Added: 4 years ago
From: retrod1
Views: 306,683
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (195)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I remember the end of his show as he walked through each spotlight and it going off with at the end his famous saying of, "Good night, Mrs. Calabash, wherever you are." The feeling he put behind those words affected me as a young teenager. This song was one of my favorites growing up. I guess in the back of my mind I knew that life had its seasons.

  • When Jimmy Durante died somebody commented, "You could warm your hands on that man". What a magnificent obituary!

  • I loved It when he sang Frosty the Snowman I watch that every year....Steve D

  • Obviously not a great voice but he could certainly put a song over so very well. This is a really great version.

  • My father used to cry at this song and I didn't know why -- Now I know.

  • This has been a favorite for a long time.

    The letters in fancy script in the railings left and right of the window platform, "C D" might indicate what television show this was or possibly the name of the ensemble that is backing him up. Can anyone tell me what the "C D" stands for?

  • Comment removed

  • @MaxPennington The "C D" stands for "Club Durant," the New York nightclub Jimmy Durante opened in the 1920's and where he and others performed for many years. The musical parts of the Jimmy Durante Show were filmed at the RKO Studios on a "Club Durant" stage set in memory of the old club.

  • How could you not just love him?

  • playin' my piano..R.I.P Eric Morecombe

  • Where are they when we need them. Great.

  • love this song

  • i watched him when i was a kid, he was beyond great! him, red skelton, jackie gleason, george burns, etc

  • Today's generation needs more music like Jimmy's...

  • If you love this song, as I do, also see and hear Eddie Albert's rendition, in which he also tells the story behind it, from "knickerbokker Holiday". you'll come away with a new understanding of what it (and life) is all about.

  • What huge Schnozzola ? All I can see and hear with this, is a handsome old man (like myself) singing a beautiful song (one of my favorites). Rest in peace, Jimmy, you will live forever in the hearts of those who love you. (And I am only one of many).

  • acha cha cha!

  • six people don't know what good music is. thumbs up if you're not bothered by the huge Schnozzola :D

  • He was so wonderful.

  • I saw this performance when it was telecast, and soon afterward ordered the LP album in which it was featured. Perhaps my experience then was the same as yours is now: until Durante performed the song, I had never really heard it. Rather, I had only experienced Kurt Weill's music and had paid no attention to Maxwell Anderson's lyrics. It wasn't until Jimmy Durante subordinated the melody to the lyrics and spoke (not sang) the words that I heard "September Song" for the first time.

  • The late great Jimmy Durante and his songs touched me all my life. Thanks to YouTube, Jimmy is still around doing his usual marvelous thing. Stan Kossen

  • his inner goodness is even bigger than his nose

  • When I was a young man, I always wondered why my mother who was also a singer held this song in such reverance.You have to live this song to truly sing this song..Jimmy lived it as did my mother and now in the autumn of my life, I can sing it because I too have lived it.....

  • for a guy with no voice he does a terrific job . .I guess he possesses a soul . He owns this song .I didn't appreciate Jimmy 35 years ago

  • He was a giant in show business when my parents were kids & I'm 63. I can remember seeing him on tv specials & as a guest but not his tv show even tho we had a tv. I was too young a kid to recoginse his greatness. There is no one of his stature that is on tv, radio or anything else today. A one of a kind. Mr. D. I know you're in Heaven telling jokes, singing playing the piano for God. You're playing the big gig for him; you can't go any higher.

  • what do u think happens after we die?

  • @sluggo06 Whatever that makes us what we are continues. Bodies exist only for our benefit to touch & use the things the EternalCreator made for us which is practically everything. Accept death you can't change the way of the world. Something has been cleared up for me. I use to wonder all the time what happened to us. Lately in physics there is a new theory that supposes only 2 things: all that exists is standing waves and the aether they create waves in. Sounds simple but the implications...

  • @aellarex since we are talking about death. go watch "are you a good person?" on my channel

  • @sluggo06 I feel we'll be in the bosom of our Father in Heaven. Never miss an opportunity to tell your loved ones, you love them.

  • sfden50 and pianatar did you see the video of the kid lip sinc Jimmy? Not all of us have to be a certain age. He does it with the kind of joy I'd like to think Mr. Durante would have appreciated.

