What an excellent cover! So many PF covers fail to do justice to the originals, but this one not only does that, it actually adds something new and novel. It's pretty unique to offer something new and worth listening to when one is referencing the sacred Pink Floyd canon. I know it's totally you and your own style and whatnot, but my take is "Jeff Buckley got together with the guys from Tool and dominated the world as a Floyd cover band, and the world's hunger for Floyd was sated."
This is great. Covers aren't supposed to replicate the originals. Who cares what note it's in. Listen to how Type O Negative did covers. If you can twist a masterpiece then you are a true musician. If you want it to sound the same as the original then go listen to the opriginal. Good job fellas.
@photogramistic .... it's not so important in what key you sing it as long the progression is the samme.... it's another band ... nothing is wrong with that. As long as i remmeber it's maybe the best cover i ever heard
@photogramistic ; like that matters this is an absolutely amazing reworking. i don't remember being this impressed by a floyd cover before - most of them just choose the wrong tunes, do too exacting a job or are downright poor quality, but this scores on all counts - i am right behind you, braintoy!
fuck yeah guys.......good-ass cover. the drums should be alot heavier though....less english cause with all that english, it looses its earieness. You know, cause that song DRIVES you know?....it drives the "sheep" to slaughter....there is no beating around the bush....."you are gonna die"....fuckin good ass cover though.
I clicked this link and thought to myself this was gonna be crap. A tough song to cover and right from the begining you guys were great. And then, your vocals, wow. Really you guys are good! Keep up the great work!
This is awesome. And yeah, Nightwish is fucking garbage. They're good musicians who waste their talent by writing shitty music. I am now going to be checking out Braintoy's music. And that's an awesome name btw.
It's a harmonica microphone. No effect. Jack white uses one live (in fact, he had one installed into his guitar :D) but some artists use a harmonica mic to create that AM radio effect (best way i can describe it). move from one mic to the other, with some delay, and u get that effect.
Great cover. I feel the big 'missing difference' is that this version seems more metal based and the original was more warm and blues based...Les Pauls can do that...
I agree with maese2000, the message of the song is lost in this version. The intensity is meant to be speared between the sung words, so we can imagine whats going on for ourself, as what psychadelical rock is all about. Imagination. This version steals all the imagination.
It's a good cover, but so much is missing. The bass is slapping that thing pretty good, but every other instrument does not do it's part in this song.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is fucking horrible. why does every singer today have to sing the same goddamn way. it takes away so much meaning from the song. because, instead of great artists writing new songs, we have crap artists taking great songs and changing them to meet today's standards. this sounds like if metallica and fallout boy teamed up to make a techno punk band. the key boardist in the video is damn good. but the guitarist gives it a weird feel,like emptiness. the drummer is good for the most part.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The singer seems to be just another face to me. I mean, I don't want to be a dousche. and my band probably won't sound as professional as these guys, but i know for a fact would could put more feeling into a Performance. and fuck professionality anyways, we don't listen to roger waters because of the way his music sounds, we listen to it because of what his work tells us about ourselves. But it doesn't matter what I say anyway, because nobody on here is going to agree with me.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don't really mean any harm by my comments. it's very good that bands like this are covering good songs. it's just not my style of music that these guys are playing. they seem like sellouts a bit. or atleast the singer might be an ignorant guy or just nothing special. and for all of you guys out there that like, to each his own. but this 17 year old is sticking to his vinyl LP'S. I enjoy writting about things that don't really matter.
crap... its nor just a song...when you hear this song.. dont you get the fell to make a revolution in the world........well, not that... but the entire litycs.. makes you fell courage!... dont you...?...the meaning does care... for me...i love this song...
its my feelings VS. yours...what do you feel when you hear this lirycs... ... its because for me this song must be singed stroger, and not so tragic as this cover is.. but is a VERY VERY GOOD cover...... dude i didnt ofended you. i have already a life...saludos desde mexico!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Tempo is off. No passion. No Gilmouresque guitar effects. Sorry, but it is piss poor. If you want t cover it, you at least have to master it and add your own identity, to not do so is to shame their name.
