Added: 2 years ago
From: henrygillardlive
Views: 119,821
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (540)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm sorry. If your going to put up a judge tape for the Blue Devils break, make it one FOR THE BLUE DEVILS BREAK. Not a random spot in the show that looks like drum break.

  • Did mike Mac write for cavies that year?

  • i can't believe Phantom got 8th. Maybe not the flashiest feature of that year, but the cleanest and tastiest.

  • Vanguard break is sick..

  • around 2:49 it looks like one of the snares triped

  • is the bald guy standing around the corps a judge?

  • 5:14 lol toss around the black guy.

  • Yo.. That link to the judge tape.. Doesn't have the break that you have on this video.. Sooo nice try

  • Comment removed

  • @jpl0219 It was recorded from 5 feet in front of them, not 50 feet to the side. Seems better to me. Fan network goes for the most dramatic angles, but not necessarily the best ones to record from.

  • When there's dirt in straight diddles,Troopers, then you know the order is messed

  • at 2:27 is a huge dci dick

  • @Mega0821 UR HIGH GUARDSMAN:

  • Press 9 for the greatest drum break in history.

  • giant penis at 2:27? lol... and cavaliers/blue coats the best. my high school drum line instructor is the bus driver for the cavaliers. its pretty kool. he gets to go to all there competitions and he can play alot of there snare music. just hes to fat to march lol. ill be lead snare next year and looking forward to an awesome year, this year playing "distorted" from cirque du something drum break.

  • Blue Stars tenors? Where are they?

  • blue stars hahahahaha!

  • santa Clara vanguard drum break sucked!!

  • Comment removed

  • Crown at 5 is also a pretty good joke.

  • I think that they are all well done, clean, technical and musical. But, and I know I'm gunna hear it, DCI has become very formulaic, including the drum breaks. There are alot of elements(almost cliches) that are becoming trite and tired.Every drum solo has to be accented by the pit with some atonal scale runs.I can list several more cliches. Don't all you drummers watch the "in the lot" videos more? It's almost better to hear them without all the triteness.

  • @lemonite1 with the exception if the blue stars 09

  • @lemonite1 Agreed. Except for SCV and Bluecoats.

  • im telling paul rennick, and hes gunna beat u DOWN

  • Comment removed

  • 2:25 Phallic reference?

  • The only reason why BD is in first is because they are afterall, BD. Given that they have more 1st place trophies than they can count would indicate placing them in first for this video...however, even though I am a drummer and have been part of both WGI and DCI, I can't allow the Devils to recieve this title...BlueCoats got it, nuff said...and whoever disputes this claim obviously is just sad because their heroes lost for once...

  • Yeah Ed! Play that marimba! :P

  • Apparently, you didn't get the memo either. I was also being sarcastic. The chairs made them look like they're good. It just ave them a visual aspect. Bluecoats win. Hands down.

  • I love Boston at #4...one of the most underrated corps ever year

  • I still think bluecoats' drumbreak is better.... Dude... I was there... It was better than BD...

  • @sn1p3r1524 But... the Blue Devils are standing on chairs! That has to make them the best, right?

  • @vancemundegaar no.....that just makes them look cool... dont get me wrong...i love bd. but bluecoats took it that year... if you wanna talk about 2010...phantom for sure.

  • @sn1p3r1524 Sarcasm doesn't translate well over the internet... I think the chairs are the worst in a series of visual gimmicks that BD's used in the past couple of years, which for some unimaginable reason the judges eat up... I don't mean to disrespect the people in BD, they're some of the most talented people in the business. But the shows they march in don't let them show it

  • @sn1p3r1524 i like it too but the only prob they use to much visuals now dont get mad but i thinks thats why they got second i think i might be wrong

  • @BSBINC1 Visuals don't mean shit for the drumming that's why I don't like BD's. Probably because Santa Clara AND Bluecoats did way better.

  • I wanna know where Carolina Crown gets the kind of money to change uniforms, drums, drum heads, and everything else... I WANT THAT KIND OF MONEY!!!

  • @TheRew400 and look at me, I play for BD, and I can stand on top of a chair and play! woooooooo..... *they're overrated...*

  • I'm sorry, but posting a link to a judge's tape doesn't prove BD's break isn't dirty. It sounds cleaner because the mic he is speaking into is only picking up a few of the snares. Don't get me wrong, it was cleaner in person than it is in this video, but it wasn't THAT clean.

