@a7xrulez1000 He's certainly not "raping" anything in any language. And even if you did put a second "p" in "raping" you'd still be wrong. He's just being awesome. No rap or rape included.
@DaGagamel fuck this "In My Opinion" bullshit, Jonathan really IS one of the greatest vocalists of all time, he is one of the last metal Gods standing in todays shitty radio metal world
@Neckromorph If it had lyrics, the vocals in this would sound almost exactly the same as the studio version, as they would be saying the same thing. However, the studio version has less repeated sounds. Besides that, Jonathan Davis himself has commented on this, stating that it was a form of "scat", in which there are no lyrics, only a basis for the vocals (which is why it isn't COMPLETELY different.).
All live performances of songs are always a little different than the studio versions. And yes, I know it's scatting, but that doesn't mean he makes up the lyrics every time he sings the song. He has his scatting lyrics to this song written down somewhere and memorized. Just because the words are made up, doesn't mean there are no lyrics.
Sometimes things might make me ooo ooo it makes me mad and when it happens fuck it ruggid in mind a hint by bite Why does it not ixist in you? right, shit, why hit in yet another day woo hoo right it's not woo hoo right but your wrong
hahaha. you should really keep on openly spouting your nazi hopes on the internet... i'm sure the government won't search your computer and monitor your activity ;)
@chewbaccapoopy Do the world a favor and quit being such an ASSHOLE! That is YOUR opinion. Obviously no one here wants to hear the shit you're saying. Why don't you just quit trolling and shut the fuck up? I think that's a better idea :)
i have the original lyrics : You not rrrh rot dot n dot n dot per rot dot n not n dot per n dot chi cot n dot rrr ah dot dot ki o ma gri a dot dot ers a pa ta ko some play to we a dot think up a bite rah sometimes you might ooh ooh rrrh we thought we might dot be mer hot something what are you ma ah do bro what are mines is dot ooh ooh rot in dot n bite ooh na na er na he woo hoo rah ate no hoo dot er ha ya dot im wer rah
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
lyrics are: you're not the right one dumb damn rapper not the right goddamn who are u to rap shit take off and whos saays you're right on top u think ur bomb artista but ur bent out of oh right suck my dick.......... srry cant finish but go to my channel and subscribe once i get 50 subs al put a vid with lyrics
drugs? tool, nine inch nails, skynard, the doors, deftones, eric clapton... hank, hank jr., big n rich, willie nelson... snoop, 50, em, dre, lil wayne, gucci mane, 3-6 maffia... all genres endless names have fun w drugs.
drugs aren't bad. idiots w drugs are bad... same w guns or hell even pencils or plastic bags.
either way notice how he sounds like one of those evangelical christians?
@eutomonation dude, drugs fuck you up, my m8 thinks he's a tree ffs.
your right that it's only if your an idiot with them, but when you take them, it turns you into an idiot, see the cycle? there's also a thing called addiction,
im not saying don't do them, I'm just saying your wrong, they do fuck you up. they're supposed to...
@eutomonation: Haha, yeah it's amazing how people will judge guys like this saying "he's on drugs! He's Satan!" but the asshole preacher on t.v. acts and talks the same way. Fuck people. We're a stupid race.
By the way, Eric Clapton created the Crossroads Festival to promote staying off of drugs, so if he did have fun with them, I'm pretty sure he is staying away from them now.
@metaloxx Listening to korn on drugs fucks your head sideways. It makes you think you've got all sorts of psychological issues that don't really exist.
