This was very interesting. I love how she showed pride in what and who she is but didn't act like there was no struggle to go with it . Very good speaker
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
WTF IS WRONG WITH ALL OF YOU?! This dumbass retarded bitch isn't anywhere near strong willed or a hero! Infact her very presense and posture speaks of insecurity! Yeah we all know she's trying to act proud of herself everyday, but she is more ashamed of herself than ever! If she wasn't, she would have talked about her past life as a man without any discomfort, and I mean REAL talking, not just writing a fucking book that only interested people would read.
Not only that, but if she was a strong willed person she would not have let the world indirectly convince her into cutting her penis off in the first place! And if she was also proud of her past life and decision, she would not have mentioned the fact that she got cheated on for lesbians! All she did was prove to the ex gfs that she was a bitch to them and really did take their advice to stooping down to their level in life. This bitch is trying to redeem her dignity for fucking up her body!
@subliminalhyminal She hasn't fucked up her body, at all. You're blind if you don't realize that the shame is part of the word piece. Seeing her talk at other conventions, I know she is very proud of who she is, in how she carries herself and the messages she shares. Not everyone fits into neat little boxes.
@subliminalhyminal hmm she's written a couple books, continued her career as a biologist, and is also a musician.. And chosen not to have surgery but live her life as the proud trans woman she is.
@teneovestriexsisto As for choosing a side. Who are you to decide that for anyone? It's up to how a person feels inside. While I may have decided to get SRS, others don't. And MANY others can't afford it. I fully believe we all have the right to decide for ourselves. What works for me probably won't work for somebody else, but that's THEIR choice not yours or anyone elses.
@teneovestriexsisto Actually... STUDY biology before you shoot your mouth off about it... There are MANY different hormones. "Estrogen" isn't even a hormone but a class of hormones while testosterone is just one of the class of hormones known as androgens...
There are hormones that control growth and MANY other functions within your body. Everyone has both oestrogens and androgens within their body in varying ratios.
"Some women have a penis. Some men don't. And the rest of the world is just going to have to get the fuck over it. And if I'm destined to be the loose thread that unravels the gender of everyone around me then I'm going to pull and pull and pull and pull until everyone is exposed, until they all finally see that all along, they were merely wearing the emperor's new clothes." THIS. awesome.
ok....this is what is commonly known as "speaking tongue in cheek" It's supposed to be funny, in other words. If I can't afford bottom surgery, or am not healthy enough, that changes who i am??? If you're confused, that's you. glad I could clear things up for ya.
Amen! And amen that you have the freedom to make your voice heard! That society has found the moment - of freedom - to take that lost thread and decidedly grow from it. When Julia uses the metaphor of the animal backed into a corner, it reminds me of all the images I've seen of animals being trapped by farmers in stalls. At some point you're so trapped you can't even turn around, all you can do is fight. There are those who haven't even a chance of winning, but even so, they - we - fight.
You're wonderful Julia... I wish you were the woman who held me and tole me that you could see the woman in my eyes, because I wouldn't feel so mixed up anymore.
"...I dont think she is unravelling anything, simply reacting to a world that has treated her so unkindly! ".
She is unravelling, taking preconceptions to task and saying things aren't what they may seem. Any of us who are living our true lives are contributing to this deconstruction of what society wants to conform to.
Your right you did not, I was refering to "the mixed messages" but while your on the subject I dont think she is unravelling anything, simply reacting to a world that has treated her so unkindly!
Still not sure I follow but okay. Unraveling is her word not mine and it was her use of it I was questioning, specifically in the context of the "just get over it" sentiment she expresses in the same piece. I'm not even sure that she means them to be seen as compatible but it comes off that way in the performance.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is a Trangenderist, her statements are the very reason why Transsexuals have a hard time being understood in society, this individual wants to be accepted as female yet not give up the very thing that makes you so, unfortunately she is the butt of every joke and the saddest thing is that she doesnt realise it! But it sells books and it will be interesting to see her in ten years time.
