This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You are awful! now delete this horrible video so that i can find the proper one of Shirley MacLaine without having to listen to your awful cat screaming, claw ripping, fingernail tearing version! I hope you work for Macdonald's now so that musical theatre isn't infected by your talentless singing!
@Andamunra Why am "I" awful? I'm not even IN this clip! And, the "proper one" would be Gwen Verdon, who originated the role on Broadway, not Shirley.. who just did it on film. So, please remove the bed-bug from up your ass and write accurately, responsibly, and maturely! -- I said "please"!
@leojrevlis Rather than continue this silly argument about who knows what, why not watch the late great Lena Zavaroni singing this song on British TV in 1975 when she was 11 years old?
I think this is pretty good for a highschool production, really. More living the moments instead of just saying lines would have made it great. The girl looks very nice and has a beautiful voice. Keep it up!
Well sung and you had the choreography down in terms of "steps," but all arm movements (at least in jazz) should stem from the solar plexus, all leg movements from the pelvis. Routine would have been GREAT if someone had managed to get that out of you. This message is 10 years too late, but if you're still perfoming, I hope you've mastered that.
I did this show in high school...in the 70's . It was scandalous. The next year the director made all the dance hall girls nuns in The Sound of Music.
It's a high school production. Some of the negative comments sound like they come from Howard Stern or Ann Coulter. Must be a lot of talented professionals out there who can't find work in the business and troll youtube for earnest performers to cut up. That's the last time I'll ever bother to check the comment timeline under a video.
I really liked this performance. My director assigned me this song for my musical theater group's showcase coming up. I'm definetly going to use some of your ideas if you don't mind ;)
she is a great dancers. and her moves were funny and sexy just like it should be.
but still looks like you are trying to hard. you should just be having fun with it, thats the point of the scene, she is not dancing for a crowd, she is just dancing with herself.
I agree it needs polish, but for cryin' out loud, this is a high school production. Grading on that curve, it's quite impressive. Definitely a lot of potential.
She's quite a good singer and pretty to boot. I'd be interested to see something she's done recently, 9 years later.
She's an amazing singer, and I thought she was a really good actress too. The one thing I can say, is that she needs some work with dancing, but as it's a high school production many of the actors and actresses haven't had all that much dance training, Honestly, despite that it was really, really good!
I did this same piece a few years ago, and its a hard one to sing and dance at the same time...the girl did good! hehe i really enjoyed it, everyones always so quick to critisize xx
Ya know, lots of people end their comments with "for a high school." But - YOU wrote "nice at any level." That's a GREAT compliment to these HS-actors.
Actually, it's the HAT that made the mistake. As I remember it from years ago, that hat was quite stiff; difficult to retract AND keep retracted. You can see her holding the top in, in other sections, to stop it from popping out.
But hey - thanks for pointing THAT out. It's nice to see that you got so much from the clip.
Very well done! Let's all remember this is a HS performance, not dinner theatre, much less the "Great White Way". She entertained and in the long run, isn't that the idea?
It's a bit hard to see her as te character because she is a high schooler, and once again it isn't "that bad" (which is apparently a biting comment) So I'll say it's pretty good. She could be "bigger" and have more fun with it and her character... but that all comes with time, experience, and a director who brings it out in you. (No dis on the director. They did well at bringing out the HS in the performance.)
Wow.. using all CAPITALS!! You must feel very strongly about what you've written. The trouble is.. I don't understand what the hell you mean! "How the song goes"? - - I don't "get" that?!?! Please explain to me how the song REALLY goes. Unexplained statements make me crazy {errr - MORE crazy than usual!!}.
Really, this is amazing. I don't have all that much theatre experience but I have been involved in music performance for a long time and I'm amazed that this high school girl stayed on pitch on the notes the entire song and sounded just as good as any Broadway professional. Her dancing was also very nicely done. "Living in the moment", as my director puts it, needs a bit of work, but other than that, great! I'm recommending this for our HS next year, and I hope we do as good a job!
her voice and character is maazing. and shes got such a good stage and lighting and music and voice so why isnt she enjoying it as much as i would if i could. shes doing her moves yeah, but she looks like shes just following steps rather than completley loosing it!!! its great though :):(
I'm gonna be brutally honest since ive been working on Broadway for 4 years. It lacks any similarities to Fosse. Your portrayal shows passion but lacks any personaliy. Now that the negatives are out of the way, way to create a dance style that differs from the norm. At 4:20 your lagging, watch the conductor. At 4:30 extend that note. Trust me, i've been a musician and music director on Broadway!
