie...But excellent!
jaygeemd 5 months ago
tbh I think JC used it as a euology for himself, and possibly an epitaph, he recognised the poignancy in Trents lyrics and fitted them into his own past,,, so Trent has been recognised and acknowledged by JC,,,can't be all that bad can it! :)
harrigab1 5 months ago
DeliveryMan has no penis because Trent cut it and then use it as a dildo to fuck del's woman
there is plenty of evidence xD
opethgarzaMD 6 months ago
trent reznor made, wrote the song, put all his feelings out into, and worked very hard on this song. this video is from 1995, and cash didnt cover it until 2002. seriosly?
dudeitsmeginn 6 months ago 23
@dudeitsmeginn i was born in 1995. so im cooler in a way, some how..........i dont know
pandabear941 1 month ago
@dudeitsmeginn yeah... *seriously
ComeGetBaked 1 week ago 2
@dudeitsmeginn jOHNNY LIVED IT
johnjacilene 1 week ago
@johnjacilene So did Trent... just in a different way.
CopCutLo 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
One time some guy tried to tell me it was Johnny Cash who wrote this song and not Trent Reznor, which is ppular opinion. And I said that was bullocks. Bullshit. NIN wrote Hurt plain and simple. But then I did some research and turns out that crazy guy was right about it the whole time. I posted all the evidence up on my channel so you guys can learn the truth too. Turns out Johnny Cash really did write the song, and a lot of people collaborated to and make it seem otherwise.
DeliveryManBoy 6 months ago
by far a better audio version. no disrespect to J. Cash for making a great song.
gabegarcia7676 6 months ago
@gabegarcia7676
cash didnt write this song.
SteveFusionX 5 months ago
Excellent harmonies. Kudos, Bowie.
joshhorne 6 months ago 3
Is there a way to disable comments on Youtube? Because I can't help read them sometimes and I always regret it.
jravell 7 months ago 35
@jravell - just exert some self-control and DO NOT READ THEM. Watch the video, then move on.
BobRoberts1492 2 months ago
@jravell lol! (i agree)
But really, its called life... use it as a small lesson in how to allow things you disagree with roll off your back :D
umageddon 1 month ago
Just beautiful...... as well as haunting.
Samthetoolfan27 7 months ago
I was fortunate enough to see bowie and reznor sing this live in portland in '95. Best concert ever.
forsho6906 7 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
check out my channel pwease :) <3 i covered this song :)
jeidocupcake 7 months ago
Yo Trent I'm gonna let you finish, but Johnny Cash wrote "Hurt"! One of the best songs of all time. OF ALL TIME
clevelandsfinest92 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@clevelandsfinest92
From Wikipedia, "Hurt"
"Hurt" is a song written by Trent Reznor, first released on Nine Inch Nails' 1994 album The Downward Spiral. -
In 2002, "Hurt" was covered by Johnny Cash
SteveFusionX 5 months ago
GREAT SONG WRITTEN BY THE ONE & ONLY TRENT REZNOR ...
carakenio 7 months ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trent doesn't deserve to be in David Bowie's presence.
issaacgooser 7 months ago
wow, to many idiots think cash wrote this masterpiece.... no Mr.Trent Reznor did. so.... shut the fuck up bout cash writin it, dont get me wrong, cash's version, is bad ass as well. but 2 completely diff things they r singing bout.
MrChevelless1972 8 months ago 3
@MrChevelless1972 indeed, although it is Trent's song Cash made it his own when he did it which is a beautiful thing, both versions wonderful and both meanings completely different from the other.
