Melody Thornton - Space live in Glasgow

[iStan4JoAndTK]

She sounds nervous here

[albinkaxxx]

you may hate me for what i'm saying, but i think melody can not sing good. she's great at this parts with 'oooh' and 'yeaah' where she's rather screaming than singing. but when she sings her voice is shaking and falters. for me ashley sings more clear.

[prixoxo1]

Melody <3

[12345678910sham22]

she had a shit mic nicolee gave all the others silver while she had gold the silvers onece sounded shit compared to nicoles gold outstandin mic

[parasanders1]

i'm sorry but melody can sing live, idk wat hapnd this time... maybe a problem with getting adjusted with the right tone

[jhordyn09]

This had to be some sort of sabotage. Wtf does she have on, and she sounds like a 13 year old at the school talent show.

[DivaBahiana]

Nicole is a media product to open doors to the latino world, because they thing latino's like Brazil racist country wanna see some one like Nicole's feature even though she cannot do like Melody can. Well my best wisshes to Mel, good luck girl, breat it . :)

[DivaBahiana]

really hope she can survive in the records industry,on her own, being black in this industry, she will have to have a strong back bone and good people that really bring her up to Beyonce's and Rhinna's spotlight exposure type other wise she will be like Chiara, trying to make it thru. She is gourgeous ahd with personality but the question is can she break thru the Musical Records Discrimination? Because like Chiara she has what it takes.

[antilicous]

she's a gr8 singer but the wat happened here she sounded rly bad

[aaliyahify]

NICOLE ACTS DRUNK I

[Jameson103186]

um real talk Melody and Carmit sound better than Nicole. If they really wanted to (and if Robin wasn't a dumb bimbo bitch) They could have done really well without Nicole. Have Melody lead with Carmit and Kimberly as 2nd lead and Jessica and Ashley do backgrounds and hooks. They really would have blown up. When Nicole left for her first solo they should have kept her ass out.

[queta89]

she's one of the best singers! I really wish she could comeout solo and survive

[dancebutterfly12]

She's the only one who sang the solo without the recorded songs playing over it.

[KikkaLovesAsh]

in the closet where my clothes should be,in that empty bed without me (8) u_u

[TROYNDEX]

right now, i do not love Nicole. She's making PCD break-up! Jess already left, Kim is thinking of leaving

[afrostar8]

this is not her best... im a lil disappointed but i still got love for her

[2009MINORITY]

4:12 Melody looks shocked by the way they cut her off like that... Team Melody!!! She the best singer in PCD

[MrsAdrianna69]

i Love Melody xd <3

[JaecustomMADE]

lmao i Love Nicole =]

[DanielFuscoMusic]

She should be the new leader of PCD, But, not sing EVERYTHING, and let all girls sing. Melody to me fits that position now, maybe not so much in the past, but lately she's been proving herself to all of us that she is the best PCD in singing.

[JaecustomMADE]

shes great . but nicoles doing a great job!

[SeiraStar39]

What the heck does Nicole think she is doing? She is hogging all the attention.  Someone needs to slap her.

[shishkababy24]

mel is awsome!!! i love the sound of her voice, it sounds so young

[googoop]

Melody is my favourite Doll, she has a great voice and is such a cutie!

[tutti0fruitti]

nicole needs to stop! i would lykk to see the girls get equal treatment!

[psych006]

although melody is my fave but the group was a dance group and once the creator of PCD brought in melody and nichole PCD became not jus a dance group but a singing sensation as well.

[rihannarocks6]

she is defintly NOT lip syncing

[noelbouthermula101]

its ashame because melody sings alot to but you would never known because the cameras are always on nicole

[maraki144]

yeah pcd is a group so i cant understand why nicole is the only one that sings, while the other girls just dance....

[ceceboo93]

i really dislike nicole singing and talking all the time

[irenePOWW]

nicole is the LEAST talented of em all!

[art1ej]

no shes not kim & jessica are worse & cant hit the notes nicole & melody can so get ya facts straight.

[CFNumeroUno]

LMFAO, right, that's why she has the highest vocal range in the group, the most powerful voice, and is hands down the best dancer. you obviously have a retarded child's perception of "talent" lmao.

[ldrockstar69]

nicole is overexposed.

[katsrayoflight]

I love Mel , and PCD, But Girl ummm must have been having a bad day?!?!?

