Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (394)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I hope to meet her one day and sing for her. She has the most amazing voice and performer!

  • Not only is she STUNNINGLY beautiful, but she has the most amazing voice I have ever heard. How she didn't win I will never understand. Haley's voice cuts straight to your soul and its amazing!!!!!

  • SHE SHOULD'VE WON! NOT SCOTTY!

  • No one else ever interpreted this song this way and I didn't like the original version, but this was pure magic, best performance of 2011. Sheryl was right, Steven was right, J-Lo was right and Randy was right. Amazingly done, couldn't have been better.

  • It's driving me mad that people are coming here saying this pip guy is better

    This is Haley's very unique arrangement

    It's so very different than it had ever been done before then

    It was her idea to start slow and build up the song, put a bluesy feel to it and so on...

    Then this pip guy comes along and sings it EXACTLY the same way

    So how can he be better??

    Like seriously WTF

  • Pip is better

  • @megbarnes44 Really? Doubt it he will be around all that long to prove your factoid!

  • This is one of the few Idol performances I've ever heard that actually left me speechless. All I could come up with is 'holy shit!'. Her rendition of Benny and the Jets was fantastic, and (I feel) much better than Sir Elton's, but this song blew me away.

  • BECAUSE IT'S UNBELIEVABLE!!!!

    THAT'S WHY!!!

  • She's taken a bluesy classic and turned it into an over-sung, over-produced chunk of plastic. Why is anyone applauding this bollocks?

  • @enterthekraken I guess after you listen to the muppets there ain't anything that could sound good.

  • @enterthekraken I've never heard a version like hers before. And it's irrelevant if someone has done it before, Haley did an excellent job.

  • the judges got it all wrong.............that wasnt the best performance of the night...........it was the best performance in idol history! WE LOVE YOU HALEY!

  • I got the chills listening to this. Thats what I call talent.

  • I'm gay, but i find myself extremely attracted to her and that sexxxxxy voice

  • Someone sang this on The Voice recently, and it just reminded me how wrong it was that she didn't win.

  • Haley should have won. She was by far the best one on the show.

  • Man, do you see her face as the applause died down, she was ready to get reamed by the judges T_T They were so mean to her every week!

  • She has the looks, they personality, and most importantly the amazing voice to get her anywhere she wants to go in life. No doubt in my mind she would've won last year if a bunch of teen girls and rednecks wouldn't have voted so many times.

  • thumbs up if this is about the 7th time this video was reset to zero once it hit 500,000 views

  • UGH SHE SHOULD HAVE WON... NOT STUPID SCOTTY MC-WHATEVERTHEFUCK

  • 0:45  - dem goosebumps..

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • This is weird for me to say because I'm a guy, but I got chill bumps... she is incredible

  • FLAWLESS!

  • Top that class of 2012

    good luck with that

  • take that gaga, natural and amazing and spontaneous choreography

  • i was hoping she was out every week until this performance. Then i wanted her to win...or at least get runner up.

  • 1:40 to 1:47 is sooooo good

    damn

  • FOR EVERYONE WHO FINDS THAT HALEY REINHARTS VOICE IS MUCHHHH BETTER THAN J-LO'S !!!

  • In my opinion this is the BEST version of The House of the Rising Sun!

  • why are you so amazing?

    *takes voice, and rocking it*

  • She has my shape.

  • She is a goddess. No one can ever replace her. <3

  • Comment removed

  • sucha sensational quality to her voice...aside from the incredible talent...!!...hit repeat....lol

  • definitely, she's a winner in my heart !

  • i dont care what the votes say, she won

  • Ok i dont get why you people keep syaing that teenagers were the cause of scottys win...im a teen and i had all my votes go to haley...of course im a guy so that might be a factor =D GO HALEY I LOVE U!!

  • This performance by Miss Haley Reinhart was epic. This performance alone should have won Haley the crown. Haley is PERFECTION!!!!!!!!!

  • why is this video is always, always brought down once it gets the 1 millionth mark!? irritating it should have been 2M + now. :(

  • How the hell did Scotty win when she could of won!?

