hey Tarantino's just admitting his honest opinion about Altman, I'm not a huge Altman fan myself but this is a very good movie. and by the way he's saying that he loves the movie.
Tarantino is so fixated on kissing Warren Beatty's ass that he wouldn't even mention Julie Christie. The film is McCabe and Mrs Miller not McCabe. And you can't call Warren Beatty the auteur of this film, Altman is the auteur. Beatty delivered a great performance but he's not the auteur.
@Tigerlily21 that doesn't necessarily mean that he is fixated on Warren Beatty, it almost sounds like Quentin did this improvised and said what ever he could say from the top of his head. Trust me, he probably most definitely thinks about Julie Christie's excellent performance.
He has a right to his opinion. I happen to think Robert Altman is one of the top 5 Greatest Directors of all time. I also would put Quentin Tarantino on my top 10 . We all say things about what a good movie is or what a bad movie is, but it seems like having some-one put it on youtube or what have you makes people write some hateful comments. What response do these people give when they hear some-one say something out loud they disagree with - Makes you think
Really enjoyed Tarantino's discussion here -- mainly because I agree with everything he says! I've never particularly liked Altman and "Altmanesque" touches either, yet "McCabe" is just fantastic, in all the specific ways Tarantino mentions. I wonder if the film works for me b/c it's a period piece; I just don't buy the whole cynical / jaded worldview in Altman's more contemporary pieces, but the darkness works here b/c everyone is trapped by historical circumstances beyond their control.
The situation that you refer to as "historical circumstances" in the movie, sounds as though you're suggesting that big busness bullying no longer exists ???
And I dis-agree that the people, in the movie, were trapped beyond their control. The last twenty minutes of McCabe & Mrs. Miller was all about how the people had the means to control the situation.
If you're going to wear Tarantino lenses when watching any film, your going to see the problem & miss the Solution part.
I found this novel called The Suicide Game that feels like a Tarantino movie and even has a character that seems to be Tarantino himself. It features a black hitman, a murderous priest, and a gay phone sex operator. I downloaded it for free at smashwords . com and it was awesome.
hey guys stop jumping on altman's dick, i ain't his biggest fan, but if tarantino has an opinion on his movies, he should, it shouldn't be a good on, if you do need a positive review or opinion and i bet altman would have a zero problem about with it
McCabe & Mrs. Miller is Altman's ANTI-CORPORATION Statement in a Post-Western vehicle.
Notice how Tarantino talks about the gun-men, but doesn't mention who paid them to kill McCabe, which is primary to the gun-men's identity and Altman's film.
good question, really smart. The answer is very simpel...because everyone of us likes to take a shit on other people heads. If I don't like you or Tarantinos pseudo intellectual speeches and I feel like taking a big shit, I just let it all out.
Not yet. Sometimes I shoot 4 to 5 shitloads a day. I'm an angry Freebird that aims for dumb fucks and feministic trash whores like Oprah or Tira banks (I'm not racist). Sometimes I hit innocent people, for that I'm sry, I allways cry after my shitload fractured a innocent skull. If you are a nice guy or a nice lady or a nice she-male, I'm sry for my gruesome attack.
Pompous ass! And, I'm not just saying that because I'm jealous!
bfor42 6 days ago
Maybe they called McCabe "Pudgy" because he was skinny... the way they called Hackman "Little Bill" in Unforgiven.
bfor42 6 days ago
I got through it all in one showing... and loved it! So, take that, Tarantino!
bfor42 6 days ago
Oh, shut up! Go make another movie!!!
bfor42 6 days ago
just to add on though, when he says "practically uninteligable" he does sound pretty snobby
samfilmkid 2 months ago
hey Tarantino's just admitting his honest opinion about Altman, I'm not a huge Altman fan myself but this is a very good movie. and by the way he's saying that he loves the movie.
samfilmkid 3 months ago
Tarantino is so fixated on kissing Warren Beatty's ass that he wouldn't even mention Julie Christie. The film is McCabe and Mrs Miller not McCabe. And you can't call Warren Beatty the auteur of this film, Altman is the auteur. Beatty delivered a great performance but he's not the auteur.
