Selena Gomez & The Scene Perform 'Who Says'

[LadyMinor13]

Selena never said she's a great singer, STOP hating. Go there and sing better, bitches.

[taylorswiftrocks132]

BITCH PLEASE, my cat's a better singer

[LucyLovex2]

She walks around casually on the stage thinking she can sing

[justinbieberjustin4e]

@HaStacie agreed :) she can't sing at all....... Even with harmonyser.......

[HaStacie]

Stick to acting sweetie.

[dikaks]

1:29 / 1:49 what the fuck

[MrsCountryGirl171]

She's Amazing Live Or Not ((: If Y'all Don't Like Her Or All You have To Say Are Negative Thing's Then Why Watch Her Videos I Mean like Seriously She Is Human Just Like The Rest Of Us! She Also Has Feelings Too ! So Why Don't Y'all Hater's Just Fu*k Off & Let The People Who Do love Her Enjoy Her Music ! Okay! Bc I'm Sure Half Of Y'all Can't Even Sing!! So Fall Back! [Haters] & Keep The Negativity Too Yourself's !!

#TeamShe'sAmazing!((:

[missfattylove]

This is how I sound... I'M A POPSENSATION!

[taylorswiftrocks132]

@missfattylove hahahahahha that should be a top comment

[LUIEpatooie]

I love her dress!

[StephanyV25]

I love Selena Gomez

[CManniste]

ohh, Justin Bieber pillow was with her, awww

[Celinaa20]

Do not criticize it because she does not sing if you sing though there certainly was difonica or did not feel well.

[FanRebaMcentire]

JUST HORRIBLE... THIS GIRL CAN'TT SING AT ALLL. U CALL THIS MUSIC???????? I CALL THIS CRAPP. PEOPLE LEAVE THIS CRAP VIDEO AND LISTEN TO KELLY CLARKSON, OR ADELE, OR TAYLOR SWIFT.

[dikaks]

@FanRebaMcentire agreed

[BurntKittenz]

Ugh selena just drives me insane sometimes

She has such a pretty voice but its like, she's scared to attempt hitting the high notes cause she doesnt think she'll sound good or whatever but i bet if she did she'd sound amazing .. she second guessed herself and instead of hitting the high notes, goes into this raspy whisper thing and it really bugs me ..

[RinaLottie1994]

@BurntKittenz OH WOW!!! That is sooo stupid. "She can sing. But she's afraid to." Like yeah thats why she sounds horrible.

[BurntKittenz]

@RinaLottie1994 Lol I know she sounds horrible, Im just saying she has a nice voice, she just doesnt know how to use it.

[jmkool91]

I love that she's barefoot lol

[xSniffyy]

@jmkool91 Most the time she performs this song barefoot =] because thats what she likes to do

[bieberfeverfan323]

I watched this video thousands of times but i just found out that theres a Justin Bieber pillow at 2:07

[bieberfeverfan323]

She was trying her best ok? its not her fault that she was off key alittle bit, its because shes losing her voice and needs more rest

[AnotherMomentTwitter]

I like her studio version songs, but live it's not good.

She breathes into the microphone and her voice is so low already, so it gets even harder to hear her sing.

She needs to practice on her singing.

[LenaHuynh2187]

I love Selena Gomez she is so cool

[iicuteamethyst]

She can't sing live. :\

[kat25300]

she is a beauty queen <3

[maya67919]

ela tem sem sato pq o video clipe dessa musica é assim e vcs tao é com inveja pq ela naomora o justin biber

[TheMygabry97]

What a fuck?

[jello920]

was she not a shoes on her feet?

[lynntran1234]

@jello920 shoes are overrated

[jello920]

@lynntran1234 aham thank you

[MegaXwillx]

@jello920 That doesnt even make sense

[Ms123beauty]

She wasn't good on the high

Notes

[sherniceng]

she needs more oxygen..haha

[mclujanarg]

/watch?v=eLQpxEp7eko&list=FLi2­K3MMMDm503Ath9zIJK_A&index=2&f­eature=plpp_video

Miley singing on Ellen >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Selena singing on Ellen

[EvannaOoi]

Haha! One of the tags in this video is Justin Bieber! Hahaha!

[Kennimadsen1000]

Nice, selena, you are good!

[cristianhere321]

I feel bad for Selena she can't sing live. It's not that she can't sing it's probably her PAST performances in country's. That and she probably has a vocal problem anybody else notice that fact that she's always holding her stomach?! - 0:57.