God way to have Balls , I agree with every good comment on this page. I love the original and hold it sacred , but this version is BALLS NASTY and wondeful .
This is one of floyds greatest anti establishment jams and you really did it proud.
hey guys? can you cover "High hopes" if nothing else just to show up that awful bag of crap nightwish version, go on chaps give them hell, show the Finnish tossers how it's meant to be done :O))
Every listen to anything you do it all just gets better and better and better. I'm a huge Floyd fan and am always skeptical of anyone attempting a cover. Wow. You blew me away.
Awesome! You guys ROCK! Thanks for putting your own spin on it, and not trying too hard to reproduce exactly what Floyd did. I am positive that David Gilmour & Roger Waters would appreciate hearing such a creative version of their classic song!
I always found the original song creepy that's why Animals is not in my collexion, though I did have a downloaded CD minus this very song, still, let's just say I prefer DSOTM, WYWH, The Wall, and the gem Meddle. Braintoyband, thank you! Will watch this now.
well My friend got the echoes book y know its a comp with a buncha songs but the intro for sheep that he plays on keys is actually played by gilmour and it has a guitar tab he also uses a pedal for the effect but im not sure which
Very nice cover of a very difficult song. I bet you've seen Roger waters live. If not, do so. I can see by what you put into this song you would really enjoy the experience, it damn near matches the original band on tour.
I am an old turd and a massive floyd fan. I believe these guys ripped this cover, I mean nearly flawless. I love the new spin on an old fav. Great Job!
wow really?? that surprises me....i guess thats why when a record company asks a modern band to record a single they say it should be under like 4 minutes....which is ridiculous...because if a song is truly good u will want to listen to it for a longer time...
Whatup, G? Yes, that's the case for now. A good song is a good song. Meddle is good, it's up there with the classics, though I think I'd say no thanks to Animals as it's quite disturbing and downright freaky :) I do respect your musical preferrence, though. Nobody makes music like those guys, eh! Peace, rock on!
This is really good, but it just doesn't touch the original
MisterBlack215 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I would LOVE if you guys could send me an MP3 of this!!
Hpesoj08527@gmail.com
Thank you!
MCLOVIN50 4 months ago
Incredible
federicoezequielbene 4 months ago
BOOO!!!
Sanduben 5 months ago
Woow guys... very good... this song is a boom!!! Yeeeah!!!
mogis20 5 months ago
Not easy to cover. Damn good job!
PCell88 5 months ago
F#CK YEAH!!!!. ...LOVE IT!
LUNDUNA1 6 months ago
Get the audio from this tune at thetunify doht cohm.
LeonidaEllison800 6 months ago
I've been told you are disbanded ... Y U NO KEEP PLAYING AWESOME MUSIC!
dlkrdlkr 6 months ago
FUCK YEAH!!!!! Been a Floyd Fan for 40 years, and I love this version!!! Keep it up fellas!!!
connberkshire 6 months ago
the singer sucks ass but the musics ok then again it kinda has to be sence its pink floyd
WhiteAsBread 7 months ago
Fuck Yes
Dazza5 8 months ago
What an excellent cover! So many PF covers fail to do justice to the originals, but this one not only does that, it actually adds something new and novel. It's pretty unique to offer something new and worth listening to when one is referencing the sacred Pink Floyd canon. I know it's totally you and your own style and whatnot, but my take is "Jeff Buckley got together with the guys from Tool and dominated the world as a Floyd cover band, and the world's hunger for Floyd was sated."
mahajohn 8 months ago
AMAZING COVER!!! Really you guys are great!
cbrei2310 9 months ago
woow that was amazing
Guns8000 9 months ago
This is great. Covers aren't supposed to replicate the originals. Who cares what note it's in. Listen to how Type O Negative did covers. If you can twist a masterpiece then you are a true musician. If you want it to sound the same as the original then go listen to the opriginal. Good job fellas.
