Man, I have to thank you very very much : first, for this cover (it's a long time since I've been looking for it, as the Melvins are sadly not so well-known in France) ; second for having brought me to Alex Grey and his art. I've just checked a little bit of his website, this is awesome !!!
syd was a joker when you compare his talent with roger waters so ill have to agree with other posters, the best thing syd did was go mad, to pave the way for roger and crew
although i do like this tune i guess it is because of the absence of the childish/ juvenile lyrics that syd normally writes .. the song bike being a laughable example
@MrSkunkd0c dude syd is awesome. too much of a genius. if he did not go mad there would be nothing he couldn't do. please dont speak bad about him. and he wouldn't charge 200 bucks for a ticket to his concert nowadays. like roger... also roger didn't try to write music untill he was forced by syd leaving.. just saying..
@AbortionsAreFun Live, i agree with you. In the Man and the Journey era, when they were still playing syd songs, but with Gilmour on guitar, was fantastic. I would've killed to have seen whatever the best five piece show was. KILLED.
The problem with The Pink Floyd was that they were just too wimpy. If it wasn't for Syd they would just be another complete stadium vomit turd band. Syd was a true genius and The Melvins have produced a CLASSIC cover here, what a legendary band they are. I would call this alternative because no one hardly knows it exists..and also most people cover crap from the sixties like the Kinks & Beatles, so this nice for a change. Long live the Mighty Melvins. Pink Floyd well meh.
I agree with your assertion about 99% of 60's covers being blase Beatles songs *yawn* , but I must make issue about your asserting that Floyd were "wimpy" . It's NOT their fault that the smaller , intimate venues closed their doors and stadium shows took-over ( circa 1970 ) .
If you like different versions ( I despise the term "cover" ) of classics , you should check out the Damned's version of Love's "Alone Again Or?" , and the Stooges' " I Feel Alright (1970)" .
Dude Pink Floyd made similiar stuff to this up to The Dark Side of the Moon. It wasn't all Syd. Live at Pompeii is a classic concert/film that sounds just like the Syd stuff.
@1401AndersonAve The greatest thing Syd did for the band was to leave, forcing the rest of the members, to step up and become leaders. Ummagumma wasn't that good, at least not the studio part, but it was an effort. Their live setlist during their transitional period (1968-1971) didn't contain much Syd material. Astronomy Domine and Interstellar Overdrive on some shows but it would be mostly improvised by Dave and Roger. After that they stumbled upon Meddle and the rest is history.
10 seconds in the clip and this looks promising.... 1 min in and I'm nodding in approval.... 3 mins and they're doing a pretty kick ass job.... "replay" dayummmmmmm
Alterna-crap? Hardly. Melvins play hardcore punk, stoner doom / sludge, and drone...but not very much alternative. They're pretty revolutionary when it comes to metal, so even if you think they suck, a lot of people look up to 'em.
I don't really agree. Torche (and by relation, Floor), Electric Wizard, Big Business, Soundgarden, Tool, Boris, and Mastodon are all good bands, and all love Melvins. Plus, with all good music you influence some shitty music, like Nirvana influencing Puddle of Mudd. It's not really their fault.
So, if you have a good idea, you should not follow through on it because a few people with a severely limited ability at having their own good ideas may be influenced. That's some sound logic.
Oh, so your comment had nothing to do with the actual song in the video that you were commenting on. Sorry, I'm such a twit I expected your comment to be on topic. My apologies.
@dinosaurjr420 Well you completely lost all credibility with that statement, seeing as AIC were one of the most renowned bands from the 90s, a lot more so than the Melvins or Dinosaur Jr.
it's not a cover. the melvins built a time machine in 1996 just for fun. notice how you never see footage of the melvins at the moment the planes hit the towers on 9/11. just what were they doing? obviously involved in black ops since the mangled demos. im keeping an eye on buzzo but he keeps calling the police and threatening to shoot me when i break into his house.
i m relatively new to melvins(dont know why) ad i was thinking interstellar overdrive...so this made me smile that they have a cover. no wonder about that..
I think this is quite possibly the greatest cover I've ever heard. I've always thought this song should be covered by a sludge band but had no idea that a cover of it actually existed.
Man, I have to thank you very very much : first, for this cover (it's a long time since I've been looking for it, as the Melvins are sadly not so well-known in France) ; second for having brought me to Alex Grey and his art. I've just checked a little bit of his website, this is awesome !!!
1981Badfish 2 weeks ago
Afuckenmazing!
ta2fiend 1 month ago
Smells like Nirvana !
KURA1117 3 months ago in playlist スラッジ
syd was a receiver of wisdom and the world was not ready for him
yerkil28 3 months ago
Melvins covering Pink Floyd? fuckin A XD
VladFerdinand1 3 months ago 2
Sick cover.