[emo0ohibo0o]

1:32 WTF :|

[NellaFace]

Nemůže zpívat živě..

[FuzeDestroy]

Was her throat soar.

[MissLana15]

its funny how she's saying "who says you're not beautiful" and then you look down at the comments and you see people calling her ugly. Way to go internet.

[justthewayweare]

oh wow that was horrible but am I surprised a disney star can't really sing..... nope

[AcmMaja]

OMG she's so untelented, ugly and slim!

It's better for her to stop singing because she's terible and aboute acting, she suck too!

FUCK YOU SELENA GOMEZ, YOU SUX! .l.

[cristianhere321]

@AcmMaja Wow that just shows a lot of impact for someone living at home, while she's earning millions of dollars and traveling the world while at the same time she's getting the chance to meet other celebrities, so thanks person who i don't know nor WISH to know. Oh by the way if your afraid to think what other people are gonna think of you then put a picture on your channel.

[rockinchick12341]

I have seen Selena sing live many times, and she sucks -_-". Stop singing and stick to acting honey. It's better.

[TheGomezBucks]

@rockinchick12341 Shes beautiful at singing. Gtfo.

[aradhanaa9]

amazing gomez

[cristianhere321]

@rockinchick12341 @rockinchick12341 She Can sing check out this video. (I can't type it in, (That's dumb) it's probably the nervousness and all the moving around the stage.

Video name: Selena Gomez | Who Says Acoustic (Live, Radio Disney)

[HeyyMonthJunee]

She doesnt sing that awesome when its live.__.

[EmilyCyrus2608]

they say selena can sing and miranda can't sing =.=

[AolaniQ]

She's so talented and beautiful.

[Lizzybown]

I think Selena is fantastic and perfect whatever you guys say!

[Pigmalionist]

she can't sing on live ...

[AolaniQ]

@Pigmalionist I'd like to see you try to sing live.

[kpeng1012]

@roshelmaher everytime she sings who says live its just not that good

[RoshelMaher]

Umm not hating coz I think she absolutely gorgeous and incredibly talented, but I kinda noticed that she cant really hit high notes? She should probably sing in a lower pitch to match her voice :) She'd be even better!

[jochu17]

no me gusta como canta muchoo.. es media detestable pero buee ee lo que ai

[Catabieber24]

canta malll

[jennifer411506]

hannah montana said i wasnt perfect...

[TheJelenafan19]

Another prolf that selena is a great singer

And she's beautiful

[luvmarz28]

haha i also like the pillow!!!

[luvmarz28]

i think she had a soar throat

[carmentrillo425]

Best Part <3 2:30 

[marzihatesbitches]

who ever touchez da dislike button is gonna get beat up 2morro from somone in ur class or nieborhood

[bestdamnalex]

@marzihatesbitches You can't write proper English, better start learning that before judging over people who obviously didn't like this video. Then maybe someone can take you serious.

[laughingpixies]

When can i get to sing the Na na na na, its so hard><

[temptasiianxx]

She can sing.. her voice is just weak. :)

[selinxnur]

as if! ''No one sees beauty queen´´ I HATE SELENA GOMEZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[dan138zig]

@selinxnur i hate you

[JustinBelieber03]

@selinxnur Si no te gusta ¿Por qué su reloj su video ¿Por qué tan mala?

Oh sí, porque no se puede cantar

¿Eres perra Sooo estúpido

[iArtemisX]

her voice is week o.o

[iArtemisX]

@iArtemisX  weak*

[nishimuraluh]

I'm not even Selena Gomez fan, but I do like her as the person she is. She does adorable things to lots of people out there, but seriously, she tries, but she can't sing. She should focus her talent on acting and that's it.

[VYB2011]

@melodiemuggy

thats actually a pillow that ellen gave her

[RubyQiuby]

Que feo jajaja hasta yo canto mas bonito

[carolniga]

omg so bad

[99Demifan]

im not saying it was bad but it was really weak

[Mimixpinzon]

Love*

[Mimixpinzon]

No guys seriously, idk whats wrong with her voice here but it does sound kind of bad. I live her but lets be honest!

[princeibz1]

But I liked this performance :)

[Rainbowunicorn2411]

YOU PEOPLE DON'T KNOW TALENT!!!!!! YOU ARE ALL CCCRRRAAZZYY!!!!! SELENA RRROOOCCCKKKSSS!!!!!!!!!

