Added: 3 years ago
From: AshRockFan
Views: 286,880
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (743)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i am inlove to flyleaf since i first heard them. keep it up!

  • Grey would be the color, if i had a heart <3

  • Wow. God has given you all such skilll. Keep being awesome flyleaf.

  • lacey did go through pain. she started doing drugs at the age of like 10.

  • This version is ALMOST as good as the Nine Inch Nails cover!!:'D

  • YOUR SOMTHING I COULD NEVER HAVE :'(

  • a great video only thing is, is it's You'll make this all go away not just you.

  • i want them . they are my something i can never have !

  • Nine Inch Nails♥…-.-

  • I prefer this version. Love it. <3

  • Flyleaf v.s Fireflight? TEAM FLYLEAF

  • I found this on Itunes but it said I had to buy this whole random album to get this amazing song...I'm so sad now -_-

  • @bridge11233 go to mp3skull.com

  • this sounded liike system of a down at first.. o.o

  • I love you for posting Flyleaf videos. Thank you so freakin' much, I have all the songs available on itunes and that's not enough for me (Flyleaf is my favorite band/artist ever). I wish these songs were on itunes, though. This one's amazing!

  • If I had to pick one band just one band to cover this song, yeah I'd pick Flyleaf.

  • This song was in my head all day

  • LOVE her voice :D

  • I can tell this is an amazing song because after the first time I listened to it, it got stuck in my head for days <3 I love you Flyleaf

  • I love this song. But it makes me feel high, and i dont smoke/do anything. Weird.

  • JUST A FADING REMINDER... OF WHO I USE TO BE... uughh deep :)

  • i miss old flyleaf

  • no one will ever be ever to recreate her voice. its amazing<3

  • I love this song <3

  • i hate how a person can change u and make u so bitter u never want to love again

  • any one else play this and the original at the same time

  • -takes quick glance at the comment section-

    -backs up slowly-

    never again.

  • I like the live one better

  • what iz the point of arguing online over bands i find it stupid and fucked up itz sumbodies opinon in thier mind and u cant change it and u dont know wat music they listen 2 u hav ur music they have thier so shut the fuckin hell up nd quiting arguing about it

  • i think the background music is better on flyleafs cover

  • No, Flyleaf does NOT have the pain that Trent has which is WHY this song is so amazing. Still a good song with her but not anywhere close to NIN.

  • @narutoslideshowmasta My dad can beat up your dad

  • @narutoslideshowmasta I would be careful in your assumption of her pain... She's been through hell and back. Her pain has manifested itself in a pleading, melancholy ache in her voice. Perhaps the reason this song seems less "painful" is her faith in Christ and her knowledge that there is nothing she cannot have through Him.

  • @ChrisMarie93 In comparison of lives I think Trent had the worse of the two. Regardless as I stated in my original comment I still like this cover, and I like the fact she's paying homage to such a brilliant man, but it's just not topping the original for me, doesn't feel as passionate.

  • i love this song soooooo much

  • Fail, Flyleaf's alright, but the lack of the simplicity of the original track takes something away from it. Her voice sounds choppy in this one as well.

  • I love Nine Inch Nails, but this waaaaayy better.. =D

  • My first time hearing this song- my reaction: WOAHH, i love it!! i have their momenti morum album (sorry forgot how to spell it) and i've heard a lot of their old songs, but apparently not all of them! Love this.

  • Reading the comment's on this video. How did The ' Disabled' Olympics have to do with a Flyleaf cover of a nine inch nails song? Js I also find it very stupid to fight and call someone names when you know nothing about them. 

  • I LOVE this song...i LOVE FLYLEAF!!!!!!!!!<3 (:

  • And second @TheToolSound If ur gonna talk shit about my favorite band go ahead just don't do it where I can c it! Flyleaf saved my life, and if u don't care well u can just suck my non- existent dick!

  • omg.. i love NIN and Flyleaf.. 

  • waaaay better than paramore :D

    still love them though

  • @princess561561 My dog snoring is "waaaay better" then Paramore. O_o

  • @IDontShine423 lolz

  • I don't care who's cover is better, this is Flyleaf's version, if you hate it, fuck off. Or, if you hate it but want to keep your lameass opinions to yourself, you're welcome to stay and remain silent. And if you're here for the sole reason of pissing people off, this is Flyleaf's video, so us Flyleaf fans have the upperhand. Just a warning.

  • LOVE flyleaf<333 amazing voice

  • how about all of you people who hate flyleaf get off why did you even listen to it anyway i mean i respect your opions and all its just your ruining it for everyone else who wants to listen to her!

