NIGHTWISH THE SIREN GIBSON AMPHITHEATRE UNIVERSAL CITY 1/21/2012

[metaleroo4ever]

This seems to be a cover of "The siren"...Tarja sang this song at her tour....and in dispite it was not her song it sounded like Nightwish!

[mikewill9511]

@77elvistheking A true Nightwish fan accepts any change in the band. Tarja has a good voice, just that her ego is a letdown, and you can see that in her interviews. I like her voice in NW, but as a solo artist, she can't write worth a darn thing.

[V4mpIr3L4dY]

Sorry but a siren's singing is supposed to hypnotize the men...

[ladyofmusick]

Tuomas, I love you. That solo was breathtaking :)

[rorexcampus]

@dark7700 jajja como las sirenas monia que aparecen en el juego god of war 1 jajaja secas y sin voz ....

[dark7700]

@rorexcampus jajajaja tomatela , de seguro sos otro inutil tarjista que no sabe a donde ir y requiere a los videos de anette sabiendo que no le gusta juajauaja das lastima

[rorexcampus]

@dark7700 jajaja ok sorry PERO eso fue lo primero que se me vino a la mente según tu sugerencia a cerrar los ojos he imaginar ...lo siento si te ofendí en algo (lo dudo porque esto no nos influye en nada a ambos)...amo a NW tanto como a TARJA.... al final el alma de Nw es thomas quien escribe las canciones tarja y annete son solo sus interpretes cada una a su manera... sigue con lo tuyo vive tu vida y olvídate de la mía.... SIN NADA MAS QUE AGREGAR...

[rorexcampus]

TARJA- THE SIREN MOSCOW 2011 FIND THIS ON YOUTUBE AND COMMENT TARJA IS SO BETTER THAN EVER FOREVER

[RockSidi]

@rorexcampus The music is not a competition who is "better" because it's alway matter of taste and a personal opinion.I like this version more and you like the old one so who is right...NO ONE or do you think that for example I'm gonna change my mind...sorry NO!It's ok if you like Tarja but you don't need to prove it here because people are not interested that at all and she is not in the band anymore...still Nightwish Rocks (my opinion)!I like Tarja too so all the best to her solo.

[rorexcampus]

@RockSidi OK share your opinion ... I just wanted to show .. who has the interest will be given the time to do ... sorry if I showed my preference to studies, the technique and vocal power that has "Tarja" ...But if as you say nightwish continuous rocking, well I love the band if Tarja at the end was just the voice ... I've always said that the soul of the band is thomas because he is the one who writes and composes ....only Tarja put his intention and emotion now does differently annete...TARJA

[RockSidi]

@rorexcampus I understand your point and you have right to like what ever you want.I only replied to you because many people (like me) are so tired of this old issue and want to move on.I like this band but I'm a NW fan and not "one member of the band fan".Anette gives also emotion to this song but totally different way but still it's matter of taste and can you accept the things to do in other way.I like the new style of this great band but also respect the old one too!NW Rocks!

[jezabeldispair]

I think anette does an amazing job on this song. If you want to argue about technique, then lets put it into perspective. in the grand scheme of things, Tarja's vocals were average at best in the opera world. I think the Anettes vocal style adds a different dimension to the songs, but different is definitely not bad here! I think the overall effect on the band since Anette joined has been nothing but positive and made nightwish what they should be. Its 5 years now guys, shes earned some loyalty!

[FUCKVEVOBIGTIME]

Tuomas' solo, where it is from? I remember it's from an earlier song?

[DanasLilMakeup]

I think Anette definitely had some extra training during these years, she sounds waaaaay better, I used to hate her gospel sound in every song, I think she understood that she has to be more versatile and she doesn't abuse her 'aaaaaaaaaayaaaaaaa' tune. Very well done, even though I think this song isn't the best for her voice, but I just looooove the way she managed to sound unique without being annoying.

[Masherin]

I like Anette singing other songs but seriously what is she doing here!? She doesnt sound like a siren! Fuck, I always tell myself not to listen to her singing the old songs =.=

[RockSidi]

@Masherin "She is singing old NW song!"You don't like this new version of the song because you start to compare it to the first your favorite version.You don't compare new NW songs because only Anette has done it so far.NW plays the old songs because they want to do so and still many fans like that too.They can't please every individual person because it's matter of taste and you have to accept that fact.As you mentioned you don't listen this but we have to allow the others to do so!

