I would like everybody who says they can hit it to post a video of it here on youtube, & it better not be some scream, strained note, or some random once in a lifetime whistle. I think anybody can randomly "hit" a note, but sing it, & in a sustained style is the true "winner."
@UNevan lol i don't have to prove anything, i know what i can do??? how would u like me to prove it? put up a video so u can see that i actually can, whould that make u feel better? :L :L
she has the most beautiful & powerful whistle register. . .and the most beautiful & powerful voice. . .she is the inspiration for my singing ---> Christina Aguilera
@NickyPerilhou yeah :) okay my highest note is a c7/g6 and my lowest is C3. my VOCAL range is 4 octaves and and my longest note is about 15- 20 seconds. so yeah i can do that :L and guess what? ima boy!! :L
That's actually not that high for a girl. I can do it, and I can do it well, really. I'm not saying she doesn't have an amazing vocal talent but sometimes it just needs to be put into perspective. But Mariah... Now that's high and insanely controlled.
@Typhoon792 Right!!! It's a high note but a lot of girls can hit that note...especially if you're under 12. But Mariah's notes are off the charts. It's the kind that you have to cover your ears cause it's so friggin high!
@ghislaine1983 :) I'm a guy though. It's a whistle note and many don't know how to do it actually. For a girl, often times it can be reached with head voice.
She does not have 5 octaves I actually bought Stripped everyone knows that G2 in fighter is her its Charles Hines (background vocals) and the "G7" I don't think so! I don't even trust her C#7 studio! Just like with "Beautiful" she has never been able to produce the F#5 live, her true range is Eb3 - Bb6, and that was in prime now it is Eb3 - Eb6 and I will say she can probably go to F#6 maybe G6 and that Eb6 was only once other than that her highest has been G#5!
you honestly cannot compare mariah and christina cause firstly in my opinion christina is better in my eyes cause she could do what mariah does and more. DID you EVER see mariah dancing all over the stage so interactive and do those whistles NO. well christina can :]
@jg9212 she has before. She doesn't just stand there all the time lol I can show you videos where mariah is dancing and singing. I do give christina credit for dancing and singing at the same time though not many professional singers can do that.
Umm, why do you bring Mariah and Britney here? They both have great voices, but big part of my friends even don't know Mariah and they call Britney a stripper. I'm huge fan of Christina and Britney, and I love them both! <3 Mariah has great voice, but maybe she isn't that popular than Christina.. in teenagers.
Chrstina sings so much better than Mariah, she's on another league: with frank sinatra, elvis & the platters, so there is no comparison, so stop talking bout her. and this note is great!!!!
what burlesque did incredible and her voice was AMAZING just cause mariah lost her voice and can no longer do whistles as she showed on her FLOPPED christmas album where she put pre recorded whistles everywhere. Just cause a person can sell records it doesnt make them an amazing singer HERE RIGHT here christina can sing her ass off & STILL CAN !
@jg9212 Her Christmas album DOUBLED Bionic's sales and TRIPLED the Burlesque soundtrack's sales. She also got a #1 hit on the adult chart, and broke a record for fastest rise to #1. Stay mad that your fave is flopping and is an even worse singer than Rihanna now. Xtincta LOST her voice completely. She can't belt for shit.
@repenttyourself uhm are you serious go on rolling stones 100 best singers of all time and mariahs 79 while christina sits at 58 come on there is music of christina singing THIS year were she sounds the same. can you show me something that shows christinas lost her voice ? OK thankyou mariah is well in her 40's and needs to just sit down and go to sleep. Dont come on this video trying to bash if you dont like you can get the fuck off.
@jg9212 Rolling Stone lost credibility years ago. People just think Xtina is better because she screams as loud as she can. Christina has completely destroyed her upper register, which was actually never very good to begin with. She is also the queen of dodging notes and straining: /watch?v=9dIukEG-Y54. You sound mad that Mariah is the Queen. More successful, talented, and all around better than Floptina. Bye.
@repenttyourself you must be completely oblivious to think rolling stones has lost credibility YOUR just mad christina has come in a higher standard for singing. Now i will admit mariah has more sales and popularity but truly just because your popular it doesnt make you more talented. Now your saying her upper register is gone i dont think so watch?v=HDeaCDUXHcc there you go a quick video less then 7 months ago it sounds great so you need to do alittle more research
@jg9212 That performance was alright, but there were no high notes. The highest note was a D5. If she tries to sing anything over that, she croaks. All Xtina does is dodge the high notes live. She's NEVER hit the high note in Beautiful or Fighter. Her upper register is gone, and it has been since her debut. Even then, it wasn't great. She always croaked while singing the high note in I Turn to You. I just find her voice incredible overrated. There are several singers out who are better than her.