444Wotan 10 months ago
Hey ... i repeat and vote for : FUCK ALL HATERS...!!! you fkn rock people!!!!!!!
dlkrdlkr 10 months ago
awesome, you guys do any other floyd tunes?
Cyan2000 11 months ago
great cover
pawanmhrjn 11 months ago
a modern take on a masterpiece, fucking awesome!
fortybelownj 11 months ago
Awesome ! The guy on the keys doubles on bass too!
maximiliancohen 1 year ago
Feels too slow to me. :(
darkwingppk 1 year ago
I am 101% fan of Pink Floyd and this is awsome, very well done boys !
Fl0yDyan 1 year ago
Wow, this was good!
ajnorris99 1 year ago
THIS IS AWESOME.
Haven't heard a heavy cover of this before.
ChemHandbook 1 year ago
a song from pink floyd's most underrated album. You did it justice
efcdk92 1 year ago
brain = melted
bollen91 1 year ago
Comment removed
rokodad 1 year ago
10 people are Sheep being lead to the slaughter...
GeneralKenobiSIYE 1 year ago
I love music....
DeviCortez 1 year ago
i think somthing is missing... what could it be??? f**k THE BASS... fools
TKLuizz 1 year ago
mind = blown
Rush1013 1 year ago
come si dice in inglese fa cacare?
GardenProg 1 year ago
Excelenteee coveeer, me encantó!!!!
pinchemiamor 1 year ago
This is great.
chocodash 1 year ago
Nice Cover! Could you send me all your PF covers mp3's ?
ELCEBOLLARODRIGUEZ 1 year ago
GOOD COVER,,EXCEPT FOR 1 IMPORTANT THINK...
THE SONG IS IN D...NO IN C...
photogramistic 1 year ago
@photogramistic Call it artistic license.
braintoyband 1 year ago 14
@braintoyband Or vocal Problems if you want..
photogramistic 1 year ago
@braintoyband Or vocal Problems if you want..is an important thing also..
photogramistic 1 year ago
@braintoyband
Sounds to me like you're tuned down a whole step...therefore, fingering in the key of "C" would be actually sounding in "D"...
brenttattoo 1 year ago
@braintoyband
Sounds like you're tuned down a whole step...making what appears to be "playing in C"...actually sound in the key of D...
brenttattoo 1 year ago
@braintoyband this is absolutely mind blowing... i cant believe my eyes, and my ears have dropped off
koushymama 1 year ago
@braintoyband Or....musician limitations...
photogramistic 1 year ago
@braintoyband indeed, well done guys
iamcraiger 11 months ago
@photogramistic Dude they're playing in drop D!
MCLOVIN50 1 year ago
@photogramistic .... it's not so important in what key you sing it as long the progression is the samme.... it's another band ... nothing is wrong with that. As long as i remmeber it's maybe the best cover i ever heard
darkrainro 11 months ago
@darkrainro omg that´s serious...
photogramistic 11 months ago
@photogramistic ; like that matters this is an absolutely amazing reworking. i don't remember being this impressed by a floyd cover before - most of them just choose the wrong tunes, do too exacting a job or are downright poor quality, but this scores on all counts - i am right behind you, braintoy!
OTLisJaymz 2 months ago
@OTLisJaymz the tune is not a problem..but...sometimes, it shows the quality of the musicians.
photogramistic 2 months ago
nahh
dreamcracker99 1 year ago
@dreamcracker99 I agree what were we thinking???
braintoyband 1 year ago
@dreamcracker99 No disrespect, you have your version of the song and thats cool. it just dosent fit into my taste of music :)
dreamcracker99 1 year ago
savage
MrGeorge138 1 year ago
Great cover guys!
jetfischer 1 year ago
fuck yeah guys.......good-ass cover. the drums should be alot heavier though....less english cause with all that english, it looses its earieness. You know, cause that song DRIVES you know?....it drives the "sheep" to slaughter....there is no beating around the bush....."you are gonna die"....fuckin good ass cover though.
