Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (412)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Do you still have no sheets for the video of "Secret (Jay Chou)"?

    I would really wanna play that also :)

  • Check out oReallyGT , same song but sounds a bit different. And quality is kinda bad.

  • 四手联弹的竟然可以一个人演奏?厉害啊

  • Comment removed

  • Check out Piano Battle with Andreas Kern & Paul Cibis :-)

  • it's well done for something played by ear, I noticed a few mistakes such as the left hand playing a little early around the 12th measure (0:33) it should still be F Ab C D E D C but you played D# F# A C F# C A F #. But this is splendid simply marvelous for someone who played by ear. Bravo.

  • last note and pedal ruined it.. but well done

  • @thegreatsze can you make a tutorial for this?PLS?! .. T^T

  • I can listen this melody repeatly whole day~

  • What is the title of this music>>??

  • i see the foot of lu xiao yu standing beside you :D

  • the best song from the best movie

  • 好聽~~雖然中間頓了一下

    不過還是覺得很好聽

  • diep respect!

  • I know right, best piece evar.

  • so brilliant...

  • uwaah. i'm jealous T^T

  • best song of the moive

    <3

    thank u so much for posting this 

  • If possible... I wish that i can have the sheets of this xD

  • You play this piece nicely. Just don't use the pedal to much next time ;)

  • Makes my heart quiver every time I hear this song.

  • 你的瘦太僵硬了,感觉要抽筋

  • wonderful :D

  • Great job modifying the piece to fit two hands but it is possible to play the original score with two hands. Just do it the way u do it now, then when the quavers for the right hand comes in, play octaves for the first note. thts how i play it. =] but Great job anyway (Y)

  • @platinumclawify haha yeah. i have done a more accurate version - you can see it in my videos (I think it's called "piano view" or something like that).

  • Nice! I wish I can play like you...

  • let go of the pedal every half bar makes it sound nicer

  • you have the sheet music for your improved version?

  • nice one. good job! =]

  • good job!

  • can you send me the music sheet of this piece pls

  • sheet music?

  • actually it's very hard ( more like impossilbe 4 me) to play exactly the every note of the original piece with just ur 2 hands :( so we need a cover :D awwwrw i can never be over this song !

  • lawl, i loved how you played the left hand. :) I thought this would be a duet but. You made it sound so pretty <3

  • A beautiful song. i agree wif u(:

  • good job :) I can play it too but it took a lot of practice (esp. with the left hand)

  • This is by far my favorite piece in that movie though. It's so touching just from the beginning till the end, along with the orchestra. Ahhh, so beautiful at 0:52...

  • a bit of edit done but rly good nonetheless

  • omg!!!! i finally found it! at school one of my guy friend was playing this song, and he said it was in this movie called secret.. and i saw that movie before, and i only saw the beggining of it though. never saw the ending, but i heard that the girl died.. and jay chou traveled back through time??? i tototally want to see the ending!! and i was looking everywhere what song this was cfause i didn't know what my friend said this piano song was called. THANK GOSH I FOUND THIS!!

  • u forrgot one key there ryt? xD

  • your skill for being able to play that duet yourself and make it sound so natural is amazing, i praise you.

  • pretty good for playing by ear

  • Where do u get the music sheet/?? =D

  • @kevinho102334 he didn't, he played it by ear.

  • @xKuyaEx He is amazing!!

  • wow you playing tenths? my fingers can't reach

  • 2hands ftw! grads

  • 2 hand 0.0

  • man, this song made me cry when i was thinking about my girl, and i suddenly heard this song.. 5 stars

  • Love it !

  • I can play with two hands too . Thinking of uploading . Its different .

  • yes i'm jealous...haha.

  • Direct influence of Bach, yet still a nice melody. This is very good song especially the melody. Keep it up man. You & Jay Chou.

  • do you have this piano sheet music?

  • pro....

  • it funny when u put u thumbs up :D

  • racist!

  • not bad.....pedal is a bit much...

  • @jgsky maybe is due to 3 hands convert to 2 hands need to drag the sound a bit longer for him to react or reach the next note =]

  • best song :)

  • As well as this version, which other Lu Xiao Yu videos on Youtube can be played with 2 hands?

    Also is there any sheet music for this version?

  • just look for ones where one person is playing...

  • Nice taste

  • hmm...i'm learning it too, i'm stuck at the melody in 0:50+

  • omg i loveeee this song =)

    and da movie was great tho

  • i just love terdsak's music. so beautiful and terdy.

  • wow! you did the left hand all by yourself! xD

  • talesincs, ur mom is basic.

  • @liquidCocaine24 wad did I say? I forgot

  • @TalesIncs It's not about how complex or basic it is... it's how good the end result is.

  • how long did u take to learn this piece? O:

  • Great! => favorite, +5*

  • i cant move my left hand so quickly up and down the scale.... im so jealous...

  • true of the best piece... or at least my favorite....

    plus you did a great job in performing it....

  • true this was the best piece...or at least it was my favorite.....

    you did a great job performing it too!!!

  • lol wow....how old is you? lol

  • Pretty fancy left hand work there

  • aww, that was so beautiful, but you killed it with the thumbs up

  • I love it!!

    now i'm practice this song by learning from u

    thank you very much

  • It was ok, but you should let go of the pedal more, cuz it's making it sound messy

  • yeah, thumbs up.. teach me hehe

  • very good and beautiful performing tnx

  • i agree that this was one of the best pieces from the film 'secret'

    - i love the way you played it, beautiful ! ^^

  • biauthiful song <3

  • does anyone know what lu xiao yu means? i know xiao yu means rain

  • Lu Xiaoyu is the name of the main female character, Jay Chou's love interest in the movie Secret :)

  • Xiao Yu mean rain. And the lu itself means road. So, I think Lu Xiao Yu means light rain on a road.