  • @msdizzywoodaccounts How win like Scotty:

    1-Get tween vote

    2-Show how Christian an american you are

    3-Sing the same every week: tweens won't notice

    Simple, isn't it?

  • HEY AMERICA....CAN YOU GET BACK ON TRACK AND VOTE FOR TALENT LIKE YOU DID DURING THE FIRST SEASON.....THIS YOUNG LADY WAS THE WHOLE PACKAGE BUT YET SOME GUY WHO SINGS COUNTRY MUSIC AND SOUNDS LIKE EVERY OTHER GUY SINGING COUNTRY MUSIC WINS?......PATHETIC......

  • if Haley is reading this. Dont let that dumbass jealous Diva, J-Lo, chase you away from your dream... YOU ARE FANTASTIC!!

  • this is pretty much the best idol performance ever.

  • Comment removed

  • ive seen every episode and this IS the best performance of a son ive ever seen.

  • Stunning! She should have won.

  • She should have won this bitch! she has everything!

  • CHILLS...

  • this was THE moment of American Idol Season 10... "hands down" (as Randy would say)

  • Whatever! I guess America likes country bumpkins like Scotty and Lauren that much! Whatever!

  • the animals covered this , can't remember who wrote it

  • 0:08

  • I'm like in love with the way she sings this song <3

    she's amazing

  • How did she not win whatever season she was on?! She sang "House of the Rising Son", "What is and what should never be" and "I (Who Have Nothing"). 3 INCREDIBLE songs I give props to whoever even attempts to sing them.

  • Gosh i love this song!!!

  • unbelieveable

    

  • I don't really care for the begining, but she got it at the end; right track. A strong, powerful voice! I'M TRUELY MOVED BY THIS SONG!

  • @jbroffermnfrapat Try listening to the beginning again - close your eyes, turn up the volume and listen to Haley's haunting voice (a capella) reverberating across the studio. That, my friend, is the one of most amazing bit of this performance.

  • @realfinnatic , I don't know, Haley should have been in the finale not Lauren

  • @jbroffermnfrapat She should have won!!

  • @realfinnatic , I don't know about winning, but she certainly deserve in top 2.

  • at 1:08 sexy weird look

  • omg i love this song i love her voice fuck all the 22 pple who disliked this damn song

  • funny:

    this was the best performance of the night, in the finale lauren and scotty gotta sing their bets performance and they both picked songs that sang at top 5

  • she killes singing blues

  • how is it that EVERY TIME I hear this its more AMAZING!!!!

  • How did this broad not win? Commercialized nonsense wins instead. Not that they weren't talented, but vocally she has the highest ceiling.

  • if i had a penis i'd be rock hard lol

  • love it

  • Comment removed

  • this performance never ceases to amaze me. there is some chemical in my brain that connects to my freakin' soul when it hears Haley sing this song.

  • @1999Hussam True, but we should remember the competition: What Is (Haley); Rolling in the Deep (Haley); Baby It's You (Haley); and a lot of people are fond of Benny and the Jets (Haley), Beautiful (Haley), and I Who Have Nothing (Haley); and I'm partial to You've Really Got A Hold On Me (Haley), Piece of My Heart (Haley), Earth Song (Haley), Rhainon (Haley), and Fallin' (Haley)

    House of the Rising Sun is better than anyone elses Idol performances by a mile. Only Haley can compete with this.

  • I love her smile at 2:12! She's absolutely adorable

  • Comment removed

  • This is such a beautiful, clear video .... love it!!

  • dear god...please protect repad

  • *ATTENTION* we are trending "Caley Its Cold Outside" on Monday, November 21st at 7pmEST/ 4pmPST DONT MISS IT!!! lets do this for haley, she asked us to! SPREAD THE WORD!

  • BICO HIT #4 :D

  • She was 10x more talented that Scotty and Lauren

  • Just heard that Haley's other HOTRS vid (the one with over 1.5 million views) was taken down yesterday --- Dang. What gives? (Weird that that video was taken down on the day that her new "Baby it's Cold Outside" music video just hit #6 on iTunes top charts for music videos!!! At least that is awesome news) Hope this version of HOTRS will stay so that future generations can hear an amazing artist!