  • @TheLogan1156 that doesn't even make sense at all, were you right on the field infront of the line??? of coarse not, he posting the link so you can hear the JUGDES COMMENT on the break, it wasn't meant to sound good, hence the "tape" quality your are hearing is not suppose to sound amazing. srry but you can't argue about the break being dirty at all

  • @bmascara34 It wasn't that clean and the scores from finals prove it. It wasn't really all that dirty, but it definitely wasn't that clean, either.

  • @TheLogan1156 dude, like i said theres no way you can justify that it was clean or not, you weren't on the field, infront of the drumlne during the finals preformance. and the score does prove it, they scored a 19.8 witch is very close to 20.

  • @bmascara34 What the hell do you mean you can't justify if it was clean or not? Shit sounds like shit no matter what asshole it comes out of. Being a drummer myself I know what dirt is, and blue devils was as close to dirt as it could go, they may have been clean the rest of the show, but that drum break should not have been in first. I think blue coats deserve that one..

  • Blooooooooooooooooooooooooo! :D

  • blue stars 9?

  • Omg bd was so dirty ugh

  • Well it does say WE picked. I didn't though so I can't complain. Nice list!!!

  • Thanks for blowing the release of your feature SCV, I appreciate it.

  • YEAHHH Boston crusaders

  • Bluecoats break was way better than Devils, period.

  • The way BD played their break this time around, it shouldn't have even made this list. MY GOD! WAS SOMEONE MAKING POPCORN!?

  • Carolina Crown hands down.

  • Troopers before Phantom Regiment? Come one man.

  • damn blue stars stepping up!

  • God. when SCV started, i wet myself:)

  • 7:09 that bluecoats colorgaurd GIRL on the right has an amazing ass

  • SCV bass 1 is tiny!!!

  • Why does everyone thing Phantom has the best battery section?

  • @MikeyyDrumss Because it's true.

  • wheres 2069?

  • wheres 2010

  • wheres 2011

  • @headgrandma101 Thanks!

  • hey, im new to this DCI thing. i have a question, whats drum break?

  • lol at 8:09 the judge is all like look at that clarity and then it's all like PWNED

  • does anybody else agree that blue devils sound like ape hair?!

  • @hellomanhowareyou Couldnt agree more. If BD sucks then BD wins

  • uhhhhhh doesn't phantom win like top drums every year

  • @lildrummercoop2007 no its kinda been blue devils every other year, bd won drums in 07, then phantom in 08, then bd again in 2009, and phantom in 2010

  • Can you spot Banished? I can ;)

  • 10-Cadets 9 -B Stars 8 -Troopers 7 -Blue Devs 6- Cavies 5 -B Crusaders 4 -SCV 3 - Phantom 1 - TIE Crown 1 - TIE Blue Coats (both played serious notes that year)
  • i may get some negative feedback about this, but i think the crusaders deserved #3 instead of vanguard

  • I'm sorry, but I remember when drum features were longer than 30 seconds. If you blink nowadays you miss most of the break.

  • 6:37 end snare loses his stick. i've watched this video so many times and have never seen that!

  • go to 8:08 and tell me that triplet roll isn't dirty.... listen hard.... one of the CLEANEST was Phantom.... BD is over rated and will always be over rated.... ITS IMPOSSIBLE TO COMPARE A WEST COAST CORPS THAT DOESN'T REALLY COMPETE WITH ANYONE ELSE INTO HALFWAY THROUGH TOUR! LOOK AT THE SCHEDULES, THEIR ONLY COMPETITION IS SANTA CLARA!!! and wouldn't you know it, those two are usually (meaning always) in the top two for half the summer.... but who are they compared to??? pioneer??? troopers???

  • @dilligan360 Ok....not only are you bashing BD and SCV, but you're also implying that Pioneer and Troopers are inferior. They're all the same kids working their butts off for three months that should've been their summer vacation. Show some respect. And stop your complaining....Phantom and Cadets will be heading West this year and you can bet that BD will still be consistent in their ranking.

  • @dilligan360 its not all about the triplet roll! plus bd won that so ....... get over it and enjoy the video ...... peace out!

  • that was sick but you should put 2010 drum breaks on

  • '09 SCV was very cute!! haha

  • People hate on BD for the same reason people hate the Yankees or Lakers or anyone or any group that is constantly in the # 1 spot. Its Envy, its smallness, and it says more about the inadequacies of the person doing the hating than it does about the object of their hate. Personally loved all of these Breaks, BD's seemed the most challenging. I heard no dirt, nor hair but then again I wasnt looking for it because Im no hater.

