Hosea's win was the biggest ass-pull on this show. Really, what.the.fuck. Even though he wasn't my favorite, I always felt that Stefan was the clear winner of the season. Good going "judges."
thing is, stefan shoulda been there instead of jamie, she was just a waste of cast spot. But even then, stefan had more than enough skill to win his season.
i don't know what is the criteria of the judges, because stefan won almost all of the other challenges while hosea were always on the edge of the knife, you can't judge a chef because he had one bad day
after this, i don't believe this show could be taken seriously
This was arguably the weakest talent pool. I mean, c'mon. The guy hasn't gone to culinary school, and he doesn't even know how to filet a fish! Are you serious?
Stefan Richter was by far the superior chef. He was absolutely robbed that season.
Eric Ripert was interviewed (he tasted all of their food) and said Stefan should have won. The rest of the Top Chef "judges" realized what a big mistake they made after the fan reaction on the blogs (including Bravo's) went ballistic.
Rosenberg took any ANY remaining goodwill by giving Stefan the "finger" on national television.
I believe this was one of those moment the producers wanted a nice guy to feature----and related realized the fans did not need the "nice guy" to win and he wasn't that nice.
If you are a Top Chef fan you are more in awe of the skill
Yeah, I love how the producers don't even bother to give him a positive edit. There is not much to work with except the showmance and "STEFAN Wins all the quickfire, WAAAAAAAAAAAAA"
You did what you had to do to beat Stefan? Lets see:
-You threw your teammate Ariane under the bus to save your own skin & survive the challenge.
-You stole Stefan's fois gras.
-Selfishly grabbed all the caviar so no one else could have any.
-Gave Stefan the crocodile to cook when no one wanted it & stuck your middle finger at him. If you got the croc, would you handle it as well? Doubt it.
Stefan lost gracefully. Hosea won with no grace or dignity.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
NO!!! fuck him Hosea!! rub that shit in his face you worked hard for that shit....and he talked shit all season. you earned it...revel it it for godsakes.
Hosea's win was the biggest ass-pull on this show. Really, what.the.fuck. Even though he wasn't my favorite, I always felt that Stefan was the clear winner of the season. Good going "judges."
Roonzy 5 months ago
Stefan is so the clear Winner! <3
mellissize 6 months ago 2
thing is, stefan shoulda been there instead of jamie, she was just a waste of cast spot. But even then, stefan had more than enough skill to win his season.
yourmom654321 10 months ago
poor stefan
golddigger0325 1 year ago 2
i don't know what is the criteria of the judges, because stefan won almost all of the other challenges while hosea were always on the edge of the knife, you can't judge a chef because he had one bad day
after this, i don't believe this show could be taken seriously
rmshred 1 year ago 2
Hosea robbed Stefan.
08Cheeseits 1 year ago 7
This was arguably the weakest talent pool. I mean, c'mon. The guy hasn't gone to culinary school, and he doesn't even know how to filet a fish! Are you serious?
infamousmonster 1 year ago
hosea is a douche bag. bravo picked him to win because he's more marketable than stefan, the real season 5 winner.
magnuspater 1 year ago 3
pfft... they culdnt let an european win could they?
TomValedro 1 year ago 6
Stefan Richter was by far the superior chef. He was absolutely robbed that season.
Eric Ripert was interviewed (he tasted all of their food) and said Stefan should have won. The rest of the Top Chef "judges" realized what a big mistake they made after the fan reaction on the blogs (including Bravo's) went ballistic.
Rosenberg took any ANY remaining goodwill by giving Stefan the "finger" on national television.
syrvagabon 2 years ago 12
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! Stefan shoulda won this won, instead this bum lucks out and gets lucky at the right time
ldc62 2 years ago 8
FaBIO SHOULDA WON
GeoffShouldWin 2 years ago
I believe this was one of those moment the producers wanted a nice guy to feature----and related realized the fans did not need the "nice guy" to win and he wasn't that nice.
If you are a Top Chef fan you are more in awe of the skill
KB77TY 2 years ago 8
he didnt deserve to win
it was the weakest winning performance for a finale, none of his food was original, like Rocko said
doggieGZ 2 years ago 13
BOOOO HIS FOOD BELONGS IN THE TRASH!
NinkaPanda 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hosea rox i would lyke 2 see u try to cook lyke him
ducktapeobsession 2 years ago
Worst of all, Hobag is a Jennifer Aniston fan. he wants to poison Jolie with his crappy rice.
BellaGoth12 2 years ago 7
Hosea didn't deserve to win at all!!!
nitecraze21 2 years ago 26
true stephan deserved
TheSpeedguy09 1 year ago
hoseah's such a douche bag
doggieGZ 2 years ago 9
Yeah, I love how the producers don't even bother to give him a positive edit. There is not much to work with except the showmance and "STEFAN Wins all the quickfire, WAAAAAAAAAAAAA"
BellaGoth12 2 years ago 5
You did what you had to do to beat Stefan? Lets see:
-You threw your teammate Ariane under the bus to save your own skin & survive the challenge.
-You stole Stefan's fois gras.
-Selfishly grabbed all the caviar so no one else could have any.
-Gave Stefan the crocodile to cook when no one wanted it & stuck your middle finger at him. If you got the croc, would you handle it as well? Doubt it.
Stefan lost gracefully. Hosea won with no grace or dignity.
HindsightPOV 2 years ago 22
Comment removed
BellaGoth12 2 years ago
Hindsight hit that nail right on the head. I would like to add suck up to Tom and annoying shomance with Leah.
Worst winner since Illan(Season 2)
BellaGoth12 2 years ago 6
Stephan is the true champion
AlphaKillaX 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
congrats hosea!
hobocakes 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
NO!!! fuck him Hosea!! rub that shit in his face you worked hard for that shit....and he talked shit all season. you earned it...revel it it for godsakes.
bwayinlan 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"nice" and "steady". That sounds so *outstanding* to me!
Paella my arse, he'd make chicken nuggets.
whozituseit 3 years ago
I'd rather listen to Fabio, Carla, and even Stephan speak.
BellaGoth12 3 years ago 8