@repenttyourself are you serious no she does not you act like your next to her and know everything she cant do that. what makes you think she cant like seriously stop putting her down she sing the same and for the beautiful live how about this one for the grammy she did even better then the video as quoted by many that it was alot better watch?v=daixgZaIR0w or fighter /watch?v=GKCWGmE1Y60 and her doing the same in 2010 /watch?v=U2Eo1n4UZ1k her VOICE IS THE SAME AND GREAT AND POWERFUL enough said
@repenttyourself & ofcourse you would send a video of her messing up you make it seem like thats every live performance. You need to get out your bubble and realize even mariah makes mistakes. so can you just leave you must be on this video for a reason. its says christina not mariah but i mean you would be a so called "hater" have nothing else to do.
Get off of Mariah's nuts and leave Christina alone. Take away the "whistle factor" and Christina wins.
Mariah's voice is beautiful, no arguments, but it is also thin, breathy and today when she sings it sounds like she's hissing. There are few songs of hers where I hear true emotion and passion. Christina is versatile and can sing virtually any genre.
btw THIS IS CHRISTINA'S VIDEO, TAKE THAT MARIAH SHIT SOMEWHERE ELSE.
@SpunkStalker101 Mariah, unlike Christina, does have a complete control throughout her range. And Mariah's voice is not thin at all. It is just light. And resonates WAY more than Christina's voice.
Christina is the one with a thin voice. No resonance indeed, her voice is not powerful but just loud. Her emission is so throaty and strained.
@Stefano94x I never said that Mariah doesn't have control. I think her voice is thin and with not much emotion, but that is my opinon. Christina is the best in the world, to me.
@SpunkStalker101 When you say a voice is "thin" it's not an opinion, because it's a matter of technique. When a voice is thin, it lacks resonance, and that's Christina's case. If you say you don't find her voice soulful, it's your opinion and that's fine, there's nothing I can do about it. But Mariah's voice is not thin at all, and that's a fact. It is far more supported, flexible and resonant than Christina's one.
@SpunkStalker101 Well you have to consider Mariah's voice is a bit worn though. I mean, in her heyday, she could belt just as well as Christina, but with a better tone quality. And her emotion goes mostly in her older songs, like I Don't Wanna Cry, Vision of Love, etc. But make no mistake, Christina is also amazing, she's very powerful and also has a very good range. I honestly don't see why people have to keep comparing them, they're both great, end of story.
@SharpestAerrow I agree, to each their own. I do like a lot of Mariah's older music, as you pointed out. I think it was better quality and she wasn't afraid to let it all out. But sadly, like the great Whitney Houston, today her voice is just an echo of what it used to be. I think Christina and maybe Celine Dion are the only true great singers left today.
There are many fools in this world that like to compare the artists.....
Im fan of MC n i dont like Cristina at all, but thats no reason to underrate her, n to compare her with MC (for me shes the greatest singer ever) but C has a notable vocal talent !
@repenttyourself of course, i see her face in the TV ALL THE TIME ! oh pleace. go to a old mariah video. but a last time notice, THIS IS A CHRISTINA AGUILERA VIDEO BITCH. floptina have more attitude than mariah.
@201011221 LMFAOOOOO. I can barely understand this, but just know that Mariah is better than Floptina in literally EVERY possible way. Better singer, isn't a flop, has sold more than 160 million more records than Xtina, etc.
@201011221 Nope, Xtina is far from a legend. She'll be forgotten in ten years while Mariah is still getting hits and selling records! Mariah's Christmas album sold more than any Xtina album since 2006.
@repenttyourself you can see the future?? oh my god ! listen to "cruz" it's a song of chrisitna, "living today!" and today her voice is legendary, hahahaha oh god, back to basic is one of the best albums in the last 20 years!
@201011221 It's just an obvious trend. Floptina peaked with her debut album, and her sales have been dwindling ever since. Back to Basics didn't even get good reviews, sooo... nope. It didn't sell too well either.
@repenttyourself christina always is original, she change her image in every Cd she don't care about what people like you is thinking. everybody said in stripped record was a musical suicide, but is a excelent Album. and mariah is over, nobody remenber her...