You obviously don't have a clue about what a transsexual person is. She was BORN female in the place that matters the most... the brain. Her activism, including her books, are to help educate the public as to the true nature of transsexualism. To help overcome the negative stereotypes that have been many still believe. You also believe SRS is a must, well it is for many and it was for me, but that is not always the case. And transition takes time, she may be post-op now. Transgenderist=CD.
I'm getting some mixed messages here. You can ask people to "get the fuck over it" or you can embrace the idea that you're unraveling traditional gender norms but I'm not sure the two are compatible, at least not in the same breath. I'm very much aware of the issues that trans people face and of the need for the rest of society to advance gender discourse, I'm just not sure this piece deals with that in an intelligent or effective way.
Anyone at all, who has been touched in anyway by gender variance, or better yet, everyone period, should pay attention to Julia. She makes me laugh, cry, and know with no uncertainty that I'm stronger than anything that can ever happen to me. reading her book was watching every thought I've ever had articulated beautifully and shouted back to me. I used to be pretty sure I could do this. Now I know I'm a BADASS!!! thank you so much, sister.
I've watched this video about 25 times over the last year and it never gets old. It's powerful because every freakin' word and emotion is TRUE. And "Whipping Girl" is a modern classic in gender studies. Thank you Julia!
it doesnt take balls to remove it... it takes a lack of purpose in life..some one who is so COMPLETELY benine to any social fitting thats who removes it...and thats exactly why.. he couldnt handle it.. atleast gay guys keep it i have no problem with gay men. what do you label this creature..a man or a woman..you say a woman but what happens when you check the birth certificate or what about old family pictures. its so sad
Creature? Interesting that you have to dehumanize her, that's what Hitler did to the Jews. She happens to be a writer, musician and spoken word artist and activist. Oh and birth certificates are amended. Benine is spelled benign and means "having a kindly disposition; gracious" I find ignorance sad. Not talent, intelligence and courage.
a man to woman kind huh...shows you women how powerful the cock is so respect it because some men cant even handle it and have to take ... learn from Shim !!
I am left moist-eyed and shaking my head in near disbelief at how good this is. I am in the middle of her book Whipping Girl right now and love it, too.
Julia ROCKS HARD!!! I absolutely love this piece; I would love to see some of her other spoken word too. It would also be awesome if her band, Bitesize had some of their songs up or some concert footage. She is a killa on tha mic !
This was very interesting. I love how she showed pride in what and who she is but didn't act like there was no struggle to go with it . Very good speaker
heartmulgrew15 1 day ago
Very affirming and positive; and instead of a dry lecternly academic style she's having fun. I like her a lot.
laikapupkino 2 months ago in playlist Julia Serano
I can't click the "Like" button enough times.
DefilerWyrm 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WTF IS WRONG WITH ALL OF YOU?! This dumbass retarded bitch isn't anywhere near strong willed or a hero! Infact her very presense and posture speaks of insecurity! Yeah we all know she's trying to act proud of herself everyday, but she is more ashamed of herself than ever! If she wasn't, she would have talked about her past life as a man without any discomfort, and I mean REAL talking, not just writing a fucking book that only interested people would read.
subliminalhyminal 4 months ago
Not only that, but if she was a strong willed person she would not have let the world indirectly convince her into cutting her penis off in the first place! And if she was also proud of her past life and decision, she would not have mentioned the fact that she got cheated on for lesbians! All she did was prove to the ex gfs that she was a bitch to them and really did take their advice to stooping down to their level in life. This bitch is trying to redeem her dignity for fucking up her body!
subliminalhyminal 4 months ago
@subliminalhyminal She hasn't fucked up her body, at all. You're blind if you don't realize that the shame is part of the word piece. Seeing her talk at other conventions, I know she is very proud of who she is, in how she carries herself and the messages she shares. Not everyone fits into neat little boxes.