Well, now that you've been working on B'way for 4 years & 4 months, I thought I'd answer!! ;-}
I think that "some" personality pokes thru, as well as a glimmer of Fosse-esque image, but I'm biased.
At 4:20 she was out of breath and barely had the "steam" left to push-out "he." It was only in this performance, not any of the other 3 shows. {Figures?.. that I taped THIS one!!}
Well that's her name, "Too Sweet Charity"!!! But seriously, she is aw-struck with Vittorio in this scene, plus she "thinks" that "he" might be her ticket to a new life. He's not just her "John" for the night!! She's on her best behavior . . At least, that's my take on the scene.
Wow! She is awesome. I really enjoyed watching her. Very talented. I'm enjoying watching all the clips you've posted. What a talented ensemble of performers.
Hey... That not nice. Knock it off! Let her speak. Everybody's got the right to their opinion. I learn a lot from comments like her's. BTW - Some K-Marts still sell hand-guns.
Was fantastic charity was awesome really great acting! Well done!! Great Band as well I dont know what those other comments are talking about because Charity is a hard part to play (apparently) haveing been in a production of it myself!!! Well done everyone thanks for the post!!
good effort for a youngster....the problem i have with high schools mature musicals, especially those that are dance heavy, is that they dont understand the material...good try though? i suppose
I get a kick out of you calling her a "youngster," since your stats show that you're only 20. Perhaps some schools don't rehearse long enough for the students to really know their characters, but she certainly knew hers, living and breathing Charity for 4 months.
ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!This Charity is great and the production values of this HS never fail to amaze me!!!! Ringwald & Applegate could learn a lot from this. Gwen 'would never believe' this was a HS production. Thank you for this.
She's amazing!!!
ElondraMidomerei 18 hours ago in playlist Broadway stuff
HECKA GOOD.
calmlcism 3 weeks ago
Nice job on the Seymour Kaufman piece. He also penned Big Spender. An underrated musical genius.
stagesurvivor5 2 months ago
How did she get away with wearing such a short dress in a high school production?
CanadianQueer 3 months ago
Those that can, do. Those that can't? Who needs 'em?
WustyBoy1 3 months ago
Fabulous. I'm sure Fosse would be proud. You've captured the spirit of the piece.
palaver2034 4 months ago
She is great...looking, acting, dancing, singing Thanks !!
gebolanos 5 months ago
Well this is definetly high school. The stage is really nice and the costumes look amazing, other then that...
BwayPrimaDonna 5 months ago
You're so awesome! :O thank you so much for uploading this video!!! xD
ViivaLaMaddi 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You are awful! now delete this horrible video so that i can find the proper one of Shirley MacLaine without having to listen to your awful cat screaming, claw ripping, fingernail tearing version! I hope you work for Macdonald's now so that musical theatre isn't infected by your talentless singing!
Andamunra 5 months ago
@Andamunra Why am "I" awful? I'm not even IN this clip! And, the "proper one" would be Gwen Verdon, who originated the role on Broadway, not Shirley.. who just did it on film. So, please remove the bed-bug from up your ass and write accurately, responsibly, and maturely! -- I said "please"!
leojrevlis 5 months ago 9
@leojrevlis AMEN!
TotalTheatreGeek 4 months ago
@Andamunra Fuck that was mean.
TheAwkwardPigeon 4 months ago
If I were her age, I would be madly in love!!!
workonitm8 5 months ago
@TeiChaps lol XD
gothicyaoifangirl98 6 months ago
Niceeeee
TheTripleLotus 8 months ago
Awesome Song !
normbates30 8 months ago
Great job especially for a high school production. Did this student ever go professional in the theater?