YoussefFishere 3 months ago
Alex Grey for the win, man.
YoussefFishere 3 months ago 3
Yea
neilembo55 4 months ago
They even did the channel-switching thing at 8:41. Awesome!
AgonizedCandle 5 months ago 2
Comment removed
AgonizedCandle 5 months ago
Comment removed
AgonizedCandle 5 months ago
Brave. Not for covering Floyd - for taking it deep into the stars.
sex6cult9revolution 6 months ago 4
Thanks Melvins, I was listening to the ending on my headphones and felt like I almost had a seizure! That can't be good for you....
MetroidFan621 7 months ago
Ledvana or Nir Zeplin? What's the name of this band?
PirateTravisJohnson1 8 months ago
@PirateTravisJohnson1 its actually Pink Melvins
MagicHetero 7 months ago 2
The cover is an art piece by Alex Grey. Hook him up his art is amazing!
knockdoun 9 months ago 3
@knockdoun If you look under the details I posted his website. Met Mr. Grey once before. Hes a good dude!
noonesremedy 9 months ago
MUH DICK
murphyhurtme 9 months ago
BONITO COVER
thesatanvlogs 9 months ago
is almost a copy but is art to make a copy of that, thank you
pardaleao 9 months ago 2
absolutely fantastic. RIP syd barret
brianwhover 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Alex grey tabs sheet, 4 hits a tab FTW
Klamron 1 year ago
Alex grey tabs sheet FTW
Klamron 1 year ago
alex grey!
bojanks15 1 year ago
good cover !
seweryne30 1 year ago
barret was a Fuckin genius , i´ll see you on the dark side of the moon syd :D
LowRider1500 1 year ago
They did a DAMNED good job with this !
DylanNotBob 1 year ago 2
I don't think Syd Barrett went mad
Everyone else did....
PhillipThunderGrunge 1 year ago 45
good cover but the stereo panning at the end kinda ruins it
Anth4400 1 year ago 2
@Anth4400 the stereo panning is in the original as well.
SomethingRules 1 year ago
Holy shit...
melvins+floyd+alex grey
Pink Floyd's been my favourite band for years
Got into Melvins after hearing MJK speak so highly of them in a tool video
and now I see they did a goddamn cover of a patgod song
I just had an orgasm.
AbortionsAreFun 1 year ago 4
I love the Melvins. But I only clicked on this song because I want to say Alex Grey is an outstanding artist!
bjvdrummer 1 year ago
a cover of pink floyd played by the melvisn with a picture of alex grey's artwork who makes the art for tool
melvins, tool, pink floyd
can it get any better?
AEthercraft 1 year ago 9
@AEthercraft only if all those three bands can share the stage together now that would be the best show on earth
jacobladders 1 year ago
Ownage
LordHarpoonKlutzer 1 year ago
Melvins will bring about the one world government. Finally!!!
Gumbyrearygood 1 year ago
great cover 5/5
reptil89 1 year ago
syd was a joker when you compare his talent with roger waters so ill have to agree with other posters, the best thing syd did was go mad, to pave the way for roger and crew
although i do like this tune i guess it is because of the absence of the childish/ juvenile lyrics that syd normally writes .. the song bike being a laughable example
MrSkunkd0c 1 year ago
@MrSkunkd0c dude syd is awesome. too much of a genius. if he did not go mad there would be nothing he couldn't do. please dont speak bad about him. and he wouldn't charge 200 bucks for a ticket to his concert nowadays. like roger... also roger didn't try to write music untill he was forced by syd leaving.. just saying..
GenMathis74 1 year ago 2
@MrSkunkd0c Roger had talent but most of his work sounded way too similar
The Wall and The Final Cut sounded like they should have been part of the same album
Floyd was at it's best shortly after syd but before roger took over (meddle, atom heart mother etc)
I like syd though because even though his lyrics and music may have been simple/childish it really could make a person feel so damn happy
AbortionsAreFun 1 year ago
@AbortionsAreFun Live, i agree with you. In the Man and the Journey era, when they were still playing syd songs, but with Gilmour on guitar, was fantastic. I would've killed to have seen whatever the best five piece show was. KILLED.
countvonjustin 10 months ago
god this is awesome lol
Jimihendrix6699 1 year ago
cool i never knew the melvins covered this
slippereal 1 year ago
f*ckin great !
acerb45666555 1 year ago
The Melvins have done this classic justice !
THIS IS BEAUTIFUL !!
I'm a fan of pre-1973 Pink Floyd , and especially of the Barrett-era P.F. ( 1965-1968 ) .
dexamyl 2 years ago
The problem with The Pink Floyd was that they were just too wimpy. If it wasn't for Syd they would just be another complete stadium vomit turd band. Syd was a true genius and The Melvins have produced a CLASSIC cover here, what a legendary band they are. I would call this alternative because no one hardly knows it exists..and also most people cover crap from the sixties like the Kinks & Beatles, so this nice for a change. Long live the Mighty Melvins. Pink Floyd well meh.