@201011221 Mariah is over? Is that why she was the fourth biggest female artist of the decade, and Floptina was #19? Mariah also had the biggest song of the decade with We Belong Together. U mad?
best vocalist ...but dont hate on good artist like mariah,beyonce,or anybody else thats good ....but you can hate on people that cant even sing like..kesha,lady gaga or anybody else who uses auto in every word they sing
@petfan1202 You're an idiot. Lumping Gaga with autotuned singers? Uh, Gaga can actually sing live and well. You clearly have your head up your ass if you think she's in the Kesha, Rihanna, Katy Perry mold.
@kellykellyfan15 yeah she used to hit these high soprano notes all the time when she was younger during her debut and stripped days. The note showcased in the video is not even her highest live note!
& stfu talking about she can do better. She can, but y'all put it like the note is bad, or not high. A lot of artist now can't even touch this note, & she hit it pitch perfectly with a run & peaking @ a G6. That's beyond epic.
You can clearly tell it's a whistle. She just doesn't have "airy" whistles. Her's are very full when she executes them correctly. Everyone has different quality notes & whistle notes, just like people have different voices & timbres. I love her head voice/whistle register.
@LifeisMusic07 It's not a whistle, it's a head voice/falsetto note. Whistle isn't that full sounding. It's more impressive to be able to go that high without whistle register anyway.
@mellynumerounoo Well whatever it is, it sounds good. Sounds like whistle to me though. If you think about when people actually whistle, like with their mouth, it'd be considering a 'whistle."
@LifeisMusic07 Listen to her G6 in "Hello" live in Milan...that was whistle. They sound diff. Also her C#7 in "The Christmas Song" studio version--that's also whistle. Whistle doesn't sound as full as the note she hit here does. Sounds more like super-high head voice.
a lot of people can hit that note but it will NEVER sound that beautiful.
coobxx2 3 days ago
I would like everybody who says they can hit it to post a video of it here on youtube, & it better not be some scream, strained note, or some random once in a lifetime whistle. I think anybody can randomly "hit" a note, but sing it, & in a sustained style is the true "winner."
LifeisMusic07 6 days ago
i can , just gimme ur skype address and i can sing it right in front of u!
hurricaneioke 3 weeks ago
Mariah can go very high yes,but she cant do it so strong and pure!!!;)) Christina the best!!!
thesofia9 1 month ago
AM i on my way to heaven ?
sandrod95 1 month ago
Sure I can and I'm a male, that's a G6 I can get till E7
gaara125able 1 month ago
@gaara125able me too and i am a STRAIGHT male
etxhioVEVO 1 month ago
There are 49 people who are deaf!
lolizzzzz 1 month ago
Jup it´s high, very high...but look on the right side "Mariah Highest Note" Video....that´s just unreal.
hardcorl 1 month ago
why yes i can, thank your for asking youtube.
BlackDiamondXx 2 months ago
i can lol
discorules2009 2 months ago
ı really like mariah <3 But Xtina is the QUEEN ! <3
xtinasfighter 2 months ago
this is a high note not whistle register - explained!
mariahCareyPortugal 2 months ago
instead of debating christina versus mariah lets debate beyonce..oops imma get flamed for this comment who cares
Jesuslostprov31gurl 3 months ago
lol i can do that note
ThatsARandomNameLOL 3 months ago
ican do much better dan dat.lol. christina is awesome.wow.
leophrixify 3 months ago
@leophrixify NO YOU CANT. Shut up
TatyanaCouture 3 months ago
Haha I can that note but Christina a little more power and I'm a boy
rahzss 3 months ago
@zanoases still alternating between your hundreds of accounts, sad boy.
XTINASDISCIPLE 3 months ago
Christina sucks! Mariah shit under her feets has more power!
Yelling isnt singing you retarded Christina Stans! LOOOOL
zanoases 3 months ago
HAAAAAAAAA-OW-OW!!! yeah yeah yeah :'D
BlondeCurlsBlueEyes 3 months ago
@Unevan
No she dosnt dick head
123546879ify 4 months ago
does anybody notice that she has the mic down beside her before her "yeah yeah yeah" 's at the end???
UNevan 4 months ago
@UNevan It is clear that the video editor edited it that way...
DominicSings 3 months ago
I honestly,prefer a note like this,over mariah Carey's whistle register. its just nicer sounding,i think
955pokerface 4 months ago
dang!!!!!!!!!! she cant hit the highes fucking note ever
nae6731 4 months ago
@UNevan hey don't get agro at me bitch :O k i'll put up a video if it would make ur life happier :L
pixiepiaf 4 months ago
And this folks, is from no training and dancing around for 5 minutes, unlike other singers.
num1Jaysta 5 months ago
@UNevan lol i don't have to prove anything, i know what i can do??? how would u like me to prove it? put up a video so u can see that i actually can, whould that make u feel better? :L :L
pixiepiaf 5 months ago
@pixiepiaf how else would you fucking prove it????
