This is a very complicated song. The melody is beautiful, and some of the words are romantic words anyone would long to hear: "You're a flower, a river, a rainbow." However, as the song progresses, Newman engages in verbal irony. "I never listen to a word you say, and whenever you have a problem, I just turn away." The song can be looked at in many ways: self-delusion, the realistically flawed love of a man for a woman, or not really love at all. Beautiful song with a biting edge.
Planes, Train and Automobiles kicks me in the teeth every time i watch it. Imagine the ending with Del sitting in the station bottle in hand singing this.
I know a girl named Marie. She was my first love, I was 8 and she was 6 years old. I lost her and met her again when I was about 15. I immediately fell in love with her again. Then I had to switch school and again, lost her. Through a friend I somehow met her again when I was 23, and again, I fell in love with her. Somehow she never really loved me as much as I loved her... so I lost her again two years ago. Now I'm almost 27, and I still think about her... maybe I meet her again one day?...
@ariel0785 That's the part that breaks my heart as well. It's so true it makes me feel like I let everyone I love down but he makes doing it sound beautiful, it tears me apart.
Perfection. He knows he doesn't deserve her, and he has to get drunk to tell her he loves her. But it comes from the heart. He inhabits the minds of these characters so perfectly. And the music is so lushly romantic. It's always been one of my favorite love songs.
To me the underlying subtext of this song is that the 'love' in question is so inadequate that one can assume it's love but only as the protagonist understands it. Most of the song catalogues that the actions of the narrator don't really denote love at all. But hey, it's the best he knows to do. It is moving and sadly beautiful.
Randy Newman is a modern master of ballad writing. Old school type of song writing, along with Woody and all the American geniuses have gone away. Computers, goofy animation and political arguments now occupy the youth. It's over, that's all folks.......
My sister, a pianist and writer in her own rite, rewrote this song for mine and my wife's wedding song in 1981 and the sentiment and my love for my wife is still strong today. A few years ago, I took my daughter to see Randy in Miami. He played this song and my daughter looked at me and asked if I was crying. I told her why.
Do you really want to be singing to your daughter about how you can't express sincerity or affection unless you're drunk? It's supposed to be a pathetic plea for sympathy and love from a man who doesn't deserve it.
In addition to the musical beauty of "Marie", the song also reflects Randy Newman's genius at assuming a character and disorienting the listener with an ironic change of perspective. In this case, a drunk, fallible, and probably unsympathetic man sings what one might suppose are the truest, most feeling and appreciative words of his life. Amazing.
@PopHorizonScanner I couldn't put it better. Amazing ability to write stories from perspective. This wreck of a human being conjures up some true beauty for the woman he loves and hurts...
@PopHorizonScanner That's a beautiful interpretation..... but I guess, this ironic change of character perspective isn't as ironic as it is.... It's dramatical, it's probably more real than you'll guess....
I almost believe that it's almost true.... He is like that, maybe not always, maybe not from the outside, but maybe much more from the inside, this song is himself, and his love for Marie.
@PopHorizonScanner And you know how I guess I know that?? Because I wasn't disorientated at all by listening it, but full of understanding and emotions.....
@PopHorizonScanner My lord, what an astounding critique......I CONCUR, MONSIEUR. Actually, I'd thought for years that this was some gay-90's fin de siecle sheet music tune that had faded from the popular favor. Then tonight I search it, and discover that Mr. Newman here composed the thing. Just amazing, I must say.
I loved it the first time I heard it. I always will love it. I guess I'll just consider it to be timeless in how a man's heart works.
@PopHorizonScanner The song is in the perspective of 'Johnny Cutler', the same character singing 'Rednecks' and 'Birmingham' (hence 'my wife's named Mary but she's called Marie etc), and shows him drunkenly telling his wife how he feels. Newman never actually liked the song as he thought it was too nakedly romantic.
It's all in the book - Randy Newman's American Dreams, which I suggest any Newman fan should get.
@PopHorizonScanner Humanizing a complex, deeply flawed character is difficult for even a skilled novelist or screenwriter, but Randy can do it in a 3 minute song. It may be a different skill than the impressionistic poetry of Dylan or the the vulnerable sincerity of Lennon, but it's why Newman is one of the best lyricists ever.
you might've noticed in the song "birmingham" which was right after or before "marie" on the "good old boys " album, there's the line 'my wife's named mary but she's called marie" so it's a continuation of the character from that song...