1401AndersonAve 2 years ago
I agree with your assertion about 99% of 60's covers being blase Beatles songs *yawn* , but I must make issue about your asserting that Floyd were "wimpy" . It's NOT their fault that the smaller , intimate venues closed their doors and stadium shows took-over ( circa 1970 ) .
If you like different versions ( I despise the term "cover" ) of classics , you should check out the Damned's version of Love's "Alone Again Or?" , and the Stooges' " I Feel Alright (1970)" .
dexamyl 2 years ago
y'all have to check out down's version of when the levee breaks....epic
seanbob24 1 year ago
@1401AndersonAve
Dude Pink Floyd made similiar stuff to this up to The Dark Side of the Moon. It wasn't all Syd. Live at Pompeii is a classic concert/film that sounds just like the Syd stuff.
ebaum1saik 1 year ago 2
@1401AndersonAve The greatest thing Syd did for the band was to leave, forcing the rest of the members, to step up and become leaders. Ummagumma wasn't that good, at least not the studio part, but it was an effort. Their live setlist during their transitional period (1968-1971) didn't contain much Syd material. Astronomy Domine and Interstellar Overdrive on some shows but it would be mostly improvised by Dave and Roger. After that they stumbled upon Meddle and the rest is history.
Art2Fly 1 year ago 2
I hate music. :P
alicemudgarden123 2 years ago 2
i hate you
zogrush 2 years ago
mmmm, good, as original... Chicken guitar!
dopietzsche 2 years ago
Really rad Cover of early Pink Floyd syd was great
Maninthebox21 2 years ago
i'll totally agree with you on this comment. always listen to what you want to.
just because a band was loved by 1,000,000 people doesn't make them good. its all opinion.
some bands just appeal to a wider audience.
but that doesn't mean you can't love bands like Nirvana and AIC. it just means you should love them by YOUR means, not someone else's.
90sCovers 2 years ago 3
@90sCovers well said, music is art and art is subjective.
dinosaurjr420 2 years ago
Fair enough, you listen to inferior music of your own accord. Is that better?
KurtInChains 2 years ago
fucking wicked syd would have loved this band
cookiemonstaman1 2 years ago
Not bad. Very syd-dave-roger-nick-rick!
FloydFan2010 2 years ago
its good but kinda noise too much and you cant make a cover f inter stellar overdrive couse it s just a improvsation
majinbunda 2 years ago
pink floyd forever.... nice cover
jesielopitecus 2 years ago 40
@jesielopitecus Good call, Equato.
TheVictoriousMarch 1 year ago
great choice for the Melvins
ex1le444 2 years ago 5
What a wonderful cover! They've done Syd proud!
duckman531 2 years ago
This is a pretty decent cover of the Pink Floyd. Don't see why anyone would complain. Good stuff.
kyokogodai 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its very HORRIBLE
LowRider1500 2 years ago
Great song done really well. I am impressed.
PizzaGod 2 years ago
I like the Alex Gray artwork on this clip.
LONG LIVE THE MELVINS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
helterskelter1178 2 years ago
God this is **MELVINS** the real music
nirvomind 2 years ago
10 seconds in the clip and this looks promising.... 1 min in and I'm nodding in approval.... 3 mins and they're doing a pretty kick ass job.... "replay" dayummmmmmm
emotivedonkey 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
These guys stink. Tell the guitar player to tune his instrument. More alterna-crap.
biglloyddobbs 2 years ago
Alterna-crap? Hardly. Melvins play hardcore punk, stoner doom / sludge, and drone...but not very much alternative. They're pretty revolutionary when it comes to metal, so even if you think they suck, a lot of people look up to 'em.
ACadaver 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Call the Melvins what you will, but the musical offspring they spawned, with the exception of Nirvana are just plain bad.
biglloyddobbs 2 years ago
I don't really agree. Torche (and by relation, Floor), Electric Wizard, Big Business, Soundgarden, Tool, Boris, and Mastodon are all good bands, and all love Melvins. Plus, with all good music you influence some shitty music, like Nirvana influencing Puddle of Mudd. It's not really their fault.
ACadaver 2 years ago 4
So, if you have a good idea, you should not follow through on it because a few people with a severely limited ability at having their own good ideas may be influenced. That's some sound logic.
Gumbyrearygood 2 years ago
lol this is a cover of a song from the 60s. Hardly alternative.
happypranksgiving 2 years ago
I know it's a Pink Floyd/Syd Barrett era cover, it's the Melvins I'm referring, you twit. What's the alternative to alternative?
biglloyddobbs 2 years ago
Oh, so your comment had nothing to do with the actual song in the video that you were commenting on. Sorry, I'm such a twit I expected your comment to be on topic. My apologies.
happypranksgiving 2 years ago
damn i cant believe it....melvins u really did it with this i never thought u were that good
MatobecerrO 2 years ago
its a cover of a pink floyd song
slideon 2 years ago
i know that.... i said that i cant believe it that there were that good becoz of the song they chose to cover...