UNevan 4 months ago
That's why I love her!!! *.*
tumy9 5 months ago
she has the most beautiful & powerful whistle register. . .and the most beautiful & powerful voice. . .she is the inspiration for my singing ---> Christina Aguilera
belifan09 5 months ago 8
@NickyPerilhou yeah :) okay my highest note is a c7/g6 and my lowest is C3. my VOCAL range is 4 octaves and and my longest note is about 15- 20 seconds. so yeah i can do that :L and guess what? ima boy!! :L
pixiepiaf 5 months ago 2
@pixiepiaf prove it.
UNevan 5 months ago
SHEEEEEEE ISSSSSSSSSSSSSSS THEEEEEEEEEEE BEST EVER NO ONE LOVES HER MORE THAN I DOOOOOOOOO
sweetheart4live 5 months ago
I can do that :L
pixiepiaf 5 months ago
@pixiepiaf Ohh really? What's your vocal range?
NickyPerilhou 5 months ago
i can do it. :p
NLMusiclover1 5 months ago
That's actually not that high for a girl. I can do it, and I can do it well, really. I'm not saying she doesn't have an amazing vocal talent but sometimes it just needs to be put into perspective. But Mariah... Now that's high and insanely controlled.
Typhoon792 5 months ago
@Typhoon792 then f*ckin do it.
daniellaj21 5 months ago
@daniellaj21 I.. do... When necessary... You mean upload a video of me doing it? That's fucking retarded...
Typhoon792 5 months ago
@Typhoon792 Right!!! It's a high note but a lot of girls can hit that note...especially if you're under 12. But Mariah's notes are off the charts. It's the kind that you have to cover your ears cause it's so friggin high!
ghislaine1983 5 months ago
@ghislaine1983 :) I'm a guy though. It's a whistle note and many don't know how to do it actually. For a girl, often times it can be reached with head voice.
Typhoon792 5 months ago
to even compare this to Mariah is just..thanks but no thanks.
notoriousjaz09 5 months ago
Wat song is that
WildThang340 5 months ago
@WildThang340 what a girl wants!
MrRafaTony 5 months ago
yes... yes i can do that :))
AdamsMusic11 5 months ago
@SteveCapSud
She does not have 5 octaves I actually bought Stripped everyone knows that G2 in fighter is her its Charles Hines (background vocals) and the "G7" I don't think so! I don't even trust her C#7 studio! Just like with "Beautiful" she has never been able to produce the F#5 live, her true range is Eb3 - Bb6, and that was in prime now it is Eb3 - Eb6 and I will say she can probably go to F#6 maybe G6 and that Eb6 was only once other than that her highest has been G#5!
OKzs 5 months ago
Mariah can, and she can even go higher, but I have much love for both,
iiloveyyou1 6 months ago 2
Yes that was not super high but im a fan :) did she ever got far as B6?
saweyes 6 months ago
@saweyes xtina? , she can reach the c7 or c#7 not sure, she is one of the most powerfull whistler :)
themasterflexG 5 months ago
Yes I can do That boy you must be really...I don't know..what not to hit that note...
:D LOL
wildpeach222 6 months ago
I can do this and I'm not even a singer.
MissAmericanDreamO9 6 months ago
omg i just tried it and did it... except i rlly hurt my throat
GeminiFirewall 6 months ago
i can do it? lmfao
#teamxtina <3333333333
SharonxxMay 6 months ago
love that performace, what a girl wants, what a girl needs haha love u xtina <3
maiosmusiclover 6 months ago
I love singing high notes like this haha
VictoriaGraceB 6 months ago
i can hit that note easily and higher
MrandMrsSodapop 6 months ago
yes i can do this also!!! and much Higher!! lol
iam0wenn 6 months ago
i cant, but mariah can :L love them both!
an0nm0us 7 months ago 9
wow! that high whistle note is so beautiful
aapascrom96 7 months ago 2
Bullshit video
nltn 7 months ago
@nltn pressed huh?
rzzzq87 6 months ago
none of you fucking assholes can do it. shut your faces.
(no, i am no directing this at the jokers. this is directed at the smug ignorant bitches who think they're special.)
telanis9 7 months ago
@telanis9 seriosuly?
there actually are a lot of ppl who can do this.