  • Bluecoats , nuff said

  • @sniggitydebo definatlyyyy

  • woah blue devils used chairs so they have to be the best!

  • SCV <3

  • so it's kind of funny that you post a link to the video that "explains" why the drum break sounds dirty but the linked video with the judges tape doesn't even include the actual drum break in it where the field judge probably goes on about how dirty the drum break actually is...

  • @aosborne678 The judge says "very tough playing conditions.

  • man blue devils 2009 show = win

  • Ha! 60 people like the penis.

  • Damn, that littleTroopers thing was not too shabby.

    Way to go, Troop.

  • phantom definatly not number 8

  • does anybody else love the black guard guy at 5:13

  • phantom at #8?! good joke

  • @erob2011 i know im a bd fan and phanton shoulda won high drums

  • @erob2011

    xD That's what I said. I think Phantom Regiment has one of the cleanest, well executed drum break in DCI. =\

  • blasphemy

  • 3:48. =)

  • I liked coats better when they weren't an indoor drum line.

  • 4:07 nazi sign

  • i freaking hate the percussion judge!

    when your standing there blasting out a break but trying to listen to make sure its clean, while being watched by thousands of people and having the guy whos giving your rating get all up in your face right before yu have to walk up and end up hitting him.

  • bluestars had a sweet drum break, too bad it was dirty :\

  • I think Phantom could have been in the top 3. They had it together and super clean.

  • i played for the devils in 96 and 97

    if ppl knew what kind of training we went through you would do your best at all times

    there was fun and games but when it got down to buisness we got serious

    i heard the some bands just play and go home

    we played marched ran worked out and we ran laps when we messed up so we

    would do our best at all times plus scott johnson is a great leader

  • @henrygillardlive To be fair that ksjjg23 is right. No one actually listens to drum breaks anymore. Drum Corps is all politics now...It's all about who can throw more money at DCI who wins, hence BD. And by no means is BD not good, but I'm sure you don't agree with some of the drum breaks put in the order that they were for this video. It just disappoints me to see these great drumlines not get ranked well in the video when judges say differently.

  • You need one for 2010 man!

  • @chrizz323 the break was just a snare bass break, for that part at least. this realization came after two weeks of searching for a tenor transcription of it. haha

  • where is 2010!?!?!?!?!?

  • West Side Story at 2:04?

  • Were they playing Shirley Murphy's at 0:39-0:40?

  • BLUEE DEVILLSSS WASS SOOO DIRTYYYYYYY !

  • @woahhitsgillyx dude shut up every band on there was great, bluedevils are always good people just hate them cause they do so well, there like the james logan of WBA

  • @DNAsxe i do agree that people hate on them alot, but this one was pretty dirty for the #1 spot it put them on in the video.

  • Wow do the Blue stars march tenor drums? I couldn't see them on the break. If they don't is there any reason why?

  • @chrizz323 They do, you just can't really see them. If you look closely at around :39 you can see them in the fourth row of field props.

  • all of them are amaizng but i enjoyed scv alot!!!

  • Bluecoats as #2 !?!!? This is blasphemy! They should be #1!!!!

  • i marched snare for my highschool on this field, most amazing thing i have to say

  • kudos to whoever wrote troop's percussion...shit, kudos to the whole staff...they've come a long way in a very short amout of time.

  • hell yeah coats!!

  • if you could re do this without all the xylephone crap it would be 10000 times better.

  • What is all that gay xylophone crap and stuff over the drums? shit sucks

  • @schm0ee What is all that gay schm0ee crap and stuff on youtube? shit sucks

  • Not gonna lie I'm a huge phantom regiment fan.. But even tho the Boston Crusaders were a little sloppy they threw it down and that was definatly my favorite drum break!

  • SCV! woo woo!

  • ok so how long have the troopers been around? it seems like they just came out of nowhere

    ps: BD should go away. cuz they are like the Yankees of DCI. like everyone knows taht more than likely, they (BD) are gonna win... it kinda gets annoying

  • @guitarxgodx100 phantom won 2008, and bd 2010 sucks, so i don't think they always win.

  • @guitarxgodx100 are you serious? the troopers are one of dci's oldest organizations...

  • @r680187 didnt know. i guess i never really looked for em

  • @guitarxgodx100

    They have been around since 1957. The reason it seems like they came out of no where is because they weren't very successful competitively in the 90s and early 2000's. They ended up taking 2006 off to reorganize. Due to this, they came back a lot stronger and "came from no where."

