Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (269)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • definitely the best version you've recorded of this song. I just love to hear it

  • i have listened to this song and your comfortably numb versions like 10 times each and i don't and will not get tired

  • <3

  • You are so incredibly talented. I cant get over your awesomeness !!! I would love to have the sheet music to this one, if u don't mind can you send to me? :)

  • LOVE

  • this is my favourite pink floyd song and i want it played at my funeral

  • @givemesumemore20 its an amazing song but ur gonna make everyone cry lol

  • this is SOOOOOOOOO amazing WOW!

  • Beautiful

  • keep em coming

  • gracias que  lindo.hace tutorial

  • All three versions are great.

  • YOu are RockSTAR!!! GReat JOB!!! amazing!!! Please Please Please Please PLease Please Do THe Final Cut song Cover , Or the Gunners Dream, or Both Please... :))

  • Te quedó padrísimo! felicidades!

  • I still think this is your best cover, even better than the excellent Stairway to Heaven which I also think is among the best. But actually I really like almost all of you covers, even from songs I don't know or I don't really enjoy listening to.

  • Uoa, great=)

  • One of the most beautiful, peaceful and dreamy songs ever, and you made it even more awesome :d

  • I like!

  • Great,great,GREAT!! *-*

  • Amazing cover. I love you *_*

  • i think like toxicity, this has become one of your signature covers. each version is a little different and not in a bad way. so dont feel bad about how the other ones turned out. i think they are just as good as this one :)

  • I'd wish i was a young,goodlooking female pianowizz.............

  • Восхитительно сыграно, впрочем как и другие вещи, жаль нельзя купить диск в Москве.

  • God God man, I'm so glad I stumbled across you here. Just stunning work.  And it is WORK. Much appreciated.

  • wow...... wow..... wow....

  • Beutifulllllllllllllllllllllll­l

  • Great!

  • I can't help but think of how amazing the song Great Gig in the Sky would sound on the piano! It'd probably be a pain in the ass to play, but the result would be so worth it!

  • *Salute*

  • Amazing is the only word for this skill, I take my hat off to you..,

  • Splendid! Very smooth playing and quite perfect replica :D

  • Just Awesome !

  • My first girlfriend sorta broke up with me yesterday. I seem to always come back to this video for comfort. Thanks for your music, Ms. VK.

  • pleasee make a tutorial !! ='( please that's so cool !! =)

  • Even if you're not completely happy with the song, I think it'd be just about the same with any Pink Floyd song with primarily guitar instrumentation. David Gilmour was pretty bend crazy in all of his guitar playing, an effect that doesn't translate easily into piano.

    Nonetheless, this was an incredible rendition!

  • :))

  • Comment removed

  • I think as an own piece it is simply wonderful. You put very much feeling in it and so on...But I have to admit it's not the feeling Pink Floyd brings to me with their song. You know this unidentifiable feeling of freedom, happiness and wanderlust. I can't describe it and I actually think that nothing, not even your exceptionally good piece, is able to come near it. Sorry

  • You gotta love the chromatic appogiaturas. Sick technique, even sicker feeling.

  • I'm still not a friend of the part from 0:50 to 0:53. It didn't sounds right. But the other stuff is fine :)

  • @MrTotoFan awe man I love that bit.

  • @Majoofi I love that bit too, but on the original song. In this pianoversjon it's to jazzy, if you understand. not the correct notes

  • This is so wonderful! Can I buy a copy of this recording somewhere?

  • @muppidupp you can get her covers on her website...

  • I share your sentiment of not being completely happy with your previous performances/versions of this masterpiece; version 3 is far superior from its predecessors !!! I know it might be a 4th.... but in any case YOU ROCK !!

  • This is a difficult song, but I think you did it justice here, Vika. Spacibo!

  • married meee!!! right now!!!

  • Victoriya, on attempt #4, try to minimize the keystrokes with your right hand in the time between :43 and 1:10. This part doesn't translate well from guitar to piano, so the bare minimum notes possible might give you the happiness you desire. Love your work!

  • Prefer your earlier camera angles where we could see more of you, rather than this over-the-shoulder shot of your hands only. Still love you and your performances.

  • It seems that piano is as easy as typing on a normal computer keyboard for her.

  • Very nice, very sensitively played, thank you

  • The emotion was captured perfectly, Vika.

    This is just what I needed to hear. ♥

  • Best Cover Of this Song.. !!

    please upload sheets of this music.. PLEASE.!!!

  • @donbeshqena sheet music is available on her website for a donation, I have it and it is excellent quality, be generous and help this brilliant musician become professional. more pink floyd coming soon by my request as well.