[Rainbowunicorn2411]

i think i see justin bieber in the back. :)

[TheZinny123]

IF U PPL HATE SELENA GOMEZ, THEN Y THE FUCK R U WATCHING THIS U FANEMIES?!?!?!?!

[TheZinny123]

AAAAAAAAG!!!! THATS IT!IM SICK AND TIRED OF PPL MAKIN FUN OF STARS!!! IF U DONT LIKE SELENA GOMEZ,THEN DONT WATCH HER U IDIOTS!!!

[CYRUS5287]

i love you selena

i'm japanese ...

I am your great fan.

by sae nakayama♥

[Reallyrandomist]

Selena, don't listen to these people who say you can't sing. You love what you do and thats all that matters. <3

[JustinBelieber03]

I Love Selena

But I think she Should stick with Acting More better

Cause the Back Up Singers Sound Better Than her

She Can't Sing Live

I'm not a Hater

I Actually Love Her

But It's Just my Opinion

[iloveselenagomez925]

@JustinBelieber03 Yea well just my opinion is shut yo mouth girl !

[JustinBelieber03]

@iloveselenagomez925 I Said It's Just My Opinion I'm a Fan of Selena Gomez If You can Read,,,,,,,, Why would I shut my Mouth ???? Your Not the Boss of Me Your Not Even Related to me ......... Your soooo Obsess with Selena ,........

[AmberineVEVO]

@JustinBelieber03 you're stupid but it's just my opinion :)

[princess18175]

So sad her backup singers sound better than her. At least she is pretty. Only tone death people say she can sing.

[s2ehello]

i cant hear hear ;( sing LOUDER



[polkadotkkkk]

when i hear her sing i feel like i have a sore throat. no offense.

[CDMxV]

STFU haters,she's amazing! <3

[CristinaGoldis]

GOD!!!SHE NEED PLAYBACK CAUSE' THIS IS SO STUPID

[themaddielovesite]

That's my girl<3 :D

[vasurexiong]

She should just stick to acting! Sorry

[mifr1999]

Sorry, but she just can't sing live :c

[DDadriana01]

I love it, awesome!!!!

[Ariie2910]

i'm a selena fan but this is not her best perfomance

[TheSuperMarija]

i love her <3 # forever and always :) ♥ #SELENATOR !

[kestertube]

I like the Back-up singers better!

GUYS START AT 1:23 and you'll see

[sarahchewvideo]

she's pretty good...

[TheLittleMelanie]

What is that dress ? Oo

[jbrocks200100]

atleast we know its live.

[MelodieMuggy]

Anyone else see the Justin Bieber picture in the background?

[AngellAwesome]

@MelodieMuggy haha thats her pillow ;D

[lsrjg]

@MelodieMuggy that would be him at 1:11

[sebtitanic10]

@MelodieMuggy its the pillow ellen gave her.

[TheMKristensen]

@MelodieMuggy That is the pillow, Ellen gave to Selena. :-)

[DogzRock88]

@MelodieMuggy thats actually the justin beiber pillow ellen gave selena :P

[derox16]

She's got nice vocals but lacks technique. Chest voice is ok, head voice needs a lot od work. She needs A LOT OF TECHNIQUE. I mean a singer without vibrato?

[youknowkannika]

she can actually sings !

[Mohit4O]

@midgetjay1995 thnx

[Mohit4O]

@midgetjay1995 thanx

[midgetjay1995]

i love her and this song it makes me feel good about myself and makes happy when i am sad thanks for writing this song!!!!!!xxxx

[biebetteful]

her vioce was almost gone so shut up !. she is a really good singer!

[Katykool1265]

I am a big selena gomez fan but her voice is not as great when live. She really needs to practice like...ALOt. This live song was very good but most of her live performances are not as good. Love selena <3

[Mohit4O]

Wish I could tell her who said that to me :(

[midgetjay1995]

@Mohit4O me too xx :/

[TheShikaidou]

If you listen to this and the studio version, they are very similar, the only thing is that her singing voice is more quiet and toned down where it's more in power in the studio where there's so many takes of it. But the regular singing is still the same.

[TheDesperatehousewiv]

Ok I love Selena Gomez. I undersand a lot of you don't like her singing but really she has a pretty tone to her vocie. She just needs to work on getting it stronger and I know she will. You rock Selena :)

[SwagTekaa]

All of you are like " She cant sing blablabla ".