  • wow the 25 people that disliked this are fucking stupid!!!

  • This sucks and not because it's not NIN because she is completely lacking any real passion or emotion. Did she read the words she was singing and understand what any of it meant? Big fail here.

  • @illudingsunshine ok, first of all if u listen to more song from Flyleaf u will notice that they have a lot of emotion in them.

  • NIN way better. simple as that.

  • @TaylorPalmer1 Well, it's true she turned this song into garbage, stupid teen shitheads.

  • @TheToolSound troll.

  • @xXxXtoph No troll, if you actually like this your a fuck head.

  • @TheToolSound why even listen to this song if your going to talk bad about it?!your ruining the song for the people who actually have good taste in music and im proud to love flyleaf i dont care what anyone says im proud and your not so why dont you do everyone a favor and go listen to your other crappy songs for us all!

  • @littleboobookitty16 Cuz Flyleaf sucks donkey dick you stupid slut.

  • @TheToolSound if it wasnt for flyleaf i wouldnt be alive and same story for others i respect your opion but my friend i have one quote for you "fighting on the internet is like playing the specail olympics,win or lose your still retarded"

  • @littleboobookitty16 I agree with you, but that's a really horrible thing to say about the disabled olympics. They're people, too. They're just people trying to show the world that they can still do amazing things... reatarded is a really harsh, offensive word...

  • @FluroUnderwear i didnt mean it to be offenseive i wouldve added no offense but i had no time

  • @littleboobookitty16 Yeah... saying 'no offence' doesn't mean that you can say any horrible shit you want without people being offended. And having no time to type 9 letters is really a pathetic excuse...

  • @FluroUnderwear i ahd to go cuz my dad was in the hospital is that so rong =-=

  • @littleboobookitty16 No, of course not, but like I said, saying "no offence" doesn't mean it won't offend people anyway. Seriously though, just because your dad was in hospital, it doesn't grant you the right to write derogatory things about the disabled.

  • @FluroUnderwear for the last time i didnt mean it to be offense!

  • @littleboobookitty16 *offensive

  • @TheToolSound even if i was a slut (which i am not) i would like my body the way it was =)

  • @littleboobookitty16 What the fuck does you liking your body they way it does have to do with being a slut.

  • There is no contest between this and the original. Trent Reznor is a genre of his own and this song merely does it justice where most covers do not. I don't think I've ever come across a NiN cover that doesn't sound amazing. This, Johnny Cash, and many others who have done NiN songs not only do them justice, but help to create a whole new genre of amazing. <3

  • There were 666 comments... So I commented because it didn't seem right. o_o

  • this song completly discribes my life

  • Usually the originals are better but Flyleaf's covers are always the best.

  • @MuffinMix42 You think this is better than the original? wow.

  • @TheToolSound Well if you don't like it then don't watch it. I respect your oppinion but if you like the original then listen to the original.

  • god her voice is beautiful

  • Love this song!!!!!!!!!!! Actually, this is how I used to feel sometimes back when I was struggling for years with depression and anxiety & stuff. & yeah it does have a different feel than the original (I just listened to it a few minutes ago), but the emotion is still there in the words and music. I really like it ;) :)

  • It's not bad, but her performance doesn't have quite enough emotion in it. That said, not many people can match Trent for skill or intensity.

  • i love this song and this cover and all you haters can hate all you want, lacey did one damn good cover the best i actually seen

  • Such a shame is right! This cover loses all the essence and power of the original by Trent Reznor. Flyleaf turned a tearful stripped down song of desperation into a generic chug-chug rock ballad for kids, an absolute disgrace! Check out Nine Inch Nails - "Something I Can Never Have (still)" for the real thing.

  • @Tamserya I completely agree, this is absolute shit.

  • Fucking Amazing

  • "grey would be the colour if i had a heart "soooo true

  • meh

  • They like being original dont they?

  • does anyone know the truth of the song

  • I love this song so much. It's a beautiful creation and works so greatly by both her and the original artist.

    Good writing is good writing. I wish there was more of it out there.

  • very nice she is very emotional and sings to the heart if i had a heart

    it will also be grey

  • This is my favourite version, Lacey's voice is amazing <3

  • 2:24 ...woahhh

  • God this is some trite crap, the original was soooo much better

  • ___ ღ ღ

  • crap

    

  • @johnking33762  Is your taste in music ^^

  • wow they killed a good song :(....