  • I think this is, as all of Vika's videos are, f**kin' awesome!

  • man i love this chics style. i wanna fudge you all over, and over and over again.

  • It just seems to me that you copy the emotion of the song (very well, I might add!) but you don't seem to experience or add to it. Why?

    But don't get me wrong, I'm a subscriber and admire your work, especially the pace at which you are able to pump out new videos.

  • The 3 versions are great!

    There is a lot of improvisations you can make on this song

    It is too much emotion to be expressed in a single song :)

  • This was one of the first songs I learned to play on guitar... and this is a lovely version of it. Beautiful, as always!

  • Do you have sheet music, or would you write some? I'd love to have it, if at all possible. I'd pay, if that's the way you roll. Really, please?

  • @Anya1138 its on her website

  • I still see your videos since 2008 and I am impressed with your endurance to make the best possible, this song it's really pretty, but it is perfect, with you playing.

  • super sweet, love it. good job. apologia pro vita sua

  • 7 people wish they wer nt here

    

  • Amazing,amazing,amazing!Very nice,this song is beaituful.

    Congrats

  • hey well done!!!, amazing you have encouraged me to play the piano

  • I hope you make sheets for this version:)

  • when you finished i started clapping

  • Love the fact you keep on improving and bring better and better versions, even when I thought it could not get better. Love the passion you put into these. Thanks!

  • I wish you were here playing...

  • if I could play piano like you I feel God

  • Superb cover, i just loved your control and sensibility over the intensity along the song. So deep, but i kinda miss the slides of the guitar, heh. :)

  • 7 people missed.

  • @vkgoeswild

    you have always been an amazing piano player i am 16 and have been playing for about 8 years, this song is extremely beautiful but, i recently lost one of my best friends from suicide and he was a die hard pink floyd fan and this was our favorite song by them and you playing this song just triggers all the great times i had with him! THANK YOU so much and i was wondering if by any chance i could get some type of sheet music for this song. it would be greatly appreciated.

  • @XxXonelovex She has sheet music available from her website for most of her songs. she probably mentioned it in one of her earlier versions.

  • @XxXonelovex you made cry ...

    i'm very happy you could remember those times with your friend, i really am ... :')

  • @XxXonelovex Your comment nearly made me cry.

  • @XxXonelovex pink floyd heals all wounds.

  • :-) thx

  • I LOOK UP TO YOU! :D

    

  • Love your videos :)

  • absolutely awesome. i just love it. its as epic as the original. you got some real talent :)

  • Epic

  • Please!! More pink floyd.. Please learn Dogs, Pigs (three different ones) Marooned! Ohh my goodness, MAROONED!

    That is all, thanks.

  • I really love how you perform this on the piano. Simply better than perfect. Congratulations, keep posting and sharing your talent for those who appreciate the real music.

  • I've watched all your videos and they're awesome, crazy request... Could you do through the fire and the flames by dragon force :S or is that TOO crazy?! If so could you do Purple Haze by Jimmi Hendrix? I thought your cover of all along the watchtower was amazing and wanted to see more... Guitar/piano solos :)

  • Wow... I can't believe you're still not happy with your cover of this song. I thought it was awesome the first time, and the second time, and again the third time! It's a hard one because it has so many different parts to it. Condensing it down to one instrument is not easy. But you do an amazing job! I look forward to version # 4 :-)

  • I want to have even just 1% of your skills

  • vk i love you but that just goes to show gilmore's solo cant be made in key boards

    gj with the power chords very intense

  • so much feeling! I love this

  • And she plays with no sheet music....

  • i think if you can put one more track of some organ behind the piano then it will be perfect

  • did any 1 else notices her vains on her right hand is in the shape of an A

  • Richard Wright is smiling down on you, sweetheart.

  • I am not sure how you cannot be happy with this Vika?

    I know you're a perfectionist but this is as perfect as it can get!! I wish I could just play the basic part on a piano but you play all of the vocal parts, melodies & sub-melodies as well in all of your song transcriptions. I really enjoy your video's! :-) Mad props to you!!!!!

  • Vika, thank you for turning one of my favourite songs into an amazing masterpiece.

  • Love Pink Floyd, love this song and now you're my new love ;-). Congrats. Amazing performance.

  • Great feeling!

  • This must be your favorite song. Hehe

  • thank you

  • its like the notes are your children you cared for every 1 of them with special attention and didnt forget 1 of the little basterds lol!i know youd be a great mom

  • NICE PLAY-IN CUTE STUFF !!!

  • Dynamics are very nice.