A G6 for girls in falsetto is possible altho it hurts
whistle register is an extension of head voice and its physically reachable for almost everyone
have u ever done a high pitched scream? Yeah... thats an uncontrolled whistle
from a technical point of view hitting a G6 by screaming is easy. LOL
PlayBadRomance100 2 months ago
@PlayBadRomance100 but christina sang it, its with vibrato and sustained and beautiful to hear.
Anime00Freak 1 month ago
i love her voice. POWERFUL AND SEDUCTIVE
leophrixify 7 months ago
i can do it
MrandMrsSodapop 7 months ago
actually, i can do this note, and so can my little brother, but i love christina still :D
123buffylover 7 months ago
I Can :D
AlejandraLizarragaV 7 months ago
Yea. I Can Do That Too.
dejai12345 8 months ago
Definitely... no joke. (:
dinaedward 8 months ago
:) i love xtina! :D
pinky09punk 8 months ago 2
Brilliant... though not her best outfit
readbtwnlines 8 months ago
Yes i can do that!
MooshieV 8 months ago
Mimi (Mariah Carey) can does the best of whistle notes
(there r a lots of her own songs use these notes)
But Christina Aguilera has the most powerful epic voice...
...that no one on this planet has!
EARAEZTE 8 months ago 49
Christina is the best ! Damn i love her voice she so versatile !
She can do everything with that awesome voice !
09neftali 8 months ago 3
yes i can lol !!!!!!!!!!
LovableNails 8 months ago 2
Yes, I can.
Streichholzli333 9 months ago
i love both xtina and mariah
xtina beats her in power
mariah has her in range
both are two different artists who are two of the best singers of all time
kellykellyfan15 9 months ago 3
I Can too:)!
raul7193 9 months ago
Não gosto das músicas dela, mas que nota alta! Jesus!
rafaelbernardorb 9 months ago
yes, i can
201011221 9 months ago
BELOW MEE. troll(:
SuperCupcakesArePink 9 months ago
mariah can hit higher
but they both suck
rebecca black wins and mariah's and christina's voices suck
rebecca black's voice is much more beautiful and powerful and versatile than christina and mariah!yeah
iamaveryuglyboy 9 months ago
@iamaveryuglyboy No that's not true!
raul7193 9 months ago
@raul7193 XD
iamaveryuglyboy 9 months ago
@iamaveryuglyboy suck ur dick!!!
xanthopia 9 months ago
@xanthopia no i want to suck dicks of hot guys~
iamaveryuglyboy 9 months ago
you honestly cannot compare mariah and christina cause firstly in my opinion christina is better in my eyes cause she could do what mariah does and more. DID you EVER see mariah dancing all over the stage so interactive and do those whistles NO. well christina can :]
jg9212 9 months ago
@jg9212 she has before. She doesn't just stand there all the time lol I can show you videos where mariah is dancing and singing. I do give christina credit for dancing and singing at the same time though not many professional singers can do that.
hessounusual95 9 months ago
@jg9212 dude... thats not even a real whistle ^ its falsetto. u can tell the difference...
PlayBadRomance100 2 months ago
@PlayBadRomance100 shes does plenty of whistles , no matter if there just falsettos or actual whistles there all amazing .
jg9212 2 months ago
mariah & christina are both good in their own unique ways i dont think they shuld be compare i love them both the same
pdronaly 9 months ago
How called this song? please XD
mrGilbert03 10 months ago
@mrGilbert03 What a girl wants is the name of the song. hahaha
(and this performance is on Stripedd tour U.K
starpatt 9 months ago
Beautiful, i love her so so so much!!
fasayago 10 months ago
she did the same note in the same song more than 3 times....
in here, she just hit the G6 but, her highest notes was Bb6 (in live)
aangcarey 10 months ago
Yes :D
patyrgh 10 months ago
why is every mariah carey fan talking shit like every singer is trash if they can't sing like mariah?
christina has her own technique... and that even mariah won't be able to do it
kgntndh 10 months ago
Can I do this? Well...yes.
Wagnerlover777 10 months ago
Yes i Can!!!!!!
xtinalove2 10 months ago
i can do that except for the very last note. lol
violetgirl1996 10 months ago
Yes I can .
Hmm Let's try Oh my window is broken ;/
No I definility can't
Y8OMaRyY8O 11 months ago
@Y8OMaRyY8O
haha lol
violetgirl1996 10 months ago
Umm, why do you bring Mariah and Britney here? They both have great voices, but big part of my friends even don't know Mariah and they call Britney a stripper. I'm huge fan of Christina and Britney, and I love them both! <3 Mariah has great voice, but maybe she isn't that popular than Christina.. in teenagers.