Woodyhayesful 9 months ago
Shirley would be proud!
garrygrant 10 months ago 2
@garrygrant What do you mean "would be"? she's not dead. She also didn't create the role of Charity, Gwen did. Now, SHE would be proud. ;-}}
leojrevlis 10 months ago
@leojrevlis Rather than continue this silly argument about who knows what, why not watch the late great Lena Zavaroni singing this song on British TV in 1975 when she was 11 years old?
Iazzaboyce 1 week ago
This is really well done!
theXwitness 10 months ago
The singing was very good. The acting needs A LOT of work, it looks more middle school.
Katiedid724 10 months ago
For a high school production this was really great, She is a lovely singer and put a lot of effort into her part.
Full marks and keep up the good work xxx
BertHigginbottom 10 months ago
awsome vid
EmilyandJessica64 10 months ago
Really enjoyed her performance. What ever happened with her?
Was this a one and only?
workonitm8 11 months ago
great performance, especially for a high school production
iluvtheighties 1 year ago
I think this is pretty good for a highschool production, really. More living the moments instead of just saying lines would have made it great. The girl looks very nice and has a beautiful voice. Keep it up!
rodriguezrosa 1 year ago
I was going to comment on how impressed I was with your performance until I saw the end- what a set! Spectacular!
BlazeOfAero 1 year ago
Songs too slow. But your an amazing singer. You should put a bit more emotion into your singing, such as "Pow." Dont just say it, belt it out (: ♥
daniellover201 1 year ago
Well sung and you had the choreography down in terms of "steps," but all arm movements (at least in jazz) should stem from the solar plexus, all leg movements from the pelvis. Routine would have been GREAT if someone had managed to get that out of you. This message is 10 years too late, but if you're still perfoming, I hope you've mastered that.
crowebobby 1 year ago
yes this is amateur, but i love it! Well done to the cast.
cd82156 1 year ago
Brilliant! You're great, girl!
MartaGabri 1 year ago 2
pretty good, could use some more enthusiam. still good
azulrey23 1 year ago
Thats one short ass dress
Nemo55455 1 year ago
That was nice, now lets see if Charity could show some emotion.
Timmyvirus1 1 year ago 2
Congratulations! I like it
Trinityeva 1 year ago
Is a very competant dancer- and her singing is really enviable. Should be very proud (: .x.
meluvyahunHP 1 year ago
this is the best if my friends could see me now on youtube... AMAZING! XXXXX
JoanOkoye 1 year ago
you could tell she loses her breath at the end. but good
xialiceee 1 year ago 2
Absolutely Brilliant. This girl oozes talent and theatre- Top notch!
FJMLAM 1 year ago
for a high school girl this is great! good voice, some intonation problems in the end, good dancing, too.
vully70 1 year ago
I did this show in high school...in the 70's . It was scandalous. The next year the director made all the dance hall girls nuns in The Sound of Music.
roccoh21 1 year ago
My high school is doing this production right now, truly brilliant, this. I myself am playing Vittorio :)
Timmyvirus1 1 year ago
It's a high school production. Some of the negative comments sound like they come from Howard Stern or Ann Coulter. Must be a lot of talented professionals out there who can't find work in the business and troll youtube for earnest performers to cut up. That's the last time I'll ever bother to check the comment timeline under a video.
tqnews 1 year ago 3
I don't know clip other people were watching, I thought she was brililant. Lots of potential. I mean for a high school production this is brilliant!
TehCheese 1 year ago 3
that was kind of painful
iamupforallfun 2 years ago
Oww - it hoits.. it hoits!
leojrevlis 2 years ago 2
I really liked this performance. My director assigned me this song for my musical theater group's showcase coming up. I'm definetly going to use some of your ideas if you don't mind ;)
AnAmatureActress 2 years ago
This gal is GREAT! anyone know where she is?/
Mclaire12
mclaire12 2 years ago
really good but try straighening your legs when you are on the couch with the hatand point your toes.
D4NC3RR 2 years ago
Great job! Not an easy number. Fosse's style requires tremendous technique and for a high school to tackle it is
admirable (how did you get it pass the censors?)