Cyrissa85 4 months ago
@subliminalhyminal hmm she's written a couple books, continued her career as a biologist, and is also a musician.. And chosen not to have surgery but live her life as the proud trans woman she is.
jessicabake2 4 months ago 2
@jessicabake2 so tell me... is she happy? or does she just have empty self given pride without feeling completely accomplished?
subliminalhyminal 4 months ago
@subliminalhyminal I can't speak for her. For myself I can say I was miserable and didn't feel like I was really living until I transitioned.
jessicabake2 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sounds and acts like a stereotypical gay man.
enuvune 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's good to see Hedwig is still working after she broke up with The Angry Inch.
littlerudi08043 8 months ago
@dem0nthesis you so don't understand why she said that.
jessicabake2 9 months ago
@teneovestriexsisto All you people want is more more more more more! Leave her alone! You're lucky she even performed for you bastards!
klutterkicker 10 months ago
this is such a great poem (and I'm crushing on her)
gorramdoll 10 months ago
"Some women have a penis, some men don't" If people could understand that they would have no problems with trannies. Sad world.
crazybay46913 1 year ago 3
julia serano is my hero!
squeakysneakerdj 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Holy shit she looks like she's having a seizure every time she talks.
SimplyTehDopest 1 year ago
This? This is AMAZING.
inkandalchemy 1 year ago 2
This was too cool! I can't wait to watch some more!
ravlo2004 1 year ago
@teneovestriexsisto As for choosing a side. Who are you to decide that for anyone? It's up to how a person feels inside. While I may have decided to get SRS, others don't. And MANY others can't afford it. I fully believe we all have the right to decide for ourselves. What works for me probably won't work for somebody else, but that's THEIR choice not yours or anyone elses.
wonderlandgrrl 1 year ago
@teneovestriexsisto Actually... STUDY biology before you shoot your mouth off about it... There are MANY different hormones. "Estrogen" isn't even a hormone but a class of hormones while testosterone is just one of the class of hormones known as androgens...
There are hormones that control growth and MANY other functions within your body. Everyone has both oestrogens and androgens within their body in varying ratios.
wonderlandgrrl 1 year ago
Oh my god, back off on the caffeine!!!
spershall 1 year ago
"Some women have a penis. Some men don't. And the rest of the world is just going to have to get the fuck over it. And if I'm destined to be the loose thread that unravels the gender of everyone around me then I'm going to pull and pull and pull and pull until everyone is exposed, until they all finally see that all along, they were merely wearing the emperor's new clothes." THIS. awesome.
tamingoftheshru 1 year ago 2
or maybe they just don't WANT to get bottom surgery, jeese get outta the binary, open yr mind
femmeriotgrrrl 1 year ago 2
ok....this is what is commonly known as "speaking tongue in cheek" It's supposed to be funny, in other words. If I can't afford bottom surgery, or am not healthy enough, that changes who i am??? If you're confused, that's you. glad I could clear things up for ya.
Melissa0859 1 year ago 2
Who's confusing people?
jessicabake2 2 years ago
I think you meant 'ma'am'.
Nyship 2 years ago
AMAZING! i love seeing you confidence and showing your internal experience! you go girl!
Thatguysart 2 years ago
And HOW HAPPY am I that My comment comes after the great Kate Bornstein. Very happy indeed.
Abby.
Angelinaeldiablo 2 years ago
I have just three letters for you. W.O.W.
: )
Abby
Angelinaeldiablo 2 years ago
Bless your frakking heart, girl. I so wanna siddown over coffee with you. Please get in touch if you're coming to NYC. love & respect, K
katebornstein 2 years ago 7
Amen! And amen that you have the freedom to make your voice heard! That society has found the moment - of freedom - to take that lost thread and decidedly grow from it. When Julia uses the metaphor of the animal backed into a corner, it reminds me of all the images I've seen of animals being trapped by farmers in stalls. At some point you're so trapped you can't even turn around, all you can do is fight. There are those who haven't even a chance of winning, but even so, they - we - fight.
Aprinsa 2 years ago
Anyway, this is exactly why different movements should unite. TheVeganIdeal[dot]org is a vegan blog authored by a transgendered person.