@mattypooz "You're not the right one dumb damn rapper Not the right goddamn Who are you to rap shit take off And who says you're right On top you think you'r bomb artista But you're bent out of oooo right Suck my dick But don't you think that you're oooo right Sometimes things might make me ooo ooo it makes me mad and when it happens fuck it ruggid in mind a hint by bite Why does it not ixist in you? right, shit, why hit in yet another day woo hoo right it's not woo hoo right" etc
@BuchekCaps Get a girlfriend dude. In the time it took you to try find words that sounded like the noises JD was making in Twist, you could have been getting fucked by some sexy blonde chic. I give you a thumbs up for trying though lol, you clearly put some time into it :D
you need to see the lyirch cause he is say somthing in english you need to google twist lyirch and is from this live version and im check it he just twist even more about what he sings here
scottish is english u fucking dick eater. An if ur thinking gaelic it's fucking not cause cause gaelic sounds stupid ass fuck and this doesn't. know ur shit b4 u talk and don't say im fucking wrong cus im from scotland u piece of shit
EVERYONE WHO THINKS THERE ARE LYRICS TO THE SONG READ! the truth is, there aint any lyrics. Just compare the live performance to the studio version and youll see
OMFG ur all tards get it through ur thick skulls! theres no lyrics its scat! just noises!, he changes it slightly every time but obviously has a basic structure to his scating he might even throw in the odd phrase like suck my dick just for a laugh but he wont every time! cuz it is random scat, nuff said on the topic i swear sum ppl can see a lyric in a fart! tards
Twist. Twist. Twist. Twist. Put me in right now make mad Prove that you're right Somehow you're not right But that doesn't make me mad Right now you're beggin' for a little brew All night Yeah it's so simple I had some Red Dog, you hand over it. Twist. Twist. Twist.
:D
RiotKidx 1 month ago
This is strange. o+o
thisisorisnotsparta 1 month ago
scooby doo on drugs
fuckin love davis
dayronduarte5 2 months ago
*seizure*.............
UBConquered 3 months ago
press 9 repeatedly for the best pelvic thrust ever :D
XxSpIkErGuYxX 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey, could you guys please take some time and check out my band and give advice, even if you mark as spam. Thanks!
kyaldabomb 4 months ago
crowd fail band win
chrisroxawsome 5 months ago
This is the one man that makes skirts looks cool. Other than Duncan McLeod
93n371cfr34k 6 months ago
Comment removed
wozzieLOG 6 months ago
Is jonathan suffering a seizure?
MrMetallicakid13 6 months ago
He's raping in a different language idiots !
a7xrulez1000 6 months ago
@a7xrulez1000 for your information it's not rapping in a different lenguage, it is scating so you are the idiot.
DeathToTheBully 4 months ago 5
@a7xrulez1000 He's certainly not "raping" anything in any language. And even if you did put a second "p" in "raping" you'd still be wrong. He's just being awesome. No rap or rape included.
TeamIndeedJOn 4 months ago
@a7xrulez1000 I find it so funny how people will come onto these videos thinking they know stuff about Korn haha.
Alterbridge321 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
How to get on the "Highest Rated Comments" List:
(Insert comment about justin beiber being a baby here)
(Insert comment about number of dislikes on this video)
(Insert comment about how you will kill the people who dislike this video)
(Insert comment about Chuck Norris here)
(Insert a funny line from the video)
(Insert a comment about clicking 0:01 to skip ads here)
(Insert a comment about how the new youtube layout stinks here)
(insert this comment)
DaevoNOfficial 6 months ago
jon is one of the most epic vocalists in the world (my opinion)
DaGagamel 6 months ago 23
@DaGagamel fuck this "In My Opinion" bullshit, Jonathan really IS one of the greatest vocalists of all time, he is one of the last metal Gods standing in todays shitty radio metal world
lilrockable 5 months ago
@lilrockable
sorry :-X
DaGagamel 5 months ago
@kornkam it's just jon scatting. twist changes all the time.
SlipknotFanGirl22 7 months ago
there are lyrics they are actual words! go onto lyrics.com And look the damn song up!
kornkam 7 months ago
@kornkam YEAH?!?!?! no.
willetterocks 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
it has lyrics
Steinway1994 7 months ago
I go to LOTS of concerts...but Korn may have the closest performance to their album versions. Jonathan has like unlimited vocal power.
TheBillyMaysShow 9 months ago 3
This song doesnt have lyrics. Stop imagining what isnt there.
Deathman5991 10 months ago
@Deathman5991
What are you talking about? Yes it does.
Neckromorph 9 months ago
@Neckromorph If it had lyrics, the vocals in this would sound almost exactly the same as the studio version, as they would be saying the same thing. However, the studio version has less repeated sounds. Besides that, Jonathan Davis himself has commented on this, stating that it was a form of "scat", in which there are no lyrics, only a basis for the vocals (which is why it isn't COMPLETELY different.).