  • ok so how long have the troopers been around? it seems like they just came out of nowhere

  • crown's break got right where they should've gotten, 30 seconds of nothing entertaining and the pit was outplaying them

  • 6:42 poor shot

  • WHERE IS THE 2010 VIDEO

  • wow this was so terrible.. should have had crown 1st.. espically considering they got high percussion that year... then caots were in the right position, then BD 3rd... this was a terrible placement video

  • @masterdrummer19 ....-_-

    If you watched to the end, you would have clearly seen, he didn't choose the order, youtube users did.

    And crown didn't win high percussion that year, the only caption Blue Devils lost was Brass and Ensemble Music.

    To be honest I agree...crown should have won, and gotten high percussion, but damn get your shit straight lol.

  • @ARZiehm well on yamahas web site it says that crown got first.... idk why then, but yeah i feel like crown should have won.

  • Bluecoats should'nt even be considered a drumline. They are more of a DOPEline if you ask me

  • this stuff is so intense

  • Can you do one for 2010???

  • 2:27 anyone? Hahaha

  • blue devils weren't really all that great... they sounded like crap in some spots... there were other drum breaks in this vid that should have been above blue devils, because they were clean...

  • I Believe that drill wise, with all the field movements, I believe #3, Santa Clara Vanguard, is my favourite. Out of the drum breaks, mine has to be BD

  • heck yeah BD always wins :D BD FTW!!

  • Must BD always win?

  • @CarterrXXX that's what I ask people when they yell "GO BD!"... but really? cavies are better, in my personal opinion...

  • The bluecoats sounded dirty on the DVD but on the judges tape you can really see how clean that whole closer was. I think they deserved at least 2nd in perc for 09. And I'm not sure Phantom's line in 2010 deserved 1st but I wasn't on the field. I thought the bluecoats and cavies were better if you include total package with the pit. But I'm not a judge. Cool video!

  • bLuEcOaTs.

  • well its the fact that he was so quick to defend the blue devils that relly they didnt deserve it at least give it the drumline that deserves it no jus because the corps is ur faviort at least attach a tape to all of them to see the truth cause relly the blue devils wer dirty and u kno it

  • I like how the dirtiest one gets #1. and don't try and go to the link that says "if you think this is dirty, click here", because it just takes you to a judges tape that isn't even judging the same drum break in that show. its the judge tape for an earlier drum break. Bluecoats should be number 1. Blue Devils should be dead last.

  • @corey0881 thats part one of the judge tape. look for part two.

  • gotta love the inevitable penis formations :D 2:28

  • I love trucking judges

  • Wow blue devils are amazing! Im pn the drumline but were not like that! Wow and santa... U no whixh 1 the were prerty good 2

  • once agian bd is over rated

  • what a suprise.. the blue devils won, didnt expect that

  • Blue Devils SUCK MY DICK

  • These are mostly good. I would say my top 3 are Blue Devils for sure, with a tie between the Santa Clara Vanguard and the Boston Crusaders

  • SANTA CLARA ALL DA WAY!

  • wheres the 2010 version? 

  • 8:14 - 8:19 Hey, Scojo, why don't you rip off of Tom more? And I completely agree, BD's break was DIRT to the extreme! High drums? Yeah, they deserved what they got this year.

  • You BD fanboys need to get real.

  • @TigerGRhymes Tell that to the judges.

  • I like the people saying "Troopers made a penis LOLOLZ" like they're clever. Congratulations, you just pointed out the super obvious. You're not cool

  • Phantom deserved higher than what they were placed as

  • The tempos are so fast these days that everything sounds like double stroke roll. Bring back mm 120! a tempo where lines can get creative in double and triple meter!

  • The tempos are so fast these days that everything sounds like double stroke roll. Bring back mm 120! a tempo where lines can get creative in double and triple meter!

  • will you be making a Top 10 Drum Breaks of DCI 2010?

  • lol 2:30 penis

  • @kodani13 Quite the odd penis.

  • troopers really????

  • BAC nuff' said

  • anyone else see the breaks from 09 as being kind of lackluster? everything just sounds the same now... like i really liked blue stars and that was about it the rest were good but just seem so similar.

  • bluecoats hands down

  • @MooberrieBear yea man!

  • @MooberrieBear  yeah... nice drum line uniforms... bandos...

  • That little kid marching snare with the Boston Crusaders got chops!!  Kudos to the child prodigy!!

  • @Ldiggy707 dude thats jason bloom hes not a kid...