In general if you look at the album Good old boys, you'll see how Newman develops the character named Johnny Cutler as a representation of the individual an his struggle to reach the american dream. in Alabama 1927, Birmingham specifically the centre of the segregation.
He wrote this for his x-wife while he was married to his 2nd wife telling her how much he missed her. I saw him live and when he told the audience that you could tell it was hard for him but he still thought it was pretty funny.
Such a brilliant piece of music, and brilliant lyric, one of the best ballads ever written that is indeed about a man confessing his flaws and weaknesses while still expressing the deep love that was so hard for him to show. Profoundly human and reflective of an experience we all have had either firsthand or indirectly.
For the born-christians, then rebelling hard against it, then looking for yourself, now bit by bit ...seeing things in a slightly different way...this might aswell be the restart of an original full-backed delight.
The song is brilliant. You can never put your finger on Randy Newman's lyrics. Sure he really does love her, but his love is a curse. Among his weaknesses he admits to one that is sadly unforgivable.
dondev54, it is not ironic, he really mourned over this woman and would not be such a jerk to be sarcastic in that context. "honest" is the better term. It is not about beating your wife in delirium and apologizing next day, it is a real love song! He was man of the world enough not to make a great drama of a little stonedness!
busisanclaire, it may not be ironic to the character who is singing this song on the album Good Old Boys dedicated to the South, but I think it might be to Mr Newman, who I don't think ever beat his wife.
Dudes, remember this is supposed to be IRONIC! He's a useless husband to Marie; drunk, lazy and violent, but the booze brings out the remorse and romance in him.
If this song doesn't break your heart, I wonder if you have one.
MoonOfNeptune 2 weeks ago
This man is a genius. He makes this look very deceptively easy. Just try to deliver a song with such honesty, and you'll find it's not easy at all
lutherlabs 2 weeks ago
This is a very complicated song. The melody is beautiful, and some of the words are romantic words anyone would long to hear: "You're a flower, a river, a rainbow." However, as the song progresses, Newman engages in verbal irony. "I never listen to a word you say, and whenever you have a problem, I just turn away." The song can be looked at in many ways: self-delusion, the realistically flawed love of a man for a woman, or not really love at all. Beautiful song with a biting edge.
Jan96106 3 weeks ago
I named my daughter Angela Marie ... i was so imperfect and she was and is so perfect. This song reflects my regret and my deep love for her.
westport999 1 month ago
This song always makes me cry .. Marie was my mom's name ...
spatinco 2 months ago
Damn, so great.
niggercamel 2 months ago
Heartbreakingly beautiful
1doctoma 2 months ago
Planes, Train and Automobiles kicks me in the teeth every time i watch it. Imagine the ending with Del sitting in the station bottle in hand singing this.
BrianRowan42 3 months ago
My name is Marie. :)
FunUsernamesAreGone 3 months ago
whoever disliked this is very sad
Summergirls1000 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I know a girl named Marie. She was my first love, I was 8 and she was 6 years old. I lost her and met her again when I was about 15. I immediately fell in love with her again. Then I had to switch school and again, lost her. Through a friend I somehow met her again when I was 23, and again, I fell in love with her. Somehow she never really loved me as much as I loved her... so I lost her again two years ago. Now I'm almost 27, and I still think about her... maybe I meet her again one day?...
Gambit1984 4 months ago
Comment removed
Gambit1984 4 months ago
Long before his incredible movie soundtracks....what a catalogue of songs. One of the best songwriters of all time.....................
chrissieravi 4 months ago
I have absolutely no idea how someone writes a song like that.
MoonOfNeptune 5 months ago 2
Classic example of an abusive man. Such raw lyrics.
fionesidhe 6 months ago
A drunk mans words are a sober mans thoughts xoxo
scarlett52x 6 months ago
im 14 and i love this song , probably bcz my name is Marie , haha but its really nice
MrsVidals 7 months ago
Nujabes ftw. check him out.
griqs 8 months ago
@cclark775 It's this part that breaks my heart:
Sometimes I'm crazy
But I guess you know
And I'm weak and I'm lazy
And I've hurt you so
And I don't listen to a word you say
When you're in trouble I just turn away
ariel0785 8 months ago
@ariel0785 That's the part that breaks my heart as well. It's so true it makes me feel like I let everyone I love down but he makes doing it sound beautiful, it tears me apart.
showbizben 6 months ago
Comment removed
TheBigDelicious 8 months ago
The lyrics just breaks my heart...
ariel0785 8 months ago
this genius is on the same level as mozart or schubert
schbrachbolidsei 9 months ago
best lovesong ever written....
rjvos59 9 months ago 4
beautiful song!!!