Samthetoolfan27 7 months ago
Bowie must have started doing heroin on this tour
StickyInADarkBlueCut 8 months ago 2
@IAmIronMant...you are right about Bowie...he was really sick on this tour. There was an announcement about it, IIRC. We had also seen him in Hartford on an earlier tour (Glass Spider, with Peter Frampton) and it was night and day.
wolfman231 8 months ago
THIS IS AWESOME!
theHomemadeCouch 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
First I comment that NIN sucks and can't play, then I wait for two weeks and comment that Johnny looks like a fidgeting carcass. Just to "stir up" the conversation :)
Sukkulakukkula 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
First I comment that NIN sucks and can't play, then I wait for two weeks and comment that Johnny looks like a fidgeting carcass, just to "stir up" the conversation :)
Sukkulakukkula 8 months ago
First I comment that NIN sucks and can't play, then I wait for two weeks and comment that Johnny looks like a fidgeting carcass just to "stir up" the conversation :)
Sukkulakukkula 8 months ago
I saw this concert back in 95... NIN was fantastic, but Bowie was complete shite. Bowie couldn't hold a tune, his voice was terrible, and it only took a few songs after NIN had left the stage for almost everyone in the arena to leave as well. As a Bowie fan... it was the most disappointing concert I'd ever been to. I really felt sorry for him, by the time we left... there were maybe a thousand people left in the arena that was sold out at 17,000 some capacity.
IAmIronMant 9 months ago
@IAmIronMant that's weird,.I'm a big fan of both,have seen most of his concerts, never seen or heard DB out of tune or singing badlyl,but as far as I know the tour with NIN was a succes,a pity. at the time I saw him in Holland his first Europian concert of the outside tour,he was ab fab ,but no NIN they continued touring in the states!!The free NIN-David Bowie live d.load sounds really cool both r great ! Am glad I didn't have to see that, DB being shite !
zenobowie 7 months ago
bowie and trent .. sends a chill right down ur spine , and it feels great :D
Warcraft20101 9 months ago 2
great work on the audio, thanx!
akar21 9 months ago
after all these years still sends a shiver down my spine
adamonthetube 9 months ago
Nine Inch Nails wrote this song....Johny Cash just redid it..both versions are amazing
MaggotPrince191 9 months ago 2
DelveryManBoy: You have no channel on youtube. What are you talking about?
trilingual 9 months ago
Two of the most powerful muscians in the world sharing the stage singing one of the most powerful songs in the world, amazing..
TheOM3G4 9 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Does anyone here understand what I am saying? I'm saying that Trent Reznor lied to all of us. He and his vampire lawyers have fabricated a giant story where Trent Reznor is honored and grateful that Johnny Cash covered "his" song. But in fact, it was Johnny Cash that was deeply wounded when he heard that his special song Hurt had been covered by Trent Reznor. There is plenty of evidence on my channel if you do not believe me. Trent Reznor stole Hurt from JC, and that is a disgrace to the M.I.B.
DeliveryManBoy 9 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy He he he. You're a silly goose.
Cxaxakluth 8 months ago
do people real ly think that Cash wrote this fab song???
The same story with Nirvana,''the man who sold the world''a classic of DB,people saying ''I saw Bowie he did a cover of Nirvana,some people live under a rock!!!
zenobowie 10 months ago 66
@zenobowie your an a hole johnny was the beast
Timmyhart15 7 months ago
@Timmyhart15 idiot,can't u read !?
zenobowie 7 months ago
@zenobowie what is even more depressing is some people think Sheryl Crow wrote all of those classic songs she covered
IZIEIDxViDz 4 months ago
@IZIEIDxViDz most of them fans I suppose,I noticed that with Nirvana at the time !
zenobowie 4 months ago
@zenobowie - Worse still I once met someone that genuinely thought The Doors covered Will Youngs 'Light my Fire'....Hells Bells :-s
770yd1n5pac3 2 months ago
Ok. To put everyone in their places and stop debating about cash and NIN.
Nine Inch Nails is the original , Trent reznor wrote it, It was released in The downward spiral 1994, Cash covered the song in 2001.
woahXgirl94 10 months ago
This dude (DeliveryManBoy) is posting on a bunch of NIN videos. He's trolling you guys... I don't have to watch his videos on his channel because I know he's laughing his ass off at people getting up in arms about Mr. Cash writing "Hurt". Those who already know, don't waste your time arguing with him. Enjoy NIN, enjoy the weather, enjoy life and don't sweat the small shit.