SITZPROBE1 2 years ago 23
congratulation!!!
it was very nice!!
she is a great dancers. and her moves were funny and sexy just like it should be.
but still looks like you are trying to hard. you should just be having fun with it, thats the point of the scene, she is not dancing for a crowd, she is just dancing with herself.
great nevertheless!!!
athoscesarferraz 2 years ago
im not a hater but she is not broadway material.
theatreprincess22 2 years ago
her acting is not that good.. her singing is ok.. she looks like she is really thinking of what to do next..
theatreprincess22 2 years ago
yeh i no reely. how do u guys thinks shes tht great.
paigerz393 2 years ago
fanominal actor
7paperairplanes 2 years ago
foul language
laubys1 2 years ago
gytarok removed the comment.. but for those who want to know what it was:
"dumb whore."
leojrevlis 2 years ago
ahhh this chick is good!
emmaperin1993 2 years ago 2
I can't get over how great she is as an actor.
My school is doing Sweet Charity this spring for our musical. It'll be the first play I've tried out for.
MetaKittie 2 years ago
GREAT PERFORMANCE!!! i loved it :D
MrJabawocky 2 years ago
sammee here!
angelkity418 2 years ago
Excellent Peformance !!!
MrShineShoes 2 years ago
Very good!!
1Cyberangels 2 years ago
WHO IS THIS WOMAN????????
SHE IS GREAT!!!!!!!
And this is a high school production? I am amazed!
Mannock 2 years ago 25
@Mannock Yeah, I'm amazed too! It looks like grade school!!!
LazlosPlane 6 months ago
@LazlosPlane You should be on the stage. There's one leaving town tonight.
Be under it.
Mannock 6 months ago
@Mannock Hahaha!
wehatemagz 6 months ago
I agree it needs polish, but for cryin' out loud, this is a high school production. Grading on that curve, it's quite impressive. Definitely a lot of potential.
She's quite a good singer and pretty to boot. I'd be interested to see something she's done recently, 9 years later.
Fabulist 2 years ago
love it!!!!!
ChelsiieVegas 2 years ago
She's an amazing singer, and I thought she was a really good actress too. The one thing I can say, is that she needs some work with dancing, but as it's a high school production many of the actors and actresses haven't had all that much dance training, Honestly, despite that it was really, really good!
pointeprincess20 2 years ago 3
this is a very nice song and a great preformance
pooperuber 2 years ago
I did this same piece a few years ago, and its a hard one to sing and dance at the same time...the girl did good! hehe i really enjoyed it, everyones always so quick to critisize xx
zoopzoopzoop17 2 years ago 2
Wonderful performance! 5*
moondogg55 2 years ago
its not a strong dance preformance
try and keep your head up and shoulders down and it will imrove your preformance
i like the couch lol :)
it was a very enjoyable preformance
well done
69bianca69 2 years ago
Hey, well done. I enjoyed this clip. Performed confidently and was entertaining. Made me want to see the whole show!!!
juanbastado 2 years ago
She's only 18 or so, she's GREAT! You people watch too much television with a million people behind the scenes.
vickthechick3 2 years ago 3
she is just not a great actress.....
jowizrock 2 years ago
it may not be broadway but still an EXCELLENT performance... hope she continued with her musical career
dolcevitausa 2 years ago 3
omg she is amazing!!!
almostfamuz123 2 years ago
Very nice for HS - nice at any level.
DancingTillIDie 3 years ago
Good comment!! THANKS!!
Ya know, lots of people end their comments with "for a high school." But - YOU wrote "nice at any level." That's a GREAT compliment to these HS-actors.
leojrevlis 3 years ago
she makes a mistake at 2:38 - the hat was meant to retract when she put it on her head!
smithy262626 3 years ago
Actually, it's the HAT that made the mistake. As I remember it from years ago, that hat was quite stiff; difficult to retract AND keep retracted. You can see her holding the top in, in other sections, to stop it from popping out.
But hey - thanks for pointing THAT out. It's nice to see that you got so much from the clip.
leojrevlis 3 years ago
Very well done! Let's all remember this is a HS performance, not dinner theatre, much less the "Great White Way". She entertained and in the long run, isn't that the idea?
newyorktomr 3 years ago
I must say I wasn't really fond of the acting, but I think she did a nice job singing. For a HS production it's quite nice :)
anneloes2 3 years ago 3
Wow It Was Really Good!