  • She was sooooo underrated. She was a true artist. I got goosebumps.

  • damn country voters.

  • she was robbed!

  • Haley is the one who really deserves to win!!! What Happen America?

  • @alexhugh999

    ...Its possible you have overrated the performances of Lauren. That's my working assumption since you have made many so negative comments on Haley videos many months after the competition has ended. Could Lauren have performed this song as well? NO. So you ought to shut up instead of revealing yourself to be a damn fool. Oh, my, I said the word, "damn." That gives you the moral high ground, doesn't it?

  • 98,000th view! : D

    (for my nth time)

  • @repad You do such nice work on these videos. Thanks for the excellence...what we appreciate so much about Haley and what she deserves in return from the legions of fans that are following her. She has to appreciate what you have done with so many of these performances...thanks again, outstanding work.

  • best 2 minutes on youtube

  • Check out New Haley Video -Posted by PierceAbrams (aka Casey Abrams)

    ----Haley in New Orleans Jazz Club

    11 minutes of perfection!

  • VOTE 4 Haley -- idolheaded poll - ends sunday - (only can vote once - so each one makes a difference)

  • BEST PERFORMANCE EVERRRRR!!!

  • @tashamumu I made a cover for this song can u please listen to it and leave a comment

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Kill music? Haley resurrected music on this show.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • This show has helped kill music. It's emphasis on the singer instead of the music, the band, and the lyrics has led to showy singing with looks and "performance art" considered far more important than they should be. It used to be that you listened to music not watched performances. All these glitzy young robots do is sing other people's songs while "acting". Watch any Eric Burdon performance of this and you'll see he let's his soul do the performing without thinking about the craft.

  • @elfhermie You are a fool sir. This show is about the competitors voices not the songs they sing. Its a competition to see who has the talent vocally and the showmanship to make it in the music business. This show doesn't kill music it helps with the creation of new artists and new music.

  • @elfhermie I appreciate your comment – but I disagree. In the early days of R&R that may have been true – but performers like Elvis, Little Richard et. Al created an insatiable demand for the performance side of the music. The Studios and MTV changed how people listened to and viewed music with the birth of the music video. I do agree that some artists simply can’t sing, so they use other visual candy to sell music. Haley can sing, and she is no robot.

  • @elfhermie As for watching any Eric Burton version please watch "Eric Burdon house of the rising sun live 2008" - not too certain his soul is doing the performing here.

  • Comment removed

  • She always sounds on the verge of losing her voice if you ask me...almost like she's got laryngitis.

  • Her voice is awesome!! It goes perfectly well with the song!

  • They showed this episode in Norway,, n I just had to listen to it again! ;3 I luv her voice!! ;]

  • Note to all future contestants on American Idol and all other similar shows - THIS IS HOW IT’S DONE!

  • This chick should've won....I'm done with AI.

  • The quality of the audio on this is soo unreal - and there is nothing better than 2 B able to really hear every nuance that is Haley

  • i've been so sick but listening to haley is so soothing. like for example if i ever get too hot i just turn to this song and get the chills and then there are songs like 'baby its you' when i get the all shivery.

  • Man, she blew me away!

  • And this comment comes form a person who HATES American Idol!!!

  • IF you disliked this...you need to get you fucking hearing checked.

  • @SeetherRocks100

    Don't sell yourself short. You like James Durbin. You can take anything.

  • that gave me goosebumps

  • {{{{{{{ATTENTION}}}}}}

    i JUST HEARD A RUMOR THAT REPAD'S VIDS WOULD BE PULLED THIS WEEK. iS IT TRUE? iS THERE A WAY TO AVOID IT? REPAD?

  • 2:24 She looks like Alicia Keys.

  • You heard it here first on repad's vids......

    You all are the first to know on Utoob.

    Haley interview in Chicago dated Aug 5,2011

    My gift to you for voting on faxo and keeping her in 1st place.

    Enjoy!

    (cut and paste this into search bar above)

    watch?v=hSnSDjC8YM8&feature=pl­­ayer_detailpage

    Beast? over here.....new Haley vid.