[Masherin]

@RockSidi I give my opinion to what I hear and I dont like what she did here, this song was not written for her voice. Everybody is allowed to express his/hers opinion, so am I doing here, damn deal with it, I wasnt even insulting her, I respect her and I actually said I like her singing other songs. Where the fuck did I say she is not allowed to sing the old songs!? I only said I(YES I) should not listen to her singing the old songs. Damn, you moron.

[RockSidi]

@MasherinI gave feedback to you so if I'm a moron like you wrote then you must be too.Did I wrote that you insulting her...NO I didn't so I don't understand where did you get that thing in your head.It's ok if you don't like this but this band needs little respect how they do the music and what they play on the stage.Anyway it's not fair to judge her from this low quality sound because it's totally different thing to be there on the spot.I like both versions but that's only my opinion!

[Masherin]

@RockSidi

Really, this is exhausting. I have much respect for this band, I buy their albums and dvds, I praise them. Here Im just not happy with the female vocals. The guys play good as always. Being a fan doesnt mean ur happy with every freaking song that's played live. Im just honest and not fake. Seriously, whats the problem? As I compliment her with other songs, I say im not happy with this one. Let people express their opinion without making their heads tired with; respect the band blabla

[RockSidi]

@Masherin The first sentence of the first comment to you was JOKE and you got it wrong and burned your pants...Fuck... we can end this bull shit.However,you must keep in mind that if you write something here then you better learn to accept negative feedback too.Everybody can say their honest opinion about your comment and even disagree with you same way like you "very strongly" expressed to me.NW gonna do what they want and they don't care a shit about our music taste.Have a nice day!

[Masherin]

@RockSidi yeah yeah everybody can give their opinion but im not into into a childish bitchfight about nothing. I do recognize quality. Well good night and just enjoy the music and stay honest; dont bitch about silly things yess

[andreeaa90]

No one can deny that Anette's voice is getting better and better with time..

[liodhan]

awww......old nightwish songs =)

[Anttisiipa]

Tuomas is playing Tutankhamen.

[andreeaa90]

@Anttisiipa and a little bit of Arabesque xD

[kokosoveniebo]

@Anttisiipa

and Arabesque also ;}

[vailismyname]

She has definitely improved singing this song :D

[Octvaerum]

COOL! Anette has done a good job here and song of myself!

[mikewill9511]

@maxadrienne2 Your comments show a great ignorance in musical skills. Lyrical and regular singing arent the same thing. When it comes to lyrical singing you have to support the whole voice with the diagphram and other techniques to create resonance. Non lyrical singing requires this but at a lower scale and less vibrato. I suggest you stop trolling NW vids and leave us true fans alone. Go kneel before Tarja in her vids.

[77elvistheking]

@mikewill9511 So you are a true fan? The one that thinks that Tarja is not good?

Because from the comment "Go kneel before...." that's what it seems!

[mikewill9511]

@alessia79twnsnd If you are here to criticize a singer even though you dont have a musical background, I suggest you leave us true NW fans alone.

[LilyLollypop10000]

the keyboard solo is with a part "Tutankhamen"! I love how they wanted to recall the old times even when they're deep in new times! <3

[andreez1]

I'm sorry but to me the only one that can sing this song is Tarja. her voice is just perfect for this song. It truly makes it seem like she's a Siren.

Anette kinda ruins the song. But she has improved. I'll give her that.

[DBCREWTOMMYSTIX]

@maxadrienne2 i was at the show.. listened to c.d. before.. she has greatly i,proved.. very good show!!!

[TheEarthforge]

Y'know, you can like Tarja and Anette and appreciate the gap in their abilities too. I think Tarja is more gifted and better, but I personally like Anette's voice combined with the music more (partially because the combination with the newer compositions is more unique to me.) Toumas is a genius composer. (But I can't say much more than that, because I cannot respect a man who used media support to hurt others. I don't care who was at fault, it was his obligation to not let it snowball.)

[lflaviorochan]

@maxadrienne2 it's not the first nor the second time I see you posting on a nightwish video bashing Anette. You are clearly searching for it just to say bad things. Stop it. You clearly don't like Anette, so stop searching for her.

