This was my first "classical music" I ever listened to with full concentration, thanks to our teacher for music. Unfortunatelyx he died to early in a motor cycle crash.
AS much as I enjoy this rendition (& I *really* do) I prefer the ones where its played just a tad slower. I know it may seem pedantic, but that slight reduction in tempo really brings out the juxtaposition between the oboe & violin. Do try & seek out other versions & hopefully you'll see what I mean :)!
@NymphetamineVille Seriously-a 6 y.o violin student learning the Suzuki Method could make Andre Rieu look bad. Rieu's great skill is in mass marketing, not musical talent! He is the Musack of the classical music world-only slightly more grating!
that version is a transcription of the violin/oboe double concerto that bach included with his series of keyboard concertos. So, this version is the original.
whats the deal with this concerto? Searching for the sheet i found several "bwv 1060" but they´re concertos for TWO CEMBALOS AND STRINGS, and the music is the same, but with both cembalos playing trebble and bass clef (chords and melody)
So wth? who made the arrangement for violin and oboe? when did this version became popular?
1060 is a double harpsichord concerto. Most likely, this arrangement came into being from the double violin concerto manuscript (now known as 1060R), which almost assuredly existed in an original form (as Bach, and composers of that time rarely wrote double concertos with opposing instruments - the said Oboe/Violin Concerto). We also have to remember the cataloguing came AFTER Bach and is a modern system. That being said, it's a nice version.
ever since i began playing violin in the 3rd grade i have always sped songs up in my practice. i'm happy to see i'm not the only one who loves to do this and loves to hear the music this way. i just wish i was as good as mr. kennedy.
J'ai écouté de trés nombreux enrgistrements de ce concerto et il n'y a rien à faire cette version est la meilleure qui existe. On y retrouve toute la force, la puissance, la beauté et la majesté de Bach. Les autres versions sont soit trop "gnangnantes", soit à coté de la plaque. Toutes mes félicitations. C'est sublime.
I played this at a competition this morning--we got the best score possible, but that's not the point. The judge said that we had a good interpretation of the piece. Haha. We basically copied the dynamics and stuff from this video.
I like this movement at this tempo. I have no problem with it. I do however have a problem with their 2nd and 3rd movements. They were definitely way too fast.
this is more than music. it is hard to explain what i feel, i just know this is real. while listening to this composition, i am actually flying into a star. simply enjoying.
It's just faster than you expected. Bach never fixed any speeds anyway. Just take it as another interpretation. Perhaps after a while, you might get used to this speed and perhaps appreciate variety. :) Cheers.
it is not meant to be in c minor in fact i guess you are from USA but if you see most of the preformances are in d minor in Europe and world so... and it really sounds better in D
the only thing i do not care for about the c minor version is ending on nasty (for the oboe) middle c at pretty much every cadence. for that (entirely selfish) reason alone, i prefer d minor... also easier for violinists as there are less flats.
This is beautifully performed...Nigel Kennedy is a great violinist .... I saw him perform Elgars Violin Concerto Last night on BBC2 at the Proms .... Remarkable performance it was !!!
Great job, except for the added doop-dads on the oboist's part. I love her sound, but I hate doop-dads with a passion! The composer didn't need any help writing the score!
What you call "doop-dads" are called ornaments, which are a natural feature of the Baroque landscape. The fact that the composer didn't write in an ornament is not evidence that he did not intend one to be played.
I speak to truth. Playing Bach at a uniform faster than cultural tempi simply has the effect of uniforming the music away from its artistic merit. While the technique of the artists and orchestra is to be admired, where is das kunst!
oh my god his neck
calebaren 21 hours ago
This was my first "classical music" I ever listened to with full concentration, thanks to our teacher for music. Unfortunatelyx he died to early in a motor cycle crash.
kareliabear 3 months ago
hahahahaah the woman flute like a fool
aghaanantyab 8 months ago
the BWV number is wrong, the BWV 1060 is the C minor concert for 2 Harpsichords and strings (one of my favorites by the way ^^)
necrotemor 1 year ago
@necrotemor
study and then make comments, the number is correct.
andreskamps 1 year ago
@necrotemor Not true.
lasepsisofi 10 months ago
@necrotemor >the BWV number is wrong,
Note that the number is BWV 1060R where "R" stands for "reconstruction".
VERITS99 7 months ago
C'est mieux,que 3ème mouvement!!!!
andy66100 1 year ago
They play a lot!!!!! Simply fantastic!
cellosnake 1 year ago
e io taccio, estasiato
robisamar 1 year ago
Perfect!. I love it! :)
Iga24031981 1 year ago
Perfect!. I love it!