  • @cailleachthehag Whatever that makes us a BEing is what continues. Bodies exist only for our benefit to touch & use everything the EternalCreator made. Accept death. You can't change the way of the world. . Lately in physics there is a new theory that supposes only 2 things: all that exists exists as standing waves and the aether they create waves in. Sounds simple but the implications change everything we thought we knew & everything will have to be redefined.

  • You really have to be of a certain age to GET this masterpiece - let's just say I'm there and leave it at that :)

  • @sfden50  and I'm right there with ya bud.

  • 6 people are complete idiots

  • these are the days to remember, that we  should remember the wonders of love!!!XXXOOO!!!

  • You should have called.....

  • MY GRANDFATHER was friends with him in the 50's 60's and 70's just b 4 he died and i got a chrstmas card from him in 73 or 74 that was kool

  • MY GRANDFATHER was friends with him in the 50's 60's and 70's just b 4 he died and i got a chrstmas card from him in 73 or 74 that was kool

  • Strangely affecting, despite the syrupy arrangement and the fact that Jimmy didn't have much of a voice. There's something about him in that hat and coat: he looks vulnerable, and lonely. Lighting up at the end was a nice touch.

  • @aurelius54 He really knew how to sell it though.

  • My Sweet girl. Our Sept. 20, will always be, Magic Time. ...and I love you so. D.M.

  • Love Jimmy !

  • Comment removed

  • I love Jimmy Durante singing old love songs

  • Jimmy, We miss you

  • Wonderful!

  • @Fooblestheclown YES IT IS! Brilliant ..

    The song is great and holds fond memories.

    Jimmy Durante was such a great talent and little-big man.

    Thanks for the recommendation, mate!

  • Thanks for posting this beautiful video. I'm playing piano for a group of retired journalists today, and they requested that I play this song. I'd never heard of it before. Now I know why they love it! What a tear-jerker.

  • @Pianomam Coincidentally, "September Song" came from a Broadway play that was made into a movie about a young journalist... who gets the girl, over the older gent who sings her this song. (But I think he gets to sing the song to other girls, optimistically, at the end of the show.)

  • A wonderful, caring man and a great entertainer!

    I doubt we will ever see another like this great man!

  • This was the song my Mom requested for her funeral. My eldest son sang it. Not a dry eye in the place.

  • @ursulamajor57 100% agree thanks for sharing

  • thanks so much for sharing. I stil remember seeing the show.  He was much loved.

    He rarely dated attractive women and when asked why he said, "everyone is beautiful to someone" ........ he was beautiful himself.

  • No amount of time will do anything to diminish this recording. People will love it forever and ever.

  • true artiste

  • wonderful just great thanks  thanks jimmy and thank you

  • High point in showbiz and the history of western civilization. God bless Jimmy Durante.

  • One of the greatest ever performers singing one of the greatest ever songs. Superb entertainment.

  • @nonsociopathskin Absolutely

  • thats a big shnozzle.

  • Dat was wunnerful! Ha cha cha cha cha!

  • One of the sweetest souls in entertainment. When Jimmy sings "September Song" it fills my head and my heart with beautiful memories of how wonderful entertainment with heart and soul could be. A beautiful song sung as only Jimmy could do it.

  • Jimmy was a Sweetheart .

  • People have so little appreciation for all that came before not realizing that we are who we are and use them as a springboard for future endeavors. Jimmy Durante is a classic example. He was not handsome, short or even a good singer but he had magic! He overcame all the Hollywood stereotypes and he shined at doing it. And he was the best at this song because he looked the part of a man in his September years and therefore made it believable. I still miss his charm and humor.

  • hackberryflat..I agree. Although I always liked Jimmy, as I get older you realize their value to society and entertainment. This song always made me a little sad when he sang it but now it applies to me and I'm glad he did. I do not want to disparage todays young stars but there just aren't that many to compete with these last of the vaudevillians. I also watched James Cagney doing Yankee Doodle and was just facinated.