NextSuperStar89 9 months ago
reflection eternal
joemac92 10 months ago
Enkel gepatenteerde dwazen amuseren zich zot als de satan en als pubers om volwassenen razend te maken .
Enkel dwazen die niemand ter wereld wil horen zien of aanzien, omdat iedereen
met het verstand op de juiste plaats vecht om er te geraken
Te moeilijk o mdomaars te bevattzen? dat hi jdod ga .
Nobody needs shitcake kakkers!In Holland ja daar eten ze shitcake! om het licht te zien...awel ja! Verlies u daar dan.
kjallesoft 10 months ago
This guy is a musical poet!! That's all that really has to be said..
jtpvg 10 months ago
Heartbraking. Randy Newman is astounding. Perfection.
lucychinn149 11 months ago
Perfection. He knows he doesn't deserve her, and he has to get drunk to tell her he loves her. But it comes from the heart. He inhabits the minds of these characters so perfectly. And the music is so lushly romantic. It's always been one of my favorite love songs.
PatriciaK55 11 months ago
To me the underlying subtext of this song is that the 'love' in question is so inadequate that one can assume it's love but only as the protagonist understands it. Most of the song catalogues that the actions of the narrator don't really denote love at all. But hey, it's the best he knows to do. It is moving and sadly beautiful.
AcousticUplift 11 months ago
@AcousticUplift Agreed, 100%
hrothgleas 11 months ago
@PatriciaK55 Perfection, exactly.
hrothgleas 11 months ago
Thanks for uploading this. I've loved "Marie" for ages but have never seen a video.
Arlenoclast 1 year ago
This is one of the best.
And I like his bell bottom jeans.
Hawkshaw33 1 year ago 2
Randy Newman is a modern master of ballad writing. Old school type of song writing, along with Woody and all the American geniuses have gone away. Computers, goofy animation and political arguments now occupy the youth. It's over, that's all folks.......
byteontheez 1 year ago
I loved this song the first time I heard it when I was 21, and I always will love this song, Marie. :)
Treebard 1 year ago 2
that's not love.
lonelygnome1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
are you people knocking him under 30 I doing a poll of classic rock haters who think 2010 rock and weezer is the best
buttawitz 1 year ago
Comment removed
buttawitz 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
RANDY NEWMAN SUCKS ASS!
The420GREASER 1 year ago
My sister, a pianist and writer in her own rite, rewrote this song for mine and my wife's wedding song in 1981 and the sentiment and my love for my wife is still strong today. A few years ago, I took my daughter to see Randy in Miami. He played this song and my daughter looked at me and asked if I was crying. I told her why.
joeblogsism 1 year ago 11
Comment removed
mikefinn50 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i don't care what lyrics he writes.
He will always sound like Toy Story to me.
Goldyman1212 1 year ago
i always will love you Benee'
paschal421 1 year ago
beautiful love song. thanks Randy.
suzeiki 1 year ago
randy looks like he has to sneze
fro164 1 year ago 4
This song is like a nice cool autumn evening. Just content.
UMSMASTA 1 year ago
The most beautiful love song ever recorded. So simple, so honest. Pure beauty.
mightyluv 1 year ago 2
SIMPLY GENIOUS QUITE POSSIBLY THE MOST GENUINELY TRUE LOVE SONG OF ALL TIME........................
jbernard214 1 year ago
kenny rankins rendition is a classic RIP KR
baldgood 1 year ago
I just saw the movie "paulie" I really like this song.
lynnae29 1 year ago 3
The shift after his first 'Marie' is like some sort of heartbreaking gas permeating my very being.
Dentakulator 1 year ago
this song makes me bawl
crackfarm76 1 year ago
My mum was called Marie, she was the most beautiful woman inside and out! I lost her when i was 17 years old, im 22 now. I miss her xoxoxo
princessjodii 1 year ago 2
Touching...
muziekengeluid 1 year ago
So moving.Always brings me to tears.
gordonw01 1 year ago
Every time I hear this song, I come close to crying. Newman is sheer genius.