TheGoliathsound 1 year ago
Could you send me an MP3 of this cover? My mail is: seba161(at)interia.pl It's fucking awesome!!
sebascreen 1 year ago
Pretty Awesome Job! Nice Jam room!!
dark09skies 1 year ago
:o Exelente... me encanto el cover !... suerte !!
pelacablechileno 1 year ago
this makes me vomit
cruxman1 1 year ago
Excellent cover just brilliant ! and i'm a big fan of pink floyd!
darkrainro 1 year ago
I clicked this link and thought to myself this was gonna be crap. A tough song to cover and right from the begining you guys were great. And then, your vocals, wow. Really you guys are good! Keep up the great work!
cbrei1023 1 year ago
Amazing job on a classic song. I love the way you remade it.
RevantheHooligan 1 year ago
they can cover what they want-but i think its sick to set´ lion attack man ´to their favorite movies in youtube
blosmi1 1 year ago
Absolutely brilliant, absolutely brilliant! Nice video too!
EelcoStorm 1 year ago
why cover pink floyd?
blosmi1 1 year ago
@blosmi1 Why not? they did an awesob job covering this song!
EelcoStorm 1 year ago
This is awesome. And yeah, Nightwish is fucking garbage. They're good musicians who waste their talent by writing shitty music. I am now going to be checking out Braintoy's music. And that's an awesome name btw.
maddpiklz48 1 year ago
you guys are amazing
1megajack 1 year ago
Muito bem trabalhado... gostei muito!
Pink Floyd na veia!
rogerprado73 1 year ago
que buena e.!!!
bassdiegofloyd 1 year ago
braintoy rox@!
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
the tempo is badass
the drummer respect nick mason !
.....its rare !
thomaslejon 2 years ago
What.... That was fucking awesome !!!!!!!!!!!
DoctorDARKSIDE 2 years ago
WOW! Just WOW!!!
HE3991 2 years ago 9
@HE3991 Send us your email address and I will send you an MP3
braintoyband 2 years ago
@braintoyband can i get one too? wicked cover. i have the animals album original vinyl perfect condition.
marineagogo@aol.com
marineagogo 1 year ago
@braintoyband Have you got this on itunes?
Dazza5 7 months ago
love you guys
TheUtubesuxass 2 years ago
This is awesome.
DemonInJerseyCity 2 years ago
wow...it's a modern cover
AzzEver 2 years ago
Love it.
kip967 2 years ago
TSSSSERMINAL SHOCK IN YOU EYES
mikemcnellyf 2 years ago
hahaha very funny! and very nice!
patikisb 2 years ago
Braintoy" fuckin awsom !!!!!!! keep it up guys ......i,ll be seeing yall, in the arena soon...san antonio tx. alamo city Rocks....
Jacksparrow1869 2 years ago 2
It's a harmonica microphone. No effect. Jack white uses one live (in fact, he had one installed into his guitar :D) but some artists use a harmonica mic to create that AM radio effect (best way i can describe it). move from one mic to the other, with some delay, and u get that effect.
TeeAreBee 2 years ago
I love this version! I love the pink floyd version alot, but the modern spin on this is very enjoyable. :D Keep it coming!
TeeAreBee 2 years ago 3
Super!
justwaving 2 years ago
Oh god this is horrible. The 1:30 mintue I listened to in here I will never get back! Oh noes. Singer....go hang yurself.
KissTheSky321 2 years ago
Great cover. I feel the big 'missing difference' is that this version seems more metal based and the original was more warm and blues based...Les Pauls can do that...
Murfman40 2 years ago 2
dont like the way he sings
spocktacular 2 years ago
Hes got great technique and the notes are all there, but its just a bit high pitched for my taste.
Still a great singer.
ZeppelinRules 2 years ago
GENIUS VERSION
thomaslejon 2 years ago
it's missing something....
and it's pissing me off that i can't tell you what it is lol
va va voom?...emotion?...meaning...