  • @oyde Thks...I agree w/you about today's "stars" being unable to compete with Durante's generation of entertainers - they try to keep rocking - seemingly no ability to enlarge the scope of what they do - the ballad singers can always sing ballads, but rockers can't always rock - "the times, they are a changing..." isn't correct - it was a verse by a young man unaware of what it's like to reminisce. Durante could - it's an awareness that occurs only after time goes by.

  • The greatest guy who ever lived, Don't doubt it,

  • Great sound quality! Thanks for posting.

  • My friend calls this her song, because she was born in September.

  • Det här är såååå bra!

  • As a young man, I had low esteem for Jimmy, but I liked the song for it's poetry. Now, in my September, I realize Jimmy is the best performer for this song - it must be viewed from"event horizon"; that point in time where you can see your shortening future and lengthly past at the same moment.

  • @hackberryflat

    I hear you, man. I am in my 60s, so I guess i am in September. and, your perspective on life begins to change. Especially when you start losing your best friends to cancer and other later-life ailments!!

  • @lgcrooks /// Sorry for the delay in answering your comments - thks for your attn. and empathy. I was so moved by the imagery of these ballads; as a boy, then a teen and later a young man; but, I felt angst when listening to them. I liked the imagery of the poetry, but now I find the cliches are true - getting old helps to understand it even better - no angst, only peaceful rememberances.

  • one of the favourtie songs of my national service days.first time ive heard this lovely versions tks for posting

  • I have been working on this song recently. Thanks for posting this vidm, because it is so great to hear a magnificent performer like Durante. Nobody can copy him, but you can learn from his attention to detail, and total commitement to whatever he does.

  • JIMMY WAS MY DADS FAVE

  • Good night Mrs. Calabash, wherever you are.

    Durante was a national treasure.

  • Thanks so much for posting this! Jimmy Durante was one of a kind. What a difference from the many bland, mass-produced performers that are popular today.

  • One of my favorite shows on the old black and white TV. Thanks for the memories.

  • Those old vaudevillians were the best entertainers ever. Everybody wanted to get into the act!

    Goodnight Mr Calabash.

  • The man who did not have a good voice but we all wanted to hear him sing and perform. He had so much charisma. Loved to hear him sing because it came from the heart and was loaded with charm. I miss him dearly and the many others in the golden era. Thanks "Jimmy wherever you are."

  • my favorite

  • One of the real entertainers from a time past

    Jimmy and others like Frank, Dino, Bing knew how to belt them out. They put feeling into a song. I'm glad I got to see them

  • I did get to see him in person once at The Hollywood Bowl. He was great. Listen to the vocalists behind him on this song. That is such a wonderful blend of voices.

  • i remember watching durante on tv with my mum and nan many moons ago he was great

  • I am so glad that I lived during the years Jimmy was around. I was a kid, but, I loved him. He appealed to all ages. God Bless Jimmy.

  • Nicely done, Jimmy.

  • A vocalist? No. But I am sure if I have ever seen such a touching rendition as this!

    Jimmy was a jewel

  • Jimmy Durante was a man of character. They really don't make them like him anymore and it's a shame.

  • What great musicality! A great performer of whom we'll never eversee the likes again... thank you tv and reality shows, etc etc...

  • wow Durante was the man!

  • Indeed he was! ;O)

  • Jimy Durante proved every day of his life it's not about your looks it's about your soul. He had a very big one!!

  • @downhill240 ..TOUCHE

  • @downhill240 nose?

  • @SHlTTER LOL That too!

  • @downhill240

    What's more, Dear, you and he both prove it: A Woman Loves a Man for that unnameable Certain... Something.

    A Ladybird may mate (for life, even) with one of any variety of cocks, for reasons as common as the male himself...

    ...And will Stay. Forty thousand, thousand years.

    But. We Love... *LOVE* our Chosen for The Something in neither his face nor pockets (in 'that', or another, way. comenow, pigs!).

    O, mark it well, Boys...

    To say it's Heart or Soul is too small, too.

    <3.

  • Goodnite Mrs. Calabash, wherever you are.

  • The prettiest/saddest version i've ever heard is by Jonny Fair. For me, this one, Jimmys version on vinyl is second. It's still up here last i checked, give it a listen & you'll see what i mean. It made me cry it was so beautifull...

  • I don't know what private means. or why I'm so fortunate, but thankyou, SO MUCH...

