How dare you ruin the piece by singing only the moving tones in the bass parts of the poco piu mosso. You must be lazy 'new music' musicians. Also, your heavy accents on beats one and three during the adagio molto ruin Schubert's lyricism. Atrocious.
beh! un romantico trattato come un barocco!! sono intonati , ma mancano di peso vocale ......anche la parte veloce .....dove i bassi hanno il madrigalismo che dovrebbe riportare ai flutti ......non si sente nulla di nulla !!!!!!! beh l'effetto voluto da schubert è andato a farsi benedire .... Non ci siamo , troppe messe di voce!!! Ricordo di aver già commentato un lavoro di questo Coro ... peccato
@giorgioot Hah, even my limited knowledge of Italian tells me you have no idea of how Schubert ought to be performed. There is nothing Baroque about this performance.
Como todo (o casi todo) lo que hacía Schubert: fascinante, inquietante, capta la atención del oyente, sorprende y, una vez que ha concluido, nos deja pensativos. Schubert casi nunca es previsible
I only know his more recent recording with the OReR and the MC that came with his (again rather disappointing) recording of Brahms' Second. It struck me as cold, sluggish and the singing - while marvelously clear - was strangely nasal. Is the older one better?
I have not heard the more recent recording, is it on Gardiner's own label? I was, am, and will continue to be moved by the MC and VP recording. I would be curious to hear your reaction to it. I feel that they create an incredible atmosphere in their live recording.
Yeah, it's on SDG. It's very much worth it for the other choral songs though, even if I think Gardiner is a bit too nervous in the Brahms Second, his rapid tempo changes feel somewhat ham-handed.
Thanks for the tip tho, I'll seek out the older recording then.
A truly spectacular piece sung by a great choir
hedgehogzrule333 9 months ago
How dare you ruin the piece by singing only the moving tones in the bass parts of the poco piu mosso. You must be lazy 'new music' musicians. Also, your heavy accents on beats one and three during the adagio molto ruin Schubert's lyricism. Atrocious.
ivoryvirtuoso 10 months ago
Really sublime masterpiece!!!
ldskts 10 months ago
Sublime!!!
ldskts 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Es ist nicht die Musik alleine die dieses Stück mich jedesmal zu einer Gänsehaut bringt.
Wahnsinn, die Musik, der Chor, der Text.....
NUR GENIAL
Franklin1122 11 months ago
Es ist nicht die Musik alleine dcie dieses Stück mich jedesmal zu einer Gänsehaut bringt.
Wahnsinn, die Musik, der Chor, der Text.....
NUR GENIAL
Franklin1122 11 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Need to marry you **busizz4me.info**
chamikajanakee 1 year ago
beh! un romantico trattato come un barocco!! sono intonati , ma mancano di peso vocale ......anche la parte veloce .....dove i bassi hanno il madrigalismo che dovrebbe riportare ai flutti ......non si sente nulla di nulla !!!!!!! beh l'effetto voluto da schubert è andato a farsi benedire .... Non ci siamo , troppe messe di voce!!! Ricordo di aver già commentato un lavoro di questo Coro ... peccato
giorgioot 1 year ago
@giorgioot Hah, even my limited knowledge of Italian tells me you have no idea of how Schubert ought to be performed. There is nothing Baroque about this performance.
Nachtmarchen 1 year ago 5
Superb
davidjohnelkan 1 year ago
Thank you so much for uploading this.
bogorzelak 1 year ago
10+!!!
TheMusicStalker 2 years ago
What a beautiful work!
Dankbarkeit1980 2 years ago
sehr geil. Naja ich sags mal so früher haben leute mehr gedacht und waren net so eingeschnitten wie wir jetzt
hakkehakke 2 years ago
Como todo (o casi todo) lo que hacía Schubert: fascinante, inquietante, capta la atención del oyente, sorprende y, una vez que ha concluido, nos deja pensativos. Schubert casi nunca es previsible
Kobzar3374 2 years ago
This piece is on my desert island for sure; an unknown
masterwork. Gardiner has a sublime recording on DG with his
Monteverdi Choir and the Vienna Philharmonic. Check it out.
Unclescrot 2 years ago 2
I only know his more recent recording with the OReR and the MC that came with his (again rather disappointing) recording of Brahms' Second. It struck me as cold, sluggish and the singing - while marvelously clear - was strangely nasal. Is the older one better?
Nachtmarchen 2 years ago
I have not heard the more recent recording, is it on Gardiner's own label? I was, am, and will continue to be moved by the MC and VP recording. I would be curious to hear your reaction to it. I feel that they create an incredible atmosphere in their live recording.
Unclescrot 2 years ago
Yeah, it's on SDG. It's very much worth it for the other choral songs though, even if I think Gardiner is a bit too nervous in the Brahms Second, his rapid tempo changes feel somewhat ham-handed.
Thanks for the tip tho, I'll seek out the older recording then.
Nachtmarchen 2 years ago
Wunderschön!!!
Ogobogo 3 years ago 3
Ausgeseichnet - Vielen dank!
nikolaiovich 3 years ago 5
beautiful!
casualclicks 3 years ago 4