  • Haley fans, I have started a new blog on HR to celebrate her signing with Interscope. It's called Haley and the Jets and you can find it by typing 'wwwDOThaleyandthejetsDOTblogs­­potDOTcom' directly into the url. Just replace the DOT with a period of course.

    There are four posts to date and I just started a weekly Casey Kasem style Top 10 countdown to number one of Haley's Idol performances. I will be linking repad's videos to them as there are simply no better on YouTube. Enjoy.

  • Comment removed

  • Faxo wall vote ends tomorrow night at 10 pm EST. They over extended it. If you can, please help get in more votes. It will be immortalized on the wall vote of fame for Haley the winner out of 132 idols.

  • voting has been extended for a few more days. shucks

  • FLAG ALL TROLLS. USE DROP DOWN BOX NEAR THE THUMB SIGNS AND CLICK IT AS SPAM. DO NOT FEED THE TROLLS.

  • WTF !!! ... the greatest female version

  • She rocked this in New Orleans. Check out the video posted by xxcrazymoe.

  • @johnkess2174 She has rocked this each stop of the tour, evidenced by all the vid's and summaries of the show from each town.

  • shit shes the best...

  • You can't get much hotter than this young lady. Well maybe Pia.

  • @skipper8257 Pia may have her matched on a technical level, but she doesn't have a stage presence, and her voice doesn't have anywhere near as much character as Haley's.

  • @skipper8257 Eh, I read your comment too fast. But yes, Haley and Pia are both damn sexy.

  • Once you all were Reinharted you were no longer a durbinator. LOL

  • Glorious. She totally blew me away with this performance. After this it was "adios Durbin" for me as far as who the best Idol of the season is. And this coming from a hard rock/metal fan who's naturally partial to his music.

  • @33stryker I love hard rock too but lost interest in James quickly. He started out great with Judas Priest but then passed up many opportunities to sing hard rocking songs. He kept saying give metal a chance but he did not give metal a chance.

  • @HaleySlaysIt

    I had no problem with most of his song choices except maybe for the 30 Seconds to Mars song which I didn't care for. He can't sing hard rock and heavy metal every week. He only wanted to give them some exposure to Idol's young audience, who otherwise would not have given it a chance. My favs of his were actually softer songs like My Guitar Gently Weeps and Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow.

    Haley did the same thing. She exposed Idol's young audience to LedZep and HOTRS.

  • @33stryker Of course he couldn't sing hard rock and metal every week but he could have sang it more often. I laughed when Steven said "don't go poppy on me". Anyway, I now find it hard to believe that he is neck and neck with Haley's EP sales. I don't think he'll go far after the tour ends.

  • Comment removed

  • To anyone whos gunna call her bad, don't do it on a video she got a standing ovation for...

  • The Haliens are coming!

  • @sfaster We've been here - and Repad is one of us!

  • Repad - You will now FINALLY get the views you well deserve! Once again your work is the best, and you appear to have the correct disclaimers. Nicely done!

  • If she makes it big, you can be guaranteed that Haley will never lip sync anything ever! The "L" in Saturday Night Live will mean just that!

  • ATTENTION EVERY HALEY LOVER!

    @rhiannonhyatt HATES HALEY! She keeps talking bad about her, and we don't like it! Copy and paste this to other Haley vids. to bring Haley hater to a stop!

  • Has anyone Realized that, yes this a competition but.....LAUREN AND HALEY ARE FRIENDS!!!! Gosh I wish people would realize that. They got along real well. Also the competition is over and Scotty is the idol. I do think that it should have been a Lauren/Haley Finale but its over. Get over it. You will hear albums from Lauren and Haley so its all good. Personally Lauren was my favorite but I can dig some Haley too LOL

  • That was the most unenthusiastic standing ovation I've ever seen.

  • Haley has demonstrated the ability to sing all genres. This girl is amazing. I hope you fulfill your dreams. You're the most beautiful woman I've ever seen in my life. Extremely hot and talented, of course.

  • At 0:46 you hear a girl in the audience scream excitedly and I swear that girl is heard during everyone of Haley's perfromances lol,

  • you someones a true artist when you like their live versions more then the studio one.

  • I think this might be one of the best performances throughout season 10! And I am a Scotty fan! Props to you Haley!!