TrentsReznor 10 months ago 64
@TrentsReznor wrong. check your facts before you go making wild statements. it was johnny cash who originally wrote this song. he just never had it recorded or copyrighted because he thought it was too special. Trent Reznor heard the song at a private engagement and recorded it as his own the following year. While johnny Cash never made a big deal about it, he was deeply offended to have his song covered by a necropheliac. There is a bit of evidence to this fact on my channel I have provided.
DeliveryManBoy 10 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Actually, you, sir, are incorrect. And before you go around spreading lies, here is the truth. Rick Rubin (famous producer, part owner of Columbia Records - VERY well known in the music business) introduced "Hurt" to Johnny Cash in the final years that Cash was alive. "Hurt" as part of a series of songs and albums that Rubin felt Cash could put a very strange and unusual twist to. Other songs include Sting's "I hung my Head" and Depeche Mode's "Personal Jesus".
bopptb 10 months ago
Comment removed
bopptb 10 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Incase you still didn't believe me, go to Google and search for "NPR Rick Rubin Cash", click on the first link. Actually, it's even listed in the "Editorial Review" section on Amazon when you search for Cash's album: "American IV: The Man Comes Around". I was going to post the links for you, but YouTube doesn't allow links to be posted in comments. Reznor himself was even quoted saying that "Hurt" was no longer his song because of how well Cash remade it as a compliment to Cash.
bopptb 10 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Just out of curiousity, who told you your facts? Your buddies? Don't believe everything you hear, even though it sounds like it could be true. I've never heard your theory before, and really, you should always site your sources when you make an assertion, let alone win an argument. I'm not trying to be rude, but you are telling other people to "check their facts" and then immediately make an unverified assertion. Citing your "YouTube Channel" doesn't count.
bopptb 10 months ago
@bopptb Those of you who would say that Cash's song is nothing compared to the Nine INch Nails version? How can you support a man who blatantly rips off a legendary country stars work and then trys to make himself look like the original composer? Further, how can you support a cross dresser who often plays with parts of dead animals? It turns my stomach. And I know your going to go cut and paste the wiki article, or tell me you have the album. It's a conspiracy. Proof on my channel.
DeliveryManBoy 9 months ago
Comment removed
ipakski 9 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Stop it. I even remember when Cash's version was released. I had been listening to the NIN version for years. This is a nice one with Bowie, another favourite of mine.
ipakski 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ipakski THEY will try and tell you Trent Reznor wrote this song. THEY will tell you, RIck Rubin suggested Johnny Cash "cover" the song, and after some apprehension, Trent Reznor eventually decided that he was "honored" to have Cash cover "his" song. Both men's albums give the writer's credit to Trent. And Wikipedia says the same. but... IT'S ALL BULLSHIT! JOHNNY CASH WROTE THIS SONG. I have proof to this fact on my channel. TRENT REZNOR STOLE HURT FROM JC!!! I have sources.
DeliveryManBoy 9 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Really? well then Cash took his sweet time releasing it seeing that NIN's version was written 8 YEARS before Johnny Cash covered it, besides songs like that arent Cash's style, so i doubt he wrote it, I love both versions though.
bilsrylos 8 months ago 2
@DeliveryManBoy Wow, conspiracy theory much?
toshineon 7 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy What the hell dude? I've seen you trolling around like every cover video of this song. Your obviously wrong. Go ride your bike and do something worthwhile.
lilORANG 10 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy no way,written by Trent Reznor,got the anbum since '94.Cash probably didn't have a clue at that time,remind you his own son tells in a special about Cash that he had to change the lyrics a bit,and it was his son he told him to cover Trent's ''Hurt'',and you can see him listening to Trent's ""hurt'' of the ''Downward spiral'' album!!Cash listening btw.He covered many songs esp. the last 2 albums have many!!You better check your facts!!
zenobowie 7 months ago 2
Comment removed
bopptb 10 months ago
@TrentsReznor I feel so stupid,you're so right !!
zenobowie 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TrentsReznor I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
DeliveryManBoy 4 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy impposible nine inch nails released the song back in 1994 on the downward spiral record
and johhny cash covered the song in 2003
johhny cash said him self that it was a cover
anyway i think your just trying to get channel views.
devilhunter123100 4 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy
You are retarded!!!