  • @FLCLnaota go die

  • @venuslynn29 what the heck? If someone doesn't like a cover, you don't tell them to die to make them like it... :P

    seriously, it's natural for someone to think someone doing a cover killed the original song. Chill.

  • @FLCLnaota Agreed! Absolutely terrible!

  • I love flyleaf

  • @TheBatmanSmells Shut up! If you don't like them THEN DON'T LISTEN TO THEM, OR COMMENT ON THE VIDEO. Don't get me wrong, I'm an easy going girl, but you are starting to get me very angry. I'm tired of seeing your comments on her and flyleaf's videos. So just stop. Okay? okay. Glad we got that over with.

  • @TheBatmanSmells dude go die in a fucking ditch if you dont like them stfu and stop looking it up!! common sense you idiot even if you do close the video dont comment

  • @coollynn212 *you're

  • @boonaga911 your 10 fucking years old and your comebacks suck. Get off youtube

  • @shrykull9 thts like really harsh.. not tryna be mean but if your older then just dont comment back.. not tryna get involved but its really immature to fight ith a 10 yr old.. if they wanna b a pussy ass bitch then let em lol

  • @sambaker877 i goess you right, i was just pissed off at the time for a different reason. im fine now and regret saying that. thanks for your honesty

  • @shrykull9 lol yw haha this one dude tryin me lol and ive been fitin with him for a lonng time and i realized tht theyre not worth it lol so now i just dnt even read it and comment back sayin stuff like uhuh ok yeah sur and it eventually annoys them so they stop lol and thnx 4 not taking it the wrong way :D

  • awesome song! great job on the vid

  • awesome song!

  • your vids do.not.suck.

  • Its beast

  • Holy shit! :-O As i huge NIN fan i have heard like millions of covers of NIN songs so far. But i somehow "missed" this one until today.

    Okay, personally i think, this is one of the better covers of a nin song. I like it.

  • it's decent. (:

  • Comment removed

  • I like Nine Inch Nails version better. Just because it's the original and they're my favorite, but they did a really good cover

  • @BoughtABride56 i like the flyleaf way better cuz he goes to low and it sounds like hes strainin his voice lol

  • @sambaker877 thank you someone agrees with me that the flyleaf version is better

  • @venuslynn29 haha flyleaf is always better! i LOVE them! but im not crazed or anything tht far lol

  • 19 ppl are stupid!!

  • THERE SONGS ARE TO SLOW THEY NEED TO SPEED UP ANYONE AGREES

    I PERSONALY LIKE ALL AROUND MEBETTER

  • @rarrroxisrarr thats just stupid, this is a cover anyway. the speed of a song doesnt matter it the lyrics the people and the music that matters

  • @rarrroxisrarr this isn't their song. just sayin'. and what's wrong with having a few slow songs, anyways? if they were all "fast", you'd probably get bored of listening to the same thing over and over. then people would complain of all the songs sounding the same. (:

  • this band butchered a perfectly good NIN song. Even took the F word out. WTH.

  • @CalFireEMTGirl Lacey just doesn't swear when she sings.

  • God I love when she finishes the line "gray would be the color....if i had a heart" gives me chills<3

  • @MazieBabeMirror Ikr! I love her.

  • I LOVE Flyleaf

  • Actually, those who argue on youtube are idiots.

    Worry about something else. -_-

  • i love how you guys are arguing about cusing. okay take it this way. if she/he wants to cuse let them. you cant change them.. and if you dont want to see it then simple ignore it. it really isnt that hard.

  • @missinghimlikecrazy * I *cussing * cuss *isn't

  • @boonaga911 what are you talkin about.

  • @boonaga911 and im sorry that my laptops "r" button doesnt work all the time. i say curse. not cuss..idiot.

  • @missinghimlikecrazy Really? Learn simple grammar, please, and spelling. Really. I'm 10 and I'm better at grammar and spelling than you.

  • If assholes comment hateful shit on a video then WHY THE FUCK WATCH IT?!?!? I MEAN REALLY! WHAT'S THE FUCKING POINT??? IF YOU DON'T LIKE A DAMN VIDEO LEAVE THE FUCKING PAGE, DAMN!

  • Look cursing is useless and it's a sin. "F" is just a way of degrading yourself so yes she is too Christian to curse. So am I. So why are we fighting over this? Only God knows.

  • @Pscaswasteland ... are you really going to argue with someone over YOUTUBE about swearing ? thats cool.

  • @1Pickle123 I'm not arguing with any one. I just think it's really crazy that people take pleasure in cursing when all it is is a word! I mean what Good will cursing ever do? I see nothing wrong with her not cursing. I think it was a very good decision.