XBabyRandomX 3 years ago
Bravo!Bravo!Bravissimo!
yourCarlotta 3 years ago
my names charity :) , <3
xoxcharityxox 3 years ago
So is my friend's cat's. And???
leojrevlis 3 years ago
She is good, but I feel that her performance lacks a bit of charisma.
bellaluce 3 years ago 4
she is fantastic!
wow!
x
RebeccaLouiseWaters 3 years ago
Amazing :]
The only thing I noticed is that her movement isn't super flowy[I know that's not a word XD]
But oh well, this is an overall spectacular performance :}
dinoxdstruction 3 years ago
She did great! Really nice voice.
Why bother to leave a comment at all if you didn't like it? Just move on. Get a life. Nobody thinks you're clever - or even average.
pdavies65 3 years ago
Es buena
venditodance 3 years ago
I am shocked at the comments just below....I think this girl was phenomenal.
BooneLoon 3 years ago 2
This show is well done. Kudos.
P.S. Please forgive my critiques, it's just what I've been trained to do.
JordyxRedvine 3 years ago
It's a bit hard to see her as te character because she is a high schooler, and once again it isn't "that bad" (which is apparently a biting comment) So I'll say it's pretty good. She could be "bigger" and have more fun with it and her character... but that all comes with time, experience, and a director who brings it out in you. (No dis on the director. They did well at bringing out the HS in the performance.)
JordyxRedvine 3 years ago
THATS NOT EVEN HOW THE SONG GOES!
BSProductioneers 3 years ago
Wow.. using all CAPITALS!! You must feel very strongly about what you've written. The trouble is.. I don't understand what the hell you mean! "How the song goes"? - - I don't "get" that?!?! Please explain to me how the song REALLY goes. Unexplained statements make me crazy {errr - MORE crazy than usual!!}.
leojrevlis 3 years ago
I repeat...
"Please explain to me how the song REALLY goes."
leojrevlis 3 years ago
Well, it's been 8 months. I guess an explanation is never coming!
leojrevlis 3 years ago
I've been waiting for a reply for a year.. How does the song "go"?
leojrevlis 2 years ago
Really, this is amazing. I don't have all that much theatre experience but I have been involved in music performance for a long time and I'm amazed that this high school girl stayed on pitch on the notes the entire song and sounded just as good as any Broadway professional. Her dancing was also very nicely done. "Living in the moment", as my director puts it, needs a bit of work, but other than that, great! I'm recommending this for our HS next year, and I hope we do as good a job!
SingenMeinLeben 3 years ago
Nice comment...... THANX
leojrevlis 3 years ago
She is really good.
shmoogle14 3 years ago
ok ok no she is good.
:)
Robynface 4 years ago
her voice and character is maazing. and shes got such a good stage and lighting and music and voice so why isnt she enjoying it as much as i would if i could. shes doing her moves yeah, but she looks like shes just following steps rather than completley loosing it!!! its great though :):(
Robynface 4 years ago
Check out other "If My Friends...." clips. Then laugh... You'll return to view this one again!!!
rodanvideo 4 years ago
Wow!! Im doing the show at the moment and I luv this song !! Whoever this is does it brilliantly good choice for charity!!
singinirishmusicgirl 4 years ago
I'm gonna be brutally honest since ive been working on Broadway for 4 years. It lacks any similarities to Fosse. Your portrayal shows passion but lacks any personaliy. Now that the negatives are out of the way, way to create a dance style that differs from the norm. At 4:20 your lagging, watch the conductor. At 4:30 extend that note. Trust me, i've been a musician and music director on Broadway!
orchestralmagician 4 years ago
Take a look at the video:
If They Could See Me Now
From: KristenQ1245
See what you think about that one regarding Fosse similarities.
Luvsdance5678 4 years ago
Well, now that you've been working on B'way for 4 years & 4 months, I thought I'd answer!! ;-}
I think that "some" personality pokes thru, as well as a glimmer of Fosse-esque image, but I'm biased.