Tigerlily21 5 months ago 2
@Tigerlily21 that doesn't necessarily mean that he is fixated on Warren Beatty, it almost sounds like Quentin did this improvised and said what ever he could say from the top of his head. Trust me, he probably most definitely thinks about Julie Christie's excellent performance.
thatmovieguy777 4 months ago
He has a right to his opinion. I happen to think Robert Altman is one of the top 5 Greatest Directors of all time. I also would put Quentin Tarantino on my top 10 . We all say things about what a good movie is or what a bad movie is, but it seems like having some-one put it on youtube or what have you makes people write some hateful comments. What response do these people give when they hear some-one say something out loud they disagree with - Makes you think
kaejae24 5 months ago
Really enjoyed Tarantino's discussion here -- mainly because I agree with everything he says! I've never particularly liked Altman and "Altmanesque" touches either, yet "McCabe" is just fantastic, in all the specific ways Tarantino mentions. I wonder if the film works for me b/c it's a period piece; I just don't buy the whole cynical / jaded worldview in Altman's more contemporary pieces, but the darkness works here b/c everyone is trapped by historical circumstances beyond their control.
cinemasailor 5 months ago
@cinemasailor
The situation that you refer to as "historical circumstances" in the movie, sounds as though you're suggesting that big busness bullying no longer exists ???
And I dis-agree that the people, in the movie, were trapped beyond their control. The last twenty minutes of McCabe & Mrs. Miller was all about how the people had the means to control the situation.
If you're going to wear Tarantino lenses when watching any film, your going to see the problem & miss the Solution part.
SnakeEyesAndSevens 5 months ago
you are all huge dicks to Tarantino.
thatmovieguy777 6 months ago 5
I agree with QT. It took me like a day to watch the movie because I kept falling asleep during the first 20 minutes. After that, the movie's solid.
klbasey 6 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I found this novel called The Suicide Game that feels like a Tarantino movie and even has a character that seems to be Tarantino himself. It features a black hitman, a murderous priest, and a gay phone sex operator. I downloaded it for free at smashwords . com and it was awesome.
Zombiegeddon007 6 months ago
hey guys stop jumping on altman's dick, i ain't his biggest fan, but if tarantino has an opinion on his movies, he should, it shouldn't be a good on, if you do need a positive review or opinion and i bet altman would have a zero problem about with it
ASDMarauder007 6 months ago
McCabe & Mrs. Miller is Altman's ANTI-CORPORATION Statement in a Post-Western vehicle.
Notice how Tarantino talks about the gun-men, but doesn't mention who paid them to kill McCabe, which is primary to the gun-men's identity and Altman's film.
BrotherOfLove84 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tarantino is a jack-ass, plain and simple.
Nodl1000 9 months ago
@Nodl1000 Then why did you take the time to click and comment on a video titled "Quentin Tarantino on McCabe and Mrs. Miller?
grindhouse141 9 months ago 10
@grindhouse141
good question, really smart. The answer is very simpel...because everyone of us likes to take a shit on other people heads. If I don't like you or Tarantinos pseudo intellectual speeches and I feel like taking a big shit, I just let it all out.
Godhand156 6 months ago
@Godhand156 I hope you've relieved yourself ;)
grindhouse141 6 months ago
@grindhouse141
Not yet. Sometimes I shoot 4 to 5 shitloads a day. I'm an angry Freebird that aims for dumb fucks and feministic trash whores like Oprah or Tira banks (I'm not racist). Sometimes I hit innocent people, for that I'm sry, I allways cry after my shitload fractured a innocent skull. If you are a nice guy or a nice lady or a nice she-male, I'm sry for my gruesome attack.
Godhand156 6 months ago
@Godhand156 Well, then, you've got a ways to go before you complete your sit cycle. Carry on sir!
grindhouse141 6 months ago
Altman has more talent in his little finger than Tarantino could ever dream of.
aloysiusone 11 months ago
@aloysiusone lol yeah, okayyyy. Does that explain Beyond Therapy?
McNugget06 10 months ago
@aloysiusone i have more talent in my dick then your a faggot
defenestration1000 7 months ago
@aloysiusone Fuck that this is the most boring film i've ever seen, its a piece of shit
aquaman284 6 months ago
none of QT's movies come anywhere close to the greatness of "McCabe & Mrs. Miller"
Hellzyead 1 year ago
"the worst sound mix"? what a crock of shit...it's an altman film
Hellzyead 1 year ago