Rosenaification 11 months ago
Antwoord = Nee. :)
KawaiiPlush 11 months ago
why do she cover her ear?
JocJav 11 months ago
@JocJav Cuz if you push there, you can hear yourself. She couldn't because there was so much noise =]
KawaiiPlush 11 months ago
Anyone can do this, just kick them in the genitals.
PDC1987 11 months ago
Please!!! G6 is easy Well for me!! And If You want to put difficult notes this are really difficult Notes from F#7, G#7,C8,G#8, To C9, Eb9 etc...
ivennein 1 year ago
I like Christina's voice!!! She has an amazing vocal range!!!
Super29041991 1 year ago
she´s amazing, soooooo original , i love her voice so much
19ilana 1 year ago
for me she's a queen of vocalist *-*
tunawisevolanatnan 1 year ago
Chrstina sings so much better than Mariah, she's on another league: with frank sinatra, elvis & the platters, so there is no comparison, so stop talking bout her. and this note is great!!!!
maiosmusiclover 1 year ago
OH HELL NO THIS BITCH BELOW ME DID NOT JUST TRY TO HATE ON CHRISTINA..... This bitch better hide well cause im coming after her!!!
ccfs5 1 year ago 50
@ccfs5 I laughed so hard when i read your comment haha. But i do agreee, i lovee christina, she's the best.
ryc101 1 year ago 2
@ryc101 thanks but its true didnt u hear about the kill that got killed three weeks ago well I LIKE TO KEEP MY PROMISIS PLUS SHE DIDNT HIDE WELL
ccfs5 1 year ago
@ccfs5 I could probably help along, right?
xxXCrimsonNightsXxx 6 months ago
for all MARIAH CAREY FANS, go away, this is a christina aguilera video.
201011221 1 year ago 5
what burlesque did incredible and her voice was AMAZING just cause mariah lost her voice and can no longer do whistles as she showed on her FLOPPED christmas album where she put pre recorded whistles everywhere. Just cause a person can sell records it doesnt make them an amazing singer HERE RIGHT here christina can sing her ass off & STILL CAN !
jg9212 1 year ago
@jg9212 Her Christmas album DOUBLED Bionic's sales and TRIPLED the Burlesque soundtrack's sales. She also got a #1 hit on the adult chart, and broke a record for fastest rise to #1. Stay mad that your fave is flopping and is an even worse singer than Rihanna now. Xtincta LOST her voice completely. She can't belt for shit.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself uhm are you serious go on rolling stones 100 best singers of all time and mariahs 79 while christina sits at 58 come on there is music of christina singing THIS year were she sounds the same. can you show me something that shows christinas lost her voice ? OK thankyou mariah is well in her 40's and needs to just sit down and go to sleep. Dont come on this video trying to bash if you dont like you can get the fuck off.
jg9212 1 year ago
@jg9212 Rolling Stone lost credibility years ago. People just think Xtina is better because she screams as loud as she can. Christina has completely destroyed her upper register, which was actually never very good to begin with. She is also the queen of dodging notes and straining: /watch?v=9dIukEG-Y54. You sound mad that Mariah is the Queen. More successful, talented, and all around better than Floptina. Bye.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself Right.
Stefano94x 1 year ago
@Stefano94x Pressed and speechless, I see.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself you must be completely oblivious to think rolling stones has lost credibility YOUR just mad christina has come in a higher standard for singing. Now i will admit mariah has more sales and popularity but truly just because your popular it doesnt make you more talented. Now your saying her upper register is gone i dont think so watch?v=HDeaCDUXHcc there you go a quick video less then 7 months ago it sounds great so you need to do alittle more research
jg9212 1 year ago
@jg9212 That performance was alright, but there were no high notes. The highest note was a D5. If she tries to sing anything over that, she croaks. All Xtina does is dodge the high notes live. She's NEVER hit the high note in Beautiful or Fighter. Her upper register is gone, and it has been since her debut. Even then, it wasn't great. She always croaked while singing the high note in I Turn to You. I just find her voice incredible overrated. There are several singers out who are better than her.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself are you serious no she does not you act like your next to her and know everything she cant do that. what makes you think she cant like seriously stop putting her down she sing the same and for the beautiful live how about this one for the grammy she did even better then the video as quoted by many that it was alot better watch?v=daixgZaIR0w or fighter /watch?v=GKCWGmE1Y60 and her doing the same in 2010 /watch?v=U2Eo1n4UZ1k her VOICE IS THE SAME AND GREAT AND POWERFUL enough said
jg9212 1 year ago
@repenttyourself & ofcourse you would send a video of her messing up you make it seem like thats every live performance. You need to get out your bubble and realize even mariah makes mistakes. so can you just leave you must be on this video for a reason. its says christina not mariah but i mean you would be a so called "hater" have nothing else to do.
jg9212 1 year ago
Get off of Mariah's nuts and leave Christina alone. Take away the "whistle factor" and Christina wins.