I dunno when i play this song i can't get that same feeling as you get from the original..
floyd u rocked!
DonMop 2 years ago
Cold heartless animalism. This sounds angry (human emotion) instead of cold and indifferent (like an animal).
marcusorilius 2 years ago 2
Impressive in its originality.
Better than the VAST majority of Pro. PF tribute acts.
Only thing missing being those gorgeous, sexy, 1977 pieces of Rick Wright keyboard magic in the middle...
not from meddle: but just to make a muddle;
that coincidentally, i shall myself be modeling; WITH a little bit of meddle, tomorrow night in Alnwick, Northumberland.
:)
I sincerely hope someone who see's this ......see's that.
Tom Rose.
OrbvsTomarvm 2 years ago
I agree with maese2000, the message of the song is lost in this version. The intensity is meant to be speared between the sung words, so we can imagine whats going on for ourself, as what psychadelical rock is all about. Imagination. This version steals all the imagination.
It's a good cover, but so much is missing. The bass is slapping that thing pretty good, but every other instrument does not do it's part in this song.
OkstadOo 2 years ago
impressionant version,
this song with your personnality its just awesome!
great musiciens all!!!!
and the voice is really in the song
great respect!!!!! thomas
thomaslejon 2 years ago
I am part of a PF Cover band since 1994... this is a really nice interpretation of the song! Bravi!!!
fwillyit 2 years ago
It's not a "cover", it's a version ...
Very good version, indeed!
Spectroman10 2 years ago 3
indeed!!!
fontes733 2 years ago
Fuck the Haters. Its a good cover and im a massive floyd fan.
doesithurt09 2 years ago 15
Rick would be proud of the intro. Great job
Smoothbassistthatsme 2 years ago 2
Pink Floyd has been my favorite band since 1982 and I have collected together an amazing
collection of their music. I was not impressed
by "Australian Pink Floyd" (the guy cannot sing)
and other Pink Floyd covers do not do the music justice (except maybe Les Claypool). I have not even heard of Braintoy before today.
Best Floyd cover I've seen or heard.
anthonyms666 2 years ago
GREAT FUCKING VOICE, great version!!
great musiciens!!
thomaslejon 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is fucking horrible. why does every singer today have to sing the same goddamn way. it takes away so much meaning from the song. because, instead of great artists writing new songs, we have crap artists taking great songs and changing them to meet today's standards. this sounds like if metallica and fallout boy teamed up to make a techno punk band. the key boardist in the video is damn good. but the guitarist gives it a weird feel,like emptiness. the drummer is good for the most part.
Terrybob123 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The singer seems to be just another face to me. I mean, I don't want to be a dousche. and my band probably won't sound as professional as these guys, but i know for a fact would could put more feeling into a Performance. and fuck professionality anyways, we don't listen to roger waters because of the way his music sounds, we listen to it because of what his work tells us about ourselves. But it doesn't matter what I say anyway, because nobody on here is going to agree with me.
Terrybob123 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't really mean any harm by my comments. it's very good that bands like this are covering good songs. it's just not my style of music that these guys are playing. they seem like sellouts a bit. or atleast the singer might be an ignorant guy or just nothing special. and for all of you guys out there that like, to each his own. but this 17 year old is sticking to his vinyl LP'S. I enjoy writting about things that don't really matter.
Terrybob123 2 years ago
awesome
love how the singer gives the song totaly new kind of feeling
5 stars from me
7350kA 3 years ago
great job from iagiu!
PlettroPazzo 3 years ago
Great cover, but why did you change the lyric to "now things are NOT really what they seem?" it completely changes the meaning
kfkfkf2000 3 years ago
C'mon who cares. It's a cover...not everybody lives and dies over the meaning of every word. It's just a song. Best Floyd cover I've ever heard.