It is not even remotely debatable!!!
You don't know Trent Reznor and you didn't know Johny Cash, because if you did, you wouldn't be making such f**king stupid statements!!!
You are either a troll, or you are mentally retarded!!!
Get a life!!!
ptownkid81 4 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy I would not watch your stupid channel even if you paid cash.
Fuck off
PabloMGP 4 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy
oh so you're the worst person ever is what you're telling me? oh its spelled Reznor, and he's kind of a lyrical genius. and this video is amazing.
nintoolradiohead182 3 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Obvious troll is obvious.
kwaal 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Johnny Cash wrote and recorded a lot of music in his lifetime. He recorded a lot of serious songs, but he also recorded a lot of funny ones like “A Boy Named Sue.” There are a lot of Johnny Cash songs that I like. Some of my favorites are "Ring of Fire", "I Walk the Line", "Folsom Prison Blues", "Get Rhythm" and "Man in Black" just to name a few. But my favorite Johnny Cash song of all has got to be the song “Hurt.” Johnny Cash wrote the song in 1974 while serving time in Folsom prison.
DeliveryManBoy 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
David Bowie should be shot for doing this.
llron1west 10 months ago
i'm really confused, is this guy for real??, i just checked his channel and i cant work out if he's just a helmet, or actually serious.....
locolegsharvey 10 months ago
Man, they sound great together. Wish they did a studio version of that...
digenovafilm 10 months ago
Is it just me or does deliverymanboy sound like the mom from water boy. Calling Trent the devil. And he doesn't even listen to what you say. He keeps posting the same fucking comments on every video. He is a fucking moron, who can't except shit. So do us all a favor and just GO!
shakakamooroar 11 months ago
Maybe this is the one you were thinking of:
Hurt: By Roy Hamilton, written 1954
Fordyshoor 11 months ago
@Deliverymanboy. I'd love to see these documents that defy the laws of time and space. I think you simply can't accept that a musician you hate wrote a song you love so you've built up this complex delusion around the whole subject. After seeing how many people have discounted you, it's pretty clear that it's not really about the song. You know, therapy might not be a bad route for you, and I actually mean this sincerely. God can be strong guidance but sometimes we all need a little extra help.
Fordyshoor 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@Fordyshoor Do not get me started on that disgraceful cover that Nine Inch Nails did of this song. I don't want to argue about it on my channel. Flame me if you like It doesn't bother me. I know that all of the proof on my page vindicates the name of johnny Cash, and prooves beyond a shadow of a doubt who actually wrote this song. It surely wasn't Trent Reznor. He's a devil worshiper.
DeliveryManBoy 11 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy
dude stop trolling. not funny anymore.
if u actually bought the single u would know the credits clearly state the song was written by Trent Reznor.
doesn't get more official than that.
and no offense for your great johnny cash...but he could have never come up with such melody and songwriting....not even if he lived another million years.
animativ 11 months ago
@animativ Cash damn well could and has. And yes Trent wrote it but even Trent thinks Cash's version is gold. Why be a jackass and argue over which is better? They're DIFFERENT. Just live and let live without being a douchnozzle.
FrancesFife 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@DeliveryManBoy You are a fucking idiot.
JeremyMetal 11 months ago 2
Comment removed
Fordyshoor 11 months ago
@Deliverymanboy. They're both great versions but before you blindly assert, I'd suggest looking at history. Unless you assume MR. Reznor built himself a time machine and stole Cash's song 7 years later, the likelihood of you being right is slim. Also, wouldn't you say Johnny Cash insinuating he's Jesus is equally sacreligious? Or maybe him covering a song by the satanic tinged Danzig years earlier? I'd suggest removing your holy head from out of your ass before you suffocate yourself.