STOP IT.

[maxadrienne2]

@lflaviorochan

You forgot to say "please". How old are you anyway, if you are above preteen you severely lack social interaction.

1 - I am here becasue I like(d) Nightwish and because interet is a free place - for the moment

2 - what I say is always backed by arguments. Good or bad, that's debatable, at least I am not spilling nonsenses like most retards here

3 - most of the time am not stating. I am REPLYING to something (a lie, a stupidity etc) some aphonic hillbilly made.

[DarkWingsAscending]

Too funny that they still use Tarja's backing vocals on this song. 2:24 to the end LOL

[pivisign]

@DarkWingsAscending That is complete nonsense. All the backing vocals in the old Nightwish songs were remade during Dark Passion Play recordings, if needed. What you hear is the sound of the choir singers in Metro Voices. Nightwish used them already on Once. How stupid of me, I thought that Tarja fans are able to distinguish her unique voice anywhere...

[Makousen]

Thank you so much for uploading this, kind person. I love Nightwish so much. I only wish they could come to the east coast.

[liodhan]

my face melted with Tuomas' solo and Nettie's voice =')

such a great sound =D

[jeremy92morgan]

Nice solo Tuomas! I still like the one from the End of an Era DVD the best though.

[E65Hawk]

I like anette's version more. Much more pleasant on the ears, yet still fucking scary and mystical

[lightaddicted]

she doesn't sing as she wants to look like. hitting a note doesn't mean you are a good singer, neither that you deliver the message that song was meant for. Tell me: what do you feel when she sings a song that Tuomas wrote? do you feel The Song, or her voice?

[lightaddicted]

@lightaddicted I just hear a good voice singing. the whole new album doesn't not have a meaning for me, if not thanks to the Nightwish mood.

[medepona]

@lightaddicted I myself think she puts more feeling into the songs than Tarja did, but that might be just me... :p

[maxadrienne2]

@medepona

Yeah, because "feeling" means having an ugly voice, missing most the notes and screaming instead of singing.

[DarkWingsAscending]

@maxadrienne2

Pffft, what are you talking about. Anette is ONLY the bestest belter of metal music EVER. DUR!!

BTW - this is sarcasm - I agree with you.

[maxadrienne2]

@DarkWingsAscending

Trust me, you would not recognize belting if it would hit you in the head.

See what I replied to @medepona, I am tired of explaining the same things to the same stupid issues.

[DarkWingsAscending]

@maxadrienne2

Trust me, I know what belting is and Anette does not belt. :)  I completely agree with you.

[maxadrienne2]

@DarkWingsAscending

Yes.

For the belting noobs here is a great example /watch?v=ecvHBLadaxM

It's a song by Kamelot called "Elisabeth" and interpreted by Roy Khan.

Until 3:00 he sings chest voice - head voice over and over and at that time he does belting. Perfectly controlled and sounds beautifully.

Does not sound anything like Anette, no? :)

[Darkshadewisper]

@maxadrienne2 yes it's fantastic i'm gonna miss Roy ^^ but i'm sure they will be just as good :D

[mikewill9511]

@maxadrienne2 He is a male. Anette is a female.

[alessia79twnsnd]

@mikewill9511

Khan is a singer. Anette is not. That's the difference. For a male belting such notes is times harder than for a female by the way.

[mikewill9511]

@maxadrienne2 And another thing. Quit the lectures. You say Anette doesn't belt here and Tarja can in Wishmaster. I will tell you something. BOTH do. The difference? Tarja is a lyrical singer and Anette not. Hence the different sound when belting.

[maxadrienne2]

@mikewill9511

I think you are just stupid.

- Is there the lyrical-way and non-lyrical way of belting? :)

- "Lyrical singer" means nothing. Tarja is a classical and metal singer. She is classified as a lyrical soprano. This has nothing do do with being "lyrical", it's just a voice type.

Try to form your culture by reading books, instead of reading YT comments. Sometimes helps.

[medepona]

@maxadrienne2 Ugly voice or not, the band has more fun on stage now than ever, her interpretations of the songs is her strong side, AND she is unique! I havent heard any other belting singers in metal before! :p Whatever this is, its new (and wasnt metal originally about creating new unique sounds and have fun?) and the band seems happy! If the sounds doesnt fit everybody, whatever! I myself for example dont prefer hiphop because i dont like the sound.... 