  • Actually, Lu Xiao Yu is the name of the main female character in the movie.

  • I know ;) But one person was asking what is the meaning of her name :)

  • and her name means rain

  • hey there, do u have the sheets for this??

  • 3手的都能彈,強

  • That...brought tears to my eyes. Beautiful playing and beautiful music....

    Secret was one movie that made me cry even too much for a girl. You were admirable...

  • wow, that was good

  • THEGREATSZE FTW. :D

  • my biggest fan :)

  • @thegreatsze could you show how to do that bit...like the 0:43-1:20? please cause the camera went to the side and it was hard to see.

  • its different then the one i played.

  • that's no fair how you played that song with only two hands. I wish I could do that

  • It can be played by duet or solo.For solo all i can say is PRactise makes perfect (:

  • There's part that sound like The Dandelion's Promise, which is good :)

  • 0:51.. onwards is the best part..

  • OMG. yu donee relii well ^^ foh liek...3 hands..i been trying 2 figure it out~ ^^

  • my finger was short :( cant play nicely T_T

  • whats the title..??..

    do u have the piano sheet for this song???

  • he got this by ear not by finding sheets and playing it off of it

  • awesome.. nice play.. ^^

  • omg !!! This version is really different from the original but it's much better

  • have you got the score for this version of (jay chou secret  lu xiaoyu)?

  • reminds me of Final fantasy 6

  • one word....Amazing!

  • wrong chord.......

  • Talented, I can listen to this everyday :D

  • i mean three

  • wow! nice. most ppl play with two ppl.. lols!

  • cool!!!! lovely!;)

  • awesome...

  • ZOMG..awwhh..i cant really played tis song..my fingers are short..and my 5th finger is weak..so there are a lot of scores i cant really play..

  • i love it

    i think its the best song of the movie too!!

    although all the songs were amazing!

  • WAY COOL!!!!

  • nicee

  • Hmm..it almost sounds like Zelda's theme song for a little bit lol

  • Yeah that's true ! :D

  • LOL! you're right!!

  • you are amazing!

  • nice post at the end of the video lol

  • This song very well I like much thanks for the video and your it beams with the piano

  • for some reason, you look like my cousin

  • Wonderful adaptation for 2 hands, great to know it can be done that way and still sound beautiful, gotta learn it now.

  • beautiful well done im trying to play this too by myself im almost done yours is good though

  • super!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111

  • love it! =)

  • you are incredible ^_____^

  • very beautiful, thx for posting!

  • omgg ur amazingg=]

  • man props dude you're so awesome!!! i want to get a piano and learn to play that song now!! lmao but seriously you're awesome!

  • great playing, and love the piano! cristofori :D

  • Amazing! meant for 3 hands but adapted to 2? that's great, good job! i've been learning this song too, and this really helped, thanks

  • Woah dang I almost learned it by watching this vid, man make anotherone too but name it lu xiao yu tutorial and play slower and you will be praised lol.

  • As you mentioned,This piece is actually a duet for three hands. you've adapted it for two ...

    How did you managed that?

  • beautiful :) i fall in love this song... where you get sheet music?

  • What? 彈錯非常多? Its music nicely played, just enjoyed it and stop criticizing! I like it alot. Good job. ^^

  • you're awesome!!!!

    Just curious, how long have you been playing piano?

  • omg! you're so awesome! How long have you been playing piano?

  • hey~ is a gd piano piece~ would u mind send me the piano sheet in someway~~! thz ~!

  • the left hand part is so fun to play :D

  • its crazy taht you can play this will only 2 hands! :P

  • so hai

  • 我喜欢这首歌这么多 3这是我的最爱

  • 这么多 **

  • i wonder why all those chinese lalas wanna give him a bad comment about this song. so what he if 彈錯非常多ㄟ. i got no idea what that means lol. he is still the best one i'd hear =D

    keep up the good work

  • yeah u r good~

  • holy u got it by ear?!

  • very good!

  • perfect...

  • can i have the score in abc's for this song please?

  • 不要挑毛病

  • im in love with this song !!!

  • I thought this can only play by two persons =P my left hand cannot turn that fast xD...

    uue are so good in playing it.. jia you =D

  • how i wish this was longer..(sigh) such a beautiful piece..u did it justice

  • I love watching everyone do their own take on this song. Their each different and they all sound good.

  • He plays it differently than I would. I have different sheet music, apparently.

  • HmongYou2tube, i already know the movie name thank you very much. i was asking the song name title and oh by the way i cannot find it that's why i asked cause i wanted to download it.

  • WOW! UR SOO GOOD!

  • omg i learned this whole song!

    haha by looking at your video and hearing!

    ahah

    its an awesome song..haha

  • Very beautiful and sweet. do you know were to get the song from and the name please?

  • Jay Chou Secret. Lu Xaio Yu. Geeez.. Use your eyes sometimes..

  • Beautiful ^^

  • Good:) But the rythm is too fast..lol

  • I think its about right. Using my ears.

  • Sorry, can u make another video but play it more slowly >P

  • nice arrangement :]

  • added to favorite :D

  • Nice.but I am feeling giddy after watching the video

  • That guy is fucking good! He learned by ear. That can be ME!!! AHAH! YES! THat means I can too! wooo hoo!

  • 謝你的影片!!  我學會了^^