Added: 3 years ago
From: MalLovesDixie
Views: 99,616
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (146)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fantasia deserved to win. She kept the show going. She worked very hard.

    SO FAR SHE IS MY ALL TIME FAVORITE!

  • Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, and Jordin Sparks are the only people that have kept on going for their singing career. The rest are just greedy whores and bitches that don't deserve to win. America chose the wrong ones. I haven't heard of any other winners in the singing industry. Fantasia's only a one-hit wonder and that's about it.

  • season 10 winner Scotty McCreery rocks it was a tight race between him and Lauren Alaina

  • taylor hicks is the best the haters suck

  • i think KELLY AND CARRIE thats IT!! Some of those i have never even heard their songs!

  • Kelly Clarkson is the best. No question.

  • Kelly Clarkson is the greatest singer. She is a worldwide superstar!!!

  • Haha Taylor Hicks was a joke. I haven't seen an album release from him in a looong time. Carrie Underwood was by far the best winner. :)

  • kelly will forever be the best idol.

  • IMO, Kelly, Carrie and David are the ONLY times that America got it RIGHT!! The other winners SHOULD have been: Clay Aiken, Jennifer Hudson (or LaToya London), Katharine McPhee and Melinda Dolittle!! I mean, c'mon, TAYLOR HICKS?!?!?! SERIOUSLY?!?! LOL

  • kelly forever

  • Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, David Cook, they all stand out. The others are good, but not in these three's league. Sorry.

  • so awesome

  • it's kelly kelly kelly of course!!!! world superstar!!!!

  • @loveukelly024 , You mean Carrie by far the best of all.

  • @row759 no

  • @loveukelly024 , I say yes that Carrie is the best Idol winner not Kelly.

  • oh i guess i missed it

  • Carrie is the best!!!

  • Kelly, Carrie & David all the way.

  • jordan sparks did not win

  • @blackberry4555 Yes she did!

  • Carrie is good, but Kelly is amazing, she is by far the most sucessfull! I love her heaps!! Im going to her concert in 2 weeks!! Yaaaaay! Cant wait!!

  • carrie all the way

  • carrie...

  • KELLY CLARKSON<3

  • I think Taylor Hicks was the best contestant! He was full of energy and passion. You could really tell that he was comfortable on stage and he has a true passion for music.

  • Carrie definitely is the best American Idol. At the present she has the most number of Grammys and although her season win was in 2005 ( that is about almost 5 years already)--she still is in the spotlight garnering awards and keeping her feet firmly planted on the ground. She is an amazing talent and i am sure American idol is so proud of her.

  • In my opinion Carrie Underwood is the best american idol ever !

  • I think Tasia iz the best American Idol Winner out of all the rest of them. Then the rest of the list goes like this:

    Kelly

    Carrie

    Jordin

    Ruben

    David

    Taylor he really sucks and i dont see why he won

  • Adam didnt win so he wouldn't be apart of this group. But he is an AMAZING singer

  • the best american Idol winner is Carrie Underwood, she's simply the BEST 4ever!!!

  • wow i think what kelly is the orginial american idol : the besttt !!!! i love

  • David Cook in my opinion is the best Idol winner EVER!!

  • now u can add adam lambert!!..lol

  • my favorite idol is fantaisa

    but i loved them all with the exception of one

    kelly ruben

    fantaisa

    carrie jordan

    david

     are all great

  • Kelly Clarkson set the bar for this competition. In my opinion, none of the other winners come close to her league with the exception of Carrie Underwood and David Cook.

  • David Cook rocks the house of AI...

  • the song said it all, DAVID COOK CHANGED AI

  • Yeah,I believed!David Cook is the reason why I really adore AI..And here,.American Idol became more more famous when DC won last season.And made his very 1st hit "Always Be My Baby" and became the track of the year 2008 in almost radio stations...

  • Fantasia is The American Idol

    Voice + Best Performer to ever hit the stage

    and her voice is so big right now it has grown so much, tasia is where it's AT!!!

  • i think their all good, but jordin, kelly and carrie are probably the only ones to get really famous

  • Fantasia is and was the true star. Forever Fantasia!!

  • kelly kelly kelly <3<3<3<3<3<3

  • she's amazing! love her :)

    GO KELLY! <3

  • u forgot kris allen

  • @YourmightTv he didnt forget Kris Allen, this is only 1-7. Kris won the 8th reason.

  • @YourmightTv 1-7 he is not a winner 4 seasons 1-7

  • KELLY CLARKSON

    kuv Carrie 2

  • Nice video..all the winners are great! Taylor Hicks is my fave- check out my Taylor concert videos.