[maxadrienne2]

@medepona

It's normal than people liking Anette also have no idea about music theory.

Wikipedia does not always help eythier.. sometimes you just need real knowledge :)

Belting is not singing high notes with a chest voice. ALL popular music (pop, rock, etc) singers do that.

Belting = singing powerful notes in the high register, using abdomen muscles (hence the term 'BELTing")

Anette's weak and out of tune screeches are just bad technique.

Belting is Tarja in Wishmaster.

[medepona]

@maxadrienne2 So I hear you claim my comment is based upon "Wiki-knowledge" and u assume I dont know what it is, just bursting out comments just because I like to mess around (but in our both cases you are the one posting discuss-friendly comments the most!)!? In that case, wrong assumption! Don't assume things about people man! That is my advice for you!

[maxadrienne2]

@medepona

Not even wiki.

"havent heard any other belting singers in metal before" is based either on Anette's own words (who falsly belives she is belting when in fact she is straining - leading to horrible results AND a permanent voice deterioration), or is based on her fan's words who logically belive her.

I sustained my reply about belting with it's true definition, antithesing what Anette does with how it should be made.

It was not intended to be a flame. Sorry if I offended.

[medepona]

@maxadrienne2 No offence taken! I know how Tarja-fanatics are like so I understand by now when people try to "prove me wrong" about Anette...!

[maxadrienne2]

@medepona

If you say a stupidity, than someone comes and proves you wrong (starting from the very definition of the terms you used) and the conclusion you draw is that they are fanatics.. well. is there anything more left to say?

I don't even mind of being called a fanatic when it comes to one of the greatest singers ever.

You should concern, because you are a fanatic.. to one of the shittiest singers in showbiz today.

[reafras]

@maxadrienne2 but...clean up your glasses before talking about the crap you see around

anette isn't a bad singer and she is on quite a perfect balance for being a singer while being also a good person with a life. idk...I'd prefer the alive singer instead of a machine that would do as the papers and rules say while hiding behind the big let's say.. like "tarja" icon nightwish created...in this case if we're talking about tarja, that would be a "shitty" machine : /

[reafras]

@maxadrienne2 but if you aren't just looking for someone to argue with...why are wasting your time here..you know if you beleive that tarja is really good,you'd simply support her on videos that actually are about her

whatever...if you're just here to argue then...it's cool i can do it for a while with you

[medepona]

@maxadrienne2 AND if i might be wrong about the "belting", may be so! BUT Anette is the few I have heard sing like that in metal! It that is me being "inexperienced" then so be it! You want to argue! You win! I give up! I have better things to do! AND: A LOT more people here arguing with you at this point so i think you can handle the loss of me! I dont want to be even more disrespectful by ruin this EXCELLENT video with a conversation leading nowhere! ANETTE ROCKS! TARJA ROCKS! END OF STORY!!)

[DanasLilMakeup]

@medepona Is that the particular way Tarja fans or Tarja followers are, arguing and arguing throwing shit to everything and everyone that think different from them and don't like all about her. It is just endless discussion with them, I dunno if they are retarded or just very stubborn close-minded people and honestly, as you said is a loss of time. You don't like NW fine, Tarja isn't the best fucking voice (actually i think she is annoying) in this world: we know it, she knows it, everyone does.

[TheSkellaish]

@maxadrienne2 I don't feel like argue with you, but if you really think Anette is "one of the shittiest singers in showbiz"... I don't know in wich universe you exist, but I wouldn't like to enter it.

[reafras]

@maxadrienne2 welll instead explaining how it goes..i'll simply say that she is working with quite high quality musicians...I'd consider it before being a smart ass

[Billium1993]

@maxadrienne2 I don't see why people like you actually visit these videos, you have to accept this is Tuomas's band, you have no right to criticize Annette.. he obviously wanted her to play this song because he thinks a version with her in it is a nice way to recreate a classic, plus don't you think us true Nightwish fans want to hear the Pre EOAE songs still? I think Annette does a good job at adapting this, go screw yourself.