  • Next to Mr.Walt Huston's rendition of this tune..

    Mr.Durante's performance of "September Song"is the

    best!

  • Excellent beyond words... Favorited it!! 5*****

  • My father explain me who was Jimmy Durante.. and he invited me to discover.. I´m impressed.. It´s a very special sensation hear this song and see.. Jimmy Durante..

  • Proof positive that heart and soul are more important in a pop singer than suppleness of voice. What tender emotions he could convey with that raspy instrument of his! He was a boyhood favorite of mine, and I still miss him after all these years.

  • You're not alone SirCyrano, I miss him too. Can't believe you knew him. His voice broke my heart.

  • Oh, I didn't know Durante personally, though it sometimes felt as if I did. I used to imitate some of his comedy routines for my grade school friends while Durante was still active, but I only came across his pop song interpretations about ten years ago. They knocked me out -- sort of like discovering that Babe Ruth was also a concert pianist. He was one of a kind; I hope younger generations discover him and keep his name alive.

  • so do i....and johnny carson was not even a Late Late Late Late show host yet....and Who In The Heck is the Conan O'Brian....Durante is rolling in his grave I think.......yep....the heart and soul goes on....thank you for caring

  • every so often I come back to this video and love every second of it. Many thanks for posting it for us to enjoy.

  • xcellent song and a very good perfomance of the singer.

  • Good night Mrs Calibash where ever you are.

  • This is great. I remember it well from my youth. Brngs back some great memories.

  • My first hero, followed by Roy Rogers, followed by Superman.

    How excellent it is to live in a time when one can access this kind of performance from so long ago; how gratifying it is to read and enjoy all of these comments, and feel reassurance that quality always endures, and never stops being appreciated.

  • Two classics for the price of one.

  • love it makes me cry

  • The goodnight Mrs Calabash routine that Jimmy performed according to Paul Harvey's The Rest Of The Story was dedicated to a waitress he met thining he had no career in show business as he was going home quite discouraged. She waited on him and told him he had what it took and that he should go back and try again. He believed her and did just that. Immediately things changed and he wanted to thank her but could not locate her. The routine was his way for her to get in touch with him .

  • and bjkcpr3, you said 'very full!'!!!!

    well full of slugs and snails and puppy dog tails!

    but i'm pretty ok some of the time!

    ;)

    "why soooo serious!!!"

  • hmm... a Jimmy Durante fan silly? :)

  • bjkcpr3

    and a happy new year from the wabbits,

    that includes you too molly :D

  • hello Silly.... even though you don't like my Charles, lol... Happiest of all in the new year!

  • Brilliant ! A great star. Pity there are no more like him. Cannot help but like him. Just had star quality.

  • What did Durante say to the groupies?

    "And you bitches t'ought my nose was big! Ah-cha-cha-cha"

  • the new joker in batman: the dark knight.

    is it my mistake or is "why so serious" a durante quote????

    i've been telling people it is!

    so just how full of it am i folks?

  • Very full! Although who knows? He was a comedian, in his many movies he could have said it. I remember this man since the earliest years of my life. I saw him in a Movie when I was around 9 yrs old and thought he was very funny. Later on I realised he was a talented pianist, the comedy ( as opposed to 'very funny')was a little lost on me. Having said all that, he should be remembered as an all round very entertaining man

  • AH CHA CHA CHA

  • Desperatly looking for "Monte Carlo or Bust"- Jimmy Durante. I know it was in a movie, but im looking for just the song. HELPPP!

  • What was the original date for this show?

    Does anyone have a clip from the 12/31/55 show???

  • in my mind, everyone else compares to Jimmy. But do love Frank Sinatra's version too. Thanks so much for the great video.

  • Hi there Molly! I hate to disagree. Jimmy's version was the version with all the Pathos of an aging man, and so it should be. Frank's version was just a sentimental song

  • hi, I see what you mean, and thank you for the comment, which brought me back to this video, which I am totally enjoying at this moment. Happiest of New Years to you and yours.

  • .Thanks Molly, the same wishes for you & Yours

  • Fantastic man! Love ya Jimmy!