Mariah's voice is beautiful, no arguments, but it is also thin, breathy and today when she sings it sounds like she's hissing. There are few songs of hers where I hear true emotion and passion. Christina is versatile and can sing virtually any genre.
btw THIS IS CHRISTINA'S VIDEO, TAKE THAT MARIAH SHIT SOMEWHERE ELSE.
SpunkStalker101 1 year ago 102
@SpunkStalker101 so true
201011221 1 year ago
@SpunkStalker101 Mariah, unlike Christina, does have a complete control throughout her range. And Mariah's voice is not thin at all. It is just light. And resonates WAY more than Christina's voice.
Christina is the one with a thin voice. No resonance indeed, her voice is not powerful but just loud. Her emission is so throaty and strained.
Stefano94x 1 year ago
@Stefano94x I never said that Mariah doesn't have control. I think her voice is thin and with not much emotion, but that is my opinon. Christina is the best in the world, to me.
SpunkStalker101 1 year ago
@SpunkStalker101 When you say a voice is "thin" it's not an opinion, because it's a matter of technique. When a voice is thin, it lacks resonance, and that's Christina's case. If you say you don't find her voice soulful, it's your opinion and that's fine, there's nothing I can do about it. But Mariah's voice is not thin at all, and that's a fact. It is far more supported, flexible and resonant than Christina's one.
Stefano94x 1 year ago
@SpunkStalker101 Well you have to consider Mariah's voice is a bit worn though. I mean, in her heyday, she could belt just as well as Christina, but with a better tone quality. And her emotion goes mostly in her older songs, like I Don't Wanna Cry, Vision of Love, etc. But make no mistake, Christina is also amazing, she's very powerful and also has a very good range. I honestly don't see why people have to keep comparing them, they're both great, end of story.
SharpestAerrow 10 months ago
@SharpestAerrow I agree, to each their own. I do like a lot of Mariah's older music, as you pointed out. I think it was better quality and she wasn't afraid to let it all out. But sadly, like the great Whitney Houston, today her voice is just an echo of what it used to be. I think Christina and maybe Celine Dion are the only true great singers left today.
SpunkStalker101 10 months ago
@SpunkStalker101
There are many fools in this world that like to compare the artists.....
Im fan of MC n i dont like Cristina at all, but thats no reason to underrate her, n to compare her with MC (for me shes the greatest singer ever) but C has a notable vocal talent !
Seductor258 8 months ago
@SpunkStalker101 mariah's voice was stronger back in the days, now it's very thin and whispery like u said
sheru7mera7naam007 7 months ago
@SpunkStalker101 Amen
lovemusvi01 7 months ago
Mariah Carey, the best vocalist of all time, can do this with ease. Floptina can't even sing now.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself floptina your mother, bitch she sing now and mariah? where is mariah? is invisible now
201011221 1 year ago
@201011221 Where is Mariah? Outselling Christina and actually GETTING HITS. Sorry you stan for a flop hasbeen who can't sing anymore.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself of course, i see her face in the TV ALL THE TIME ! oh pleace. go to a old mariah video. but a last time notice, THIS IS A CHRISTINA AGUILERA VIDEO BITCH. floptina have more attitude than mariah.
201011221 1 year ago
@201011221 LMFAOOOOO. I can barely understand this, but just know that Mariah is better than Floptina in literally EVERY possible way. Better singer, isn't a flop, has sold more than 160 million more records than Xtina, etc.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself mariah have decades of years, she's a old women, christina have just 10 years in the industry and is a legend, so shut up
201011221 1 year ago
@201011221 Nope, Xtina is far from a legend. She'll be forgotten in ten years while Mariah is still getting hits and selling records! Mariah's Christmas album sold more than any Xtina album since 2006.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself you can see the future?? oh my god ! listen to "cruz" it's a song of chrisitna, "living today!" and today her voice is legendary, hahahaha oh god, back to basic is one of the best albums in the last 20 years!