[maxadrienne2]

@Billium1993

Being a true fan does not mean to kiss Tuomases ass. Did it not strike you already that all you "true fans" are using almost the same phrases? "If Tuomas thought.. It's Tuomas band" and so on.

.

Also - my post was punctual. Focused on an issue, with a demonstration, definitions etc. I disputed on PRINCIPLE level.

The fact that you and idiots like you get inflamed and just spill PERSONAL attacks and insults, pretty much shows your level.

Way to go, "true fan"!

[DanasLilMakeup]

@maxadrienne2 I think the same and is just disgusting seeing ppl kissing either Tuomas' ass or Tarja's ass and saying even if they have a stroke is perfect, c'mon! YES, Anette still needs technique and is out of tune when she hits high notes, and YES, Tarja also needs to find the way and stop having vibratto in every fucking note she sings and understand that not everything is sung like an aria, it gets annoying, nobody's perfect ppl, enjoy the fucking music and get over it.

[maxadrienne2]

@DanasLilMakeup

I agree mostly, but not with the vibrato part. Vibrato is a natural feat of any voice and cannot be removed, just controlled. Tarja anyway renounced the operatic/even/constant vibrato since after Wishmaster.

And even if (I agree with you here) she approaches almost any song clasically, she does it without sounding pretentious. She's just being true to her vision about music.

I like and listen to her since '98 but not because of fandom. I simply like her singing.

[DanasLilMakeup]

@maxadrienne2 I also listen to her in NW since the same year, but you see, I know vibrato is natural, but there are times when her vibrato sounds forced, especially live, and to me tends to bee kind of annoying for the ears at some point, I also enjoy opera and I haven't had the same experience with other sopranos. And is not like she sounds pretentious; is just her voice doesn't fit, I disliked big time her version of Still of the Night, the music is great but her voice is the problem to me.

[maxadrienne2]

@DanasLilMakeup

Imho her vibrato is perfect and she is among the few classical singers who does not need to control it. Funnily you mentioned opera - because all opera singing requires forced and measured vibrato.

Regarding Still of the Night - some time ago 20.000 ppl at a concert of hers, around me, were having ear orgasms hearing it. Nuff said?

I mean - there too many people knowing music that adore her. At least that should add a bit of doubt to your when thinking that.

[DanasLilMakeup]

@maxadrienne2 Oh, I respect your opinion, I can see you are great fan from her and well, I am just saying that her vibrato sounds better in albums like Oceanborn and Wishmaster, even Century Child; then for me started to get annoying. About Still Of The Night, IN MY OPINION, she broke the song i nto pieces, perhaps is me thinking that bands like Whitesnake are untouchable, but like I said, music to me was fantastic, her voice wasn't, maybe because i am not Tarja fan, that's what I think. :)

[DanasLilMakeup]

@maxadrienne2 and like saying she is among a few classical singers, to me sounds pretentious, there are a lot of better singers and maybe not that famous, Tarja is great but not the best, just sayin'. Then again makes me remember about the 'all that she does is perfect' thing. xx

[maxadrienne2]

@DanasLilMakeup

The vibrato in Oceanborn was purely operatic, thus forced, constant and even. I like that period of hers just because it demonstrated she can sing mezzo and dramatic parts.

I don't even know what being a "fan" means. If by that you are implying I like her music because I like her or because of some loyalty, that's not the case.

-

So, I don't like her voice because I am a fan, but I became a fan because I like her voice. What other reason to becoming a 'fan"?

[DanasLilMakeup]

@maxadrienne2 Sorry If I missunderstood your point but to me you sound contradictory with your comments, like you say you agree about the 'not kissing their ass (either Tarja or Holopainen) and your comments sound like that to me, I am ok saying she is great BUT not the best and she will never will, unless the other huge voices die, all of them. I think arguments or discussions about this are so over rated and like i said in some comment above is loss of time. Have a good day/night.

[maxadrienne2]

@DanasLilMakeup

If you consider that someone truly appreciating X is "kissing X's ass", it's because you have an inner hate for X. The kind of hate based on envy.