[Piluka444]

melodie the best

[TROYNDEX]

I don't think Melody needs any improvement. She and Ashley are the 2 best singers in the whole entire group! This song and Ashley's song are my 2 fav songs out of the solos. Nicole is loosing her touch. I think Nicole needs more training. She can't hog all of the fame. I know Melody was probably demanding a solo. She got solos, and she's really good. I think Nicole is hurting the group.

[135pantera]

NO, she is not hurting the grou! If she is why do yu think they got the number one girl group title?? BEcause they're puzzle. Each one of them have roles to fill in and if nicole is hurting the group like that they wuldnt be where they are today!!

[aluia91]

go baby doll, you run the show! Nicole need to go solo? Lol ... you want to hear another F.L.O.P ??? That album was never release anyway! Stuff you shit head

[CelebrityProfit]

wats up with nicole? im a fan but shes almost taking advantage, dont "poor comment" me but im just saying.

[lilmissashleym]

what a mess at 2:40!

[lilmissashleym]

l love her song but she's awful live

[pgtips123]

I went to watch PCD last night, and heard her sing live and she sounded awesome singin live! :)

[lolfunnylol]

melody can sing but shes just a little picthy and needs to control it better cause her notess are a tad bit all over the place but i love her :) you can tell she sounds different live and on the album though

[GigiHarville]

that was a mess

[DerekOdgers]

Wow, melody has an awful voice.. Wtf..

[tati0439]

r u stupid look at her other videos look at caged bird u dummy

[cutiepiebabii3]

melody CAN sing!!

idk why nicole is the only one who sings in the group...to be honest nicole is NOT all that

[97348207]

Melody is a good singer!! but Nicole sings better than melody.. BUT PCD ROCK!!!!

[krayZkid1794]

i think that this isnt relle her range. like shes a soprano. so thats probably why she was struggling to hit the relle low notes. but it still sounded gud. and i still love her!! yay!! go melody!!

[orjustdesire]

i honestly dont understand why people think melody sounds good. this is her natural, live voice. on the cd its so processed and edited. yeah, that can make anyone sound good. she sounds like a fucking snorlax

[hashbrownsNketchup]

has anyone hear actually hear nicole sing? she has no control in her voice at all.

[orjustdesire]

example?

[hashbrownsNketchup]

examples being every single time she sings. her voice wavers, she can barely hold a note half the time.

[JAYRYANTV]

nicole can actually sing go to i'll be your love on youtube nicole sang perfectly. she can really sing she needs to go solo

[CFNumeroUno]

she has waaaay more range and power than messlody. that's not an opinion...it's a fact. are you mad??? Nicole's highest in full voice live = Bb5. Messlody's highest in full voice live = F5, and it's thin as hell. In falsetto/whistle register, Nicole's highest is G#6. Messlody's is the forced Eb6 that she squeaked out at 3:36 in this video. Nicole wins. :)

[AtomicFall]

Agreed! I don't understand the blind faith people put in Melody's voice...They hear her belt out a few high notes in PCD's singles, or in this song, and they instantly think she can carry lead o.o She has a cute background voice but she doesn't have the vocal talents or presence Nicole does..That and I hardly hear her actually "singing" in this performance at all :[..

[coolmixedgal]

O.k first off she does acually have some song that she sings u idoit! Nd secondly u wouldn't b a idoit if you would acually look her up and hear some of the songs she sings. Its not blind faith, people who acually listen and THINK before they type idoitic stuff like melody than people like you, who dnt know ANYTHING bcuz they won't look up the stuff turn into idiot like you.

[AtomicFall]

Sorry, I stand by my comment. I've looked up enough videos of her singing to form my opinion. She does not have the vocal range that Nicole does. With some training, possibly. She's a good soprano but all she can do is those melismas...And that's it. Really. I've heard her sing "Hurt" by Christina and honestly...Just sounds like she's yelling most of the time. Like I said...With proper training and time, she'd probably improve.

[differentme87]

wow that was not good. I like melody but she did not sound good. and nicole was kind of in to herself... do you love me?..

[hahawhawha1]

luis are you back there lol

[xlilcutie93x]

ANOTHER prime example of why nicole is lead.. Melody has a powerful range, but its untrained and can only sing in the upperrange of chest. Nicole's voice is versatile, and has control in all areas....

[wickedband]

hey buddy..shut up

[xlilcutie93x]

hey fuck face, i dont want to shut up.

[hausofb]

her singing sounds dry.