Iga24031981 1 year ago
I really like this faster version. Does anyone know where I can find a higher quality (audio) recording of this performance?
Edootjuh 1 year ago
@Edootjuh
Listen to this music with Trevor Pinnock.
You tube - Bach - BWV 1060
migrando2 1 year ago
Great
(but try to avoid the following movements)
IlIlIlIlIIlI 1 year ago
@IlIlIlIlIIlI Why...? 3rd movement is awesome...
vikibarac 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@IlIlIlIlIIlI Why...? 3rd movement is awesome..
vikibarac 1 year ago
This is fabulous - thanks!
VallisDavies 1 year ago
I thought partitia is great, but this is just better from bach.
ildr2003 1 year ago
AS much as I enjoy this rendition (& I *really* do) I prefer the ones where its played just a tad slower. I know it may seem pedantic, but that slight reduction in tempo really brings out the juxtaposition between the oboe & violin. Do try & seek out other versions & hopefully you'll see what I mean :)!
MrHicks091 1 year ago
@NymphetamineVille Seriously-a 6 y.o violin student learning the Suzuki Method could make Andre Rieu look bad. Rieu's great skill is in mass marketing, not musical talent! He is the Musack of the classical music world-only slightly more grating!
MrHicks091 1 year ago
I always thought something is missing with Andre Rieu. After looking at Nigel Kennedy, I finally know. Thanks for pointing it out!
walkingon2001 1 year ago
@walkingon2001 What would that be-musical talent? ;)
MrHicks091 1 year ago
@walkingon2001 What would that be-musical talent? ;)
MrHicks091 1 year ago
@MrHicks091 yup, can't agree less! I really hope to attend one of his concerts live.
walkingon2001 1 year ago
o my gosh, this is beautifully played, I nearly cried!
walkingon2001 1 year ago
This is an absolutely spot-on performance. I am intimately familiar with this piece and by far this is the best rendition I have heard to date.
CembaloMeister 2 years ago
I listened to this last night...
it was so beautiful! *_*
newFranzFerencLiszt 2 years ago 2
that version is a transcription of the violin/oboe double concerto that bach included with his series of keyboard concertos. So, this version is the original.
interyeti 2 years ago
whats the deal with this concerto? Searching for the sheet i found several "bwv 1060" but they´re concertos for TWO CEMBALOS AND STRINGS, and the music is the same, but with both cembalos playing trebble and bass clef (chords and melody)
So wth? who made the arrangement for violin and oboe? when did this version became popular?
leandrusi 2 years ago
inculte
Mikujo 2 years ago
you are ;)
leandrusi 2 years ago
1060 is a double harpsichord concerto. Most likely, this arrangement came into being from the double violin concerto manuscript (now known as 1060R), which almost assuredly existed in an original form (as Bach, and composers of that time rarely wrote double concertos with opposing instruments - the said Oboe/Violin Concerto). We also have to remember the cataloguing came AFTER Bach and is a modern system. That being said, it's a nice version.
musicmatt09 2 years ago
you automatically fall in love with that wonderful music: "when angels praise god, they play Bach, but in their spare time they play Mozart."
mightybassman1 2 years ago
hmmm. and beethoven
aweitzer1 2 years ago
Love both!
Amazing!
koliatima 2 years ago
ever since i began playing violin in the 3rd grade i have always sped songs up in my practice. i'm happy to see i'm not the only one who loves to do this and loves to hear the music this way. i just wish i was as good as mr. kennedy.
dave240vert 2 years ago
great piece, thank you!
Cppinne 2 years ago
1:00
amwlhzll 2 years ago
I got the C minor version and sounds greeeat, D minor sounds screechy on violin
wirmike 2 years ago
Magnifique, wonderful, ausgezeichnet
Sarmizegetusa 2 years ago 2
Thank you for sharing the beauty of this marvellous music and video.
stlivermore 2 years ago
une splendeur de tous les instants !!
robynsalain 2 years ago
Ich fühle mich der Abschied in der ganzen Orchester und Oboist und Geiger alle, dass,, es ist dunkel Stück der Tat
whomakemefeel 3 years ago
J'ai écouté de trés nombreux enrgistrements de ce concerto et il n'y a rien à faire cette version est la meilleure qui existe. On y retrouve toute la force, la puissance, la beauté et la majesté de Bach. Les autres versions sont soit trop "gnangnantes", soit à coté de la plaque. Toutes mes félicitations. C'est sublime.
yam88120 3 years ago
I played this at a competition this morning--we got the best score possible, but that's not the point. The judge said that we had a good interpretation of the piece. Haha. We basically copied the dynamics and stuff from this video.