MatobecerrO 2 years ago
true
slideon 2 years ago
see! :)
MatobecerrO 2 years ago
Really nice. :)
Mialje 2 years ago
Comment removed
Epsilon15 2 years ago
I don't think the Melvins have ever covered a song and not improved it in some way, shape, or form.
dinosaurjr420 2 years ago
besides this one
JesusFan666 2 years ago
Sorry, you can't improve on Interstellar Overdrive. It's a good cover but the orginal will always be the best.
KurtInChains 2 years ago
and this is coming from a nirvana fan... ha hahahahaha
dinosaurjr420 2 years ago
Sadly I don't listen to Nirvana anymore, so your attempt at an insult failed completely.
KurtInChains 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
easy enough... AIC are even more boring!
dinosaurjr420 2 years ago
@dinosaurjr420 Well you completely lost all credibility with that statement, seeing as AIC were one of the most renowned bands from the 90s, a lot more so than the Melvins or Dinosaur Jr.
KurtInChains 2 years ago
They captured the essence and sound of that era real well. Doesn't sound like a modern band doing it at all.
swans1997 2 years ago
awfuckinsome!!!! I bet Syd would love this!
Trgr66 2 years ago
This is insanity I love the Melvins and the Piper.
halfcabdisaster7 2 years ago
What a jam.
CVargas 2 years ago
Finally a band that has the balls to cover this psychotic babble. Great cover!
dickrobot 2 years ago
it's not a cover. the melvins built a time machine in 1996 just for fun. notice how you never see footage of the melvins at the moment the planes hit the towers on 9/11. just what were they doing? obviously involved in black ops since the mangled demos. im keeping an eye on buzzo but he keeps calling the police and threatening to shoot me when i break into his house.
jonnyrocketballs69 2 years ago 113
Hey, they also had been there when Kennedy was shot!
FrozenSnake999 2 years ago
Are u serious?
Trgr66 2 years ago
lmao that's grand
alistermbouvart 2 years ago
Melvins will bring about the one world government. Finally!!!
Gumbyrearygood 1 year ago
@jonnyrocketballs69 kara
streets1390 1 year ago
LMFAO thats what i believe as well
snoogans9 1 year ago
@jonnyrocketballs69 you can see Buzzos face and hair in the debris of the plane hitting the first tower...
ladyintheradiator187 10 months ago
@jonnyrocketballs69 you`re kinda stoned, don`t you ?
costin12 10 months ago 2
electric wizard has. live though. its a cool cover.
weedmanman420 2 years ago
Check out Psychic Tv's cover of "Set The Controls"...
swans1997 2 years ago
It's the perfect song for the Melvins to cover.
ChickenPissInTheRoad 2 years ago
They really do this song well.
They keep it fucking real here man.
Bossk14 2 years ago 2
ABSOLUTELY!
Trgr66 2 years ago
Comment removed
animal90sFreak5 2 years ago
WOW.
melvins. interstellar overdrive. what else is there to say?
again, wow. this is like the best thing i've ever heard
HammarHeart 2 years ago 2
Awesome.
AlbertMondback 2 years ago
yeahh..this smell like kundalini..
COCKSHIT3 2 years ago
I never noticed it with the original, but the first notes sound a lot like "I Can See for Miles."
KonradAdenauer 2 years ago
This is the way a cover should sound - FREAKIN' AWESOME!
Syd DEFINITELY would have dug it!
xbxbear 3 years ago 2
jack evans
roderick strong
austin aries
matt sydal
armandmax 3 years ago
awesome!I have this on a huge FLAC Syd disc,just heard it yesterday!Fuck yeah,rightous!
paisleybabee 3 years ago
love it.
SocialDeviant77 3 years ago
syd barrett would have looooved this if he heard it
jacobladders 3 years ago 5
Syd's smiling... This is plugged in...
xbxbear 3 years ago 3
i m relatively new to melvins(dont know why) ad i was thinking interstellar overdrive...so this made me smile that they have a cover. no wonder about that..
jorninorion 3 years ago
I think this is quite possibly the greatest cover I've ever heard. I've always thought this song should be covered by a sludge band but had no idea that a cover of it actually existed.
HVF12 3 years ago
Psychic Tv did a killer cover of "Set The Controls"... Very good, check it out .
swans1997 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There is a really great video interview of the Melvins at serenedominic. com
SerenityNow67 3 years ago
purely awesome
emotivedonkey 3 years ago
Best cover ever.
onephiftyone 3 years ago 6