Fordyshoor 11 months ago
@Fordyshoor I have supplied plenty of proof on my channel that johnny Cash wrote this song in 1974 and that Trent Reznor stole the song and covered it on the downward spiral in 1994. There are documents where Juaqine Pheonix attempts to alert the major news outlets of the Nine Inch Nails conspiracy. Interview Notation of his daughters making similar claims. Copyrighted paperwork and legal documents from Trent Reznor's lawyers that show contempt. I have made a solid case Trent stole the song.
DeliveryManBoy 11 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy ...Johnny said he covered it dude, you know nothing.
Norokrex 11 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Really now, well then you'll have no trouble believing that I am Ghandi's mum, even though I'm fifteen. oh yeah, and Abraham Lincoln is Jesus' gardner.
Wanker.
7PsycoMantis7 11 months ago
@7PsycoMantis7 As Abraham Lincoln, I can verify that statement. I'm also an Alien from the Same plane tthat the Hindu Gods are from, I founded Shintoism, was Cleopatra when I founded ancient Greece and I use my Sixth eye to hypnotize Lawn Gnomes into coming to life and worshiping me as God.
MajickDemoniack 10 months ago 2
@MajickDemoniack Don't we all..?
7PsycoMantis7 10 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy And I like Jhonny Cash too.
7PsycoMantis7 11 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy
I can't believe that such an alarming number of people don't get the joke.
I myself had a good chuckle.
ReluctantlyAwake 10 months ago
@ReluctantlyAwake what joke? I have evidence on my channel that proves everything that I have ever said to anyone is true.
DeliveryManBoy 10 months ago
Trent Reznor wrote this song, makes me wonder who changed lines ;)
Anyway, both songs deserve to be heard and enjoyed.
oolek 11 months ago
this is a really cool duet in general, and a sweet performance of the song
and i think the only version that ever mattered, was Trent`s. originals are usually better then covers. "Hurt" is no exception to this.
Wolfysama 11 months ago
@Wolfysama Oddly enough, Trent himself would disagree with you, he said that he was so blown away by cash's verson of the song that it was no longer his.
Norokrex 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
In the fankierocks1 Johnny Cash hurt video comments, Frankierocks1 blocked me from posting on his page because I was arguing so good. Go on that comments section and accuse frankierocks1 of being a nazi tyrant for deleting me. Explain to him how NIN stole the song Hurt from Johnny cash, since I can't defend him there anymore. With a little help from the resistance, I think we can eventually coerce Trent Resnor to admit to what he has done, and then get his version of Hurt banned for all time.
DeliveryManBoy 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SparkedTiger Look, you are becoming more of a problem than I can handle here. Your kind of getting in the way of my crusade here making me argue with you over grammar, when I have conspiracies to uncover here. I've already got enough problems what with all the people going on my youtube channel and posting all this ignorant hate speech and disliking all my videos. What do I have to say to get you to go away and stop posting all this crap on my Johnny Cash evidence videos? Stay off my channel!
DeliveryManBoy 11 months ago
I'll add some kindle.
@Everyone responding to the rantings of an illogical Internet Kid nitwit that is DeliveryManBoy, please continue to feed the fire to the obvious Troll. There is further enjoyment to be had out of this.
Now the flame rises higher!
Grictonis 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Grictonis Your not making any sense. Of course I think that Johnny Cash's version is better. I love Johnny Cash. It is MR. Trent Reznor I am upset with for covering this beautiful song and using computers and synthisizers. It just does not work. Not to mention he changed the line Crown of Thorns which was a reference Cash made to Jesus, to Crown of Shit, which is just anti-christian. It makes me sick. I despise Mr. Trent Reznor's cover. And I have tried to see the bright side in this.
DeliveryManBoy 11 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Well I'm glad to see you ignorant Christians blindly believing what you want to without bothering to do any research. Keep up the good work, at least I get a good laugh.
LazyRWT 11 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy
Cash made it his own in his COVER. Reznor made the song first.
nyfantana 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SparkedTiger You've left six or seven offensive posts on my channel in the last two days, and thats not even counting the ones you made on my videos. This is getting out of hand mstrk and I want it to stop NOW!!!! It's one thing to disagree with me thats all well and fine, but you stay off of my profile man. All the language you use and your anti-christian messages end NOW! Leave me alone. Enough is enough. Were not in highschool anymore. Johnny Cash wrote the song. Get over it Ninny fan!