Aprinsa 2 years ago
You're wonderful Julia... I wish you were the woman who held me and tole me that you could see the woman in my eyes, because I wouldn't feel so mixed up anymore.
nitzwalsh86 2 years ago 3
Which is to say you're a goddamn awesome girl. You were always a woman, and anybody who fails to recognize Julia is... well... fucked.
nitzwalsh86 2 years ago 2
"...I dont think she is unravelling anything, simply reacting to a world that has treated her so unkindly! ".
She is unravelling, taking preconceptions to task and saying things aren't what they may seem. Any of us who are living our true lives are contributing to this deconstruction of what society wants to conform to.
xtraceex 2 years ago 2
Society moves constantly, sometimes for the better but more often than not by the helms of monitarians.
teneovestriexsisto 2 years ago
Love it! Thanks
dancewomyn1 2 years ago
My previous comment was a response to Teneo the "transgenderist". For some reason it did not get posted under their comment.
mtfradgal 2 years ago
mtfradgal, I did reply to your comment but exceeded the 500 character limit and emailed you instead
P.s.
a CD or Crossdresser changes clothes,
a Transvestite gets excited about that,
a Transgenderist changes gender most revert, and a Transsexual changes sex to match the body and mind. :)
teneovestriexsisto 2 years ago
Brilliant and hilarious. I love Julia's transgressive and provocative truisms. She is a genius!
lff12 2 years ago
I think you must be sarcastically agreeing with someone else since I didn't say anything even remotely resembling that.
DNI12333 2 years ago
Your right you did not, I was refering to "the mixed messages" but while your on the subject I dont think she is unravelling anything, simply reacting to a world that has treated her so unkindly!
teneovestriexsisto 2 years ago
Still not sure I follow but okay. Unraveling is her word not mine and it was her use of it I was questioning, specifically in the context of the "just get over it" sentiment she expresses in the same piece. I'm not even sure that she means them to be seen as compatible but it comes off that way in the performance.
DNI12333 2 years ago
A Transsexual Actually! Hermaphrodites is an obsolete word and most individuals with the observable condition like to be regarded as Intersexed.
Hugs!
teneovestriexsisto 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is a Trangenderist, her statements are the very reason why Transsexuals have a hard time being understood in society, this individual wants to be accepted as female yet not give up the very thing that makes you so, unfortunately she is the butt of every joke and the saddest thing is that she doesnt realise it! But it sells books and it will be interesting to see her in ten years time.
teneovestriexsisto 2 years ago
You obviously don't have a clue about what a transsexual person is. She was BORN female in the place that matters the most... the brain. Her activism, including her books, are to help educate the public as to the true nature of transsexualism. To help overcome the negative stereotypes that have been many still believe. You also believe SRS is a must, well it is for many and it was for me, but that is not always the case. And transition takes time, she may be post-op now. Transgenderist=CD.
mtfradgal 2 years ago 28
Transsexualism was changed in 1994 to G.I.D. to separate people with from those that want!
teneovestriexsisto 2 years ago
Awesome speech! Gave me goose bumps.
smbikerchic 2 years ago 3
Absolutely awesome.
Otana 2 years ago 2
Wow. *clapclap*
spywez 2 years ago 2
I'm getting some mixed messages here. You can ask people to "get the fuck over it" or you can embrace the idea that you're unraveling traditional gender norms but I'm not sure the two are compatible, at least not in the same breath. I'm very much aware of the issues that trans people face and of the need for the rest of society to advance gender discourse, I'm just not sure this piece deals with that in an intelligent or effective way.
DNI12333 2 years ago
I'm a BADASS too!
Ukka68 2 years ago 2
Anyone at all, who has been touched in anyway by gender variance, or better yet, everyone period, should pay attention to Julia. She makes me laugh, cry, and know with no uncertainty that I'm stronger than anything that can ever happen to me. reading her book was watching every thought I've ever had articulated beautifully and shouted back to me. I used to be pretty sure I could do this. Now I know I'm a BADASS!!! thank you so much, sister.
Melissa0859 2 years ago 5
electric performance, and full of wonderful, terrible truth.