Philmacrakken 3 years ago
crap... its nor just a song...when you hear this song.. dont you get the fell to make a revolution in the world........well, not that... but the entire litycs.. makes you fell courage!... dont you...?...the meaning does care... for me...i love this song...
maese2000 2 years ago
What are you trying to say? revolution? courage? all because the guy says not? Get a life it's a friggin great cover of a friggin great song.
Philmacrakken 2 years ago
its my feelings VS. yours...what do you feel when you hear this lirycs... ... its because for me this song must be singed stroger, and not so tragic as this cover is.. but is a VERY VERY GOOD cover...... dude i didnt ofended you. i have already a life...saludos desde mexico!
maese2000 2 years ago
you make no sense, whatsoever.
lol
Glazenburg 2 years ago
ok sorry guy!!!... perhaps i cant tell what i want, because english is not my mother tongue... =), NICE COVER...!
but hey... we both like pink floyd!!!. hahhaha
un saludo desde mexico....
!!!
maese2000 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tempo is off. No passion. No Gilmouresque guitar effects. Sorry, but it is piss poor. If you want t cover it, you at least have to master it and add your own identity, to not do so is to shame their name.
tmick7 3 years ago
Wow.....thats better than anyone could have covered it.
DuckNazi 3 years ago
God way to have Balls , I agree with every good comment on this page. I love the original and hold it sacred , but this version is BALLS NASTY and wondeful .
This is one of floyds greatest anti establishment jams and you really did it proud.
googoobh 3 years ago
WOW!!
What a voice!
Awesome band!
specialeeffexx 3 years ago
Concentrated shred!!!!
rockman2561 3 years ago
What a voice . I wanna an album.
purplestarr88 3 years ago
Best cover of Pink Floyd I ever heard!
tirouge0 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
your stupid
rainbowmonkey27 3 years ago
sweet jesus i wish i had a keyboard player
mikemcnellyf 3 years ago
You've really put your own style into this instead of slavishly copying the original which is no mean feat!
Very impressed as I LOVE Pink Floyd and doing covers is not for the faint hearted or talentless!!!
Well done and thanks for the link...
GNeuman 3 years ago 2
hey guys? can you cover "High hopes" if nothing else just to show up that awful bag of crap nightwish version, go on chaps give them hell, show the Finnish tossers how it's meant to be done :O))
Love ya ....
Defiance6666 3 years ago 6
good cover.
oneofspades 3 years ago
Great version of this awesome classic. You guys rock. You made it your own without sacrificing the original feel. Very cool experience. Thanks. Liz
willienelsonpri 3 years ago
Every listen to anything you do it all just gets better and better and better. I'm a huge Floyd fan and am always skeptical of anyone attempting a cover. Wow. You blew me away.
tapistree 3 years ago
fuckin incredible i must say.
I love pink floyd, and animals is my favorite album, and you guys totally rocked this song. added your own flare to it which made it pretty awesome.
overall that was a great job, keep it up. and nice jam space haha.
ChaostheClown 3 years ago
Sweet! You've taken me on a journey to the past! And thanks to our talented friend AMY for sharing.
cheers
buniluvr 3 years ago
good job! that was awesome.
intentionalsound 3 years ago
I love this stuff,keep up the great work guys...
and thanks for the heads up Amy, Rip :)
Riptor717 3 years ago
Awesome! You guys ROCK! Thanks for putting your own spin on it, and not trying too hard to reproduce exactly what Floyd did. I am positive that David Gilmour & Roger Waters would appreciate hearing such a creative version of their classic song!
Amy
amccann7 3 years ago
Very good so far. Now for part 2.
AllisterCooper2008 3 years ago
I always found the original song creepy that's why Animals is not in my collexion, though I did have a downloaded CD minus this very song, still, let's just say I prefer DSOTM, WYWH, The Wall, and the gem Meddle. Braintoyband, thank you! Will watch this now.