DeliveryManBoy 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I would like to take this opportunity to appologize to anyone in the youtube community that I may have offended with my comments. If you visit my channel, you will see that a great many threats have been communicated against me because of my beliefs. This is no excuse for me to be negative. While I remain adamant that it was wrong and disreputable for Nine Inch Nails to have covered this song which Johnny Cash wrote back in the 70's, If I lower myself to the level of my opponents, then they win.
DeliveryManBoy 11 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy epic troll is epic xDD I like ur style mate :*
SpazSlo 1 year ago
David Bowie's voice is SO .sexy, I SO would: anytime ,anywhere,anyhow; even though is old, even though I'm gay!
TriptykalBabe 1 year ago
Ist there is THAT v. special song, which I adore, sung by Trent, and who else too but David Bowie: aka God...
Divine combination..
TriptykalBabe 1 year ago
Does anyone know the music at the very beginning, it sounds really good.
TheJ731 1 year ago
Don't feed the trolls people, and they will go away (ie, DeliveryManBoy). Even the fish know that this song is a Trent Reznor original. He's just baiting y'all because he loves any kind of feedback, even the negative kind. And unfortunately many of you are falling for it.
voodooseed72 1 year ago
@voodooseed72 And I see him on almost every video of this song as I have been looking for the best version.Obviously he has made this into a crusade and nobody will get it through to him.All the articles, facts ect. won't stop him.Seems funny that Cash said in the " Rolling Stone" how much he admired Trent's lyrics.Funny coming from the man Trent "stole" the song from him.Hey, it keeps him off the streets, he's safer taking his venom to comment threads.......Peace!
trippinvic 1 year ago
@trippinvic there is plenty of evidence to support the claim that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. There are multitude's of evidence on my channel which speaks to the matter at hand and proves, in my opinion, beyond a shadow of a doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. Trent Reznor did not write it, he just made a horrendous and obnoxious cover. If you don't believe all the evidence on my channel, just do a simple google search and you will find plenty of evidence.
DeliveryManBoy 1 year ago
@trippinvic The dude is a troll, plain and simple. He knows the truth, everyone knows Trent wrote it, even a moron like him, but people responding to him, even in a negative manner, is what he lives for. That's just how sad and pathetic his life is. Unfortunately there are many just like him no matter where you look on the internets. Just check any given music video here or any imdb board and you'll see what I mean. He's not even worthy of a direct response. He's a troll-baiting piece of poo.
voodooseed72 1 year ago
@voodooseed72 I have seen alot of it on many comment threads, it seems to be a major hobby to some people.Yes, it is pretty sad.What bothers me is seeing all the negativity it creates. Johnny Cash and Trent Reznor both are ground breaking and gifted musicians and I hate to see either of their names being bashed over this foolishness.Ah well, what can you do but try to ignore it and not get baited into responding to them.Like arguing with a rock.No one wins and it's a waste of effort.
trippinvic 1 year ago
@voodooseed72 LOL-"poo"? Love it! Missed the irony the first time.Nice to see someone expressing anger without resorting to cursing.Very well done.No troll food from you! Kudos!
trippinvic 1 year ago
@trippinvic Have you seen any of DeliveryManBoy's videos? He even attempts 'singing' this, it's really funny, but kinda sad too. The dude obviously has a few screws loose, to say the least. I kinda feel sorry for him, but even more-so, I pity his parents who brought such a waste of space into the world. He's the greatest excuse for pro-choice I've ever seen. Besides, no pregnancy that's a result of in-breeding should go full term.
voodooseed72 1 year ago
Comment removed
trippinvic 1 year ago
@voodooseed72 I checked his page to see his "proof" and as I am significantly older and read alot I would have heard of this while it was happening.I did,however, read how much JC loved the song and was pleased to get permission from Trent to cover it.JC was a strong man of great character and would not have just let it go if his beloved song was stolen.He not only insults Trent but Johnny as well.Some way to respect his idol,potraying him as a spineless wuss.Incredibly disrespectful and sad.
trippinvic 1 year ago
@voodooseed72 Damn, someone else is making an abortion joke? thats like the 3rd different one this morning. I guess you were the first to put the inbreeding twist on it, but damn, I thought you were better than that voodooseed. I had come to expect great things from you. You were the first to put a whole different spin on the resistance. Now your just like raputin67rr or eXXXaJackXXX from the Nine INch Nails - Hurt With Lyrics page.