[hvnlyvoice08]

wow...that's really sad, I think they all do meth or something, I'm not trying to hate it's just they come across so differently in their videos...synth kicks butt

[FrontPageStatuz]

lol omg that is so funny...can you elaborate though?

[hvnlyvoice08]

on the meth or how they come across differently in their videos. Well It's like this ever artist has a character they play but it's understood that it's fake right? atleast by the artist. these girls actually believe in their characters like they are really these sex pods who everyone loves, like they really are divas, I was hoping they would be a little bit humble because to be honest they have no reason to be haughty. They are products, shipped and packaged for sale to the public. that's it.

[FrontPageStatuz]

LMAO!!!!! You are so fucking hilarious....I totally get what you're saying but the meth thing was too funny...lol..but it's your opinion and last I checked Youtube allows it..unfortunately some of these people can never get the picture

[alecitalindis]

WTF....what's up with nicole saying...do u love me?? do u love me'? oh, you love me more??? will u take me on a date???

gosh!! she's so full of herself!!!

[wideangels]

the track of melody is shit ! she has a great voice but she is just not in at the begining !

[06004]

how desperate is nicole here? "do you love me?" AdzPower, i think she is drunk

[zombiprincess]

hahahahah she sound REALLY drunk :D

[06004]

she sucks!!! she should stick with being a backgroundsinger

[Spaghettioss]

I know Melody can sing but she sounds horrible here...

[melody11021992]

She sang over backup track cos they didn't made an instrumental song for it! If you would hear others (Ashley, Kimberly and Jessica), they've also singed with backup track... Only Nicole didn't...

[DanielFuscoMusic]

@melody11021992 no, melody's song only had the chorus playback, just like when Nicole sings. the other 3 girls had the actual song playing. Ashley to me was the best of Ash, Jess, and Kim.

[melody11021992]

@DanielFuscoMusic yeah, but she only sang 1st verse without her original song coz she sang it without any music... in the 2nd verse you can again hear original song... so they only let nicole to sing on instrumental song. but I don't get why nicole didn't sing HER solo song (although they're all her) until u love you instead hush hush...

[DanielFuscoMusic]

@melody11021992 She had certain parts playing back. not EVERYTHING even when PCD performs songs Melody sings her parts with no playback. only backround. and that wasnt the second verse that was the bridge. and in the bridge she used the regular part of that song so she could ab-libs over it. and then it cut out so she could be featured alone. so... exactly. and I dont like nicole because she used those songs like Jai-ho and Hush Hush under Nicole Scherzinger feat. PCD. which is why the broke up

[melody11021992]

@DanielFuscoMusic I didn't mean that she sings at ALL songs with original parts, only on this song. and I don't know what were her plans with that bridge, but obviously, she wanted to do her own thing and not only sing it the way it is already done, so that's maybe why she did that part differently.

oh, and I must agree with you on what you wrote about nicole. :)

[DanielFuscoMusic]

@melody11021992 :)

[melodyashley4ever]

i loveeee hear mel sing! she is so perfect!

[CrystalCorinne]

lol.. i just realized i spelled "role" wrong... my bad:-)

[AdzPower]

is nicole drunk?!

[Zakilicious1]

Melody Killed it from 3:35 until 3:40 but the rest wasn't that good,, normaly she sings better then that...

[nelsonqwx]

someone said ima fuck u up

[ShunKiro]

She sings soo good ! Amazing !

[DenisaWorld]

I LOVE THIS SONG....I LOVE MELODY=)

[Toyah18]

Wooow Melody She A Good Singer!

[kiddalove18]

it was the quailty on the video!!!!

[pinkpooksta]

What happened Mel?! Your normally so good... You must have been nervous. As for Nicole, what the hell is up with the 'do you love me? wanna go out on a date with me? do you think my bf Lewis would mind?' Can she be anymore up herself?! I wish the record company would stop allowing her to hog the limelight cos the other girls are all equally talented.

[guyman33]

Talents broken down

Melodie- Singer, sorry she messes up dances a lot.. love her though

Jessica- Idk? Don't interest me. Seems as though she wanted to replace Carmit...

Ashley- Singing AND Dancing, excellent at both

Kimberly-Dancing then singing, but I'm not saying she's bad at singing it just takes a 2nd to dancing

And the Nicole who's job it is to hog all the spot light while singing for the most part horribly live (and she doesn't even dance!!!) We should phase her out an make equals of all!