  • so glad carrie won. she is the most successful! but so mad taylor hicks won. katharine would have been a much better representative!

  • David Cook honestly... gave a new meaning for A.I.,

    versatility, originality, he has a strong voice., out of all those winners., HE is the BEST!!!.. hehe

  • David Cook is the best...See Time of my Life is here...Amazing singer ever!That's DC...

  • fantasia all they way, no "ands" "ifs" or "Buts"

  • SORYY~~~~ accidentaly press 2 star . very nice la 5 star 5 star la

  • Kelly clarkson all the way!

  • i like it.

    carries my fave idol

  • Fantasia is the Best of the bunch.

  • tat +kris :( adam should have won

  • carrie is the best american idol for me

  • kriiiissss!!!!!!!! luv ya!! <3333

  • kelly clarkson is hot.

    i love her face

  • Kelly the best of the best!!!

  • The new video is up y'all. It's got all 8 of your American Idols.

  • Thanks for all of the great comments y'all. I'm working on one for all 8.

  • u really do like david cook, right?

    proove: the song is DC song

  • American Idol should have been this way:

    Season 1- Kelly Clarkson (no doubt)

    Season 2 - Clay Aiken

    Season 3 - Fantasia Barrino

    Season 4- Carrie Underwood (she's so gorgeous!)

    Season 5 - Chris Daughtry

    Season 6 - Jordin Sparks

    Season 7 - David Cook (but Archuleta comes close)

    Season 8 - Adam Lambert or Danny Gokey!

    Yipee!

  • @MrPlanax Archuleta doesn't come close, 12 million votes is alot.

  • @Azelf3 it wasnt based on the votes. it was based on my personal preference.

  • david, kelly, and carrie are the best and they will always be, no competition

  • kelly is the best

  • fantasia rocks

  • aw kelly's pic is too cute!

    1. kelly aND DAVID

    2. carrie

    3.kris

    4.jordin

    5. ruben

    6. fantasia

    7. taylor

  • now we can add kris to the video! =)

  • DAVID COOK IIIIS ROOOCK

    I really like him

  • Kris should have been ADDED... wohooo..

  • you are way to organized

  • kris won! he needs to be added now 2

  • david cook is the best

  • Kelly, Carrie and David! Their on a league of their own. The awesome idol trio!

  • yes! they're the best American Idols!

  • Adam lambert sicks hes weird and gay goathick i hate him.

  • You are the best of the best Taylor Hicks!!!

  • ADAM IS NEXT

  • You stink he sucks

  • KRIS WON THE SHOW!!!!!

  • TAYLOR HICKS WON THE SHOW!!!!!

    so what. i dont think kris sucks but not worthy of the title.

  • My favourite is of course David Cook!

  • you should add the names somewhere in the video

    \but otherwise cool video

  • kris allen is gonna win this year

  • You did a VERY good job at this!!!

  • adam lambert is the next american idol...no question abt that..

  • Danny Gokey....

    is the Season  8

    American Idol

    Trust Me

  • It's either adam or allison...danny will probably get 3rd, unless VFTW picks him up to 2nd

  • yeah.. got to agree with you...

    he's like, a bit of david cook, and a bit mellow, if you know what i mean...

    i don't see why a lot of people think it'll be adam lambert... i mean, he's good but still, i think danny's better...

  • Danny IS better than Adam...only reason why ppl(more like chicks) love Adam cuz he's got the emo look on him, and he has a good theatrical performance. Even Simon said that during the audition. Adam's voice is good...but at the same time its not.

  • Awesome job on the video. It's amazing.

  • ADAM LAMBERT I LOVE HIM HE IS HOT

  • David Cook is #1

  • YOU all got Fantasia twisted she won awards for her Broadway performance and she is workingon some special projects won another Image year , she has two state of the art recording sudios and ahs been working steadily since leaving Broadway and is also ddoing Gospel now!!! She is very secretive she is only 24 and doing just fine!!!! Very busy!!!!

  • FANTASIA!!!!

  • season 8 - Adam Lambert,,

    yeah!!

  • fantasia is my fav of all

  • Comment removed

  • r u a critic, shut up, just comment on the video we don't want an update, fuck face!

  • Where was Daughtry????

  • Daughtry didnt win. Sadly. He was in Season 5, the season Taylor Hicks won. Which, if you ask me, Daughtry was the best of that season. Oh well, he's way more famous then Taylor Hicks anyways.

  • wouldn't it b cool if dey all performed together on 1 stage singing 1 great song?!!

    dat would b something amazing 2 watch!!

    btw Awesome job wid d vid

    luuuved it!