At 4:20 she was out of breath and barely had the "steam" left to push-out "he." It was only in this performance, not any of the other 3 shows. {Figures?.. that I taped THIS one!!}
What have you done on B'way?
leojrevlis 4 years ago
That was fab! We're doing Sweet Charity at school this year and we have to sing this song for the audition!
usukifrenzy211 4 years ago
i think its excellent!
Tizzybix 4 years ago
Whoa. Easy tiger.
1- Yes. It's what I think. A opinion.
2- You're taking this way too seriously if you looked into my profile to find out my age.
3- Never said I was an expert.
4- I'm not "judging" Fosse at all. But seriously, find Gwen doing that dance and compare her to this video. Yeah. The difference is obvious.
6- Truth is in the eye of the beholder so stop bitchin up such a storm about it.
crazyjazzchick 4 years ago
I was in a "mood" when I ranted to you yesterday. Over-reacting is what I do best!! ;-}
[I LOVE when someone responds with a numbered list.]
Please search and view "I'm a Brass Band," and tell me if Charity stinks in that number too!
Thanks!!!
leojrevlis 4 years ago
It's obvious she's very talented... she just seems a little too sweet. Not quit brash enough.
gracieburns 4 years ago
Well that's her name, "Too Sweet Charity"!!! But seriously, she is aw-struck with Vittorio in this scene, plus she "thinks" that "he" might be her ticket to a new life. He's not just her "John" for the night!! She's on her best behavior . . At least, that's my take on the scene.
leojrevlis 4 years ago
she is absolutly amazing as Charity i mean not Gwen Verdon good, but definatly Christina Applegate good!!
she looks a tiny bit nervous.
but she is sooooooo good!!
lovexx54 4 years ago
this was great
ILoveToSing2010 4 years ago
Wow! She is awesome. I really enjoyed watching her. Very talented. I'm enjoying watching all the clips you've posted. What a talented ensemble of performers.
leanmusclcowboy 4 years ago
I think it is great for a High School....I have been to a fair share of High School Musical and most are not nearly as good as this!!!!
imspinningaround1 4 years ago
she's very very good!
gabbyxoxoxo 4 years ago
She's incredible, I hope she carried on in theatre, because she has true talent.
AshleyTisdale05 4 years ago
She's still terrible. God, I just want to shoot myself in the head.
colleenlfogarty 4 years ago
Please do!
rodanvideo 4 years ago
Hey... That not nice. Knock it off! Let her speak. Everybody's got the right to their opinion. I learn a lot from comments like her's. BTW - Some K-Marts still sell hand-guns.
leojrevlis 4 years ago
Was fantastic charity was awesome really great acting! Well done!! Great Band as well I dont know what those other comments are talking about because Charity is a hard part to play (apparently) haveing been in a production of it myself!!! Well done everyone thanks for the post!!
ichigosama 4 years ago
Excellent singing!
terry585 4 years ago
good effort for a youngster....the problem i have with high schools mature musicals, especially those that are dance heavy, is that they dont understand the material...good try though? i suppose
jbactr 4 years ago
I get a kick out of you calling her a "youngster," since your stats show that you're only 20. Perhaps some schools don't rehearse long enough for the students to really know their characters, but she certainly knew hers, living and breathing Charity for 4 months.
Thanks for commenting, I suppose.
leojrevlis 4 years ago
pretty smooth tap dancing legs
DanceTaps 4 years ago
i love this! very talented!
Haileelynn 4 years ago
wow i hope this girl went on to do more stuff onstage. she's wonderful
sskylaarr 5 years ago
Im a profesional and Wow shes Fantastic. shes definitly got a career going for her
mandygene2222 5 years ago
She reads the comments from time to time. I'm sure she'll appreciate the fine compliment.
leojrevlis 5 years ago
wow. those legs!
namesinthesand 5 years ago
Nicely understated performance. So very unstageschool like.
colinconcis 5 years ago
excellent video..thanks for sharing...this girl is fabulous
KATHYS1977 5 years ago
Very excellant.. kudos!
SHP2SHR 5 years ago
ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!This Charity is great and the production values of this HS never fail to amaze me!!!! Ringwald & Applegate could learn a lot from this. Gwen 'would never believe' this was a HS production. Thank you for this.
doug18020 5 years ago