[CrystalCorinne]

melody can sing... but this wasnt here best performance... melody can sing...she was off pitch... you can tell that she doesnt have a lot of vocal training... she's not belting properly nor is she on the right notes... even tho ppl dnt like that nicole sings everything.. nicole still has a beautiful voice & has training... melody still has all the potential in the world tho:-)

[courtneypmbowie]

why in the hell would the record company train Melody if Nicole is the obvious money maker and the only one who is allowed to really sing? LOL they should train them ALL (especially Melody, great potential) though. It would make them a better group (if you could call them that)

[CrystalCorinne]

exactly melody has great potential... thats why i said she should receive training... ashley has a soft sweet voice & is trained although her voice is not as strong as melody's... & in terms of them being a group... yes the have a lead singer but the dancing still plays a huge roll in their success & thats where ashley, kim, & jess come in:-)

[larryofiah]

saying things that make people fail in buisness

if melody had been trained earlier she would threantend her position so shell constantly on form and trying and now nicole is in a serious relations ship and getting old so shell want to go solo melody is still young so she could heve taken her place but now pcd is going to end and melody could have been a ledgend and so could nicole but knoe after 2 albums they r over and nicoles fans are angry fo leaving and there is a lot of contravesy think

[Caotic3]

Melody...u can singg so what happend here..were u trying too hard or something..come on noww

[keithtv17]

melody wes not in good condition while singing in this tour cous they are shooting the music vid of bottle pop

[kayylahhmariie]

i love Melody boo ! maybe she juts kinda got nervous idk ..lol

[keithtv17]

she was sick when she is singing it !!!!

[MsClarkDiamond29]

Usually melody sounds good, but i dunno what happened in this performance......that high note was the WORST!

[keithtv17]

melody has cold thats why she can sing well

[CarolWipple]

i think she is the only girl who couldn't go solo. i mean she's a great singer, but i think she is better with the group. i mean she almost killed me at 3:36-:39

[keithtv17]

she now in good condition will in there tour cous she was busy making the music vid of bottle pop

[atleastbesubtle]

nicoles a right hog lmao

[dawnymsz]

nicole disgusts me.

[thiagotoledoaf]

she sounds sick.

[Lily19Chic]

She has a greet voice

I think she should sing more

[melodypussycatdoll]

I love her voice...

[xodamndanielle]

woahh idk whatt was going on during this performance, but melody sounded like she was working extremelyy hard which she usually doesn't. she seemed to be straining for her low notes which was like woahh to me because she usually is so effortlessly on point. LOVE her her voice is killer, so i was shocked on this one.

[houarie75]

Good voice very good but maybe she have so sing she's forget the thecnic...

[popsysaz]

this girl is amazing

[Lovekellycl]

Melody is the best, Nicole is a good singer too

[GirliciousLikeMe]

sorry to say but nicole is better live then melody.

but its still ok.

[nylerobin]

I disagree, I think Melody is better

[Myke209]

Nicole is better ive but Melody has the better voice.

[nylerobin]

Personally, I think it sometimes sounds like Nicole's a little winded when she performs live. Not taking anything away from her cuz she is a talented vocalist, but she just sounds out of breath at times as the show wears on.

[XanthanPanter]

haha... She probably sounds this way because she sings to much lol... Should share more parts...

[TheBluntOne]

You're stupid

[GirliciousLikeMe]

we all have our own opinion, i have mine, u have urs, that doesn't make me stupid.

[15DarkAngel18]

you think she is stupid? she only said that she prefers nicole, she said mel is good. its not like she comments on vids saying I HATE MEL! like people comment about nicole.. so seriously GET OVER IT!! she is not stupid, and you are the stupid one for making a big deal of her own opinion, which wasn't bad at all.. so everyone STOP HATING HER OR NICOLE!!!

[TheBluntOne]

I didn't make a big deal about anything. You wrote a paragraph about MY opinion, dumbass.

[mosperez]

I'm very very sorry if anyone gets ofended, but I really think she sucks! :S

[rheinrhein23]

is that a WHISTLE REGISTER?

[peeples38]

yes that note got to the whistle register so tell me why she isnt allowed to that on pussycat dolls songs???

[princeroderick]

Because the record company doesn't want her to sound better than Nicole, even though everyone knows she already is!!!! Go MELODY!!! Her parents picked the right name for even!!

[peeples38]

i know i got to meet her at a show she is so goofy i was cheesin the whole time lol

[nylerobin]

You are so lucky you got to meet Melody