jasonfu6699 3 years ago
I like this movement at this tempo. I have no problem with it. I do however have a problem with their 2nd and 3rd movements. They were definitely way too fast.
oboeplayar 3 years ago
Bach is awesome
ugahur 3 years ago 24
@ugahur violin vs oboe
aghaanantyab 8 months ago
At this tempo, it sounds like a bit like Vivaldi -not a bad thing, in my judgment.
polymath7 3 years ago 3
this is more than music. it is hard to explain what i feel, i just know this is real. while listening to this composition, i am actually flying into a star. simply enjoying.
p.s. yes, its supposed to be this fast, why not.
tahcion 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Too fast and what the hell is Nigella Lawson doing playing the oboe? Sweet music from the bosom but not quite right
hiodori 3 years ago
holy crap is this supposed to be this fast?
jasonfu6699 3 years ago
It's just faster than you expected. Bach never fixed any speeds anyway. Just take it as another interpretation. Perhaps after a while, you might get used to this speed and perhaps appreciate variety. :) Cheers.
waihoong11 2 years ago
i swear this is meant to be in c minor, sounds like d minor to me
AytidaRed 3 years ago
it is not meant to be in c minor in fact i guess you are from USA but if you see most of the preformances are in d minor in Europe and world so... and it really sounds better in D
marindrinov 3 years ago
A) i am from the UK
B) Bach wrote it in C minor
C) I have played it in C minor
AytidaRed 3 years ago
you are right ! I have the c minor on sheet music. I hear it more these days in d minor. Strange.
lentosy 3 years ago
weird. mine is in D minor.
Are you sure you don't have an arrangement?
jasonfu6699 3 years ago
completely sure
AytidaRed 3 years ago
the only thing i do not care for about the c minor version is ending on nasty (for the oboe) middle c at pretty much every cadence. for that (entirely selfish) reason alone, i prefer d minor... also easier for violinists as there are less flats.
chroboe 3 years ago
I don't have an arrangement, it's the original i'm sure!
AytidaRed 3 years ago
For someone with a reputation for being "out there", Nigel Kennedy's playing is all class in this concerto. The oboist is fabulous.
MerlinTheDraconic 3 years ago
I call this class
talkingheadfromhere 3 years ago
lindo....apaixonante.
ra1nha 3 years ago
beautiful~!
musicStoneD 3 years ago
lovebachlovebachlovebachlovebachlove...
7yvy 3 years ago 17
....
:)
BachLoveNat 3 years ago
metooemtooemtooemtooemtooemtoo
musicStoneD 3 years ago
This is beautifully performed...Nigel Kennedy is a great violinist .... I saw him perform Elgars Violin Concerto Last night on BBC2 at the Proms .... Remarkable performance it was !!!
livesteam 3 years ago 2
Great job, except for the added doop-dads on the oboist's part. I love her sound, but I hate doop-dads with a passion! The composer didn't need any help writing the score!
genmaximus110 3 years ago
What you call "doop-dads" are called ornaments, which are a natural feature of the Baroque landscape. The fact that the composer didn't write in an ornament is not evidence that he did not intend one to be played.
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
I was about to say that all Nigels are freaks, but then I forgot about Sir Nigel Gresley the British designer of first class steam locomotives.
3NUNS 3 years ago
the man who turns all things bach into irish jigs
3NUNS 3 years ago 3
LOLOL! You're killing me here!
The30YearOldVirgin 3 years ago
I speak to truth. Playing Bach at a uniform faster than cultural tempi simply has the effect of uniforming the music away from its artistic merit. While the technique of the artists and orchestra is to be admired, where is das kunst!
3NUNS 3 years ago 2
die Kunst
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
If you hate it so much, why watch it?
NintendoHarryPotter 3 years ago
its german idiot
fritten00 3 years ago
Love both! but because I´m oboist too, I love her! fantastic, amazing!
Oboeia 3 years ago
Tolle Musik, tolles Duett, tolles Orchester, tolle Akustik. Einfach alles da für ein Super Konzert!
ichmalealsobinich 4 years ago
IT'S SOOOOOOO BEAUTIFUL!
Many thanks to my friend Alban from Canada
for sending it to me :)
LOVE TO YOU!
BachLoveNat 4 years ago
Thank you Nat - very much !
jurek46pink 3 years ago
totally rockin' !
Da5h1t 4 years ago
super
eisfree 4 years ago
Wunderschön, kein Kommentar!
Romaenli 4 years ago
omg amazing!!!
scuffmcgruff86 4 years ago
Thanks for posting!
marindrinov 4 years ago