Deathman5991 9 months ago
@Deathman5991
All live performances of songs are always a little different than the studio versions. And yes, I know it's scatting, but that doesn't mean he makes up the lyrics every time he sings the song. He has his scatting lyrics to this song written down somewhere and memorized. Just because the words are made up, doesn't mean there are no lyrics.
Neckromorph 9 months ago
@Neckromorph dude no, he just makes up angry growls and grunts when they play this song live
Eminem4liife 9 months ago
You're not the right one dumb damn rapper
Not the right goddamn
Who are you to rap shit take off
And who says you're right
On top you think you'r bomb artista
But you're bent out of oooo right
Suck my dick
But don't you think that you're oooo right
Sometimes things might make me ooo ooo it makes me mad and when it happens fuck it ruggid in mind a hint by bite Why does it not ixist in you? right, shit, why hit in yet another day woo hoo right it's not woo hoo right but your wrong
Eskew42 11 months ago
@Eskew42 Put me in right now make me mad
prove that your right
somehow your not right, huh
but that doesn't make me mad
right now your're beggin for a little brew
all night
Yeah it's so simple
I had some Red Dog, you hand it over
Twist, twist, twist
These are the lyrics. He does kinda say stuff.
Eskew42 11 months ago
@Eskew42 hahahaha!!!
sickstar14 9 months ago
welcome to the new wave of scream-boxing
swishandflicker54 11 months ago
PORRA tava cantando mal pa caralho
igor00isdeadkiller 11 months ago
Does anybody know what's the song after or before this wait if u know tell me both lol :D
EROXKING 11 months ago
Man Johnathon Davis is such a Talented songwriter
thelonelylama 1 year ago
you see, I make these noises everytime I see someone took a dump and didnt flush
STERNrogering 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
korn sucks so much ass, and always have... if you like korn, you are fucking white trash. do the world a favor and die.
chewbaccapoopy 1 year ago
@chewbaccapoopy
hahaha fuck you kkthxbye
sicmagg0t 1 year ago
@chewbaccapoopy I would die... but then id go to hell to early. id rather wait about three years..
xSiegHeil88x 1 year ago
@xSiegHeil88x
for what, some race war?? hahaha you are TRASH. GARBAGE. WASTE... just a piece of stanky shit, really.
chewbaccapoopy 1 year ago
@chewbaccapoopy YES. yes I am. Im glad you feel the same way as i do.
xSiegHeil88x 1 year ago
@xSiegHeil88x
hahaha. you should really keep on openly spouting your nazi hopes on the internet... i'm sure the government won't search your computer and monitor your activity ;)
dumbass.
chewbaccapoopy 1 year ago
@chewbaccapoopy no ones openly shouting anything you little prick. fuck the faggot ass government.
xSiegHeil88x 1 year ago
@chewbaccapoopy Do the world a favor and quit being such an ASSHOLE! That is YOUR opinion. Obviously no one here wants to hear the shit you're saying. Why don't you just quit trolling and shut the fuck up? I think that's a better idea :)
Chevellefan01 7 months ago
@Chevellefan01
hahahahahah. okay, "Chevellefan01".
chewbaccapoopy 7 months ago
@chewbaccapoopy Okay who the hell are you to be making fun of someone's username "chewbaccapoopy"??? WTF??
Chevellefan01 7 months ago
@raidergansta he isn't saying anything all growling no lyrics
JACKSONSPIDER 1 year ago
Badass dancing lol
nickm456123 1 year ago
haah what is he saying?? lol i love this song
raidergangsta 1 year ago
I like KoЯn
turntaglerocker 1 year ago
y would Korn play at woodstock only gay hippies went there
countrymetal18 1 year ago
@countrymetal18
hey dumbass, woodstock 99 was actually a complete fucking bro trash-fest, hence the riots...
chewbaccapoopy 1 year ago
hes so wierd live its awesome!
nikthedick123 1 year ago
thats an interesting dance at 0:09
SNB222 1 year ago
@SNB222 put ur hands in the air like you just dont care!
DeJay323 1 year ago 3
Fucking Woodstock 1999...Will always give me regrets i wasnt there
yunus1338 1 year ago
Ita purr ratta seena reena boooo rabnabab!!!! There's your fuckin' lyrics ok?