201011221 1 year ago
@201011221 It's just an obvious trend. Floptina peaked with her debut album, and her sales have been dwindling ever since. Back to Basics didn't even get good reviews, sooo... nope. It didn't sell too well either.
repenttyourself 1 year ago
@repenttyourself christina always is original, she change her image in every Cd she don't care about what people like you is thinking. everybody said in stripped record was a musical suicide, but is a excelent Album. and mariah is over, nobody remenber her...
201011221 1 year ago
@201011221 Mariah is over? Is that why she was the fourth biggest female artist of the decade, and Floptina was #19? Mariah also had the biggest song of the decade with We Belong Together. U mad?
repenttyourself 1 year ago
Amy Lee can sing higher and longer but ive gotta say, that was fucking amazing!
lilchewyz 1 year ago
This is whistle, is so high it can't be anything else I think.
NausAllien 1 year ago
i think that amy lee can beat this ;)
darkkeness666 1 year ago 2
@darkkeness666 YEAH!!!!!!! Not only can she beat this but she can be the respect factor.AMY LEE PWNS!
monkeygirl333sm 1 year ago
@monkeygirl33sm Really I think that the TALENT is way better that te IMAGE, 3/4 of her body is naked WTF! amy say that (:
darkkeness666 1 year ago
@darkkeness666 Amy is just the best in every single way. Period. =-D
monkeygirl333sm 1 year ago
Christina better than Mariah CURRY..
Xtina can dance and sing whereas Mariah scary only yelling like MADWOMAN haha
sariandmarco 1 year ago 2
I got chills!!! haha, that for me means amazing!!!
pastry1000 1 year ago 2
This is G6 her highest note live is A6 but G6 is still ridiculously high
NinjutsuTenor01 1 year ago
best vocalist ...but dont hate on good artist like mariah,beyonce,or anybody else thats good ....but you can hate on people that cant even sing like..kesha,lady gaga or anybody else who uses auto in every word they sing
petfan1202 1 year ago
@petfan1202 You're an idiot. Lumping Gaga with autotuned singers? Uh, Gaga can actually sing live and well. You clearly have your head up your ass if you think she's in the Kesha, Rihanna, Katy Perry mold.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
i never knew she could hitthose notes. her voice is rare
kellykellyfan15 1 year ago
@kellykellyfan15 yeah she used to hit these high soprano notes all the time when she was younger during her debut and stripped days. The note showcased in the video is not even her highest live note!
bakatais 1 year ago
That's not even her highest live note!
bakatais 1 year ago
& stfu talking about she can do better. She can, but y'all put it like the note is bad, or not high. A lot of artist now can't even touch this note, & she hit it pitch perfectly with a run & peaking @ a G6. That's beyond epic.
LifeisMusic07 1 year ago
You can clearly tell it's a whistle. She just doesn't have "airy" whistles. Her's are very full when she executes them correctly. Everyone has different quality notes & whistle notes, just like people have different voices & timbres. I love her head voice/whistle register.
LifeisMusic07 1 year ago 2
@LifeisMusic07 It's not a whistle, it's a head voice/falsetto note. Whistle isn't that full sounding. It's more impressive to be able to go that high without whistle register anyway.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
@mellynumerounoo Well whatever it is, it sounds good. Sounds like whistle to me though. If you think about when people actually whistle, like with their mouth, it'd be considering a 'whistle."
LifeisMusic07 1 year ago
@LifeisMusic07 Listen to her G6 in "Hello" live in Milan...that was whistle. They sound diff. Also her C#7 in "The Christmas Song" studio version--that's also whistle. Whistle doesn't sound as full as the note she hit here does. Sounds more like super-high head voice.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
@mellynumerounoo In my last comment I never actually said it was a whistle. I said it "sounds" like a whistle considering what I said.
LifeisMusic07 1 year ago
@LifeisMusic07 Oh, gotcha.
mellynumerounoo 1 year ago
She sang higher in i turn to you i think!
catsmartie 1 year ago
Christina can do anything and everything. She is my angel of music ♥
SpunkStalker101 1 year ago 4
reminds me of Arkha Sva
grindylover 1 year ago
@Xtina4evahLegend well, tbh. Christina outshine's Gaga. Christina had all these crazy outfit's before Gaga was even famous. Aguilera forever. <3
DeclannMVs 1 year ago
she can do WAYY better than that!
LupitaP1999 1 year ago
Only in my wildest dreams!...Her version of Etta James' "At Last" is banging!
diannakaplan04 1 year ago
suck it britney
Dude0096 1 year ago 21