Looking at your history it's fairly obvious. You visit a huge amount of Tarja videos, start by posting that you like her, than trash her and end up fighting with people over it. After 1-2 weeks, you leave dissapointed of people immaturity :)

[DanasLilMakeup]

@maxadrienne2 Ah yeah I forgot that tarja fans tend to spy others channels LOL. In case you didn't read, those videos say NIGHTWISH-She Is My Sin, not Tarja She is my sin, and so on, and like, seriously, this make me lol all the time, people like you are just hilarious, think you know about pretty much everything but truth is you only repeat what others say. Anyway, I have work to do, if you excuse me, have a good day! xx

[maxadrienne2]

@DanasLilMakeup

"Spy other channels" Why would someone leave its channel public, than for ..the public.

It's like walking naked on the street and accusing people they are perverts. You're funny :)

[ThePanteleia]

@maxadrienne2 But to compensate, she has a lovely head voice.Power isn't always a factor to what's good.This is why Anette shines in songs like Slow,Love,Slow.Technique can be discussed, but how a certain voice can affect is completely subjective.Plus,may I say,Tarja is not a master of singing too, the early demos show off a really deep voice, but no good technique whatsoever.Then she literary pushed the voice out of her lungs, without resonating.Now, she does it, but the deep voice is gone.

[maxadrienne2]

@ThePanteleia

(First post)

I am sorry but your words have no meaning. I am trying to inflamate or insult you (and other "fans"), but maybe make you think again, maybe gain some culture and gain some musical ear.

I will address most of your sentence and prove them wrong punctually, with proof .. like in court.

I HOPE this way you and others like you would finally get that nobody is trashing Anette, or worshipping Tarja. It's just reality.

So here I go:

[maxadrienne2]

@ThePanteleia

(Third)

"Tarja is not a master of singing too, the early demos show off [...]"

This is NW first TV apparition

/watch?v=4Binso-m5eA&feature=r­esults_main&playnext=1&list=PL­D9084CAD52CC4483

This is NW first recorded demo

/watch?v=FmDmokZILt8

We hear here a girl singing in a very low tessitura resembling a dramatic-mezzo soprano and having a perfect technique. Sometimes her voice sounds like crying. Those were the trademarks for AFF and Oceanborn which most "old fans" adore.

[ThePanteleia]

@maxadrienne2 I think you didnt get my point :).I meant that now Tarja has an awesome technique,but before, in recordings,sometimes she was out of tune(passion and the opera, not live however) and in The Forever Moments her voice sounds pushed,I dislike anything that sounds unnatural.What I was trying to say is,even though she has now improved,I liked her more in the older albums,simply because her tembre was so much softer and deeper,despite the flaws she had then.Technique isn't everything.

[maxadrienne2]

@ThePanteleia

I replied so detailed to make you understand you are writing nonsenses.

It was for nothing it seems.

You mentioned voice deepness, I replied and proved Tarja uses now when she wants to a much deeper voice.. and you keep writing "her tembre was [..] deeper".

You say she had a weaker technique in the demos, I reply proving ON the demos you are wrong, you keep writing "despite the flaws she had then".

And so on..

I think you are just stupid and a waste of my time.

[ThePanteleia]

@maxadrienne2 and no, it has nothing to do with Anette, i simply noticed that you see technique as some grand master of what's good and what's not, simply decided to share my philosophy.I also dislike the way you replied, like i'm trying to stab you with my comment.One simply cannot live with that in mind :D.Overall, I never saw you bashing Anette, not trying to defend her, simply wrote it all down the bad way.

[maxadrienne2]

@lightaddicted

Hitting a note does not mean you are a good singer. Any student from any music school can do that. Many do that without studying, by ear.

NOT hitting the notes.. well.. that does make you a bad singer.

[feriaxD007b]

Tutankhamen in the solo!!!! :D

[markena909]

Anette looks great in her black dress <3

[TheKlem27]

It's wonderful to hear Tutankhamen in this. So old, so beautiful !

[hcn0jonah]

i didn't like that 2:47 but the rest is amazing

[Zephyesa]

Anette continues to grow even better

[Zephyesa]

YES AT LAST THEY HAVE RETURNED!!!!

[lukkaturi]

Who tied my hands to the wheel...?

[jeffhardyrules1991]

Loved the keyboard solo 

[SilverDommi]

Anette's dancing <3

[hawk1513]

i was blown away with this song live. GREAT NIGHT!

[1LilDave]

Okay, so Tuomas did or didn't make a mistake in the keyboard solo?