  • Carrie is the most successful Idol as far as award winning...Kelly still holds the album sales only because she's been around longer...I love them both! David Cook's cd rocks as well...I hope that he jumps right up there with Carrie and Kelly as Idol success

  • In my opinion, David Cook and Kelly Clarkson have been the most talented winners so far. They both have voices that no one could ever imitate. But personally, I prefer David. He's the definition of perfect :)

  • I agree.

  • Y'all the song is The Time Of My Life and the artist is David Cook (the seventh American Idol Winner).

  • cool

    and can i ask who is the singer of this song ?

    thanks

  • it's DAVID COOK!!!

  • what is the name of this song!!!

  • TIME OF MY LIFE by DAVID COOK

  • fantasia is the best and simon has said so many times that she was

  • let me just say one thing fantasia barrino has done a lot in her career she has had the best selling singe of anying other winning idol her first album sold 2million album she has had a best selling book she has made history with lifetime with her story about life by rate at number2 and she done broadway and got rave reviews and there more to come thanks

  • Ruben, Fantasia, and Taylor didn't make shit out of there career's.

  • Fantasia did.

  • Really? haven't heard of her in 5 years

  • are you serious??? Fantasia has had twoo solid albums, made billboard history, 8 time grammy nominee, billboard and image award winner. Newyork times best selling book, amazing stint on the color purple, with no bad reviews. And currently about to release her third studio album as well as a gospel album. BOTH CDS WEre nomintated for grammys the first one was nominated for 4 grammys the latest cd was nominated for 3. 09 is Fantasia year you will c..

  • oh thats funny .. because i dont know ANYONE who's a fan of her ... or even heard of her! she hasn't had a hit in well... ever. if you keep up with her okay, but really she hasn't done much

  • then you must be living in a well.

  • i hate 4th place curses!

    1 - tamyra, 4 - chris daughtry, 6 - lakisha.

  • david, carrie, jordin, then kelly. fantasia, rueben, and taylor suck!

  • kelly has the best vocal voice than anyone in america. she so totally blows out anyone. the rest winners are good, but no-one can compare to kelly.

    thnx for the vid

  • true but i think david cook's really good too. he's a tight second.

  • yes they can

  • yh kelly is the most successful winner ever.

  • I don't care what anyone says, Fantasia is the best Idol Winner definitively, no questions asked. From her jazzy vocal stylings to her unmatched stage presence, she is the true star. I don't care how much success or media attention the others garner, Fantasia is the most outstanding vocalist and is the true legend in the making....

  • Nononononononononono Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood tie for first, David Cook second... the rest don't matter.

  • I agree

  • fantasia is the best

  • lol is taylor hicks really a forgotten idol?

  • possibly! lol. nobody has seen or heard of him sense he was on american idol! hes been in magazines, but what else?? l

  • i made a mistake i meant Taylor Hicks damn it -.-""

  • I love American Idol because almost ALWAYS the right person wins. Not too many shows are good about getting it right and American Idol does!!

  • if that was the case Fantasia,Ruben,and Taylor would have not won.

  • I said ALMOST. Plus I still think the right person won between Ruben and Clay. As for Fantasia and Taylor... not so much. Chris should have won instead of Taylor. Fantasia? Who was up against her? I think that was the season that was pretty boring. At the time I would have said Diana, but time has shown that Jennifer Hudson should have won it all.

  • I hold Jennifer in high esteem but when she's matched against Fantasia, Fantasia is most likely to come out on top. Just compare their performances @ the Patti LaBelle Tribute. Yes, Dreamgirls catapulted Jennifer into superstardom and made her an overnight success, but Fantasia has real presence in the music industry dishing out unmatched, heart-wrenching, soul -searing greatness in each performance and will continue to shock rookies and legends alike with her outstanding voice...

  • I'll just take your word for it because i'm not the kind of person to talk about someone I know nothing about. I don't follow Fantasia's career; therefore I know nothing about what she's accomplished. I remember she had a good voice on Idol and that's about it. I just said Jennifer because she's the only idol from that season that I have seen or heard of since the show ended.

  • k. Sorry I must have missed the part where you said "almost" I think LaToya London should have won season 3. Diana DiGarmo was the runner up for season that season. I agree Chris should have won season 4.

  • Oh I completely forgot about LaToya. I loved her. She was the 4th place curse wasn't she? Did she ever release a CD or anything?

  • Yup she was that really stunk. Um, I looked up her info. on Wikipedia (I dont know how reliable that site is) and it says she released some singles, sang on other peoples cds and is in "The Color Purple" in Chicago.

  • I think the right person won between Ruben and Clay too.

  • cool video how did u make it?

  • I went to one true media to make it. Got pictures from Google and I had downloaded Time Of My Life. It's really easy.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more