  • like the whole demonic wrist bands he's wearing the whole time he plays

  • @MrTapeitup its a she:)

  • @BluffasourisRex lol oh my bad, i didn't mean no disrespect in that

  • Even voice solo of David Gilmour ! Crasy ! Bravo :)

  • wow thats amazing !

  • Comment removed

  • NICE!!!

  • at some points it was so good that it seemed as if the keyboard would play the hands as instruments

  • I love this song and brilliantly played as always is the case with ALL your covers.

  • I LOVE YOU !!! ^^

  • Seen pinkfloyd last year in Pittsburgh...you sound good

  • Indeed...wish you were here.....

  • Absolutely brilliant and extremely impressive to play this "live":) Warm Wishes & Hugs - DeniseX

  • Wow that looks like a great keyboard dude, mind sharing what brand n stuff it is?

  • @sillybilly972 Looks like Roland RD-700SX to me

  • @sillybilly972 Looks like Roland RD-700DX based on the top left corner of the video.

  • вражаючий

  • Usually, who loves metal bands hates prog bands and also the opposite...I have to say you are an exquisite exception :-)

  • every time I hear this song I think of Lords of Dogtown.. Amazing song, amazing cover, flawless.

  • I always love your covers.

  • Just a question Vika, how much time do you spend in average to do a video? Like, i know you make some arrangements on your covers, but does it take you much time?

  • A+++ buyer, instant payment. Lightning fast transaction! Waka Waka this time for Africa. No seriously though, good job.

  • you are an amazing player with more feeling in your little finger, than the most in two hands (best hearable in your version of raindrops). but in min 3:06 your playing is a bit undefinite. and your timings in the mainmelody could have been better in timings - because i know, you have done it better on other songs. oh... so much critic - but here are so much compliments. with good reason. keep walkin' :)

  • Can I have the music for this please?

  • Just amazing!

  • Nice , Scorpions?

  • @superturbocharged Are you kidding?!?

  • @superturbocharged Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here

  • Just awesome.

  • Great song :)

  • love playing along to your covers with my guitar : ) thanks for another awesome video

  • haha one of my favorite songs, found myself singing along... it does seem terribly hard, and still you just can't help being amazing. Had I not seen this, based only on listening, I'd have probably thought there was more than one person playing, but nope, just you! Astonishing

  • i love you!!!

  • interesting interpretation. the dissonant melodies were an interesting take for the slide work. usually a pitch shifter/bender is the answer for that. (lol, if you have three hands.) funny how this alters from that to almost a country feel in parts of the lead. for some reason floyd never clicked with me personally, altho gilmore was amazing.

    always great fun watching you work.

  • I was waiting for the Roger Waters voice the whole time.

  • @Lmig08 to bad David Gilmour is the one who sings it lol

  • @jobin9 I like more Rogers voice. watch?v=vW-Dy2bYbAM

  • @Lmig08 yea maybe you should speak English cause i dont know what the hell your saying

  • Be Happy

  • 4 people are surd...

  • It really pisses me off that I didn't stick with my piano lessons when I was a kid!!

  • 4208 views and... only 508 "thumbs up"?! it's not fair at all...

  • @gigigogusan That is strange?

  • @desertfeathers I would say "strangelove" but now it's PinkFloyd time, not Depeche :P

  • @gigigogusan ? Ok :o

  • wow this is great

  • Have you wrote any original song?

  • I wanted to see the 2 people who disliked play the piano

  • I love this song so much...it reminds me of my boyfriend who is a long way away at the moment :( Thank you, this is beautiful

  • Perfect again!!!

  • 2 people dont miss barret ;(

  • She's so amazing; I can't truly express my love for her art,,, she's beyond amazing;;; and I wasnt even lkistening to Pink Floyd when I was young.

  • You play better than "Scott, The Piano Guy" on PBS. :)

    Truly beautiful! Thumbs Way up!

    peace....

  • Eargasm

  • @ppaarroott totally

  • thumbs up for modern melodic techniques

  • The sound is magical =)

  • that's so cool, i love it :')

  • maybe you have to change the part when second guita,r I think its gilmour's guitar ,starts to play,the part before he starts to sing,but everithing else is great!tnx for uploading

  • @tykqa they're all Gilmour's guitar. Waters only plays bass on this song; Gilmour plays 6-string, 12-string, and pedal steel.

  • Amazing

  • as always, flawless

  • oh my she thinks like i do lol ! i want that keyboard to bad its 1500$ used wtf :-(

    

  • what kind of piano is that?

  • @fatboy1333 Roland RD-700GX, you can read it in the top left corner.

  • just perfect.

    well done as usually :D:D

  • I just love the way it is played. With the emotion.

  • You should cover "goodbye blues sky". Awesome version this is :)

  • Marry me!!