DeliveryManBoy 1 year ago
@DeliveryManBoy
Your fanaticism of Johnny Cash blinds you to the truth.
ZetsubouMFZB 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ZetsubouMFZB Let me tell you something buddy.This is the greatest song that Johnny Cash ever wrote. On the 6th of January, my rebel uncle Bobby killed himself by chopping off his arm with an ax. I never was aloud to hang out with him because my mom said he was crazy. They used to always tell story's about him and how he would run from the Sheriff every other weekend in his dodge charger for all of the town to see. We listened to this song at his funeral. Every man there drank a 24 pack himself.
DeliveryManBoy 1 year ago
@DeliveryManBoy
Trent Reznor wrote the song and Johnny Cash covered it. There are plenty of interviews and other sources to confirm that fact. Also your little story about your uncle does nothing to change the fact that you were wrong about the write of the song. You may just be another internet troll since no sane being can possibly be that oblivious.
ZetsubouMFZB 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ZetsubouMFZB there is plenty of evidence to support the claim that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. There are multitude's of evidence on my channel which speaks to the matter at hand and proves, in my opinion, beyond a shadow of a doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song hurt. Trent Reznor did not write it, he just made a horrendous and obnoxious cover. If you don't believe all the evidence on my channel, just do a simple google search and you will find plenty of evidence.
DeliveryManBoy 1 year ago
@DeliveryManBoy
I doubt your homemade videos could trump over interviews by both Trent Reznor and Johnny Cash and the fact that Reznor wrote the song in 1994 while Cash's version was released in 2002. Cash even admitted that it was a cover. Any Google search would lead to undeniable evidence that Reznor wrote the song and Cash covered it. For a guy who practically worships Johnny Cash, you sure know nothing about one of his biggest hits/covers.
ZetsubouMFZB 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ZetsubouMFZB Now while most of these statements are at the very least half truths, if you look a little closer you will see a web of deceit. At the very heart of the matter, is one big ugly lie, and that is to say, that Trent Reznor wrote the song “Hurt” He did not. It was Johnny Cash. And once you see how easily they have manipulated the truth about Cash's death and his music, you will be very disturbed just as i was. Please join me in boycotting Nine inch nails altogether.
DeliveryManBoy 1 year ago
@DeliveryManBoy
You're just trying to get channel views. You are the only person in the world who seems to think Cash wrote it. Also, I can't imagine Cash talking about drug addiction. "The needle tears a hole, the old familiar sting, try to kill it all away, but I remember everything." You just WISH Cash wrote it, and its strange because its probably the biggest cover of all time and everyone in the music industry knows it. And finally, those lyrics are very fitting to NIN's style, not Cash's.
JamesCmuse 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JamesCmuse You've left six or seven offensive posts on my channel in the last two days, and thats not even counting the ones you made on my videos. This is getting out of hand mstrk and I want it to stop NOW!!!! It's one thing to disagree with me thats all well and fine, but you stay off of my profile man. All the language you use and your anti-christian messages end NOW! Leave me alone. Enough is enough. Were not in highschool anymore. Johnny Cash wrote the song. Get over it Ninny fan!
DeliveryManBoy 1 year ago
@DeliveryManBoy How about you crawling back into that black hole from which you came from? That would stop all the negative comments you're complaining about in an instant. Also, like I told you in the comment on your 'version' which you deleted, mental illness is hereditary. Yes, your uncle was obviously a nutcase, but all the signs point to you being one too. Sad, but true. Seek help, take your meds, get lost.
PS, 'aloud' and 'allowed' are two entirely different words, you illiterate troll.
voodooseed72 1 year ago