Nitrousoxide2k 1 year ago
from wut I've heard he's singing backwards
reglano1 1 year ago
god, that looks like they had so much fun with that gig...
iamazebrahearmeroar 1 year ago
Comment removed
bill4930 1 year ago
i like the korn in my bred.
it rocks!
k0kzhkl 1 year ago
gonnaeattheburrrrrrrrrrrrrrrraseta
stevan345 1 year ago
I like korn
ballmdr 1 year ago
turntaglerocker 1 year ago
@turntaglerocker No dude. Jonathan has said about 5000000 times now that theres no lyrics exept "twist" so shut the fuck up.
zacwashere2007 1 year ago
twist
stevan345 1 year ago
Twist
wowhorde12 1 year ago
bomb song
krish633 1 year ago
nina nina nina nina
KoRn0Graphy2010 1 year ago
I think every time he does this song live it's not the same, i think he just scats diffrently if u no wat i mean.
CuJoBo0013 1 year ago
KoЯn forever
megatron4o0o0o0o 1 year ago
Eta bu rata seta eta bu rat rat
therealbatty4life 1 year ago
Original korn <3
BenLightsOutHenigan 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lyrics are: you're not the right one dumb damn rapper not the right goddamn who are u to rap shit take off and whos saays you're right on top u think ur bomb artista but ur bent out of oh right suck my dick.......... srry cant finish but go to my channel and subscribe once i get 50 subs al put a vid with lyrics
bigmamas500 1 year ago
@bigmamas500 that's not the lyrics. that is just what comes up on a google search moron. he isn't saying anything. "scat" i believe its called.
MrWeglwegl 1 year ago
lol at the beggining he says "NOM NOM NOM" XD
sebita4 1 year ago 2
Sick!!
kipperoncrack 1 year ago
man....this video brings up some sweet memories. rome, new york....1999!!! i was literally in front of the stage when korn played.
afsalim 1 year ago
@afsalim id do anything to go back in time and see them front row at woodstock, very jealous, that is fucking amazing
ryanD311 1 year ago
This is the shit.
Bandaids4ever 1 year ago
-.-
wtf is that ?!?
KnuffHoernchen846 1 year ago
best
Sicurns 2 years ago
Comment removed
BIoodBath 2 years ago
No, you're cool because you can't spell "write" actually.
Johnjayhawk83 1 year ago
this song is hilarious, but still sounds better on the album.
btw, love that gay hand flutter at 0:10 XD
thapwnisher 2 years ago 3
Korn aint drugs. its just crazy anger. And its freakin bomb! Korn 4 Life! RAAAG-SAMINA-RIBADOO-ROP!
Serj511Guitar 2 years ago 3
i agree with you baby... korn rocks... like a morning cup of very very very strong coffee
bluemeeny70 2 years ago 2
looveee the way he dances!
3bayftw 2 years ago
I swear he makes up random noises as he goes along at every concert XD
ooo0315 2 years ago 3
Ha, I thought munky was fred durst.
They were wearing identical clothing at that festivity.
DaltonsBizkit 2 years ago 2
its isn't drugs kids, he's skitzophrenic.
drugs? tool, nine inch nails, skynard, the doors, deftones, eric clapton... hank, hank jr., big n rich, willie nelson... snoop, 50, em, dre, lil wayne, gucci mane, 3-6 maffia... all genres endless names have fun w drugs.
drugs aren't bad. idiots w drugs are bad... same w guns or hell even pencils or plastic bags.
either way notice how he sounds like one of those evangelical christians?
eutomonation 2 years ago 2
Nah, we actually sound different. More faster and booming ;)
meredithmccoy 2 years ago
@eutomonation dude, drugs fuck you up, my m8 thinks he's a tree ffs.
your right that it's only if your an idiot with them, but when you take them, it turns you into an idiot, see the cycle? there's also a thing called addiction,
im not saying don't do them, I'm just saying your wrong, they do fuck you up. they're supposed to...
louisalive 2 years ago
@eutomonation huh.. John is skitzophrenic... ? o_O no way
DaSassyDanca 2 years ago
@eutomonation: Haha, yeah it's amazing how people will judge guys like this saying "he's on drugs! He's Satan!" but the asshole preacher on t.v. acts and talks the same way. Fuck people. We're a stupid race.