But can you sing like her ? I don't think so, guys.

[derox16]

@SwagTekaa Sweetheart, I'm on the Mezzo-Soprano vocal range. I am a full octave above her, and I can easily outsing her with the fact that: as I sing I can do vibratto, she can't. I'm not saying she's a bad singer, but she LACKS technique.

[daraai]

what's wrong with her voice ? she sicks or what ?

[t2thed1113]

awk moment when backround singers are better than the singer

[t2thed1113]

2:04 ha ellens gift in backround!

[MsMackerin]

she has a singing voice , she just doesnt suit her song, she would be better at slow songs <3

[TaTaTew09]

whoooo mexican power! even though she cant sing, she is becoming very successful ! :)

[ludmiilafonseca]

@RondoTheMVP LOL, EVERYBODY SAID !

[ddudinhaabieber]

s22 sortuda por namora o jb

[Katylenel]

she cant really sing...BUT SHE CAN ACT!!! 

[kawthar1997]

STOP HATING GGGGGG !!!! NOBODY IS PERFECT i love her and justin <3 <3

[Snake1n]

WTH is wrong with her dress&shoes&voice it’s horrible sorry! I do like the song but you cannot say that she wasn’t bad at live wow!!! I’m shocked I just don’t know why xD

[xxxemoangelxxximo]

she should back up singer !

[MiriamLoveSong]

Horrible

[beliieveindreams]

2:25 to 2:32 sounds amazing! She's has grown so much as an artist. I love her, she's my queen <3

[osnapitzfaith01]

SELENA IS MY ROLE MODEL-3

[AnishArora0003]

selena is amazing....!!!! <3

[xoxolovejustinxoxo]

LOVE the Justin Bieber pillow! Wish I had It!! haha

[marguilyrics]

check out the bieber pillow :D

[adriana15Rose]

she don't need shoes, she has Justin Bieber :D No, that was a big joke ;D Seriously, ich like her very much, because she's pretty, down-on-earth and she has a heart for everyone!

[allilovesyall]

I love the justin beiber pillow in the background

[susanneisthename]

I think she knew that it didn't sound very well

[susanneisthename]

She has sung better..

[Sweetjessica024]

i Love Demi Lavoto Her voice speaks  with harmony<3

[Mohit4O]

Well done audience! You kept quiet otherwise my ears would have been bursting with screams!

[alyssacjy]

The gorgeous and overly amazing Selena Gomez (: <3

[alyssacjy]

Selena's improving everytime I watch her live videos (: KEEP IT GOING SELENA!! LOVE YOUUUUU!!!!!!! :D <3

[Funshine100]

Her voice is so beautiful it gives me chills.

I can't believe how beautiful and talented one person can be

1. Sings like an angel

2. Acts better then anyone on disney

3. SHE IS CRAZY BEAUTIFUL

[Funshine100]

@MissKamarya i dont get what ur saying, i love her voice

[BringItOn97]

im pretty sure that when all you guys give her hate she just sings this song or thinks about this song

[TheMKristensen]

Selena has a very sweet and good voice, but it isn't strong. She runs out of breath, but otherwise I love her voice. <3

[Ohsupjazel15]

personally, shes a good actress and shes very pretty, but I think singing isn't her thing, not saying that she's bad at singing, but it seems like she can't go alll out when it comes to it.

[littleshan100]

selena's very pretty shes very good at acting and has a good voice but very weak but there's nothing wrong with that she's way better then me lolz i cant sing sooo good luck selena

[kenny5945]

0:23 is this the gay

[vamozero1]

CHEGO NUMA HR QUE ELA FICOU ROCA

[connorlovesgaga]

She looked in pain, like she was putting on a fake smile, especially when she tried to belt out those notes pmsl aw cutie

[HannahundLaraforever]

I like selena and i like this song but sometimes i dont like her voice, sometimes she sounds amazing but sometimes she doesnt!! But she is sucessful so its not of my buissness!! Sorry for my bad englisch!!

[evi36216]

Shes a good actres but sibger no ..... shes ugly, doenst have style .... cant sing, the only things she can do is act ... :) attentiom : i like her but ...

[insanebitchful]

selena's

acting = PERFECT!

singing = AWFUL!

[SofiLovesLadyGaga]

@insanebitchful you are not right :)