[emil9412]

@1LilDave I didn't hear any mistakes... though you might think so because it's not the original solo??

[PinkFloydGirl9532]

@1LilDave Hahaha he didn't, it's from a different song! :P

[mikewill9511]

The aiaiaia sounds like someone crying.... nice....

[Adrianabunbury]

i can't see the difference between her past "Siren" and this one, is the same, she is out of tune in many times,

[mikewill9511]

@Adrianabunbury Tell me the minute when she's out of tune....

[Adrianabunbury]

@mikewill9511 i'm gonna give you the opportunity to find it by yourself :) btw i prefer that anette sings her new songs i mean like Want my tears back or the Dove, the owl and ...... 'cuz her voice fits with the music, the old songs just are not for her, i like also Eva and the Poet and the P.. even her Voice in Cathedral walls with STS sounds good.. i'm not hate her, she has her good qualities.. like a beautiful soft voice

[soccerstud4243]

@Adrianabunbury actually, she was never out of tune the whole song.....

[Adrianabunbury]

@cybellena ohhhhhh I see that you pay too much attention to my comments, thanks means a lot to me, Thank you again XD... and who needs to get a life is you, who stay on yt reading my comments, i didn't want to come back to this video 'cuz i don't like too much this performance, but your funny comment made that i break my promise... everyone is free to post a comment on a video, and is more enjoyable when people like you answer them.. XD...

[cybellena]

@Adrianabunbury

you actually know that you'll hate the performance before you see it that's the reason you are posting each and every nw video some bullshit just because you can...

you're charming...quite much

[TheEscapist15]

I'm amazed. Anette is singing this song soooooo f*ckin goooood <3... Her voice is way more stronger than before. Tuomas, Emppu, Marco & Jukka are amazing (as usual). I really love the mix in Tuomas' solo *w*

Nightwish FOREVER!!!

Thanks for the upload ^^

[majskanoc]

Totally amazing and beautiful performance!!!

[Bluebluememory]

never thought anette could sing this song so well! though her aiaiaiaiai does sound ridiculous.

[cybellena]

@Bluebluememory i actually like it...it fits much better than "Ha Ha Ha" since song is about sirens.

[Nightowljrm]

Nice to see some Angels Fall First thrown into the mix!

[jandrodavid]

24 hours ago, I was there, listening to this song :D

[ceauvama]

actually i love the aiaiaiiaiaiaiaaaaaa!!!

[HeartsEyes]

@ceauvama Me, too. And actually it is just vocalizing around the ayayaha part that was already in the old version as well. Nothing really new.

[Eireajanele]

@sahara0587 Try to think of her as the wife of the man who was caught by a siren. This sounds really like someone crying in despair...

[sahara0587]

@Eireajanele ¬¬ I dont think so, she can sound good without making the ''aiaiaiaiaiai'', she should replace it by a looooong beautiful note. The 'aiaiaiaiaia'' sucks in such incredible song.

[Ahasverus92]

Arabesque + Tuthan Kamen = Best keyboard solo ever :D

[DeEscapist]

Better than Tarja! I want reedition of "Once" with Anettes version of The Siren!

[TranceAnton]

@DeEscapist LMAO. You must be joking.

[SymphonyOfSword2Swan]

@TranceAnton its his/her preference c'mon

[azabache1525]

The most amazing siren ever!

[0NightStar0]

Yeahh Arabesque and Tutankhamen in Tuomas' keyboard solo! :D

[FrkBerwald]

@0NightStar0 Its not the first time he does something like this, I have a rare live CD from Sweden where he in the Pharaoh Sails To Orion plays Moondance in the middle of the song, it improved the song really much (I love them both so having them at the same time was magical)

[0NightStar0]

@FrkBerwald Yeah I know, really cool! :D Or on the last tour when Emppu plays the solo of Walking in the Air in Dead Boy's Poem :)

I really love that they do these things! (also in Planet Hell and Nemo on this tour :D )

[azabache1525]

@0NightStar0 Thats really amazing!

[nightwishfan60]

@0NightStar0 I loled at Tutankhamen and so hope they play it in future

[mc23243]

Anette really amazed me, her voice is stronger and more beautiful than ever before. Tuomas, Marco, Emppu and Jukka are great as always. Thank you for uploading