CraigasaurusLex 1 year ago
Comment removed
imchiquitabanana 1 year ago
I love this song.. I loved u that first time I saw you.. Would be very cute if u have a daughter named Marie :)
imchiquitabanana 1 year ago
Do you really want to be singing to your daughter about how you can't express sincerity or affection unless you're drunk? It's supposed to be a pathetic plea for sympathy and love from a man who doesn't deserve it.
GotNextVideo 1 year ago 2
@GotNextVideo Well done, gotnext, I think you hit the nail on the head.
benjaminlhaines 1 year ago
this is so real, lord, so beautiful
MoveOverCasanova 1 year ago
nujabes - reflection eternal
yocam420 1 year ago 20
Song reminds me of an uncle .He was not one to express feelings-but he truly loved his wife.
newrochellephoenix 2 years ago
Comment removed
NathalyVAinshtein 2 years ago
In addition to the musical beauty of "Marie", the song also reflects Randy Newman's genius at assuming a character and disorienting the listener with an ironic change of perspective. In this case, a drunk, fallible, and probably unsympathetic man sings what one might suppose are the truest, most feeling and appreciative words of his life. Amazing.
PopHorizonScanner 2 years ago 74
What a great comment.
marvy1118 2 years ago 3
@PopHorizonScanner Well damn it. I wanted to say that! Well done. Your comment touched me like the song.
fireblossom2u 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@PopHorizonScanner Well damn it. I wanted to say that! Well done. Your comment touched me like the song.
fireblossom2u 1 year ago
@PopHorizonScanner agreed, 100%. This failure of a man can come up with this total expression of love...
hrothgleas 1 year ago
@PopHorizonScanner I couldn't put it better. Amazing ability to write stories from perspective. This wreck of a human being conjures up some true beauty for the woman he loves and hurts...
hrothgleas 1 year ago
@PopHorizonScanner You got that just right. Sheer poetry from the depths of the soul of a degenerate. 'Probably unsympathetic?'
hrothgleas 11 months ago
@PopHorizonScanner That's a beautiful interpretation..... but I guess, this ironic change of character perspective isn't as ironic as it is.... It's dramatical, it's probably more real than you'll guess....
I almost believe that it's almost true.... He is like that, maybe not always, maybe not from the outside, but maybe much more from the inside, this song is himself, and his love for Marie.
Musicsmoke 7 months ago
@PopHorizonScanner And you know how I guess I know that?? Because I wasn't disorientated at all by listening it, but full of understanding and emotions.....
Musicsmoke 7 months ago
@PopHorizonScanner My lord, what an astounding critique......I CONCUR, MONSIEUR. Actually, I'd thought for years that this was some gay-90's fin de siecle sheet music tune that had faded from the popular favor. Then tonight I search it, and discover that Mr. Newman here composed the thing. Just amazing, I must say.
I loved it the first time I heard it. I always will love it. I guess I'll just consider it to be timeless in how a man's heart works.
iamintheburg 5 months ago 2
@PopHorizonScanner The song is in the perspective of 'Johnny Cutler', the same character singing 'Rednecks' and 'Birmingham' (hence 'my wife's named Mary but she's called Marie etc), and shows him drunkenly telling his wife how he feels. Newman never actually liked the song as he thought it was too nakedly romantic.
It's all in the book - Randy Newman's American Dreams, which I suggest any Newman fan should get.
Nobody writes them like Randy.
rockermanmatt 4 months ago 2
@PopHorizonScanner Humanizing a complex, deeply flawed character is difficult for even a skilled novelist or screenwriter, but Randy can do it in a 3 minute song. It may be a different skill than the impressionistic poetry of Dylan or the the vulnerable sincerity of Lennon, but it's why Newman is one of the best lyricists ever.
GotNextVideo 4 months ago 2
you might've noticed in the song "birmingham" which was right after or before "marie" on the "good old boys " album, there's the line 'my wife's named mary but she's called marie" so it's a continuation of the character from that song...
MrJaybuck 2 years ago
In general if you look at the album Good old boys, you'll see how Newman develops the character named Johnny Cutler as a representation of the individual an his struggle to reach the american dream. in Alabama 1927, Birmingham specifically the centre of the segregation.
nata3211 2 years ago
I love this song. It is so tender.
Jennirn2u 2 years ago
I guess marvy isn't hired for the smart comments...
greatidear 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
marvy1118 2 years ago
Comment removed
marvy1118 2 years ago 3
..sometimes i´m crazy, and i guess you know..