  • Well to answear to your question, mostly because Jimmy Durante =!(does not equal) Jessica Alba xD . But i don't know how do you find this clip so funny, it's more melancholyc if you ask me.

  • this is very funny i dont know why it has so few viewers...

  • It's not a comedy skit, Bolta - you missed the point. Good bye, Mrs Callabash - wherever you are.

  • i missed the vid i watched inka dinka before this one and posted comment on wrong vid thats all...

  • A Class Act All The Way..

  • i truly believe this is kat's dad. her nose looks just like his! love durante tho.

  • he proudly referred to his nose as schnauser

  • a class act all the way-- not a mean bone in his body----------i can hear it.. thanks for posting this...........franco

  • He has a lot of heart. But I can sing as well or better than him!! Spunky guy though. Very confident.

  • So much Love in his Heart.

  • a great entertainer and a wonderful song.

    thanks for posting it.

  • i really love this! ots amazing how a song can do so much! absolutely amazing : )

  • Is fantastic! Someone knows as can I to record on the computer from YouTube

  • the olde durante... i can't believe he's gone.

  • His version has stayed with me ever since I saw it, that one time long ago. Brings tears to my eyes. Thanks for posting it!

  • ha cha cha

  • there never was an entertainer as loved by his peers and the public like jimmy..there will never be another durante

  • i like his "make someone happy" help me from being sad.

  • What a world this would be if Jimmy could bring every one together, especially those that think about or contemplate divorse or seperation. Ask yourself did all of you give it a chance?

  • To OLDPLAT

    if i had another chance, i would do it so differently. I love this song, so beautiful

    and true..

    joanie

  • the best

  • My Mum and Dads fave song... I'm older now and can understand the meaning so much more...

  • I guess we all have songs that move us, are our favorites, and there are so many, it's hard to choose. But for me, this version of September Song by Jimmy Durante will always bring happiness, tears, and fond memories of a wonderful performer.

  • What an incredibly moving performance! No voice, no looks, no tricks, but some artists have an instinct for communicating from their heart to yours. Durante does it here with his "tell it like it is" phrasing, but even more with his movement and posture - that of an aging man eager to make the most of love in the time that he understands will some day run out. My guess is that after this, the next "good" singer I hear performing this song will seem insipid and insincere.

  • It would be much to quite there.....

  • If only the birds with the most beautiful voices sang in the forrest, It would much to quiet there. L Russell Brown

  • Jimmy Durante was a once in a lifetime performer. There will never be another like him. I loved him more than words can ever say.

    L Russell Brown--writer of TIE A YELLOW RIBBON ROUND THE OLE OAK TREE.

    Come and listen to me sing my latest song

    ALL I CAN GIVE YOU FOR NOW I sing it under my

    family name Larry Brown.

    Jimmy would have given me the chills if he were alive to perform it!

    L Russell Brown

  • He has no singing voice, but he does seem an endearing kind of guy of a bygone era. I am 32 and like this stuff of his. I did enjoy his "Frosty the Snowman" song as a child. Maybe that's what did it.

  • He has no singing voice, but he does seem an endearing kind of guy of a bygone era. I am 32 and like this stuff of his. I did enjoy his "Frosty the Snowman" song as a child. Maybe that's what did it.

  • guy could make you cry, like all good comics

  • Please see Jimmy in the old movie, The Man Who Came to Dinner. He plays a character named Banjo that is based on Harpo Marx. He's really good in it.

  • Jimmy, sei uno dei nostri !

  • Who else but Jimmy could sing a love song while wearing a trilby hat and a raincoat? Brilliant and under-rated musician.

  • this nose knows! he was one of a kind, i loved him in "It's a Mad^4 World"

  • if people gave my previous post a thumbs down because of my somewhat pungent language, I apologize, but the fact still remains Jimmy Durante is 1000000 times more talented than the vast majority of todays "entertainers"

  • marvelous

  • Jimmy Durante lost 10 times more talent when he took a dump than most performers today have ever had!!

  • jimmy will allways live in clips like this when some of the plastic 'celebrities" today are long forgotten....give em hell up there jim ....

  • Great style. Jimmy was one of a kind.

    REST IN PEACE, old buddy.

  • Beautiful interpretation for a beautiful music!