AllisterCooper2008 3 years ago
by the way... which one's brain??? muhahahaha!
diamondog1974 3 years ago
the singer wasnt angry enough
revo1jeff 3 years ago
Hats off to you gentlemen!!! just phenomanal musicianship!!! Is that even a word? whatever it sounds good!!!
diamondog1974 3 years ago
Great Cover! Like a tidal wave!
wesmatron 3 years ago
Awesome! You guys rock! I look forward to any new albums you may produce. Keep rockin' \m/
BruceBeefcake 3 years ago
yeah they are real good...
SirJamesII 3 years ago
Wow very very GOOD !!!
petale3 3 years ago
intro is actually played on guitar but sounds good
TheXPatient 3 years ago
you mean bass. it was played on bass.. the constant droning (in 5) from the bass and keyboards.
danielinsporto 3 years ago
well My friend got the echoes book y know its a comp with a buncha songs but the intro for sheep that he plays on keys is actually played by gilmour and it has a guitar tab he also uses a pedal for the effect but im not sure which
TheXPatient 3 years ago
sounds nice. makes me feeled relaxed.
Jaystinian 3 years ago
Brilliant guys...that was wicked!!
mudman1881 3 years ago
holy shit
you guys rock
best cover ive heard
danbreadandham 3 years ago
Ooooooh. Great version.
weemalky 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
out fucking standing!!!
squonkness 3 years ago
YOu guys are AWESOME!!!!!!!!!! The best cover Ive heard in a long time....such Talent!!!
mommaswatchinU 3 years ago
FUCKING EXCELLENT!! Love it :O))
TheGoodDoctor62 3 years ago
Very nice cover of a very difficult song. I bet you've seen Roger waters live. If not, do so. I can see by what you put into this song you would really enjoy the experience, it damn near matches the original band on tour.
Plutonwolf 3 years ago
I am an old turd and a massive floyd fan. I believe these guys ripped this cover, I mean nearly flawless. I love the new spin on an old fav. Great Job!
solnovi 3 years ago
I don't like the Emo/Punk sing style convering Rodger's style, didn't say they did a bad job, just don't like it
elconquistidor1991 3 years ago
its different, but theres been worse (screemo anyone?)
i think it fits the mood of the song :)
Ele3tricEye 3 years ago
you clearly dont listen to much punk, or emo for that matter.
thepot23 3 years ago
nice cover...though it gets a little too heavy in my opinion for most of it...
metic56 3 years ago
animals is the most underrated album of all time...
metic56 3 years ago
I so agree with you, just this song alone off the album was freakin epic!
solnovi 3 years ago
i especially love dogs...pink floyd and led zeppelin are the only 2 bands that can make a 20 minute song that doesnt ever get old...
metic56 3 years ago
Really? I've heard a lot of great 20 minute songs from a LOT of great bands!
HammerOfPink 3 years ago
name 5....
themusicman1973 3 years ago
True. And let's not forget 'Hey Jude', which to this day holds the longest song ever to hit #1.
AllisterCooper2008 3 years ago
wow really?? that surprises me....i guess thats why when a record company asks a modern band to record a single they say it should be under like 4 minutes....which is ridiculous...because if a song is truly good u will want to listen to it for a longer time...
themusicman1973 3 years ago
Whatup, G? Yes, that's the case for now. A good song is a good song. Meddle is good, it's up there with the classics, though I think I'd say no thanks to Animals as it's quite disturbing and downright freaky :) I do respect your musical preferrence, though. Nobody makes music like those guys, eh! Peace, rock on!
AllisterCooper2008 3 years ago
So is Meddle. PF released that in 1971, and Dave Gilmour has much affection for it.
AllisterCooper2008 3 years ago
yea i own meddle......its also a very good album....i still prefer animals though....
themusicman1973 3 years ago
Great job buddy! Thanks for sending this! 5 stars and in my favorites!
Hogweed11 3 years ago
love the intro, love the video. great job guys!
drenei 3 years ago
this is pretty good, actualy...nothing beats the original, but still..congrats, m8´s
HumanSlayer6911 3 years ago
The introduction on this one is good.