  • @Pscaswasteland ; they are words, they are used to speak. you can find them in the dictionary. what good will they do ? what good will any other word in the english dictionary do ? same thing a curse word can do.

  • @1Pickle123 A curse word degrades you and simply makes you look like an idiot. I see no point so I dont use them.... Not saying you have to follow my example. Curse all you like :-)

  • @Pscaswasteland ; a curse word is a part of the english language. dont like it ? then sit down & shut up :)

  • @1Pickle123 Ok Whatver. God bless

  • @1Pickle123 Honestly I agree. If it`s part of the english language, let`s use it. We made words for a reason, didn`t we?

  • @1Pickle123 People who use curse words are not respected and thought lowly of having a poor use of vocabulary. People's careers have ended all due to a simple profanity and some did not even have to speak a curse word, but be present in a setting where said curse words were spoken. There are also studies on how curse words can affect one's intelligence and behavorial patterns.

  • FAGGOT SHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Dmac11a666 whoa, whats YOUR problem Buster??

  • @boonaga911 The butchering of this song by this crap band....

  • @Dmac11a666 oh whatever. thats your opinion. i wish that peoplewould understand how beautiful flyleaf song meanings are. get outta here if u dont like the band. why go bitching on their vids. i mean srsly. r u a troll? have u got no life?r u picking a fight? or are you just a plain bitch....? really. what is your purpose? Im asking a question. answer me plz. OH, unlessur too stupid for that. here lemme dumb it down a bit. why r u on thisvid?! there. your inferior brain might able to answer tht

  • @boonaga911 I'm on this vid cause I like nin and wanted to see if this was a good cover...it's not..."I'm asking a question. answer me plz. OH, unlessur too stupid for that." Seriously you're going to ask me a question, then ask me to answer it and then write, "OH, unlessur too stupid for that." In the same comment before even giving me a chance to answer? LMFAO!! You're one stupid bitch let me tell you...Don't like my opinion ignore it you dick licking bitch!

  • @Dmac11a666 haha great comeback Einstein!!!!

  • @boonaga911 Wow, that was even better comeback!!! More like you can't think of anything to say...LOL :P

  • @Dmac11a666 yeah guess what honey? I'm not mad anymore I shouldn't be wasting my time on an idiotic troll. bye, and don't message me or reply to me. thx.

  • @Dmac11a666 also, do u think uve used enough cuss words? Or do you need to add another "bitch" or "dick" IDK, alls I know is you shouldnt be talking to a temn yr old like that. -_- thts right, im ten. now whatchuu gunna do????! >:D

  • @boonaga911 Since your profile says you're 20 i'll assume you're a fucking lying piece of shit...

  • @Dmac11a666 yeah, you'd think but whatcha gonna do. I couldnt put my real age or I wouldn't have this account. and my other one. its easy. just think about it. :|

  • @boonaga911 What am I going to do? And I still care your age because.........

  • @Dmac11a666 oh mah god..i thought i told you not to reply? are you Blindd??!

  • @boonaga911 Shut your cock holster....

  • @Dmac11a666 your mom needs to shut her cock holster bitch

  • @Dmac11a666 oh quiet down fucktard, btw, what i meant by "oh, unlessur too stupid for that" was unless your too stupid to understand the question i asked.haha ur so stupid learn how to read idjit

  • @boonaga911 You mean unless "you're" too stupid for that...Which proves you are....

  • @boonaga911 Just because you can call someone a name, doesn't mean you're cool. You're probably one of the people who are looked down on because you take you're anger out in names

  • @awilmot0650 actually no, this guys just making me mad. I've calmed down now.

  • beautiful.. i still prefer trent but this is quite nice.

  • Awww...is she too Christian to say "fuck" or "fucking" to be precise? That was my favorite part, the "fucking" gives that line emphasis that gives me chills. She did a good job but there is no emotion in her cover. Trent had plenty of emotion in his version which is why I like it better. The guitar parts are better than the piano parts in the original.

  • @xOpHeLiAcInMeX Who cares?

  • @coollynn212 hahahaa for reals.

  • @coollynn212 haha i cracked up when i read your comment!!!!! :D

  • good cover. 

  • wow, im sorry, but this the worst cover of a song since warrant tried to redo queen's "we will rock you"

    it totally misses the point of the original...i mean completely and wildly misses the point

  • Better than NiN, must say...

    or is it that i just dont like nin style, well i love this

  • i love there covers