Ukka68 2 years ago 2
Amazing.
liaficheva 2 years ago 2
Loved, loved, loved it. :)
She's coming to our campus tomorrow to talk about Whipping Girl. I'm really excited.
kurjara 2 years ago 2
Some women have a penis, and some men don't. And the world is just going to have to get the fuck over it. LOVE that line!
SonicJMC 2 years ago 6
I've watched this video about 25 times over the last year and it never gets old. It's powerful because every freakin' word and emotion is TRUE. And "Whipping Girl" is a modern classic in gender studies. Thank you Julia!
mtfradgal 2 years ago 4
this is completely fucking amazing. i love her so much. whipping girl is one of the best things i've ever read.
kasperjonatan 2 years ago 14
I think what makes 'Whipping Girl' so good is the research. I agree it is an incredible book.
jessicabake2 2 years ago
@jessicabake2 It's more than the research. It's also one of my favorite books ever.
Aprinsa 1 year ago
Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.
mychaelblack 3 years ago 4
So very, very strong
eroticjames 3 years ago 3
Great video very well made and very well put Kiss Kiss.
torontoteddy62 3 years ago 2
Wow, this was capitvating to watch!
HGUFNH 3 years ago 3
She's amazing. Amazing. Amazing.
(Read Whipping Girl if you haven't)
ShaneWednesday 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
it doesnt take balls to remove it... it takes a lack of purpose in life..some one who is so COMPLETELY benine to any social fitting thats who removes it...and thats exactly why.. he couldnt handle it.. atleast gay guys keep it i have no problem with gay men. what do you label this creature..a man or a woman..you say a woman but what happens when you check the birth certificate or what about old family pictures. its so sad
TURKIYE5150 3 years ago
Creature? Interesting that you have to dehumanize her, that's what Hitler did to the Jews. She happens to be a writer, musician and spoken word artist and activist. Oh and birth certificates are amended. Benine is spelled benign and means "having a kindly disposition; gracious" I find ignorance sad. Not talent, intelligence and courage.
jessicabake2 3 years ago
I don't know if she knows how beautiful she is or what a good job she's doing, but I hope she does
g4ybar 3 years ago 38
Brilliant in both content and delivery.
RandalWithOneL 3 years ago 6
RIGHT ON, JULIA!!!
kayandkaycorp13 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
a man to woman kind huh...shows you women how powerful the cock is so respect it because some men cant even handle it and have to take ... learn from Shim !!
TURKIYE5150 3 years ago
Takes more balls to remove it than keep it. Don't you love irony?
jessicabake2 3 years ago
shes a genius
Xariabyron 3 years ago 5
eek, its in the post, exciting
PoorElbe 3 years ago
Having read Whipping Girl, all I can say to this is Julia, YOU FUCKING RULE!!!
RedstarChimera 3 years ago 3
Julia Serano is so awesome; love it!
Jayhawke 3 years ago 2
Im loving this
Ladyquintessence 3 years ago 2
ohhh this is really awesome...i got goosebumps
championtrout 3 years ago 2
Amen Sister....
syntaur 3 years ago 3
APPLAUSE! EXCELLENT PIECE!
moomay11649 3 years ago 3
I am reading her book "Whipping Girl" right now, very amazing read. Gets me ranting and raving just before bed every night. GOOD JOB JULIA!
bagelsandwiches8 4 years ago 2
I am left moist-eyed and shaking my head in near disbelief at how good this is. I am in the middle of her book Whipping Girl right now and love it, too.
jaseman816 4 years ago 4
lOVE THE PIECE ITS BRILLEANT
rebecca341 4 years ago
it's hard to make a drama of your own drama. She did it brilliantly
vonhatenfeld 4 years ago 3
this piece is soo good it gives me chills
toyletseat666 4 years ago 3
Julia ROCKS HARD!!! I absolutely love this piece; I would love to see some of her other spoken word too. It would also be awesome if her band, Bitesize had some of their songs up or some concert footage. She is a killa on tha mic !
toyletseat666 4 years ago 5
soo good.
robofabi 4 years ago 4