MoveOverCasanova 2 years ago
yes, especially when you take the line before this.
but this intellectual level in a lovesong is surely not everybodies cup of tea
. but i like it very much, -
he is one that has to be precise to be real
MoveOverCasanova 2 years ago
In my world, this video would have 60,588,223 views.
marvy1118 2 years ago 6
He wrote this for his x-wife while he was married to his 2nd wife telling her how much he missed her. I saw him live and when he told the audience that you could tell it was hard for him but he still thought it was pretty funny.
FloyedRose335 2 years ago
you´re a flower you´re a river you´re a rainbow --
MoveOverCasanova 2 years ago
Such a brilliant piece of music, and brilliant lyric, one of the best ballads ever written that is indeed about a man confessing his flaws and weaknesses while still expressing the deep love that was so hard for him to show. Profoundly human and reflective of an experience we all have had either firsthand or indirectly.
musoid 2 years ago 9
How could you, Marie?
freezedriedpoop 2 years ago
Beautiful, hopeful, sad... thanks Randy.
jasonsgroovemachine 2 years ago 4
For the born-christians, then rebelling hard against it, then looking for yourself, now bit by bit ...seeing things in a slightly different way...this might aswell be the restart of an original full-backed delight.
Bernard
lekezenman 2 years ago
No wonder the open-minded Dutch people were his best match in Europe!
This Randy Newman is a musical genious, nerdy as he might even look to you today...
Bernard
lekezenman 2 years ago 2
The song is brilliant. You can never put your finger on Randy Newman's lyrics. Sure he really does love her, but his love is a curse. Among his weaknesses he admits to one that is sadly unforgivable.
"when you're in trouble....I turn away.."
cristop5 2 years ago 2
dondev54, it is not ironic, he really mourned over this woman and would not be such a jerk to be sarcastic in that context. "honest" is the better term. It is not about beating your wife in delirium and apologizing next day, it is a real love song! He was man of the world enough not to make a great drama of a little stonedness!
busisanclaire 2 years ago
busisanclaire, it may not be ironic to the character who is singing this song on the album Good Old Boys dedicated to the South, but I think it might be to Mr Newman, who I don't think ever beat his wife.
dondev54 2 years ago
it is dedicated to the south, but it is not a concept album, no "story", and Marie does really exist.
And i also am pretty sure that Newman did not beat a woman, and didn´t imply anything different
MoveOverCasanova 2 years ago
listen to "fretkillr" on youtube for the best version....
sirfleabert 2 years ago
@sirfleabert While he is a talented musician his version is nowhere close to Randy's.
paulosham1 1 year ago
Comment removed
schnuddeldi 2 years ago
Its 30 years ago this year. Man am I getting old. lol
dondev54 2 years ago
I have to listen to the twice when ever I come here:)
Jbear9 2 years ago 2
please check out Kenny Rankin version of Marie. Possibly one of the best performances of any song in my opinion
baldgood 2 years ago
Dudes, remember this is supposed to be IRONIC! He's a useless husband to Marie; drunk, lazy and violent, but the booze brings out the remorse and romance in him.
dondev54 2 years ago
What sells it is the contrast between the melody and the lyrics. BOTH emotions are real. The song is about that place in between good and bad.
tbrenholts 2 years ago
Yeah, that's right. But this captures his remorse. He doesn't deserve her, but he can only admit it to himself when he's loaded.
mikerudjazz 2 years ago
So incredible.
He is brilliant....
thank you, for posting.
rosesredvioletsblue 2 years ago
oh and what a beautiful song. He really is a genius.
RealiD1221 3 years ago 2
Is Marie a real person? Was she a lover of his?
RealiD1221 3 years ago
she's a character from good old boys
bassintheham 2 years ago
Beautiful
zodiacbluesbaby 3 years ago
Such a beautiful song.
waynescooby 3 years ago
I love you Randy Newman...
Marie
Hattonibrothers 3 years ago
Wow, what a song..really beautiful
ladybluluv 3 years ago 2
This is a serious contender for one of the best songs ever written.
frenfroe 3 years ago 40
Agreed. This song destroys me every time I hear it.
joeypropeller 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@frenfroe UR LAME RANDY NEWMAN IS A RETARD LIKE YOU! SORRY U SUCK...
The420GREASER 1 year ago
Simply awesome (and he still is)!!!! Tnx!
RWillemM 3 years ago 5