By the way, Eric Clapton created the Crossroads Festival to promote staying off of drugs, so if he did have fun with them, I'm pretty sure he is staying away from them now.
Drucef 2 years ago
@eutomonation pretty sure he's not a schizophrenic, man :\
MissEmoPanicx 2 years ago
0:10 / 0:12 john dance LOL
92DropDead 2 years ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sucks!!
really sucks!!
martynaviles 2 years ago
or you could do drugs and groove on the music.....either way KORN is enjoyable
SpliffdeBrownsville 2 years ago 3
Don't do drugs. Fucks you up.
WPH15 2 years ago
first korn song i ever heard, we were listenign to it in the schoolyard and all the other kids thought we were crazy.
they were right
STARDORKS 2 years ago 6
When i hear this song and some other songs of korn like "clown" i wanna do like JD in clown video. Its so psychodelic :D
Don't use drugs!
Listen to KoRn it's safely and make you more creazy :D
metaloxx 2 years ago 84
shit that is exactly what i thought....korn makes you go high....love clown , i listen to it 20 times a day
pausec 2 years ago 2
LOL
WPH15 2 years ago
@metaloxx Listening to korn on drugs fucks your head sideways. It makes you think you've got all sorts of psychological issues that don't really exist.
xXDandZXx 8 months ago
crazy ass song.
TheBurntPi 2 years ago 4
That sounded PERFECT! other bands cant do that 0_0
IvanDominguez10 2 years ago 5
i was at this concert they rock
MYPRODUCTIONS1399 2 years ago
hahahahhaha
from 0:10 to 0:14 hes doing the thriller dance
hellfreak007 2 years ago
Sounds like when I hear the voices tell me to do the things I feel like i shouldn't do.. YES MASTER I WILL KILL!
TheDoobad1 2 years ago 30
LOL haha
underoath9100 2 years ago
You won the game. =]
xXxStayxSicxXx 2 years ago 2
damn you I just lost the game
AllentheGuitarist7 2 years ago
damn u muhterfucker haha
ZFighter07 2 years ago
Ah...never gets old..
rohan2533 2 years ago 6
what the..... how old this song is?!
paulymindfreak 2 years ago
it's from 1996, on the life is peachy album
staticxman2000 2 years ago
they rock !! i wish they will come to romania
i also have this video uploaded
kornf13 2 years ago 3
*_*
I love this song x3
Korn is the best!
Mabe12Mabe 2 years ago 3
He always hops around the stage in the same way X3 <3
MellowJelly 2 years ago 4
i cant belive here to stay did not even exist in 99,years sure fly by,twist is so awesome free style beatboxing bitches!!
k5lta 2 years ago
he's not beat boxing you stupid piece of shit.
youtoob92 2 years ago
yeah SCAT free style beatboxing,and why must you call me a stupid piece of shit i done nothing to you.
k5lta 2 years ago 2
to those people who are so very familiar about head's guitar, what model is he using?
6digit 2 years ago
thats his ibanez universe.
k5lta 2 years ago
when did he have his APEX models made? i have a 2009 ibanez magazine, but i have no ideas when they were made.
gh3rckl3gend 2 years ago
he had those made in like 2001 and the newest in 2007 so i doubt it will be in the 09 edition of the ibanez magazine.
k5lta 2 years ago
how did you get a Ibanez magazine is there a number for them?
ekalb2185 2 years ago
custom made 7 string ibenanez guitar
dadyrghluv 2 years ago
GUAU¡¡¡ korn is the best ,is fantastic listen this song to all volume
crane238 2 years ago
отстой-slipknot круче!
3337229 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You can see that the lyrics are something very important on this song... just kidding
fsalencar 2 years ago
no lyrics, just scat, JD jas said so numerous times
mattypooz 2 years ago 30
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hes proboably speaking scottish
but they did a realy good performance
Cesar3048 2 years ago
no dude, its scat. no lyrics. other then in the studio recorded version where he says "twist," but thats about it.
specailboi95 2 years ago 3
this is not scat.
enter twist lyrics on google you'll find them.
if you listen to the song a few times you'll see it's right.
swisspunk91 2 years ago
No those are interpretations. Korn has never released official lyrics. For any song. Ever.
drumgroovy 2 years ago
@mattypooz there are lyrics
MrFilipinjo 1 year ago
BuchekCaps 1 year ago
@BuchekCaps Get a girlfriend dude. In the time it took you to try find words that sounded like the noises JD was making in Twist, you could have been getting fucked by some sexy blonde chic. I give you a thumbs up for trying though lol, you clearly put some time into it :D
mattypooz 1 year ago
@mattypooz
you need to see the lyirch cause he is say somthing in english you need to google twist lyirch and is from this live version and im check it he just twist even more about what he sings here
larawora 1 year ago
@larawora STFU dude! Learn to structure your sentences!
mattypooz 1 year ago
@mattypooz fuck you
larawora 1 year ago
what language is language?
drummerkid275 2 years ago
THis sounds so fucking cool xD. i love korn
cmpunky 2 years ago 9
Yunat ooooh ratat Eeimta eempa pouuu ratatingna oontapuon shrata
Tiika ruunta ouuuhrat dA-tatika maubeautiyata tadousaputa eeeurrraaatt sopentenbidyata Figabeibet eeuuureaatt sometight thingmy ouh rigdot eema
Ahimuraha sombi raha ima ahehntabeau rataima
Disaa ouh rah say aheenaraoueeta oouhoora inaua babauuraha
Yatatim ouuuhrat.
Puteh eeuurana Meemat boomdaa beaurat
sihma hamimurata Bathiin uhrahta meemaa aahh uhnda
Biima meaurat ihna Beeeeuurreaatttda
Ah eihse bahuh hiemaheba ina Eeeuurra
xSubliminaLx 2 years ago 4
grat man is that realor did u just write what u were hearin?
sasoripuppets1 2 years ago
there r no lyrics if you listen to the studio version & compare it with live versions you`ll see that there r no real lyrics it´s scatting
vonzockerfuerzocker 2 years ago 4
true
shanegleason 2 years ago
he's speaking Scottish
5abiTheGreat 2 years ago 2
don't you mean gaelic?
pmonroy86 2 years ago
scottish is english u fucking dick eater. An if ur thinking gaelic it's fucking not cause cause gaelic sounds stupid ass fuck and this doesn't. know ur shit b4 u talk and don't say im fucking wrong cus im from scotland u piece of shit
scottyxander 2 years ago
people ther is lyrics look um up serioulsy im not joking
MEHARJE94 2 years ago
just because you can look up lyrics, doesn't make them real
shaneg43 2 years ago 8
Korn - Twist (With Lyrics)
has the lyrics
(look up this exact name)
Dawkinsdude20 2 years ago
...XD
Pancakenumberone 2 years ago
the only lyrics in the song is Twist.
Guser223 2 years ago
no, there are actually lyrics. look em up.
BsktbllPLayer1307 2 years ago
if you think "ETA OOO RA DA ETAETA OOO RA ATA ETA OOO RA" are lyrics then your a dumbass its scatting
PunchingKitty 2 years ago
DUDE punching kitty look up the real lyrics bsketbll dude is right
Dawkinsdude20 2 years ago
the only real lyrics are Twist
PunchingKitty 2 years ago 39
yes we u lied before punching scanky
Dawkinsdude20 2 years ago
BEASTLY HUMAN !!!! well said mr. DAVIS
xyrenvalent15 2 years ago 4
EVERYONE WHO THINKS THERE ARE LYRICS TO THE SONG READ! the truth is, there aint any lyrics. Just compare the live performance to the studio version and youll see
WickedJ133 3 years ago
or it could be the fact that he gets the crowd to shout twist
tobalishus21 2 years ago
Jd scattin love it
Devildriver786 3 years ago
there are Lyrics
normaly impossible
freddythezigioiner12 3 years ago
BEASTTTTTTTT haha
Kankuro000123 3 years ago
OMFG ur all tards get it through ur thick skulls! theres no lyrics its scat! just noises!, he changes it slightly every time but obviously has a basic structure to his scating he might even throw in the odd phrase like suck my dick just for a laugh but he wont every time! cuz it is random scat, nuff said on the topic i swear sum ppl can see a lyric in a fart! tards
lukeslater1986 3 years ago
AdjacentTangent 3 years ago
There are no lyrics?
superman12211331 3 years ago
not really
just twist
reak7835 3 years ago 2